Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 3383l
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETW
WRIT PETITION Nos: 18994 & 20681 of 2019
WRIT PETITION NO: 18994 OF 2 019
Between:
1. Sayari Narasimhulu (died per L.Rs.)
2. Smt. Sayari Chinnamma, W/o Late Narasimhulu aged about 6.1 years,
3. Sayari Krishnaiah, S/o Narsimhulu, aged about 45 years,
4- Sayari Srinrvasulu, S/o Narsimhulu, aged about 41 years,
5. Sayari Anjaneyulu, S/o Narasimhulu, aged about 39 years,
Nos.1 to 5 are rlo Kaverammapet village, Jadcherla Mandal,
Mahabubnagar District.
6. Smt M.Uma Rani, W/o Anjaneyulu, D/o Narasimhulu Aged about 35 years,
Rl/o Ru kkampally villa ge, Nawa bpet t\,4a ndal, IVlahabubnag-a r District.
...PETITIONERS
AND
The State of Telangana, rep- by its Principal Secretary, Revenue Department
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The Joint Collector, Mahabubnagar District, t\rlahabubnagar.
a
The Revenue Divisional Officer, Ivlahabubnagar Division, Mahabubnagar
District-
The Tahsildar, Jadcherla Mandal. Mahabubnagar District.
S.mt. Sabera Bee (D_ied per Lrs RR7 & 8), Wo Late Shameemuddin aged
about 70 years, Rl/o Bijinepally village and Mandal, Nagarkurnool District. -
Md. Yousufuddin, S/o Lae Shameemuddin, aged 50 years, R/o Beside Bus
Stand, Bijinepally Village and [Vlandal, Nagarkuinool Diitrict.
Mohammad Khadarmohiaddin, S/o. lvlohammad Sameemuddin, Aged about
Vgars_.ry1o H.No- 5-37l2, Rahath Nagar, Bijinapalli lvlandal, Mahabubnagar
!lDistrict,
T.S. - 50S203.
Mohd. Nazia Beguq, D/o. l\/ohammed Sameemuddin, W/o. Yaseen, Aged
?boul 4! years, F/o. 3-13-145, L.B.Nagar, Saroornagar, Ranga Reddy
District, T.S. - 500074.
-r
RR 7 and 8 are^ brought on record as LRs of the rj rceased Respondent
No. 5 as per C.O.dt. 12.09.2023, in lA No. ,t ot ZOZS.,..RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of ln(J a praying
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, thr:
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, Order or
that in the
U ilrh Court may be
Direclron. nr( re ,tarticula rly one in
the nature of Writ of Certiorari, to call for the records r :lating
passed by the 2nd respondent in Revrsion Case
to the orders
No. D1/ 3 1/2015 dr 1718t2019
upholding the orders passed by the 3rd respondent dt. :( l4l?.015
No B/ROR/3626/2012 and the orders of
the 4th
No.4/205/2010 dt. 181612011 , and to quash the same, and r
brearing Fite
€,st)ondent in File
Jrant.
lA NO: 1 OF 201 I
Petition under section 1si cpc praying that in the ircrmstances
stated
in the affidavit fileci in support of the petition, the High
Co I t may be pleased to
suspend the orders passed by the 2nd respondent rr Flevision
case No.
D113412015 dt- 17r8r2o1g uphording the orders passed
301412015 bearing Fire No.B/RoRr3626r2012
respondent in Fire No.4/205/2010 dt. 1,r6t2o11
by 1r e 3rd respondent dt.
and the .rders of the 4th
, pendinq , isposar of the main
Writ Petition.
Counsel for the petitioner: SRI Dr. K.KRISHNAIAH
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 to 4: AGp FOR REVENUE
counsel for the Respondent No.6 to 8: sRr y.soMA sRrNr-
H REDDY
WRIT PETITI ON NO:2068 1 0F 2019
Between:
1 Smt.. Shabera Bee, (.Diell as per Lrs p3 and p4), Wr, , _atr., Shameemuddrn
Aged about 70 yrs, R/o Buiner;altyVi,age inJ[/rnorr .,
ig;ilri;,;,;iDi;i;.i
Bus Stand, Bijinepaily Viilage and MirOJ, f.lr'sXikurnoct
I,istrict.
2. Md Yousufuddin, S/o. Late Shameemuddin Aged abo,r 50 yrs, R/o.
Beside
3. l\,4ohammad Khadarmohia^ddrn,_ S/o tVohammad Same: lurldin, Aqed
3i,il""1f't y",5LNo.
about
5_372, nanatn r.lagai, eu,apJii M, .i:.rln,1',['r,u.,]ofrIi,rl.
4. Ivlohd Nazia Bequm, D/o
_Mohammad Sameemuddin \V/,r yaseen,,neEiv
ab
Tts_tqs;
L.R-G!ri''srroo,,, r;ar. Ransa Aged
B?.3;:,,-+.1?tB,
-Petitioner Nos. 3 and 4 are brought on record as LRs of the deceased
Petitioner No.1 as per C.O.dt. 29.04.2024 in l.A.No.1 of 2024.
...PETITIONERS
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Revenue
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The District Collector, Mahaboobnagar District, Mahaboobnagar Town and
District.
The Joint Collector, [Vahabubnagar District, Mahabuhnagar.
The Revenue Divisional Officer, [\i]ahabubnagar Division, Mahabubnagar
District.
5. The Tahsildar, Jadcherla Mandal, [/ahabubnagar District.
6. Sayari Narsimhulu (Died per L.Rs.)
7. Smt. Sayari Chinnamma, W/o. Narsimhulu, Aged about 61 Years,
8. Sayari Krishnaiah, S/o. Narsrmhulu, Aged about 45 Years,
9- Sayari Srinivasulu, S/o Narsimhulu Aged about 41 Years,
10. Sayari Anjaneyulu, S/o. Narsimhulu, Ageci about 39 Years,
Nos. 6 to 10 are Rl/o. Kaverammapet Village, Jadcherla Mandal,
Mahabubnagar District.
'l '1 .Smt. M.Uma Rani, W/o Anjaneyulu D/o Narsimhulu,
Aged about 35 Years,
Rl/o. Rukkampally Village Nawabpet Mandal, firlahabubnagar District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ of Mandamus to declare the action of the Joint
Collector/3rd Respondent in review the Order passed in Revision Case
No.D1/34/2015, dated. 1710812019, through the Endorsement Order, dated.
1710812019 and kept abeyance in Review Application filed by the 8th
Respondent, which is illegal, arbrtrary and also without jurisdiction and also
violation of Provisions of the Andhra Pradesh Rights in Land and Pattadar
Passbooks Act, 1971 and also violation of Article 21, 3004 of the Constitution of
lndia and consequently set aside the Endorsement Order, dated. 1710912019
passed by the Joint Collector/3rd Respondent in Review Application given by the
Respondent No.B.
---
lA NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under Sectron 151 CPC praying that in the ( rcumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High CoLr . may be pleased to
suspend the Operation in Endorsement Order, dated. 17la)t2O19, keeping the
abeyance Order vide Revision Case No.D1/3412015, dated l7lOBl2O19, which is
passed by the Joint Collector/3rd Respondent in Review Ap 1 I cation grven by the
Respondent No.8, pending disposal of the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI Y.SOMA SRINATH REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 to 5: AGP FOR REVENUE
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
IN THE HTGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRI JUSTTCE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT PETITION N os.18994 & 20681 OF 2019
Dated:|7.02.2026
Between:
Sayari Narasimhulu (died per LRs.)
and five others.
. . Petitioners
Attd
The State ofTelangana, reptd, by
its Principal Secretary,
Revenue Department,
Hyderabad and five others.
.- Respondents
COMMON ORDER:
Writ Petition No. I 8994 of 2019 is filed to issue a Writ of
Certiorari calling for the records relating to the orders passcd by
respondent No.2-Joint Collecror, Mahabubnagar District, in Revision
Case No.Dl/34/2015 dated ll .OB.2O\9, upholding the orders, dared
30.04.2015, passed by respondenr No.3, vide File No.B/ROIll3626/2012
and the orders, dated 18.06.2011, passed by respondent No.4 in file
No.A/205/2010, and to quash the same.
1,,\1,J
LYPNa 13991 &
2.
2063taf2atq
Writ Petition No.20681 of 2019 is filed to :sLre a wrir of
Mandantus declaring the action ol respondent No.3 . cin: Collector,
Mahabubnagar District, in reviewing the order passed ir llevision Case
No.D1i34l20 l5 dated
.I7.08.2019,
through the Endorsen:nt crder, dated
I1 .09.2019, and kccping the order dated 17.08.2019
ir abeyance, as
illegal, arbitrarl, and to set aside the same.
3.
Since the parties, the subject propefty and the iss r,:s involved in
both the Writ Petitions are one and the same, both the \i -it l)etitions are
heald togethcr and are being disposed of by this commo r c,rder.
4.
Writ Petition No. I 8994 of 2019 is taken up as a l, z.d case insolar
as thc tacts of the case are concerned. For convenience, the parties lvill
be rc fcr-red to as they are arrayed in Writ Petition No.18') r,1 c,f 2019.
5.
Hcald [)r. K. Krishnaiah, leamed counsel for tre petitioners,
learned Assistant (iovelnment Pleader for Revenue for r e ; pondent Nos. 1
to 4 and Sri Y. Soma Srinath Reddy, leamed counsel lbr respondent
Nos.6 to 8
6.
Briefly stated, thc facts of the case, as avened in tl: writ affidavit,
are that petitioncr No. I purchased land admeasuring A,: .,5-()0 guntas in
Sy.No.543,ts, situated at Polepally Village, Jadc.rerla Mandal,
nr.r.,:,;Yi
Mahabubnagar District, from
one Mahabub Bee for uuf ia .on.iarffif
through a registered sale deed
13.02.198 I and as such,
after his death, petitioner Nos.2
Iegal heirs, are the absolute
6.1.
owners and possessors of the
Originally, one Sherfuddin, was
Acs. l8-3 I gunras in Sy.No.543
partitioned the said land between
and (ii) Mahabub Bee, each
the share of Mahabub Bee,
wif-e of Shameemuddin, created
of Shameemuddin, i.e., the son of
records were mutated shor.ving
as
that Sabera Bee (respondent No.5),
a fraudulent and fabricated sale
bearing Doc.No.3l l/1972 dated
Mahabub Bee in her favour and
Bee
whire Acs.g-
land in Sy.No.543/B and Shameemuddin
pattadar of land in Sy.No.543lA;
revenuc records
owner of_ tand admeasuring
of polepally Village, ancl he had
indu Bee. Consequently, the revenue
narne of respondent No.5
said land.
his two wives, namely (i) Sindu
I6 guntas was allotted to the share
Mahabub Bee as pattadar of
to 6, being his
being allorted half share. Accordingly,
Acs'9-r5 guntas was alrotted to
S
bearing Doc.No.562119g I dated
decd
22.02.1972, purporledly execured
by
basing on the said void document,
the
was illegally incorporated as pattadar
in the
II-
l
I':'3. '1
tttlNo t69,1 &
)a68loI)019
6.2. Oncoming to kuow about
Bee filed a suit lir/c O S
Mahabub
the said fraudulent transacli rrr'
No' l2 of 1980 on the file
Court. Mahabuhnagar'
against
respondent Nos 5 ar( 6 seeking
recovery orpossession.
decrar.ation ortitle and
compromise
on 06.08.1980 in terms of
Nos.5 and 6 admitted the
of the I) strict Murrsif
The said s' I w:1s dect'eed
petition, wher: rt tespondent
titte of Mahabub Bee and dctiv:
of the lands in SyNos'542 lB' 5431Lfhe
Acs.9- I 5 guntas, to her'
has been preferred against
ed possession
and 549/8' totr aclmeastrring
said decree attained finali'-' '
as' no appeal
the same'
6.3. That Mahabub Bee' as averred
supra, sold an extel of
No l through a
Sy.No.543/B to petitiorler
Doc.No.562/1981 datcd I1.02
Acs'6 00 in
registered sr e deed bearing
198 t
Sabera Bee
husband '1'
6.4. While so, r'vhen Shameemuddin' {
No'6)' r cc'llusiorr with
No 5) and lather ol respondent
(respondcnt
rvith thc possession
Mahabub Bee. intcrlcrcd
on thc file
laner filed O.S No l24 of t981
of pe i ioner No l ' the
of Distrrr t Nlunsif Coutl'
perpetual injunction
Mahabubnagar, seeking
granting permanent
decrced on 24.12.19g4,
and tl': said suit was
injunct r rL in his favour'
t,pN" t:{;:
I
2068t oI)0t9
Since no appeal has been filcd challenging the said judgme nt and decree,
the same atlained finality.
6.5. [t is lurther avened that though petitioner No. I had been in
continuous possession and cultivation of the subject land lor over lour
decades, his name was erroneously recorded only in the cultivator
column instead of in pattadar column from 1980-gI onwards. On the
shength of the registcred sale deed and the decree passed in OS.No.124
o1' 198 l, petitioner No. I made an application to respondent No.4-
Tahsildar fbr incorporation of his name as pattadar in the revenue
records, hor.r,ever, the said application was rejected, and instead, a
Pattadar Passbook was erroneously issued in favour of Respondent No.5
vlde proceedings No.4/208/2010 dated I 8.06.201 l.
7.
Aggrieved thereby, petitioner No. I prelened an appeal belore
Respondent No.3, which stood dismissed on 30.04.2015. Chailenging
the same, a Revision rvas filed before Respondent No.2, which was also
dismissed ll& order dated 17.08.2019, and aggrieved by the same,
W.P.No.l8994 of 2019 is filed.
8. During the pendency of the Revision, petitioner No.l died and as
such, petitioner Nos.2 to 6, who were brought on record as his LRs, have
,n,, ,!l;i
l
2068toI20t9
filed Review Application beforc respondent No.2, se r kin,q to review the
order dated t7.08.2019 passed in Revision Case No.l) l,t3,ll20l5 and that
respondent No.2 passed order dated 17.09.2019 keepLr
the earlier order
dated 17.08.2019 in abcyance until lurther orders. A.g1;rieved by the
same, Writ Petition No.2068 I ol20l9 is filed
9.
This Cour1,',vhile considcring I.A.No.l ol 2019 in \V.p.No.206gl
of 2019, obscrved that no power is vested in resl) )nd,lnt No.2-Joint
Collector undcr Section 9 of the Andhra pradesh Ii shtr; in Land and
Pattadar Pass Books Act, 197 I , and accordingl.,,. granted interim
suspension of endorsement order dated 17 .09.2019.
10.
Leamed counsel lor petitioners submitted that lespondent No.2,
without proper appreciation ol'thc lacts ol the case. ,: red in dismissing
the Revision petition. thereby upholding the orders o. r:spondent Nos.3
and 4; that Mahabub Bee, i.e., the vendor of the peti .i rners, filed a suit
vlde O.S.No.l2 of 1980 on the file of the Distri, t lr4unsif Courl,
Mahabubna-ear, against Respondent Nos.5 and 6, seelt ng declaration of
title and recovery ol possession, wherein she specifica Iy r:ontented that
she did not alicnate t-he subject propefty to responden. r'o.5 and that the
sale deed bearing docur.nenr No.l I I of 1972 dated 12.012.1972 was a
L.\1, J
tt/P No 13991&
)468 t of )A I9
lalse and fabricated document.'Ihe said suit was dccreed on 06.08.19g0
in terms of compromise, wherein Respondent Nos.5 and 6 admitted the
title of Mahabub Bee and delivcred the possession of land admeasuring
Acs.9-15 guntas in lavour of Mahabub Bee i.e., the vendor of the
petitioners, thcreforc, respondent Nos.5 and 6 have no right or titlc over
the subject propefty.
10.
l.
Learned counsel lbr petitioners furlher submitted that
respondent Nos.2 to 4 have no power to reject the Civil Courf decree on
the ground that it is not registered, and in fact, there is no requirement
for registration of the compromise decree and the offrcial respondents
are bound to implernent the said decree. He further submitted that in the
compromise petition, as per which the suit was decreed, respondent No.5
and her husband specifically admitted the title of Mahabub Bee (vendor
olthe petitioners) and have also delivered the possession of the propemy,
therefore, the petitionc-rs' vendor had title and possession of the
properfy, and thus, the sale decd executed by her in favour of petitioner
No.1 is valid. He finally submitted that the respondents-authorities have
lailed to appreciate the aforesaid judgments and decrees passed by the
civil Court in respect of the subject property and erred in rejecting the
request of petitioner No. I to rnutate his name as 'pattadar' in revenue
'\l
-
Li\;A, J
u/Pi\'a.18991 &
20681 of20t9
records. By contending thus, learned counsel for pe i ioners prayed
to
allow writ Petition No. 18994 0l 2019 and to disrr ss writ Petition
No.20681 of 2019.
On the other hand, leamed counsel lor resp I r'le rt Nos'6 to 8
I 1.
submitted that Mahabub Bee sold her share ol lLnd admeasuring
Acs.g.l5gtsinSy.No.543torespondentNo'5throtr'.hregisteredsale
deed bearing document No.3l 111972 dated 22'( )- lt)'12 and the
possession was also dclivered; that respondent I\ r ' 5 submitted an
apptication for tnutation belore respondent No'4, r'n'ho in turn, after due
e
nquiry, has recorded the name of Mahabub Bee both r thc Jamabandhi
for the year l91l-72 and in pursuance of apprcr al by the Nazin
Jamabandi ofllcer,_her name was shown as pattadar;r d crrltivator in
the
relevant records and fufther, pattadar pass books art' titlc deeds have
also been issuecl in her name.
11.t
.
Learned counsel lor Respondent Nos.6 to -c lurther submitted
that Mahabub Bee, having already sold her share of ancr ie', Acs'9'15
gts in favour ol Respondent No.5 in the year 1972. cannot re-sell the
said land to an extent olAcs.6.00 gts to petitioner Nc' in the
year 1981,
therefore, the sale deed executed by Mahabub Bee in I |vour of
i
petitioner
,rrr..,litlr
l
206E I oI )019
No.1 is invalid and as such, the Tahsildar rightly dismissed the petition
filed by petitioner No. I seeking to incorporate his name as pattadar in
revenue records
I 1.2. He further submitted that the compromise decree is silent with
regard to the registered sale deed dated 22.02.1912 and the same has not
been cancelled, therefore, Mahabub Bee did not acquire any fresh right
as per the compromise decree. In support ol his contention, learned
counsel relied upon judgment ol Hon'ble Apex Court, in Navratan Lal
Shurma Vs. Ratlha Mohan Sharmu and orst wherein it was held as
follows:-'Tltis Con l in Pushpct Devi Bhagat (supra), as well as
several other cases, has held that only the Court thctt
entertains the pelilion o.[' contprotn ise can determine its
legalitv, at the time o.l recording the compromise or
when it is qLrestioned by vvav oJ u recall application. No
other remedr is available to the porq) who is aggrieved
by the comprotni.se detree as an appectl and fresh suit
are nol mainlainable mtder the CPC.
I
1.3.
He further submitted that the name of respondent No.5 IS
recorded as owner and possessol in the pahani lor the year 1971-72 and
'202a scc ot',tLtt'rcE sc 3u zo
L\). J
also in subsequent pahanies and the petitioners
)4681 oI )A l9
ritVo
approached
respondent No.4 for mutation of their names aftcr nrore than three
decades, that too, without possession
11.4. Learned counsel further submitted that petiti )rler. No.l filed a
suir O.S.No.124 of 1981 for injunction basing on tl r sale deed dated
13.02. 1981, without arraying respondent No.5 as a;riL 1r', thcreflore, the
said decree is not binding on respondent No.5.
1.5.
Learned counsel further submitted that res: rndent No.8 has
neither jurisdiction nor power to review his orvn or,l rr. in exercise of
power conferred under Section 9 of the ROR Act. nd as such. the
Endorsement order dated 17.09.2019 passed by l'riur, [, e ping the earlier
orders dated 17.08.2019 in abevance, is illegal. I r support of his
contention, learned counsel relied upon the Judgment ol the erstwhile
High Court ol Andhra Pradesh, in Lambuli pedtta t:'t utlru Vs. Mohd
Ali Hussuin2. wherein it is held as hereunder:"The.Joint Collector has no jttisdiction to re.t.i , hit; oturt
order in erercise of power conferred under Section 9 oi ROR
Act. Further, he has no jtLrisdiction to review or eol,en or
recall his own order except on the ground of the et t ier ortler
'2oo: mw surrlaRy oz+
-
LNA, J
WPN1 13991 &
2468tof2019
being vitiated on dccount o.f any fi.aucl pLal,ed and
perpetuated by any ofthe parlies to tl.rc proceedings.,'
12.
Leamed counsei finally prayed to dismiss Writ petition
No. 18994 of 2019 andro allow Writ pctirion No.206gI
I3
'
of 2019.
In the light of contenlions raised and submissions made on
behalf of the petitioners as welr as responclents, the points that
arise for
determination of this Court are:-
l. Ll/hether lhe order rhted 17.0g.2019 possett by
respondent No.2 in Revisiott Cuse No.Dl/34,
upltolding lhe ortlers tlated J0.04.201S and
18.06.2011, passed by respontlent Nos.3 and 4,
respectively, is s ustain0ble?
2. Whether lhe Endorsemenl ortler chted t 7.09.2019
passed by Respotulent No.2 in Revision Cose
No.Dl/34/2015 keeping the earlier orcler tlsted
17.08.2019 in abeyance is sustuinable?
Point No.1:-
14.
The contentions raised lcamed counsel lor respondent Nos.6
to
8 is three fold', firstly' that schedule is not mentioned in the compromise
decree; secondly, the compromise decree is not registered
and as such, it
has no value in the eye of law; and lastly, since respondent
No.5 is not
'l
)a6Etof20t9
made a party to the suit-OS.No.124 of I98I filed by 1rr titioner No.l, the
judgment and dccree passed therein is not binding on rt spondent No.5.
15. As regards the contention of leamed coun:;r I lirr rcspondent
Nos.6 to 8 that schedule is not mentioned in the cont ,t ornise decrec, a
scrupulous perusal of the material available on recorc particularly, the
plaint in OS.No. l2 ol I 980, makes it clear that sche I r e of property is
described therein and in the compromise pctition al; ,. the property is
described as 'subject properry'. Therefore, it goes u, .hout saying that
suit schedule propefty in OS.No.l2 of 1980 and the ' ubiect propefiy',
as mentioned in the compromise decree are one and I r,: s;ame. I{encc,
the contention of learned counsel lor respondent Ncs 6 tc 8 regarding
non-mentioning of schedule of properly in the co rrpromise decree
prepared by the Courl is not sustainable and has no sirr ificancc. Furlher,
it appears that due to inadvertence or typographical n i,take/error on the
parl of the staff concerned of the Court in preparinl: tre decree, therc
was non-mentioning of the schedule in the compronr ;: rlecree, whicl.r
itself does render the decree passed therein a nullity.
16.
The second limb of the contention of lclLr ncd counsel for
respondent Nos.6 to 8 is that the compromise decr r : ir; niandatorily
t,
-/
L\A. J
)068t oI )0 tq
registerable and in the instant case, since the compromise decree, which
is heavily relied upon by the petitioners, is not registered, it has no
value
17. The law in this context is well-settled by the Hon'ble Apex Court
in Gurcharan Singh antl others Vs. Angrez Kaur and unothei" In the
said judgment, the Hon'ble Apex Court has interpreted Scction 17 of the
Registration Act and observed as hereunder:-
"Section 17 of the Registration Acl provides .for
regislration of docuntents, which is to the
following effect:
*17. Documents of v'hich registration rs
compulsory. (l)The./ollowingdocuments
shall be registered, if the propertlt to v,hich they
relate is situate in a district in u,hich, and tJ they
have been execuled on or ofter the date on vt'hich,
Act WI of 1864, or the Inclion Registrtttion Act,
1866, or the lndian Registrotion Act, l87 l, or the
Indian Registration Act, I877, or this ..1ct came or
comes into forcc. nomely-
(vi) any decree or order o;f'a colo't, except a
decree or order expressed to be made on a
c o mp ro m i s
'zozo lrol scc zso
e and co mp r i s i ng i nt movo b le p ro p e r t!\',
'-.1
L\A,I
trPi\o- 18991 &
other than that which is the subject
, r ,;,n, of ,h)ont'"'0"
suil or proceeding; or"
-\-uff_Yj\'_\-_\-_Y
''Reverting bock to the
facts of the presenl case it i.\
clear that suit No. 556 of 2 t_g_lggl
appellant.s against Bhajan Singh
filert b.., rhe
relates to tlt( tuit
propertJ described in plaint ancl
decree was ptt. setl
only with regard to suit properties
A to D. The dt,L,ee
dated 9-t-t995 was, thus, expressly
covered b1. tirc
erpre.ssion "any decree or order
of
a court,, LL tp17
the legi.slattte has speci,ficall1,
excluded applicuL t it.r;
of clauses (b) and (c) with regard
to any decre: rtr
order of a court, applicability of
Section l7(tt t.,t
cannot be imported in Seclion
indirect ntethod. We, thus, are
t7(2)(v, by tny,
o/. the consitltt:j
o|.tinion thot decree and order rlated
require registration and werefully
9_l_I995 dit{ t .tt
covered by Sec,i tr:
l7(2)(vr, which contains exclusion
as reqtLired in Section t7(l). The
from registrori tt
High Court a.s t,, 1,,
as the first appellare court erred
conclu.sion that decree ctated
n'Hi.\tr,ttio4 und duc to it bring
arul void. "
in coming ta ,,, e
I 9_ t _ I 995 requ it.L t,
not registerecl, is n, /
W
L\'.1 J
tt+'\'o 18991 &
24681 of)019
18. It is also relevant to refer to the judgment of the I{on'ble Apex
Court in Som Dev v. Rati Rama.ln the said judgmenr, the Hon'ble Apex
Court, while interpreting Secrions l7(2)(vi) and l7(l)(b) and (c) oi thc
Registration Act, has held as follows:-
" lB. ... But with respect,
it must be pointed oltt that ..t
decree or order ofa court does nol require t.egistration i.f
it is not based on a compromise on the ground that
clauses (b) and (c) of Section l7 of the Registrution Act
are attrdcted. Even a decree on a compromise does not
require registration d it does not toke in properq, tlnt is
not the subject-matter of the suit...... ... ... "
19. From the above judgment, it is clear that all the decrees and orders
of the Couft including compromise decree do not require registration,
subject to the exception that in case, the decree is passcd in respect ol
property that is not the subject-matter of the suit.
l
20. In the present case, admittedly, Sherfuddin, owner of land
admeasuring Acs. l8-3 1 guntas, partitioned the said propcrty cqually in
lavour of his two wives-Sindu Bee and Mahabub Bee (vendor ol
petitioners). The name of Mahabub Bee was mutated in the revenue
records as the owner and possessor of her share and pattadar passbooks
and title deeds have also been issued to her. While so. when Mahabub
o
zooolro; scc zas
----
urN,, rcLcY
i
Bec came to knorr", that respondent Nos.5 created rr fo.n.a ,uil'''JJ'j
purported to be executed by her, she filed a suit for r eclaration
of titlc
and possession ,t1e O.S.No. I2 of l9g0 against t.l ] d3scendants
Sherluddin and Sindu Bee, i.e., respondent No.6 ltr:r :in-son
of
ol Sindu
Bee and Respondent No.5-daughter_in_law of Sindu t e.e.
The said suit
rvas decreed basing on the compromise petition_
1.,\ I,jo.4g9 of l9g0
filed under Order XXIII Rule 3 of CpC.
21. In the said compromise petition, the defenr i nts therein, i.e..
respondent Nos.5 and 6 herein have categorically adn
itted the title of
the Mahabub Bee in respect of the subject propefty th: .erin,
schedule propcrty, and delivered possession thereo|
i.e., the suit
r, Mahabub Bee.
Therefore, the decree in o.S.No. l2 of I9g0 did not cr ate
anv trtrc ror
the first time in Mahabub Bee-thc petitioner,s vendor.
22.
I'herefore, when the properly mentioned in re compr.ornise
decree is nothing but the suit schedule property, and
decree does not take into hold any property other
fLe compromise
than t r,3 siuit schedule
propeny, in the light of the judgments of the Hon'ble
Ap >: court i,.iarz
Dev's case (cited supra) and Gurcharan Singh's case , ited
compromise dccree need not be registered. In addition 1c
supra), the
rhat. this court
-
L,\.1 J
noticed that there is no challenge to the said compromise decree either
on the ground that it was lraudulent or vitiated by collusion or that it was
passed by a Court which had no jurisdiction to pass it.
'l'hr:relbre, it
rvould mean that the decree is not vitiated by collusion.
23.
Further, it is pertinent to note that compromise of a suit can be
ellected and the imprimatur of the Court obtained thereon lcads to
passing of decree only if the compromise petition/mcrno tlled in the
Court bears the signatures of both the parties to the suit and their
respective counsel. In a case, where one party sets up a compronlise and
the other pafty denies it, the Court can decide the question whether, as a
matter of fact, there has been a compromise or not. But, \\'hen a
compromise is to be recorded and a decree is to be passed itr ternts
thereol, Order XXIII Rule 3 of CPC envisages that the terrlls to the
compromise should be reduced into writing and signed by both thc
partie s to the suit
24.
Admittedly, thc suit-OS.No.l2 of 1980 has been liled b1
Mahabub Bee (vendor of petitioner No.l ) against respondent Nos.5 and
6 seeking a declaration of title and recovery of possession. Thereaftcr, in
terms of the compromise entered into between the parties, the suit was
.-
.'A6l of 2019
decreed in her lavour. t'hus, it is clear that through the sraiC compromise
decree , Mahabr-rb Bee did not,acquire any ne\\' right titlc, but she has
asserled her pre-existing right/ title/ intercst over th(r subjcct land, and
shc. in turn, sold thc subject Iand in lavour olpetition,: \c,. l.
2-5. In thc case on hand, the compromise petition jr licates that it was
one on admission of a pre-existing right of Mahabr b Eiec. Thus, the
prcsent case falls under Section l7(2)(vi) of Registrr irrn Act, 1908, as
the compronrise decrcc is expressed to be made irt r:sp,:ct of the suit
schedule propefiy and hence, the said compromise ,l:cree need not be
registered and non-registering of the compromise decr :e does not render
it nulI and void
26.
For the loregoing reasons, this Court holds tlr, t tl-e compromise
clccree passed in OS.No. l2 ol t980 need not bc rt uislcred, in other
rvords, non- rcgistcrin q. of thc compromise ciecree do(: noI render it null
and void
.
As regards thc tliird limb of submission ol' i arned counsel lor
respondent Nos.6 to 8 that since respondent No.5 is r r- nrade a party to
the suit- O.S.No.l24 of l98l filed by petitioner No. l,tr injunction, the
said decree is not binding on respondent No.5, it is rc rc ssen that law in
'';;F1+:,ffi'*sBryw'uE,{ :: ! Et! rffi * "'-..* .,--"
?
I
tt:l'\o 18991 ,t
this aspect is well settled, i.e., a person files a suit lor injunction against
a person/s who tries to interfere rvith his,rher possession and not against
an), othcr person.
28. While so, petitioner No. I filed suit-Os.No.l24 of 198 I against
respondenl No. I for the relief ol injunction, when the latter tried to
interfere with his possession over the subject property and the said strit
was decreed in lavour of petitioner No.l.
'fherefore, in pursuance ol the
said decrec, petitioner No. I is said to be in continuous possession and
enjoymcnt of the subject property for more than four decades
29. ln such an event, the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
Ravinder Kaur Grewal ancl Olhers v. Manjit Kaur untl Orlrersj, conlcs
to the aid of the petitioncrs, wherein it is categorically hcld that
continuous and uninterrupted adverse possession would conf-er right,
title and interest and the sanle can be used as a sword.
30.
In the light of the aforesaid reasons and discussion, this Court
hotds that the order dated 17.08.2019 passed by respondent No.2,
upholding the orders passed by respondent Nos.3 and 4, is illegal and
contrary to law and as such, the same is liable to be sct aside. Point No. I
'1zors1 s scc zzs
-
l
"rrr.,;i;]
:066toI20|t
is accordingly answered in favour of petitioners r \\'PNo. I8994 ol
2019.
Point No.2:-
3l.
A pc|usal of the record reveals that on all i pplication filed to
revicw thc orders dated 17.8.1019. passed r Ilevision Casc
No.Dl/3412015, respondent No.2 has passed order; rlated 17,09.2019,
keeping the earlicr ordcrs dared 17.08.2019 in abelar :e, u,hich anlounts
to reviewing his own orders dated 17.08.2019. This .ourse of action ol
respondent No.2 is impcrmissible in law in the ligh rl the.ludgment ol
the crstwhile High C'ourt of Andhra Pradcsh ir Ltmhadi pedcla
Bhadru's case (cited supra). In the said judgment, it i calegorically hetcl
that .loint ('ollector, unless thc carlier order is vit i t,:d on account 01'
fraLrd being playcd and pcrpetuated by any of he parlies 1o the
proceedings, has no jurisdiction to review or reop(r or recall his own
order.
32.
ln the casc on hand, it is not the case oleirl.t r parlies that fraud
was played and pcrpetuated by the opposite party. In he instant case, the
only grouncl on which respondent No.2-Joint Collect,r'is; emporvered to
revieu, or rccall his own order is abscnt, therefore, r.es r,rndent No.2-Joint
ry
2t
trp\' tsLrYt ,1,
)063tof)019
Collector has no jurisdiction to review or recall his own order.
Accordingly, the endorse ment order dated 17 .09.20 I 9 passed by
respondent No.2, reviewing his own order dated 17.08.2019, is held to
be passed without any jurisdiction or power vested on him. As a sequel,
this Court holds that the endorsement order dated 17.09.2019 passed b1,
respondent No.2 is ittegat and arbitrary and is unsustainable
3. Point No.2 is accordingly answered
In view of the fbregoing reasons and discussion and in the light
of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgments cited
supr4 this Court holds that the order dated 17.08.2019 and the
endorsement order dated 17.09.2019 passed by the Respondent No.2 are
unsustainable and the same are liable to be set aside.
35.
In the result, both the Writ Petitions are allowed arld the order
dated I 7.08.20 l9 in Rcvision Case No.D l/3412015 and the endorscment
order dated 17.09.2019, passed by respondent No.2, are hereby set aside
36.
Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.
That Rule Nisi has made Absolute as above witness
on this Tuesday' the
sni aianesx xurvren SiuoH, The chief JusticeTwenty
Hon'ble
The
-b"r"rieenth
"'' .'Six'
and
Day of February, Two Thousand
SD/- C. DEEPIKA
IS TANT REGISTRA
/iTRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble Sri Justice Laxmi Nara
n
Alishetty
(For His LordshiPs Kind Perusal)
To,
The errncipat Secretary, Revenue Department, Secretariat' Hyderabad'
re,.ffi
;.;ffi- xs.{:l
State of Telangana
2 The District collector, Mahaboobnagar
Diskict, Mahaboobnagar
Towrr rrd f istrict.
3 The Joint Collector. Ma
Mahabubnagar
4. TheRevenueo,r,r,onu'n'o'on"garDistrict
Officer. tr.4ahabubnagar
Division. Mahabubna
I r Dr;tflct.
5 The Tahsildar, .lao"f,"rla l\"landal'
Mahabubnagar Distrrct
6 11 LR copies
7 The Under Secretary unroa
of !.dia' Ministry of Law,
8. The Secretary, Telangar
9. one cc to sRr Dr.
r 0. one
,r*ra
oouo"'t"t Association' Library'
HNAIAH' Advocate
^.o*'u
cc to sRr y soMA
t*''o'"
11. Two ccs to Gp FoR
a*o cD copres
Justice aod ( lmrany
Hrgh court I /rldings,
#s;!. ,
REDDY' Advocate
*u VENUE' High court for
-.i I
-..
*
E&,::
Hyderabad.
[.PUC]
[.PUC]
the state ofrelanga..
GJP
'.
:-Effigir
Affarrs, New
,.t&l
,itf:
,Si
t Hlderabad lourl
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1710212026
.-
.*';iit'"
)
2il
-t-
COMMON ORDER
.-\
(:
' 'i'li
*
('q^,
1r26
4. .r'
'.
\ftiP.Nos.18994 & 20681 oi 2A19
ALLOWING BOTH THE WRIT PETITIOI\ S,
WITHOUT COSTS
&6
b
:J,i"
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review