Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34841
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENry SEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDTN
WRIT PET]TION NO: 23907 0F 2013
Between:
Smt.Karike Nirupqlani, Wo K.Satyanarayana, Occ: House wife, R/o H.No.1.t-100,
Srinivasa Colony, Ramachandrapuram village and mandal, Medak District.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The Govemment of A.P, rep.by, its Principal Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Joint Collector, Medak District at Sangareddy
3. The Tahsildar, Patancheru Mandal, Medak District.
4. {agariamudi . Verrkata Subba Rao, S/o late Radhakrishna Murthy, occ
Business, Ri/o Rachapudi, post Addanki, Kousapadu mandal, prak-asham
District.
5. Lagula Manohar, S/o. Jangaiah, Rt/o Nandigama village, Patancheru mandal,
Medak District.
6. L.Bheemaiah, S/o Jangaiah, R/o Nandigama village, patancheru mandal,
Medak District.
7. LRamulu, S/o Jangaiah, Rl/o Nandigama village, Patancheru mandal, Medak
District.
L.Laxman, S/o Jangaiah, R/o H.No.1-b2, Nand igama village, Patancheru
Mandal, Medak District.
9. Smt.Mujahithipuram Pushpamma,
Lingampally, Ranga Reddy District.
Wo Yadaiah, Fl/o H.No.1-141,
10.K.Amruthamma, Wo Mogulapa, Rt/o H.No.2-26, Damarched village,
Basheerabad. mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
11.Aliva Prabhavathi, Wo A.Yadagiri, R/o H.No.2-26, Damarched village,
Basheerabad mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
(respondents 5 to 11 are not necessary parties and are rep.by their GpA
holder i.e., respondent No.4)
12.Yellagoni Pentamma, Wo Yadaiah, R/o Nandigama village, Patancheru
manda', Medak District.
13.Chakal,i .S_atyallgyqna, S/o Pentaiah, R/o Nandigama village, Patancheru
mandal, Medak District.
14. Chakali Laxminarayana, S/o Pentaiah, R/o Nandigama village, Patancheru
mandal, Medak District.
l5.Chakali Mallesham, S/o Satyanarayana, Rl/o Nandigama village, Patancheru
mandal, Medak District.
16. Ramineni Shekar Saibaba, S/o Veeraiah, Rl/o Nandigama village, Patancheru
mandal Medak District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to issJe a writ, order or Direction more particularly one in the nature
of
writ of Manrjamus declaring the impugned proceeding No.F3/4770l2008F3l42lRoV2oc8 dated 22.s.2o09 passed by the 2nd respondent as illegal,
arbitrary, without jurisdiction and consequenfly direct the 3rd respondent to reenter the nam€, of the petitioner in the revenue records.
lA NO: 1 OF 2A25
Petition under section 1s1 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
expedite the ht:aring of the w.P. No, 23907 of 20'13 by fixing an early date for
final hearing, and pass such other order
Counsel forther Petitioner: SRt CH. VIDYASAGAR RAO, SENTOR COUNSEL
REPRESENTING SRI PALLE SRIHARINATH
Counsel forthe Respondents No.1 to 3: Gp FOR REVENUE
counsel for the Respondent No.4: sRr v. RAvr KIRAN RAo, sENloR couNSEL
APPEARING FOR SRI JAYARAJ JOEL BABU RAIDU
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TEI"ANGANA
AT ITYDERABAI)
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION No.2-39_OJ oJ 2013
pATE: &?.O2.?026
BETWEEN:
Karike Niruparani
....Petitioner
AND
The Government of Andhra
Pradesh represented by its
Principal Secretary, Revenue
Department and 15 others.
Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri Ch.Vidyasagar Rao, learncd Senior Counsel
representing Sri Palle Sriharinath, learned counsel for the
petitioner; learned Government Pleader lor Revenue for the
official respondents and Sri V.Ravi Kiran Rao, learned Senior
Counsel appearing for Sri Jayaraj Joel Babu Raidu, learned
counsel lor responclent No.4 and perused the i-ecord.
2.
This writ petition is filed unrler Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, with the following prayer:"...to issue a Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one in the
nature of Writ o.f Mandamus declarhtg the impugned proceeding
No.F3/ 4770/ 20O8-l'^3/ 42/ ROR/ 2O0E dctte<l 22.5.2009 passed by
tlrc 2nd resportd.ent as illegal, arbitrar'4, wtthottt juisdiction and
)
:onsequently direct the 3rd respondent to re-enter the name of the
,cetitioner in the reuenue records and pass such other order or
orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the
,nterest of .justice."
3.
'lhe lis pertains to agricultural land admeasuring Ac.6.13
Gts in Sy No. 256 of Nandigama Village, Patancheru Mandal,
Medak District. The petitioner claims to have purchased an
extent of Ac.2.08 Gts out of the said survey number from
respondent Nos.13 and 14 uide registered sale deed dated
25.03.:2004. The 4th respondent claims rights over the entire
extent of Ac.6.13 Gts in Sy No.256 based on a registered
General Power of Attorney-cum-Agreement of Sale dated
30.08.11007 executed in his favour by respondent Nos.5 to 11,
who clzrim to bc the legal heirs of the original protected tenant,
late LaSlula Swamy.
Factual matrix {in brief}
4.
The present writ petition emanates from protracted
dispute concerning agricurltural lands in Sy.Nos.25l, 252 and
256 of Nandigama Villagc, under the provisions of the Andhra
PradeshL (Telangana Area) Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act,
1950 (frr short, 'the 'lenancy Act'), and subsequent revenue
adjudications. 'lhe essential facts, stated in their chronological
sequence, are delineated hereunder:
--"'--Y
,,/
i) Originally, one Bhooma Goud was the protected tenant of
the subject lands. Upon his demise, his sole son, Lagula
Swamy, succeedcd to the tcnancy rights by virtue of
Section 4O ol the Tenancy Act. 'l'hereafter, the competent
authority granted a certificate under Section 38-E of the
Tenancy Act in favour of Lagula Swamy on 14.05.1985,
conferring orvnership rights, and his name was
accordingly mutated in the revenue records as pattadar
and possessor.
ii) It is thc casc on record that certain sale transactions were
allegedly executed in the year 1973 by Lagula Swamy in
favour of Yellagoni Pentamma and the predecessors of
respondent Nos.13 and 14. These transactions are stated
to have been unregistered and on plain paper, and to have
preceded the grant of the Section 38-E certificate.
iii) On the strength of such alleged documents, the Mandal
Revenue Officer (MRO), Patancheru, issued certificates
under Section 13-B on
29.O9.1994 in
File
Nos.F/3897 11994 and F/38961L994, recognising rights
in favour o[ the said purchasers to an extent of Ac.1.OO in
Sy. No.256 and Ac.S.13 Gts respectively.
iv)
Lagula Swamy is stated to have died leaving behind two
wives namely; Gangamma and Basamma and four
daughters through Basamma, who are arrayed as
respondcnt Nos.5 to 11.
on 30.08.2oo7, thc said legal heirs executed a registered
v)
General Power o[ Attorney-cum-Agreement of Sale with
possession in flavour of the 4ft respondent in respect of
[he entire extent of Ac.6.13 Gts in Sy.No.256.
vi)
lSubsequently, in the year 2008, respondent Nos.S to 11,
represented by their GPA holder (4rh respondent),
prefcrred a revision before the Joint collector under
Iiection 9 of the Andhra pradesh Rights in Land and
l)attadar Pass Books Act, 1971 (for short ,lg7I Act)
challenging the validity of the 13-B certilicates dated
2'9.O9.1994.
vii)
I
- was asserted in the revision proceedings that the
alleged transactions of thc year lg73 were legally
unsustainable, as Lagula Swamy was, at the relevant
point o[ time, onlv a protectcd tenant and therefore not
vr:sted with transferable title. It
',r,as also placed on record
ttrat subsequent to the issuance of the certificate under
S,--cti<>n 38-E on
i4.0S.198S, the statute imposed a
prohibition on alienation for a period of eight years under
Sr:ction 48-A of the Tenancy Act. The notices issued to the
ccncerned parties were returned with the endorsement
)
'refused', and they were accordingl5r proceeded against ex
parte.
viii) By order dated 22.O5.2OO9, the Joint Collector allowed
the revision, holding that the alleged sale transactions of
1973 were devoid of legal validity and that the 13-B
certificates issued in 1994 were unsustainable in law. The
Joint Collector arccordingly set aside the said certificates
and directed mutation of the revenue records in favour of
the GPA holder-cum-agreement holder, i.e., the 4th
respondent, in rcspect of the entire extent in Sy.No.256.
i*) In the interregnum, the present petitioner had purchased
an extent of Ac.2.O8 Gts out of Sy.No.256 from
respondent Nos.i3 and 14 under a registered sale deed
dated 25.O3.2OO4. Pursuant thereto, a Pattadar Pass
Book and Titlc Deed were issued in her favour on
22.03.2005 and her name was entered in the revenue
records.
x) It is asserted that the petitioner became aware of the Joint
Collector's order dated 22.O5.2OO9 only on 25.07.2013,
when certain persons allegedly interfered with her
possession clairning rights under the said order. On
enquiry, petitioner was informed that the revenue entries
had been altered for the year 2oL2-13 in favour of the
16ft respondent on the basis of the impugned order.
xi)
Aggrieved thcrebl', petitioner instituted the present writ
petit.ion scckir-rg to assail the <>rdcr oI the .Joint collector
irnd for consequential directions to restore her name in
'-he revenue records.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner assailed the impugned
order <lated 22.o5.2oo9 and has advanced his submissions as
under:
i) That the )d respondentJoint Collector lacked
jurisdiction to entertain a revision under Section 9
of the 1971 Act, for the purpose of setting aside a
certificaLe issued undcr the provisions of the
Tenancy Act. The revisional porver under Section 9
of the 1971 Act is confined to orders passed under
Sections 3, 5, 5-A or 5-B thereof, and does not
extend to adjudicating upon thc validity of a 13_B
certificate issued under the Tenancy Act. The
impugned order was therefore stated to be without
jurisdiction and void.
ii) That the petitioner, having purchased the subject
property under a registered sale deed dated
25.03.2004 and having been issued a Pattadar Pass
Book and Title Deed on 22.O3.2OO5, was a
necessary and proper party to the revision
proceedings.
iii) That failure to implead the petitioner and afford an
opportunit-v of hearing was alleged to be violative of
the principles of natural justice. [t was also urged
that the revision petition itself, having been filed in
the year 2008 challenging certificates issued in
1994, suffered from inordinate delay and ought not
to have been entertained.
iv) That the petitioner is a bona fide purchaser for
valuable cclnsideration, who acted on the basis of
subsisting revenue entries and 13-B certificates
standing in the names of her vendors.
v) That the pctitioner's rights had crystallised and
ought not to have been unsettled by the impugned
order on the basis of Pattadar Pass Book and
subsequent Pahanies reflecting her possession.
Submissions on behalf of respondent No.4
6.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for respondent No.4,
supported the impugned order and submitted as under:
i) That the foundational document of titre is the certificate
issued under Section 38-E of the Tenancy Act on
14.05.1985 in favour of late Lagula Swamy. Upon his
demise, his legal heirs (respondent Nos.5 to l1)
succeeded to the property. The alleged alienations of
the year 1973, r,r,hich formed the basis for issuance of
13-B certificates in lgg4, were stated to be legally
untenable.
ii) That at the time of the alleged sale in LgZ3, Lagula
Srvamy was only a protected tenant and had no
transferable title. orvnership rights were conferred only
upon issuance of the 38-E certificate in
1995.
Moreover, Section 48-A of the Tenancy Act imposed a
statutory embargo on alienation for a period of eight
years thereafter. Any transaction in contravention of
the said provision was asserted to be void.
Consequently, the 13-B certificates, having been
founded upon such transactions, were liable to be
annulled.
iii) That the revisional jurisdiction under section 9 of the
l97l Act empowers the Joint collector to examine the
legality and correctness of entries in the Record of
Rights. where the foundational document for mutation
is void or non-est, the revisional authority is competent
to set aside such entries to prevent perpetuation of
illegality in the revenue records.
i*r) That no title can pass from a person who has none, and
the petitioner's vendors, deriving title from a void
transaction, could not convey any lawful interest, thus
petitioner cannot claim as a bona fide purchaser.
v) That the ',r,rit petition was also stated to be liable for
dismissal on the ground of dcla_v, as the impugned
order u,as passed in 2OO9 whereas the writ petition was
instituted in 2013.
Submissions on behalf of respondent Nos.l to 3
7.
Learned Government Pleader lor Revenue (Telangana
Area) supported the impugned order and submitted as under:
i) That the Joint Collector had excrcised his revisional
jurisdiction in accordance with lau'.
ii) That the 13-B certificates were issued without proper
authority and on thc basis of rransactions lacking legal
validity. The Joint Collector, upon examination of the
relevant records and statutory provisions, set aside the
said certilicates and directed correction of the revenue
entries.
l0
i:i) That the impugned order is reasoned and within the
scope of statutory powers, and does not r,rrarrant
interf<:rence in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226
ol thc Constitution of India.
8.
I have taken note of the respective submissions urged and
the material on record, including the proceedings before the
revenlre authorities, the impugned order dated 22.os.2oo9, and
the other connected documents and perused the record.
Consideration by this Court
9.
In the present case, it is apposite to remind oneself of the
contours oljurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. 'lhis court does not sit in appeal over findings recorded
by a cluasi-judicial authority. lnterference is warranted only
where the impugned order is vitiated by jurisdictional error,
patent error of law apparent on the face of the record,
perversitr', or violation of principles of natural justice. Reappreciation of evidence or substitution of this court,s view for
that of the sratutory authority is impermissible within the
limited,lompass otjudicial review.
1971 Ar:t
1().
The core /is that arises for consideration pertains to the
competence of tly: Joint collector to examine the validity of a
ll
l3-B certificate issued under the'l'enancy Act while exercising
revisional jurisdiction unde r Section 9 of the 1971 Act.
11. Section 9 of the 1971 Act empowers the District Collector
to call for and examine records relating to orders passed under
Sections 3, 5, 5-A or 5-B of the I97I Act for the purpose of
satisfying himself as to their legalicy or propriety. These
provisions relate to preparation and maintenance of record of
rights and mutation entries.
L2. It is well-settled that a 13-B certificate originates under
the Tenancy Act. However, in the present casc, the revision
before the Joint Collector was directed against mutation entries
in the revenue records, u,hich were admittedly founded upon the
13-B certificates issued in 1994.'fhus, the revisional authority
was called upon to examine the legality o[ entries made in the
rccord of rights.
13. It is apposite to observe that '*,here mutation entries are
founded upon a document alleged to be void or lacking legal
sanctity, the authority vested with supervisory jurisdiction over
revenue records cannot be rendered functus officio in examining
the validiff of such foundational document, to the limited extent
necessary to assess the legality of the consequential entries. In
the present case, the Joint Collector did not embark upon an
independent determination of tenancy rights; he confined
t2
himsr:lf to examining whether the mutation entries could be
susta.ned in law if the underlying transaction itself was devoid
o[ leg,ll effcct-. 'lhcreforc, the exercise undertaken by the Joint
collector cannot be characterised as one beyond the scope of
Section 9 of the 1971 Act.
Allese d Viola tion o f Natural Justice
L4. [n the instant case, it is undisputed that the petitioner
was not arrayed as a party to the revision proceedings. However,
the re corcl discloses that notices were issued to the then
record,:d pattadars, which were returned ',l,ith the endorsement
'refuseC', and the-v were accordingly set ex parte.
15. It is to be noted that the petitioner claims to have
purchascd the propertv in 2oo4 from respondent Nos.l3 and
14, whose names were reflected in the revenue records on the
strength of thc 13-B certificates. The question, therefore, is
whether the petitioner had acquired such a vested and
independcnt right as u,'ould render the impugned order void for
non-imrlcadmcnt. As already observed, the title of respondent
Nos.13 and 14 u'as wholly traceable to the alleged alienations of
r973 and the consequential 13-B certificates. If
the
foundational transaction itself lacked legal validity, any
derivatire claim flowing therefrom cannot confer a superior or
indepencent rjght upon the petitioner. In such circumstances,
l3
mere non-impleadment would not, by itself, render the
impugned order void, particularly in the absence of
demonstrable prejudice or infringemcnt o[ a lcgally sustainable
right.
Validitv of the Petitioner's Title
L6. A perusal of the record reflects t.hat late Lagula Swamy
was granted ownership rights under Section 38-E of the
Tenancy Act only on 14.05.1985. Prior thereto, he was a
protected tenant.
L7. It is trite law that under the schcmc o[ the'lcnancy Act, a
protected tenant does not possess absolute ownership rights
prior to conferment of ownership under Section 38-E.
Furthermore, Section 48-A of the Tenancy Act imposes a
statutory prohibition on alienation for a period of eight years
from the date of issuance of the ownership certificate.
18. In the present case, the alleged alienation is of the year
L973, i.e., prior to conferment of ownership in 1985. Prima
facie, such transaction could not have conveyed valid title. The
13-B certificates issued in 1994 were founded upon the said
alleged transaction. If the underlying sale itself lacked legal
efficacy, any derivative rights flowing therefrom would
necessarily be unsustainable.
l4
19. Furthermore, the petitioner's purchase in 2oo4 was from
respondent Nos.i3 and 14, who derived their claim solely from
the 1{}-B certificates. It is w,ell settled that a transferee cannot
acquire better title than that possessed by his transferor. The
plea <rf bona fide purchase, though equitable in character,
cannol override statutory prohibitions or validate a transaction
that is voirl in lau'.
20- '[he Pattadar Pass Book and revenue entries relied upon
by the petitioner are fiscal records and do not, by themselves,
confer titlc. Thev merely rcflect possession or entries made for
revenue purposes. ln the absence of a valid root of title, such
entries cannot crcate or perfect ownership.
Delav:rnd laches
2L- At this juncture, it is relevant to note that the impugned
order rvvas l)asscd on '22.os.2oo9, whereas the writ petition ,rvas
instituted in 2013. The petitioner states that knowledge of the
order was zrcquirr:d onlSr in July 2OL3. While the explanation
may n()t be cntircly convincing, it is evident that the writ
petition was filed soon after the asserted date of knowledge.
22. on the other hand, the revision before the Joint collector
was filel in 2ooti challenging certificates issued in 1994. The
revisionirl ar-rthorit-\, acceptcd the explanation of knowledge and
proceedt:d t. examine thc legality of the certilicates, particularly
l5
i
T
t
t
I
I
T
in view of the allegation that the unde.rlying transaction was
a
*
void. tt is settled that a void transaction does not acquire
validity by lapse of time, and the aurhority r,r,as justified in
examining the matter on merits. The revisional authority
therefore cannot be faulted. Thus, no ground is made out for
interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Conclusion
23.
For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered
view that the impugned order dated 22.O5.'2OO9 passed by the
Joint Collector, Medak district, does not suffer from any
illegality, perversity, or jurisdictional infirmity warranting
interference under Article 226 of the constitution of India. The
said order correctly held that the alleged lg73 transaction was
legally untenable and that the 13-B certificates issued in 1994
were unsustainable . The consequential direction to rectify the
revenue entrtes ln favour of the 4th respondent, claiming
through the legal heirs of late Lagula Srvamy. is therefore,
unassailable.
24. It is also noted that the interim order granted on
14.o8.2o13 in w.P.M.P.No.29387 of 2o13 has continued for a
considerable length of time and has become absolute on
I
J
r6
29.02.2024. continuance of such interim protection, in the
absence ol an5, sustainable ground, cannot be justified.
2s. Accordingly', the writ Petition is dismissed. The order
dated 22.o5.2009 passed b.r' the Joint collector, Medak District,
is alfirmed. 'l'hc inrcrim order dated 14.08.2013 in
W.P.M.P.No.29387 of 2OI3, which was made absolute on
29.O2.2024, is hereby vacated.
oonscqucnth,., misccllaneous pe titions pending if any shall
stand r:loscd. No order as to costs.
Sd/. P. PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT REGTSTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFTCER
To
one c(] to SRI PALLE SRTHARTNATH, Advocate
Two ccs to Gp for Revenue, High court for the state
Hyderabad. [OUT]
topucl
of rerangana at
3. one cc to sRI JAYARAJ JOEL BABU RAIDU, Advocate
topucJ
4. Two C[) Copies
MP.
v
HIGH COURT
DATED i2710212026
,f,;
t
()
THE S
0 5 ritlP ')ntn
*
a
ORDER
WP.No.23907 of 2013
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
hb
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review