Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
{
[ 34841
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITI ON NOs: 1434 oF 2004 &2 3738 0F 2022
W.P.No. 1434 0F 2004
Between:
smt Bommaraiu Pushpa Devi. Wo.B Sathaiah, Occ Cultivation' R/o H No' 1ii,Twkamlzal'(V) HyathnagarMandal R R Distrrct
BommaraiuSathalah'S/o.lateSomaiah@B.Ramaswamy,R/o.H.No'1-42'
irrii.i.6t (V). Hyathnagar Mandal R R District'
...PETITIONER
AND
B. Yadaiah, S/o.Samaiah, Occ: Police Constable, HC No
s-tgli. sn"e, Rao Nagar, Alwal-10, R R Dist.
2114' R/o H No 1-
B. Shankeraiah, (Died as per LRs RR'1Oto14)
Turkamzal
V. Maruthi, S/o. not Known, Occ Village Administrative Officer'
Village, Hyathnagar Mandal, R.R. District
R District'
4 Mandal Revenue Officer' Hyathnagar Mandal, R
Malakunta'
Revenue Divisional Offrcer, Eastern Division, R.R Dist
Hyderabad.
f)
Joint Collector, R.R. Drstrict, Lakadikapool, Hyderabad'
Rep by its
State of Telanqana. (the then Government of Andhra Pradesh)'
6'niuf S""i"irt"v, Secietariat Bu ild ings. Hyderabad'
(R7 is impleaded as per C.O dt. 1gt2l2}15 in WPMP No 3456/2015)
-:
O8. Smt
fl P--ushpam rna
w/a :LEG 4anlasi
BixapatiGo
ud
R/o. rr .No.2-93 Patiguda Aged a bout6 4'years, r.
:c. Agricultu re
Vilta 9e, Turka
Abdult apurmet
yamzat
N,r
Mand
nicipatity,
09. s ri. Nandagiri al Ranga Redd y Districf T.ti
D as Gou d
S/o. Late Papaiah
Go u4, A9 ed
about 60 years,
R/o. H.No. 2-95
Pati guda Vi llag€
Or : Toddy To pper,
Abdultapu rmet
,-Tu7kE
yamzal
Mandal Ran ga
M r ,"icipality,
Reddy
,
i
Respondent n os.8
and 9
n IA No.Zl20 2a (Wp
No.
Diskjci r.S
i'-U*"Sf;d as pt: c.o.dt. 20.02.2026
10. Bomma rilu
Laxmi @ ta kshmi
Wo. Late Bo rnmaraju
Shankei Age
Colony, Kam
60 years, H.N ("2 -75.
maguda, Abdul lapu
SriSri Na gar
rmet Mandal
11. Bomma raju
Rangir ?eddy District.
Ashok
S/o; Late B ommaraju
Colony, Ka mmaguda Shank er, Age; 44years
, Abdull apurmet Mandal H .No 2-7511. SriSri Nagar
12. Bom maraj
Ra nga leddy
u Jagadish
District.
S/o Late Bomm
ara.1u Shanker
Age 37 years,
Colony, Kamrna
H.N o.2- 73.
guda Abdufiap
Sri Sri Na gar
urmet Manoa
13. Bo mma rdu
L Ranga f :ddy District
Jeevan Ku rnar,
S/o Late Bo rnma
ralu Shanker
Colon Y,
, Age: 32 years H.No.
9pp; SB I Bank and A ndhra
t- 25. SriSriNa gar
Raod , Abilullapu
Bank, Ka mmagudl
rmet
Turka yamj alX
t4. J ananeela Sony,Mandal Rang a Redd Y District
wlo Jananela Narsimha
, Age: 34 years, H.No.
Kam maguda;A
2-75 Sr i Sri
bdulapu rmet Mandal
Nagar Colon
Ra nga Reddy
Y,
D rsit ct.
Responden
t nos. 10 to 74 are
deceased Responde
brought on record
nt
s LRs of the
no.2
as per C, o
No.u2o2 5 (Wp
No ./r 434 of 2OO4). .dt.20.02.2 t 26 in IA
...F:I SPONDENTS
1l
EEri-ri---
l-i,
praying that in the
Petition under Article 226 ot the Constitution of lndia
High Court may be
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith' the
of ltilandamus
pleased to pass orders, directlons or writ in the nature of Writ
Authority illegal and
declaring that the rmpugned order passed by the Appellate
UnconstitutlonalandallowtheWritPetitronbysettingaSidetheordersoftheJoint
F11857'l/98 by
collector. R.R. District, dated 16 7 200'1 , in lnam Appeal File No
allowing the writ Petition.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 20'l O(WPMP. NO: 41325 0F 2010)
stated in
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
may be pleased to
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
w P- No '1434 of
receive the documents as Additional Material Papers in the
2004.
l.A. NO:'l OF 2004(wPMP. N O: 1870 OF 2004)
Petitionundersection,l5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesStatedin
theaffidavitfiledinsupportofthepetition.theHighCourtmaybepleasedtopaSS
passed in lnam
order suspending the operation of the orders dated 16'7 '2001
AppealFileNo-F1/857,1/gStillthefinaldisposalofthefinaloftherevisionpetition
and to pass such other orders to meet the ends of
justice'
IAN O:,3 OF 2024
PetitionunderSectionl5lcPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedin
be pleased to
the affidavit filed in support of the petition the High Court may
r.eceivetheDocumentsfrledhereinasperenclosedRunninglndexherernas
of 2004'
"Additional Material Papers" in the above Writ petition No 1434
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI A'GIRIDHAR RAO
Counsel for the Respondents No'1,8to14 : SRI N'NAVEEN
KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondents No'3,4to7: SRI MURALIDHAR
GP FOR REVENUE
REDDY KATRAM'
W.P.No .23734 o F 2022
Between:
Bomma ,fl ,J,5::its?3"-"J,Yi?:ffir','f,['"11,:i'3:^f3,::fi
Farmer
rteddY District
?;iiur',Ii3l'*3"'n?
...PETITIONER
AND
by its Principal I )cretary' Revenue
The State of Telangana, Represented
o""pr"'t"iJr.ri's""i"i,iti'tBuildingsHyderabad
District' Lakdi-Ka-Porr Hyderabad
The District Collector, Ranga Reddy
Represent d by its Secretary'
The Chief Commisstoner' Land Administration'
ni'luiai, Hvo"rabad, Telangana state'
rbrahimpatnam
4 The Revenue Divisionar officer,
Ranga ReddY District
Division, r urkayamiar V rage,
TheTahsildar,,AbdullapurmetMandal'RangaReddyDis'tct
p:[ff'a,J,,'#11?]
l,ll,,?',i;l'lr],?83,i
tetingana state
ilft]i;Av DisiriCt"?1l,Bl?l',?:r,T"::'1fil,'",?Lxll,l;;
- rout 51 Years Occ'
Smt. Bommaraiu Sugunamma W/o
late Dqll9h' Agerl
Nagar colonv'
Housewife, Resident ;i'" i i"l""':;;JDo'
oisrict. Tela"I lana state
r-no
vanasthalipuram L a r'ragli' ni"giR"ddy
...RESPONDENTS
PetitionunderArticle226oftheConstitutionoflndr;rprayingthatinthe
be
filed therewith' the t igh Court may
circumstances stated in the affidavit
of
more partrcurarry ' ne in the nature
preased to issue a writ, order or direction
the Respondents n ssuing Proceedings
wrir of certiorari, declaring the actron of
pass book
and also issuing : pattadar
2BlO4l2O22
daled
2212022
No.D1/6
Letter
pass book No
Katha No 60316 and e-pa1rdar
with
Nos.T05010180989
bearing
Nos 6
issued in favour of th') Respondent
603'17
No
Katha
with
TO50-10180990
-elangana Rrghts in
against the
and
illegal
irregular'
arbitrary,
and 7 ts totally,
Act 9l2O2O a rd consequently set
Pattadar Pass Books Act' 2020 ie '
Land and
aside the same
:u
IA NO: 2oF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC prayrng that
in the circumstances stated in
theaffidavitfiledinsupportofthepetition.theHighCourtmaybepleasedto
suspend the lmpugned Proceedings issued by
the 2nd respondent vide Letter
No-D1l622t2O22daled''2SlO4t2o22byremovingthenamesofRespondentNos6
andTintherevenuerecordsandinDharaniPortalandrestoringthepetitioner's
Portal in respect of Ac 0 03 guntas
name in the revenue records in the Dharani
Village' Abdullapurmet Mandal'
each in Sy.No.358/AA situated at Turkayamial
Ranga Reddy District, pending disposal of the
Writ Petition'
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI A'GIRIDHAR
RAO
MURALIDHAR REDDY KATRAM'
Counsel for the Respondents No'1tos : SRI
GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondents No'6&7 : SRI
N'RAVI PRASAD
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TT LANGANA
AT HYDERABN)
THE HON'BLE SRI WSTICE G.M.MOHIU DDIN
WRIT PETITION Nos.1434 of 2OO4 and 2373t of 2o.22
DATE: &o.O2.2O26
Writ Petition No.1434 of 2OO4
BeLrr'een:
Bommaraju Pushpa Devi and another
..Petitioners
AND
B.Yadaiah and l3 others
... Respo nde nts
Writ Petition No.23738 of 2o.22
Between
Bommara-jn Pushpa Devi
...Petitioner
AND
The Statc of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Revenuc Department, Hlfderabad and six others
... Respondents
COMMON ORDER
Since the subject matter, parties involved an,1 he issues that
arise in the above Writ Petitions are integrally on,: nd the same,
thcsc matters are being disposed of by this common r r ler.
\
2.
W.P.No.7434 of 2004, is filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, with the follorving prayer:"-.--.....^oA be pl.eased to pass orders, directions or u,rit in the
nature of uit of mand-amus declaring that the impugned_ order
passed by the AppeLLate AuthoritA illegal and unconstitutional
and allout the uit petition bg setting aside the orders of the
Joint Collector, R.R. Dstnct, dated 16-7-2OOl in Inam Appeal,
File No. F1/8571/98 bg alLowing the utit petition and to poss
such otl,Ler order or orders to meet the ends of justice.
3.
W.P.No.23738 ol 2022, is filed under Article 226 of t]ne
Constitution of India, with the following praycr:". ......*oA be pleased ,o rssue a Wnq ord.er or directioru more
particularly one in the nature of Wit of Cerliorari, declaring the
action of the Respondents in issuing Proceedings Letter
No.D1/622/2O22 dated:28.04.2022 and also issuing epottadar pass book beaing Nos. TO5O1O18O989 Luith Katha
No.6O316 and e-pattadar pass book No. T05O1O18O99O uith
Katha No.60317 issued in fauour of the Respondent Nos. 6 and
7 is totallg, arbitrary, irregular, tllegal and against the
Telangana Rights in Land and Pattadar Pa-ss Books Act, 2O2O
i.e., Act 9/2020 and consequentlg set aside the same and pass
such otter order or orders os this Honourable Court may deem
fit and proper in the circumstances of the case.
4.
The lst petitioner (wite of 2Dd petitioncr in W.P.No. 1434 of
2OO4) in both the writ petitions is one and the same.
5.
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 in W.P.No- 1434 of 2OO4 are
appellants in Proceedings No.Fl/8571/98 dated 16.O7.2OOl.
.4.
6.
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 in W.P.No. 1434 r>f 2004 and
respondent Nos.6 and 7 in W.P.No.23738 of 2022 tre hereinafter
referred as 'rival claimants'.
7.
Heard Sri Giridhar Rao, learned counsel frrr- the petitioners
in both the writ petitions and Sri N.Naveen Kumar, I zrrned counsel
for respondent No.1, 1O to 14 and Sri K.Muralidhar leddy, learned
Government Pleader for Revenue for respondent Ni r.3, 4 to 7 in
W.P.No.1434 of 2OO4 and respondent Nos.l to 5 in \! P.No.23738 of
2022, Sri N.Ravr Prasad, learned counsel for responde 'rt Nos.6 and 7
and pcrused the record.
Chronology of the litigation
8. The present writ petitions, though instituted nez I v two decades
aparL, emanate from a common dispute regarding t re agricultural
Iand admeasuring Ac.O-32Y2 Gts in Sy No.358 c- Turkayamjal
Village, Hayathnagar Mandal (presently Abdullap I -met Mandal) ,
Ranga Reddy District. What commenced as l r rntra-lamily
disagreement bctwcen brothers in respect of ance; ral Inam land
has, over the years, escalated into protracted a I I multifrrri<>us
litiga tion.
9.
W.P.No.l434 of 2OO4, instituted in rhe year 2004, calls in
question the proceedings of the Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy
District, dated 16.07.2001 in Inam Appeal Fite No.Fl/8571/98,
whereby the order granting Occupancy Rights Certificate (ORC) in
favour of the 1st petitioner was set aside and a direction was issued
to grant ORC jointly in favour of the 2"a petitioner and respondent
Nos. 1 and 2, each with equal shares.
lO.
W.P.No.23738 of 2022, filed almost two decadcs thercafter,
assails the implementation of an ORC granted in the \.ear 2008 in
favour of respondent Nos.6 and 7 therein, u,ho assert independent
rights over extents of Ac.O-O3 Gts each in the very same Sy No.358.
The said writ petition arises out of and in furtherance of the
implementation of the order passed by this Court in W.P.No. 1 1907
of 2021.
Factual matrix lia brief)
11.
The Subject land admeasuring Ac. 1-25 Gts in Sy No.358 of
Turkayamjal Village, is undisputedly a 'Chakali Vandla Bavi,
Chowtha lqaru- land governed by the provisions of the A. p.
(Telangana Area) Abolition of Inams Act, 1955 (for short 1nams Act').
The record indicates that the original Inamdars were Devarakonda
qry
Bhoomaiah, Devarakonda Kistaiah and Devarakonrlz iayanna, each
holding an undivided l/3'a share.
12.
The present dispute concerns the branch :
'Devarakonda
I
Kistaiah. According to respondent Nos'l and 2 in /.P.No.1434 of
2004, their father [-ate B. Rama Swamy was the Inar rdar/ co-sharer
and, upon his demise on 08.10. 1972, h.is sons nant( ty, B. Sattaiah
(2nd petitioner in W.P.No.1434 of 2004) and the t-t I pondent Nos. I
and 2 i.e., B. Yadaiah and B. Shankaraiah cor'r nued in joint
possession and cultivation, their names were reflectt < as such in the
revenue records.
13.
The petitioners assert that the 2nd petitior(: is the son of
Late B. Samaiah and not of Late B. Rama Swarnl , and that both
individuats are t\\/o entirely different persons' It is he case o[ the
petitioners that aftcr separation from his brothers r:;pondent Nos'1
and 2 in W.P.No- 1434 of 2OO4, tlrre 2na petitiont i independently
purchased Ac.O-32'/z Gts out of Sy.No.358 through rr rregistered sale
deeds from private individuats in 1980-81 utilizinp .he jewellery of
the 1,r petilioncr and subsequently executed an : eregistercd gift
deed dated 05.I1.1981 in favour of the l"t peti'i)ner' The rival
claims thus turn substantially on identity of lll age, nature of
acquisilion of rights, possession ald entitlement utrrl rr the Act'
L4.
Following amendments to the Rules framed under the
Inams Act and the conduct of special drives for identification of
eligible occupants, the 1"t petitioner apptied for grant of
occupancy rights based on her claim of possession through the gift
deed. The Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO), by proceedings
dated 09.03. 1998 in File No.J/8738 /97 , grantcd an ORC in her
lavour and consequential pattadar pass book was issucd.
15.
Aggrieved thereby, respondent Nos. 1 and 2 preferrcd an
appeal under Section 24 of thre Act before the Joint Collector, Ranga
Reddy District, in Appeal No.F1/8571/98. By order dated
16.07.200l, the Joint Collector allowed the appeal, set aside the
ORC granted to the 1st petitioner and held that the legal heirs of Late
Rama Swamy, namely B. Yadaiah, B. Shankaraiah and B. Sattaiah
were entitled to occupancy rights in equal shares in respect of Ac.O-
32Yz Gts in Sy.No.358, having regard to the revenue entries
reflecting their joint possession. The relevant portion of the order
reads as follows:
'On perusal of the pahanies for the gears 1977-78 tt is seen that
the land bearing Sg.No.358 admeasuing Ac.1-25 guntas is clossifed as
"Chakali Vandla Bavi Choutha Inam and the names of Durgaialy
Ramaswomg and Aagaiah <tre recorded as lruqmdars and tLe names of
Dtraialg RamaswamA, Mgsaiah and Rangaiah qre recorded os
possessors. In the pahani for the year 1981-82 the name of Chalkali
Aagaiafu Chakali Ramqsuamg and Chakali Durgaiah recorded os
lnamdors. In the pahani for the year 1987-88 the names of Bommoraju
Sataial4 $hdnkaraiqh and Yqdaiah sons of Ramasuamg are sholrn as
possessors to Lhe ertent of 3/ 4th share in Sy.No 358. 7 Le- names of
thtrgaiah, Jangaiah, Yadaioh and Rangaiah are also qzcorded as
possessors aguinst Sg.No.358- In tl'te pahani for the gea' 1 989-90 the
name oJ Bomtnaraju Sqthaiqh, Shankaraiah and Yada ah sons of
Ramasuomg haue been recorded as possessors agatnst Sg No.358. 1l is
seen fronr the etllnes in the Reuenue Records thqt Rc'most t tng u,as one
of the Inomdars tn respect of Sg.No.358 situated. at Turko t ,njal V Lage,
Houatnagar ltkndaL The name of RamaswamA, faller o[ t <'appellants
ond responde'nt No.2 is recorded as Inamdar against St No.358 right
Jronl the lJear 1955 56 to 1957 58 (sesho,ta Pahani) oruuords
The contention o[ tlw Counsel for Respondents thot tl ( lather oJ the
appellants and Respondent No.2 did not haue ang agri<'ult ual lqnds is
totallg un-belieuable in uieu of tlle fdct that the name of I\ ntasudma is
recorded as iramdar in tte reuenue records. The names of t Le appellants
ond Respondcttl No.2 haue been shou,n as possessors ir le pahanies
agoinst 5A.No.358. Tlerefore, the contention of the Respond z I No.2 that it
s a self acquirt:d propertA is totallA baseless and the Respo'L 'ent No.2 has
crectted a sqlc lransochon on a plain paper and also a Gi,ft t eed which is
un registered only lo depiue llrc oppellants th.eir legitimote tigllts in the
propertA hetd bg their father as inamdar. The Gifi Deec t,htch is unregistered is rn-ualid in the eAe of Intu and hos been cr c|ted onlg to
transfer the soid propertg in fauour of Respondent No.l uht ;s the uife of
Respondent No.2. Therefore, this CourT is of the uielu thot I v appellants
and as well as Respondent No.2 utho are tLLe legal t eirs of kate
oJ Sg.
Ramoswanlg ore entitled for grant of Occ'upancg Rights rn
"spect
Village,
rrlal
Turka.l
situated
al
No.358 to an crtent oI 0 32% Wntas
Hagathnagar Mandal.
In the resutt lhe oppeal is allouted and. the orders o1 the Reuenue
Diuisronat Officer, dt.9.3.1998 passed in fite No.J/8738/9'. ve set aside
and tle Reueiue Diuistona[ OJficer, RR Eost Division shrtLL i:: te ocanpanca
Rights Certtficote in fauour oJ the oppellants namelA 1) Bomnl, raju Yadaiah
S/o.Lqte V.Rartasutamg, 2) Bomntaraju Shu'nka'raia't S/ o. Lqte
B.Ramasuantg ond os utell qs Respondent No.2 nqn*L Bommaraju
Sothaish S/ o. l.ate B. Ramasuamg with equal shores-
16.
Pursuant to the said appellate order, the IDO issued a
fresh ORC dated 16.06.20O3 in File No.J /1917 12003 : favour of the
three brothers, .rnd the Mandal Revenue Officer (MR( ) implemented
the same in thc rcvenuc records and issued pattadar I ass books and
title deeds in thcir respective names.
!r!-l_Ill-l
\
17.
The petitioners initially filed C.R.p.No .3929 of 2OO I bcfore
the ersLwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh against the order of tl-re
Joint Collector dated 16.07 .2OOl. By order dated 23.12.20O3, the
revision was dismissed as not maintainable, holding that no revision
lies against an order passed under Section 24 of the Act and
granting liberty to pursue appropriate remedy.
18.
Thereafter, W.P.No. 1434 of 2OO4 was instituted challenging
the order of the Joint Collector dated 16.07.2OO1. During its
pendency, ancillary proceedings ensued, including criminal
proceedings arising out of allegations of fabrication of school records
pertaining to paternity, culminating in frling of a charge sheet in
C.C.No.O9 of 2Ol7 on the flle of the IV Metropolitan Magistra[e,
Ibrahimpatnam.
19.
Certain third parties, claiming independent titie under a
registered sale deed dated 1O.03.1988 and consequential occupancy
rights, also sought impleadment in the said writ proceedings
asserting that they had acquired portions of land in Sy.No.358 and
obtained ORCs and pattadar pass books in their favour. Multiple
interlocutory applications were Iiled by both sides placing additional
documents -aad seeking amendments, thereby prolonging
adjudication.
20..
While mrrtters stood thus, respondent N,r.6 and 7 in
W.P.No.23738 of 2022 were granted ORCs b1' -he RDO on
24.12.2OO8 in Procecdings No.J/2819/2OO8 for Ac.O ' 3 Gts each in
Sy.No.358/AA. Consequcntial pattadar pass books uere issued to
them in the year 2O09. These grants were made sull .equent to the
appeltate order dated 16.07.200l and during th: pendency of
W.P.No. 1434 of 2OO4.
21.
With thc introduction o[ the Dharani portal r rd issuance of
e-pattadar pass books, respondent Nos.6 and 7 lL' proached the
authorities seeking mutation and issuance of upc i ted electronic
pass books. As their request was not process( 1, they hled
W.P.No. ll9O7 of 2O2l before this Court. By order da t d 16.06.2021,
this Court obscrved that pattadar pass books ci rlnot prccede
mutation in revenue records and directed the petiti(,1 ers therein to
upload requisite documents on the Dharani portal lcr consideration
by the District Collector in accordance with law.
22.
Upon subsequent administrative inl t I rention and
compliance procecdings, the District Collector issut I proceedings
d,ated 28.04.2022 and the Tahsildar issued e-pattadar pass books in
favour of respondent Nos.6 and 7 for Ac.O-03 i ts each. The
contempt case filed alleging non-compliance was Llr reafter closed
-!-
q
recording compliance- Aggrieved by the issuance of these e-pass
books, the present W.P.No.23738 of 2022 has been filed.
Submissions of the parties in W.P.No.143.4 of 2OO4
On behalf of the petitioners
23.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners assailed
the order dated 16.07.2OO1 passed by the Joint Collector in
Appeal No.Fl/8571/98 and advanced the following submissions:
i) That the 2"d petitioner had purchased the subject extent of
Ac.O-32Y2 Gts in Sy.No.358 during the years 1980-81 from the
erstwhile possessors, namely Bagaiah, Ramulu, pentaiah,
Ettat1za and Maisaiah, for valid sale consideration. Though
the sale deeds were unregistered, it is urged that possession
was delivered pursuant thereto.
ii)
That in view of the finalcial contribution made by his wife, the
2nd petitioner executed an unregistered gift deed dated
05. 1 1.1981 in favour of the l"t petitioner, who has since been
in exclusive possession and enjoyment of the land.
ii|
That the 2"d petitioner is the son of Late B. Samaiah, S/o.
Agaiah, alrd not the son of Late B. Rama Swamy, S/o.
Narsaiah. According to the petitioners, the respondents
have deliberately conflated two distinct individr als in order to
-
project a false claim of joint family entitlement.
irr) That respondent Nos. I and 2, having allegec , separated in
J
the year 1972, preferred the appeal ber re the Joint
Collector only in 1998, after an inordinate laps : of time.
v) That the Joint Collector proceeded to set e side the ORC
granted to the 1"t petitioner without affording proper notice
and opportunity, and relied upon pahanies all,: ;edly produced
belatedly and without verifi cation.
vi) That the Joint Collector exceeded the limit d jurisdiction
under Section 24 of the lnams Act by e I barking upon
questions of title and partition, which fall exc usively within
the domain of civil Courts. According to I re petitioners,
entitlement to occupancy is related to actual p( ssession as on
the crucial/ relevant date and not on the basis : ' succession or
inheritance.
On behalf of respondent Nos.l and 2
24.
Learned counsel for respondent Nos.l and 1 supported the
impugned order and submitted as under:
i) That the land is ancestral Inam land and that r( r'enue records,
including pahanies from 1955-56 onwards, corr istently reflect
t2
the name of Late B. Rama Swamy as one of the
lnamdars/ possessors. After his demise in 1972, the names of
his sons, B. Sattaiah, B. Yadaiah and B. Shankaraiah, were
recorded as joint possessors and cultivators, which
conclusively establish joint family possession.
ii) That the alleged unregistered sale deeds and gift deed set up
by the petitioners are fabricated and legally unenforceable.
The purported vendors were never shown in revenue records
as Inamdars or possessors. Further, once the Inam vested in
the State under the Act, no private transaction could conler
valid title without slatutory recognirion.
iii) That the petitioners have taken inconsistent stands regarding
the identity of the 2nd petitioner's father in the affidavit and
reply afhdavit, thereby undermining their credibility.
iv) That there exists pima facie material indicating manipulation
of records, on the basis of criminal proceedings initiated on
allegations of fabrication of school records, culminating in
filing of a charge sheet in C.C.No.09 of 2077 .
v) That the Joint Collector's order, passed upon detailed
examination of the revenue records, has been implemented
and fresh ORCs and pattadar pass books have been issued.
The settled position, having remained undisturbed for over two
lt;*
.._l::".0; .,-
Z
3>'
i3
decades, ought not to be unsettled in exercise , f discretionary
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constituri,r r
vi) That the writ petition involves seriously dispu, cl questions of
fact relating to genealogr, title and possessior r which cannot
be adjudicated in writ proceedings.
On behalf of proposed res Pondent Nos.8 and 9
25.
karned counsel appearing for the propo; d respondent
Nos.8 and 9, submitted that his clients are bona 7 ie purchasers
of a portion of land in Sy.No.358 under a registered s rle deed dated
1O.03.1988. It is contended thar they have
subsequen tly
obtained occupancy rights and pattadar pass books -r their favour
and are in settled possession. Any adjudication in t I -' presen t writ
petition, according to them, would directly affect rlL( ir proprietary
rights and, therelore, their impleadment is necessilra for complete
and effective adjudication.
Submissions of the parties in W.p.No.23Zgg OF 2O..2 r.
On behalf of the petitioner
26.
Learned counsel for the petitioner assailecl t l- : issuan<:e of
e-pattadar pass books in favour of respondent Nos. > and 7 and
submitted as under:
ry
i) That the impugned action of the revenue authorities in issuing
e-pass books was taken without issuing notice to the
petitioner, despite the pendency of W.P.No. 1434 of 2OO4 and
the subsisting dispute concerning Sy.No.358, thereby violating
principles of natural justice.
ii) That the ORC granted in 2O08 in favour of respondent Nos.6
and 7 was obtained by suppressing material facts, particularly
the alleged prior sale in favour of the petitioner's husband in
1980. It is asserted that respondent No.6 and the husband of
respondent No.7 were signatories to the earlier transaction
and were fully aware of it.
iii) That the grant of ORC in 2OO8, during the pendency of
W.P.No.1434 of 2OO4, is hit ky the doctrine of lis penden s and
the authorities ought to have awaited the outcome of the
pending litigation.
i") That in W.P.No. 11907 of 202 I this Court had observed that
pattadar pass books cannot be issued in the absence of
mutation in revenue records; yet, under the guise of
compliance in contempt proceedings, the authorities
mechanically impiemented the ORC without proper
verihcdion.
v) That the pe[itioner's detailed representations to the authorities
were not considered before issuance of the irc lugned e-pass
books.
On behalf of respondent Nos.6 and 7
27.
Learned counsel for respondent Nos.6 anc 7 (Bommaraju
Sattaiah and Bommaraju Sugunamma), has submitt,: I as under:
i) That respondent Nos.6 and 7 possess indepenJ rnt title on the
basis of ORC granted on 24.12.2008, which hz s neither been
challenged in appropriate proceedings nor se, aside and has
attained irnality.
ii) That the issuance of e-pattadar pass books \'..r in compliance
with the directions issued by this Court in \v P.No.119O7 of
2O2 | and subsequent administrative instructio .s. The present
writ petition amounts to a collateral ir tack on the
implementation of a judicial order.
ii|
That the petitioner, whose ORC was set asidr: in 2001, lacks
locus standi to object to implementation c I a valid ORC
granted to third parties.
iv)
That respondent Nos.6 and 7 are not parties Lc V.P.No.1434 of
2OO4 and the dispute therein pertains to a distinct set of
claims among different Parties.
v) That allegations of fraud are baseless and that thc vendors
had conveyed only a portion of their holding earlier, retaining
the remaining extent which devolved upon their lcgal heirs,
culminating in the gralt of ORC in 2OOg.
On behalf of the official respondents
2a.
The learned Assistant Government pleader for Revenue
submitted that the authorities have acred strictry in accordance with
the directions issued by this Court in W.p.No. ll9O7 of 2O2l and,
subsequent instructions from the competent authority. It is
contended that once the technical facility for implementation of
ORCs was enabled in the Dharani portal, the District Collector and
Tahsildar merely implemented a subsisting and valid ORC, without
adjudicating inter se disputes between private parties.
29-
Having taken note o[ the respective pleadings and rival
submissions urged on behalf of the parties and the material on
record, the following points arise for determination.
Consideration by this Court
3().
In the present case the foundation of the petitioner,s claim
in both writ petitions is with regard to ORC granted in her favour in
1998, which.:^tds set aside by the Joint Collector by order dated
t7
-----
16.07.2OOl. The challenge to that appellate order for ns the subject
matter of W.P.No. 1434 of 2004. The subsequer.I
issuance of
e-pattadar pass books in favour of respondent IVr s.6 and 7 in
implementation ol the 2008 ORC rn Lhe year 20'22 impugned in
W.P.No.23738 of 2022, is a consequential developnr :nt during the
pendency of the earlier writ petition. Therefore, the ; rstainability of
the second n,rit petition i.e., W.P.No.23738 of 2022 is intrinsically
dependent upon the outcome of the first. Theref: 'c, this Court
proceeds to examine, in the hrst instance, tht
lcgality and
sustainability of the order dated 16.07.2001 passr:r by the Joint
Collector.
A. Maintainability of VI.P.No.1434 of 2OO4
31.
The principal controversy in W.P.No.1434 ('1 '2OO4 revolves
around thc followrng:
i) the identity of the predecessor-in-interest
ii) the nature of acquisition as to whether he property is
,
joint family Inam land or self-acquired prc ferty;
iii) the factum of possession on the notified late under the
Act; and
iv) the validity and evidentiary worth of ur -egistered sale
deeds and gift deed relied upon by the pet Lioners.
32.
The aforesaid issues are quintessentially disp rted questions
of fact requiqing detailed appreciation of oral an<
documentary
ffi
at-
\
evidence. Determination of lineage, examination of revenue entries
spanning several decades, proof of execution and consideration of
unregistered documents, and adjudication of rival claims of
inheritance are matters that ordinarily fall within the province of a
competent civil Court.
33.
It is pertinent to note that the scope ofjudicial review under
Article 226 of the Constitution is limited to examining the decision_
making process and not to re-appreciating evidence or substituting
hndings offact recorded by a statutory appellate authority. The Joint
Collector, while exercising appellate jurisdiction under Section 24 of
the Act, has undertaken an examination of contemporaneous
revenue records and recorded findings based thereon. This Court, in
exercise of writ jurisdiction, cannot convert itself into a court of hrst
appeal on facts.
34.
Further, in regard to the nature of controversies raised and
the availability of an efhcacious alternative remedy by way of a civil
suit for declaration of title and consequential reliefs, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the writ petition is not an appropriate
forum for adjudication of such intricate factual disputes.
GG
t9
B. Leealitv of the Order
35.
d bv the Joint Colle : :or
On perusal of the order dated 16.O7 .2OO\, t is relevant to
note that thc Joint Collector has adverted to cer ihed copics o[
pahanies for multiple years, including those
;receding and
succeeding the notified date under the Act, zLr d recorded a
categorical finding that the names of B. Sattaiah, B Iadaiah and B.
Shankaraiah q,ere reflected as joint possessors.
36.
The appellate authority further noted earlier 'ntries showing
Late Rama Swamy as Inamdar and concluded that, rr ron his demise,
his sons continued in joint possession, thereby er -itling them to
occupancy rights in equal shares. The reasoning is founded upon
contemporaneous revenue entries which, though nr t conclusive of
title, carry significant evidentiary value in matters of I ossession.
37.
It is to be noted that the contention regarc ing absence of
notice is not borne out from the record. The ;r rpugned order
indicates that thc parties were heard and material ,,as considered
belore arriving at the conclusion. No procedural irregularity or
violation of principles of natural justice of such r.t rgnitude as to
vitiate the order is demonstrated. Further the plea o. iimitation and
adverse possession, raised in the context of Inam la,t I vested in the
State, does not advance the petitioner's case in ur t proceedings,
particularly when the dispute essentially concerns inter se claims of
co sharers. Therefore, this court finds no jurisdictional error, pa[ent
itlegality, or perversitSr in the order of the Joint Collector'
C. Cond uct of the Detitioners
38.
It is to be noted that the inconsistent stands taken by the
petitioners with regard to the identity of the predecessor-in-interest
cannot be overlooked. The pleadings disclose vacillation between the
names 'Rama Swamy' and 'Samaiah,' thereby iniroducing avoidable
ambiguity into the Proceedings.
39.
In the present case, the writ jurisdiction being discretionary
and equitable in nature, a litigant approaching the Court is expected
to disclose facts candidly and maintain consistency in pleadings.
While this Court refrains from expressing any conclusive opinion on
I
i
collateral criminal proceedings, the existence of such proceedings
i
further underscores the disputed factual matrix' rendering writ
I
adj udication inaPProPriate'
I
i
D. Locus Standi in W.P.No.23738 o f 2022
&
i
I
4().
It is to be noted that with the dismissal of W'P'No' 1434 of
I
2OO4, the appellate order dated 16.07 '2OOl stands aihrmed' The
I
I
petitioner's cJg im based on the 1998 ORC thus stands negated'
I
/
2l
4L.
The rights asserted by respondent Nos.6 anc 7 stem from a
distinct ORC granted in 2OO8, which has no
becn directly
challenged in appropriate proceedings. The impt ned action in
W.P.No.2373B ol 2022 is confined to issuance o1-t pattadar pass
books pursuant to implementation of that ORo
Ftrrther, the
absence of a subsisting legal right in the petitioner c zer the subject
land, the petitioner cannot maintain a challenge to rrplementation
of an independent statutory grant made in favour c ' third perrties.
Loans standi in u'rit proceedings is founded upon exrs -r:nce of er legal
right and its infringeme nt. Thus, such right is n() demonstrably
established in thc instant case.
E. Challen
to
im lementation of
dic I t
directions,
allegations of fraud and plea of lis pendens
42.
[t is relcvant to note that the issuance ol r ltattadar pass
books in favour of rcspondent Nos.6 and 7 was effe'r t :d pursuant to
directions issued b-v this Court in earlier procr:r 6linq5 and in
compliance with conscquential administrative in s ructions. The
impugned acLion
IS
thus mere$ consequentir J to, and in
implementation of, a subsisting ORC granted ir 2008. In the
absence of a direct challenge to the foundational ORC itself, a
collateral attack upon its implementation cannot br :ountenanced,
\
as it would amount to reopening issues that have either attained
hnality or were not questioned within a reasonable time.
43.
The allcgations of fraud in securing the ORC of 20Og raise
disputed questions of fact necessitating detailed examination of
evidence, which cannot be undertaken in summary proceedings
under Article 226 of the Constitution. If the petitioner is so advised,
it remains open to her to seek appropriate relief before a competent
civil forum.
44.
lnsofar as the plea of li.s pendens is concerned, the grant of
an ORC is a statutory recognition of rights and not a transfer inter
uiuos by a party to pending litigation. Moreover, in view of the
dismissal of W.P.No. 1434 of 2OO4, tt e very foundation for invoking
the doctrine does not survive in these proceedings.
Conclusion
45.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, this Court finds that
the disputes raised in W.P.No. 1434 of 2OO4 involve seriously
contested questions of title, succession and possession, which are
not amenabie to adjudication under Arttcle 226 and must be
pursued before a competent civil Court. The order dated 16.O7.2O01
passed by the Joint Collector is a reasoned and lawful exercise of
appellate jurisdiction based on revenue records ar I discloses no
jurisdiclional error, perversity or violation of natural j rstice.
46.
Consequently, in W.P.No.23738 of 2022, thc retitioner lacks
any subsisting legal right to maintain the challengt: The impugned
action is merely consequential to prior judicial lirections and
implementation of a subsisting ORC which has r < t been directly
assailed. The pleas of fraud and lis pendens raise c isputed factual
issues beyond the scope of writ jurisdiction. With -re dismissal of
W.P.No.1434 of 2OO4, the very foundation of the 1x litioner's claim
stands extinguished, and no legal impediment t rrvives to the
implementation of rights in lavour of respondent No:;. i and 7.
47 .
Accordingly, W. P. No. 1434 of 20O4 and 1[ .P.No.23738 of
2022 are hereby dismissed. The order dated 16.07. tOO 1 passed by
the Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District, in Ir m Appeal File
r
No.F1/8571/98, as well as the proceedings of the
lnd respondent-
District Collector in Letter No.Dll622/2022 dated t8.O4.2022 and
the consequential issuance of e-pattadar pass bo: <s in favour of
respondent Nos.6 and 7, are affirmed. The revenue uthorities shall
r
maintain the revcnue records in accordance wit:t the respective
ORCs and in accordance with la'.v.
I
\qii;t,,,.
\.
48.
The interim order dated 2O.O5.2O22 granted in
W.P.No.23738 of 2022 shall stand vacated.
49.
F
urther, it is made clear that this judgment shall not
preclude any party lrom working out their remedies before a
competent civil Court, if so advised. A1l questions relating to title,
possession and validity of documents are left open to be adjudicated
in such proceedings, uninfluenced by any observations made herein
except to the extent necessary for disposal of these writ petitions.
As a sequel, misccllaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed. No order as to cos[s.
DY
SD/.A. SRINIVASAR
GISTR
ISTA
//TRUE COPY//
To,
SECTION OFFICER
'1 one CC to SRI A.GIRIDHAR RAO, Advocate [OPU
2 Two CCs to GP FOR REVENUE. High Court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderabad [OUT]
3 One CC to SRI N RAVI PRASAD, Advocate lOPUCl
4 One CC to SRI N NAVEEN KUMAR, Advocate lOPUCl
5 fwo CD CoPies
BSK
BS
-L
-----
!t
HIGH COURT
DATED:2010212026
iI THE s
COMMON ORDER
WP.No.1434 of 2004
& WP.No.23738 of 2022
(J
!
17 ilAn
K
t
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITIONS
WITHOUT COSTS
lA
TC
20?6
*
=
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review