The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. The power available for the Cantonment Board under Section 335 for cancellation / suspension of license etc., normally would be available immediately after grant of permission or after a reasonable period, but not at this distance of 30 years after grant of permission. It is the settled law, the power available with the authority should be exercised in a reasonable time. Therefore, this Court is conscious of the settled legal position. In that view of the matter, though a prayer is made to direct the 1st respondent to hold an enquiry on the ground of fraud and misrepresentation, this Court is not inclined to grant the said relief in view of the position explained above. That apart, when the enquiry on the same issue is pending before the learned Magistrate in CC No. 995 of 2022 on the file of the XI Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad, giving a direction to hold an enquiry would be amounting to allowing a parallel enquiry which is not permitted in law. Therefore, this Court does not find any merit in the Writ Petition and accordingly, the same is liable to be dismissed.
12. The Writ Petition is dismissed. However, it is open to petitioner to take recourse to the action, which may be permissible in law. No costs.
13. Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if any shall stand closed. -------- ----------------------------NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA, J 03nd September 2026 ksld
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 31719 OF 2022
03.09.2026
Between:
Smt. Akkineni Dharani
….. Petitioner
And
Secunderabad Cantonment Board & others
….. Respondents
O R D E R:
The writ petition is filed to cancel the building
permission dated 27.05.1996. The writ petition is filed with the
averments that, aggrieved by the inaction of the 1st respondent
in cancelling the building permission vide board resolution No.
2 (1-35), dated: 27.05.1996 and the property tax identification
number in favour of respondents No. 2 and 3 with respect to
Plot No. 4 and 5 admeasuring 907 sq. yards in Sy. No. 157/8 of
Gunrock Enclave Co-Operative Housing Society at Thokatta
Village, Secunderabad Cantonment, Hyderabad District, as
arbitrary and illegal.
2.
Respondents
It is the specific averment of the petitioner that
2 and 3 without having any right, title and
interest in plot Nos. 4 and 5, fraudulently obtained building
permission for plots No. 1 to 5 by using forged signatures and
therefore, prayer is sought to direct Respondent No. 1 to cancel
the building permission in respect of Plot Nos. 4 and 5 and
sought for a new building permission in favour of petitioner as
per procedure prescribed in plots No. 4 and 5. It is the case of
the petitioner that plot No. 4 admeasuring 462 sq. yards was
acquired by her from her father A. Naga Murali Krishna through
a registered release deed, dated 24.12.2020, which he acquired
after the death of his wife Smt. Usha Murthy. It is also her case
that she acquired property right over plot No. 5 admeasuring
445 sq. yards from grandmother Smt. N. Savitri through a
registered settlement deed, dated 24.12.2020 and that both
plots are adjacent to each other in Survey No. 157/8 at
Gunrock Co-Operative Housing Society.
2.1.
It is the case of petitioner that late Smt. Usha
Murthy purchased plot No. 4 through sale deed dated
15.06.1982 and her grandmother Smt. N. Savitri purchased plot
No. 5 on 19.05.1982 and they were in possession and
enjoyment and that after petitioner acquired the property which
she is in possession and enjoyment and that plots bearing No. 1
to 3 belong to the 2nd respondent and his parents and that
Respondents 2 and 3 are running their offices in a building
constructed in Plot No. 1 to 3 and they are using plot No. 4 and
5 to store the material during construction of their office and
later on, started using the same as parking and as they are
closely related they never objected the use and enjoyment of the
plots for parking and that after she acquired the property rights,
she enquired with respondent No. 1 for mutation of property in
her name and to her surprise, she came to know that the 1st
respondent officials granted building permission to plot No. 1 to
5 in favour of Respondents 2 and 3 and a common PTI number
was allotted and Respondents 2 and 3 along with their family
members took building permission from Respondent No. 1 and
constructed the building over plots No. 1 to 3 only, but
permission was obtained for plots No. 4 and 5 also and that
building permission was obtained with the forged signatures
with the predecessors in title and that fraudulent game was
played by providing residential addresses of 1 and 3 for all
communications and that entire fraud was carried out when her
mother was sick; therefore, she lodged a complaint with police
Kharkana on 09.07.2021 and the same was registered on FIR
No. 113 of 2021 for the offences under Section 420, 406, 46 and
471 IPC and the police seized the concerned documents from
the 1st respondent and sent to forensic lab for examination and
the police have received a report from handwriting expert stating
that signatures of grandmother and mother of petitioner were
forged and the police filed charge sheet and the same is
numbered as CC No. 995 of 2022 and the same is pending and
several applications were made to the 1st respondent between
22.02.2022 and 15.05.2022 citing forgery issue and requested
to cancel the building permission as well as PTI number
pertaining to her plots No. 4 and 5; despite several requests, the
1st respondent grossly failed to take any action on her
representation and that she also paid fees for grant of new
building permission on plots No. 4 and 5 and that her building
permission was returned with the reasons that there is crime
registered with police authorities and that respondents No. 2
and 3 without right, title over the plots obtained building
permission by committing forgery of the signatures of her
predecessors in title and that building permission was granted
without verifying the documents and title deeds and that
building permission granted on plot No. 4 and 5 is null and void
and the same is liable to be cancelled. Therefore, alleged action
of the 1st respondent is not cancelling the building permission in
favour of Respondents 2 and 3 and returning her application for
building permission as illegal and arbitrary.
3.
The 1st respondent filed detailed counter. In Para
No. 4, they stated that the 1st respondent received the
Application for building plan on plots No. 1 to 5 of Gunrock
Enclave and as per the plan submitted the plots belong to Sri N.
Ranga Rao, Smt. N. Saraswathi, Sri N. V. Naidu, Smt. Usha
Murthy and Smt. N. Savitri and the total extent is 2321 Sq.
yards and the plan was submitted by the respective owners by
affixing their signature on building plan and plan was
submitted for construction of ground, first and second floors;
after scrutiny and verification of the site, the 1st respondent
accorded permission for ground, first and second floors on
27.05.1996 and the same was released to the applicants; in
Para No. 5, they stated that construction of building was
completed and when an Application was submitted for mutation
for payment of property tax, the same was mutated in their
names. It is the specific stand of respondents, sanction of
building permission is a municipal sanction accorded by the 1st
respondent and the dispute pertaining to title among the plot
owners, the appropriate forum to decide the dispute would be a
competent civil court having jurisdiction. It is also their specific
stand in Para No. 6 that permission was granted 24 years back
and at this distance of time, on the ground of forgery of
signatures, seeking cancellation of building permission by way
of representation cannot be acted upon and that too, when the
complaint of petitioner for the offence of forgery etc., is pending
consideration in CC No. 995 of 2022; when the same issue is
pending before the learned Magistrate, the same exercise cannot
be done by the 1st respondent and at any rate, the 1st
respondent will abide by the order passed by the learned
Magistrate. It is also stated that the Application submitted for
sanction plan was returned by the 1st respondent on 31.05.2022
stating that criminal case is pending and the subject property
documents are in the custody of police. It is also pointed out
that there is a recital in the documents relied by petitioner
stating that settler/releaser shall undertake to defend the title
of the settle/release in case any defect is found or any rival
claim is made in respect of schedule property. In view of the
recital, petitioner has to initiate the legal proceedings to clear
the cloud over the title and also stated that the predecessors-intitle of petitioner never objected grant of permission during their
lifetime.
4.
The unofficial respondents filed their respective
counters. A perusal of their counters would disclose that late
Smt. Usha Murthy and Late Smt. N. Savitri have signed for
grant of permission and that by the date of so-called settlement
deed and release deed, they have no right to transfer.
It is
stated that Smt. Usha Murthy and Smt. Savithri received entire
sale consideration through cheques dated 08.05.1990 and
21.01.1991 and also through cheque dated 18.01.1991. A
perusal of the lengthy counter it is explained that late Smt.
Usha Murthy is the brother's daughter of the 2nd respondent
and Smt. Savithri is the brother's wife of the 2nd respondent and
wife's sister of the 2nd respondent. Therefore, all of them are
closely related and that they signed the Application for grant of
building permission. It is further stated, they have purposefully
filed a criminal case in view of the family disputes which arose
in 2012-13 and that they are trying to convert the family
litigation into criminal one.
5.
For the counters filed by the 1st respondent
rejoinder is filed and upon the death of the 2nd respondent,
Respondents No. 4 and 5 came on record. Respondents no. 4
and 5 filed their respective counters but on similar lines.
6.
Heard Sri Rajasripathi Rao, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Sri Srinivasa Rao Pachwa, learned counsel for
petitioner, Sri K.R. Koteswara Rao, learned Standing Counsel
for Respondent No.1, Sri B. Raveendra Babu, learned counsel
for Respondent No.3, Sri K.V. Bhanu Prasad, learned Senior
Counsel assisted by Sri Rohit Reddy Samula, learned counsel
for Respondent No.4 and Sri C. Ramachandra Raju, learned
counsel for Respondent No.5.
7.
From a perusal of the pleadings, the Point for
consideration is Whether the building permission granted by the
1st respondent through board resolution No. 2 (1-35), dated
27.05.1996 in favour of Respondents 2 and 3 as well as PTI No.
PTO3H38019087 in respect of plot Nos. 4 and 5 for an extent of
907 square yards in Survey No. 157/8 of Gunrock Co-Operative
Housing Society can be cancelled on the ground of fraud and
forgery?
8.
Surprisingly, there is no whisper or mention in the
prayer stating that they made a representation on such and
such date for cancellation of building permission and therefore
the inaction on the part of the 1st respondent is illegal and bad.
Straight away, petitioner questioned the inaction in cancelling
the building permission without mentioning the details of efforts
made by her for cancelling the building permission. The 4th
respondent specifically raised this issue in her counter and
drew the attention of this Court on that aspect. That apart, as if
fraud and forgery is already established, petitioner is straight
away asking for cancellation of building permission. Looking at
the prayer, this court is of the view that same does not disclose
a valid cause of action.
9.
Allegation
of
fraud
and
forgery:
The
main
contention of petitioner is signatures of predecessors-in-title of
petitioner
were
forged
for
obtaining
building
permission.
Building permission was granted 26 years prior to filing of Writ
Petition. Curiously, the predecessors-in-title of petitioner never
made any complaint nor chose to question the building
permission on the ground of fraud and forgery. It is the
petitioner who claims to have acquired title to the property on
24.12.2020 filed this Writ Petition on the ground of fraud and
forgery. In this case, the 4th respondent brought to the notice of
this Court an important averment made by petitioner in Para
No. 8 of the writ affidavit which reads as under:
“
I submit that on enquiry, I came to know that respondents
No. 2 and 3 along with their family members took building permission
from respondent No. 1 for construction of building vide board resolution
No. 2 (1-35), dated: 27.05.1996”.
Therefore, even from her own admission, Respondents No. 2 and
3 along with family members took building permission. Late
Smt. Usha Murthy is the daughter of the brother of the 2nd
respondent and Smt. Savitri Murthy is the wife's sister of the 2nd
respondent and also brother's wife. Definitely, all of them are
family members. In that view of the matter, this Court is unable
to countenance the allegation that building permission was
obtained by playing fraud and forgery. Further, the 4th
respondent also filed memo on 29.10.2025 along with a plaint
in O.S. No. 105 of 1999. The said suit was filed by the 2nd
respondent and Smt. N. Saraswathi and Smt. N. Savitri is the
one of the predecessors-in-title of petitioner. She along with two
others filed suit against the 1st respondent Cantonment Board.
Taking into consideration the admission in Para No. 8 of the
Writ Petition and also the plaint in O.S. No. 105 of 1999 on the
file of the III Additional Senior Civil Judge at Secunderabad, this
Court is of the prima facie view that the allegation of fraud and
forgery is not made out. Therefore, the decision relied upon by
petitioner in Ranbeer Bose v. Anita Das1 does not apply to the
facts of this case.
2024 (13) SSC 284
10.
During the course of arguments, learned Senior
Counsel appearing for petitioner vehemently emphasized on the
existence of 6' feet service lane in the sanctioned plan and tried
to convince this Court that there is violation, as there are
encroachments. There is no pleading to that affect in the writ
petition and the building permission was attacked on the
ground of fraud and forgery. Deviating from the stand in the
Writ Petition and taking a new stand during the arguments with
regard to 6' feet lane is not permissible. A new aspect which is
not pleaded cannot be entertained and building permission
cannot be cancelled on that ground that too, after 26 years.
11.
The power available for the Cantonment Board
under Section 335 for cancellation / suspension of license etc.,
normally
would
be
available
immediately
after
grant
of
permission or after a reasonable period, but not at this distance
of 30 years after grant of permission. It is the settled law, the
power available with the authority should be exercised in a
reasonable time. Therefore, this Court is conscious of the settled
legal position. In that view of the matter, though a prayer is
made to direct the 1st respondent to hold an enquiry on the
ground of fraud and misrepresentation, this Court is not
inclined to grant the said relief in view of the position explained
above. That apart, when the enquiry on the same issue is
pending before the learned Magistrate in CC No. 995 of 2022 on
the file of the XI Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate,
Hyderabad, giving a direction to hold an enquiry would be
amounting to allowing a parallel enquiry which is not permitted
in law. Therefore, this Court does not find any merit in the Writ
Petition and accordingly, the same is liable to be dismissed.
12.
The Writ Petition is dismissed. However, it is open
to petitioner to take recourse to the action, which may be
permissible in law. No costs.
13.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
-------- ----------------------------NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA, J
03nd September 2026
ksld
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review