Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C)(PIL) No.11/2022
Smt. Adwitiya Chakrabarti, Daughter of Lt. Dipankar Chakrabarti, Resident
of Matripalli Road, Badharghat, P.O. Siddhi Asharam, Agartala, West
Tripura, Pin – 799003.
-----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Environment, Forest
and Climate Change, Indira Paryavaran Bhawan Jorbagh Road, New Delhi,
Pin – 110003, India.
2. The Chief Wild Life Warden and Principal Chief Conservator of Forests
(Wildlife), having their office at Office of Principal Chief Conservator of
Forests, Department of Forests and Wildlife, Govt. of NCT of Delhi, ABlock, 2nd Floor, Vikas Bhawan, I.P. Estate, New Delhi, Pin – 110002.
3. Director General of the Department of Revenue Intelligence, having their
office at Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (Headquarter), Drum Shape
Building, I.P. Bhavan, I.P. Estate, New Delhi, Pin – 110002.
4. Chairman of the Custom and GST Board, having their office at North
Block, Central Secretariat, New Delhi, Pin – 110001.
-----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Manoj Kumar Biswas, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Biswanath Majumder, C.G.C.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Date of hearing
: 12th September, 2022.
Date of judgment
: 21st September, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Indrajit Mahanty, C.J.)
Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard all parties.
2.
The above PIL petition is filed by a law graduate in public interest
with prayers to seek issuance of show cause to the respondents as to
why a writ of or in the nature of Mandamus shall not be issued
declaring that possession of all exotic animals/ birds by persons (other
than those who have made voluntary disclosure with the time
contemplated in Advisory, dated 11.06.2020(Annexure -3), issued by
Respondent No. 1, is illegal and the person in possession of such
exotic animals/ birds be forthwith prosecuted for violation under the
Customs Act by Department of Revenue Intelligence and under the
Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972.
3.
Petitioner relies upon news articles (Annexure – 1 & 2) to demonstrate
that there is proliferation of trade in exotic wildlife species in the
State.
4.
Petitioner submits that Birds and Animals can be categorized under
following heads via a) Indigenous/ local or Indian animal species and
b) Exotic/ Foreign or non-Indian animal species. Petitioner further
submits that there is no provision/ prohibition under the Wild Life
(Protection) Act, 1972 qua the second category. Petitioner further
submits that Respondent No. 1 issued an Advisory dated 11.06.2020
for dealing with import of exotic live species in India and declaration
of stock within six months of the issuance of the Advisory.
5.
Petitioner in his written submissions further contends that –
“3. Significantly, if a person who has availed the
Advisory and made Voluntary disclosure is treated at par
with a person who has not made declaration during the time
period contemplated in the advisory; the legislative intent
behind issuing advisory i.e., to grant immunity to a person
making voluntary disclosure within stipulated time stands
defeated and the Advisory serves no purpose. By not carrying
out amendments in the two Acts granting immunity from
prosecution and forfeiture to a person who has not made
voluntary disclosure under the Advisory issued by Respondent
No. 1 and thereby treating him at par with a compliant citizen
would be violative of Article 14 of Constitution of India.
4. The protection to the person found with exotic
species as noticed in the judgments of in the matter of Anil
Naidu Versus UOI (Writ Petition No. 807 of 2019) vide order
dated 11.09.2019 and Allahabad High Court in the matter of
Dinesh Chandra Versus UOI (PIL civil 22903 of 2019) vide
order
dated
30.08.2019
against
coercive
steps
and
prosecution under The Wild Life Act, 1972 and The Customs
Act 1962 is prior to issuance of Advisory by Respondent No. 1
on 11.06.2020. Bombay High Court in the matter of Imran
Latif Versus DRI (Writ Petition No. 4779 of 2019) vide order
dated 27.09.2019 held such offence under Customs Act, 1962
as bailable. Exotic species Birds and animals are subjected to
torture while being caught and smuggled. This is offence of a
grave magnitude and person smuggling or possessing such
exotic species must be subjected to custodial interrogation to
uncover the entire chain of criminals involved in the heinous
crime. The offence of smuggling exotic species and possession
of such species (not immune by timely disclosure as pert the
Advisory) must be specifically made non bailable under the
Customs Act, 1962, and exotic species must be added in the
Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972.
5. It would thus be in the public interest, if this
Hon’ble Court would direct or at least recommend
appropriate amendment in The Wild Life(Protection) Act,
1972 by adding exotic species therein so that their domestic
trade, transportation, breeding, possession etc within India
can be made a punishable offence. Moreover, unless
undeclared exotic species are directed to be, or at least
recommended to be, included in Notifications issued under
Sections 11B, 123 and 135(1)(i)(c) of the customs Act, 1962,
the concerned persons found with undeclared exotic species
within India would continue to have protection of law as
recognized in the aforesaid judgments of Allahabad High
Court and Bombay High Court. Thus, to wipe out the
distinction between domestic / wild animals and the exotic
species and to take stern action against the persons who are
concerned with possession, transportation, dealing, breeding
etc of exotic species, the directions as sought would be in
public interest.
6. Only then persons in possession of such animals
would be accountable under the said two Acts. Thus, this
Hon’ble Court under the Writ Jurisdiction in public interest
shall forthwith direct the Respondents to bring out
appropriate legislative amendments to include exotic species
in Schedule II of the Wile Life (Protection) Act, 1972 and to
amend the Notifications issued under Sections 11B, 123 and
135(1)(i)(c) of the Customs Act, 1962 so that the owner of
exotic species who have not made disclosure during the
Advisory can be forthwith arrested and prosecuted under The
Wild Life Act, 1972 as well as The Customs Act 1962 and
exotic species can be confiscated by the Respondents.”
6.
We have examined the Advisory which is essentially concerning 4
issues:
a.
Developing an inventory of exotic live species in India
through Voluntary Disclosure Scheme to streamline
CITES compliance.
b.
Procedure for import of exotic live species.
c.
Registration/ Declaration of progenies of the imported
exotic live species,
d.
The processes under this Advisory shall be dealt online
through the Parivesh Portal.
7.
Significantly, the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in the case of Dinesh
Chandra versus UOI (PIL CIV 12032 of 2020) had considered pre and
post Advisory period and held as under:
“9. An earlier PIL Civil No. 22903 of 2019: Dinesh
Chandra Vs. Union of India and others, filed by the very same
petitioner against the same respondents was dismissed vide a
detailed judgment dated 30.08.2019. It is not in dispute that
the said judgment attained finality and binds the parties, as
the same has not been challenged by any of the parties. It was
inter alia observed that:“37. From the aforesaid, it is very clear that
exotic birds/ animals do not come under the purview
of Wild Life Protection Act, 1972. There is no
provision under the Wildlife (Protection)Act, 1972
to issue licence or permission for dealing in exotic
birds. There are no Rules and Regulations and
procedures for keeping, breeding, buying, selling
and exhibiting such animals (exotic animals) within
country which have been bred in India. No
documents are specified and no permission are
required as per Customs Act for keeping, breeding,
buying, selling and exhibiting such animals (exotic
animals) within country which have been bred in
India. Animals have been bred in captivity in India,
customs Act does not have role in it.
47. It is well settled that the Court must be
extremely careful to see that under the guise of
redressing public grievance it does not encroach
upon the sphere reserved by the Constitution to the
Executive and the Legislature. Thus, it cannot direct
the government to initiate legislation or interfere in
the matters of governmental policy, except in cases
of violation of fundamental rights.
48. From the aforesaid, we are of the view that
the Central Government has consciously kept the
exotic animals/ exotic birds out of the purview of
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 by not including
them in its Schedules, and has thus permitted their
domestic trading, possession and captive breeding
in India. Such legislative intent and decision of the
Government can neither be interfered with in writ
jurisdiction, nor can any direction be given to the
Government in this regard to amend Wildlife
(Protection) Act, 1972 or Customs Act, 1962. At the
point of Import/ Export, a Customs/ DRI Officer has
jurisdiction to detect and prevent International
Trade, i.e., import/ export of live animals and birds
into or out of India, if found in violation of the
provisions of Customs Act, 1962 read with the
‘CITES’ and Foreign Trade Policy. Thus, any live
animals and birds, while being smuggled through
the Indian Customs Frontiers, can be seized at the
point of Import/Export by DRI/ Customs and the
concerned persons can be subjected to penal and
confiscatory provisions in accordance with the
provisions of the Customs Act, 1962. There is no
restriction on domestic trade, keeping, captive,
breeding, buying, selling and exhibiting ‘exotic
animals/ exotic birds’ within India, either under the
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 or under the
Customs Act, 1962 or under the Foreign Trade
(Development & Regulation) Act, 1962 or CITES.
Any person in possession of ‘exotic animals/ exotic
birds’ within India, is not bound to comply with the
requirements of Section 11C to 11F of the Customs
Act, 1962 regarding intimation of place of storage,
precautions to be taken in acquiring, maintaining
accounts or sale, as they are not notified under
Section
11B.
Similarly,
mere
‘acquisition’,
‘purchase’, or ‘possession’ of the exotic animals or
exotic birds within India, shall not invite any penal
consequences under the Customs Act, 1962 or
Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972.”
49. For all the reasons mentioned above, the
present Public Interest Litigation petition is hereby
dismissed without costs.”
10.
The said judgment dated 30.08.2019 was much
before the issuance of the subject Voluntary Disclosure
Scheme, announced and published on 11.06.2020 by the
Central Government through the Ministry of Environment,
Forest and Climate Change. So far as any smuggling
activities if noticed at the point of Import/Export, a
Customs/DRI Officer would continue to have jurisdiction to
detect and prevent International Trade, i.e., import/ export of
live animals and birds into or out of India, if found in
violation of the provisions of Customs Act 1962 read with the
‘CITES’ and Foreign Trade Policy, and any live animals and
birds, while being smuggled through the Indian Customs
Frontiers, can be seized at the point of Import/ Export by
DRI/Customs and the concerned persons can be subjected to
penal and confiscatory provisions in accordance with the
provisions of the Customs Act, 1962.
11. There is no change in the legal position stated in
the said judgment dated 30.08.2019 even in respect of
domestic trading, possession, transportation and captive
breeding of exotic species within India, at least for a period of
six months from the date of introduction of the present
“voluntary disclosure scheme” as the Clause (b) of Part I of
this voluntary disclosure scheme also provides that – “the
declarer would not be required to produce any documentation
in relation to the exotic live species if the same has been
declared within six months of the date of issue of the
advisory.”
8.
SLP (C) 11659 of 2020 filed against the said judgment was dismissed
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide an Order dated 13.10.2020.
Thereafter, Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Swetab Kumar
versus Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change and
Others (Writ Petition (Civil) No. 540 of 2022) while dealing with
the challenge to legality and validity of the Advisory again approved
the said decision of Allahabad High Court and observed thus:
“3. We have gone through the judgments of the High
Courts referred to above upholding the Advisory impugned
herein and are in agreement with the same. It may be noted
that a Special Leave Petition, being SLP (C) No. 11659 of
2020, was filed against the abovementioned judgment of the
Allahabad High Court which came to be dismissed by this
Court vide order dated 13.10.2020.
4. The above judgment of the Allahabad High Court is
a complete answer to the present PIL filed by the petitioner.
Any interpretation to the contrary as suggested by the
petitioner would defeat the very object of the Advisory. Once
a declaration within the window of six months as provided
under the Advisory is made, the exotic live species, including
its progeny, the declarant or transferee(s) are fully exempt
from explaining the source of exotic live species. The exotic
live species which is declared or its progeny, are not liable to
confiscation or seizure by any Central Agency or State
Agency. Consequently, the declarant or the transferee(s) of
such declarant will be immune from prosecution under any
civil, fiscal and criminal statute by any Central or State
Agency. Any other interpretation would lead to absurdity.
5. However, any declaration made after the expiry of
the window under the Advisory shall carry no such exemption
and the declarer shall have to comply with all requisite
documentation under the extant laws and regulations.”
9.
The same Advisory has also been the subject matter of challenge
before various other High Courts. However, it has been upheld at all
junctures. Reference may be made to the judgment of the Delhi High
Court dated 23.10.2020 rendered in Khodiyar Animal Welfare
Trust & Anr. Vs. Ministry of Environment [Writ Petition (Civil)
No. 6372 of 2020]; judgment of the Rajasthan High Court dated
14.10.2020 in Vivek Swami Vs. Union of India [D.B. Writ Petition
No. 7491 of 2020]; judgment of the Meghalaya High Court dated
14.10.2020 in Miss. J.S. Wahlang Vs. Union of India [PIL No. 15 of
2021].
10.
Bombay High Court has come to a conclusion in no uncertain terms
in the case of Imran Latif Shirgawkar Versus DRI (Writ Petition
No. 4779 of 2019) that the offence concerning exotic live species
under Customs Act, 1962 would remain ‘bailable’ under Section
104(7) of the said Act, in absence of any notification under Section
135(1)(i)(c) of Customs Act, 1962 notifying exotic animals/ birds as
“prohibited goods” (as issued in case of Fake Indian Currency), and
bail would continue to be statutory as well as fundamental right.
11.
The Advisory is an executive direction to maintain inventory of exotic
species and regulate the import of such species. The exemption that is
provided in the Advisory is limited to dispensation with explanation
of source of exotic species. Consequence of non-declaration within
the time stipulated in the Advisory is that the owner of exotic species
is required to comply with all requisite documentation under the
extant laws and regulation.
12.
There is no change in the statutory provisions in this regard to the
period pre or post advisory. The judgment dated 11.09.2019 of
Bombay High Court in the matter of Anil Naidu Versus UOI (Writ
Petition No. 807 of 2019) as well as the judgment dated 30.08.2019
passed by the Allahabad High Court in the matter of Dinesh Chandra
Versus UOI (PIL Civil 22903 of 2019), which clarify the position in
regard to the inapplicability of the penal provisions of Wild Life Act,
1972 and the Customs Act 1962 in regard to exotic species continue to
apply as per extant laws and regulations despite advisory dated
11.06.2020.
13.
As per settled position of law in various judgments noticed above as
per the extant laws and regulations-
(i)
Domestic trade, possession, transportation and breeding
of undeclared exotic animals/ exotic birds within India
continues to be out of the purview of Wildlife
(Protection) Act, 1972.
(ii)
There is no reverse burden to prove licit importation into
India, because such undeclared exotic species are not
included in Notifications issued under Section 123 of the
Customs Act, 1962.
(iii)
The undeclared ‘exotic animals/ birds’ continue to be out
of purview of provisions of chapter IVA- Detection of
illegally imported goods and prevention of disposal
thereof, containing Sections 11A to 11G, as they are not
notified under Section 11B. Thus, the person
in
possession of undeclared ‘exotic animals/ Birds would
continue to be not bound to comply with requirements of
Section 11C to 11F of the Customs Act, 1962 regarding
intimation of place of storage, precautions to be taken in
acquiring, maintaining accounts or sale thereof.
(iv)
The offence concerning exotic live species under
Customs Act, 1962 continues to be ‘bailable’ under
Section 104(7) of the said Act, in absence of any
notification under Section 135(1)(i)(c) of Customs Act,
1962 notifying exotic animals/ birds as “prohibited
goods” (as issued in case of Fake Indian Currency), and
bail continues to be statutory as well as fundamental
right.
14.
Despite the above settled legal position continuing even for the
undeclared stock of exotic species, court can neither legislate, nor
direct Government to legislate in a particular manner. The Court
cannot direct the Central Government to forthwith make amendments
against legislative will to include all exotic species in the Wild Life
(Protection) Act, 1972 and also in the Notifications issued under
Section 11B, 123 and 135 of the Customs Act, 1962. Court can neither
direct seizure/ confiscation contrary to existing provisions, nor can
direct change in classification of such bailable offence to non-bailable
offence, to enable arrest and prosecution of all the persons concerned
with such undeclared stock of exotic animals / exotic birds.
15.
Large number of citizens across the country commonly own pets such
as dogs, cats, birds, rabbits etc which may also belong to exotic
species and might have been purchased or procured from those
involved in captive breeding. Such pets may number in millions and
also breed. We have considered the submissions of the petitioner
about suggested wiping out of the distinction between exotic species
and indigenous species by directing or at least recommending
amendments in the two Acts. We are of the view that we can neither
direct, nor expect the Government to take such drastic steps in haste,
without assessment of impact and without detailed study. Such
amendments in statutory provisions which may result in drastic penal
action against common man cannot be directed or even recommended
as prayed by the petitioner. The petitioner effectively wants that even
all such exotic pets in domestic possession will have to be forfeited
and housed by government and their owners shall be arrested,
imprisoned and prosecuted under wild life Act and compelled to
disclose the source under Customs Act, 1962. The step suggested by
the petitioner will have very wide and far reaching ramifications. We
cannot lose sight of the facts that most people possessing such exotic
species are animal lovers and over time such exotic species become a
part of the family like a child in the house. There are sufficient
safeguards available in law to prevent cruelty to animals which are
also applicable to exotic species. Directing the amendments in the tow
Acts as suggested or even to suggest the Respondents to legislate such
amendments, would lead to chaos and no public purpose will be
achieved. Even otherwise in light of the judgments discussed above
the Court cannot direct the Central Government and the Central Board
of Indirect Taxes to forthwith make amendments against legislative
will to include all exotic species in the Wild Life (Protection) Act,
1972 and also in the Notifications issued under Section 11B, 123 and
135 of the Customs Act, 1962. Court can neither direct seizure/
confiscation contrary to existing provisions, nor can direct change I
classification of such bailable offence to non-bailable offence, to
enable arrest and prosecution of all the persons concerned with such
undeclared stock of exotic animals / exotic birds.
16.
We are unable to agree with the submission of the petitioner that,
failure to arrest/prosecute such person who did/could not make
declaration within the time stipulated in advisory would frustrate the
purpose of the Advisory. Unless a person is caught smuggling exotic
species on the international borders, no presumption can be drawn that
domestic keeper have illegally imported the exotic species on the
ground that such person has not declared ownership of exotic species
within the stipulated time, or has acquired such species after the
stipulated time, for any arrest/prosecution/confiscation based on
presumption would be unreasonable and violation of rights guaranteed
under Article 14 and 21 of Constitution of India.
17.
This puts all the key issues raised by petitioner to rest in the negative.
With above observations the petition is dismissed. No costs.
(S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Munna S
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review