Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A(J) NO.14 OF 2023
Shri Lalit Kapali.
……Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura.
………Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. Sarkar, Sr. Advocate.
Ms. V. Poddar, Advocate.
Ms. S. Banik, Advocate.
Mr. D. Gope, Advocate.
Ms. N. Debbarma, Advocate.
Ms. M. Pal, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 22/04/2024
Whether fit for reporting
: YES/NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
T. AMARNATH GOUD(J)
This present appeal has been filed under section
374 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 against the
Judgment
and
Order
of
conviction
and
sentence
dated
27.01.2023 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge,
West Tripura District, Agartala, Fast Track Court, in connection
with Case No. Sessions Trial (T-1) 49 of 2014 convicting the
appellant to suffer rigorous imprisonment for Life with a fine of
Rs.10,000/- (Rupees Ten Thousand) only along with default
stipulation for the commission of the offence punishable under
Section 302 of Indian Penal Code, 1860.
2.
The brief fact of the case is that the deceased
Champa Debnath was married to accused Lalit Kapali about 6
years back from the date of filing the FIR dated 11.01.2014.
After 15/20 days of marriage, convict-appellant Sri Lalit Kapali
used to come into the house in a drunken condition and used to
torture her physically and mentally on the victim on demand of
money. As the victim refused to bring money from her parental
house, the accused-Sri Lalit Kapali and Smt. Kiran Kapali used to
assault her. At the time of filing of FIR, the said Champa
Debnath had a child, aged about 4 years. Since 10/12 days back
from the date of the FIR, the accused persons increased torture
on the victim on the demand of money. On 10.01.2013, in the
morning, the accused Sri Lalit Kapali left his house and at 10 am
returned to the house and assaulted the victim and dragged the
victim to the kitchen and poured kerosene oil on her person, and
set fire to the body of the victim. Hearing the hue and cry, local
people came and shifted the deceased to the GBP hospital and
the informant came to know about the incident from his
daughter, i.e. the victim in the GBP hospital. Stating the above-
mentioned fact, the informant filed an FIR before the OC of West
Agartala Women PS. The victim died subsequently.
3.
against
Based on the FIR, a P.S. case was registered
the
accused
persons.
After
completion
of
the
investigation and finding sufficient materials, charge-sheet was
filed and the accused was put on trial. After hearing both sides,
the following points were framed for determination:“i) Whether accused Sri Lalit Kapali committed murder of the deceased
Champa Kapali?
(ii) Whether accused Sri Lalit Kapali and Smt Kiran Kapali
committed cruelty and dowry death of decease Champa Kapali ?
4.
To prove the charges, the prosecution examined
15(fifteen) witnesses and one Court witness and also exhibited
some documents. On the other hand, the convict appellant did
not adduce any defence witnesses.
5.
After
examination
of
the
P.W.s,
the
convict
appellant was examined under Section 313 of the Criminal
Procedure Code, 1973 and after hearing both sides, the learned
Trial Court convicted the appellant as stated above.
6.
Being aggrieved by the said Order of Judgment and
Conviction dated 27.01.2023, the convict appellant has preferred
this instant appeal.
7.
Heard Ms. V. Poddar, learned counsel appearing for
the appellant as well as Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P., appearing for
the State-respondent.
8.
Mr. V. Poddar, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant submits that there is no motive behind the commission
of the crime as both the deceased and the accused-appellant
had a marriage borne out of love relation. The allegation of
demand for dowry has not been proved as no specific demand
for dowry has been specified by the parents of the deceased.
P.W.-3 in her deposition stated that when he found the victim
with a burned injury, the victim only requested him to give
information to her mother, but she did not seek any help or
divulge the name of the perpetrator, the instant reaction of the
victim put the shadow of doubt on the story of the prosecution
as there is no urgency or cry for help. The alleged place of
occurrence is visible to the witnesses but there is no eye witness
to the said incident. Further, the forensic evidence could not
determine whether the death of the victim was suicidal or
homicidal in nature. Further, there is lacuna in the investigation
process. According to the dying declaration, a stick has been
used to perpetrate the crime but the said stick has not been
produced as evidence. Learned counsel submits the date and
time of the dying declaration of the victim is not specified and
contradictory. Further, the accused and his parents in their
statement stated that they were trying to help and bring the
victim to the hospital after the incident. Learned counsel also
casted doubt on the evidence on P.W.-1, the mother of the
victim,
wherein
the
victim
divulged
the
incident
after
a
considerable period of time. Stating thus, learned counsel urged
this Court to allow this appeal and acquit the convict appellant
herein.
9.
On the other hand, Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P.,
submits that P.W.-1, mother of the deceased specifically
mentioned that the convict-appellant used to torture her
daughter for dowry and also stated the victim-deceased divulged
to her that the accused beat her with lathi and pour kerosene on
her. P.W.-2, the father of the deceased also confirmed the
demand for dowry and torture and beating of the victim by the
convict-appellant. Learned P.P., also relied upon the evidence on
P.W.-3 to prove that the convict-appellant used to consume
liquor. Further Doctor also certified that the victim-deceased at
the time of the dying declaration was fit to give the same. The
dying declaration of the victim was recorded by the Deputy
Magistrate and Collector and therein he stated that her husband
came home drunken every day and used to beat her. On the
date of the incident, he struck her with a stick and after she fell
down, he poured kerosene on her and ignited it with a match
stick, causing severe injuries on her body. P.W.-5 who is the
independent witness stated that the victim-deceased divulged to
him that her husband beat and poured kerosene on her and put
her body on fire in the house of her husband. P.W.-10, who was
posted in AGMC and GBP Hospital stated that the patient was
admitted with 95% burn injuries, and since the admission, till
the morning of 12.01.2014, the patient was conscious as it
appears from the entry of the bed head tickets. The said witness
also stated that the patient succumbed to her injuries on
22.01.2014 and the dying declaration of the victim was recorded
on 11.01.2014. P.W-8, the Deputy Collector and Magistrate who
recorded the dying declaration also stated the fact that the
victim stated that she was beaten by the convict-appellant and
then he poured kerosene on her and put her body on fire.
To support his argument on the point that the
Executive Magistrate who recorded the dying declaration is the
independent witness, learned P.P., relied upon Para-6 of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment reported in (1998) 9 SCC
titled as Ravi Chander and ors Vs. State of Tripura.
The same is produced here-in-under:“6. After giving our anxious consideration to the facts and
circumstances of the case and the evidences adduced and also after taking
into consideration the two recorded dying declarations, namely, the first
one recorded by the ASI and the second one recorded by the Executive
Magistrate and also after taking into consideration the oral dying
declaration said to have been made by the deceased to PW 4, Prem Chand,
it appears to us that the first dying declaration which was recorded by the
ASI cannot be accepted. The deposition of PW 4 Prem Chand appears to be
reliable and his deposition also gets support from the post-mortem report.
Prem Chand has deposed that his sister stated to him that previously in the
hospital under threat her signature was taken on a paper by the police and
she had not made any such statement. PW 4 also deposed that in the
previous evening the mother-in-law hit the deceased on the head with the
rolling pin. From the post-mortem report it transpires that a lacerated
injury was found in the parietal region. Such injury on the head fits in with
the case of hitting the deceased with a rolling pin (belna) as alleged by the
deceased. We have carefully looked into the dying declaration recorded by
the Executive Magistrate and it appears to us that there is no occasion to
hold that such dying declaration was not taken properly by the Executive
Magistrate. Correction made in the first leaf in respect of Question No. 7
and the answer given to such question is only in respect of describing
whether it was the question or the answer. The statements given by the
deceased have been recorded without any overwriting or without any
interpolation. Initials have been put by the Executive Magistrate at the
bottom of the first leaf and only a part of the signature has touched some
writing in respect of Question No. 8 for which no doubt can be entertained
about the correctness of recording. So far as the flow of writing is
concerned, it also appears that all the questions and answers have been
recorded in the same flow. We have also looked at the reverse side of the
page and considering the same it does not appear to us that there is any
occasion to doubt that such writing was subsequently made by the
Executive Magistrate. The Executive Magistrate has also deposed in the
case and he has specifically deposed that he recorded the dying declaration
in question and answer form. He has denied the suggestion in the crossexamination that there was any antedating or fabrication on his part in
recording the dying declaration. The Executive Magistrate is a disinterested
witness and is a responsible officer. There is no circumstance or any
material on record to suspect that he had any animus against the accused
or was in any way interested in fabricating the dying declaration. The dying
declaration recorded by him tallies substantially with the dying declaration
said to have been made orally to the brother Prem Chand PW 4. Simply
because the offence under Sections 498A and 304B IPC could not be
established beyond doubt by the prosecution for which the accused were
acquitted of the said charges, it cannot be held that the accused had no
motive for committing the said murder. Although the dying declaration
recorded by the Executive Magistrate was sent to the Investigating Officer
after about a fortnight, we do not think that for such delay, genuineness of
the said dying declaration recorded by the Executive Magistrate is to be
doubted. There is an entry in the despatch register by which the said
statement was sent to the DSP (H) Ludhiana by the Head Constable of the
police post. Mr Roy has contended that the doctor who countersigned the
first dying declaration recorded by the ASI has not been examined by the
prosecution. In our view, for not examining the doctor, the dying
declaration recorded by the Executive Magistrate and the dying declaration
orally made to Prem Chand, PW 4, need not be doubted. Moreover, it was
open to the accused to examine the doctor alleged to have countersigned
the dying declaration recorded by the ASI if the accused had intended to
rely on such dying declaration.
On the same point, learned P.P., also relied upon
para-10.1 of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reported in (2022) 4 SCC 741 titled as State of Uttar
Pradesh Vs. Veerpal and anr. The same is produced herein:“10.1. In Laxman after referring to and considering the earlier
decisions on the credibility of the dying declaration recorded by the
Magistrate, it was observed that the Magistrate being a disinterested
witness and a responsible officer and there being no circumstances or
material to suspect that the Magistrate had any animus against the
accused or was in any way interested for fabricating a dying declaration,
question of doubt on the declaration, recorded the Magistrate does not
arise.”
On point of circumstantial evidence and to support
the statement of P.W.-5, learned P.P. relied upon Paras-30 and
66 the Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court reported in (2019)
4 SCC 771 titled as Pattu Rajan Vs. State of Tamil Nadu.
The same is produced herein:“ 30. Before we undertake a consideration of the evidence
supporting such circumstances, we would like to note that the law relating
to circumstantial evidence is well settled. The Judge while deciding matters
resting on circumstantial evidence should always tread cautiously so as to
not allow conjectures or suspicion, however strong, to take the place of
proof. If the alleged circumstances are conclusively proved before the
Court by leading cogent and reliable evidence, the Court need not look any
further before affirming the guilt of the accused. Moreover, human agency
may be faulty in expressing the picturisation of the actual incident, but
circumstances cannot fail or be ignored. As aptly put in this oft quoted
phrase: “Men may lie, but circumstances do not”
66.
In our considered opinion, the overwhelming, consistent,
cogent and reliable testimonies of PWs 1 and 2, along with the
aforementioned corroborative evidence, conclusively prove the prosecution
case. We reiterate that PWs 1 and 2 were steadfast in their testimony
about the motive, the last seen circumstance, recovery of the dead body
based on the confession of Accused No.2, and about the identification of
the dead body. We do not find any embellishment or exaggeration in the
evidence of these witnesses. Moreover, the evidence of the other
prosecution witnesses (especially PWs 7, 26, 27, 29, 32 and 33) is
homogeneous, consistent and reliable, and corroborates the testimony of
PWs 1 and 2, which leads us to conclude that the chain of circumstances is
complete and points solely at the guilt of the accused. In our considered
opinion, the prosecution has proved the complicity of all the appellants in
murdering Santhakumar by strangulating him and thereafter throwing the
dead body at Tiger Chola. It is worth recalling that while it is necessary
that proof beyond reasonable doubt should be adduced in all criminal
cases, it is not necessary that such proof should be perfect, and someone
who is guilty cannot get away with impunity only because the truth may
develop some infirmity when projected through human processes. The
traditional dogmatic hyper technical approach has to be replaced by a
rational, realistic and genuine approach for administering justice in a
criminal trial. Justice cannot be made sterile by exaggerated adherence to
the rule of proof, inasmuch as the benefit of doubt must always be
reasonable and not fanciful. (See Inder Singh v. State (Delhi
Administration), (1978) 4 SCC 161; State of H.P. v. Lekh Raj & Anr.,
(2000) 1 SCC 247; Takhaji Hiraji v. Thakore Kubersing Chamansing & Ors.,
(2001) 6 SCC 145; Chaman & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand, (2016) 12 SCC
76)”
On the point of special knowledge, learned P.P., relied
upon Paras-21 and 22 the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court reported in (2014) 4 SCC 353 titled as Rajkumar Vs.
State of Madhya Pradesh. The same is produced herein
under:“21. Admittedly, the appellant did not take any defence
while making his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., rather boldly
alleged that the family of the deceased had roped him falsely at the
instance of the police. However, appellant could not reveal as for what
reasons the police was by any means inimical to him.
22. The accused has a duty to furnish an explanation in
his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. regarding any incriminating
material that has been produced against him. If the accused has been
given the freedom to remain silent during the investigation as well as
before the court, then the accused may choose to maintain silence or even
remain in complete denial when his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. is
being recorded. However, in such an event, the court would be entitled to
draw an inference, including such adverse inference against the accused as
may be permissible in accordance with law. (Vide: Ramnaresh & Ors. v.
State of Chhattisgarh, Munish Mubar v. State of Haryana, and Raj Kumar
Singh alias Raju @ Batya v. State of Rajasthan.
Stating thus, learned P.P., urged this Court to
dismiss the appeal and uphold the order of Judgement and
Conviction as passed by the Trial Court.
10.
Before coming to the conclusion of the case, let us
examine some important witnesses.
11.
PW.1 Smt. Mira Debnath, the mother of the
deceased, in her evidence, deposed that the deceased-Champa
Debnath was her daughter who died in the month of January,
2014 just after 6 years of her marriage with accused Sri Lalit
Kapali. She led a happy life at her matrimonial home for about
15 days and thereafter her husband started beating her for
bringing money from them and when they could not fulfill the
demand they used to make torture upon her for bringing money.
It was on a certain day in the morning in the month of January,
2014 accused Lalit Kapali started beating her daughter with a
lathi and when she fell on the ground she was set in fire after
pouring kerosene on her body. Thereafter, the accused fled away
through the window of the dwelling hut. Her house is located
after crossing two houses from the house of the accused
persons. PW.1 further deposed that after the incident she got
information about sustaining injury of her daughter from one
Santosh Paul and she rushed to the house of the accused
persons where she found her daughter lying with burn injury and
she took her to the AGMC and GBP hospital by an Auto rickshaw
when her daughter told the aforesaid incident to her at AGMC
and GBP hospital. On the following day, she submitted a written
complaint at the police station which was written by one Sanjib
Roy in the court premises as per her version.
During cross-examination, PW.1 stated that the
complaint petition was written as per her version. Further
nothing contrary was indicated in her cross-examination.
12.
PW.2, Sri Sefal Debnath deposed that after
the marriage, the convict-appellant used to create pressure upon
her daughter to bring money for him. The witness also stated
that the victim told him that her husband used to beat her when
she asked him to give her some money.
13.
PW.3, Sri Santosh Rudra Paul in his evidence
deposed that after the incident, the victim requested him to give
information to her mother and he then rushed to the parental
house of Champa Kapali and reported the same to the mother of
Champa and the mother of Champa namely Mira Debnath.
In cross-examination, PW.3 deposed that at their
area the day laborer used to work for the whole day, they
consumed alcohol after finishing the work. At the time of the
occurence, the accused Lalit Kapali was the driver of the truck
vehicle.
14.
PW.5, Sri Bikash Sarkar in his evidence deposed
that he know accused Lalit Kapali and his mother accused
Kiranbala Kapali. PW.5 further deposed that Champa Kapali, wife
of accused Lalit Kapali died about 2 years ago after sustaining
burn injury. After getting information about the incident he went
to the hospital to see her on the following day of sustaining burn
injury. In the hospital, she told him that her husband set her on
fire after beating her at her husband's house.
15.
PW. 8 Sri Takshiray Debbarma in his evidence
deposed that on 11.1.14 he was posted in the office of the SDM,
Sadar, West Tripura, Agartala in the post of Deputy Collector
and Magistrate and on that day he recorded the dying
declaration of victim Smt. Champa kapali in the AGMC and GBP
hospital, in ward FS-2. Before the recording of her statement,
the medical officer on duty, namely, Sutirtha Dasgupta gave her
fitness certificate for the recording of dying declaration of the
patient and in her statement she stated to him, "Her husband
every day used to come back at home under intoxication and
used to quarrel and on the day of occurrence in the morning at
about 10.30 my husband gave hit on my head with a lathi and
as a result he fell down on the ground and at that time she
poured kerosene on my body and set me on fire with match stick
causing burn injury on my whole body". After recording her
statement he obtained her thumb impression and also certified
that the statement of patient Smt. Champa Kapali wife of Sri
Lalit Kapali was given by her to him at AGMC and GBP hospital
and
recorded
by
him.
The
witness
identified
the
dying
declaration recorded by him along with the certificate of the
Doctor.
16.
PW.10 Dr. Diptendu Chaudhuri in his evidence
deposed that on 10.01.2014 he was posted at AGMC and GBP
Hospital, Agartala as a Medical Officer. On that day around 12.43
pm one patient namely Champa Kapali was admitted with burn
injury at their hospital, initially, she was attended by junior
doctors and he himself informed the fact to local PS. The carbon
of said information given by him to the O/C GB outpost Agartala
have dated initial with official seal is marked as Exhibit 8 as a
whole. The Patient was admitted with 95% burn injuries and
since admission till the morning of 12.01.2014 patient was
conscious as it appears from the entry in bed head tickets and
ultimately patient succumbed to her injuries on 22.01.2014. The
dying declaration of the victim was recorded on 11.01.2014.
17.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
18.
The charge against the convict appellant herein is
under Section 302 of IPC for the brutal murder of his victimwife. It is alleged that after subjecting his wife to a severe
beating with a stick, he poured kerosene on her and set her
body on fire, resulting in her death.
19.
The
evidence
presented
before
that
can
be
categorized into 4(four) category 1) Dying Declaration of the
victim--deceased,
2)
Witness
Testimonies,
3)
Magistrate
Testimony and 4) Medical Evidence.
20.
Let us now produce the dying declaration of the
victim deceased taken on 11.01.2014:“My husband would come home drunk every day
and subject me to physical assaults. On the day of the incident,
at around 10.30 AM, he struck me on the head with stick.
Consequently, I fell on the ground, and then he proceeded to
pour kerosene on my body and ignited it with a matchstick,
causing severe burns to my body.”
The victim, before her death, made the above
extracted dying declaration before the Magistrate i.e. P.W.-8,
which was duly recorded. In her statement, she accused her
husband, the convict-appellant herein, of beating her and setting
her person on fire.
21.
In the witness testimonies, P.W 1, the mother of the
deceased and P.W 5, who is an independent witness testified that
the victim confessed to them about the dowry demands and
torture inflicted by the convict-appellant.
22.
Further,
P.W
8,
the
Magistrate
in
terms
of
the
Judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court as cited by the learned P.P.
can be considered as an independent witness. He confirmed that
the deceased victim identified her husband, the convict-appellant,
as the one who beat her with a stick and set her on fire.
23.
In the medical evidence, P.W 10, a hospital staff
member, testified that the victim had suffered 95 percent burn
injuries and the patient gave her dying declaration on 11.01.2014
and since admission till the morning of 12.01.2014, the victimdeceased was conscious as evident from bed head ticket.
Further, the doctor confirmed that the victim was in a fit state to
give her dying declaration.
24.
After reviewing the evidence presented before the
court and after taking into consideration the Hon’ble Apex Court
Judgment as referred by the learned P.P., it is evident that the
convict-appellant herein is guilty of the brutal murder of his wife.
i.e., the deceased victim. The dying declaration, supported by
witness
testimonies
and
medical
evidence,
establishes
the
convict-appellant's culpability beyond a reasonable doubt.
25.
In view of the above, this Court finds no ground to
interfere with the impugned Judgment and Order of Conviction
and sentence dated 27.01.2023 and, accordingly, the same is
upheld and the present appeal stands dismissed.
26.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
B. PALIT, J
suhanjit
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT
SINGHA
RAJKUMAR SUHANJIT
SINGHA
Date: 2024.04.25
14:46:24 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review