Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 18
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Shri. Bishu Kumar Tripura
Son of Shri Malindra Tripura, resident of Lalmaibari, Padmalochan High
School, PS-Melagharh, District-Sepahijala, Tripura.
----- Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Home
Department, having his office at Secretariat Complex, PO Kunjaban, PS
New Capital Complex, Sub-Division-Agartala, District West Tripura.
2. The Secretary,
Government of Tripura, Home Department, having his office at
Secretariat Complex, PO Kunjaban, PS New Capital Complex, SubDivision-Agartala,
District
West
Tripura.
3. The Deputy Secretary,
Government of Tripura, Home Department, having his office at
Secretariat Complex, PO Kunjaban, PS New Capital Complex, SubDivision-Agartala, District West Tripura.
4. The Director General of Police,
Tripura, Police Headquarters, Fire Brigade Chowmohani, PS-West
Agartala, PO & Sub-Division-Agartala, District West Tripura.
5. The Advisory Board,
Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
Act, 1988, Tripura, represented by its Secretary.
6. The Union of India,
represented by the Secretary to the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government
of India, South Block, New Delhi-110001
----- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Sankar Lodh, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S.S. Dey, Advocate General.
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Asstt. SG.
Mr. Ratan Datta, P.P.
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P.P.
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
8th February, 2022.
Date of Pronouncement
:
16th March, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 2 of 18
B_E_F_O_R_E_
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[Per S.G. Chattopadhyay], J
The petitioner, hereinafter referred to as the detenu, has
been detained pursuant to order No.F.15(9)-PD/2021(P-II)/2330 dated
20.08.2021 (Annexure-1 to this petition) issued by the Home Secretary to
the Government of Tripura in exercise of powers conferred under sub
section (1) of section 3 of Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances, 1988 (for short „PITNDPS‟ Act).
[2]
The grounds of detention as disclosed in the impugned order
dated 20.08.2021 are as under:
[1]. From the records submitted by the Director General of Police,
Tripura, it has appeared that Shri Bishu Kumar Tripura S/O Shri
Malindra Tripura of Lalmaibari, Near Padmalochan High School,
PS-Melagarh, Sepahijala District was involved in the following
cases:
(i)
Melagarh PS case No. 2020MLG028 dated 19.06.2020 under
sections 148/149/353/325/427/307, IPC and section 3 of
Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act and sections
20(b)(ii)(C)/29, NDPS Act.
(ii)
Manu PS case No.2021MNU004 dated 30.01.2021 under
sections 20(C)/29(i) of NDPS Act and, it has appeared that he is
still operating through the help of his associates and supporters
in transportation of NDPS articles.
[2]. The records have also disclosed that he is a repeated offender
and is continuously doing illegal activities regarding
transportation of NDPS articles. This is very dangerous for the
society at large where several youths are heading towards drug
addiction, which further decreases the national productivity in
all walks of life. Despite arrest in different cases said Shri Bishu
Kumar Tripura S/O Shri Malindra Tripura of Lalmaibari, Near
Padmalochan High School, PS-Melagarh, Sepahijala District did
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 3 of 18
not mend his ways and is continuously spoiling the future
generation.
[3]. The person is still active in illicit trafficking of NDPS articles as
revealed from field information but could not be arrested redhanded again and issue of detention order under PITNDPS will
also help Police in initiating financial investigation laid down
under Chapter-V(A) of NDPS Act.
[4]. It is essential to keep Shri Bishu Kumar Tripura behind the bars
in the national interest since this drug addiction not only spoil
the individual drug addict but also spoils the career of youths.
Under the influence of drugs, youths are easily motivated
toward social crimes which may further lead to communal
violence, hatred among communities and even international
tensions, since Tripura is having Indo-Bangladesh border. This
drug addiction encourages youths to commit crimes like
snatching, theft of bike, burglary, dacoit etc. when they need
money to fulfill their urge for drug.
[5]. From the statement of witnesses and from the records, it has
transpired that Shri Bishu Kumar Tripura has accumulated huge
property at Bishramganj and Melagarh which appears to be
disproportionate to his known source of income.
[6]. The Director General of Police, Tripura has proposed to prevent
Shri Bishu Kumar Tripura S/O Shri Malindra Tripura of
Lalmaibari, Near Padmalochan High School, PS-Melagarh,
Sepahijala District from continuing his harmful and prejudicial
activities by engaging himself in illicit traffic of narcotic drugs
and psychotropic substances in the interest of society.
[3]
The detenu was made aware of the grounds of detention
and copies of the documents relied on by the detaining authority along with
the detention order was duly served on the detenu. He made a
representation dated 28.08.2021 [Annexure-9 to the writ petition] to the
detaining authority. The said representation was rejected by the State
Government and the rejection order dated 18.09.2021 was communicated
to the detenu by the Home Secretary to the Government of Tripura
[Annexure-10 to the writ petition]. Thereafter, the State Government vide.
No.15(9)-PD/2021(P-II)/2627 dated 14.09.2021 made a reference in
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 4 of 18
respect of the matter to the State Advisory Board in terms of section 9(b) of
the PITNDPS Act. The Advisory Board opined that there were sufficient
causes for the detention of the petitioner. Pursuant to report dated
06.11.2021 of the State Advisory Board, the State Government in exercise
of power conferred under section 9(f) read with section 11 of the PITNDPS
Act confirmed the detention order for a period of 1(one) year w.e.f. the
date of his detention by order No.F.15(9)-PD/2021(P-II)/3283 dated
11.11.2021 (Annexure-12 to the writ petition) issued by the Home
Secretary.
[4]
The detenu has structured his challenges to the detention
order mainly on the following grounds:
(i)
The orders whereunder the detenu was granted bail in
Melagarh PS case No.2020/MLG/028 and Manu PS case No.2021 MNU
004 prior to the issuance of the detention order were not placed before
the detaining authority.
(ii) Non placement of these vital documents before the detaining
authority and non consideration of the same by the detaining authority has
vitiated the detention order because those were necessary to arrive at a
subjective satisfaction as contemplated under sub section (1) of section 3 of
PITNDPS Act for issuing detention order.
[5]
In the counter affidavit filed on behalf of State respondents
1, 2, 3 and 4 by the Deputy Secretary, Home, Government of Tripura on
20.12.2021, it has been asserted that the detenu is a drug peddler against
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 5 of 18
whom several cases have been registered. It is stated that the investigating
agency has already laid charge sheet against him in Melagarh PS case
No.2020/MLG/028 and Manu PS case No.2021 MNU 004. In the third case
lodged as Bishalgarh PS case No.2021 BLG 059 under sections 20(b)(ii)(C)
and sections 25, 27A, 29 and 32, NDPS Act, he has been granted pre arrest
bail by the High Court on 20.08.2021 and the State Government has
decided to challenge the order in SLP before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court.
Further averment made on behalf of the State respondents is that
invocation action of the provisions of PITNDPS Act against the detenu was
felt necessary to deter him from repeating commission of offences under
the NDPS Act. It has also been asserted by the State respondents that there
is no merit in the petition because all procedural safeguards prescribed
under the law has been followed by the detaining authority by affording
earliest opportunity to the detenu for making an effective representation
against the detention order and the matter was also referred to the advisory
board within the timeframe prescribed under the law and pursuant to the
report of the State advisory board the detention order was confirmed by the
State Government.
[6]
A Separate counter affidavit was filed on behalf of Union of
India (respondent No.6) by B.S. Meena, Under Secretary to the Government
of India in the Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance contending that
the State Government forwarded the detention order to the Central
Government in terms of sub section (2) of section 3 of PITNDPS Act within
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 6 of 18
the time stipulated under said sub section (2). It was received by the
Ministry of Home Affairs of the Government of India on 26.08.2021 which,
in turn was forwarded to the Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance. It
was asserted in the counter affidavit filed by respondent No.6 that there
were no breach of safeguards provided to the detenu under Article 22 of
the Constitution.
[7]
Notice was also served on State Advisory Board (respondent
No.5) but no counter affidavit was filed on behalf of the said respondent.
[8]
We have heard Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned advocate for the
petitioner and Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General appearing for the
State along with Mr. R. Datta, learned P.P, Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl.
P.P and Ms. A. Chakraborty, advocate.
[9]
Mr. Lodh, counsel appearing for the petitioner has argued
that the detention order passed by the detaining authority is liable to be
quashed mainly because bail orders whereunder detenu was released on
bail in Melagarh PS case No.2020/MLG/028 and Manu PS case No.2021
MNU 004 were not placed before the detaining authority and non
consideration of the bail orders vitiated the subjective satisfaction of the
detaining authority. To buttress his arguments, Mr. Lodh, learned counsel
has relied on the decision of the Apex Court in Rushikesh Tanaji Bhoite
vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors. reported in (2012) 2 SCC 72 wherein
the Apex Court observed that in a case where the detenu was enjoying his
freedom under the bail order passed by the court, at the time of passing the
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 7 of 18
order of detention, such bail order must have to be placed before the
detaining authority to arrive at proper satisfaction about the need of
preventive detention. Counsel has relied on the following observation of the
Apex Court in paragraph 9 and 10 of the judgment:
“9. In a case where the detenu is released on bail and is enjoying
his freedom under the order of the court at the time of passing
the order of detention, then such order of bail, in our opinion,
must be placed before the detaining authority to enable him to
reach at the proper satisfaction.
10. In the present case, since the order of bail dated 15-8-2010
was neither placed before the detaining authority at the time of
passing the order of detention nor the detaining authority was
aware of the order of bail, in our view, the detention order is
rendered invalid. We cannot attempt to assess in what manner
and to what extent consideration of the order granting bail to the
detenu would have effected the satisfaction of the detaining
authority but suffice it to say that non-placing and nonconsideration of the material as vital as the bail order has vitiated
the subjective decision of the detaining authority.”
[10]
Counsel has further argued that preventive detention actually
tantamounts to punishment without trial. Therefore, detaining authority
must record its subjective satisfaction in the detention order as to why
issuance of the preventive order was necessary. Counsel submits that
recourse to preventive detention cannot be taken as a substitute to an
ordinary law and where recourse to criminal proceedings would be sufficient
to deal with the crime committed by the detenu, preventive detention is not
permissible. Counsel has derived support to his contention from the decision
of the Apex Court in the case of Rekha vs. State of Tamil Nadu through
Secretary to Government & Anr. reported in (2011) 5 SCC 244 and
the decision of the Apex Court in Munagala Yadamma vs. State of
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 8 of 18
Andhra Pradesh & Ors. reported in (2012) 2 SCC 386. In the case of
Rekha (Supra) the Apex Court observed as under:
“29. Prevention detention is, by nature, repugnant to democratic
ideas and an anathema to the rule of law. No such law exists in
the USA and in England (except during war time). Since, however,
Article 22(3)(b) of the Constitution of India permits preventive
detention, we cannot hold it illegal but we must confine the power
of preventive detention within very narrow limits, otherwise we
will be taking away the great right to liberty guaranteed by Article
21 of the Constitution of India which was won after long, arduous
and historic struggles. It follows, therefore, that if the ordinary
law of the land (the Penal Code and other penal statutes) can deal
with a situation, recourse to a preventive detention law will be
illegal.
30. Whenever an order under a preventive detention law is
challenged one of the questions the court must ask in deciding its
legality is: was the ordinary law of the land sufficient to deal with
the situation? If the answer is in the affirmative, the detention
order will be illegal. In the present case, the charge against the
detenu was of selling expired drugs after changing their labels.
Surely the relevant provisions in the Penal Code and the Drugs
and Cosmetics Act were sufficient to deal with this situation.
Hence, in our opinion, for this reason also the detention order in
question was illegal.”
[11]
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel contends that in the case of
Munagala Yadamma (Supra) the ratio decided in the case of Rekha
(Supra) was reiterated and it was held that where the offences complained
of, can be dealt with under the ordinary law of the land, recourse to the
provisions of preventive detention is contrary to the Constitutional
guarantees enshrined in Article 22, 19 and 21 of the Constitution and
sufficient grounds have to be made out by the detaining authorities to
invoke such provisions. Counsel has relied on the following observation of
the Apex Court in paragraph 7, 8 and 9 of the judgment:
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 9 of 18
“7. Having considered the submissions made on behalf of the
respective parties, we are unable to accept the submissions made
on behalf of the State in view of the fact that the decision in
Rekha case [(2011) 5 SCC 244], in our view, clearly covers the
facts of this case as well. The offences complained of against the
appellant are of a nature which can be dealt with under the
ordinary law of the land. Taking recourse to the provisions of
preventive detention is contrary to the constitutional guarantees
enshrined in Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution and sufficient
grounds have to be made out by the detaining authorities to
invoke such provisions.
8. In fact, recently, in Yumman Ongbi Lembi Leima v.State of
Manipur [(2012) 2 SCC 176] we had occasion to consider the same
issue and the three-Judge Bench had held that the personal liberty
of an individual is the most precious and prized right guaranteed
under the Constitution in Part III thereof. The State has been
granted the power to curb such rights under criminal laws, as also
under the laws of preventive detention, which, therefore, are
required to be exercised with due caution as well as upon a proper
appreciation of the facts as to whether such acts are in any way
prejudicial to the interest and the security of the State and its
citizens, or seek to disturb public law and order, warranting the
issuance of such an order.
9. No doubt, the offences alleged to have been committed by the
appellant are such as to attract punishment under the Andhra
Pradesh Prohibition Act, but that in our view has to be done under
the said laws and taking recourse to preventive detention laws
would not be warranted. Preventive detention involves detaining
of a person without trial in order to prevent him/her from
committing certain types of offences. But such detention cannot
be made a substitute for the ordinary law and absolve the
investigating authorities of their normal functions of investigating
crimes which the detenue may have committed. After all,
preventive detention in most cases is for a year only and cannot
be used as an instrument to keep a person in perpetual custody
without trial. Accordingly, while following the three-Judge Bench
decision in Rekha's case [(2011) 5 SCC 244] we allow the appeal
and set aside the order passed by the High Court dated 20-7-2011
and also quash the detention order dated 15-2-2011, issued by the
Collector and District Magistrate, Ranga Reddy District, Andhra
Pradesh.”
[Italics supplied by us]
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 10 of 18
[12]
Based on the above observations of the Apex Court, counsel
contended that in Melagarh PS case No.2020/MLG/028 as well as Manu PS
case No.2021 MNU 004 the investigating agency has already laid charge
sheets against the detenu and the designated courts can very well take care
of those charges under the ordinary law and therefore, a preventive
detention order is unwarranted. Under the premises aforesaid, counsel has
urged for setting aside the preventive detention order.
[13]
In order to repel the submissions made by the counsel of the
petitioner Mr. S.S. Dey, learned Advocate General has contended that the
plea raised by the detenu to challenge the order of his detention and the
points argued by the counsel of the petitioner in support of such plea are
wholly untenable. With regard to the plea raised by the counsel of the
petitioner about the the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority,
learned Advocate General has contended that the detention order clearly
demonstrates that the detaining authority came to the conclusion about the
dire need of the preventive detention of the petitioner after considering all
the relevant materials. It has been argued by learned Advocate General that
the adequacy of the material on the basis of which the detaining authority
arrived at its satisfaction cannot also be examined in the court of law. Even
the reasonableness of the satisfaction of the detaining authority cannot be
questioned. Counsel submits that all relevant facts and documents were
considered by the detaining authority to arrive at a subjective satisfaction
and copies of all those documents were supplied to the detenu. Counsel
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 11 of 18
further contends that the detenu was completely aware of the bail orders
passed by court in his favour in Melagarh PS case No.2020/MLG/028 and
Manu PS case No.2021 MNU 004 and therefore, non supply of the copies of
the said orders to him could in no way prejudice the detenu. Moreover, the
detaining authority has clearly indicated in the detention order that facts of
Melagarh PS case No.2020/MLG/028 and Manu PS case No.2021 MNU 004
were examined by the detaining authority for arriving at the subjective
satisfaction about the need of preventive detention of the detenu. As
contended by learned Advocate General, in this factual context, the bail
orders cannot be treated as vital documents and non consideration of such
documents has in no way vitiated the subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority. Learned Advocate General argues that the Apex Court has held
that application for bail and an order made thereon, are not always
mandatory and such requirement would depend upon facts of each case. To
nourish his contention, counsel has relied on the decision of the Apex Court
in the case of Sunila Jain vs. Union of India & Anr. reported in (2006)
3 SCC 321 wherein the Apex Court has held as under:
“19…………………….The detaining authority will have to satisfy
himself on the basis of the materials placed on record, as to
whether the order of preventive detention should be passed
against the detenu or not. The constitutional mandate can be said
to be violated, provided : (1) the impairment has been caused to
the subjective satisfaction to be arrived at by the detaining
authority; and (2) if relevant facts had not been considered or the
relevant or vital documents have not been placed before the
detaining authority.
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 12 of 18
20. In the instant case the order of detention has been taken note
of the fact that the detenu had already been released on bail in
the following terms:
"You were arrested on 30-1-2003 and released on bail by
the Hon‟ble Judge, Special Court of Economic Offences,
Bangalore, upon executing a personal bond for an amount
of Rs. 10,000/- and security in the form of cash for the like
sum."
21. It is also not in dispute that a copy of the order granting bail
and order of remand has been furnished to the detenu. In this
view of the matter we are of the opinion that non-furnishing of a
copy of the application of bail cannot be said to be a ground
which impaired the subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority or the same was a relevant fact which was required to
be taken into consideration by him and the application for bail was
required to be supplied to the detenu. It is now well settled that
all the documents placed before the detaining authority are not
required to be supplied; only relevant and vital documents are
required to be supplied.
22. As in the fact of this case, we are satisfied that the application
for bail was not a vital document ,copy whereof was required to
be supplied to the detenu, in our opinion, the order of detention is
not vitiated. A Division Bench of this Court in K. Varadharaj v.
State of T.N. [(2002) 6 SCC 735] upon noticing some of the
decisions relied upon by Mr. Mani inter alia held:
"6. From the above observations, it is clear that placing of
the application for bail and the order made thereon are not
always mandatory and such requirement would depend
upon the facts of each case."
[Italics supplied by us]
[14]
It is contended by learned Advocate General that apparently
all documents which were vital and necessary for formation of subjective
satisfaction of the detaining authority were placed before the detaining
authority before making the detention order on the basis of which the
detaining authority arrived at the conclusion that his preventive detention
was necessary in order to prevent him from repeating the commission of
such offence. In the given facts and circumstances of the case, the bail
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 13 of 18
orders cannot be treated as vital and material documents to arrive at a
subjective satisfaction inasmuch as such orders did not introduce any
variation in the circumstances which necessitated the preventive detention
of the detenu.
[15]
In this background, the most vital question which falls for
our consideration in this case is whether the bail orders might have
influenced the detaining authority in the formation of his subjective
satisfaction and whether non placement and non consideration of the same
would vitiate the order.
[16]
We have perused the entire record of the case and
considered the submissions of learned counsel representing the parties.
[17]
It is not in dispute that Melagarh PS case No.2020/MLG/028
was registered against the detenu on 19.06.2020 for commission of offence
punishable under sections 148,149,353,325,427 and 307 IPC and section 3
of Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984 as well as section
20(b)(ii)(C) and section 29, NDPS Act in which the detenu was released on
pre arrest bail by an order dated 04.07.2020 of the Special Judge,
Sepahijala Judicial District in BA No.43 of 2020 and the ground of bail
recorded by the learned Special Judge is that the materials which were
placed before the court did not support his involvement in the commission
of the alleged offence. It is not also in dispute that after investigation of the
case, police laid charge sheet against the detenu. It is also an admitted
position that the detenu also got involved in Manu PS case No.2021 MNU
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 14 of 18
004 which was registered on 30.01.2021 for commission of offence
punishable under sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 NDPS Act in which he was
arrested by police and after few days of remand he was released on bail by
the Special Judge of Dhalai Judicial District by his order dated 23.03.2021
and in the said case also a supplementary charge sheet dated 21.08.2021
was filed against the detenu. Subsequently, he got involved in another case
which was registered under the Bishalgarh police stations as BLG PS case
No.059 of 2021 for commission of offence punishable under sections
20(b)(ii)(C) and sections 25, 27A, 29 and 32, NDPS Act and he was granted
pre arrest bail by this court on 20.08.2021. On the same day, the impugned
order of detention was issued.
[18]
From the facts stated above, it would appear that the detenu
was granted bail in Melagarh PS case No.2020/MLG/028 and Manu PS case
No.2021 MNU 004 prior to the date on which the detention order came to
be issued. In the detention order (Annexure-1 to the writ petition) no
reference has been made to those bail orders. It is, therefore, assumed that
those bail orders were not placed before the detaining authority for his
consideration at the time of passing the detention order. Whether such non
placement and non consideration of the bail orders has affected the
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority is the issue on which
counsel of the parties have placed arguments and counter arguments.
[19]
Sub section (1) of section 3 of the PITNDPS Act postulates
that the Central Government or a State Government or any officer of the
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 15 of 18
Central Government not below the rank of Joint Secretary who has been
specially empowered by that Government and in case of State Government,
any officer not below the rank of Secretary of that Government specially
empowered by the State Government for this purpose, if satisfied, that with
a view to preventing the person from engaging in illicit traffic in NDPS, his
detention is necessary, may make an order directing detention of such
person. With regard to “satisfaction” contemplated under sub section (1) of
section 3 of the Act, the Apex Court in a catena of decisions has observed
that the satisfaction of the detaining authority to which section 3(1) refers is
his subjective satisfaction.
[20]
The argument which learned Advocate General has urged
before us is that in the given fact situation, the bail orders were not vital
documents for formation of the subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority and as such non consideration of those bail orders has in no way
caused any impairment to the subjective satisfaction of the detaining
authority because all relevant facts and vital documents were considered by
the detaining authority at the time of passing the detention order.
[21]
Since, in the detention order there is no reference to the bail
orders, the order ex facie says that those orders were not placed before the
detaining authority and as a result the detaining authority at the time of
passing the detention order was not aware of the fact that the detenu was
granted bail in those cases and no challenge against those orders were
raised by the State in the higher forum. Absence of awareness of such
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 16 of 18
essential facts on the part of the detaining authority, in our view, resulted in
non application of mind which obviously affected the subjective satisfaction
of the detaining authority. None can say with certainty that such bail orders,
if placed before the detaining authority and considered by such authority
would not have persuaded him to desist from passing such order of
detention. In the case of M. Ahamedkutty vs. Union of India & Anr.
reported in (1990) 2 SCC 1 the Apex Court held that non consideration of
the bail order amounted to non application of mind. We can profitably quote
the following observation made by the Apex Court in paragraph 25 of the
judgment which is as under:
“25. Non-consideration of the bail order would have, therefore, in
this case amounted to non-application of mind. In Union of India
v. Manoharlal Narang, (1987) 2 SCC 241, the Supreme Court‟s
interim order in pending appeal against High Court‟s quashing of a
previous order of detention against the same detenu was not
considered by the detaining authority while making the impugned
subsequent order against him. By the interim order Supreme Court
had permitted the detenu to be at large on condition of his
reporting to the police station daily. It was held that nonconsideration of the interim order which constituted a relevant and
important material was fatal to the subsequent detention order on
ground of non-application of mind. If the detaining authority
considered that order one could not state with definiteness which
way his subjective satisfaction would have reacted and it could
have persuaded the detaining authority to desist from passing the
order of detention. If in the instant case the bail order on
condition of the detenu‟s reporting to the customs authorities was
not considered the detention order itself would have been
affected. Therefore, it cannot be held that while passing the
detention order the bail order was not relied on by the detaining
authority. In S. Gurdip Singh v. Union of India (1981) 1 SCC 419,
following Ichhu Devi Choraria v. Union of India (1980) 4 SCC 531
and Shalini Soni v. Union of India (1980) 4 SCC 544 it was
reiterated that if the documents which formed the basis of the
order of detention were not served on the detenu along with the
grounds of detention, in the eye of law there would be no service
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 17 of 18
of the grounds of detention and that circumstances would vitiate
his detention and make it void ab initio.”
[Italics supplied by us]
[22]
In our considered view, the bail orders were the most
pertinent and proximate matters which cannot be discarded as irrelevant
and remote in the given fact situation of the case and as such those orders
should have been placed before the detaining authority for consideration
and arriving at a subjective satisfaction as contemplated under sub section
(1) of section 3 of PITNDPS Act to arrive at a conclusion with regard to the
necessity of the preventive detention of the detenu.
[23]
In the case of Rekha (Supra) which has been relied on by
the counsel of the petitioner, the detention order was held to be bad by the
Apex Court as the detaining authority was not made aware of the fact that a
bail application of the detenu was pending on the date when the detention
order was passed. In the case of Rushikesh Tanaji Bhoite (Supra)
which has been relied on by the counsel of the petitioner, the Apex Court
has clearly observed that non placing and non consideration of a material as
vital as the bail order vitiates the subjective decision of the detaining
authority.
[24]
Therefore, we are of the view that in the given facts and
circumstances of the case, the orders whereunder the detenu was granted
bail in the cases referred to in the detention order were relevant and vital
documents and non consideration of those documents by the detaining
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
Page - 18 of 18
authority has resulted in his non application of mind which has vitiated the
detention order passed by him.
[25]
For the foregoing reasons, the petition stands allowed and
the impugned detention order dated 20.08.2021 of Bishu Kumar Tripura is
set aside.
[26]
The detenu is to be set at liberty at once unless his detention
is required in any other case.
[27]
In terms of the above, the writ petition stands disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Rudradeep
WP(C)(HC) No. 04 of 2021
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review