Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRL.A.(J)29 of 2022
Shri Bipul Saha,
son of Shri Braja Gopal Saha
of Ompi, West Para, P.S. Ompi,
District : Gomati Tripura
---- Convict Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
---- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Sarkar, Sr. Adv.
Ms. V. Poddar, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P.P.
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment
& Order
:
12.12.2023
:
09.01.2024
:
NO
Whether fit for
reporting
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
(Biswajit Palit, J)
Heard Mr. S. Sarkar, Learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms.
V. Poddar, Learned Counsel appearing for the appellant as well as Mr.
S. Debnath, Learned Addl. P.P. appearing for the State.
2.
This is an appeal by the convict-appellant Shri Bipul Saha
against the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated
05.04.2022 delivered in Sessions Trial Case No.ST(GT/A)40 of 2016 by
the Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur.
3.
The prosecution against the convict-appellant was based on
the written complaint/ejahar filed by one Tapash Deb, Son of Late
Rakhal Deb of Village-Ompinagar, P.S. Ompi, Amarpur, Gomati,
Tripura stating inter alia that on 17.05.2016 in the night around 7.30
p.m. accused person Bipul Saha, Son of Late Brajendra Saha of Village
Ompi Paschim Para and another namely Rangbhanga Reang, Son of
Unknown accompanied by the younger brother of the informant
namely Tapan Deb, Son of Late Rakhal Deb purchased some meat
from Ompi Bazar and consumed the same in the residence of Bipul
Saha having dinner. Since, that night, the brother of the informant
Tapan Deb got missing and nobody could say his whereabouts. It was
further alleged by the informant that both the accused persons
kidnapped his brother with intent to defraud him some money which
the brother of the informant had withdrawn on that day. The informant
also suspected that some other persons namely Adhir Roy, Niresh
Kalai, Sudip Das, Subir Kalai and one Manna Kalai might be involved
with the alleged occurrence. The informant further alleged that due to
searching of his brother on the basis of missing diary, there was some
delay in lodging the FIR.
4.
Based on the said information, Ompi P.S. registered a case
being No.2016 OMP 005 under Section 364A/120B of IPC and the case
was endorsed to SI Surjya Kanta Jamatia of said P.S. by the O/C of
Ompi P.S. and after completion of investigation, the IO of the case laid
charge sheet under Section 302/201 of IPC against the convictappellant Bipul Saha and under Section 120B of IPC against another
accused namely Rangbhanga Reang to face trial, in the jurisdictional
Court. Since, the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC is
exclusively
triable
by
the
Court
of
Sessions,
so
the
relevant
prosecution papers were committed to the Court of Learned Sessions
Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur and later on, the case was
transferred to the Court of Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Gomati
District, Udaipur for completion of trial of the case. The Learned
Additional Sessions Judge after going through the relevant prosecution
papers and also after hearing both the sides framed charge under
Section 302/201/120B of IPC against the appellant Bipul Saha and
under Section 120B of IPC against another convict Rangbhanga Reang.
The present appellant denied the charge, pleaded not guilty and
claimed to be tried.
5.
In order to substantiate the charge, prosecution in this case
adduced in total twenty eight numbers of witnesses and relied upon
some documentary evidences marked as Exbt.P/1 to Exbt.29 including
the Inquest Report [Exbt.P-2/3], Postmortem Examination Report
[Exbt.P/17] and Report of Tripura State Forensic Science Laboratory,
TSFSL
[Exbt.P/18,
Exbt.P/20].
After
recording
the
prosecution
evidence, the appellant was examined under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. to
have his response on the incriminating materials those surfaced in the
evidence. The appellant renewed his claim of innocence and denied
those incriminating materials revealed against him. Thereafter, having
appreciated the evidence on record and after hearing elaborate
arguments of both sides, the trial Court returned the finding of
conviction as the prosecution had been successful in establishing the
charge against the present appellant, particularly, on the basis of
circumstantial evidence. Thus, the appellant has been convicted to
suffer RI for life with fine of Rs.5000/- under Section 302 of IPC id to
suffer SI for three months along with RI for life with fine of Rs.4000/under Section 120B of IPC id to suffer SI for three months and also to
suffer RI for three years with fine of Rs.2000/- under Section 20 of IPC
id to suffer SI for two months and all the sentences were ordered to be
run
concurrently.
The
appellant
has
challenged
the
finding
of
conviction as well as the order of sentence by means of this present
appeal.
6.
Mr. S. Sarkar, Learned Senior counsel assisted by Smt. V.
Poddar, Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has strenuously
argued that the prosecution in this case has failed to bring whom the
charge leveled against the convict-appellant. He has further submitted
that this case is purely based on circumstantial evidence but the
prosecution in this case has failed to prove the chain of circumstances
that lead to the conviction of the appellant. Learned Senior counsel
also drawn the attention of the Court that the Learned Trial Court did
not consider the statement of the witnesses of PW-1 and PW-7 and
came to a wrong finding of conviction. It was further asserted that
Learned Trial Court has also failed to consider the evidence of PW-3
and there were material discrepancies in the statement of witnesses
which Learned Trial Court has failed to consider. Apart from that, there
was delay of eight days in lodging the FIR, no satisfactory explanation
is given by the prosecution in the FIR.
7.
Learned Senior counsel again submitted that PW-28 in
course of his examination very specifically stated that on 23.05.2016
at about 13.45 hrs. accused Rangbhanga Reang was taken to
Lundingfa Old Jhum under Konaram Para of Ompi PS but on that day,
no dead body was recovered. More so, the bag containing the seized
articles, were also not seized. Before entering into the house of
appellant Bipul Saha he did not procure any search warrant and did
not cause search of his body by independent witnesses. Said witness
again
stated
that
although
the
dead
body
was
recovered
on
25.05.2016 at about 13.45 hrs. but Hand Sketch Map with index was
prepared on 26.05.2016 but the Learned Trial Court did not take into
consideration those points and ultimately convicted the appellant.
Thus, according to Learned Senior counsel, there is serious perversity
in the finding of conviction.
8.
Finally, Learned Senior counsel submitted that disclosure
statement has not been proved in view of the provision of Section 27
of Evidence Act and since the evidence of witnesses of the prosecution
suffers from various infirmities so Learned Senior counsel has
submitted that the prosecution has failed to prove the charge as
framed against the appellant and thus, he is entitled to acquittal in this
case.
9.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Debnath, Learned Additional P.P.
appearing on behalf of the prosecution submitted that this case is
totally based on circumstantial evidence as there is no direct eye
witness of the alleged occurrence of offence. But in this case,
prosecution has been able to prove the chain of circumstance to
substantiate the guilt of the appellant and furthermore, according to
Learned Additional P.P. the prosecution in this case has been able to
prove the disclosure statement of the accused persons under Section
27 of the Evidence Act. Thus, according to Learned Additional P.P., the
Learned trial Court has rightly after elaborate discussions of all the
legal aspects has delivered the judgment against the appellant and
urged this Court not to interfere with the judgment of conviction and
the consequential order of sentence.
10.
For appreciation of the submissions made by the Learned
Counsel for the parties, it would be apposite to note at the outset that
there is no dispute that the brother of the informant Tapan Deb @
Chanu was murdered on 17.05.2016. As the entire case is based on
circumstantial evidence, so let this Court take a short survey of the
evidence as laid by the prosecution.
11.
PW-1, Tapash Deb is the informant. He deposed that on
17.05.2016 after returning back to home he inquired about his brother
Tapan Deb @ Chanu from his mother when she told him that Chanu
had left home at around 2.00 to 2.30 p.m. after handing over cash
amounting to Rs.2,50,000/- to his mother and at about 8 p.m. at night
Chanu (deceased) called his mother to inform that he would go to the
Office of Udaipur Finance Company. Said PW-1 further stated that at
about 9 p.m. he rang up to the mobile of his brother Chanu when his
brother informed that he would stay in the house of one official of
Finance Company. On the following day, they started searching his
brother Chanu but could not trace him out and his mobile phone was
found to be switched off. He rang up one Suman who was an official of
Finance Company and on query, said Suman told his brother i.e. PW-1
that Chanu did not accompany him on the previous day. After that,
they started searching him thoroughly but could not trace him out.
PW-1 again stated that one Bikram Saha (PW-13) of Ompi market told
them that his brother Chanu accompanied by Bipul Saha and
Rangbhanga Reang purchased one hen from him on last Tuesday and
chopped the same in a meat shop and went to the house of Bipul Saha
where they consumed the meat which was purchased by the brother of
PW-1.
After that, on 23.05.2016, he laid the FIR to OC, Ompi P.S.
which was written by one Prabir Shil and he identified his signature
marked as Exbt.1.
12.
PW-17, Prabir Shil is the scribe who identified the FIR
marked at Exbt.1/1 and his signature marked as Exbt.1/2.
13.
PW-6, Smti. Basanti Deb is the mother of deceased Tapan
Deb @ Chanu. She in her evidence stated that on 17.05.2016, her son
Tapan Deb @ Chanu withdraw Rs.2,50,000/- from the bank and
keeping the said money with her he left the house at about 12 p.m. In
the evening, said Chanu told her over phone that he had gone to the
house of an employee of a Finance Company at Udaipur and will return
back on the next day in the morning. But in the next day morning her
son did not turn up and she tried to rang up his mobile but it was
found switched off. Thereafter, on thorough search PW-6 went to the
house of Bipul Saha who used to drive their car but not found him in
the house. So, she wen to Ompi Motor stand where she disclosed the
matter to her elder son Tapash Deb (PW-1). She further stated that
brother of Bipul Saha namely Dinesh Saha who was also their driver
told her that Bipul Saha disclosed to him that the whereabouts of
Chanu could be known from Rangbhanga Reang. So, her son Tapash
Deb (PW-1) informed the matter to police and accordingly, police
arrested Rangbhanga Reang who disclosed to the police about the
place where her son was killed. Said PW-6 further stated that Bipul
Saha always accompanied her deceased son and it was her belief that
her son was killed by Bipul Saha for the purpose of misappropriation of
amount of Rs.2,50,000/-.
In course of her cross-examination, minor discrepancy was
found but Learned Trial Court came to the observation that minor
discrepancy do not go to the root of the matter and shake the basic
version of the prosecution story and it was not exaggeration or
improvement on the part of the witness and he relied upon a decision
of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in a case cited in Bharwada
Bhoginbhai Hirjibhai vs State of Gujarat AIR, 1983 SC 753 :
(1983) (3) SCC 217 wherein it was held that “Discrepancies which
do not go to the root of the matter and shake the basic version of the
witnesses therefore cannot be annexed with undue importance. More
so when the all important “probabilities -factor” echoes in favour of the
version narrated by the witnesses.”
14.
PW-7, Samir Paul deposed that on 18.05.2016 in the
morning he came to know from his elder sister (PW-6) that Chanu did
not return back to home on 17.05.2016 in the night as he had gone to
Udaipur to meet the employee of Finance Company. But on that day,
the employee of Finance Company came to the house of Chanu at
Ompi and made query about Chanu. After query by the employee of
Finance Company, the family members of Chanu started searching
about him but could not trace out Chanu and accordingly, a verbal
information about the missing of Chanu was given to the Ompi P.S. by
PW-1, Tapash Deb. Said witness also deposed that prior to the lodging
of ejahar by PW-1 they came to know from one Bikram Saha and Abu
Deb @ Sukanta of Ompi that on 17.05.2016, his nephew Chanu was
accompanied by Bipul Saha and Rangbhanga Reang, they purchased a
hen from them. PW-7 further deposed that they informed the police
who arrested Bipul Saha and Rangbhanga Reang and on 25.05.2016,
the dead body of Chanu was recovered by police from Doctor Singh
Para in a Jhum Khet as pointed out by Rangbhanga Reang. He
identified his signature as Exbt.2 in the inquest report.
During cross-examination, PW-7 stated the place where
from the dead body of Chanu was recovered was a deep jungle at a
depth of about 120 feet from main road. He was put under crossexamination by the defence when he stated that, he said to the IO that
the dead body of Chanu was recovered as pointed out by the accused
Rangbhanga Reang but that portion “pointed out by Rangbhanga
Reang” was not found in the statement recorded by the IO. Learned
Trial Court also took the view that this minor discrepancy does not go
to the root of the matter and shake the version of the prosecution
story. As such, it does not amount to improvement or exaggeration on
the part of that witness. Learned trial Court relied upon another
citation in Narayan Chetanram Chaudhary & Anr. vrs. State of
Maharashtra, (2000) 8 SCC 457 wherein it was held that “Only such
omissions which amount to contradiction in material particulars can be
used to discredit the testimony of the witness. The omission in the
police statement by itself would not necessarily render the testimony
of witness unreliable. When the version given by the witness in the
Court is different in materials particulars from that disclosed in his
earlier statements, the case of the prosecution becomes doubtful and
not otherwise. Minor contradictions are bound to appear in the
statements of truthful witnesses as memory sometimes plays false and
the sense of observation differs from person to person. The omissions
in the earlier statement if found to be of trivial details, as in the
present case, the same would not cause any dent in the testimony of
PW 2. Even if there is contradiction of statement of a witness on any
material point, there is no ground to reject the whole of the testimony
of such witness.”
15.
PW-13,
Bikram
Saha
was
declared
hostile
by
the
prosecution and his portion of statement was marked as Exbt.2
(subject to proof by I.O.).
16.
PW-9, Usha Ranjan Kalai and PW-22, Sanjit Saha were also
declared hostile but nothing came out relevant from their evidences.
Leading to discovery under Section 27 of the Evidence Act,
prosecution adduced some more other witnesses.
17.
PW-15, Srikanta Deb and PW-16, Subrata Das deposed that
on 13.06.2016 at about 10 to 10.30 a.m. at Ompi P.S. the convictappellant, Bipul Saha disclosed the manner as to how he caused the
death of Tapan Deb @ Chanu and in their presence Bipul Saha
disclosed that on 17.05.2016 he purchased a hen from Ompi market
and thereafter he along with Rangbhanga Reang took the meat to his
house and while going to his house Bipul Saha also purchased three
numbers of alcohol bottles and in his house at night on the same day
Chanu @ Tapan Deb came and he along with Chanu @ Tapan Deb and
Rangbhanga Reang consumed the meat with alcohol. Bipul Saha in
their presence further disclosed that he mixed sleeping pills in Cocacola bottles and the same was offered to Chanu who consumed the
Coca-cola and thereafter, Chanu became senseless. On the night itself,
after consuming meat with alcohol Rangbhanga Reang left home from
the house of Bipul Saha and at about 4 a.m., Bipul Saha took the body
of Chanu @ Tapan Deb by his Max vehicle bearing No.TR-03-4112 and
started proceeding towards Doctorsingh Para/ Gamaku. On the way,
Bipul Saha found road block because of the fall of a log on the road
and so he could not proceed straight way and as a result, he had to
back with his vehicle and finding a lunga, Bipul Saha caused the fall of
the body of Chanu @ Tapan Deb and the body rolled down at the foot
of lunga. Said Bipul Saha reached at the foot of lunga and drag the
body to a drain and started pressing neck of Chanu by his leg and
covered by banana leafs. Bipul Saha also disclosed that he concealed
the wearing apparels of Chanu @ Tapan Deb in his latrine and he
threw the Coca-cola bottles in a pond of his adjoining house of one
Mrityunjoy Guha. Those witnesses further stated that on the same day
as per pointing of accused Bipul Saha, police recovered Coca-cola
bottles from a pond from in adjoining house of Bipul Saha and the
stripe of sleeping pills from the bamboo fencing of the house of
accused Bipul Saha and on the same day, Bipul Saha also pointed the
place i.e. the latrine from where the police recovered the wearing
apparels of Chanu. From the wearing apparels of Chanu which were
recovered from the latrine of Bipul Saha, police also recovered the ATM
Card in the name of Chanu. Said PW-15 identified his signatures as
Exbts.13, 13/1, 13/2, 13/3 in the disclosure statement and pointing
out evidence of accused Bipul Saha in four pages.
18.
PW-15 further identified his signature in the seizure list as
Exbt.14 after the seizure of the stripe of sleeping pills and also
identified the seized material i.e Exhibit-M.O.8. He also identified his
signature as Exhibit-4/1 in the seizure list after the seizure of the
wearing apparels with ATM Card and money bag of Tapan Deb and
also identified the seized materials as Exhibit-M.O.10, M.O.1, M.O.2 &
M.O.9. He identified his signature as Exhibit-15 in the seizure list after
the seizure of a portion of sit cover of the Max vehicle of Bipul Saha
with some blood stain and identified the seized material marked as
Exhibit-M.O.11. PW-16 identified his signature as Exhibits-13/4, 13/5,
13/6, 13/7 in the disclosure statement and pointing out evidence of
accused Bipul Saha in four pages. He identified his signature in the
seizure list in respect of seizure of stripe of sleeping pills marked as
Exhibit-14/1 and identified the seized materials marked as ExhibitM.O.7. Said PW-16 identified his signature as Exhibit-15/1 in the
seizure list after seizure of Coca-cola bottles and identified the seized
materials
marked
as
Exhibit-M.O.8.
Said
witness
identified
his
signature as Exhibit-4/2 in the seizure list after the seizure of wearing
apparels with ATM Card and money bag of Tapan Deb marked as
Exhibit-M.O.10, M.O.2 & M.O.9. He identified his signature as Exhibit15/1 in the seizure list in respect of seizure of sit cover of Max vehicle
with some blood stain and identified the seized materials marked as
Exhibit-M.O.11.
19.
PW-18, Rajesh Das is a professional videographer who
made the videography at Ompi P.S. when accused Rangbhanga Reang
and Bipul Saha made their disclosure statement as well as other places
till the recovery of the dead body of deceased Chanu and visiting the
scene of occurrence at the instance of the accused persons. He
developed two discs from the recorded video and handed over the
same to I.O. along with a certificate made under Section 65B of the
Indian Evidence Act. The I.O. seized the same by preparing seizure list
wherein he put his signature marked as Exhibit-6/2 and identified the
seized discs marked as Exhibit-6/2 and Exhibit-M.O.4 and ExhibitM.O.5 respectively. He identified the certificate marked as Exhibit-16
and signature therein marked as Exhibit-16/1.
20.
PW-25, Debasish Deb also deposed in the same manner like
PW-15 & PW-16. According to this witness, accused Rangbhanga
Reang disclosed that late night at about 0400 hours appellant Bipul
Saha informed Rangbhanga Reang on mobile that Tapan Deb @ Chanu
expired in the house of Bipul Saha and as such, instructed said
Rangbhanga Reang to assist him to dispose of the dead body of Tapan
Deb @ Chanu. But Rangbhanga Reang refused to come but being
threatened by appellant Bipul Saha he finally agreed and instructed to
reach Konaram Para where the dead body would be disposed of but
after some time Rangbhang Reang was informed by appellant Bipul
Saha that he had already disposed the dead body of Tapan Deb @
Chanu in a lunga, in between Konaram Para and Doctor Singh Para
jungle and on query by Rangbhang Reang the appellant Bipul Saha
informed about the place of disposal of the dead body. Said PW-25
further deposed that Rangbhang Reang also disclosed that he could
show the place where the dead body of Tapan Deb @ Chanu was
concealed and accordingly, he took the persons present in the P.S. to a
lunga known as „Puran Jum‟ in Doctor Singh Para jungle wherefrom a
drain the dead body of Tapan Deb @ Chanu was recovered which was
covered with banana leaves. After that, the inquest was made and the
witness put his signature on the inquest report and identified his
signature marked as Exhibit-2/2. This witness identified his signatures
in the disclosure statement of accused Rangbhang Reang marked as
Exhibits-22/2 and 22/3.
21.
PW-10, Tapan Das deposed that about two years back he
went to the residence of accused with police and on reaching there as
per noting of accused in his house one bag containing some clothes
were recovered from the tank of a Kaccha latrine and from the pocket
of a pant recovered one ATM Card, PAN Card belonging to Tapan Deb
and a Key and after that, he handed over the same to the police who
seized the same by preparing seizure list wherein the witness put his
signature and identified the same marked as Exhibit-4. He also
identified the seized ATM Card marked as Exhibit-M.O.1 and PAN Card
marked as Exhibit-M.O.2.
During cross-examination, PW-10 stated that he did not find
any road nearby the latrine. But in course of his cross-examination, he
stated that the latrine was situated at a stones throw distance from
the road.
22.
PW-24, Rupan Das, the then DCM of Amarpur deposed that
on 25.05.2016, the inquest was conducted and a report was prepared
on the dead body of Tapan Deb @ Chanu in the Ompi Hospital wherein
he put signature marked as Exhibit-2/1. Said witness further deposed
that on 13.06.2016 he went to Ompi P.S. for recording the disclosure
statement of accused Rangbhang Reang and he put his signature in
the disclosure statement of Rangbhang Reang marked as Exhibit-22
and Exhibit-22/1. Said witness further deposed that after seven to
eight days of such recording another disclosure statement of appellant
Bipul Saha was recorded at Ompi P.S. and thereafter, appellant Bipul
Saha took them to his house wherein at his pointing a stripe of
medicine, wearing apparels from the latrine tank, Coca-cola bottle
from the pond of his house were recovered and after completion of the
aforesaid procedure i.e. disclosure statement and recovery of the
aforesaid articles at his pointing, he put his signature in the disclosure
statement and pointing out memorandum marked as Exhibit-13/8 to
Exhibit-13/11. Said PW-24 further deposed that on the pointing of
accused Bipul Saha one purse was recovered from his house and in the
purse ATM Card along with some papers were also recovered. This
witness identified the ATM Card along with Tablets, Coca-cola bottle,
money bag and wearing apparels which were already marked as
Exhibits-M.O.1, M.O.7, M.O.8, M.O.9 and M.O.10 respectively.
During cross-examination, PW-24 stated first of all strip of
medicine was recovered followed by other articles. This witness could
not say the date of manufacture, expiry, name of the company of the
aforesaid stripe of medicine.
23.
PW-28, Surjya Kanta Jamatia, the I.O. of this case who
conducted investigation and laid charge sheet against the present
appellant and another. This witness identified the seizure list showing
the seizure of half pant as Exhibit-7/1, signature identified as Exhibit7/2, identified the seizure list showing seizure of empty strip of tablet
as Exhibit-14/2, signature identified as Exhibit-14/3, identified the
seizure list showing seizure of Coca-cola bottle marked as Exhibit15/2, signature identified as Exhibit-15/3, identified the seizure list
showing seizure of half sleeve ganji (vest) and black pant as Exhibit4/2 and signature identified as Exhibit-4/3.
These were the material witnesses of the prosecution as per
Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
24.
PW-19, Dr. Shyam Debbarma deposed that on 25.05.2016
at Ompi CHC he conducted the postmortem over the dead body of
Tapan Deb in connection with Ompi P.S. Case No.2016/OMP/005 dated
23.05.2016 under Section 364A/120B of IPC and on examination he
gave the following observations :
“1) The body was decomposed with plenty
maggots over the body;
2) Both eyes were liquefied and sockets were
empty with plenty of maggots;
3) Central incisors, right lateral incisors teeth
(upper and lower) were found missing;
4) On opening of abdomen gas sound is head with
foul smell;
5) There was multiple abrasion on left knee,
lacerated would measuring 1 cm x 3 cm on
occipital region, brain and thorax were found
congested.”
Said witness further deposed that Viscera was sent for
forensic and toxicological analysis and as per report of forensic
examination the cause of death was due to asphyxia because of over
dose of drugs. He identified the postmortem report in two pages
marked as Exhibit-17 and his signature marked as Exhibit-17/1. He
further deposed that on 25.05.2016 he handed over the viscera of the
dead body of Tapan Deb to police at Ompi Hospital Morgue which was
seized by a seizure list and he identified his signature marked as
Exhibit-8/1.
25.
PW-20, Dr. Subhankar Nath deposed that on 23.06.2016
the DNA Typing Division received two exhibits marked as „H‟ and „I‟ as
inter divisional examination and opinion from Toxicology Division in
connection with Ompi P.S. Case No.2016/OMP/005 dated 23.05.2016
under Sections 364(A)/120(B) with added Sections 302/201 of IPC.
The period of examination was 27.06.2016 to 03.08.2016. According
to this witness, the two exhibits were as follows :“1) Exhibit-H:- A piece of seat cover of the vehicle
No.TR-03-4112(Max) of Bipul Saha having four
encircled area by white colour, contained some
black stain.
2) Exhibit-I :- One brown colour envelope having
six gala seals of Ompi CHC and signature along
with stamp of medical officer, Ompinagar CHC,
Gomati Tripura dated 17.06.2016, inside which a
blood stained gauge, said to be the dry blood of
Tapash Deb, the elder brother deceased.
The Exhibit-H was examined for blood and
saliva. The Exhibit-I was examined for blood. On
biological examination blood stained and saliva
stain was not detected in the Exhibit-H. Blood stain
was detected in the Exhibit-I. The DNA Profile was
generated from the Exhibit-I is shown in the
Annexure-A and it is found to be the human male
blood. The report was prepared by PW-20 in the
official compute in four sheets and signed on
03.08.2016 and submitted to Toxicology Division
for forwarding the report to the forwarding
authority i.e. the SDPO, Ompi, Gomati Tripura. The
report was forwarded to the forwarding authority
along
with
Toxicological
report
vide
No.SFSL/374/16/TOX/167/16/4911
dated
04.08.2016 by the Director of SFSL, Tripura. PW-20
identified the report as Exhibit-18, the signatures
therein identified as Exhibit-18/1 to 18(4) and the
forwarding
letter
of
Director-cum-Chemical
Examiner, Government of Tripura identified as
Exhibit-19 and the signature of the Director
identified as Exhibit-19/1.”
26.
PW-21, Suman Chakraborty deposed that on 31.05.2016
their office received one sealed packet from SDPO, Ompi containing
exhibits in connection with Ompi P.S. Case No.2016/OMP/005 which
was endorsed to him by their Director for examination and opinion.
Inside the sealed packed there were five plastic containers marked as
Exhibits-A to E containing Stomach, Liver, Kidney, Hearts, Spleen
subsequently marked in their Lab as TOX/167/16A to TOX/167/16E.
Subsequently, on 23.06.2016 four more exhibits marked as Exhibits-F,
G, H and I in connection with same case were forwarded by the same
forwarding authority and received and endorsed to him as usual.
Exhibits marked H & I were referred to DNA FP Division as per
requisition of IO. The rest exhibit marked „F‟ was one plastic bottle of
cold drinks written Coca-cola etc. The container affixed a paper slip
with case reference, particulars of witness with signature etc;, inside it
found 10 ml of dirty coloured muddy liquid substance. Exhibit marked
„D‟ was containing an empty blister strip of twenty tablets written
Warnax 0.5 Alprazolam Tablets. This packet was also bearing case
reference,
particulars
of
witness
etc.
subsequently
marked
as
TOX/167/16(F) & (G). The Exhibits were examined from 16.06.2016 to
25.07.2016 by Chemical colour test Chromatographic (TLC, GC) and
Spectroscopic (MS method). On examination Ethyl Alcohol and
Alprazolam, A Benzodiazepine Group of Drugs has been detected in the
viscera sample of deceased Tapan Deb marked as TOX/167/16A and
TOX/167/16B. Exhibit marked C, E and F were negative for the
presence of common Organo Phosphorous, Organochloro, Pyrethroids
and Carbamates Group of Pesticides and Arsenic. Exhibit-D was not
examined as it was not suitable for detection of common poison.
Exhibits
marked
as
A,
B
and
F
has
been
exhausted
during
examination. PW-21 further deposed that the report was prepared by
him in the official computer in three pages which he identified as
Exhibit-20 and signatures therein identified as Exhibits-20/1, 20/2 and
20/3.
Following are the witnesses of the investigation part :
27.
PW-28, Surjya Kanta Jamatia who conducted investigation
of the case and he identified the exhibited documents. He deposed
that on 23.05.2016 one Tapash Deb laid the ejahar which was
registered
vide
case
No.2016/OMP/005
dated
23.05.2016
and
identified the same i.e. Exhibit-1/3. He filled up the printed FIR form
marked as Exhibit-24 and the signature marked as Exhibit-24/1. He
further deposed that on 18.05.2016, one written missing information
of Tapan Deb @ Chanu was received at P.S. which was entered in the
General Diary bearing No.15 dated 18.05.2016. On 23.05.2016, he
visited the P.O. and prepared the hand sketch map marked as Exhibit25, and his signature marked as Exhibit-25/1 with separate index
marked as Exhibit-26 and signature of him marked as Exhibit-26/1. He
also conducted the inquest over the dead body of Tapan Deb @ Chanu
at the place of recovery and prepared a report and identified the same
marked as Exhibit-2/3 and his signature marked as Exhibit-2/4. He
also deposed that he arranged for postmortem examination of the
dead body of deceased Tapan Deb @ Chanu and on production by Dr.
Shyam Debbarma, he seized the viscera of deceased at Ompi Hospital
morgue by preparing seizure list marked as Exhibit-8/2, signature
marked as Exhibit-8/3. On 26.05.2016, he again visited the place of
occurrence where the
dead body was recovered and prepared hand
sketch map of the second P.O. marked as Exhibit-27 and his signature
marked as Exhibit-27/1 with separate index marked as Exhibit-28
along with signature marked as Exhibit-28/1. He further deposed that
in course of investigation, he made a prayer for adding Section
302/201 of IPC in this case. He arranged for sending the viscera to the
SFSL. He caused arrest of accused Bipul Saha from East Agartala P.S.
as the accused on 10.06.2016 surrendered at East Agartala P.S. He
also seized some portion of seat cover containing blood stain from the
vehicle bearing No.TR-03-4112 (Max) and seized the same by
preparing seizure list and identified the seizure list marked as Exhibit15/4 and his signature marked as Exhibit-15/5. On 16.06.2016, he
sent requisition for collection of blood sample of informant Tapash Deb
and on the following day, the blood sample of Tapash Deb was seized
from Dr. Biswajit Debbarma, by preparing seizure list Exhibit-10/1 and
his signature marked as Exhibit-10/2. He arranged for sending the
seized blood sample for forensic examination. On 24.06.2016, he
seized two Compact discs by preparing seizure list and identified the
same marked as Exhibit-6/3 and his signature marked as Exhibit-6/4.
On 19.08.2016, he submitted a prayer before the Court for tagging the
GD Extract in connection with GDE No.15 dated 18.05.2016 which was
marked as Exhibit-29 and after completion of investigation he laid
charge sheet.
During cross-examination he deposed that on 23.05.2016 at
1345 hours accused Rangbhang Reang was taken to Lundingfa Old
Jhum under Komaram Para of Ompi P.S. but on that day, no dead
body was recovered. The bag containing the seized articles were also
not seized. He further deposed that accused Bipul Saha brought out
the empty strip of tablets from the bamboo fencing of kitchen room as
per seizure list marked as Exhibit 15/2 and accused Bipul Saha
produced Coca-cola bottle and the same was seized. He also stated
that the seizure list marked as Exhibit-14/2 does not contain any
description regarding the date of manufacturing of tablets, Company,
date of expiry etc. He again stated that although the alleged dead
body was recovered on 25.05.2016 at about 1345 hours, but the hand
sketch map with index were prepared on 26.05.2016.
28.
PW-26,
Pradip
Das
deposed
that
on
24.05.2016
in
connection with East Agartala P.S. GDE Nos.53 and 58 dated
24.05.2016
and
Ompi
P.S.
Case
No.05/2016
under
Sections
364A/120B of IPC, he seized one vehicle bearing No.TR-03-4112
(Mahindra Max) from Resham Bagan in the garage of Pradip Banik and
Ajit Banik by preparing seizure list marked as Exhibit-23, and his
signature marked as Exhibit-23/1, and said witness after seizure
handed over the aforesaid vehicle to the I.O. of that case.
29.
PW-11, Shri Jibananda Das seizure witness deposed that on
23.05.2016 the I.O. seized one mobile phone (Black colour) by
preparing seizure list wherein he put his signature and identified the
same as Exhibit-5, on 24.05.2016 the I.O. seized the CD containing
the statements of Bipul Saha and Rangabhang Reang by preparing
seizure list wherein he also put his signature as witness which he
identified as Exhibit-6. On 26.05.2016 the I.O. seized a pant (light
blue coloured) by preparing seizure list wherein he put his signature as
a witness which he identified as Exhibit-7. On 25.05.2016 the I.O.
seized the exhibits in bottle after postmortem by preparing seizure list
wherein he put his signature as witness and identified the same as
Exhibit-8, on identification by the witness black coloured mobile
marked as Exhibit-M.O.3, 2 numbers of CDs as marked as ExhibitM.O.4 and Exhibit-M.O.5, blood stain in gauge cloth is marked as
Exhibit M.O.6.
30.
PW-12,
Md.
Atikul
Islam
Khadim
deposed
that
on
23.05.2016 the IO Surjya Kanta Jamatia seized one mobile phone
(Black colour) by preparing seizure list wherein he put his signature as
witness, which he identified as Exhibit-5/1. On 04.06.2016, the IO
seized a Max vehicle bearing No.TR-03-4112 of accused Bipul Saha by
preparing a seizure list wherein he put his signature as witness and
identified his signature marked as Exhibit-9. On 17.06.2016, the IO
seized dry blood sample of the deceased in gauge cloth by preparing
seizure list wherein he put signature which he identified as Exhibit-10,
on 24.06.2016 the IO also seized two CDs developed by videographer
Rajesh Das by preparing seizure list wherein the witness put his
signature marked as Exhibit-6/1, he also confirmed Exhibit-M.O.3,
Exhibit-M.O.4, Exhibit-M.O.5 and Exhibit-M.O.6.
31.
PW-27, Ajit Banik deposed that on 24.05.2016 one vehicle
bearing No.TR-03-4112(Mahindra Max) was undergoing repairing in
their workshop and on that day, the police seized the said vehicle by
preparing seizure list wherein he put his signature marked as Exhibit23/1.
32.
PW-2,
Shri
Panjiham
Reang,
PW-3,
Smti.
Aldirani
Debbarma, PW-4, Pandirai Reang, PW-5, Kanta Rai Reang, PW-8, Nitai
Rudra Paul, PW-14, Ajay Reang could not say anything about the
prosecution case.
33.
PW-23, Sumit Sen is the Marketing Agent of Sree Ram
Transport Finance Company deposed that on 16.05.2016, Tapan Dey
@ Chanu executed an agreement for the purpose of a Bus and on next
Wednesday, he was supposed to go to the house of Tapan Dey @
Chanu for procuring the money from him and on Wednesday, when he
rang up to Tapan Dey on his mobile number he found that the same
was found to be switched off, so on the same day, he went to Ompi
Syndicate Office where he came to know that Tapan Dey @ Chanu was
missing. PW-23, further deposed that Tapan Dey @ Chanu did not go
to his residence on Tuesday and after eight to nine days he came to
know that the dead body of Tapan Dey @ Chanu was recovered.
34.
These were the some and substance of the evidence on
record of prosecution. Before we proceed further to re-appreciate, it is
to be noted here that Learned Additional P.P. in course of hearing of
argument submitted that since the case
is entirely based on
circumstantial evidence and the prosecution both by oral/documentary
evidence on record has been able to prove the charge against the
appellant, so Learned Addl. P.P. urged for upholding the conviction.
35.
On the other hand, Learned Senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the accused appellant submitted that the prosecution has
failed to prove the chain of circumstances in this case and relied upon
one citation of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Sharad Birdhichand
Sarda versus State of Maharashtra reported in (1984) 4 SCC 116
Hon‟ble the Supreme Court have been pleased to observe as under :
“151. It is well settled that the prosecution must
stand or fall on its own legs and it cannot derive
any strength from the weakness of the defence.
This is trite law and no decision has taken a
contrary view. What some cases have held is only
this: where various links in a chain are in
themselves complete than a false plea or a false
defence may be called into aid only to lend
assurance to the Court. In other words, before
using the additional link it must be proved that all
the links in the chain are complete and do not
suffer from any infirmity. It is not the law that
where is any infirmity or lacuna in the prosecution
case, the same could be cured or supplied by a
false defence or a plea which is not accepted by a
Court.
152. Before discussing the cases relied upon by the
High Court we would like to cite a few decisions on
the nature, character and essential proof required
in a criminal case which rests on circumstantial
evidence alone. The most fundamental and basic
decision of this Court is Hanumant v. The State of
Madhya Pradesh : AIR 1952 SC 343 This case has
been uniformly followed and applied by this Court
in a large number of later decisions uptodate, for
instance, the cases of Tufail (Alias) Simmi v. State
of Uttar Pradesh : (1969) 3 SCC 198 and Ramgopal
v. State of Maharashtra : (1972) 4 SCC 625. It may
be useful to extract what Mahajan, J. has laid down
in Hanumant's case (supra):
"It is well to remember that in cases
where the evidence is of a circumstantial
nature, the circumstances from which
the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn
should in the first instance be fully
established
and
all
the
facts
so
established should be consistent only
with the hypothesis of the guilt of the
accused.
Again,
the
circumstances
should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency and they should be such as to
exclude every hypothesis but the one
proposed to be proved. In other words,
there must be a chain of evidence so far
complete as not to leave any reasonable
ground far a conclusion consistent with
the innocence of the accused and it must
be such as to show that within all human
probability the act must have been done
by the accused."
153. A close analysis of this decision would show
that the following conditions must be fulfilled
before a case against an accused can be said to be
fully established:
(1) the circumstances from which the
conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be
fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated
that the circumstances concerned 'must or
should' and not 'may be' established. There is
not only a grammatical but a legal distinction
between 'may be proved' and 'must be or
should be proved' as was held by this Court
in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade & Anr. v. State of
Maharashtra : (1973) 2 SCC 793 where the
following observations were made:
"Certainly, it is a primary principle that
the accused must be and not merely may
be guilty before a court can convict and
the mental distance between 'may be'
and 'must be' is long and divides vague
conjectures from sure conclusions."
(2) The facts so established should be consistent
only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the
accused, that is to say. They should not be
explainable on any other hypothesis except that
the accused is guilty, (3) the circumstances should
be of a conclusive nature and tendency.
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis
except the one to be proved, and (5) there must be
a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent
with the innocence of the accused and must show
that in all human probability the act must have
been done by the accused.”
36.
Here in the case at hand, according to the prosecution, the
prosecution has been able to prove the motive, disclosure statement
and the circumstantial evidence to sustain the charge against the
appellant. Now, for the sake of evidence, I would like to refer herein
below the provisions of Section 27 of the Evidence Act which reads as
follows :
“27. How much of information received from
accused may be proved.- Provided that, when any
fact is deposed to as discovered in consequence of
information received from a person accused of any
offence, in the custody of a police officer, so much
of such information, whether it amounts to a
confession or not, as relates distinctly to the fact
thereby discovered, may be proved.”
37.
In this case to substantiate, evidence leading to discovery
under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, prosecution has adduced PWs10, 15, 16, 18, 24, and 28. The evidence of those witnesses have been
elaborately discussed. The appellant by the trend of cross-examination
of those witnesses during trial could not raise any doubt to disbelieve
their evidence. It is a settled principle of law that as per Section 27 of
the Indian Evidence Act an information received from the accused in a
police custody leading to discovery of fact is admissible and relevant.
In the present case, there is no dispute on record that the disclosure
statement of the accused persons namely Bipul Saha and Rangbhanga
Reang were made during their police custody. In this case, the fact
discovered by the police with the help of disclosure statement of the
accused persons in police custody and the recovery of incriminating
materials on the strength of such statement is that it was the accused
who concealed those articles at the hidden places and it appears from
the evidence on record that the prosecution has been able to prove the
fact of recovery beyond reasonable doubt against the present
appellant. Regarding motive, it is the case of the prosecution that the
appellant Bipul Saha had some link with the deceased and as such, he
had knowledge about the withdrawal of Rs.2,50,000/- by the deceased
for purchasing of a vehicle which prompted the appellant to made up
in mind with another accused namely Rangbhanga Reang for killing of
deceased Tapan Deb.
38.
The Learned Trial Court below, to prove motive relied upon
the following citations :
42. In Ranganayaki v State, AIR 2005 SC 418 the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that though it is a
sound proposition that every criminal act is done
with a motive, it is unsound to suggest that no
such criminal act can be presumed unless motive is
proved.
43. In the case of Atley v State of UP, AIR 1955 SC
807 the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that “Where
there is clear proof of motive for the crime, that
lends additional support to the finding of the court
that the accused was guilty but the absence of
clear proof of the motive does not necessarily lead
to the contrary conclusion. The absence of proof of
motive has this effect only, namely that the other
evidence bearing on the guilt of the accused had to
be very closely examined.”
39.
Regarding circumstantial evidence and its admissibility, the
prosecution should satisfy the following tests :
1) The circumstances from which an inference of
guilt is sought to be drawn must be cogently and
firmly established.
2) Those circumstances should be of a definite
tendency unerringly pointing towards guilt of the
accused.
3) The circumstances taken cumulatively should
form a chain should complete that there is not
escape from the conclusion that within all human
probability the crime was committed by the accused
and none else.
4) The circumstantial evidence in order to sustain
conviction must be complete and incapable of
explanation of any other hypothesis then the guilt of
the accused and such evidence should not only be
consistent with the guilt of the accused but should
be inconsistent with his view.
40.
Here, in the case, the accused Rangbhanga Reang has led
to discovery of the dead body of Tapan Dey @ Chanu and the present
appellant Bipul Saha has led to discovery of the wearing apparels of
the deceased, one strip of sleeping pills of Warnax 0.5, one Coca-cola
bottle, used in the crime, one half sleeve ganji, one black pant, one
PAN Card and one ATM Card containing the name of the deceased. All
those discovered facts were within the knowledge of the present
appellant. The medical evidence i.e. PW-19 and the Forensic evidence
i.e. the evidence of PW-21 corroborated the fact that the deceased had
consumed Ethyl Alcohol and Alprazolam Tablets which caused the
death of the deceased, Tapan Deb.
41.
According
Alprazolam Tablet
to
the
Learned
Court
below,
Warnax
0.5,
and other articles had direct noxious with the
circumstances of this case which is only inconsistent with the
innocence of the accused but consistent with the guilt of the accused
person i.e. the appellant of this case. Thus, from the evidence on
record specifically the disclosure statements of the appellant and
another co-accused and from the evidence of other witnesses of the
prosecution, it is clear that prosecution in this case has been able to
prove that the present appellant was responsible for the murder of the
deceased. The appellant even during his examination under Section
313 of Cr.P.C. remained silent save and except denial which lead to an
inference that the prosecution had been able to prove the chain of
circumstances in this case.
Thus, this Court does not find any reason to interfere with
the finding of conviction and as consequence thereof, this appeal being
bereft of merit, and stands dismissed.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
Date: 2024.01.10 16:14:58 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review