The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. 09.2019 the Bank had received the cheque forwarded by United Bank of India, Udaipur (now, PNB, Udaipur) deposited by the complainant for encashment but was returned unpaid stating that the cheque had been dishonoured on the ground of insufficiency of fund on the account of Sri Bhusan Das i.e. the accused. However, in reply to the question of the court, the official of Tripura State Cooperative Bank, Udaipur Branch informed the United Bank of India about the dishonour of cheque on the ground of insufficiency of fund. DW2 also replied that it must have been done by mistake because encashment of the said cheque was already stopped by the Bank. [9] The learned trial Court on appreciation of the evidence came to the conclusion that the defense set up by the accused and the statements of DW1 and DW2 together with the documentary evidences show that the accused had stopped the payment of cheque on 01.11.2018 much prior to the alleged date of execution of the cheque on 23.09.2019 on the ground that the cheque was allegedly missing. Since the accused is not required to prove his case beyond reasonable doubt on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities, he had been able to rebut the presumption attached to a negotiable instrument in terms of Section 139 of NI Act. The complainant had also not produced the Bank statement or annual turnover or books of account which would lead to th…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
Crl. L.P No.03 of 2023 in Crl. A No.03 of 2023
Sri Apu Ghosh
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
Sri Bhusan Das and another
......Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. P.P.,
Mr. K. Datta, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
11/05/2023
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
[2]
Petitioner is the complainant who seeks special leave to
appeal in terms of Section 378(4) of Cr.P.C. against the judgment of
acquittal dated 19.01.2023 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate 1 st
Class, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura in Case No. CR (NI) 56 of 2019. The
accused/respondent No.1 has been acquitted of the offence punishable
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (NI Act, 1881
for short).
[3]
Case of the complainant is that the accused was in friendly
relationship with him and an amount of Rs.4,50,000/- was borrowed from
the petitioner on 29.03.2019 at hotel Maharaja in presence of one Uttam
Sutradhar and another Pritam Datta of Rajarbag, Udaipur. Again on
03.04.2019 at about 5 pm the accused further borrowed Rs.7,50,000/- at
the same hotel Maharaja, Rajarbag in presence of one Sanjit Debnath and
Ratan Chakraborty for the purposes of his business with a condition that
he would return the borrowed money before Durga Puja 2019. On being
approached by the complainant, the accused issued a cheque bearing No.
012853 dated 23.9.2019 amounting to Rs.11,06,000/- only to the
complainant drawn on Tripura State Co-operative Bank Limited, Udaipur
Branch vide Account No.000211010018047 in presence of Sanjit
Debnath, Raju Dey and Biswajit Saha, out of his total debt of
Rs.12,00,000/- to discharge his debts and liabilities. On the very same
day
the
complainant
deposited
the
cheque
in
his
account
NO.0462010237253 lying with United Bank of India, Udaipur Branch for
his encashment. However, on 24.09.2019, the Branch Manager, United
Bank of India, Udaipur Branch returned the cheque as unpaid stating inter
alia that due to „funds insufficient‟ the cheque had been dishonoured.
Thereafter, on 03.10.2019 through his advocate petitioner served a
demand notice by registered post asking payment of the amount of
cheque of Rs.11,06,000/- within the stipulated period of 15 days from the
receipt of the said notice failing which legal action would be taken
against him. On 12.10.2019 the accused had received the registered notice
dated 03.10.2019 but no payments were made till the filing of the
complaint. Therefore, he alleged that the accused has dishonestly cheated
and deceived the complainant knowing fully well that there were
insufficient fund in his bank account. His actions construed an offence
punishable under Section 138 of NI Act, 1881 and also under Section 420
of IPC.
[4]
The accused appeared before the court on summons and
substance of accusation were framed under Section 251 of Cr.P.C against
him under Section 138 of NI Act which were explained to him in Bengali
to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. During trial,
complainant examined five witnesses including himself and exhibited the
following documents:
“1. Cheque vide No. 012853 dated 23.09.2019 of amount
Rs.11,06,000/-(Rupees eleven lac six thousand) only issued by the
accused in favour of P.W.1, was marked as Exhibit-1;
2. Counter part of the Deposit Slip dated 23.09.2019 submitted to
United Bank of India, Udaipur Branch was marked as Exhibit 2;
3. Bank Return Memo dated 24.09.2019 issued by the United
Bank of India, Udaipur Branch;
4. Counter part of the Postal Receipt dated 03.10.2019 was
marked as Exhibit 3;
5. Copy of Legal Notice dated 03.10.2019 (in 03 pages), which
was marked as Exhibit 4;
6. Acknowledgement Card dated 12.10.2019 with regard to
Notice served upon you was marked as Exhibit 5.
7. Copy of Registration Certificate of vehicle bearing Registration
No. TR-03-1389 (OM Bus) in the name of CW1, was marked as
Exhibit 6 in comparison with original;
8. Copy of Notification vide No. F.8(5)-PWD(C)/2012/dated 4th
November, 2015 enlisting the name of contractors including name
of PW1, was marked as Exhibit 7, Exhibit 7/1 (in 03 pages) in
comparison with the original;
9. Copy of Trade Licence issued by the Udaipur Municipal
Council, in the name of partner of PW1 namely Shri Ratan
Chakraborty, was marked as Exhibit 8 in comparison with the
original;
10. Partnership agreement between PW1 and 02(two) others, was
marked as Exhibit 9;
11. Return Memo bearing the seal of Punjab National Bank
previously United Bank of India was marked as Exhibit 10.”
[5]
The complainant adduced further Examination-in-chief
through affidavit. The accused was examined under Section 313 of
Cr.P.C after conclusion of the prosecution evidence to which he denied
the allegations and expressed his willingness to adduce evidence. He
adduced two witnesses, himself and another Sri Swapan Jamatia DW2.
He also exhibited Bank slip dated 01.11.2018 Exhibit D/1; (ii) counter
copy of the information in writing dated 31.10.2018 given by DW1 and
counter signed by Officer-in-charge, R.K Pur Police Station which was
marked without objection as Exhibit D/2. The defense took the plea that a
blank cheque bearing No.012853 drawn on Tripura State Co-operative
Bank Limited, Udaipur Branch containing his signature was missing from
beneath his pillow and on the same date the complainant had visited his
house. Regarding that, he had made a GD entry at R.K Pur Police Station
and submitted a prayer before the Bank authority for cancellation of his
missing cheque. After 10 months and 22 days of the incidence the
complainant lodged the instant case falsely implicating him of misusing
the lost cheque.
[6]
The learned trial Court after conclusion of evidence and after
hearing the parties framed points for determination inter alia (i) whether
the accused issued the cheque in question vide No.012853 dated
23.09.2019 for Rs.11,06,000/- against his account with Tripura State
Cooperative Bank Limited in favour of the complainant in discharge of
any legal debt or liability, either in whole or part and if so; (ii) whether
the said cheque was presented in the bank within the period of three
months or the period of the validity and that the cheque was returned
dishonoured by bank on the ground of insufficiency of fund or otherwise?
(iii) whether the complainant issued demand notice to the accused within
30 days from the date of dishonour of the cheque and if so, (iv) whether
the accused failed to make payment of the said cheque amount within 15
days from the receipt of said demand notice.
[7]
Learned trial Court proceeded to determine these issues.
Having dealt with the ingredients of the provisions of Section 118(a) and
139 of the NI Act, and certain decisions on the subject such as K.
Bhaskaran v Sankaran Vaidhyan Balan reported in (1999) 7 SCC 510,
Hiten P. Dalal v Bratindranath Banerjee reported in (2001) 6 SCC 16;
Tapan Kumar Saha v Balai Chandra Das reported in (2022) 1 TLR 537
and Rangappa vs Mohan reported in (2010) 11 SCC 441 learned trial
Court came to a finding that the complainant had on 01.11.2018
submitted an application intimating the matter regarding missing of his
cheque noticed on the afternoon of 30.10.2018, to the Officer-in-charge,
R.K Pur PS which was entered in G.D vide No.17 dated 01.11.2018. On
the same day he submitted a prayer to the Branch Manager, Tripura State
Cooperative Bank Limited, Udaipur Branch for cancellation of the said
missing cheque and deposited Rs.71/- as cancellation charges. DW1 had
identified a counter copy of the information in writing dated 31.10.2018
given by him and counter signed by the Officer-in-charge, R.K Pur PS
exhibited as D/2. The complainant also had taken a plea that another
matter relating dishonour of cheque by the same accused for an amount of
Rs.90,000/- was settled through Lok Adalat and Rs.70,000/- was paid to
the complainant. DW2 Shri Swapan Jamatia, Branch Manager of Tripura
State Cooperative Bank Limited, Udaipur Branch had deposed as per the
bank records that one copy of information which was entered into the
G.D of R.K. Pur PS was submitted stating that blank cheque No.012853
against the account of the informant with Tripura State Cooperative Bank
Limited, Udaipur Branch bearing his signature was lost. Based on such
information, the payment of the said cheque was stopped on 01.11.2018
and accordingly a Bank slip of the same date was issued identified as
Exhibit D/1.
[8]
During cross-examination DW2 also stated that on
24.09.2019 the Bank had received the cheque forwarded by United Bank
of India, Udaipur (now, PNB, Udaipur) deposited by the complainant for
encashment but was returned unpaid stating that the cheque had been
dishonoured on the ground of insufficiency of fund on the account of Sri
Bhusan Das i.e. the accused. However, in reply to the question of the
court, the official of Tripura State Cooperative Bank, Udaipur Branch
informed the United Bank of India about the dishonour of cheque on the
ground of insufficiency of fund. DW2 also replied that it must have been
done by mistake because encashment of the said cheque was already
stopped by the Bank.
[9]
The learned trial Court on appreciation of the evidence came
to the conclusion that the defense set up by the accused and the
statements of DW1 and DW2 together with the documentary evidences
show that the accused had stopped the payment of cheque on 01.11.2018
much prior to the alleged date of execution of the cheque on 23.09.2019
on the ground that the cheque was allegedly missing. Since the accused is
not required to prove his case beyond reasonable doubt on the touchstone
of preponderance of probabilities, he had been able to rebut the
presumption attached to a negotiable instrument in terms of Section 139
of NI Act. The complainant had also not produced the Bank statement or
annual turnover or books of account which would lead to the inference
that any transaction actually took place between the complainant and the
accused. In this regard, learned trial Court relied upon a decision of this
Court in case of Tapan Kr. Saha vs Balai Chandra Das (supra). Based
on these findings and other observations the learned trial Court acquitted
the accused. The principal point No.1 was decided in negative.
[10]
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
appreciation of evidence on part of the learned trial Court suffers from
error which can be corrected in appeal where the evidence adduced by the
parties can be re-appreciated in entirety. It is submitted that the learned
trial Court committed an error in arriving at a finding that the accused had
successfully rebutted the presumption under Section 139 of the NI Act as
not only had he made a GD entry before the R.K Pur Police Station but
also informed the Bank of the missing cheque on 01.11.2018. The learned
trial Court also committed an error on the issue of testing the bona fides
of the complainant on the touchstone of his financial capacity despite
sufficient evidence on record to the contrary. He submitted that the
petitioner has therefore made out an arguable case and good grounds to
seek leave to appeal. Therefore, permission may be granted to the
petitioner to prefer an appeal against the impugned judgment of acquittal.
[11]
The accused-respondent has filed a counter-affidavit.
Learned counsel for the respondent submits that the GD entry was
exhibited by the learned trial Court without any objection by the
complainant side. Moreover, he had adduced the evidence of Bank
Manager of the drawee cheque wherein he specifically stated that the
Bank authority had received a charge of Rs.71/- for stop payment of the
cheque mentioned in the complaint petition and accordingly he had
stopped the payment. However, the Bank Manager of Tripura State Co-
operative Bank reiterated that for the reasons not known to him the
cheque was dishonoured for insufficiency of fund in the Bank Account of
the respondent No.1. The respondent further states that the complainant
was not an income tax payee and as such it was not possible for him to
lend such big amount of Rs.12 lakh. It renders a probable case of the
defense that the cheque was not issued for legally enforceable debt and as
such the presumption under Section 139 of the NI Act was successfully
rebutted. That is why the learned trial Court acquitted the accused.
[12]
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and have also taken note of the case of the complainant and the
defense and the materials adduced during trial. I have also gone through
the judgment of acquittal rendered by the learned trial Court. Without
venturing to make any comment on the merits of the case of the parties, at
this stage, as it may cause prejudice to either of them, this Court on
consideration of the materials adduced during trial and the observations
and findings of the learned trial Court, is of the opinion that the issues
raised by the petitioner relate to appreciation of evidence by the trial
Court which if permitted can be examined in entirety by the appellate
Court on granting leave to appeal. The issue revolves around the
appreciation of evidence whether the accused has successfully rebutted
the presumption raised under Section 139 of the NI Act in the given facts
and circumstances of the case. The rebuttal of presumption being
essentially on the basis of appreciation of evidence and documents
adduced by the parties, this Court is of the considered view that the
petitioner has been able to make out a case for grant of special leave to
appeal.
[13]
Accordingly, permission is granted. The instant petition is
allowed and disposed of.
The appeal [Crl. A No.03 of 2023] is admitted for hearing.
Call for the lower court records from the concerned court. Office to
prepare the Paper Book. Counsel for the parties may obtain the Paper
Book.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH) CJ
Dipesh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review