Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
ON THE 24th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 21700 of 2021
BETWEEN:SATISH KUSHWAH S/O RAM SEVAK
KUSHWAH, AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: SERVICE (CONSTABLE NO
424) A B ROAD GOL PAHADIYA BEHIND
SHANKAR COLONY LASHKAR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
….....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI D.P. SINGH - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY
VALLABH
BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
THE
DEPUTY
SECRETARY
HOME
DEPARTMENT
VALLABH
BHAWAN
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
THE DIRECTOR GENERAL (HOME
GUARD) CITIZENS SECURITY AND
DISATER
MANAGEMENT,
HEAD
QUARTER
JABALPUR
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
4.
THE INSPECTOR GENERAL HOME
GUARDS CITIZENS SECURITY AND
DISASTER
MANAGEMENT,
HEAD
QUARTER BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
THE DISTRICT COMMADANT HOME
GUARD , DISTT. GWALIOR GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
….....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SOHIT MISHRA - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This petition coming on for orders this day, the Court pronounced
the following:
ORDER
1.
The present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
directed against the order dated 28.09.2021 (Annexure P/1), whereby on
the basis of the order dated 27.09.2021 (Annexure P/2), which was a
correspondence between the Department of Home and the Director
General of Police (Home Guard), the appointment of the petitioner on the
post of Home Guard (volunteer sainik) has been cancelled. Assailing the
said order to be in flagrant violation of principles of natural justice, as it
has been passed without affording any opportunity of hearing as well as
being per se illegal, has been prayed for being set aside. Further,
quashment of Annexure P/2, the correspondence on the basis of which the
order dated 28.09.2021 (Annexure P/1) has been passed, is also sought to
be quashed.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that the petitioner was engaged with the
respondents/department as a Confidential Sainik since 2012 and since his
induction in the department the petitioner is performing his duties. As the
petitioner was performing the duty as a Confidential Sainik with the
respondnets/department, the then Superintendent of Police considering his
eligibility forwarded his case for appointment as a Home Guard Volunteer
vide DO letter dated 25.01.2020. On the basis of said correspondence,
respondent No.3 wrote a letter dated 11.06.2018, whereby the petitioner
alongwith other Confidential Sainik was called for verification of his
educational qualification as well as physical fitness. Thereafter, after due
verification of the educational qualification as well as after clearing the
physical test vide letter dated 27.07.2018 the petitioner was provisionally
nominated as a Home Guard Sainik and after submission of the form
No.12 by the petitioner disclosing his antecedents, he was inducted in the
Unit of Home Guard as Home Guard Sainik and was awarded batch
No.424 w.e.f. 01.09.2018. The petitioner thereafter had undergone training
as per the order dated 29.08.2018 and after successful completion of the
training the petitioner was allowed to perform work as Home Guard
Sainik, but abruptly, vide Annexure P/1, the order of appointment of the
petitioner as Home Guard Sainik was cancelled without affording any
opportunity of hearing, thus, constrained the present petition has been
moved.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner while placing reliance on Rule
8(d) proviso of M.P. Home Guard Rules, 2016 argued that proviso
appended to Rule (d) provides for appointment of persons for confidential
work relating to internal security and for that purpose the State
Government had powers to relax the eligibility conditions and Home
Guards may be enrolled accordingly for a period and number specified by
the State Government and in that context, the petitioner was appointed as
Confidential Sainik in the year 2012. It was further argued that this fact has
not been disputed by the State that the petitioner was appointed as a
Confidential Sainik. Further while placing reliance on Rule 6 of the
aforesaid Rules of 2016, it was argued that Rule 6(d) provides for
nomination of the Home Guard Volunteers in different ranks and in the
light of the aforesaid provision vide order dated 27.07.2018 the petitioner
was temporarily nominated on the post of Home Guard Volunteer Sainik
by Director General of Police, Home Guard and thereafter vide order dated
01.09.2018, the petitioner was inducted in the Home Guard and was
allotted batch No.421. It was further contended that though the
appointment of the petitioner on the post of Home Guard Volunteer Sainik
was legal and under the provisions of Rules 2016 holding his appointment
in the aforesaid post to be illegal, was perverse and had wrongly been
cancelled and that too without giving any opportunity of hearing, thus, it
was contended that since the principles of natural justice has not been
followed, the impugned order be set aside.
4.
It was further contended that admittedly, the impugned order dated
28.09.2021 (Annexure P/1) from its bare perusal appears to have been
passed on a dictate and command of Department of Home, which
admittedly is the parent body, therefore, the impugned order by Director
General of Police, Home Guard can very well said to be without due
application of mind, thus, it deserves to be set aside. To bolster his
submissions, reliance was placed in the matter of Jaswant Singh And Ors.
vs State Of Madhya Pradesh And Ors. reported in (2002) 9 SCC 700;
wherein Hon'ble Apex Court has held that since the order has been passed
without any opportunity of hearing given to the party, the order impugned,
therefore, stands vitiated. Further reliance was placed in the matter of
Mahendra Kumar Chaurasiya Vs. State of M.P. reported in 2002 (3)
MPLJ 112; wherein coordinate Bench of this Court has held that even in
the case of invalid appointment or in case where validity of order of
appointment is questioned, it is necessary that opportunity of hearing
should be granted to person concerned and considering the period for
which the petitioner has rendered the services as also he was regularized
by competent authority, his appointment should have been cancelled.
Further reliance was placed in the matter of Biecco Lawrie Ltd. Vs. West
Bengal reported in (2009) 10 SCC 32; for the preposition that principle
of natural justice is attracted whenever a person suffers a civil consequence
or a prejudice is caused to him by an administrative action. In other words,
principle of natural justice is attracted where there is some right which is
likely to be affected by any act of the administration including a legitimate
expectation. Further reliance was placed in the matter of Mansukhlal
Vithaldas Chauhan Vs. State of Gujarat reported in (1997) 7 SCC 622 for
the preposition that in the performance of duties, if the authority in whom
the discretion is vested under the Statute, does not act independently and
passes an order under the instructions and orders of another authority, the
Court would intervene in the matter, quash the orders and issue a
mandamus to that authority to exercise its own discretion. On the basis of
the aforesaid arguments, learned counsel for the petitioner has prayed for
setting aside the order dated 28.09.2021 (Annexure P/1).
5.
Per contra, Shri Sohit Mishra, learned Govt. Advocate for the State
while supporting the order passed by the Director General of Police, Home
Guards has contended that no illegality has been committed by the said
authority in passing the impugned order, as admittedly neither in M.P.
Home Guard Act, 1947, nor in the Rules framed thereunder, there is any
provision of appointment of a Confidential Sainik as a Home Guard
Volunteer Sainik and in absence of any specific legal provision the
appointment of the petitioner as a Home Guard Volunteer Sainik was
rightly held to be illegal and was cancelled.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondents/State has also contended that so
far as appointment of the petitioner as a Confidential Sainik is concerned,
the said appointment itself is under cloud, as no certificate as provided
under the Rules is available with the petitioner, nor any order with regard
to his appointment as a Confidential Sainik passed by any of the authorities
is made available and when his initial appointment itself was bad in law
conferral of appointment on the post of Home Guard Volunteer Sainik was
also not legally sustainable, therefore, has rightly been set aside. It was
also contended that the post of Confidential Sainik since does not come
under the regular establishment of police or Home Guard and the posts of
said confidential Sainik were created vide order dated 31.05.2005, due to
the dacoity problems and as service of Confidential Sainiks are also not
entitled for any pension and are only entitled for honorarium, the
recommendation made by Superintendent of Police for their appointment
as a regular Home Guard Volunteer Sainik was itself per se illegal,
therefore, the impugned order cannot be said to be illegal and the petitioner
being devoid of any substance is liable to be dismissed.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
8.
For analyzing the controversy this Court deems it necessary to quote
certain rules which may be relevant. Rule 6 of M.P. Home Guard Rules,
2016, which provides for nomination of Home Guards Volunteers in
different ranks is quoted herein below:
6.
Nomination of Home Guard Volunteers in clifrerent ranks:Subject to the directions issued by the State· Government, the
volunteers may be nominated to other ranks in the following manner:(a) Volunteer Company Commander - by the Inspector General;
(b) Volunteer Platoon Commander, Volunteer Assistant Platoon
Commander - by the Deputy Inspector General and Additional
Commandant General;
(c) Volunteer Nayak, Volunteer Hawaldar - by .the Divisional
Commandant;
(d) Volunteer Sainik, Volunteer Lance Nayak - by the District
Commandant;
The total sanctioned strength· of Home Guard Volunteers per
company in all the Districts of Madhya Pradesh shall be 165. The
number of Volunteers per company shall be as follows:Details of Determinate Number of Volunteers per Company
Designation
Number
Nomination Volunteer Company Commander
Nomination Volunteer Platoon Commander
Nomination Volunteer Assistant Platoon Commander
Nomination Volunteer Company Hawaldar Major
Nomination Volunteer Company Quarter Master
Nomination VolunteerSection Hawaldar
Nomination Volunteer Section Nayak/ Section Lance
Nayak
Home Guard Volunteers
Total
9.
Further Rule 8 of M.P. Home Guard Rules, 2016, which provides for
enrollment as a Home Guard Volunteer is also quoted herein below:7.
8. Enrolment as a Home Guard Volunteer:- No person shall
be enrolled as a volunteer of Home Guards:
8.
(a) Unless he has completed the age of 18 years but has not
completed the age of 28 years as on 1st August of the year of the
enrolment:
9.
Provided that if the candidate is a member of Scheduled Cast/
Scheduled Tribe or other backward classes, he shall be entitled to a
maximum of 5 years relaxation in the upper age limit:
10.
Provided further that a candidate, who is a permanent
Government servant should not completed the age of 38 years.
11.
(b) Unless he is not a citizen of India and the resident of the
district "in which is seeking ·enrolment and the .domicile of Madhya ·
Pradesh. He shall have to submit a domicile certificate to this effect
issued by Competent Authority.
12.
(c) Unless he has passed 10th standard examination from
Maqhya Pradesh Board or from a school situated in Madhya Pradesh
which has affiliation to a Central Board:
13.
Provided that a candidate of the scheduled tribe shall be eligible
if he has passed 8th standard.
14.
(d) Unless he possesses good moral character as per extant
instructions of the Government of Madhya Pradesh:
15.
Provided that the State Government may, for the confidential
work relating to internal security, relax the eligibility conditions and
home guards may be enrolled accordingly for period and in number to
be specified by the State Government. Evecy effort shall be made to
keep the identity of the home guards so appointed confidential.
10.
Rule 8 sub rule (d) proviso gives powers to the State Government to
relax the eligibility conditions for a person to be appointed for confidential
work relating to internal security and in that regard Home Guards may be
enrolled accordingly for the period and number to be specified by the
State Government. In that context, since Gwalior and Chambal Division
were notified as dacoity affected areas under Section 3 of the M.P. Dacoity
and Vyavharan Prabhavit Kshetra Adhiniyam, 1981, vide order dated
10.04.2000 rights were given to the District Superintendents of Police to
appoint Confidential Sainiks and to pay them the honorarium etc. with a
further stipulation that any decision regarding relaxation in the educational
qualification/height/ age could be taken by the Range Inspector General of
Police and in pursuance to the aforesaid order vide order dated 31.05.2005,
20 posts were created in the dacoity inflicted areas and thereafter it appears
that the petitioner was appointed as a Confidential Sainik in the year 2012
and since then the petitioner was working in the office of Superintendent
of Police as a Computer Operator/Confidential Sainik. On 27.07.2018, the
Director General of Police, Home Guard nominated the petitioner
temporarily on the post of Home Guard Volunteer Sainik, which appears to
be in consonance with the Rule 6 of the Rules of 2016, thereafter, vide
order dated 01.09.2018 the services of the petitioner were inducted in the
Home Guard and he was given Batch No.424, the entire process of
induction of the petitioner as a Home Guard Volunteer Sainik was after due
verification of educational qualification as well as his medical fitness.
11.
According to this Court, the nomination of the petitioner on the post
of Home Guard Volunteer Sainik appears to be done under legal umbrella
of rule 6 of the Rules of 2016. This aspect appears to have not been
considered by the Director General Home Guard while passing the order
dated 28.09.2021 (Annexure P/1). It also appears that under the dictate of
Home Department the said order has been passed, though the
correspondence of the Home Department does not in mandatory form had
made it compulsory for the Director General of Police, Home Guards to
remove the petitioner, rather had directed him to take a legal recourse but
the Director General of Police treating it to be a command without
applying its mind and without taking any legal recourse, without following
principles of natural justice and without giving any opportunity of hearing
to the petitioner had passed the impugned order which according to this
Court is not sustainable. In all the judgments cited by the counsel for the
petitioner the Hon'ble Apex Court as well as this Court had reiterated the
fact that the principle of audi alteram partem is required to be followed
whenever there is any civil consequences or prejudice is caused by any
administrative action or even in the cases of invalid appointments though
here in this Court has found that appointment of the petitioner was not
invalid.
12.
Thus, this Court while quashing the order dated 28.09.2021
(Annexure P/1) relegates the matter back to the Director General of Police
to take a fresh decision in the matter after giving opportunity of hearing to
the petitioner and without getting influenced by the order dated 27.09.2021
(Annexure P/2). Let this exercise be completed within a period of three
months from today. In the meanwhile, it is directed that the petitioner shall
be allowed to work as a Confidential Sainik at the place where he was
earlier working.
13.
It is further directed that for the intervening period between the
impugned order and this order the Director General of Police may take
decision with regard emoluments which had to be paid to the petitioner.
14.
With the aforesaid direction, the present petition stands allowed and
disposed of.
E-copy/certified copy as per rules/directions.
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
neetu
NEETU
SHAS
HANK
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR,
ou=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=36b486bb0d381b950e435e
c09e066bc6b58cb947c1474b7dc349
a1cf27eaa2ce, postalCode=474001,
st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=E60A9BBFC39E0EE500
EAADE1E0B3B8565CB3A7DC9F5CD0
48197DF0FF3149AE58, cn=NEETU
SHASHANK
Date: 2024.01.25 13:10:22 -08'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review