Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC010235992019
2026:GAU-AS:1049-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.A./176/2021
SANKAR NARAYAN NANDI
S/O- SUBHENDRA NARAYAN NANDI,
R/O- QTR. NO. 180B, GOSALA,
P.S.- JALUKBARI, DIST- KAMRUP(M).
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY PP, ASSAM.
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MD. A H LASKAR, MR D J HALOI,MR. S A HUSSAIN,MR S DAS
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM,
–B E F O R E –
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
For the Appellant(s)
: Md. A H Laskar, Mr. S Das,
Mr. S A Hussain, Mr. D J Haloi,
Advocates.
For the Respondent(s)
: Ms. A Begum, APP, Assam.
Date on which judgment is reserved : 06.01.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 30.01.2026
Page No.# 2/15
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment ?
:
N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
:
Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(M. Zothankhuma, J)
Heard Mr. S Das, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Ms. A Begum,
learned Additional Public Prosecutor, Assam for the State.
2.
This appeal has been filed against the impugned judgment dated
13.07.2018 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Kamrup (Metro), Guwahati in
Sessions Case No. 342/2016, by which the appellant has been convicted under
Section 302 IPC for killing his mother with a sharp edged weapon ( Bothi Dao)
which is used for cutting vegetables, fish etc.
3.
The appellant’s counsel submits that the appellant’s challenge to the
impugned judgment is firstly on the ground that the appellant did not kill his
mother and in this respect, he has relied upon the explanation/answers given by
the appellant in his examination under Section 313 CrPC to question numbers
11, 12 & 15. The alternative challenge made by the appellant to the impugned
judgment is that, even though the evidence of PWs- 5 & 7 appears to prove the
fact that the appellant had killed his mother, the conviction of the appellant
could not have been done under Section 302 IPC, inasmuch as, there was no
premeditation and/or intention to kill his mother. The act of killing his mother
had been made due to a grave and sudden provocation under the influence of
Page No.# 3/15
alcohol and as Exception-4 to Section 300 IPC was attracted to the facts of the
case, the charge under Section 302 IPC should be altered to Section 304 Part-II
IPC, as at best, the conviction could only have been made under Section 304
Part-II IPC. He thus submits that when the evidence shows that the death of
the mother was due to a grave and sudden provocation, which resulted in a
fight between the appellant and PW-7 (brother of the deceased), resulting in
the death of the mother, the complete chain of events could have only led to the
conviction of the appellant under Section 304 Part-II and not under Section 302
IPC.
4.
In support of his submission that the appellant could not be said to be a
reasonable person in the ordinary sense of the term as he was intoxicated,
thereby attracting Exception-4 to Section 300 IPC, he has relied upon the
Division Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Nipam Phukan @ Petai
-Vs- State of Assam (Criminal Appeal (J) No. 91/2019), wherein at Para-46 it
has been held as follows –
“46. As has been held by the Supreme Court, the test to be applied to see as to
whether the sudden provocation on the part of the deceased to the appellant, was
grave or not, is whether a reasonable man would likely to lose self-control as a
result of the sudden provocation. In the present case, the admonition and
reprimand given by the deceased to the appellants, who were under the influence
of liquor, not to create nuisance on the road and to go home, was sudden and
unexpected. The appellants were not expecting such a sudden and unexpected
admonition/reprimand. Besides, the appellants being apparently under the
influence of liquor, they could not be said to be reasonable persons in the ordinary
sense of the term, as there is a vast difference between an intoxicated person and
a person who is not under the influence of liquor. Though a reasonable person may
not lose self-control as a result of such provocation, it would not be unexpected for
a person under the influence of liquor, to regard and react to the said provocation
as a grave provocation.”
Page No.# 4/15
The appellant’s counsel submits that the appellant being under intoxication,
the appellant could not be said to be a reasonable person, who would be able to
act and behave as an intoxication free reasonable person. He submits that there
is always a difference in the behavior of a person who is intoxication free vis-avis a person who under the influence of alcohol. As such, while a reasonable
person may not lose self-control easily when provoked, the same may not be
true for a person under intoxication.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the Supreme Court
in the case of Vijay @ Vijaykumar -Vs- Stateof T.N., reported in (2025) 3
SCC 671 has laid the test to decide whether sudden provocation was grave or
not, which is, if a reasonable man would likely lose self-control as a result of the
said provocation. He submits that Para 22.2, 22.3 and 23 of the said judgment
has clearly provided the objective test to be applied for deciding the said issue.
Para 22.2, 22.3 and 23 of Vijay @ Vijaykumar (supra) is as follows:“22.2. The main difficulty lies in deciding whether a certain provocation was grave
or not. A bare statement by the accused that he regarded the provocation as grave
will not be accepted by the court. The court has to apply an objective test for
deciding whether the provocation was grave or not. A good test for deciding
whether a certain provocation was grave or not is this:“Is a reasonable man likely
to lose self-control as a result of such provocation?” If the answer is in the
affirmative, the provocation will be classed as grave. If the answer is in the
negative, the provocation is not grave. In this context, the expression “reasonable
man” means a normal or an average person. A reasonable man is not the ideal
man or the perfect being. A normal man sometimes loses temper. There is,
therefore no inconsistency in saying that, a reasonable man may lose self-control
as a result of grave provocation. A reasonable or normal or average man is a legal
fiction. The reasonable man will vary from society to society. A Judge should not
impose his personal standards in this matter. By training, a Judge is a patient man.
But the reasonable man or the normal man need not have the same standard of
behaviour as the Judge himself. The reasonable man under consideration is a
Page No.# 5/15
member of the society, in which the accused was living. So, education and social
conditions of the accused are relevant factors. An ordinary exchange of abuse is a
matter of common occurrence. A reasonable man does not lose self-control merely
on account of an ordinary exchange of abuses. So, courts do not treat an ordinary
exchange of abuses as a basis for grave provocation. On the other hand, in most
societies, adultery is looked upon as a very serious matter. So, courts are prepared
to treat adultery as a basis for grave provocation.
22.3. The question of loss of self-control comes up indirectly in deciding whether a
particular provocation was grave or not. So, if it is proved that the accused did
receive grave and sudden provocation, the court is generally prepared to assume
that homicide was committed while the accused was deprived of the power of selfcontrol. In some cases, it may be possible for the prosecution to prove that the
accused committed the murder with a cool head in spite of grave provocation. But
such cases will be rare. So, when the accused has established grave and sudden
provocation, the court will generally hold that he has discharged the burden that
lay upon him under Exception 1 to Section 300IPC.
23. What should be the approach of the court? The provocation must be such as
will upset not merely a hasty and hot-tempered or hypersensitive person, but one
of ordinary sense and calmness. The court has to consider whether a reasonable
person placed in the same position as accused would have behaved in the manner
in which the accused behaved on receiving the same provocation. If it appears that
the action of the accused was out of all proportion to the gravity or magnitude of
the provocation offered, the case will not fall under the exception. The case can
only fall under the exception when the court is able to hold that provided the
alleged provocation is given, every normal person would behave or act in the same
way as the accused in the circumstances in which the accused was placed, acted.”
6.
The learned counsel for the appellant submits that in the present case, PW-
7 had admonished the appellant for allegedly abusing his mother as she had
given him only Rs. 30/-, which led to blows being traded between the appellant
and PW-7, wherein the deceased mother had thereafter given two slaps to the
appellant. The provocation and the fight between PW-7 and the deceased was
grave, for which Exception-4 to Section 300 would be attracted. He thus submits
Page No.# 6/15
that the impugned judgment should be set aside and the appellant should either
be acquitted of the charge under Section 302 IPC or in the worst case scenario,
should be convicted under Section 304 Part-II IPC.
7.
Ms. A Begum, learned APP, Assam on the other hand, submits that PW-5 is
the eye witness to his son, the appellant, killing his mother with a Bothi
Dao,which nearly severed the neck of the deceased. She submits that when
there is an eye witness to the crime in question, the stand of the appellant that
he had not committed the crime is patently false. Further, in the case of Veer
Singh & Others -Vs- State of Uttar Pradesh, reported in (2014) 2 SCC
455, the Supreme Court has held that it is not the number of witnesses, but the
quality of the evidence of the witnesses which is important and there is no
requirement under the law of evidence that any particular number of witness is
to be examined to prove or disprove a fact. The evidence must be weighed and
not counted. Further, as a general rule, a Court can act on the testimony of a
single witness provided it is wholly reliable. In the present case, when there is a
eye-witness to the killing of the deceased by her son, i.e., the evidence of the
eye witness father and read with the evidence of the maternal uncle of the
appellant (PW-7), the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 IPC suffers
from no infirmity.
8.
Learned APP, Assam further submits that Exception-4 to Section 300 IPC is
not attracted to the facts of the present case, inasmuch as, the provocation had
been initiated on the part of the appellant and not by the deceased or by the
maternal uncle (PW-7). Further, the alleged retaliation by the appellant, nearly
severing the neck of the deceased in response to the deceased mother slapping
the appellant twice, when the appellant and the maternal uncle were fighting,
does not attract Exception-4 to Section 300 IPC. She accordingly submits that
Page No.# 7/15
the impugned judgment of the learned Trial Court should not be interfered with.
9.
We have heard the learned counsels for the parties and also perused the
materials available on record.
10. The brief facts of the case is that on the fateful day, i.e., 16.03.2016, the
appellant had taken money from his mother (deceased) and had gone out from
the house. He later came back after consuming liquor and demanded money
from the deceased (mother). The appellant was given 30 rupees by the
deceased. As the appellant was not satisfied with the amount of money given to
him, he started abusing his mother (deceased).
11. The brother of the deceased, who was also in the house at the relevant
point of time, objected to the appellant abusing his sister, the deceased. A
quarrel ensued between the appellant and PW-7, which apparently ended with
the appellant and PW-7 assaulting each other. The assault by the appellant on
PW-7 was objected by the deceased, which led to the deceased slapping the
appellant twice. Thereafter, PW-7 left the residence of the deceased. However,
the appellant picked up a Bothi Dao (a sharp weapon) and hacked the neck of
the deceased, due to which the neck of the deceased was nearly severed.
12. The eye witness who saw the appellant hacking the neck of his mother
with the Bothi Dao is PW-5, is the father of the appellant. PW-5 in his evidence
stated that the appellant (son) demanded money from his mother. His wife then
gave Rs.30 to the appellant. However being not satisfied, the appellant started
abusing his mother. PW-7, who was also present, objected to the appellant
abusing the deceased. A quarrel ensued, due to which the appellant tried to
assault PW-7. As the deceased objected to the appellant trying to assault PW-7,
PW-7 left the place. However, the appellant picked up a Bothi Dao and struck
Page No.# 8/15
the neck of his mother. The appellant then fled with the Bothi Dao in his hand.
13. The evidence of PW-7 is to the effect that the appellant took the money
from his sister and went out. He came back again after consuming liquor and
demanded money from his sister. A quarrel ensued, due to which the appellant
started abusing the sister of PW-7. PW-7 thereafter scolded the appellant and
told him not to abuse his mother. The appellant became enraged and pushed
PW-7 to a nearby bed and pressed his neck. PW-7’s sister thereafter rushed at
the appellant and slapped him twice. The appellant then went inside a room.
PW-5 and the deceased followed the appellant, while PW-7 came out of the
house. The appellant then came out with a Bothi Daoin his hands, while PW-7
was working with a dao in the garden. On coming out, the appellant took the
dao from PW-7 and left. PW-7 then entered the house and saw his sister lying
dead with a cut injury on her neck. Though PW-5 told PW-7 to take his sister to
the hospital, he saw that she had died. The police were thereafter informed.
The police thereafter saw the appellant standing on the road with the Bothi Dao
and the dao which he had taken from PW-7.
14. The evidence given by the Doctor (PW-2) is to the effect that he examined
the deceased on 13.03.2016 and found the following:“There was a chop wound of size 12cm x 7cm x spinal cord deep present on
right postero lateral aspect of neck, transversely, the anterior end being 5 cm
lateral to the midline and 6cm above the clavicle. Skin, muscles, vessels, nerves,
spinous process of 6th cervical vertebrae, body of 7th cervical vertebrae and
spinal cord inside the 7th cervical vertebrae all were cut at this level. The
wound was deeper at posterior aspect. Margins were sharp, contused at places
and blood clots were adherent to the margins which resist washing.
On Internal examination-
Page No.# 9/15
On opening the body cavities, skull and scalp were healthy. Vertebrae is already
described. Membranes of brain were pale. Brain was pale, Spinal cord is already
described. Thoraxic walls were healthy. Pleurae, right lung, left lung, larynx and
trachea and pericardium were pale. Heart was healthy and chambers were
empty. Vessels were healthy.
On abdomen- wall was healthy, peritoneum, esophagial mucosa, stomach
mucosa and small intestine mucosa were pale. Stomach cavity contained semi
solid food particles. Small intestine contained semi digested food particles.
Large intestine contained gases and fecal matter. Liver, kidneys and bladder
were pale. Bladder contained normal colour urine.
External and internal organs of generation were healthy.
OpinionDeath was instantaneous following injury sustained over the spinal cord as
described. Injury was ante mortem caused by sharp edged heavy weapon and
was homicidal in nature. Approx. time since death was 2-8 hrs.
The injuries described in the PM report are sufficient to cause death in the
ordinary course of nature. Ext. 1 is my report and Ext. 1(1) is my signature.”
15. In his examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C, the appellant has denied the
evidence recorded by the learned Trial Court, with regard to PW-7 scolding him
and the deceased slapping the appellant, besides the evidence of the appellant
coming out from the house with a Bothi Dao and taking a dao from PW-7.
Further, he has taken the stand that PW-7 was the culprit and not the appellant,
as he has stated in his explanation to question No.15 as follows:“Q. No.15. What do you have to say regarding this case against you?
Ans: When the occurrence took place, my father was not there. My maternal uncle
was also armed with dao. My mother suddenly entered in between us and she
received the injury, on being caused by my maternal uncle. I was innocent. I told
police about the real incident but nobody believed me.”
Page No.# 10/15
16. The explanation by the appellant to the evidence adduced against him that
he had killed his mother, is to the effect that at the time of occurrence, his
father (PW-5) was not present and that his maternal uncle (PW-7) had killed his
mother. The said explanation given by the appellant is not supported by any
corroborating evidence and neither has the appellant made himself a witness, to
prove that it was PW-7 who had killed the deceased and not the appellant.
Further, the same is not in consonance with evidence of his eye witness father,
who saw the appellant striking the deceased.
17. On considering the fact that the appellant has taken a stand that he was
intoxicated and could not be said to be a reasonable person at the time of the
incident, we do not have any reason to believe the explanation given by the
appellant that he was not the perpetrator of the crime, on the basis of the
explanation given by him under Section 313 Cr.P.C to question No.15. In fact,
the answers given by the appellant to question Nos.2, 4 & 5 implies that the
appellant had killed his mother. The question Nos.2, 4 & 5 and the answers
given to the same by the appellant, in his examination under Section 313
Cr.P.C., are as follows:“Q.No.2.
PW1 Sri. Khagen Ch. Deka testified that deceased Gita Nandi used
to reside in front of his Railway quarter at Gosala. He also added that in the
year 2016, one morning he heard some hullah in the house of the deceased
and after going there he saw a lady in a pool of blood inside the room and
came to hear that you had killed her? What is your reply?
Ans: May be true.
Q.No.4.
PW3 Tonmoy Chatterjee testified that he knows the informant
Subhendra Narayan Nandi and the deceased Gita Rani Nandi, died in 2016. He
also testified that he used to reside at the adjacent quarter of informant and on
the relevant day, he was in his shop at Maligaon Chariali. He deposed that after
he heard, that the incident had taken place near his quarter, he rushed there
Page No.# 11/15
and saw that there was a large gathering in front of the quarter of Subhendra
Narayan Nandi. Police was also there. He further added that on going inside the
quarter, he saw that Gita Rani Nandi was lying on the floor in a pool of blood.
Her neck was almost severed and heard that you had committed the murder.
What is your reply?
Ans: May be true.
Q.No.5.
PW4 Santana Dey (Bhattacharjee) testified that Subhendra Narayan
Nandi was her maternal uncle and deceased Gita Rani Nandi was her maternal
aunt. She stated that you are her cousin. She testified that in 2016, after
getting the information of her death, she rushed to the residence of Subhendra
Narayan Nandi and saw the dead body of Gita Rani Nandi in a pool of blood on
the floor of the house. She further deposed that there was cut injury at her
neck and later on, she came to know that you had committed the murder. What
is your reply?
Ans: True.”
18. There is nothing in the evidence to show that the father of the appellant
had any reason to fabricate a story, to the effect that the appellant had killed his
mother. In fact, we find the testimony of the father (PW-5) to be trustworthy
and it inspires the confidence of the Court. This is not only due to the fact that
no reason has been given by the appellant as to why PW-5 should tell a lie, but
also due to the fact that the testimony of PW-5 is corroborated by the testimony
of PW-7. PW-5 being a reliable eyewitness to the crime in question, we do not
accept the attempt made by the appellant, to pin the death of the deceased at
the hands of PW-7, especially when the evidence of PW-8, who is a Policeman,
In-charge of the Gosala Police Outpost, had stated that while he was on his way
to the place of occurrence, he saw the appellant with the Bothi Daoin his hands,
as the appellant was going to the Gosala Police Outpost to surrender. PW-8 had
further stated that he not only seized the Bothi Daofrom the possession of the
Page No.# 12/15
deceased, but also seized another dao produced by the inmates of the house of
the deceased.
19. We are, thus, of the view that it was only the appellant who had killed his
mother with the Bothi Dao and nobody else. The above being said, the only
other issue that has to be looked into, is as to whether the appellant was
correctly convicted under Section 302 IPC and whether the case could have
attracted Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC. If Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC is
attracted, we would have to see whether the conviction of the appellant would
have to be done under Section 304 Part-I or Part-II IPC.
20. In the case of Ajmal vs. State of Kerala, reported in (2022) 9 SCC
766, the Supreme Court referred to the judgment in the Pulicherla Nagaraju
vs. State of A.P, reported in (2006) 11 SCC 444, wherein it was held that to
decide whether a case falls under Section 302 IPC or 304 Part-I or 304 Part-II,
the intention has to be seen and the intention to cause death has to be
gathered from a combination of a few or several more circumstances, which are
not exhaustive but which include (i) nature of the weapon used; (ii) whether the
weapon was carried by the accused or was picked up from the spot; (iii)
whether the blow is aimed at a vital part of the body;(iv) the amount of force
employed in causing injury; (v) whether the act was in the course of sudden
quarrel or sudden fight or free for all fight; (vi) whether the incident occurred by
chance or whether there was any premeditation; (vii) whether there was any
prior enmity or whether the deceased was a stranger;(viii) whether there was
any grave and sudden provocation, and if so, the cause for such provocation;
(ix) whether it was in the heat of passion; (x) whether the person inflicting the
injury has taken undue advantage or has acted in a cruel and unusual manner;
Page No.# 13/15
(xi) whether the accused dealt a single blow or several blows. The above list of
circumstances is, of course, not exhaustive and there may be several other
special circumstances with reference to individual cases which may throw light
on the question of intention.
21. In the case of Gurmail Singh and Another vs. State of UP and
Another, reported in (2022) 10 SCC 684, the Supreme Court has held that in
order to make culpable homicide as murder, the act by which death is caused
should fall not only under anyone or more of the Clauses firstly to fourthly under
Section 300 IPC, but they should also not fall under any of the 5 Exceptions to
Section 300 IPC.
22. In the case of Nipam Phukan (supra), this Court was dealing with an
appeal arising out of a conviction of the appellant therein under Section 302/34
IPC, for having slapped a person who had provoked the intoxicated
accused/appellant standing on the street. The provocation had been made by
the deceased who had come out from his house and admonished the
intoxicated accused/appellant. It was in that context that this Court had held
that the accused/appellant, who was under intoxication and took offence to the
admonishment, could not be said to be a reasonable person, vis-a-vis a
reasonable person free of intoxication. This was due to the fact that there was a
difference between an intoxicated person and a person not under the influence
of liquor. The reaction to a provocation by a person under intoxication and by a
person who is not under intoxication would be different, inasmuch as, a person
under the influence of liquor was likely to lose his power of self-control more
easily than a person not under intoxication. It was in that context where this
Court had held that the accused/appellant therein was subjected to a grave and
sudden provocation by the deceased in a public place/street, besides being a
Page No.# 14/15
stranger to the accused/appellant. On the other hand, the appellant and the
deceased herein are no strangers to each other. In fact, the appellant is the son
of the deceased mother. The incident also occurred inside the house of the
deceased. The provocation was also initiated by the appellant, when he started
abusing his mother for giving him only Rs. 30/-. The fight had ensued between
the appellant and PW-7 and not with the mother. Just because the mother
apparently gave two slaps to the appellant, who was fighting his uncle (PW-7),
does not lead us to believe that there was any provocation initiated by the
deceased against the appellant, nor did the deceased fight the appellant. The
factual situation in this case is different from the fact situation in Nipam
Phukan (supra) and as such, we are of the view that the decision in Nipam
Phukan (supra) is not applicable to this case. A decision is only an authority
for what it decides. A little difference in facts changes the precedential value of
a decision. Thus, in our opinion, Exception-I and IV to Section 300 IPC do not
appear to be attracted to the facts of this case.
23. On considering the fact that the appellant had used a Bothi Dao on a vital
part of the body of his mother (neck), which nearly severed the neck/head of
the victim, goes to show that a huge amount of force had been deployed by the
appellant. Though there may not have been any pre-meditation in the killing of
the deceased by the appellant, the weapon used with great force on the neck of
the deceased leads us to the conclusion that there was a sudden intention on
the part of the appellant to kill the deceased.
24. Though the Supreme Court in the case of Vijay @ Vijaykumar (supra)
has held that when an accused has generally established grave and sudden
provocation, which would attract Exception-1 to Section 300 IPC, the
provocation in this case has been made on the part of the appellant. Further, for
Page No.# 15/15
attracting Exception-4 to Section 300 IPC, the quarrel has to lead to a fight
between the parties. In the present case, there being no fight between the
appellant and his mother, we are of the view that Exception-4 to Section 300 is
not attracted to the facts of this case.
25. In view of the reason stated above, we do not find any ground to interfere
with the impugned judgment of the learned Trial Court.
26. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.
27. Send back the LCR.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Pranab
Kumar
Deka
Digitally signed
by Pranab
Kumar Deka
Date:
2026.01.30
11:37:49 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review