Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/30
GAHC040011652025
2026:GAU-AP:1145-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRL.A(J)/14/2025
Passang Saidu
Son of Shri Kesang Wangdi Saidu, resident of Village Khoina, PO and PS Nafra, West
Kameng District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP
represented by the PP of AP
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Legal Aid Counsel, Jaya Doji
Advocate for the Respondent : P P of AP,
Linked Case : CRL.A(J)/16/2025
Sang Dorjee Khasidu
Age: 26
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Atok Khasidu
resident of Village Khoina
PO and PS Nafra
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP
Age: 0
Occupation :
Page No.# 2/30
Address:represented by the PP of AP
-----------Advocate for : Legal Aid Counsel
Advocate for : P P of AP appearing for The State of AP: Advocate appearing for
respectively.
Linked Case : CRL.A(J)/15/2025
Tsering Dondu Saidu
Age: 20
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Dorjee Saidu
resident of Village Khoina
PO and PS Nafra
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the PP of AP
-----------Advocate for : Legal Aid Counsel
Advocate for : P P of AP appearing for The State of AP: Advocate appearing for
respectively.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE YARENJUNGLA LONGKUMER
Advocate for the Appellant : Ms. Jaya Doji (Legal Aid counsel)
Advocate for the Respondents
: Mr. D. Loyi, P.P (AP)
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 05.11.2026
Page No.# 3/30
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:12.11.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
: No
the Operative part of the judgment ?
Whether full judgment has been
: Yes
pronounced ?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Date : 12-11-2026
(Y. Longkumer,J)
Heard the learned Legal Aid counsel Ms. Jaya Doji for the appellants.
Also heard learned P.P. Mr. D. Loyi for the State respondents.
2.
This is an appeal filed by the appellants from Jail against the
judgment and order dated 22.03.2024 passed by the Court of Sessions
Judge, West Kameng, East Kameng and Tawang, Arunachal Pradesh
convicting the appellants in Sessions Case No.13/2023 under sections
302/201/34 IPC read with section 25(IB) of the Arms Act whereby they have
been sentenced to life imprisonment with fine of Rs.20,000/- for the offence
under section 302 IPC read with section 34 IPC. Further they have been
sentenced to RI for seven years with fine of Rs.5000/- for the offence under
section 201 IPC and further sentenced to two years SI with fine of Rs.5000/for the offence under section 25 (IB) of the Arms Act with a default clause.
All the sentences have been directed to run concurrently.
3.
The prosecution case is that on 13.04.2023 a written FIR was
received from Shri Sange Tsering the O.C of Nafra P.S to the effect that
while investigating a missing report received on 09.04.2023 in respect of one
Page No.# 4/30
Gajabu Napudu, it was learnt that the missing person was last seen on a
motor bike with accused Sang Dorjee Kasidu on 06.04.2023. The accused
Sang Dorjee Kasidu was summoned to the Police station on 12.04.2023 and
interrogated. During interrogation it was revealed that the accused Passang
Siadu and accused Tsering Dondu Siadu had stopped accused Sang Dorjee
Kasidu and the deceased when they were coming back from Bomdila on
06.04.2023 at Rahung Nalah and the deceased was hit by a wooden stick
where he instantly fell down. His body was loaded into a red Maruti Car
bearing registration No.AS-01-AJ-3337 and the three accused drove away
towards Munna camp with the dead body.
4.
On receipt of the FIR dated 13.04.2023, a case was registered
being Dirang P.S Case No.8/2023 under section 302/120B/201/34 IPC and
investigation was initiated. Having found prima facie case against the
appellants, the I.O submitted charge-sheet against all the appellants under
section 302/120B/201/34 IPC on 11.07.2023. Charges were framed against
all the appellants under section 302/120 B/201/34 IPCand Sec 25 (1B)/27(1)
Arms
Act
on
10.08.2023.
The
charges
were
read
over
to
the
accused/appellants and they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. The
case accordingly went up for trial.
5.
In order to bring home the charges against the appellant-
accused, the prosecution side examined 15 witnesses and exhibited
documents and material exhibits. The defense did not adduce any evidence.
6.
Upon examining the evidence available on record, the learned
Trial Court was of the view that the prosecution had succeeded in
establishing the case against the accused-appellants and had proved the
charges
brought
against
the
appellants-accused
under
section
Page No.# 5/30
302/120B/201/34 IPC and Sec 25 (1B) Arms Act beyond reasonable doubt
and accordingly convicted and sentenced the appellants.
7.
Assailing the impugned judgment and order dated 22.03.2024,
in Sessions Case No.13/2023, the learned Legal Aid counsel for the
appellants has submitted that the impugned conviction and sentence cannot
be sustained in view of the fact that there are several material
inconsistencies in the prosecution case.
8.
The first ground taken by the counsel for the appellants is that
in the seizure memo dated 13.04.2023, it is not indicated from which
accused the Maruti Car or the Honda Bike or the SBBL gun was seized. Even
the seizure memo of the mobile phones does not indicate from whom the
phones were seized. The seizure memo of one wooden stick measuring 30
inches long and one miji local dao measuring 21 inches also does not show
from which accused they were seized. It is the submission of the learned
counsel that the recovery of the dead body and also the seizure of the
wooden stick and local dao did not have any independent witnesses and
therefore they could not have been admissible in evidence.
9.
Another discrepancy which the learned Legal Aid counsel has
pointed out is that the dead body of the deceased was handed over for post
mortem examination on 13.04.2023 at 1050 hours. However, the disclosure
statements of the accused persons under section 27 of the Evidence Act
were recorded only at 1750 hours, 1800 hours and 1815 hours respectively
on 13.04.2023. The learned Trial Court has mainly relied on the disclosure
statements of the accused persons to arrive at the conviction. However, the
records reveal that the disclosure statements of the accused persons were
recorded only after the discovery of the dead body and therefore, the said
Page No.# 6/30
disclosure statements could not have been admissible in evidence.
10.
The learned Legal Aid counsel has submitted that the extra judicial
confession made by accused Sang Dorjee Kasidu before the village
authorities cannot be the basis of a conviction in respect of the co-accused
Passang Siadu and Tsering Dondu Siadu, at best it could be admissible only
against accused Sang Dorjee Kasidu.
11.
Another ground taken by the learned Legal Aid counsel is that
the evidence of PW 4/wife of accused Passang Siadu and that of PW 15/I.O
of the case has proved that there was no motive in the instant case. The
said PWs had deposed that the misunderstanding between accused Passang
Siadu and the deceased has been amicably settled and there was no enmity.
Another finding of the learned Trial Court was that the extra marital affair
between the deceased and accused Passang Siadu’s wife was the motive
behind the crime. However, this finding has also been negated by the
evidence of PW 4 and PW 15.
12.
Another finding of the learned Trial Court was that the CDR
records of the accused persons and that of the deceased shows that during
the time of the incident the tower location of the accused persons and that
of the deceased were the same which revealed that they were all together
at the P.O at the time of the incident. With regard to this finding, the learned
Legal Aid counsel submits that it is mandatory that a section 65B certificate
under the Evidence Act should accompany the CDR in order to make it
admissible as evidence. However, in the instant case there was no Section
65B certificate to make the electronic evidence/CDR admissible. The learned
Trial Court could not have therefore relied upon the CDR which was
produced by the prosecution.
Page No.# 7/30
13.
As regard the conviction under section 25(1B) of the Arms Act,
the learned Legal Aid counsel submits that the prosecution could not prove
that the seized SBBL gun was in the possession of the accused persons at
the time of the seizure. In the seizure memo there is no indication as to the
person from whom the gun was seized. In such a situation, the learned Trial
Court could not have convicted the accused persons under section 25 (1B)
of the Arms Act.
14.
The learned Legal Aid counsel further submits that the
prosecution has not been able to establish that there was a meeting of
minds and a common design between the accused persons in order to
sustain a conviction under Sec 120B IPC. Mere knowledge, association,
presence or suspicion of involvement is not sufficient. She submits that the
prosecution must establish a conscious agreement to pursue an illegal act or
a legal act by illegal means. However, in the instant case the prosecution has
not been able to show any common intention in respect of the accused
persons.
15.
Under the circumstances as stated above, the learned Legal Aid
counsel submits that the conviction and sentence imposed upon the
appellants cannot be sustained and the same should be interfered with by
this Court.
16.
In support of her submissions, the learned Legal Aid counsel
relies upon the following authorities: 1.
Pooranmal vs The State of Rajasthan &Anr reported in 2026
INSC 217
2.
Desh Deepak Kumar Vihangam @ Deepak Kumar vs The State
Page No.# 8/30
of Bihar reported in (2022) 7 SCC 721
17.
Mr. D. Loyi, learned Public Prosecutor on the other hand submits
that the inconsistencies pointed out by the learned Legal Aid counsel are
only minor in nature and does not go to the root of the matter.
18.
The learned Public Prosecutor submits that the challenge in the
appeal must be examined in the light of the entire evidence and not by
isolating individual circumstances from the chain proved by the prosecution.
The learned P.P. submits that the appellants have failed to disclose any
material infirmity warranting reversal of the conviction.
19.
It is submitted that the prosecution case rest on a chain of
circumstantial evidence when taken together points consistently towards the
guilt of the appellants and forms a complete chain excluding a reasonable
hypothesis of innocence. Learned P.P. submits that the circumstance of
motive; conspiracy and preparation; events leading to the occurrence; the
last seen theory; confession before the village elders; the disclosure and
recovery of material objects; and the CDRs viewed cumulatively supports the
conviction.
20.
The learned P.P. further submits that the extra judicial confession
made before the village elders is required to be evaluated in conjunction
with the other circumstances relied upon by the prosecution. In this regard,
the learned P.P. relies on the case of Siva Kumar vs State by Inspector
of Police, (2006) 1SCC 714, and the case of Laxman vs State of
Rajasthan reported in 1997 Supreme (Raj) 25, to support his contention
that an extra judicial confession may constitute reliable evidence of guilt
where it is voluntary, truthful, trustworthy and beyond reproach and that
Page No.# 9/30
corroboration is not required for every material particular. The essential
requirement is that the Court must be satisfied as to the genuineness and
reliability of the confession. The statement made before the village elders is
therefore voluntary and truthful and can be admissible in evidence.
21.
With regard to the contention of the appellants that the CDR cannot
be relied upon for want of certificate under section 65B of the Indian
Evidence Act, the learned P.P. submits that no objection was raised by the
appellants regarding the exhibition of the CDR during the trial. He submits
that an objection directed to a curable defect in the manner of proving a
document ought ordinarily to be raised when the document is tendered, so
that the party producing it has an opportunity to meet the objection. It is
submitted that the belated objection should not by itself displace the
conviction without an assessment of the admissibility issue and the other
evidence on record.
22.
In view of theabove submissions, the learned P.P would argue that
the Trial Court has rightly convicted the appellants by consideration of the
entire evidence on record and the grounds raised in the appeals do not
warrant interference with the impugned judgment of conviction.
23.
We have heard the submissions made by the learned counsel
for the rival parties and we have perused the trial court record. In order to
find out as to whether the impugned judgment and conviction can be
sustained or not, we will examine the evidence adduced by the prosecution
during the trial.
24.
PW 1 is the complainant and he is the O.C of Nafra PS. He
stated that on 09.04.2023 a missing person report was received at the Police
Page No.# 10/30
station. It was reported by one Asangbu Napudu that his elder brother
namely Gajabu Napudu was missing since 06.04.2023. Basing on the report
PW-1 initiated enquiry and visited Khoina village and came to know that the
deceased Gajabu Napudu had come from Bomdila with one Sang Dorjee
Kasadu on his Bike and thereafter he was not seen. He enquired from Sang
Dorjee Kasadu and he disclosed that he had brought the deceased from
Bomdila and dropped him at Khoina village. But he found that Sang Dorjee
Kasadu had lied to him and had not disclosed the real facts. He therefore
summoned him to the Police station on 12.04.2023 and during his
interrogation Sang Dorjee Kasadu disclosed that one Passang Saidu and
Tsering Dondu Siadu had killed the deceased at Rahung Nalah area. Sang
Dorjee Kasadu disclosed that they had taken the dead body in a Maruti Car
and disposed it near Munna camp.PW-1 arrested Passang Saidu and Tsering
Dondu Siadu from Saidel. As the place of occurrence was within the
jurisdiction of Dirang P.S, he prepared a report regarding the enquiry
conducted by him and submitted the same before the O.C of Dirang P.S in
the form of an FIR and also handed over the accused persons. He identified
all the accused person at the dock. PW-1 was not cross-examined.
25.
PW 2 deposed that the deceased person came from Shergaon
to his house on 04.04.2023 and stayed with him at Bomdila. The deceased
stayed in his house from 04.04.2023 to 05.04.2023. On the evening of
06.04.2023, Sang Dorjee Kasadu came to his residence and took away the
deceased on his Bike. After the deceased went with Sang Dorjee Kasadu, he
was not seen again. On 07.04.2023 he had a telephonic conversation with
the parents of the deceased who asked him about the deceased. He told
them that the deceased had gone with Sang Dorjee Kasadu on 06.04.2023.
Page No.# 11/30
PW 2 was not cross-examined.
26.
PW 3 is the brother of the deceased. He deposed that on
06.04.2023 there was a festival in their village Khoina. On the morning of
06.04.2023, his deceased brother called him from Bomdila and told him that
he will come to the village on 07.04.2023 with Sang Dorjee Kasadu to attend
the festival. In the evening also at around 5 PM his brother made a video
call to him and asked him as to what he needed for celebrating the festival.
His brother had purchased one pair of boots and socks for him and showed
him the same on the video call.His brother told him that he will be coming to
the village the same evening i.e. 06.04.2023 with Sang Dorjee on his
motorbike. He told his deceased brother to be careful as Sang Dorjee used
to consume liquor and does not know how to ride a bike properly. At about 8
PM his brother had not reached home and he repeatedly called him on his
mobile phone. Initially his phone was not reachable, then he found it busy
and after a while it was switched off. He then called Sang Dorjee Kasadu to
ask about the whereabout of his brother but he did not receive his calls. At
about 10.30 PM he came back home from the festival ground and found his
deceased brother’s bag in his room but his brother was not there. He again
went to the festival ground in search of his brother and Sang Dorjee but
they were not there. After searching for a while he returned home again but
his brother had not arrived till then. He thought that his brother might be
somewhere with Sang Dorjee. He called Sang Dorjee again and upon
receiving the call Sang Dorjee told him that they have reached the village
and that his brother had gone home. The next dayi.e.07.04.2023 he
searched for his brother in the village but he was not found and therefore he
informed the villagers and all the villagers searched for his brother all day
Page No.# 12/30
and night on 07.04.2023 but he was not found. Accordingly, on 08.04.2023
he lodged the missing person report at Nafra Police station. PW 3 further
deposed
that
during
enquiry
by
the
village
elders
Sang
Dorjee
Kasaduinformed them that when he was coming with the deceased on the
evening of 06.04.2023 on a motorcycle they saw Passang Siadu who was
waiting on the road as his Car was damaged. They stopped near Passang
Siadu and one person with his face covered assaulted the deceased with a
stick from behind. On being asked by the village elders as to why Sang
Dorjee did not try to save the deceased, he said that a gun was pointed at
him. Sang Dorjee also said that he brought the bag of the deceased to his
house in the village but the deceased was left behind. Thereafter Sang
Dorjee was taken to Nafra Police station. Later on,PW-3 came to know that
Sang Dorjee, Passang Siadu and Tsering Dondu Saidu had killed his brother.
PW 3 identified all the three accused persons at the dock as they are all
from the same village and he knows them since childhood. PW 3 also
deposed that prior to the incident of murder of his brother there was a
meeting of the village authorities for a dispute between Passang Siadu and
the deceased on the ground that Passang Siadu’s wife used to roam around
with the deceased. His deceased brother also came to attend the village
meeting where he was found innocent and Passang Siadu had to give a fine
of a traditional bowl to his brother as compensation for false allegation. He
came to know that Passang Saidu and the other accused persons had killed
his brother due to the said incident.
27.
PW 4 is the wife of accused Passang Siadu. She deposed that
she does not know anything about the case and does not know how
deceased GajabuNapududied and who killed him. She also stated that there
Page No.# 13/30
was a village meeting regarding an alleged illicit relationship between her
and the deceased but the dispute was amicably resolved. On 20.11.2022,
the deceased had called her over the phone and asked her to come to a
newly constructed BPL building near their house to sellhousie ticket for the
Chindang festival. She went to the building and when she entered the room
the deceased closed the door from inside. He was then writing on the housie
ticket to sell it, but during that time he saw Passang Siadu from the window
and then he jumped from the window and ran away. When she opened the
door her husband Passang Siadu was standing there and asked her as to
why the deceased had run away. She told him that the deceased had come
to sell housie ticket. On being cross-examined, PW 4 deposed that the
misunderstanding between her and her husband regarding relationship with
the deceased was amicably solved and there was no enmity.
28.
PW 5 is the owner of the Honda motor bike bearing registration
No.AR-04A-0832. He deposed that during the time of the incident there was
a festival at the village. As his father was serving at Itanagar he had come to
his village Khoina for doing social service on behalf of his father for
celebration of the festival. He kept his bike along with the key at his
residence at Khoina village. On 06.04.2023 at about 9:30 hours Sang Dorjee
Kasadu who is his cousin brother came and asked him for his bike to go to
Nafra. He gave him the bike and he returned back to Khoina at 1300 hours.
Thereafter he again asked for the bike to go to Salari for some work. On the
same day Sang Dorjee Kasadu went alone on his bike towards Salari. In the
evening at around 1935 hours he called Sang Dorjee Kasadu and enquired
about the bike but Sang Dorjee told him that he was reaching Salari and
disconnected the call saying that he was riding the bike. On 07.04.2023
Page No.# 14/30
Sang Dorjee Kasadu told him to come to his house and take back his
motorcycle. At around 1930 hours on 07.04.2023 he went to Sang Dorjee
Kasadu’s house and took back his motorcycle. He saw that the motorcycle
had some minor damages and it was parked outside the house of Passang
Saidu. In the evening of 07.04.2023, AsangbuNapudu came to the festival
ground and informed that his brother was missing since the evening of
06.04.2023 and requested the villagers to help him search for his brother.
Accordingly, all the villagers started searching for his deceased brother but
could not find him.PW 5 further deposed on 12.04.2023 Sang Dorjee Kasadu
narrated in the presence of village panchayat that Passang Saidu had
murdered the deceased and he was also present in the meeting. On being
cross-examined PW 5 reaffirmed that he had heard Sang Dorjee Kasadu
explaining about the incident before the village panchayat but he did not talk
about the entire incident.
29.
PW 6 is a seizure witness. He deposed that he accompanied the
I.O to the place of occurrence (P.O) and also to the residence of the accused
persons. He stated that one wooden stick and one white colour gunny bag
was recovered during the investigation. He also deposed that one Maruti Car,
one Honda bike, one local dao and one SBBL gun were seized from the
possession of the accused persons. PW 6 also deposed that the accused
Passang Siadu and Sang Dorjee Kasadu led the police team to the P.O for
recovery of the dead body and other materials. He identified the accused
persons at the dock and he also identified the wooden stick recovered from
the P.O, the local dao recovered from the residence of the accused persons
and the while colour gunny bag recovered from the P.O. In his crossexamination PW 6 stated that it is not mentioned in the seizure memo from
Page No.# 15/30
whose possession the Maruti Car, the Honda bike and SBBL gun were seized.
30.
PW 7 is also a seizure witness. He deposed that the SBBL gun
was recovered from the roadside of Khoina village in a hidden place which
was shown by Passang Siadu.The dao, motorbike and Maruti Car were
recovered from the residence of Passang Saidu. The wooden stick and white
colour gunny bag were recovered from the P.O from where the dead body
was recovered.PW 7 deposed that during recovery of the dead body and
materials from the P.O the accused Passang Siadu and Sang Dorjee Kasadu
led the Police team for the recovery. The PW 7 identified accused Passang
Siadu and Sang Dorjee at the dock. He also identified the wooded stick
which was recovered from the P.O, the local dao which was recovered from
the residence of Passang Siadu, the white colour gunny bag which was
recovered from the P.O, the seized Car and also the seized bike. In his crossexamination PW 7 stated that in the seizure memo it is not mentioned from
whose possession the materials were recovered.
31.
PW 8 is the gram chairperson of Khoina village. He deposed
that he knows all the accused person as they are all residents of Khoina
village. He stated that during the month of April there was afestival in the
village but during that time the deceased was found missing. The brother of
the deceased Asangbu informed him about the missing report at Nafra P.S.
On 10th and 11th April 2023, they had engaged the villagers to search for
the deceased but he was not found. Thereafter Sang Dorjee was asked
about the whereabout of the deceased person. In the public meeting Sang
DorjeeKasadu disclosed before them that he along with Passang Saidu and
Tsering Dondu Siaduhad killed the deceased . After this disclosure he asked
Sang Dorjee Kasadu to surrender before the Police as the village authorities
Page No.# 16/30
cannot resolve dispute relating to murder. In his cross-examination PW 8
stated that he has not seen the murder nor does he know with what kind of
weapon the deceased was killed. However, he had signed as a seizure
witness to the recovery of the arms license in his presence.
32.
PW 9 deposed that he knows the accused persons as they are
from his village. He stated that on 12.04.2023 there was a village meeting
where accused Sang Dorjee Kasidu was asked about the whereabouts of the
deceased as he had brought him from Bomdila before he went missing.
During the public meeting Sang Dorjee Kasidu disclosed before them that he
along with Passang Siadu and Tsering Dondu Siadu had killed the deceased
at 9th Mile area and they had taken away the dead body in a Car. After this
disclosure by Sang Dorjee Kasidu, he along with three other persons took
him to the Nafra PS for his safety and handed him over to the Police to avoid
untoward situation.
33.
PW 10 is another person from Khoina village. He deposed that
in the month of April 2023 there was a festival in their village but during that
time Gajabu Napudu was found missing and he along with other villagers
searched for him on 7th and 8th April 2023 but he was not found. On 12th
April there was a village meeting regarding the missing person wherein Sang
Dorjee Kasidu was asked about the whereabouts of GajabuNapudu as he
had brought him from Bomdila before he went missing. During the public
meeting Sang Dorjee Kasidu disclosed before them that he along with
Passang Saidu and Tsering Dondu Saidu had killed GajabuNapudu at 9 th Mile
area.After the disclosure of Sang DorjeeKasidu regarding the murder, he
along with three other persons took SangDorjee Kasidu to Nafra PS and
Page No.# 17/30
handed him over to the Police.
34.
PW 11 is another villager from Khoina village. He deposed that
he knows all the accused persons as they are from the same village. PW 11
deposed that on 12th April there was a village panchayat meeting regarding
the missing report of GajabuNapadu. Sang Dorjee Kasidu was asked about
the whereabouts of the missing person as he had brought him from Bomdila
before he went missing. During the meeting Sang Dorjee Kasidu disclosed
before them that he along with Passang Saidu and Tsering Dondu Siadu had
killed GajabuNapadu.After the disclosure, he along with three other villagers
took Sang Dorjee Kasidu to Nafra PS and handed him over to the Police. PW
11 also deposed that he was a seizure witness to the recovery of one
registration certificate of Honda motorcycle and one mobile handset. In the
cross-examination PW 11 stated that the seizures were made in the village
itself.
35.
PW 12 is also one of the Khoina villagers
. He deposed that
he knows all the accused persons as they are from his village. During the
month of April there was a festival in his village but during that time
GajabuNapudu was found missing. On 12th April there was a village
Panchayat meeting regarding the missing report where Sang Dorjee Kasidu
was asked about the whereabouts of the missing person as he had brought
him from Bomdila before he went missing. During the public meeting Sang
Dorjee Kasidu stated that he along with Passang Siadu and Tsering Dondu
Siadu had killed Gajabu Napudu. After the disclosure by Sang Dorjee Kasidu,
he along with three other villagers took him to the Nafra Police station and
handed him over to the police.
Page No.# 18/30
36.
PW 13 is also from Khoina village and he knows all the accused
persons. He deposed that in the month of April there was a village
panchayat meeting regarding missing of GajabuNapadu. During the public
meeting Sang Dorjee Kasidu disclosed that he along with Passang Saidu and
Tsering Dondu Siadu had killed the deceased . He further deposed that the
arms license was seized in his presence at their village itself.
37.
PW 14 is the Doctor/M.O who conducted the post mortem
examination. In her examination-in-chief PW 14 deposed that on 13.04.2023
she was posted at CHC Dirang as Medical Officer. On that day a requisition
was received from the I.O of the case praying for conducting postmortem
upon the body of Late GajabuNapudu,male, aged about 26 years, at around
10:50 AM. PW 14 deposed that the cause of death was due to spinal cord
injury and traumatic brain injury and the death was homicidal in nature. She
further stated that the injuries on the dead body areanti-mortem in nature
and the time of post mortem examination might be within 5 to 10 days from
the time of death as decomposition and liquefaction had already started. PW
14 also deposed that the injury suggested that blunt weapon was used for
causing the same.The wooden stick and the local dao were shown to PW 14
and she affirmed that the wooden stick can cause the injury which was
found on the dead body, and even the local dao can cause such injury if it is
used from the blunt side. In her cross-examination, the PW 14 stated that it
is a fact that basing on the nature of the injury, the injury might have been
caused by a blunt weapon.She stated that the injuries found on the body of
the deceased cannot be caused by a road traffic accident. She reiterated
that the wooden stick and local dao might have caused the injury on the
body and she has made the said assumption as per the nature of the injury.
Page No.# 19/30
38.
PW 15 is the I.O of the case. He deposed that on 13.04.2023 he
was posted at Dirang P.S as O.C. On that day a written FIR was received
from the O.C of Nafra PS. In the FIR, it was stated that the complainant had
received one missing report regarding one person namely GajabuNapudu
and during his enquiry regarding the missing report he had come to know
that one Sang Dorjee Kasidu was involved in the case and that during
interrogation of Sang Dorjee Kasidu, he had revealed that Passang Siadu
and Tsering Dondu Saidu had killedGajabuNapudu at the 9 th Mile area. It
was alleged in the FIR that when Sang Dorjee Kasidu was coming from
Bomdila with Gajabu Napudu, Passang Saidu and Tsering Dondu Saidu had
stopped them at Rahung Nula and they assaulted GajabuNapudu with a
wooden stick. GajabuNapudu fell down and his body was loaded into one
red Maruti Car bearing registration No.AS-01AJ-3337 and was taken towards
Munna camp. PW 15 stated that the three accused namely Sang Dorjee
Kasidu, Passang Siadu and Tsering Dondu Saidu were handed over to him by
the OC of Nafra PS as the incident had taken place within the jurisdiction of
Dirang P.S.
39.
PW 15 further stated that he had registered the Dirang P.S Case
No.8/2023
under
section
302/120B/201/34
IPC
and
started
the
investigation. He also deposed that he was shown the P.O by accused
Passang Siadu and Sang Dorjee Kasidu. They led him to the place where the
dead body was thrown by them. As per their lead and direction he
recovered the dead body from a deep gorge about 40 meters from the
road.The dead body was already in semi decomposed stage. He prepared a
rough sketch map of the P.O and also took photographs of the dead body
and the P.O. He examined the informant as well as other independent
Page No.# 20/30
witnesses and recorded their statements under section 161 Cr.PC. He also
conducted inquest over the dead body in the presence of relatives of the
deceased and the Executive Magistrate Dirang. During the inquest he found
injury mark on the head and the back side of the head . He also handed over
the dead body to the relative of the deceased after the post mortem. On
being led by Passang Siadu he recovered one wooden stick measuring about
30 inches from the P.O at Rahung Nala, and one 12 bore SBBL gun No.7781
from the jungle situated near the residence of Passang Saidu .He also
recovered one local dao measuring about 21 inches with handle from the
residence of Passang Saidu. He also seized one white gunny bag from the
P.O and it was disclosed that the same was used for packing the dead body.
One Honda bike bearing registration No.AR-04A-0832 was seized near the
residence of accused Passang Saidu as the said bike was used for bringing
GajubuNapudu from Bomdila. One Maruti 800 car bearing registration
No.AS-01AJ-3337 was seized from the possession of Passang Saidu who
disclosed that the Car was used for transporting the dead body from Rahung
Nala. After recovery of the above-mentioned materials the accused persons
were formally arrested and during their interrogation, they admitted that
they have murdered GajubuNapudu as he had illicit affairs with the wife of
Passang Saidu. It was found that during the commission of the offence one
SBBL gun belonging to WangjaMatadu was also used. Though the seized
arms license No.3701WKD dated 04.05.2000 was in the name of
WangjaMatadu with validity upto 31.12.2011, but it was being used by his
son Tsering Wangja Matadu. It was discovered during investigation that the
said SBBL gun was taken by Passang Saidu from Tsering WangjaMatadu for
the purpose of hunting but his intention was to kill the deceased with the
Page No.# 21/30
gun. It was disclosed that accused Passang Saidu had fired the gun to kill
the deceased but it misfired and they had thrown the misfired bullet in the
Salari River. The misfired bullet could not be recovered. The PW 15 also
stated that he submitted requisition for obtaining the CDR of the mobile
phones belonging to the accused persons and the deceased. He obtained
the CDR report and found that the mobile number of the deceased was
8798098676, that of accused Passang Saidu was 9612521106, that of
accused Tsering Dondu Saidu was 8798912517 and the number of accused
Sang Dorjee Kasidu was 7630807727. As perthe CDR it was found that there
were multiple calls made between the accused and the deceased on
06.04.2023. Their last mobile tower location was also found to be together
at the PO. PW 15 deposed that during investigation as it was found that the
SBBL gun was used without proper license, and he had obtained prosecution
sanction from the District Magistrate for prosecution of the accused persons
under the Arms Act and application was moved before the Trial Court for
adding section 27 and 30 of the Arms Act to the charges against the
accused persons. Having found prima facie case against the accused persons
he submitted charge-sheet against them under section 302/120B/201/34
IPC read with section 27 of the Arms Act. PW 15 also proved all the exhibits.
40.
In his cross-examination PW 15 stated that he had recorded the
disclosure statement but there was no independent witness. He did not
produce the certificate under the Indian Evidence Act regarding the
photographs. He also stated that he had not forwarded the wooden stick for
FSL examination and had not collected or examined the finger prints of the
accused to match with the stick. He further stated that there is no
independent eye witness in the present case. He denied the suggestion that
Page No.# 22/30
the charge-sheet was filed against the accused person only on the basis of
suspicion and also denied the suggestion that the accused persons are
innocent.
41.
After the prosecution witnesses were examined, the appellants
were also examined under section 313 Cr.PC wherein their defense was only
denial and they did not give any explanation regarding incriminating
circumstances. On being asked whether they had any witness to examine in
their defense and as to whether they had anything to say before the Court,
their reply was in the negative.
42.
It is an admitted fact that there is no eye witness in the instant case.
The conviction by the Trial Court has been made on the basis of
circumstantial evidence. The case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda vs State
of Maharashtra, (1984) 4 SCC 116 lays down 5 principles governing
conviction on the basis of circumstantial evidence. At paragraph 153 of the
judgment, the Supreme Court held that the following conditions must be
satisfied before a case against an accused can be held to be fully
established:
“A
close analysis of this decision would show that the following
conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can be said to
be fully established:
(1)
The circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn
should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the circumstances
concerned “must or should” and not “may be” established. There is
not only a grammatical but a legal distinction between “may be
Page No.# 23/30
proved” and “must be or should be proved” as was held by this Court
in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra (1973) 2 SCC 793
where the observations were made. “Certainly, it is a primary principle
that the accused must be and not merely may be guilty before a court
can convict and the mental distance between “may be” and “must be”
is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions”.
(2)
The facts so established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not
be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is
guilty.
(3)
The circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency.
(4)
They should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be
proved, and
(5)
There must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of
the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must
have been done by the accused.”
43.
From the evidence adduced by the prosecution it can be seen that
there was an extra judicial confession made by the accused Sang Dorjee
Kasidu before the village authorities to the effect that he along with Passang
Saidu and Tsering Dondu Saidu had killed the deceased person. This
confession has been proved beyond reasonable doubt by the deposition of
PW 3, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13. These PWs have all deposed that on 12 th April
2023 there was a village panchayat meeting regarding the missing report of
Gajabu Napudu. They deposed that during the public meeting accused Sang
Page No.# 24/30
Dorjee Kasidu disclosed that he along with Passang Saidu and Tsering
Dondu Siadu had killed Gajubu Napudu. Under the Indian Evidence Act, a
confession caused by inducement, threat or promise is inadmissible. A
confession made to a Police Officer or a confession made in Police custody
without the presence of a Magistrate is also inadmissible. In the case of
Siva Kumar vs State by Inspector of Police, (supra), the Supreme
Court held that an extra judicial confession made before a village
administrative officer was admissible because they are not Police Officers. In
the case of Sahadevan vs State of Tamil Nadu, (2012) 6SCC 403, the
Supreme Court held that an extra judicial confession to be admissible as
evidence must be voluntary and truthful, it must inspire confidence, its
credibility must be strengthened by corroboration and a chain of cogent
circumstances and it should not suffer from material discrepancies or
inherent improbabilities. In the case of State of Rajasthan vs Raja Ram
(2003) 8 SCC 180, it was held that an extra judicial confession if
voluntary, true and made in a fit state of mind can be relied upon and its
evidentiary value depends upon the credibility of the person to whom it is
made. The Supreme Court also recognized that conviction can be founded
on such a confession if the witnesses are unbiased and their evidence
inspires confidence. It was further held by the Supreme court that,“ such a
confession can be relied upon and conviction can be founded thereon if the
evidence about the confession comes from the mouth of witnesses who
appear to be unbiased, not even remotely inimical to the accused and in
respect of whom nothing is brought out which may tend to indicate that he
may have a motive of attributing an untruthful statement to the accused,
the words spoken by the witness are clear, unambiguous and unmistakably
Page No.# 25/30
convey that the accused is the perpetrator of the crime and nothing is
omitted by the witness which may militate against it*****If the evidence
relating to extra-judicial confession is found credible after being tested on
the touchstone of credibility and acceptability, it can solely form the basis of
conviction”. The PW 3, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 are credible witnesses. They are
the appellant’s own villagers and they have no reason to be biased nor do
they have any enmity against the appellants. In the present case we are of
the view that the confession was voluntarily made by the accused Sang
Dorjee Kasidu before the village authorities without police presence and
there was no threat, coercion or inducement.The Legal Aid counsel had
raised an argument that the confession of co-accused Sang Dorjee Kasidu
could not have been used to incriminate the other co-accused Passang Siadu
and Tsering Dondu Siadu. However, in view of the provisions of section 30 of
the Evidence Act the extra judicial confession is an additional circumstance
against the other two co-accused as they are being jointly tried.
44.
With regard to the submission of the learned Legal Aid counsel about
the discrepancies in the timing between the discovery of the dead body and
the recording of the disclosure statement, we are of the view that the
discrepancy is not automatically fatal to the prosecution case. The question
is whether the disclosure of the accused actually led to the discovery of the
dead body and the other incriminating materials or whether the prosecution
is attempting to attribute an already known recovery to the accused
persons. In the case of Ravishankar Tandon vs State of Chattisgarh
2024 INSC 299, the Supreme held that the prosecution must establish that
the dead body was recovered as a consequence of the information given by
the accused and that the place of recovery was not already known to the
Page No.# 26/30
police or witnesses before the disclosure.
45.
We have observed from the records that there is credible oral
evidence establishing that the accused Passang Siadu and Sang Dorjee
Kasidu had actually led the Police to the place where the dead body was
recovered. Before that, the evidence shows that all the villagers have been
searching for the deceased for the whole day and night on 07.04.2023 but
they could not find the dead body. Therefore, the prosecution case is not
defeated merely because the written disclosure statement was recorded at a
later point of time. The important distinction is between the accused leading
the police to the place before the body was discovered as opposed to the
accused being taken to a place where the body had already been
discovered. In A.N.Vankatesh vs State of Karnataka, (2005) 7SCC
714, the Supreme Court recognized that the conduct of an accused in
pointing out the place where the dead body was found is relevant under
section 8 of the Evidence Act, independently of whether the accompanying
statement is admissible under section 27 or not. Thus, we are of the view
that even if we hold that the disclosure statement made by the appellants is
not admissible under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, still it is relevant under
Section 8. Hence, even if the formal disclosure statement is defective or was
recorded later, the oral evidence in this case shows that the accused
Passang Siadu and Sang Dorjee Kasidu led the Police to the P.O and such
conduct is an admissible piece of evidence under Section 8 of the Evidence
Act. In the case of Bodhraj@ Bodha vs State of Jammu and Kashmir,
(2002) 8SCC 45, it was held that the exact information leading to
discovery must be proved. If it was not recorded, it may be established
through oral evidence. In this case the mere fact that the disclosure
Page No.# 27/30
statement was prepared after the recovery does not invalidate the discovery
as the prosecution has proved through direct testimony that the accused
Passang Siadu and Sang Dorjee Kasidu had led the Police to the place where
the dead body was found and therefore, the delay in recording the
disclosure statement can at best be treated as an investigative irregularity
rather than a fatal infirmity.
46.
The Trial Court has also relied on the “last seen theory” as a link in
the chain of circumstantial evidence in order to arrive at a conviction. We
are also in agreement with the finding of the Trial Court that it was the
accused Sang Dorjee Kasidu who was last seen with the deceased person.
The testimony of PW 2 has proved that on the evening of 06.04.2023,
accused Sang Dorjee Kasidu came to his residence and took away the
deceased person on his bike. This evidence of PW-2 has not been rebutted
by the defence. The accused is expected to offer an explanation as to when,
where and under what circumstances he parted company with the deceased
particularly when that fact is within his special knowledge. In this case the
prosecution has established beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased was
last seen alive in the company of the accused Sang Dorjee Kasidu and the
interval between the last sighting and the discovery of death is sufficiently
narrow and the possibility of intervention by another person is reasonably
excluded.
47.
In respect of the contention of the Legal Aid counsel that there is no
motive in the present case, the evidence of PW 4 and PW 15 goes to reveal
that there was an earlier dispute with regard to illicit relationship between
the deceased and the PW 4/wife of accused Passang Sadu in the year 2022
and the said dispute had been settled by the village authorities. However,
Page No.# 28/30
the PW 4 deposed that on 20.11.2022 the deceased had called her over the
phone and asked her to come to a newly constructed BPL building near her
house to sell housie ticket. However, her husband Passang Siadu saw them
from the window and the deceased ran away from there upon seeing
Passang Siadu. The testimony of PW 4 is also another link in the chain of
circumstantial evidence that the suspicion of an illicit relationship between
the deceased and PW 4 can be a motive for the offence.
48.
The recovery of a wooden stick from the P.O and the recovery of a
local dao from the residence of accused Passang Saidu is also a relevant link
in the chain of circumstantial evidence inasmuch as the post mortem report
had revealed that the death of the deceased was caused by spinal cord
injury and traumatic brain injury. The PW 14/M.O had corroborated the post
mortem report by deposing that the injury suggested that a blunt weapon
was used for causing the same. Even in the cross-examination the PW 14
deposed that as per the nature of injury, the wooden stick or dao could have
caused the injury on the deceased which led to his death.In the case of
Mukesh vs State (NCT of Delhi), (2017) 6SCC 1, the Supreme Court
said that associating independent witnesses with recovery is a rule of
caution and not an inflexible legal requirement. It was held that the seizure
memo need not mandatorily be attested by independent witnesses. Non
attestation of the seizure memo by independent witnesses cannot be a
ground to disbelieve the recovery of articles consequent upon being led by
the accused.
49.
The principal ingredient of criminal conspiracy is an agreement or
meeting of minds between two or more persons to achieve an unlawful
object. To establish an offence under section 120B IPC, the prosecution
Page No.# 29/30
must prove that there were at least two or more persons involved in the
conspiracy; there must be an agreement or meeting of minds between them
to do an illegal act or do a legal act by illegal means. The accused persons
must knowingly and intentionally become a party to the agreement.
Conspiracy is generally hatched in secrecy and direct evidence of agreement
is seldom available. However, it may be inferred from the circumstances and
conduct of the accused persons. In the present case the evidence of the
PWs has proved beyond reasonable doubt that there was criminal conspiracy
to commit murder of the deceased person between Passang Siadu, Sang
Dorjee Kasidu and Tsering Dondu Siadu.
50.
We have also examined the evidence with regard to the conviction
under section 25 (1B) of the Arms Act. The evidence of the PWs coupled
with the material evidence produced by the prosecution has proved that the
arms license of the SBBL gun was in the name of WangjaMatadu but the
gun was being used by his son Tsering Wangja Matadu. During investigation,
the said SBBL gun was recovered from the roadside at Khoina village in a
hidden place on being shown by accused Passang Siadu as testified by PW
7. Section 25 (1B) of the Arms Act deals with unauthorized acquisition,
possession or carrying of firearms or ammunitions in contravention of the
licensing requirements under section 3 of the Arms Act. The fact that the 12
bore SBBL gun was recovered from the jungle near the house of the accused
Passang Siadu as per his disclosure has not been rebutted by the defence.
Section 3 of the Arms Act prohibits the possession or carrying of firearms or
ammunitions without a valid license. There is no defenceevidence that the
accused persons had license in their name to possess or use the SBBL gun.
Therefore, the prosecution has established absence of valid license on the
Page No.# 30/30
part of the accused persons. The Trial Court has rightly arrived at a finding
that the accused persons are guilty of committing offence under section 25
(1B) of the Arms Act.
51.
With regard to the absence of explanation by an accused person in
his 313 Cr.PC examination, the Supreme Court in the case of Shard
Birdhichand (supra) held that a false explanation or absence of
explanation can be used as an additional link only when the prosecution has
satisfactorily established the other links in the chain and the circumstances
point towards the guilt of the accused with reasonable definiteness and
further the circumstances are proximate in time and situation. In the instant
case an adverse inference can be drawn against the appellants regarding the
absence of any explanation by them as the other links in the chain of
circumstances have pointed towards their guilt.
52.
Thus, under the facts and circumstances and upon due consideration
of the evidence in its entirety, we do not find any merit in these appeals and
accordingly, the same is dismissed.
53.
For the valuable assistance rendered by Ms. Jaya Doji, the learned
Legal Aid counsel, the Arunachal Pradesh State Legal Services Authority shall
pay her the fees as per the prescribed rates.
54.
Registry shall send back the Trial Court Records forthwith.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review