Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC040018172026
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : Crl.Rev.P./19/2026
Smti Mipet Tayeng
Daughter of Shri Kokok Tayeng, resident of Sille Village, PO Oyan, PS Sille Oyan
Sille, East Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and Anr
represented by the PP of AP 2:Ms Mama Tang
Age: 0
Occupation :
Daughter of Late K Tang
resident of E Sector
Naharlagun
PO and PS Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Tabit Tapak, Omeng Taga,Taloh Tabing,Bebeng Siboh,Aso Dalbong
Advocate for the Respondent : P P of AP,
Linked Case : Crl.Rev.P./20/2026
Smti Mipet Tayeng
Age: 47
Occupation :
Address:Daughter of Shri Kokok Tayeng
resident of Sille Village
PO Oyan
Page No.# 2/10
PS Sille Oyan Sille
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and Anr
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the PP of AP
2:Smti Goken Tang
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Wife of Late K Tang
resident of E Sector
Naharlagun
PO and PS Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
-----------Advocate for : Tabit Tapak
Advocate for : P P of AP appearing for The State of AP and Anr: Advocate , appearing
for 2, respectively.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE YARENJUNGLA LONGKUMER
04.11.2026
ORDER
The instant application under Section 438 read with Section
442 of the BNSS, 2023 has been preferred by the petitioner praying
for setting aside and quashing the impugned order dated
28.09.2026 passed by the learned JMFC, Naharlagun rejecting the
Crl. Misc. Case No. 593/2026 filed by the petitioner praying for
sending the disputed signature ad handwriting over the cheque
bearing No. 021994 for Rs.84Lakhs and also the disputed signature
and handwriting over the purported undertaking dated 10.05.2022,
for expert opinion.
Page No.# 3/10
2.
Heard Mr. T. Tapak, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. T.
Ete, learned Addl. PP appearing for the State respondent.
3.
The case of the petitioner herein is that the petitioner is the
accused in Complaint Case No. 78/2022 which was instituted by the
respondent No. 2 before the learned JMFC, Naharlagun. The
complaint was with regard to recovery of Rs.84Lakhs out of which
Rs.20Lakhs was paid through cheque and Rs.64Lakhs was paid in
cash.
4.
The basis of the claim of Rs.84Lakhs by the complainant was
that the accused petitioner had issued a cheque bearing cheque
No. 021994 from the Bank of India, Itanagar Branch. The said
cheque is supported by an undertaking dated 10.05.2022 allegedly
signed
by
the
accused
petitioner.
The
petitioner
entered
appearance and disputed the genuineness of the signature over
her cheque and the handwriting filling up the cheque and also the
supporting undertaking, on the ground that it was not her signature
or handwriting.
5.
The petitioner in her 313 Cr.P.C. statement before the learned
Trial Court clearly defended that she has never issued any cheque
to the complainant nor she had any business connection with the
complainant but only with her mother Smti. Goken Tang who is the
mother of the complainant/ respondent No. 2 as the cheque was
Page No.# 4/10
issued as a security during the course of business in between the
mother of the complainant and the petitioner. Therefore, the said
cheque had never been issued to the complainant at any point of
time for payment of any liabilities.
6.
It is also submitted that the complainant’s evidence/PW’s has
already been closed during which the complainant has examined 4
(four) witnesses). The complainant witness No.3, a Bank employee
has clearly stated during the cross-examination that he has verified
the signature maintained in the bank with the cheque and was
found to be correct. However, the petitioner claims that the
signature over the cheque does not belong to her.
7.
In view of the disputed facts, the petitioner filed the application
praying for expert opinion over the disputed signature on the
cheque as well as the handwriting over the cheque and the
supporting undertaking.
8.
It is also the case of the petitioner herein that she had filed the
Crl. Misc Case No. 593/2026 before the JMFC, Naharlagun under
Section 266 (2) of BNSS, 2023 seeking for a direction for expert
opinion over the disputed signature in the cheque bearing No.
021994 for Rs.84Lakhs and also the signature and handwriting over
the supporting undertaking dated 10.05.2022. However, the learned
Trial Court rejected the said application on the ground that the
filling up of details by anyone other than the accused is immaterial
Page No.# 5/10
and that the signature on the cheque belongs to the accused who
has admitted by putting her signature.
9.
The learned Trial Court by relying on the case of Bir Singh-vs-
Mukesh Kumar; reported in (2019) 4 SCC 197, held that the cheque
being filled by any person other than the drawer is immaterial if the
cheque is duly signed by the drawer. Being aggrieved, the
petitioner has approached this Court.
10.
Per contra, the learned Addl. PP Mr. T. Ete appearing for the
State respondent has argued that the scope of this Court in a
revision is very limited. He has submitted that this Court can interfere
with the order of the Trial Court only if the order had been passed
without jurisdiction, or it is perverse, or there is manifest error, or it is
arbitrary and reflects total non-application of mind. The learned
Addl. PP relying on the cases of Shubhwati-vs-Alka Rastogi; reported
in 2025 SCC OnLine Del 6743 as well as the case of Manda
Syamsundar-vs-Kurella Anjaneyachari & Anr; reported in 2008 ALL
MR (Crl.) Journal 269 submits that the Hon’ble Delhi High Court as
well as the Andhra Pradesh High Court in the above cited cases
have held that the presumption under the NI Act, though,
rebuttable operates in favor of the respondent. It is for the accused
to rebut such by leading appropriate defence evidence and the
Court cannot be expected to assist the accused to collect the
evidence on his behalf. It is submitted that the cheque bounced
not on account of the fact that the petitioner’s signature was not
Page No.# 6/10
tallying with the specimen signature of the appellant kept with the
bank, but on account of insufficient funds. The signature of the
appellant was not objected to by the bank, but the same was
returned with the remark ‘insufficient funds’ This circumstance
clearly shows that the signature on the cheque was that of the
petitioner.
11. In the above cited cases, the Court held that if the reasons for
dishonour was for mis-match of the signature then the accused
could have been justified in seeking examination of the disputed
cheque
through
a
handwriting
expert.
However,
in
the
circumstances, when there is no issue of signature mis-match, there
is no justification for allowing the handwriting to be examined by a
expert to prove the signature. It was also held that a prayer to seek
the cheque to be sent to a handwriting expert is completely
unwarranted and that the accused is at liberty to adduce any
evidence in support of her defence. It was also held by the Delhi
High Court in the case of Shubhwati (supra) that the application for
seeking expert opinion had been rightly dismissed by the learned
Trial Court by observing it to be not only belated, but also being
without merit.
12. Similarly, in the instant case, the learned Addl. PP has taken this
Court to the deposition of the complainant witness No. 3 who is the
representative of the Manager of the Bank of India, Itanagar
Branch. The CW No. 3 deposed that the cheque in question
Page No.# 7/10
belonged to the petitioner and he had accepted the cheque
bearing No. 021994 dated 10.05.2022 for an amount of Rs.84Lakhs in
favor of Mama Tang. In the cross-examination by the defence, the
CW No.3 deposed that the signature of the petitioner was verified
with the one maintained at the bank The learned Addl. PP also
referred to the 313 Cr.P.C. statement of the petitioner. On being
asked, whether the cheque bearing No.021994 was issued by the
petitioner, the petitioner replied that he had given the cheque to
the mother of Mama Tang as security for a loan of Rs.30Lakhs.
13.
In view of the above, the learned Addl. PP submits that the
signature on the cheque was never in dispute and he further
submits that the case is now at the final argument stage and the
petitioner has been given an opportunity to adduce her evidence.
As held by the learned Trial Court, there was no necessity for the
Trial Court to send the signature for expert opinion. Moreover, the
learned Addl. PP submits that the learned Trial Court has the
discretion to refuse an application for expert opinion inasmuch as,
the accused/ petitioner does not have an absolute right to have
the cheque referred to a handwriting expert merely by disputing
the signature.
14.
This Court has duly considered the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the parties and also perused the pleadings and
the documents relied upon. The revision jurisdiction of this Court is
Page No.# 8/10
primarily supervisory and corrective. It is intended to prevent
miscarriage of justice, to correct jurisdictional errors and to ensure
legality, propriety and regularity of criminal proceedings and not
function as a second appellate Court. This Court in a revision
cannot reappreciate the evidence as if hearing in an appeal, or
substitute our own factual findings merely because another view is
possible.
15. In a revision challenging the rejection of an application to send
a signature in a cheque for expert opinion, the question is whether
the learned Trial Court refusal was based on correct understanding
of the law and whether the Trial Court has considered the
materiality of the disputed signature and whether the Trial Court
had taken account of the right of the accused to rebut the
statutory presumption. This Court has also to see whether the
impugned order has resulted in a patent illegality, arbitrary exercise
of discretion or miscarriage of justice. Only on such grounds, the
impugned order can be interfered with by this Court.
16. Upon going through the records, this Court is in agreement with
the submission of the learned Addl. PP that the concerned cheque
bearing No. 021994 was dishonored due to insufficient funds and
not because of mismatch in the signature. As held by the Delhi High
Court in the case of Shubhwati (supra) and by the Andhra Pradesh
High Court in the case of Manda Syamsundar (supra), in the instant
Page No.# 9/10
case also there is no justification for allowing the handwriting or the
signature to be sent for expert opinion. Further, the petitioner had
already examined herself as a defence witness. Since it was her
defence that the handwriting in the cheque and the disputed
undertaking is not her signature or her handwriting, nothing
prevented her from moving an application at the stage of her
defence evidence. Admittedly, the case is at the stage of final
argument.
17.
It is a settled position of law that sending a disputed
cheque/signature for handwriting expert opinion in a Negotiable
Instruments case is not mandatory in every case.
18.
The learned Trial Court has to exercise its judicial discretion,
considering the facts and circumstances of each case. In the case
of Bir Singh (supra), which has been relied upon by the learned Trial
Court, the Hon’ble Supreme Court had held that the presumption
under Section 139 of the NI Act arises when the drawer admits the
signing and handing over the cheque. Whether the accused filled
in the cheque particulars was immaterial in determining whether it
was issued towards debt or liabilities. The handwriting expert opinion
would not rebut the statutory presumption merely by showing that
particulars were filled in by someone else. Consequently, it was held
that allowing the expert examination served no useful purpose in
the circumstances.
Page No.# 10/10
19.
This Court upon examining the impugned order dated
28.09.2026 is of the considered view that it is a reasoned order
based on the facts and does not warrant the interference of this
Court in a revision. Moreover, the case is also now at the final
arguments stage and the petitioner could have the remedy of filling
an appropriate application against the final order as and when it is
passed.
Resultantly, this revision petition is dismissed at the motion stage,
itself as being without merit.
JUDGE
Checked & verified
Digitally signed
by Talom Tali
Date: 2026.11.05
10:53:55 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review