Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!
[ 3383 I
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETry
WRIT PETITION NO: 15102 OF 2023
Between:
S. Sunny Kumar, S/ o. Late Sri. Babaiah, Ag99 .about 3I .years, 9..- Private
Employe6, R/ o. H.No. 6-1-30/ A, Near Vailanky College, Shivrampally,
Rajendranagar - 500 052, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana
...PETITIONER
AND
The Government of Telangana, Department of Revenue, RqO. bV its Principal
Secretary, Office at Secret-ariat Building, Tank Bund, Hyderabad
2.
District Collector, Ranga Reddy District, Appellate Tribunal -ynder
Maintenance and Welfare of Parentl and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, Office at
lntegrated District Offices Complex (IDOC), Kongarkalan (V), lbrahimpatnam
(M),-Ranga Reddy District - 501 510
3. Revenue Divisional Officer, Rajendra Nagar Division, Tribunal under
Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, Office at
Attapur, Rajendranagar, Ranga Reddy District
4. The Sub-Registrar, Rajenilra Nagar, Office at Sub-Registrar Office, Attapui,
Rajendra Nagar, Ranga Reddy District.
5. Smt. G. Narsamma, Wo. Late Sri. G. Yadaiah, Aged about 76 years, OccHousewife, R/o 3-4-472, Narayanguda, Hyderabad - 5OO O27
..RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate wri!, order or Direction more particularly one in
the nature of Writ of Mandamus a.Declaring the proceedings No.338/DWO/ FRO/
2023 Dt. 23.05.2023, issued b/,,the Respondent No.2 whereby the Respondent
No.2 in a mechanical mannerr# confirmed the orders passed by the
Respondent No.3 in revoking the*Gifi Settlement Deed bearing No. 2045 of 2021
Dt. 15-02-2021 in respect of,property bearing No. 6-2-391212, admeasuring 100
Sq.yards Plot Nlo.17lNorthern Part, in Sy.No. 150/AA, situated at Katedan Village,
GHMC, Rajendranagar Mandal, Shivrampally, Ranga Reddy District (hereinafter
referred to as :subject Property for the sake of brevity) as being bad, arbitrary,
illegal, mechanical, high-handed, unconstitutional, violative of Article 14, 21 and
300-A of the Constitution of lndia and also contrary to the provision of
lVlaintenance ;ihd Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007.
b.Consequentiarlly, set-aside the revocation of the Gift Settlement Deed bearing
No. 2045 of 2021 Dt. 15-02-2021 in respect of property bearing Plot No.17, in
Sy.No. 150/ AA, admeasuring 100 Sq.Yds situated in Katedan Village, Ranjendra
Nagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District and direct the Respondent No.4 to effect the
necessary charges in the records, pursuant to setting-aside the revocation order.
lA NO: 1 OF 20?3
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit fil,:d in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to susJrend the operation of the proceedings No.338/ DWO/ FRO/ 2023
Dt. 23.05.2023, issued by the Respondent No.2 in respect of property bearing No.
'6-2-3gt2t2, adrneasuring 100 Sq.yards Plot No.17lNorthern Part, in Sy.No.
150/AA, situa'.ed at Katedan Village, Gl-{MC, Rajendranagar Mandal,
Shivrampally, llanga Reddy District in respect of the subject property i.e.,
pending disposill of the present Writ Petition
Counsel for the, Petitioner : Ms. JANAKI, REPRESENTING FOR SRI R. ANURAG
Counsel for the, Respondents No.lto4 : ASST. GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondents No.S : SRI B.RAMESH, Senior Counsel
for SMT.R.SWARNALATHA
The Court madr: the following: ORDER
i
qfr
;t6
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT PETITION No.15102 of 2023
2+
Datpd.
-.01.2025
Between:
S.Sunny Kumar
..Petitioner
And:
The Government of klangana,
Revenue Department, reptd by
its Principal Secretary, Hyderabad
andfour others.
Respondents
ORDERz
This Writ Petition is filed to declare the proceedings
No.338/DWO/FRO12023, dated 23.05.2023 issued by respondent No.2,
thereby confirming the orders passed by respondent No.3 in revoking the
Gift Settlement Deed bearing No.2045 of 2021, as illegal, arbitrary and
unconstitutional and further, to direct respondent No.4 not to entertain any
sale transaction in respect of the schedule property by placing the same in
the prohibited list.
,
2.
,,,.,
Heard Ms. Janaki,'leamed.counsel representing Sri R. Anurag,
learned counsel-on-recorj.. io, the petitioner, learned Assistant
WPNo.75702 of 202j
LNA,
I
Governr,ent Pleader for Revenue appearing for respondent Nos.l to 3 and
Sri B.Ramesh, leamed senior counsel appearing for Smt R.Swarnalatha,
learned counsel-on-record for respondent No.5.
3.
In brief,, the facts of the case are that respondent No.5, who is
maternal grandmother of petitioner, has approached respondent No.3-
Primary Authority under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and
senior citizens Act, 2007, (for brevity hereinafter referred to as ..the
Senior citizens Act"), i.e., respondent No.3 herein, by filing case
No.FVl60112022 seeking cancellation of the Registered Gift Settlement
Deed dated 15.02.202[ executed by her in favour of the petitioner. After
considering the entire material on record, respondent No.3-primary
Authoritl' passed an order, dated 31.t2.2022, holding that the Gift
Settlement Deed dated 15.02.2021 is liable to be cancelleil and directed
responde:rt No.4 to take necessary steps accordingly. Pursuant to the said
order, resrpondent No.4 has revoked the said Gift Settlement Deed., vide
Revocation of Gift Settlement, bearing document No.29 t/2023, dated
09.01 .201'.3. Aggrieved by the order dated 3l.lz.2oz2 of respondent No.3,
the petititlner has preferred an appeal before the First Appellate Authority-
respondent No.2 and the ,.id uop.al was disposed of, rejecting to grant
stay of the orders passed ui rffiorrdent No.3. Aggrieved by the same, the
present \\rrit Petition is titea.
/
./
,,@
wPNo.15702 of 2023
LNA,
4.
I
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the Gift Settlement
Deed dated 15.02,2021 does not have any pre-condition of maintenance of
respondent No.5 by the petitioner and after execution of the said Gift
Settlement Deed, the petitioner has developed the property, which was a
vacant plot, into a two-storied building with his own funds and by
obtaining loans worth Rs.40 lakhs. He further submitted that petitioner
requested respondent No.5 to reside in the ground floor of the house, but
respondent No.5 wanted a separate room for herself and as such, as per
her desire, the petitioner constructed a pent house with all amenities and
facilities. Learned counsel further submitted that petitioner was targeted
by the.other family members, through respondent No.5, for monetary
reasons and due to increase in land value.
5.
By contending as supra, leamed counsel prayed this Court to allow
this Writ Petition.
6.
In support of his submissions, learned counsel for the petitioner
relied upon the judgment, dated 08.04.2025, of this Court in
W.P.No.30278 of 2023 (PRohit Saurya Vs. The Snu of Telangana) and
also the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sudesh Chhikaru v.
Ramti Devil
I
"*f.
12022 SCC Online SC 1684
.P "sr
I
.4
wPNo.15102 ol 2023
LNA,
7.
]
rn P.Rohit saurya's case (cited supra), this court held that the
requirem:nts under Section z3(l) of the Senior citizens Act are not
satisfied for cancellation of the registered gift deeds executed by
respondent No.4 and hence, respondent No.3 therein had no jurisdiction to
cancel ttre gift deeds and accordingly, set aside the order passed by
respondent No.3 cancelling the Gift Settlement Deeds.
8.
rn sudesh chhikars's case (cited supra) the Hon,ble supreme
Court ha:; categorically held that effecting transfer subject to a condition
of providing the basic amenities and basic physicat needs to the transferor-
senior citizen is sine qua non for applicability of Sub-section (l) of
Section-23 of the Senior Citizens Act and that in the counter-affrdavit filed
by. respondent No.l therein, it is not pteaded that the release deed was
executed subject to such a condition. By observing thus, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has set aside the impugned order therein passed by the
Maintenance Tribunal as well as the order of the High Court, whereunder
the subjer:t Release Deed therein was declared as null and void.
9.
Per contra, learned senior counsel appearing for respondent No.5
submittecl that originally, the husband of respondent No.5 had purchased
.:
the vacant land admOasuring.200 square yards in plot No.l7, in
r?4
: rtf.
Sy.No.15'c/AA, situated at Kattedan village, Rajendra Nagar, Ranga
I
o
WPNo,15702 of 2023
LNA,
I
Reddy District, through registered Sale Deed bearing document No.1091
of 1997 dated 03.04.1997 and the same was nominally registered in the
name of respondent No.5. While so, taking advantage of the old age of
respondent No.5 and her emotional dependency, the petitioner promised to
take care of her and provide effective support and maintenance for the rest
of her life; and that basing on the said assurance, respondent No.5 had
executed a Gift Deed in respect of the subject property in favour of
petitioner
9.1. Learned senior counsel further submitted that there is no reason for
respondent No.5 and other family members to exclusively choose the
petitioner to be the sole beneficiary of the subject property, but for his
promise to take special care of respondent No.5 and the said assurance is
the implicit condition for execution of gift deed in favour of the petitioner
and therefore, prayed this Court to dismiss the writ petition with
exemplary costs for subjecting respondent No.5 to trauma and also
considering the fact that the petitioner has suppressed the real facts and
approached this Court with unclean hands
jl
9.2. In support of his contentions, learned senior counsel for respondent
'i1
No.5 relied upon the followingjudgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court:,-:.'rt#;
( "i;
WPN1.151O2 of 202j
LNA, J
1. (Jrmila Dixit vs. Sunil Sharan Dixi?
2. Vorinder Kaur Vs. Daljit Kaurj
10. In Urmila Dixit's case (cited supra), the facts of the case are that
gift deed and vachan patra/promissory note were registered on 09.09.2019
and that, in the promissory note, it has been stated that respondent will
take care of the appellant till the end of her life and if he does not do so,
the appellant will be at liberty to take back the gift deed. However, the
respondent has alleged that the promissory note is fabricated. In such a
scenario, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has referred to various previous
judgmenl:s of the Hon'ble Supreme Court with regard to interpretation of
the provisions in the beneficial legislations qua the Senior Citizens Act,
wherein it was categorically held that the said Act should receive a
purposefirl or functional interpretation and a construction that advances
the remedies of the Act must be adopted. Further, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court obr;erved that in Sudesh Chhikaru's case, two conditions/essentials,
viz., the transfer must have been made subject to the condition that the
transferer: shall provide the basic amenities and basic physical needs to the
transferor:; and the transferee refuses or fails to provide such amenities and
physical needs to the transfe5or, are expounded for attracting the
;{,f
:t--/,
' 1zozs12sca7B7
' 2025 scc oNLTNE DEL6272
/
a
(fr
WPN0.15102 of 2023
LNA.
I
application of Section 23(l) of the Senior Citizens Act and the said
conditions must be appropriately interpreted to further the beneficial
nature of the legislation and not strictly which would render otiose the
intent of the legislation. By observing as such, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
has quashed the Gift deed, dated 07.09.2019, thereby upholding the order
of the Primary authority declaring the gift deed as null and void.
I
1. In Vurinder Kaur 's case (cited supra), the Delhi High Court at para-
30 held as follows:-
"If we examine thefacts of the instant case in the light
of the legal principles as discussed above, the settled
legal positton which emerges is that for attracting the
provisions of Section 23(l) of the Senior Citizens Act,
the deed in question need not expressly contain a
condition thqt transferee shall provide the basic
amentties and basic physical needs to the transfero4
especially in the context of execution of a gift feed. "
12. Before adverting to the facts/merits of the case, this Court feels it
necessary to reiterate that it is well settled principle of law that a
beneficial legislation must receive a liberal construction in consonance
with the objectives that the e"t .on..rned seeks to serve. Admittedly, the"
'r!
'
"urq[ter involved in the pres:nli6lse relates to Senior Citizens Act, a
beneficial legislation. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Ilrmilu Dixit's case
('r
WPNI.15102 of 2O2i
LNA, !
(cited supra) while dealing with the matter relating to Senior Citizens Act,
has refen'ed to various citations of the Hon'ble Supreme Court pertaining
to the sai,l Act, and further, keeping in mind the beneficial intention of the
statute, held that the said Act empowers senior. citizens to secure their
rights promptly when they transfer a property subject to the condition of
being malntained by the transferee.
13. Coming to the case on hand, it is to be seen that respondent No.5
executed a gift deed in favour of petitioner, out of love and affection, and
the said p;ift deed did not provide/stipulate any condition for maintenance
of respondent No.5 by the petitioner. Therefore, the judgm.nt of th.
Hon'ble Slupreme Court in Sudesh Chhikaru's case (cited supra) squarely
applies to the instant case, wherein it is categorically expounded that for
attracting the application of Section 23(l) of the Act, the transfer by the
transferorsenior citizen must have been made subject to the condition that
the transferee shall provide the basic amenities and basic physical needs to
the transfbror. However, in the instant case, no such condition is reflected
in the gilt deed executed by respondent No.5 in favour of the petitioner
and there [ore, in the absen"" of same, Section 23(l) of the Senior Citizens
Act is not attracted. ,
",t'
rl#
r"t '
/
/
,-t.
a
WPNo.151O2 of 2023
LNA,
I
14. Furthermore, it is relevant to note that in Urmila Dkit's case (cited
supra), in the subject gift deed therein, it was recorded that the donee
maintains the donor and the former makes all necessary provisions for the
peaceful life of the donor and in promissory note which was
simultaneously executed therewith, it was stated that the donee shall serve
the appellant therein (donor) and her husband till the end of their life, and
in the absence of fulfilling such obligation, the subsequent deed can be
taken back by the appellant therein (donor). In such backdrop of the case,
even though the donee therein has disputed the subject promissory note
therein by pleading that the same is fabricated, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
by referring to various judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court with
regard to liberal construction of the beneficial Act qua the Senior Citizens
Act, observed as under:-
"ln our considered view, the relief available to senior
cittzens under Section 23 of the Act is intrinsically linked
with the statement of objects and reasons of the Act that
elderly citizens of our country, in some cases, are not being
looked after. It is directly tn furtherance of the objectives of
the Act and empowers serfior citizens to sec:ure their rights
promptly when they ,transfer a property subject to the
condition of being rhatntaineQ by the transferee."
,t,'.-l{f,
{,
{t
(,
h.
wPNo.15102 of 2023
LNA, J
15. The facts of the case in urmila Dixit,s case (cited supra) and the
facts in ttte present case are completely different and as such, the same has
no applir:ation to the present case, especially in the absence of any
condition in the gift deed. Further, the gift deed was nor executed subject
to condition that respondent No.5 shall be taken care of and maintained by
petitioner; as such, the two essentials expounded by Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Sudesh Chhikara's case (cited supra) were not satisfied for
attracting the provision of Section 23(l) of the Senior Citizens Act.
16. In Vorinder Kaurb case (cited supra), it was the specific allegation
of the senior citizen therein, who is aged about 8g years, that she was
harassed and not maintained and was subject to confinement by the done
immediately after execution of the Gift deed and she was not even given
food and clothes by the appellant therein. In the said facts, the High Court
of Delhi observed that the hand written letters and other material was
brought c'n record by the senior citizen therein to prove that the appellant
therein c,rmpletely failed to provide such care, amenities and physical
needs to her and as such, held that the senior citizen therein has
establishe'd the pre-condition for exercise of power under Section 23 of
the Act. The High cpurt";'of D'elhi has finally observed that while
exercisinl5thlpowers unddr''#arion z3(r) of the Act on an application
moved b), u senior citiziin seeking declaration that the deed is void, the
L\
(-.,
WPN,.757O2 of 2023
LNA, J
Tribunal is expected to look into all the relevant material and not only the
bare contents of the application so made and accordingly, upheld the
order passed by the District Magistrate cancelling the subject gift deed
therein.
17. In the instant case, respondent No.5 except seeking to cancel the
gift deed executed in favour of the writ petitioner, has not specifically
made any allegation with regard to her non-maintenance and being
neglected by respondent No.5. Furthermore, respondent No.5 averred that
she was taken care and was being looked after by her three daughters for
\
\
quite some time, but, after execution of the gift deed in favour of
respondent No.5, they started behaving rudely and indifferently and also
did not allow her into the house. Thus, it is evident that respondent No.5
has not made specific allegations against the writ petitioner that he failed
to provide such care, amenities and physical needs to her and has
neglected to maintain her and furtheffnore, there is no mention of the said
conditions in the gift deed. In such a backdrop of the present case, the
judgment of the High Court of Delhi is not applicable to the present case.
18. In the light of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
''i1'
considered view that Section' 23(1) of the Senior Citizens Act does not
r.".,*S;
attract to the case on hand anil as such, the action of respondent No.4 in
I
I
WPNo.1s102 of 2023
LNA,
]
revoking the subject Gift Settlement Deed, dated 15.02.2021, pursuant to
the order dated 31.12.2022 passed by respondent No.3-primary Authority,
is declarr:d as illegal, arbitrary and unconstitutional.
19. In the result, the writ Petition is allowed and consequently,
Revocation of Gift Settlement, bearing document No.29L/zoz3, dated
09.01.20'.23, in respect of the subject property, is set aside.
2o. Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, in this writ petition shall
stand clo;sed. No costs
SD/. P.C. SULEKHA DEVI
REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
OFFICER
To,
of Revenue,
2. The Disl:rict Collector, Ranga Reddy Eistrict, Appellate Tribunal under
Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act,2007, Office at
lntegratt>d District Offices Complex (IDOC), Kongarkalan (V), lbrahimpatnam
(M), Ranga Reddy District - 501 510
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Rajendra Nagar Division, Tribunal under
Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, Office at
Attapur, Rajendranagar, Ranga Reddy District
\
4. The Sutr-Registrar, Rajendra Nagar, Office at Sub-Registrar Office, Attapur,
Rajendr;a Nagar, Ranga Reddy District.
5. One CC to SRI R.ANURAG Advocate [OPUC]
6. Two CCs to GP FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana.
touTI
7. One CC to Sfi4T n.SwnnrrtAr-ATHA, Advocate. IOPUCI
B. Two CD Copies.
BSK
i
,,.t$j
f\
,
€,
HIGH COIJRT
DATED i2',210112026
ORDER
WP.No.1tt1 02 ot 2023
ALLOWIFIG THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOU. COSTS
It
i
:i,''i{E'
4 la lat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review