Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3383 ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRIT PETITION NO: 16424 OF 2018
Between:
1. S. Rameshwar Rao, S/o. Late S. Ramdas. Aged about 49 years,
Rlo. 1-24-282,lndira Nagar Colony, Lothkunta, Atwal, Secunderabad.
2. S. Vinod Kumar, S/o. Late S. Ramdas. Aged about 47 yea$, Rlo. 1-24-282,
lndira Nagar Colony, Lothkunta, Alwal, Secunderabad.
3. T Dhan Raj, S/o.T. . Narasimha Rao, aged about 59 years, R/o.132-2RT,
Prakash Nagar Colony, Begumpet, Secunderabad.
4. H.L.Srinivas, S/o.H.Lakshmin atayana, aged about 39 years, RloJ-24-212,
lndiara Nagar Colony, Lothukunta, Alwai, Secunderabad.
..PETITIONERS
AND
The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, Rep. by its Commissioner,
M.C.H. Buildings, Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
The Zonal Commissioner of G.H.M.C, North Zone, Secunderabad_
The Deputy Commissioner of G.H.lV.C, Commissioner, Alwal Circle 27, Alwal,
Secunderabad.
4. The Sub-Registrar, Registration Office, Vallabh Nagar, Begumpet, Prakash
Nagar, Secunderabad.
5- Nemarugommula Venkateshwar Rao, S/o N. Ramchander Rao, aged 61
years Occ. Business Rl/o Presidency Avenue, Road No.7, Alwal, Hyderabad.
6. Patlori Suresh Kumar, Sio P. Hanmanth Rao, Aged 42 years Occ. Employee
R/o FIat No.402, Patloori Amrutha Residency, Mangapuram Colony, Old
AIwal, Hyderabad.
7- Dr. Vamsr Priya Aravally, Wo Sumanth Balguri Aged 37 years Occ. Doctor
Rep. by her GPA namely Sri. B. Sudhakar Rao S/o Malhar Rao, aged 65
years Occ. Business Rl/o Flat No.405, Laxmi Ganapathi Nilayam, Central Part,
Kompally, Hyderabad.
8. Devendar Rendla, S/o Mallaiah, Aged 50 years Occ. Business PJo H.No.6105111N20A, Godavari Homes, Jeedimetla, Hyderabad.
9. B. Ram Reddy, S/o late B. Malla Reddy, Aged 56 years Occ. Business R/o
23-6-897 / 4, Laldawvaza, Hyderabad.
-'
!
10. Gandra Sugunakar Rao, S/o G. Sugreeva Rao, Aged 3 I years Occ. Business
R/o H.No.7-6-8611, Vidya Nagar, Jagtial, Dist. Jagtial.
11. Koya Anthony, S/o Koya Raiaiah Aged 76 years Occ. I g riculture R/o H.No.2-
1-407, Flal No.'103, Shanthi Apartments, Nr akunta, H) lerabad.
12.Joginipally Harender Rao, S/o J. Ananda Rao, Aged , years Occ. Business
R/o H.No.5-133173 and 74, Flat No.301, Venkateshr ara Residency, Road
No.2, Mangapuram Colony, OId Alwal, Hyderabad.
13. R. Lalitha @ R. Sandhya, W/o R. Sudhakar, Aged 5'1 lr:ars Occ. Housewife
Rt/o H.No.1-7-100l14, ptor No.112, Reddy Ent:t l\/e, Temple Alwal,
Secunderabad.
14.B. Ramesh, S/o B. Pentaiah, Aged 48 years Occ. Bu iness R/o H.No.7-13,
Balanagar, Shetipally Kalan lvlandal, Medak District.
15.M Narayan Reddy, S/o Hanumanth Reddy, Aged 72. erars Occ. Agriculture
R:/o H.No.3-5-170, A/5, Narayanaguda, YMCA, Hyderab t,l.
RR 5 to 15 are impleaded as per C.O.dt. 03.03.2025 ir lANo.212024.
16. Joginipelly Raj Gopal Rao, S/o J.Thirupathi Rao, : ged 65 years, Occ:
)ist Karimnagar.
Respondent No.16 is impleaded as per C.O. dl.27.01.2026 in
Business, R/o. H.No.10-1-246, Ramnagar, Karimnagar
l.A.No.1/2025.
.RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arlicle 226 of the Constitution of lnc i r praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the :ligh Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ of ftilandamus or any other apprrt rriate Writ, Order or
direction declaring the inaction on the part of the responc( nts herein, in taking
aclion on the representations d,.0211212013, O6tj2 2:.013, 17t02t2014,
04t 1 2t201 4. 29t 1 2t201 4, O5t01 I 20 1 5, 21 I 12t201 5. 21 I O8t2( 17 and 2511012017,
submitted by the petitioners herein, and allowing illegal ;onstructions in lhe
petitioners Iands to an extent of Ac.13.22 guntas situated r l]y No.592 and 593
part at Old Alwal Village, (Saibabanagar), Atwal Circle, rr cler G.H.M.C Alwal
Mandal, M edcha l/lt/a lkajigiri District, by the unauthorized o l ru pa nts/en croachers
without any valid permissions from the competent authority as illegal, arbitrary
and contrary to the provisions of G.H.M.C.Act, and conr erquently direct the
respondents herein not to allow any unauthorized construc i,:ns to be made in
the petitioners land and to take further action for den r Iition of the illegal
constructions made by the unauthorized occu pants/encroac.r ;rs in the petitioners
land to an extent of Ac.13.22 guntas situated in Sy.No.S) I and 593 part OId
Alwal Village, (Saibabanagar), Alwal Circle,
under G.H.lvl.C Alwal lrrlandal,
Medchal/Matkajigiri District.
IANO:lO F 201e
Petition under Section 151 cpc praying
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
direct the Respondents herein, not to accord
that in the circumstances stated
the High Court may be pleased to
any permissions for construction of
buildings and regularizing any illegal permissions
under BRS and LRS and also
to stop forthwith the iregar constructions that is
being made by any unauthorized
occupants/encroachers in the petitioners rands
to an extent of Ac.13.22 guntas
situated in Sy.No.592 and 593 part, old Alwal
Village, Arwal circle 27, under
G.H.M.C Malkajgiri Mandal, Medchal/fi/alkajgiri
District, pending disposal of the
above Writ Petition.
IANO:2O F 2018
Petition under section i51 cpc praying that
in the affidavit fited in support of the petition,
in the circumstances stated
the High Court may be pteased to
direct the Respondent No. 4 heretn, not to register
the lands situated in Sy.No.592 and 593 part near
any document in respect of
Old Atwal Village, Alwal Circle
27, under c.H.M.C AIwar ,vrandar, IVedchar/tvarkajori
the title deed and link document, pending disposal
District, without verifying
of the above Writ petition.
IANO:1OF2 020
Petition under Section 151 cpc praying that in
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the circumstances stated
the High Court may be pleased to
extend the order dated 181061201g, passed by
this Honble court in l.A.No.1 of
2018 in W.P.No .16424 of 2018, pending disposal
of the above Writ petition.
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the
the circumstances stated
High Court may be pleased to
extend the order dated 1g.06.2019 passed by this
Hon,ble Court in lA No. 1 of
-
2018 in WP No. 16424 of 2018 as extended by orde ,r i dated 17.12.2020,
05.O2.2021, and 23.O4.2021 pending disposal of the above vrit petition.
lA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in th€ )lrcumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High CcL -l rr ay be pleased to
direct the respondents herein, not to allow/permit any .r r-authorized building
constructions in S.No.592 of Alwal GHlr,4C circle, pending ri:;posal of the above
Writ Petition.
lA NO: 2 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the )ircumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High CoL 1 may be pleased to
extend the order 18-06-20'18 passed by this Hon'ble court I LA.No.1 of 20.18 in
W.P.No.16424 ot 2O18, pending disposal of the above Writ I 'etition.
IA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the ;ircumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High CoJ t may be pleased to
Vacate the lnterim Order dated: 18-06-2018 passed in LA I o. ' of 2018 in W.P.
No.16424 of 2018 in the interests of justice and pending c :;posal of the above
writ petition.
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Between:
1. The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, Rep. r.y its Commissioner,
M.C.H. Buildings, Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
2. The Zonal Commissioner of G.H.M.C, North Zone, Sec.l rrlerabad.
3. The Deputy Commissioner of G.H.M.C, Commissioner, rlwal Circle 27, Alwal,
Secunderabad.
...PETITIONERS
AND
S. Rameshwar Rao, S/o. Late S. Ramdas. Ace I about 49 years,
No. 1-24-282,lndira Nagar Colony, Lothkunta, Alwal, iir 6:96(gmg66.
-
2 S. Vinod Kumar, S/o. Late S. Ramdas. Aged about 4T years, Rto. 1_24_282.
lndira Nagar Colony, Lothkunta, Atwal, Sedunderabad.
3 T Dhan Raj. S/oT Narasimha Rao, aged about 59 years, R/o.132-2RT,
Prakash Nagar Colony, Begumpet, Secunterabad.
4. H.L.Srinivas, S/o.H.Lakshminarayana, aged about 3g years, NoJ_24_272,
Indiara Nagar Colony, Lothukuntd, Alwal, Secunderabad.'
5. The Su!-Registrar, Registration Office, Vallabh Nagar, Begumpet, prakash
Nagar, Secunderabad.
6. Nemarugommula Venkateshwar Rao, S/o N. Ramchander Rao. aoed 61
years Occ. Business R/o Presidency Avenue, Road No.7, Alwal, Uyber6OaO.
7. Pallori Suresh Kumar, S/o P. Hanmanth Rao, Aged 42 yearc Occ_ Employee
Rl/o Flat No.402, Pafloori Amrutha Residencyi Mang'apuram Cotoni, blJ
Alwal, Hyderabad.
8. Dr. Vamsi Priya Aravally, W/o Sumanth Balguri Aged 37 years Occ. Doctor
Rep. by her GPA namely Sri. B. Sudhakar-Rao S/o Malhar Rao. aoed 65
years Orc. Business Rt/o Flat No.405, Laxmi Ganapathi Nilayam, Centrlt part,
Kompally, Hyderabad.
9 D-e1u91!9r Rendla, S/o Maltaiah, Aged 50 years Occ. Business R/o H.No.6_
1O5l1lN2OA, codavari Homes, Jeedimetla, Hyderabad.
10. B. Ram Reddy, S/o late B. Malla Reddy, Aged 56 years Occ. Business Rl/o
23-6-897 I 4, Laldarwaza, Hyderabad.
11 Gandra Sug-u1q[ar.Rqo, S/o G. Sugreeva Rao, Aged 64 years Occ. Business
R/o H.No,7-6-8611, Vidya Nagar, Jagtiat, Dist. Jagiial.
12 fo_y^a_ryr]h.o.ly, S19 (oya Rajaiah Aged 76 years Occ. Agricutture Rjo H.No.21-407, Flat No.103, Shanthi Apartments, N,ltakunta, Hydlrabad,
13.
loginipally-H{glder Rao, S/o J_ Ananda Rao, Aged 12 yearc Occ. Business
Rl/o H.No.5-133173 and 74,-Flat No.301, Venkateshwaia Residency, Roid
No.2, Mangapuram Colony, Old Alwal, Hyderabad.
14.
R Lalitha @ R Sandhya.W/o R. Sudhakar, Aged 51 years Occ. Housewife
Ryo H.No.'1-7-100l14, Plot No.112, Reddy Enclave, Tempte Alwat,
Secunderabad.
15. B. Ramesh, S/o B. Pentaiah, Aged 48 years Occ. Business FJo H.No.7-.13,
Balanagar, Shetipally Kalan Mandal, Medak Diskict.
16.M. Narayan Reddy, S/o Hanumanth Reddy, Aqed 12 vears Occ. Aoriculture
RJo H.No.3-5-170, AJ5, Narayanaguda, yMCA, Hyderabad.
1 7.
Joginipelly_Raj. 9.op?L Rqo, Slo J.Thirupathi Rao, aged 65 years, Occ:
Business, R/o. H.No..1 0-1-246, Ramnagar, Karimnagar, Dist: Karimnagar.
...RESPONOENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pteased to
vacate the interim direction in l.A.No.1 of 2018 in Wp No.16424 of 2O1B granted
-,/
on 18.06.2018 rn and dismiss the writ petition with costs, pr nding disposal of the
writ petition.
IA NO: 3 OF 2024
Between:
1. Nemar_ugommula Venkateshwar Rao, S/o N. Ranrci lrder Rao, aged 61
years Occ. Business R/o Presidency Avenue, Road Nc. ', A wal, Hyderabad.
2 Patlori Suresh Kumar, S/o P. Hanmanth Rao, Aged 4 2 years Occ. Employee
R/o Flat No.402, Patloori Amrutha Residency, [\.4arr, 2rpr- ram Colony, 0ld
AIwal, Hyderabad.
3 Dr. Vamsi Priya Aravally, W/o Sumanth Balguri Agec l7 l/ears Occ. Doctor
Rep b1r her GPA namely Sri. B. Sudhakar Rao Sio ,,,lathar Rao, aged 65
years Orcc.. Business R/o Flat No.405, Laxmi Ganapatf i \ilayam, Central part,
Kompally, Hyderabad.
4. Devendar Rendla, S/o Mallaiah, Aged 50 years Occ lusiness R/o H.No.610511|N2OA, Godavari Homes, Jeedimetla, Hyderaba( .
5 Q, Ram Reddy, S/o late B. Malla Reddy, Aged 56 ye : .s Occ. Business Rt/o
23-6-897 / 4, Laldarwaza, Hyderabad.
6. Gandra Sugunakar Rao, S/o G. Sugreeva Rao, Aged 1) years Occ Business
Rl/o H.No.7-6-86/1, Vidya Nagar, Jagtiat, Dist. Jagtiat
7 Koya Anthony, S/o Koya Rajaiah Aged 76 years Occ r Jrictlture R/o H.No.21-407, Flat No.103, Shanthi Apartments, Nallakunta, Hy lerabad.
8. Joginipally Harender Rao, S/o J. Ananda Rao, Aged;'j years Occ. Business
R/o H.No.5-1 33173 and 74, Flat No.301 , Venka-iesh I r.a Residency, Road
No.2, Mangapuram Colony, Old Alwal, Hyderabad.
9. R. Lalitha @ R. Sandhya, W/o R. Sudhakar, Aged 51 ears Occ Housewife
ry" H.No.1 -7-100114, Plot No.'1 12, Reddy EnrtLve, Temple Alwal,
Secunderabad.
10. B. Ramesh, S/o B. Pentaiah, Aged 48 years Occ. B r lness R:/o H.No.7-13,
Balanagar, Shetipally Kalan Mandal, Medak District.
11 Y; ry?fy{_Re_d-dy, S/o Hanumanth Reddy, Aged tZ e,ars Occ. Agricutture
Rl/o H.No.3-5-170, AJ5, Narayanaguda, YMCA, HyderaL rJ.
...PETITIONERS
AND
Ra1e9!rya1 Rao, S/o.. Late S. Ramdas. Ar1, ct about 49 years,
Q.
No. 1-24-282,
lndira Nagar Colony, Lothkunta, Alwal ll rr;underabad.
2 $ Vinod Kumar, S/o. Late S. Ramdas. Aged about 4t yeas, cUo. 1-24-282,
lndira Nagar Colony, Lothkunta, Alwal, Secunderabad
J ! Dhal Raj, S{o T- Narasimha Rao, aged about 59 years, Rl/o.132-2RT,
Prakash Nagar Colony, Begumpet, Secunderabad.
4 H.L.Srinivas, S/o.H.Lakshminatayana, aged about 3 ) years, oUoJ-24-212,
lndiara Nagar Colony, Lothukunta, Alwal, Secunderabi r
-7
5. The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, Rep. by its Commissioner,
M.C.H. Buildings, Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
6. The Zonal Commissioner of G.H.tV.C, North Zone, Secunderabad.
7. The Deputy Commissioner of G.H.M.C, Commissioner, Alwal Circle 27, Alwal,
Secunderabad.
8. The Sub-Registrar, Registration Office, Vallabh Nagar, Begumpet, Prakash
Nagar, Secunderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
Vacate the lnterim Order date 18-06-2018 passed in LA.No.1 of 2018 in
W.P.No. l6424 of 2018 the interests of lustice and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI TARUN G.REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 to 3: SRI K.RAVI MAHENDER, SC FOR GHMC
Counsel forthe Respondent No.4: GP FOR STAMPS & REGISTRATION
Counsel for the Respondent No.5 to 16: SRI T.V.RAMANA RAO
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OII TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARIi
ALISHETTY
"A.NA
WRIT PETITION No.16424 of Z) !9
DATED: 27.01.2o26
Between:
S.Rameshwar Rao and 4 others
.. Petitioners
AND
The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation,
Rep. by its Commissioner, M.C.H.Buildings,
Tank Bund, Hyderabad and 3 others.
. Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed to declare the inact on of respondents
in considering the representations dated 02.12:O1,1, 06.12.2013,
t7.o2.20t4, 04.1,2.2014, 29.12.2014, 05.01.:t,)t5, 21.12.2015,
21.O4.2OI7 and 25.1O.2O 17, submitt6d by l,f r petitioners and
allowing illegal constructions in pelitioner's lar-r,l ; to an extent of
Acs.13 - 22 gts in Sy.Nos.592 and 593 part, srt_ rterl at Old Alwal
Village (Saibaba Nagar), Alwal Circle, Alwal I landal, MedchalMaikajgiri District, without any valid permission f r r:n the competent
authorit5r as illegal, arbitrary and contrary to he provisions of
G.H.M.C Act and for consequential relief.
I,NA,J
W.P.No.l6424 of 2018
2.
Heard Sri Tarun G.Reddy, learned Counsel for petitioners, Sri
K.Ravi Mahender, learned Standing Counsel for respondent Nos. I to
3 and Sri T.V.Ramana Rao, learned Counsel for respondent Nos.S to
16.
3.
L,earned Counsel for the petitioners would submit that
originally, one Palla Narsimham, who is the grandfather of petitioners
herein was the owner and possessor of land admeasuring Acs. 18 - O1
gts, having acquired the same through a compromise decree dated
20.10.1978, in a partition suit t,,,ide o.S.No.8O of 1963, between his
brothers; that he executed Family Settlement Deed dated
17.O7.1980, between himself, his son and 7 daughters, as per which,
Ac. 1 - OO gts was allotted to each daughter and the remaining to his
son P.Vishwshwar Rao, however the properry u'as not partitioned by
metes and bounds and the same !\.as in joint possession of
petitioners' family; that after the demise of Palla Narsimham, as
disputes arose between the family members of the petitioners, they
were compelled to approach the Court by way of hling a suit uide
O.S.No.206 of 2008, on the hle Principal District Judge, Malkajgiri
District, for partition of subject property and the same was pending
adjudication.
-
'1
LNA,J
P.No 16121 of 2018
4.
Learned Counsel for petitioners furthc- sr.rbmitted that
petitioners neither sold the subject property to ar y third party nor
executed General Power of Attorney (G.P.A) or zLrr. authorization in
favour of anybody including P.Vishweshwara Rao .r-rd never apptied
for conversion of subject land from agriculture t I non-agriculture
and also not submitted any layout plan before corr I otent authorities,
however, several unauthorized persons/encroaarl ri-s occupied the
sLlbject property and obtained permissions [,)- construction by
submitting false and fabricated documents arr i rnaking illegal
cons[ructions in the subject property. The mu - r:ipal authorities
without verifying the title to the property anc link documents,
granting permissions for constructions; that pct i ioners submitLed
several representations dated 02. 12.2013, 06. 72.2 ) la',, 17 .O2.2O I 4,
04.12.2014, 29.12 2014, 05.01.2015, 21,12.201: . 21.O8.2O17 and
25.10.2017, to respondents Corporation to take -j rticn against the
illegal constructions being made in the subjecr roperty, but the
same were not considered by the respondents CorJr, r.ation. Aggrieved
by the same, present writ petition is filed.
5.
Per contra, iearned Counsel for respondent \ ts.lj to 16 would
submit that respondent Nos.5 to 16 are bona fidl:1 uLrchasers of plot
which are developed in the subject property, hav I gJ paid valid sale
LNA,J
ll/.P.No.16424 of 2018
consideration to their vendors; that the vendors of the respondent
Nos.S to 16 started purchasing the subject plots from the year 2OO0
i.e., much prior to the filing of suit uide O.S.No.206 of 2OO8 and the
plot owners formed into a Sociely named as 'Sai Baba Nagar Welfare
Association' and number of houses were constructed by duly
obtaining building permissions from the respondents Corporation
much prior to the interim Orders passed by this Court. He placed on
record, copies of registered sale deeds, basing on which, respondent
Nos.S to 16 are claiming right over the subject property-
6.
Learned Standing Counsel for respondent Nos. 1 to 3 by
referring to the Counter would submit that the suit hled by the
children of P.Narasimh arr^, uide O.S.No.206 of 2008, on the file of
Principal District Judge, Malkajgiri District, for partition of subject
property was dismissed on 2l .Oq .2022, r't'ith the following
observation:
'On careful perusal of euidence of P.W. 1 and P.W'2 read
tuith Exs.Al to A16 and Exs'B 1 to 825, it categoically
established the fact that plaintiffs ond defendants acted
upon the Fomilg Settlement .Deed, occordinglg theg
conuerted the tand into plots and sold autoy the same to
uaious people and that tLte prospectiue purchasers are in
possession of the said land and tlrcre is no land as such as
suit scLedule propertA and the plaintiffs herein failed to
establish that theg uere not giuen possession of the land as
per tfle Familg Settlement Deed as such the plaintiffs are not
LNA,J
LV.f'.No.16424 of 2018
entitled for ong partition of the suit schedu,t properties as
praged for u.then there is no partition, the qu:;i,.ion of shares
does not aise ot aII and issue No.2 and 3 is n :i'd ogainst the
plaintiffs and in fauour of defendant."
7.
Learned Standing Counsel for respondent rlos.1 to 3 further
submits that in view above findings, petitioners a..r nct the owners of
the subject properly; that the total land covered
rL Siy.Nos.592 and
593 is Acs.27 - 14 gts, whereas, petitioners are clrt rning interest over
Acs. 13 - 22 gts rn the said survey numbers, and .r 1ve not mentioned
the boundaries of the land being claimed by the I ; that unless and
until petitioners identify their land on ground ancl 3re,lt a compound
wall or fencing, it is very difficult for the responder ts ()orporation for
not considering the applications for grant of builclir g permissions. He
further submitted that large number of houses we: ' constructed over
the subject property much prior to the interim Orrl rrs passed by this
Court and i[ is for the petitioners to safeguard thei prlperty; that as
and u.hen a person approaches respondentl; Crrrporation by
submitting a copy of registered sale deecl, the respondent
Corporation would grant permissions for constrrr: ion based on the
prima facie title and possession of such appli r(rnt. He further
submitted that petitioners did not furnish F rticulars of the
z
unauthorized constructions and that the responder ts tlorporation is
neither empowered nor dut5r bound to get into the .itle issues of the
LNA,J
W.P.No.l6424 of 2018
petitioners and the alleged encroachers and prayed to dismiss the
writ petition as the same is devoid of any merit.
8.
Admittedly, there is no dispute regarding filing of suiL uide
O.S.No.206 of 2008, for partition, by the children of late
P. Narasimham
and dismissal of the suit by the trial Court uide
Judgment and decree dated 2LO9.2O22, and though an appeal in
A.S.No.245 of 2023 has been preferred, against the said Judgment
before this Court the same is pending adjudication. In the Judgment
and decree dated 21.09.2022, the trial Court specihcally observed
that petitioners' family members acted upon the Family Settlement
Deed dated 17.07 .1980 and converted the land into plots and sold
away the same to third parties ald that prospective purchasers are
in possession of their respective plots and there is no land as such of
plaint schedule property and thus, the petitioners have no right over
the lands in Sy.Nos.592 and 593 as claimed by them. Even in the
writ petition, petitioners neither mentioned the boundaries of the
subject propert5r nor gave the details of the encroachers as aileged by
petitioners, therefore, without identifying or locating their land,
petitioners cannot seek any reiief in the writ petition. Further, third
party rights have already been created in respect of the subject
property in the year 2O00 onwards and the subsequent purchasers
LNA,J
lr I'No.16424 of2018
i.e., respondent Nos.s to 16 after obtaining ne( ( ssary permissions
from the respondents Corporation, constructed ,.ouses and are in
possession of their respective houses.
9.
The respondent Nos.5 to 16 have placed <,; record, copies of
registered sale deeds and building permissions ot t,ained by them in
respect of their properties to prove their ownersl- :p and possession
and thus, the contention of the petitioners that Jrird parties have
encroached upon the subject property and have I ardr: constructions
without any valid permissions is untenable. The ret;tioners cannot
seek direction to the respondents Corporat rL not lo granl
<
permissions to third parties in respect of slL rject property by
submitting representations, without establishin ; their title and
possession over the subject property. From the re :orC, it is evident
that the saies in respect of subject property havr: taken place since
2000 and structr-lres have been raised by thr: purchasers duly
obtaining permission from GHMC and whereas, srr : for partition was
hled in the year 2OO8. Furthermore, from the co ries of sale deeds
and photographs placed on record, it is evident Lhat the subject
property has been developed and has been convertr 1 into plots and it
is no more an agricultural land even prior to fili rg of the suit for
partition, however, in the suit, the subject pr rperty has been
.-
LNA.J
W.P.No.l6424 of 2018
mentioned as agricultural 1and. Though, Appeal in A.S.No.245 of
2023 is hled aggrieved by the dismissal of suit i.e., O.S.No.2O6 of
2008, before this Court and the same is pending adjudication.
10. It is appropriate to note that it is a settled principle of law that
while granting permission for construction, the Commissioner,
GHMC has to only consider the prima facie title and possession of the
applicant in respect of the property for which permission for
construction has been sought for and the Commissioner cannot go
into the disputed question of title of the property and adjudicate the
same.
11. In Hgderabad. Potteries Priaate Limited u. Collector,
Hgd.erabadt the erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh held that
the Commissioner is not empowered to decide any disputed questions
ol title or the ownership over the properfy and he is only entitle to
proceed on the basis of prima facie title of the applicant seeking
permission.
12.
lr K. Pauan Raj o. The Municipal Corporation of
Hgderabadz the erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh held that
' zoot il; ,Lt-o ooo
'2008 (r) ArD 792
LNA,J
t4/.P.No.16124 of 2018
the Commissioner therefore cannot be compelle<l to decide the title
dispute if it is complex in nature and he is entitlc r to proceed on the
basis of prima facie title of the applicant for grant r f permission.
13. The Commissioner on being satisfied that tt spondent Nos.5 to
16 have pima facie title and possession over ttr subject property,
has granted the building permission. Furthermo -, , this Court while
exercising the ivrit jurisdiction under Article 226 of Constitution of
India cannot go into disputed question of facts arr [itle disputes and
also cannot sit in appeal over the decision o1 a,n administrative
aul hority, i.e., Commissioner in granting permissi: r
14. In the light of foregoing discussion and the egzrl position, this
Court is ol the considered opinion that the writ r :r-iU on is devoid of
any merit and is liable to be dismissed.
15. In the result, the rvrit petition is dismissec. 'lhere shall be no
Order as to costs.
Sd/-C.DEEPIKA
AS S STANT REGISTRAR
,/-..
//TRUE COPY//
SETCTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SRI TARUN G REDDY, Advocate [OPUC]
2. One CC to SRI T.V.RAIUANA, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to SRI K.RAVI MAHENDER, SC FOR GHMC l( PU,3l
4. Two CCs to GP FOR STAMPS & REGISTRATION, Fi, ir Crourt for the State
of Telangana at Hyderabad [OUT]
5. Two CD Copies
BSR
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2710112026
t
( oR
ORDER
WP.No.16424 ot 2018
C)
1 -l: Ii hl ,
?at1ln?t
t
*
s!t.: 1 - i-tll'
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
ao lal*t
I
.l
+v
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review