The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
04. 11.2022 and 16.05.2023 respectively are hereby set aside. Consequently, it is directed that the Project Officer, Women and Child Development Project shall 7:14:42 PM immediately make appointment of the petitioner on the post of Aanganwadi Sahayika at Aanganwadi Centre Khejramaphi, Gram Panchayat Khejramaphi, Tahsil Jaisinagar, District Sagar.
14. With the aforesaid observations, the petition filed by the petitioner stands allowed.
15. Pending interlocutory application, if any, shall stand disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANJAY DWIVEDI
ON THE 17th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 13338 of 2023
BETWEEN:ROSHNI PATEL D/O SHRI RAMNATH PATEL, AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION: AANGANWADI
SAHAYIKA,
GRAM
PANCHAYAT KHEJRAMAPHI,
TAHSIL JAISINAGAR, DISTRICT SAGAR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI D.K. DIXIT - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
THE SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF WOMEN AND
CHILD DEVELOPMENT PROJECT, MANTRALAYA,
VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
COM M ISSION ER , SAGAR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
ADDITIONAL COLLECTOR SAGAR, DISTT. SAGAR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
PROJECT OFFICER, WOMEN AND CHILD
DEVELOPMENT PROJECT, TAHSIL JAISINAGAR,
DISTT. SAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
TULSA PATEL D/O SHRI NARAYAN PATEL, R/O
VILLAGE KHEJRAMAPHI, JAISINGAGAR, DISTT.
SAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
ANAMIKA D/O MAAN SINGH RAJPUT, R/O
VILLAGE KHEJRAMAPHI, JAISINAGAR, DISTT.
SAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
DIVISION,
SAGAR
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI AMIT GARG - PANEL LAWYER FOR RESPONDENT NOS.1 TO
4/STATE)
Signed by: ANIL
CHOUDHARY
Signing time: 1/23/2024
7:14:42 PM
(NONE FOR RESPONDENT NO.5)
(SHRI SHYAM YADAV - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.6)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
Pleadings are complete. With the consent of learned counsel for the
parties, the petition is finally heard.
2.
By the instant petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
the petitioner is challenging the order dated 16.05.2023 (Annexure-P/7) passed
by the Commissioner, Sagar Division, Sagar, whereby the appeal preferred by
the petitioner against the order dated 04.11.2022 passed by the Additional
Collector, has been rejected.
3.
The facts of the case in a nutshell are that the petitioner and respondent
Nos.5 and 6, all have submitted their applications in pursuance to the
advertisement issued for appointment of Aanganwadi Sahayika of Gram
Panchayat Khejramaphi, Tehsil Jaisinagar, District Sagar. Along with these
persons, other candidates have also applied and total 14 applications were
received. Thereafter, appointment was made in favour of the petitioner vide
order dated 26.07.2022. The petitioner joined the services in pursuance to her
appointment order on the same day i.e. 26.07.2022. However, the appointment
of the petitioner has been assailed by respondent No.5 before the Additional
Collector Sagar, who in turn, vide order dated 04.11.2022 not only rejected the
appeal, but accepted the counter claim of respondent No.6 cancelling the order
of appointment made in favour of the petitioner on 26.07.2022. The Additional
Collector has further directed that respondent No.6 be granted 60 marks in the
final merit list dated 21.04.2022 on the basis grading 'A' already given to her.
Resultantly, respondent No.6 came at Sr. No.1 and as such, became entitled to
Signed by: ANIL
CHOUDHARY
Signing time: 1/23/2024
7:14:42 PM
be appointed on the post of Aanganwadi Sahayika at Gram Panchayat
Khejramaphi because she was older in age.
4.
Thereafter, the said order of Additional Collector was further assailed in
second appeal before the Commissioner, Sagar Division, Sagar, but that was
dismissed vide order dated 16.05.2023. Hence, this petition challenging the
order of Commissioner, Sagar Division, Sagar as well as the Additional
Collector.
5.
Shri D.K. Dixit, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has founded
his claim mainly on the ground that the appeal decided by the Additional
Collector is without jurisdiction. He submits that as per the policy of
Aanganwadi Worker, if any appeal is preferred challenging the appointment of
Aanganwadi Worker/Sahayika, the same shall lie before the Collector and it
shall be decided by the Collector only. He further submits that the Additional
Collector has no authority to decide the appeal and, therefore, the order passed
by the Additional Collector is without jurisdiction. He has also assailed the
order on the ground that as per the chart prepared by the Selection Committee
comparing the merit of the candidates, the petitioner has been shown at Sr.
No.2 giving grading 'A' and as such, secured 80 marks whereas according to
him, respondent No.6 placed at Sr. No.1 and she was awarded grading on the
basis of marks secured by her and as such, in view of the circular dated
27.11.2020 (Annexure-P/9), the marks of respondent No.6 were calculated as
45.33 whereas the petitioner's marks as per the said list, shown as 80 marks.
Shri Dixit submits that there were other candidates secured same marks and
with a comparative assessment since the petitioner was meritorious, therefore,
appointed on the post of Aanganwadi Sahayika and her appointment was rightly
Signed by: ANIL
CHOUDHARY
Signing time: 1/23/2024
7:14:42 PM
made by the respondents. Although, he submits that the Additional Collector
misinterpreted the said circular dated 27.11.2020 and wrongly observed that
respondent No.6 is meritorious and as such, appointment on the post of
Aanganwadi Sahayika has to be made in favour of the petitioner and according
to Shri Dixit said finding is illegal and contrary to the provisions of the circular
dated 27.11.2020. In support of his submission, the counsel for the petitioner
has placed reliance upon a judgment reported in [2013(3) M.P.L.J. 386]
parties being K.K. Gupta vs. State of M.P. and others.
6.
The counsel for the State has supported the finding given by the
Additional Collector and Commissioner and submitted that nothing wrong is
committed by the said authorities while making comparative assessment holding
that respondent No.6 was meritorious.
7.
Shri Syam Yadav, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.6 in
response to the submission made by Shri Dixit has submitted that the order
passed by the Additional Collector cannot be said to be an order passed by the
incompetent authority for the reason that even in M.P. Land Revenue Code,
1959 when appeal preferred to the Collector, the same is decided by the
Additional Collector. Meaning thereby, the Collector must have delegated the
power to the Additional Collector under which he has decided the appeal,
therefore, nothing wrong is committed by the Additional Collector and order
deciding the appeal cannot be said to be without jurisdiction. He has further
submitted that though the appeal challenging the appointment of the petitioner
has not been preferred by respondent No.6, but in an appeal preferred by
respondent No.5, a counter claim was also raised by respondent No.6 and that
counter claim was considered and allowed by the Additional Collector holding
that respondent No.6 is meritorious and as such, appointment was directed to
Signed by: ANIL
CHOUDHARY
Signing time: 1/23/2024
7:14:42 PM
be made in her favour. He has further submitted that though there is no
provision for filing counter claim, but ultimately had a counter claim not been
there, the Additional Collector would have decided the appeal holding the
entitlement of the candidate to have been appointed on the post of Aanganwadi
Sahayika. He has submitted that nothing illegal is done by the Additional
Collector entertaining the counter claim and holding that respondent No.6 is
meritorious and entitled to be appointed on the post of Aanganwadi Sahayika.
8.
Considering the rival submissions made by the counsel for the parties and
perusal of record, especially the circular dated 27.11.2020, which is a
clarificatory circular, it is clear that if a mark-sheet issued awarding grading
instead of marks, as to in what manner the selection would be made. It also
clarifies that if mark-sheet is issued on the basis of marks, then as to how
calculation would be made awarding marks to the candidates.
9.
As per Shri Dixit, the total marks awarded to respondent No.6 as per the
Caluse-IV of the said clarificatory circular were 45.33 whereas in a comparative
chart, the marks of the petitioner has been shown 80 marks and according to
him, the petitioner should have placed at Sr. No.1 as she was meritorious
candidate for the reason that other candidates who have secured same marks
when comparatively assessed, the petitioner was found a meritorious candidate
and therefore, given weightage and as such, she was entitled to have been
appointed. The Additional Collector, therefore, misinterpreted the said circular
and instead of placing the petitioner, placed respondent No.6 at Sr. No.1
holding her meritorious.
10.
Thus, in my opinion, the finding given by the Additional Collector is not
proper and it is contrary to the provisions of the clarificatory circular dated
27.11.2020. Even otherwise, the order of Additional Collector deciding the
Signed by: ANIL
CHOUDHARY
Signing time: 1/23/2024
7:14:42 PM
appeal wherein the order of appointment of Aanganwadi Sahayika was
questioned is otherwise not proper for the reason that the scheme of
Aanganwadi Sahayika very clearly provides that if any challenge is made to the
appointment, the appeal shall lie to the Collector and the Collector is the only
authority which can decide the appeal, but no other authority having power to
do so. Even if the submission made by the counsel for respondent No.6 is
accepted, the said submission is contrary to law because the law very
categorically provides that a power delegated to a particular authority cannot be
re-delegated to other.
11.
The case in which the counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance i.e.
K.K. Gupta (supra), this Court has held that the authority which is earmarked
to do a particular thing in a particular manner, in its place, the other authority
even holding current charge cannot perform said statutory function.
12.
Further, the Supreme Court in a case reported in AIR 1967 SC 295
(Barium Chemicals Ltd. and Aother vs. Company Law Board and
Others), has observed as under:"36. As a general rule, whatever a person has
power to do himself, he may do by means of an agent.
This broad rule is limited by the operation of the principle
that a delegated authority cannot be re-delegated,
delegatus non potest delegare. The naming of a delegate
to do an act involving a discretion indicates that the
delegate was selected because of his peculiar skill and the
confidence reposed in him, and there is a presumption that
he is required to do the act himself and cannot re-delegate
Signed by: ANIL
CHOUDHARY
Signing time: 1/23/2024
7:14:42 PM
his authority. As a general rule, "if the statute directs that
certain acts shall be done in a specified manner or by
certain persons, their performance in any other manner
than that specified or by any other person than one of
those named is impliedly prohibited". See Crawford on
Statutory Construction, 1940 Edn., Article 195, p. 335.
Normally, a discretion entrusted by Parliament to an
administrative organ must be exercised by that organ
itself. If a statute entrusts an administrative function
involving the exercise of a discretion to a Board consisting
of two or more persons it is to be presumed that each
member of the Board should exercise his individual
judgment on the matter and all the members of the Board
should act together and arrive at a joint decision. Prima
facie, the Board must act as a whole and cannot delegate
its function to one of its members."
13.
Considering the aforesaid, performing the function of Collector deciding
the appeal of Aanganwadi Sahayika by the Additional Collector, in my opinion,
is not proper and said order can be considered to be without jurisdiction. If the
order of Additional Collector goes, the subsequent order passed by the
Commissioner would automatically fall as such, this petition is allowed. The
order passed by the Additional Collector and the Commissioner dated
04.11.2022 and 16.05.2023 respectively are hereby set aside. Consequently, it is
directed that the Project Officer, Women and Child Development Project shall
Signed by: ANIL
CHOUDHARY
Signing time: 1/23/2024
7:14:42 PM
immediately make appointment of the petitioner on the post of Aanganwadi
Sahayika at Aanganwadi Centre Khejramaphi, Gram Panchayat Khejramaphi,
Tahsil Jaisinagar, District Sagar.
14.
With the aforesaid observations, the petition filed by the petitioner stands
allowed.
15.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, shall stand disposed of.
(SANJAY DWIVEDI)
JUDGE
ac/-
Signed by: ANIL
CHOUDHARY
Signing time: 1/23/2024
7:14:42 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review