Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 3485 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI
RAO
WRIT PETI TION NO: 349 45 0F 2015
Between:
1. Roop Karan Sanghi, S/o Late Sri B?ir?ng Prasad Sanghi. Aged about
years, Occ. Business, Rl/o Sri La ks .hmr Nivas,
5-2-58311. Road No. 7, Banlara
Hitts, Hyderabad - 34.
Smt. Ivlaniu R Sanqhi. W/o Sri. Rajendra prasad Sanghi,
Aged 55 years, Om
Housewife, Ryo Sri Lakshmi Mvjs, s_7_sas7; R;";'
/, Banjara Hils,
Hyderabad - 34.
il;
...PETITIONERS
AND
represented by principat Secretary, Ivtunrcipat
il*g,^.JJ^EllSSna
Aomrntstratton
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
Greater_ Hyderabad Municipal Corpn., Rep. by its
Road, Hyderabad.
Commissioner, Tank Bond
Hyderabad Metrooolitan Water Works & Sewerage Board.
It4anaging Directoi, project Division -VL Sitr"-t"i'rtt
rep. by its
H-trrgr,, Hyderabad
Hyderabad Metrooolitan Develop.m_ent Authority, rep. by its
Managing
Director, siruated'at Btock _ A, HntoA coiip-iei'iIini(a,'"rrvoerauaa
The Commissioner of police, Cyberabad, Hyderabad.,
o
Station House Officer, pet Basheerabad police Station, Ranga
Reddy District
Govt.of Telangana, rep. by its Executive engineer, Roads & Buildings
Dept.,
Lakdikapoot,Hyderabdd RZ is impleaded as per C.O. dt. 29-1O_15 in WpMp 45153
of 15
The District Collector, R_R. District, Lakdikapool, Hyderabad
R8 is impleaded as per C.O. dt.2i-4-11 in WpMp 13324
of 16
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arricre 226 0f the constitution of rndia praying
that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit titeu tnerewrth, the
High'cJurt
;;y b;
pleased toto issue a writ or order or direction,
more preferabr-y in the natuie of
writ of mandamus, declaring the action of the respondents 1 demolishing the
compound wall and digging the pits in the property admeasur 1g Acs.4-00 gts in
Sy.No. 689/C and Acs.0-20 gts. in Sy. No. 14l3 part of C,r ndla Pochampally
Village, Medchal li,4andal, RR District, to the extent of 8 to '10 1 etres in depth and
12 to 15 ft. breadth, as illegal, arbitrary and unauthorizec and consequently
direct the respondents not to dismantle the compound wall o dig up the pits or
lay water pipeline in the petition schedule property, in the inter ,st of justice
l.A. NO: 1 OF 201S(WPMP. NO: 44908 OF 2015)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the cl. umstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court iay be pleased to
grant injunction restraining the responds, their men, agr-. ts, assignees or
anybody claiming through or under them from interfering ryith the peaceful
physical possession of the petition schedule property, relonging to the
petitioners or dismantling the boundary wall or digging up th( pits, laying water
pipe line in the property admeasuring Acs.4-00 gts in Sy.No 189/C and Acs.O20 gts. in Sy. No. .14l3 part of Gundla Pochampally Village, IVr dchal Mandal, RR
District to the extent of 8 to 10 metres in depth and 12 to 1) ft. breadth, in the
interest of JUstice pending disposal of the writ petition
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2!16(WPMP. NO: 35434 OF 2016)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the ci ( umstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court nay be pleased to
direct the respondent No 2 to conduct the survey of the lands i nd demarcate the
boundary of the petitioners property so as to enable the peli' oner to claim the
compensation in accordance with the law in the interest of justi e.
lA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the cirr rmstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court r ray be pleased to
expedite the date of hearing of the present writ petition. in the i terest of justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI SHARAD SANGHI
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI POTTIGARI SRIDHAR LEDDY, SPL. GP
REP. FORADDL. ADVOCI( E GENERAL
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI P. KESAVA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI T. SUDHAKAR REDD\'
(sc FoR HMWSSB)
Counsel for the Respondent No.4: SRI V. NARASIMHA GOUE,, SC FOR HMDA
Counsel for the Respondent No.5 & 6: GP FOR HOME
Counsel for the Respondent No.7: GP FOR ROADS & BUILDI\ 35
Counsel for the Respondent No.8: GP FOR REVENUE
The Court made the following: ORDER
l!
(IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
W,P.No.34945 of 2O15
Dt.og.o2.2026
Between:
Roop Karan Sanghi and alother
Petitioncrs
and
State of Telangana and othcrs
Re sponde nts
ORDER:
1.
The present Writ Petition has been filed to declare the action
of the rcspondcnts in demolishing the compound wall and digging
pits in the petitioners' propertv admeasuring Acres 4.00 guntas in
Sy.No.689/C and Acs.O.2 guntas in S1,.No.1413 part of Gunclla
Pochampally Village, Medchal Mandal, R.R.Distrct, to the extent of
8 to 10 metre s in depth and 12 to 15 ft. breadth, as il1ega1 and
arbitrary, and consequently direct the respondents not to
dismantle the compound wall or dig pits or lay water pipeline in
the subject property, in the interest ofjustice.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, the l"t petitioner is the
absolute owner and possessor of land admeasuring Acre 1.17
=.-+':+'--_-+
tl
guntas in sun,ey No 689/C and the !"a petition:. is the absolute
ou,ner and possessor ol land admeasuring Acr: 0.2O guntas in
sur\/c.v No.1.l/ll, both situated at Gundla poc.,rmpally Village,
Medchal Manrlitl, Ranga Reddl-District. The petiti r,ers purchased
their respecLive lands under registered salc decds bearing
Nos 8237119q0, dt 02 07.1990, and 923212OO,-'_ dr.0S.11.2OO2,
respectivel\.
3.
The grievzrnce ol the peritioners is that despir e they being the
absolute owlrers ancl possessors of the aforement i rnecl properties,
the respondcr)ts, \\ ithout follori,ing due proce j ; of lau., have
entered their land on 21 .1 0.20l S and demolisher the compound
wa-ll for digginq piLs. as such the petitioners ll.er r constrained to
Iile the insrarrr rr lir pcrition.
4.
Heard lt irrned counsel lor the petitionc r , Sri pottigari
Sridhar Reddl'. learned Special (iovernment pleac:r representing
the Office of thc Additional Advocate General for r< spondent No.1,
Si Veeresh Kunrerr, Iearned Standing Counsel for rr spondent No.3,
Sri V.Narasimha Goucl, learnecl Starding CouL sel for HMDA
appearing for respondent No.4, and perused the rec trd.
5.
When the matter Iirst came up for hearing , n 02 .1 1 .2015,
this court recorc'lecl the strbmissions of the then r. Lr.ned Advocate
o
General, who submitted that pits urere being lard in the said land
to
bring Godavari River water to the twin cities, and that on
23 .lO .2O 15
the water had been released from Yellampalli
Barrage(Godavari River) and so far n,aters travelled 90 kms, and
that the said r.vater may reach Hyderabad City in a few days(from
that date). He also stated that the land over which pits were dug
for laying pipelines was not privaLe land. Hou,ever, the said fact
has to bc ascertarned b1'conducting surveyand to show their bona
7tdes, this Court directed them to deposit a reasonable amount
and accordingly, the learned Advocate General produced a cheque
bearing No.753805 for Rs.75 iakhs in the narrre of the
Registrar(Judicial) of the High Court and the said cheque was
alleged to be deposited rvith the Registrar(Judicial)
6.
Further, a counter affidavit is also filed by the respondents
stating that the rough sketch maps of the disputed land were
prepared by the Board Engineers, and that pipelines were laid
within the 100 feet of R & B Road margin and even the alignment
map of the drinking water supply pipeline from Godavari Source
to Hyderabad, also showed that the Board laid pipeline within the
R & B Road margin. It was further stated that as a precautionary
measure, the Board has addressed the District Collector uide letLer
tl
l'
I
i
dt.29.10.2015 in Lr.No.F1l lO24Z
l2OtS/627a; requesting an
I
l
enquiry into the m:ttter to determine as
I
I
patta lar-rd or n,ithin the 100 ft road
i
l
to rvhetf er it is a private
margin oi. I l&B Authorities.
Further it is conter-rcled that if the said
prtvate lald. the District Collector
found to be a
has to inir.r rte proceedings
under the Act 6 of Telangana Domestic
Pipelines(Acquisitron of Right of User
lar'rcl
and Indur trial Water Grid
in Land) Act 20 15 (for short
'the Act) by issuing a notification, Ibr
objection I from the land
owners and r.letermr.ing the corrpensarion.
that the Boarcl has expressed its u,illing
as per the notificatio,, if it rias proved
It *,a s further stated
to pal, th I compensation
that the lz nd belonged to
the petitioners.
.lt is also stated in the counter alfidavit that ( i.O.Ms.No.149,
dt.27.O8.2O15, had been issued
bv the GovernrrL, nt prescribing
certain guidelines, a,d under both
the Acts, if thr. Collector finds
that the lanC where the pipelines u,ere
Board was willing to pay compensation
8.
in accordar< e with law.
Today, rn,hen the writ petition was
learneC counsel for the petitioners
laid was pr vate land, the
taken up li r hearing, the
vehemently cont_r nded that the
subject land belongecl to the petitioner
and the ar thorities high
handedly, wlthout follos-ing clue process
of lar,v, hzr. c demolished
)
the compound wall, dug pits, and laid pipelines rn the property for
the use of the Water Board
9.
On the other hernd, rhe lealned Special Government Pleader,
Sri Pottigari Sreedhar Recldy, submitted that the title and
possession of the petitioncrs has to be determined b1' conducting a
proper survey and demarcation of the land. He further submitted
that if the survey discloses that the subject land belonged to the
petitioners, the authorities s,ould invoke the applicable laws in
force as on the date o[ takir-rg possession and would pay
approprlatc compensatlon
10. The learned Special Government Pleader further submitted
that, as a result of the bilurcation of the revenue districts, at
present, the District Collector, Medchal Malkajgiri, is
the
appropriate authority to underlake and complete the said
exerclse
11. Since, the District Collector, Medchal Malka3giri, is suo moto
impleaded by this Court today as party respondent No.9, and the
\
said respondent is directed to conduct a survey by the Assistant
Director of Survey and Land Records Department with the aid of
Tippans and Survey Map, and determine whether the pits for
laying pipelines were dug in the petitioners' patta land or within
I
the 100 feet R & B road margir-t, as claimed br, ]rc respondents,
within a period of six (06) weeks from the date ol re<:t:ipt of a copy
of this order
12. Furrher r1. it is found that the pipelint:s r ert, Iaicl in the
pri'ate 1.,d b.longing to the pctitioners, thc l. i51;,1.1 collector,
Medchal Mall<a.jgiri, rs directe cl to initiate approJ. 1 iatc proceedings
undcr the Right to Fair Compensation anci Trerns rar-t.rrcv rn Land
Acqursition, Ilehabilitation eurd Resettlement
( t, 20 1
3 or any
other apltlicable lau s and pal compensation t.: thc petitioners
along u,ith er1;1;licable intcrcst , forthu,ith, si,c.t Lhc, mafter is
pending for o'c. a ctecade. Tl-re rcspondent No.Er/l- isL.ct Collector,
Medchal Malkajgiri, is directed to take steps as :xpr:ditiously as
possible in redt:ssal of the grievzrnce of the petirt(,r ers
i3' with the aborre directions, the writ petitiorr rs clisposed of.
No order as to costs.
As a seqr-rel thereto, miscellaneous petrtions, il an_v, pending
1) SCII K.BHAVANI SWAMY
shall stand closcd
ASS ISTANT REGISTRAR
'=--
//TRUE COPY//
\
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Principal Secretary, Municipal Administration Depirr ment, State of
Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2 The Commissioner, Greater Hyderabad lvlunicipal Coqrr , Tank Bond Road,
Hyderabad.
The Managing Director, Hyderabad Metro politan Water Vorks & Sewerage
Board, P roject Division - VI, Situated at S.R. Na gar, Hy c -.rabad.
4 The Managing Director, Hyderabad M etropolitan Devel c )ment Authority,
Situated a[ Block - A, HMDA Complex , Tarnaka, Hyder a rad.
The Commissioner of Police, Cyberab ad, Hyderabad
cer
Basheerab ad Police Station
rffi
- _:-,-
I iif.ffi:tll"r;J3[S:! Govr orreransana,
Roads and Buirdinss Dept,
iipjj$gffi [*ffi*$*i,1i*",."*0,,ru,"
f
:i#f,fi is,E[i8FH3x&?'J,',.",'rt'e!:,fi ;Jiilt,,;lifl sT.:,to#,,
l: iH?":"?i:?":[jIfilL9+-' SRTDHAR REDDY, sPL GP, Hish court ror the
" iH3,i#ir'",51?eovocAre GENERAL, Hish courr ror the state or
18. Two CD Coiies '
PMK
-:= -:.=-:l
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED:0910212026
S-i,.1,'1-E
o
ORDER
WP.No.34945 of 2015
O
1'i
2 0 t[B 2[U6
I
I
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
7rs
z--ftJue .
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review