Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
(1)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ROHIT ARYA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE AVANINDRA KUMAR SINGH
WRIT PETITION NO. 23060 OF 2023
BETWEEN :1. RAMNARESH @ RINKU KUSHWAH, S/O
RAMDAYAL KUSHWAH, AGED 30 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: STUDENT, R/O VILLAGE
PHOOLPURA POST DIPERA DISTRICTMORENA (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. DEEPAK JATAV, S/O ASHOK JATAV, AGED 20
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
STUDENT,
R/O
VILLAGE
DIPEHRA,
POST
DIPERA,
DISTRICT- MORENA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. SACHIN BAGHEL, S/O SHRI SURENDRA
SINGH, AGED 24 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
STUDENT, R/O VILLAGE GOHADI GOHAD,
TAHSIL AND POST GOHAD, DISTRICT- BHIND
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4. KU. TAPSYA KUTWARIYA, D/O SHRI
NARENDRA SINGH KUTWARIYA, AGED 23
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
STUDENT,
R/O
MUNSIYO KA MUHALLA, LAKKAD KHANSA
KAMPOO, LASHKAR, GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
5. VIKAS SINGH, S/O SHRI DHARMENDRA
SINGH, AGED 27 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
STUDENT, R/O VILLAGE AND POST MASURI,
DISTRICT- BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
(2)
…..PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI PRASHANT SINGH KAURAV- ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
THROUGH ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
COMMISSIONER, DEPARTMENT OF
MEDICAL EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF
MADHYA PRADESH,
6TH FLOOR,
SATPURA BHAWAN, ARERA HILLS
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF MEDICAL
EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF MADHYA
PRADESH,
6TH FLOOR, SATPURA
BHAWAN, ARERA HILLS, BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
COMMISSIONER, GWALIOR DIVISION,
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
….... RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI ANKUR MODY – ADDITIONAL ADVOCATE GENERAL)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
:
13/12/2023
Delivered on
:
12 /01/2024
This petition coming on for hearing this day, Hon'ble Shri
Justice Rohit Arya passed the following:
ORDER
This petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
filed by the petitioners, who were candidates in NEET (UG) 2023
Examination held on 07/05/2023 seeking the following reliefs:
“i-
That, the action/inaction of respondent department of
(3)
not allotting the MBBS Unreserved Category Government
School Quota Seats to the meritorious Reserved Category
Government School Quota candidate to be ex-facie illegal,
arbitrary and contrary to the provisions of law;
iiThat, respondent department may kindly be directed to
allot the MBBS seat of Unreserved Category Government
School Quota to the meritorious Reserved Category
Government School Quota candidate;
iii- That, respondent department may kindly be directed to
commence fresh counselling from Round 1 in regard to
Government School Quota for Unreserved and Reserved
candidate;
iv- That, it may be declared that action/inaction of
respondent department of not allotting the MBBS Unreserved
Category Government School Quota seats to the meritorious
Reserved Category Government School Quota candidate is in
violation to the dictum of Saurav Yadav & Others v. State of
Uttar Pradesh & Ors ((2021)4 SCC 542)
Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court deems fit in
the facts and circumstances of the case may also kindly be
granted”
Results were declared on 13/06/2023. After completion of counseling
successful candidates were allocated seats in respective colleges. No
seats are vacant. The aforesaid facts are recorded in the order passed by
this Court on 08/11/2023.
In the backdrop of the aforesaid facts, the writ petition is taken
up for decision. It is pertinent to mention that petitioners respectively
belong to OBC, SC, OBC, SC and EWS categories.
2.
Before adverting to the merits of rival contentions, it would be
expedient to extract the rule position governing the point in issue.
Department of Technical Education Skill and Training has framed
M.P.Chikitsa Shiksha Pravesh Niyam, 2018 which inter alia provide as
(4)
under :Rule- 1 laf{kIr uke vkSj izkjEHk-&
¼1½
bu fu;eksa dk laf{kIr uke e/;izns'k fpfdRlk f'k{kk izos'k fu;e]
2018 gSA
¼2½
;s fu;e e/;izns'k jkti= esa buds izdkf'kr gksus ds fnukad ls
izo`Rr gksaxsA
Rule 2 (B) defines as under:¼B½
^izoxZ* ls vfHkizsr gS] efgyk] Lora=rk laxzke lSukuh] lSfud
fnO;kax ,oa vfuoklh Hkkjrh; izoxZ(
Rule 2 ¼i½ defines for ^Js.kh* as under:¼i½
^Js.kh* ls vfHkizsr gS] vuqlwfpr tkfr] vuqlwfpr tutkfr] vU;
fiNM+k oxZ ,oa vukjf{kr Js.kh A
Rule 4 provides for reservation. Rule 4 (1) provides for
reservation Js.kho) and Rule 4 (2) defines reservation izoxZokj.
For ready reference, the said Rules are quoted below:
4.
vkj{k.k &
¼1½
Js.khokj vkj{k.k &
¼d½
Js.khokj vkj{k.k vuqlwph&2 ds [k.M ^v^ vuqlkj gksxk A
¼[k½
jkT; 'kklu ds fn'kk&funsZ'kksa ds rgr dzhehys;j dh ifjf/k esa
vkus okys vU; fiNMk oxZ Js.kh ds vH;FkhZ dks vkj{k.k dk ykHk ugha fn;k
tk,xkA
¼x½
dkmaflfyax ds f}rh; pdz esa vkjf{kr Js.kh fo'ks "k dk vgZrk/kkjh
iathd`r vH;FkhZ miyC/k ugha gksus dh n'kk esa izos'k gsrq vkoaVu fuEu dze ls
fd;k tk,xk%&
¼1½
vuqlwfpr tutkfr dh fjfDr;ksa ds in ds fo:) vuqlwfpr tkfr
(5)
ds vH;fFkZ;ksa dks;
¼2½
vuqlwfpr tkfr dh fjfDr;ksa ds fo:) vuqlwfpr tutkfr ds
vH;fFkZ;ksa dks;
¼3½
vuqlwfpr tutkfr ,oa vuqlwfpr tkfr ds fjfDr;ksa ds fo:) vU;
fiNMk oxZ ds vH;fFkZ;ksa dks; ,oa
¼4½
mijksDr rhuksa Jsf.k;ksa ds vkjf{kr vH;FkhZ miyC/k ugha gksus dh
n'kk esa] fjfDr;ksa ds fo:) vukjf{kr Js.kh ds vH;kfFkZ;ksa dks A
¼?k½
dkmaflfyax ds vafre pdz esa vkjf{kr Js.kh fo'ks "k dk vgZrk/kkjh
iathd`r vH;FkhZ miyC/k ugha gksus dh n'kk esa] ,slh Js.kh dh fjfDr;ksa ds fo:)
vukjf{kr Js.kh ds vH;fFkZ;ksa dks izos'k fn;k tk,xk A
[k.M&c izoxZokj vkj{k.k provides as under :-
[k.M&c izoxZokj vkj{k.k
izoxZ
IkkB~;dze ftlesa
ykxw gS
leLr
vfuoklh Hkkjrh;
vH;FkhZ
efgyk vH;FkhZ
leLr
fnO;kax vH;FkhZ
leLr
Lora=rk lsukuh ,e-ch-ch-,l- ,oa chvH;FkhZ
Mh-,llSfud vH;FkhZ ,e-ch-ch-,l- ,oa chMh-,l
egkfo|ky;
ftuesa ykxw gS
dsoy futh
egkfo|ky;ksa
leLr
egkfo|ky;ksa esa
dsoy 'kkldh;
egkfo|ky;ksa esa
dqy lhVksa
dk izfr'kr
The aforesaid Rules were further amended vide State notification
dated 19.06.2019. The definition of izoxZ and Js.kh was amended as
under :-
1mifu;e 2 ¼B½ rFkk 2 ¼i½ ds LFkku ij] dze'k% fuEufyf[kr
mifu;e LFkkfir fd, tk,a vFkkZr%&
(6)
¼B½
^^izoxZ^^ ls vfHkizsr gS] efgyk] Lora= laxzke] lsukuh ,oa fnO;kax
izoxZ
¼i½ ^Js.kh^ ls vfHkizsr gS] vuqlwfpr tkfr] vuqlwfpr tutkfr] vU;
fiNM+k oxZ vkfFkZd :i ls detksj oxZ (EWS) ,oa vukjf{kr Js.kh
2fu;e 4 ds mifu;e ¼2½ ds LFkku ij] fuEufyf[kr mifu;e
LFkkfir fd;k tk, vFkkZr%&
^^¼2½ ^^izoxZokj vkj{k.k%&
¼d½
izoxZokj vkj{k.k vuqlwph&2 ds [k.M &^c^ ds vuqlkj
gksxk
¼[k½
izFker izoxZokj vkj{k.k dh fjfDr;ka Js.khokj u gksdj
dqy fjfDr;ksa ds vk/kkj ij fu/kkZfjr dh tk;sxh rRi'pkr bu fjfDr;ksa ij
fu/kkZfjr Js.khokj vkj{k.k ykxw fd;k tkdj fofHkUu Jsf.k;ksa esa foHkkftr fd;k
tk;sxk(x½
dkmaflfyax ds f}rh; pdz ¼ekWi vi pj.k½ esa izoxZ fo'ks"k
ds vgZr/kkjh iathd`r vH;FkhZ miyC/k ugha gksus dh n'kk esa izoxZ fo'ks"k dh
fjfDr;ka vkoaVu gsrq lacaf/kr Js.kh ds iathd`r vH;kfFkZ;ksa dks Lor% vkoaVu gsrq
miyC/k gks tk;sxhThere was further amendment by way of notification dated
10/05/2023, wherein the definition of (B½ izoxZ was further revised as
under :-
¼B½
^^izoxZ^^ ls vfHkizsr gS] efgyk] Lora=rk laxzke lsukuh] lSfud]
fnO;kax] vfuoklh Hkkjrh; izoxZ ,oa 'kkldh; fo|ky; ds fo|kFkhZ(
2-
fu;e 2 ds mifu;e ¼i½ ds i'pkr~ fuEufyf[kr mifu;e
tksM+s tk,a] vFkkZr~%&
^^¼Q½ ^^'kkldh; fo|ky;** ls vfHkizsr gS] e/;izns'k 'kklu }kjk
lapkfyr 'kkldh; fo|ky;**(
¼c½ ^^'kkldh; fo|ky; ds fo|kFkhZ** ls vfHkizsr gS] ,sls fo|kFkhZ
ftUgksaus 'kkldh; fo|ky; esa d{kk 6oha ls 12oha rd fu;fer v/;;u dj
ijh{kk mRrh.kZ dh gks vFkok f'k{kk dk vf/kdkj vf/kfu;e ds ek/;e ls izos'k
ds vk/kkj ij d{kk 1 ls 8oha rd futh fo|ky;ksa esa v/;;u djus ds i'pkr~
'kkldh; fo|ky; esa d{kk 9oha ls 12oha rd fu;fer v/;;u dj ijh{kk
(7)
mRrh.kZ dh gks-**
Accordingly the corresponding Schedule II [k.M&c was revised,
which is as under :-
4- vuqlwph ds fo|eku [k.M ¼c½ dh lkj.kh ds LFkku ij fuEufyf[kr
lkj.kh LFkkfir dh tk,%&
^^izoxZ
¼1½
ikB;dze ftlesa ykxw gS egkfo|ky; ftlesa ykxw
¼2½
gS
¼3½
efgyk vH;FkhZ
leLr
leLr egkfo|ky;ksa esa
fnO;kax vH;FkhZ
leLr
leLr egkfo|ky;ksa esa
Lora=rk laxzke ,echch,l ,oa chMh,l
dsoy 'kkldh;
lsukuh vH;FkhZ
egkfo?kky;
lSfud vH;FkhZ ,echch,l ,oa chMh,l
dsoy 'kkldh;
egkfo|ky;
'kkldh;
,echch,l ,oa chMh,l leLr 'kkldh; ,oa
fo|ky; ds
futh egkfo|ky;
fo|kFkhZ
dqy
lhVksa
dk
izfr'kr
¼4½
5^^
The procedure for filling-up of the vacancies as amended by
notification dated 19/06/2019 is relevant for the present case. As per
the revised procedure firstly percentage of vacancies shall be worked
out on the basis of class-wise (izoxZ) reservation and not category-wise
reservation (Js.kh) out of total vacancies. Thereafter, such vacancies
shall be further divided into the proportionate number of category-wise
vacancies. For instance; in the instant case the vacancies were
classified in the following manner :
(8)
Bifurcation of MBBS Seats Reserved for Government School Quota for Admission Through Neet UG 2023
SC
ST
16%
Govt
Govt.
open seats
% of
reservation
20%
Pvt
Private
open seats
OBC
Govt
14%
Pvt
EWS
Govt
Total
Pvt
Govt Pvt
Govt
Remarks
Seats Govt.
& Pvt.
10%
UR
No
E
W
S
Qu
ota
Pvt
Govt
Pvt
Women Reservation is against all available seats across all category and class. There is no earmarked seat for women. There
were 2004 female admissions against 4308 total available seats 46.51 %.
Ex
Army (SN)
available only
in Govt.
Medical
Colleges
80 SN
admissions.
Total Ex
army seats
(SN) 58
MBBS seats
Freedom
Fighter (FF)
seats available
only in Govt.
Medical
Colleges
15 FF
Admissions.
Total FF
seats 57
MBBS seats
Handicapped
(PWD) in Govt.
and Pvt.
Medical
Colleges
40 PWD
Admissions.
Total PWD
197 seats
GS
(Government
School) in
Govt. and Pvt.
Medical
Colleges
197 GS
admissions.
Total GS
Seats 197
1908 2034
Total Seats
Note : 366 NRI seats in private medical colleges not included in chart.
Thereafter, under Rule 2 (x) after completion of given number of
counseling round in the last mop up round if vacancies in the particular
class are available, the vacant seats shall be transferred to other
candidates in that category notwithstanding the class i.e. izoxZokj. In
other words, in the aforesaid given chart if 89 candidates are not
available in unreserved government schools, the remaining seats shall
(9)
be transferred to the open category and likewise if 41 ST candidates are
not available the remaining seats shall be transferred to ST category
etc. to be filled up in vertical reservation. In the instant case, as against
89 unreserved seats for Government schools only 12 students were
found to be above the cut off marks. As a result, remaining 77 seats
were transferred to open category in vertical reservation.
Petitioners scored the marks as under:Petitioner No.1
Petitioner No.2
Petitioner No.3
Petitioner No.4
Petitioner No.5
The validity of amended Rules (vide notification dt.19/6/2019)
have not been challenged.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that all the
candidates ought to have been considered firstly under unreserved
category and if they have not been able to compete securing less than
cut off marks, they could have been considered for the respective
reserved category as has been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of Saurav Yadav and others Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and
others [2021) 4 SCC 542]. According to him, petitioners since have
secured more marks than the the last candidate admitted under the
unreserved category school all should have been admitted in the said
category. That having not been done, they have been subjected to
typical hostility in violation of their fundamental right under Article 14
of the Constitution of India.
(10)
4.
Per contra, Shri Mody submits that by way of amendment by
notification dated 19/06/2019, the procedure for filling up Neet (UG)
examination has been revised. Vacancies are required to be filled up by
providing izoxZokj vkj{k.k i.e. class-wise reservation in contradistinction
to category-wise reservation as in vogue in common parlance.
As discussed above, after division of vacancies percentage-wise
in different classes, as reservation has been provided to different
categories in each class with the provision that in case candidates of a
given category in the said class are not available, those vacancies shall
be transferred to the same respective category for filling up under the
vertical reservation. In the instant case as only 12 students could
qualify from amongst the unreserved government school class the
remaining seats were transferred to general category to be filled under
vertical reservation. He submits that 89 seats earmarked for unreserved
(government school) category firstly were required to be filled up from
amongst the unreserved category having more marks than the cut off
marks. He therefore submits that since only 12 unreserved category
candidates could cross the cut off marks they have been given
admission against 89 vacancies. Remaining 77 vacancies were
transferred to open category or unreserved category in vertical
reservation, though there has been no occasion of such transfer in other
categories. Since none of the candidates has been given admission
against the remaining vacancies of open category having secured less
marks than the petitioners (the cut of UR off being 456 marks),
petitioners can not make a complaint for not being considered
alongwith general category candidates in vertical reservation as has
(11)
been the factual matrix in Saurabh Kumar's case.
Learned counsel further submits that none of the petitioners
secured more marks than the candidates admitted in their respective
category (social reservations) either in first round or in mop up round.
Hence, grievance of the petitioners in the obtaining facts and
circumstances is of no consequence.
5.
Heard.
6.
The law on the point in issue is no more res integra and has been
elaborately dealt with by the Apex Court in catena of pronouncements
referred to in the case of Saurav Yadav Vs. State of U.P. (Supra).
Social reservations (categories) in favour of SC,ST and OBC under
Article 16(4) are “vertical reservations”, while special reservations in
favour of physically handicapped, women, government school etc.
under Articles 16(1) or 15(3) are “horizontal reservations”. While
explaining
the
concept
of
“overall
reservations”
and
“compartmentalised reservations”, the Apex Court in the case of Anil
Kumar Gupta Vs. State of U.P. ((1995)5 SCC 173) has held that
where the seats reserved for horizontal reservations are proportionately
divided among the vertical (social) reservations and are not
intertransferable, it would be a case of compartmentalised reservations.
The special reservation is a watertight compartment in each of the
vertical reservation class. As against this, in overall reservations while
allocating the special reservation students to their respective social
reservation category, the overall reservation in favour of special
reservation has yet to be honoured.
(12)
7.
However, the case in hand is distinguishable from the above,
inasmuch as here the seats have first been divided class-wise (i.e.
horizontally/special
reservations)
and
then
category-wise
(i.e.
vertically/social reservations) in terms of Rule 2(“kha”) quoted above.
From a bare perusal of the chart quoted above, it is clear that out of
total 4308 seats, 366 NRI seats were excluded from calculation. Out of
the remaining 3942 seats, firstly 5% horizontal reservation was
provided to Government School class which comes to 197 seats.
Secondly, these 197 seats have been proportionately divided in SC, ST,
OBC etc. categories. Similar calculations have been made for other
classes viz. Ex Army, Freedom Fighter and Handicap. Further, as per
Rule 2(“ga”), in the second round of counselling if the requisite
number of registered candidates are not available in a particular class,
the left-over vacancies are to be made available to the registered
candidates of the respective category. In pursuance of Rule 2(“ga”), in
the instant case, as many as 77 left-over vacancies of OC (open
category)
were
automatically
added
to
the
general
pool
(unreserved/vertical category) for being made available on merit to any
candidate, irrespective of his/her caste. In terms of Rule 4(1)(“ga”)
(ibid) seats in each of the categories were filled-up, in conformity with
settled principles of law as reiterated by the Apex Court in Saurav
Yadav Vs. State of U.P. (Supra). Therefore, it is not a case where the
reserved category candidates have been refrained from staking claim
against open category seats, nor is it a case where cut-off marks of last
student of Open/Unreserved Category (i.e. 456 marks) is less than that
of any of the petitioners. As such, when the said vacancies were pooled
in the open category for all the candidates (including the petitioners) in
(13)
terms of the aforesaid Rules, the contention of the petitioners that any
prejudice was caused to them cannot be countenanced, moreso in
absence of any challenge to the constitutional validity of the rules in
vogue.
The petition sans merit and is, accordingly, dismissed.
(ROHIT ARYA)
JUDGE
rahul/and
ANAND SHRIVASTAVA
Date: 2024.01.12
14:02:22 +05'30'
(AVANINDRA KUMAR SINGH)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review