Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
- : 1 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
WRIT PETITION No. 6261 of 2013
BETWEEN:RAMESHWAR BHATI S/O SHRI SHANKARLAL BHATI, AGED ABOUT
56 YEARS, OCCUPATION: UNEMPLOYED SITAMAU KHEDA, TEH.
SITAMAU, DISTT, MANDSAUR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI PRASANNA R. BHATNAGAR, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
PETITIONER.)
AND
SECRETARY STATE OF M.P. AND 3 ORS. GOVT. DEPARTMENT OF
1. HOME (POLICE) VALLABH BHAWAN MANTRALAYA, BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE INDORE ZONE, 2 KOTHI ROAD
2.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
SUPERINTENDANT OF POLICE DISTT-MANDSAUR (MADHYA
3.
PRADESH)
SHYAMLAL
DHAKAD
S/O
NARAYAN
DHAKAD
VILL4.
DETHLIKHURD, TEH- GAROTH (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI RAJWARDHAN GAWDE, LEARNED PANEL LAWYER FOR THE
RESPONDENTS/STATE.)
Reserved on
:
05.12.2023
Pronounced on
:
05.01.2024
This petition having been heard and reserved for order, coming
up for pronouncement this day, this Court pronounced the following:
ORDER
The petitioner is aggrieved by an order dated 30.9.2011 passed
by the Superintendent of Police, District Mandsaur whereby he has
- : 2 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
been terminated from service after conducting the regular departmental
inquiry. And also against the order dated 23.11.2011 passed by the
Inspector General of Police, Indore Zone, Ujjain whereby a
departmental appeal has been dismissed.
The facts of the case, in short, are as under :
1-
The petitioner was initially appointed to the post of Constable on
26.5.1980 and thereafter he was promoted to the post of
Head
Constable on 15.7.1990. During his posting as Head Constable at
Police Station Garoth, District Mandsaur, an FIR No. 240/2010 was
registered u/s. 8/15 of the Narcotic Drug Psychotropic Substances Act
based on the discreet information received on 25.07.2010. Following
the due process, a police team comprising ASI Rambharose Sharma
(PW-10), Head Constable Rameshwar Bhati (the accused/appellant),
Constables Dashrath Malvi, Vinodsingh, Banapsingh, Omprakash,
Chandrapalsingh and witnesses Shantilal and Krishangopal Joshi
proceeded with all paraphernalia by official vehicle bearing registration
No.MP-03-3114 and searched the houses of Bhagatram S/o Janakilal
Porwal, and Kishore @ Nandkishore S/o Jagdish Dhakad situated in
Village Dethli Khurd. The police found and seized 868 kg of illegal
poppy straw, a tractor trolley bearing registration No.MP-14-S-4577
and an unnumbered TVS Star City motorcycle. The police arrested
Bhagatram and Kishore @ Nandkishore, brought them to the police
station, and registered Crime No.240/2010 under Section 8/15 of the
Narcotic Drugs & Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. After
completing the investigation a charge sheet was filed against the
accused.
2.
After three months of recovery of poppy straw, Shyamlal, the
brother of one of the arrested persons Kishore @ Nandkishore; sent a
- : 3 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
written complaint to the Director General of Police (D.G.P.) asserting
that on 24.07.2010 at about 8:00 PM, the petitioner along with
'Thanedar' R. B. Sharma and 4-5 policemen came in a private Jeep at
the house of Bhagatram and Kishore @ Nandkishore forcibly seized 4400 kg poppy straw kept therein under the license and an unnumbered
TVS motorcycle. They also took Bhagatram, Kishore, and his wife
pregnant Mamta to the Police Station.
3-
It is further alleged that Shyamlal along with one Babulal went
to the police station and talked to HC Rameshwar Bhati; the petitioner,
who misbehaved with him and demanded Rs.20 lakhs for releasing the
persons detained by the police. He also threatened him that in case of
failure to fulfill his demand, he would be implicated in false cases
along with family members. After some negotiation, he agreed to take
Rs.15 lakhs. Shyamlal and Babulal came back to the Village Dethli
Khurd and discussed the matter/demand with the family/relatives of
Bhagat and Kishore. They all arranged Rs.5 lakhs and handed it over to
Shyamlal, who delivered the same to the petitioner: Rameshwar Bhati
in the night itself. The petitioner released Mamta w/o Kishore and
asked for the remaining amount stating that he has to pay the same to
'Deputy Sahab'. Shyamlal assured him that as soon as they will arrange
the money, the same will be delivered to him.
4-
It is also alleged that the family arranged Rs.5 lakhs more and
delivered them to the petitioner on 27.07.2010 (after three days) and
the remaining Rs.5 lakhs were arranged and delivered on 02.08.2010.
During this entire period, the petitioner was repeatedly threatening
them to give him more money, else face dare consequences against the
other family members also.
5-
After about a year and four months, vide letter No.
- : 4 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
I.G./Ujjain/SE/Oct./11/GB/2/237/2011 dated 14.11.2011, the Inspector
General of Police, Ujjain instructed the S.P., Mandsaur to initiate the
penal action against the petitioner under the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988. The S.P., Mandsaur sent a letter No.25/10/2012/1318-D
dated 20.01.2012 to the SHO, Police Station—Garoth, who in turn
registered Crime No.36/2012 under Section 342 of
IPC and Sections 7, 13 (1)(d)(ii) of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988 and investigated the same. The Investigation Officer recorded
statements of complainant Shyamlal, Mamta, Babulal S/o Kanhaiyalal,
Verdilal, Onkarlal, Omprakash, Govind, Shambhulal, Durga Shankar,
Biju @ Vijay, Rajesh @ Raju, Babulal S/o Durga Shankar and some
other official witnesses and the witnesses relating to the other usual
investigation and filed the charge-sheet.
6-
Simultaneously, respondents decided to initiate disciplinary
action against him by issuing a charge sheet dated 7.12.2010 to the
petitioner on the following charges :
“vkjksi
1fn- 25-7-10 dks Fkkuk xjksB iathc) vi0 Ø0 240@10 /kkjk
8@15 ,u Mh ih ,l ,DV dk dk;e fd;kA vkids }kjk izdj.k ds
vkjksih Hkxrjke iksjoky fd'kksj mQZ uanfd'kksj /kkdM+ rFkk enu /kkdM+
fuoklh nsFkyh [kqnZ dks NksM+us ds uke ls fd'kksj /kkdM+ dh xHkZorh iRuh
eerk dks Fkkus ykdj voS/kkfud d`R; djukA
2vkosnd ';keyky o ckcwyky /kkdM+ ds ek/;e ls fn0 25-7-10]
27-7-10 ,oa
2-8-10 dks 5&5&5 yk[k dqy 15 yk[k :i;s izkIr dj
e0iz- iqfyl jsX;wys'ku ds iSjk Ø0 64]2]10 ,oa e0iz- flfoy lsok vkpj.k
fu;e 1965 ds fu;e 3¼1]3½ ,oa 14 dk mYya?ku djukA
3nLrkost Ø0 458 fn0 17-8-10 ls 3750 oxZ fQV iMr ckMk
dherh 4]51]000 :0 esa nLrkost Ø0 561 fn0 25-10-10 ls 750 oxZ fQV
iMr ckMk dherh 2]16]000 :0 ,oa nLrkost Ø0 570@28-10-10 ls 5250
oxZ fQV] iMr ckMk dherh 4]01]000 :0 dqy dherh 10]68]000 :0 esa
viuh iRuh xhrkckbZ ds uke ls Ø; djus ds laca/k esa iqfyl v/kh{kd ls
fdlh izdkj dh vuqefr izkIr ugh dh] u lwpuk u nsdj e0iz- flfoy
lsok vkpj.k fu;e 1965 ds iSjk Ø 19 ¼2½ dk mYya?ku djukA
4iwoZ esa Hkz"Vkpkj djus laca/kh f'kdk;r izekf.kr gksus ij lsok ls
inP;qr djus ds i'pkr Hkh vius vkpj.k esa lq/kkj u ykukA”
- : 5 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
7-
The petitioner submitted the reply to the charge sheet denying
the charges. The reply filed by the petitioner was not found satisfactory.
The petitioner also made a request for a change of the Inquiry Officer.
The departmental inquiry was conducted by the Inquiry Officer without
appointing a presenting officer. According to the petitioner, most of the
objections submitted by him before the Inquiry Officer were turned
down, and one sided inquiry was conducted thereafter inquiry report
was submitted to the disciplinary authority. Thereafter, a show-cause
notice dated 9.9.2011 was issued to him and he submitted the reply
dated 20.9.2011 seeking exoneration from all the charges. Vide order
dated 30.9.2011, punishment of termination from service was
imposed on the petitioner. Thereafter, he preferred an appeal which too
has been dismissed. Hence, the present petition before this Court.
8-
The respondents filed their reply in detail justifying the
imposition of a major penalty and dismissal of the appeal and prayed
for dismissal of the Writ Petition.
9-
The petitioner was subjected to the Special Trial for the offenses
u/s. 7, 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d)(ii) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act. Vide judgment dated 1.2.2016 passed by the Special
Judge, Mandsaur he was convicted and sentenced to undergo four years
RI and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- with default stipulation. The
petitioner preferred Criminal Appeal No. 278/2016 against the
aforesaid judgment which came to be allowed vide judgment dated
30.11.2019 passed by this Court and the judgment dated 1.2.2016
passed by the learned Special Judge has been set aside. The said
judgment has been placed on record by the petitioner vide application
for taking the document on record and prayed that now he is entitled to
- : 6 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
reinstatement in service.
10-
Shri Prasanna Bhatnagar, learned counsel for the petitioner,
submitted that the respondents conducted the departmental inquiry in
violation of settled principles of law. The request of the petitioner for a
change of the Inquiry Officer was not considered. The petitioner was
not given a proper opportunity for a hearing by the Inquiry Officer. The
Inquiry Officer himself played the role of prosecutor by examining and
cross-examining the witnesses. The disciplinary as well as the appellant
authority did not consider the aforesaid grounds while imposing the
punishment and dismissing the appeal on merit. It is further submitted
that on the same set of charges, the petitioner was put to criminal trial
under the provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act, but now he
has been acquitted of all the charges by this Court, therefore, the
allegation against the petitioner regarding illegal demand has not been
found proved against him hence the punishment of termination is liable
to be withdrawn. It is further submitted by the learned counsel that all
the witnesses examined by the Inquiry Officer were not independent
witnesses, they were all related to the accused persons in Crime No.
240/2010, therefore, they had a grudge against the petitioner. It is also
submitted that FIR No. 240/2010 under the NDPS Act was registered
by the ASI, the entire investigation was conducted by him and the
petitioner was only a member of the investigation team. He had no
authority to make any change in the FIR or the charge sheet or not to
submit the charge sheet in favour of the accused persons. Therefore, he
alone has wrongly been punished by way of Departmental Enquiry.
11-
It is further submitted by the learned counsel that in order to
weaken the case of the prosecution, false allegations were made against
the petitioner after a period of three months from the date of recovery
- : 7 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
of illegal poppy straw to get an acquittal in the criminal case. Now the
most important ground is that the petitioner has been acquitted
honorably from all the charges under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
So far as the so-called illegal demand made by the petitioner is
concerned, it has not been found established by this Court. Hence, the
impugned termination order is liable to be quashed and the petitioner is
liable to reinstatement in service with all back-wages. In support of his
contention, learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on the
judgment of the apex Court in the case of G.M. Tank V/s. State of
Gujarat : (2006) 5 SCC 446. So far as the Inquiry Officer acted as
Presenting Officer, the apex Court as well as this Court has deprecated
such an action and set aside the entire proceedings in the case of Union
of India V/s. Ram Lakhan Sharma : (2018) 7 SCC 670; Irfan Ahmed
V/s. State of M.P.: 2021 (2) MPLJ 356.
12-
On the other hand, Shri Rajwardhan Gawde, learned Panel
Lawyer appearing for the respondents/State, submitted that the
petitioner had committed an illegal act while discharging the duties as
Head Constable by calling the pregnant wife of the accused – Kishore
Dhakad in the Police Station in respect of Cr. Case No. 240/2010
demanded a total of Rs.15.00 Lakhs from the accused persons
Shyamlal and Babulal. During the said period, the petitioner procured
the immovable properties worth Rs.10,68,000/- in the name of his wife
without prior approval from the Police Department, which is not the
charge under the Prevention of Corruption Act against the petitioner,
and the said charge has been found proved against him in Departmental
Enquiry. Therefore, the charges in the departmental inquiry as well as
criminal cases are different. Merely on an acquittal in the criminal case,
the petitioner is entitled to reinstatement in service. Even otherwise, the
- : 8 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
entire service record of the petitioner was not up to the mark. Earlier,
also he was removed from service by way of Departmental Enquiry
and later on was reinstated but he did not show any improvement. He
tarnished the image of the police by demanding a bribe of Rs.15.00
Lakhs for not falsely implicating the persons in criminal cases
registered under the NDPS Act. Therefore, he rendered himself unfit
for the police service. Hence, he has rightly been terminated from
service Writ Petition be dismissed without any interference.
After having heard the learned counsel for the parties, I have perused
the material available on record.
13.
There are four charges against the petitioner. The first charge is
that he brought Mamta a pregnant wife of Kishore Dhakad to the police
station in order to release the accused - Bhagatram, Kishore @
Nandkishore Dhakad, and Madan. The prosecution examined as many
as 14 witnesses and none of them were cross-examined by the
petitioner, hence their deposition became unrebutted. The Inquiry
Officer recorded their deposition in the inquiry and thereafter, the
Inquiry Officer himself cross-examined the present petitioner. He was
given various suggestions in respect of the charges, but he denied all of
them and gave his explanations. The petitioner examined the 5 defense
witnesses. Thereafter, the Inquiry Officer without analyzing the
evidence directly jumped to the conclusion that the charge No.1 is
found fully proven. The defense witnesses have been discarded because
they were related to the delinquent. The Inquiry Officer has also
observed that R.V. Sharma, Sub Inspector conducted the seizure and
brought the pregnant woman to the police station. Sub-Inspector was a
senior member of the team, and the petitioner was associated with him
for charge No.1, therefore, the petitioner alone cannot be held to be
- : 9 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
responsible for charge No.1 being a junior member of the team. The
entire investigation and seizure were carried out by R.V. Sharma, Sub
Inspector. The Inquiry Officer simply recorded the statements of the
witnesses and jumped to the findings without appreciating them. Even
otherwise, all the witnesses were related to the accused persons in the
NDPS case. Charge No. 1 is partly proved because the petitioner was
alone not bringing the Smt. Mamta to the Police Station.
14.
The charge No.2 is that the petitioner demanded Rs.15.00 Lakhs
from Shyamlal and Babulal, for which the complaint was made after
three months from the date of registration of FIR. Against the public
servant, the demand for a bribe should be reported before fulfilling the
illegal demand.
According to the complainants, they arranged the
huge money and gave it to the present petitioner, but the said amount
was not recovered from the possession of the petitioner. The witnesses
– P.W.1 and P.W.2 who said to have handed over Rs.5.00 Lakhs to the
petitioner did not give any explanation as to from where they arranged
this huge amount of money. The Inquiry Officer ought to have asked
the question about the arrangement of this money. Only on the basis of
their oral statement, Charge No.2 has been found proved which is not
supported by documentary evidence. Hence same has wrongly been
found. Even other wise the petitioner has been acquitted of the charges
of the PC Act by this High Court.
15.
So far as charge No.3 is concerned, that has been found proved
against the petitioner as he acquired the immovable properties in the
name of his wife without prior approval/ permission from the
Department. He did not inform the department after the purchase of
these properties He purchased a plot measuring 3750 Sq.ft. for
Rs.4,51,000/- vide registered sale-deed dated 17.8.2010; a plot
- : 10 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
measuring 750 Sq.ft. Was also purchased by him in Rs.2,16,000/- on
25.10.2010; and plot to admeasure 2500 Sq.ft. in Rs.4,01,000/-, in
total, 10,68,000/- after 25.7.2010, The period of purchase of the
properties are matching with the date on which the petitioner allegedly
received from the complainant. therefore, it could be connected with
the allegation of acceptance of money that was utilized in the purchase
of the said properties. The only defense that the petitioner took was that
his wife purchased the properties for which he was not required to get
permission from the Department. The petitioner has failed to file any
document or produce the evidence to show the secured from where his
earned amount of Rs.10,68,000/- to purchase the properties within 3
months. The petitioner was required to get permission from the
Department under the provisions of
Rule 19(2) of the M.P. Civil
Service (Conduct) Rules, 1965. Therefore, the said charge No. 3 has
rightly been found proven.
16.
So far as charge No.4 is concerned, that is in respect of the past
tainted service record of the petitioner. During his service, he was
found involved in accepting Rs.2,500/- as a bribe in the year 1992. He
was removed from the service and later on, the said punishment of
removal from service was reduced to the stoppage of 5 increments and
reinstated back in service on 15.9.1995. Thereafter again, the allegation
of demand of Rs.1,000/- as bribe was found proved. In the year 2006
also, he received Rs.500/- as a bribe, and a punishment of stoppage of
one increment was imposed upon him, which was maintained in the
appeal. Therefore, the petitioner did not improve his conduct and the
charges were found proven. In view of the above, charge No.4 has
rightly been found proved against the petitioner.
17.
The petitioner was also prosecuted in the criminal case and he
- : 11 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
was convicted and sentenced. However, in an appeal his conviction has
been set aside, but that was only in respect of accepting the bribe of
Rs.15.00 Lakhs. But, so far as acquiring the properties without prior
permission from the Department and his past tainted service record,
were not the charges in the criminal case. Therefore, on acquittal, it
cannot be said that the petitioner is entitled to reinstatement into the
police services.
18.
It is correct that the Presenting Officer was not appointed in this
case and the Inquiry Officer himself cross-examined the present
petitioner/delinquent. The petitioner was required to explain what
prejudice was caused when the Inquiry Officer put the questions or
cross-examined him. Therefore, only on this ground, the inquiry cannot
be said to be vitiated. When two charges have been found proved and
the petitioner has failed to give any explanation about the properties
purchased during the said period when the allegations of acceptance of
bribe are there coupled with his past blemished service record.
19.
The Division Bench of this Court in the case of State of M.P.
V/s. Dr. Ashok Kumar ILR 2018 MP 352 has held that the Court
should not interfere with the administrative decision unless it is
illogical suffers from procedural impropriety or is shocking to the
consciousness of the Court. The High Court is not the Court of Appeal
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India over the decision of the
authority holding the departmental inquiry against the public servant.
The power of judicial review is not directed against the decision but it
is confined to the decision-making process in the exercise of
supervisory writ jurisdiction. In another case of R.K. Solanki V/s.
Central Bank of India: ILR 2018 MP 1051, the Division Bench of this
Court has considered the effect of acquittal in a criminal case in the
- : 12 :W.P. No. 6261/2013
disciplinary proceedings. It has been held that the punishment imposed
on the appellant is not based on the conclusion in a criminal trial but on
the finding recorded in the inquiry on the deposition of witnesses.
Adequacy of evidence cannot be the subject matter of judicial review.
Interference can only be made where the findings are perverse it is a
case of no evidence. Exoneration from a criminal case does not
mechanically exonerate the employee from the departmental inquiry. In
the case of Rajendra Singh Raghuvanshi, V/s. State of M.P.: ILR
2017 MP 1086 this Court has held that appreciation and assessment of
the material brought on record by the department and the delinquent is
within the exclusive domain of disciplinary authority and cannot be
faulted unless the conclusion drawn by the authority suffers from
voices of jurisdiction, the perversity of approach, the conclusion drawn
by the authority are such which no man of common prudence shall
arrive at and the conclusion are lacking in bona fide applying the
principles of Wednesbury reasonableness. Therefore, no case for
interference with the impugned orders of punishment is made out.
Accordingly, this writ petition is dismissed.
No order as to cost.
( VIVEK RUSIA )
JUDGE
Alok/-
Date: 2024.01.05 18:12:51 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review