Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 2nd OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 27215 of 2019
BETWEEN:RAMDULARI D/O HAMIRA, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, R/O 162/3, JUNA
1. RISALA GALI NO.3, NEAR GANESH MANDIR INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
BHURIBAI S/O MOOLCHAND, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, R/O 982,
2. PANCHAM KI PHEL, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
DASHRATH S/O PARAG, AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS, R/O 1, AJAY BAUG
3. COLONY, MUSAKHEDI ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
SITARAM S/O BABULAL, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, R/O PWD OFFICE
4. COMPOUND, MYH INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
UMESH S/O GULAB SINGH, AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS, R/O 480, ADIVASI
5. BHIL COLONY, MUSAKHEDI, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
BHAGWATI RAMCHANDRA, AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, R/O 719,
6. GOVIND COLONY, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
RASHEED S/O MOHD. KHAN, AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS, R/O KILA
7. MAIDAN, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
PARMESHWAR S/O TRIYAMBAK RAO, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, R/O
8. 103 KANDILUPRA, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
SHANTI BAI W/O JAGDISH, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, R/O 1, AJAY
9. BAUG COLONY, MUSAKHEDI ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
LATE GANGARAM S/O GOVIND THROUGH KESHARBAI W/O LATE
10. GANGARAM, AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS, R/O 9, SUBHASH COLONY
BANGANGA INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
-2LATE SHAEEF S/O MOHD. KHAN THROUGH ISA BI W/O LATE
11. SHAREEF, AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS, R/O PWD QUARTERS, KILA
MAIDAN, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
LATE TEKCHAND S/O NANURAM THR PHUL KUMARI W/O LATE
12. TEKCHAND, R/O 1624 DWARIKAPURI, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
SARJU BAI W/O BALLA, AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS, R/O 889, GALI NO. 7,
13. BHAGIRATHPURA, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
VITTHAL S/O LAXMAN, AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS, R/O 185,
14. VENKATESH VIHAR, AERODRUM ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
LATE BETIBAI D/W/O PARMANAND THROUGH MANOJ S/O LATE
15. BETIBAI, AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS, R/O 39G, LAL MAKAN, KACCHI
MOHALLA, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
CHETAN S/O ONKARLAL, AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS, R/O 46,
16. MAHAWAR NAGAR, ANNAPURNA ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
MIZAJILAL S/O PRITAM LAL, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, 369-F, RAJ
17. NAGAR, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
GOPAL S/O BHAGATJI, AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS, R/O BRAHMA BAUG,
18. INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
KHEMCHAND S/O ONKARLAL, AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS, R/O 46,
19. MAHAWAR NAGAR, ANNAPURNA ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
INDUBAI W/O BAU SAHEB, AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS, R/O SHIVAJI
20. NAGAR, MALWA MILL, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
LATE DINESH S/O PANNALAL HADA, THROUGH NAVEEN HADA, R/O
21. INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
DINESH S/O PANNALAL, AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, R/O 236, KASRAVAD
22. KHURD, KHANDWA ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
BABULAL S/O RAJARAM, AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS, R/O 195, BAJRANG
23. NAGAR, SIRPUR, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
-3-
24.
RAJU S/O MADHAV RAO, AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS, R/O 143, SAIBABA
NAGAR, PHOOTI KHOTI, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
25.
SITARAM S/O PANNALAL, AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, R/O 237,
KASRAVAD KHURD, KHANDWA ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
26.
MADHU BAI W/O HARISHCHAND, AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS, R/O 249,
DEO NAGAR HARIJAN COLONY, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
27.
BALKISHAN S/O RAMGOPAL, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS, R/O 41, MOG
LINE NEAR PWD OFFICE MAIN ROAD INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
RATIBAI W/O JANKIRAM, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, R/O BHAGIRATH
28. PURA, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
SANTOSH S/O AMARLAL, AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS, R/O 20/1,
29. BAKASHIBAGH COLONY INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
LATE SURESH S/O RANGAJI THROUGH MAMTABAI W/O SURESH,
30. AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS, R/O BHAGIRATHPURA, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
MANOJ S/O TUKARAM, AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS, R/O 224, RISHI
31. VIHAR, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
LATE RAGHUNATH S/O NARAYAN THROUGH SHYAM GAWDE, R/O
32. 158/7, DURGA NAGAR, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI J. S. SENGAR, ADVOCATE.)
AND
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT THROUGH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
1. MANTRALAYA, VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
UNDER SECRETARY, P.W.D., GOVT. OF M.P., MANTRALAYA, VALLABH
2. BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
CHIEF ENGINEER, P.W.D., M.P. NIRMAN BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, P.W.D., DIVISION NO. 1, INDORE (MADHYA
4. PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
-4(BY SHRI SUDHANSHU VYAS, PANEL LAWYER.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This petition coming on for orders this day, the court passed the following:
ORDER
The petitioners have filed the present petition being
aggrieved by the order dated 20.06.2019 whereby the order dated
04.03.2018 has been canceled and approval has been given to grant the
benefit if circular dated 07.10.2016.
The facts of the case in short are as under:
02.
The petitioners were appointed in the year 1974 as daily
wagers. They approached the Labour Court by way of reference case
No.72/2003 to claim classification as permanent employees. Vide award
dated 18.03.2004, the Labour Court directed the Public Works
Department to classify them as permanent under the Madhya Pradesh
certified standing orders. In compliance with the aforesaid award, the
State Government passed an order dated 09.03.2005 declaring them
permanent labour on a minimum pay scale.
03.
The State Government sought a reference No.32/2006 from
the Labour Court in which direction was given to make payment at par
with the pay scale sanctioned for the permanent employees and
determine the amount of arrears. The aforesaid order was challenged by
way of writ petition before this Court in which the order passed by the
Labour Court dated 22.09.2006 was upheld and thereafter SLP was filed
and that was dismissed vide order dated 16.01.2012. According to the
petitioner, despite the order of the Supreme Court, the arrears were paid
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
-5-
to them up to April 2007 and thereafter, w.e.f. May 2007 it was stopped,
therefore, they approached this Court by way of Writ Petition No.3056
of 2012. Vide order dated 15.05.2012, all the writ petitions were allowed
and order dated 27.02.2012 was quashed and respondents/ State were
directed to pay the salary and other benefit which is payable to the other
regular employees of the M.P. PWD.
04.
The State of Madhya Pradesh, Public Works Department
challenged the aforesaid order by way of Writ Appeal No.371 of 2012.
Vide order dated 26.09.2012, all the writ appeals were partly allowed by
modifying the order passed by the Single Judge to the extent that
petitioners shall be entitled to monetary benefit in respect of a
permanent employee, not of a regular employee. The operative part of
the order is reproduced below:
In view of the aforesaid, we find that in the last Para of
the order of learned Single Judge, the word ‘regular employee’
has been written, but from the reading of the entire order, we
find that the intention of the learned Single Judge was for grant
of monetary benefit in respect of the payment as of permanent
employee and not of regular employee. It appears to be by way
of oversight.
05.
After the aforesaid order, the Executive Engineer, Division-I
passed an order dated 03.03.2014 granting them the benefit of the
regular pay scale to the petitioners. Meanwhile, the State Government
also preferred SLP against the order dated 26.09.2012 passed in writ
appeal. Vide order dated 04.04.2016 the Apex Court dismissed the SLP.
06.
After five years, the respondents realized that the Executive
Engineer gave a wrong interpretation of the order passed by the Division
Bench of this Court and wrongly granted the benefit of the regular pay
scale to the petitioners vide order dated 03.03.2014. The petitioners are
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
-6-
at the most entitled to the benefit of the circular dated 07.10.2016 for
declaration as permanent employees in their respective category in a
fixed minimum pay scale. Hence, this petition before this Court.
07.
Shri J.S. Sengar, learned counsel for the petitioners submits
that the Division Bench of this Court vides order dated 26.09.2012 has
only held that the petitioners are entitled to monetary benefit in respect
of payment as of permanent employee and at that time the benefits of
the permanent employee were at par with the regular employees,
therefore, the writ petitioners agreed for the aforesaid change in the
order passed by the Writ Court. It is further submitted that at that time
the judgment of Ramnaresh Rawat and the circular dated 07.10.2016
were not there hence, now that circular and the judgment cannot be
given effect in the case of the petitioners. Although all the similarly
situated daily rated were declared as permanent employees the
Government used to give them benefits at par with the regular
employees. At last, it is submitted by the learned counsel that without
giving any opportunity for a hearing the respondents have canceled the
order dated 04.03.2014. hence bad in law.
08.
In support of his contention, learned counsel for the
petitioners has placed reliance on the judgment passed in the case of (i)
Engineer-In-Chief, P.H.E.D. and others V/s Budha Rao Magarde and
others [2002 (1) M.P.L.J. 385] (ii) Rakesh S/o Parshuram Yadav and
others V/s State of M.P. and others [2007 (1) M.P.L.J. 133] and, (iii)
Arvind Kumar Mehra V/s State of M.P. and others [I.L.R. (2018) M.P.
1663].
09.
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
The respondent filed the reply by submitting that the
-7-
petitioners are only entitled to the benefit of the circular dated
07.10.2016. The then Executive Engineer wrongly passed the order
dated 04.03.2014 without understanding the order passed by the Writ
Court. The petitioners were only entitled to a declaration of the
permanent status not of the regular employee as they did not complete
25 years of service. Now, the uniform policy has been adopted by the
State Government to give permanent status to all the daily rated
employees in terms of a circular dated 07.10.2016. Hence, the writ
petition is liable to be dismissed.
Appreciation and conclusion
10.
It is correct that the Writ Court had directed the respondents
to pay the salary and other benefits to the petitioner which are payable to
other employees but the fact remains that the petitioners were never
recruited or appointed as regular employees Before appointment no
procedure was prescribed under rules was followed by the department,
they were engaged as a daily rated employee. The Division Bench of
this Court has modified the aforesaid order passed by the Writ Court and
held that the petitioners are entitled to the monetary benefits as
permanent employees. The petitioner did not challenge the aforesaid
order at the relevant point in time. However, the then Executive
Engineer gave a wrong interpretation of the order passed by the Writ
Appellate Court and granted them the benefit of a regular pay scale. It is
settled law that the estoppel does not apply against the law. There is no
provision in any of the recruitment rules for giving the benefit of regular
employees to the daily rated employees after conferring them the status
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
-8-
of permanent employees. Even the petitioners were not contingencypaid employees, therefore, the erroneous order can be recalled at any
given point in time.
11.
So far as the question of grant of opportunity of hearing is
concerned, it is correct that no opportunity of hearing was given to the
petitioners, and for that, the matter is liable to be remanded to the
respondents but that would be a futile exercise because the respondents
have taken their stand by way of reply in this petition and which will not
be changed even if the direction is given to decide the matter afresh.
12.
This Court has examined the entitlement of the petitioners
on the basis of the argument raised by the petitioners and the reply filed
by the respondents. In view of the order passed by the Writ Appellate
Court, the then Executive Engineer passed the wrong order on
03.03.2014 which has rightly been canceled by the impugned order.
13.
In view of the above, no case for interference is made out.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed. It is made clear that there
shall not be any recovery from the petitioner due to the recalling of the
order dated 03.03.2014, because the petitioners were not at fault. If any
amount has been recovered same be returned to them.
No order as to cost.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Divyansh
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
-9-
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 05-01-2024
17:22:32
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review