Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 3rd OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 31278 of 2023
BETWEEN:1.
RAKSHA SHARMA W/O ASHOK SHARMA, AGED
ABOUT 25 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NIL WARD NO. 5
KUMBHRAJ, POST KUMBHRAJ DISTRICT GUNA.
HAAL MUKAM- SINGAPUR GREEN VIEW,
BIJUKHEDI, MANGLIYA, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
ASHOK KURMI S/O LTE MANGAL SINGH KURMI,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURE GRAM SANAI, POST SANAI JILA
GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
( BY SHRI SHIVAM SONI-ADVOCATE)
AND
Signed by: PRAVEEN
Signing time: 03-012024 19:09:01
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH PRAMUKH
SACHIV GHR VIBHAG GHR MANTRALAYA
SACHIVALAY BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
POLICE ADHIKSHAK
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
THANA
PRABHARI
MAHODAY THANA
KUMBHRAJ, JILA GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
THANA PRABHARI MAHODAY THANA MRIGVAS
TEH. KUMBHRAJ, JILA GUNA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
5.
VINOD SHARMA S/O SHRI OMPRAKASH SHARMA
WARD NO. KUMBHRAJ, POST KUMBHRAO JILA
GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
SAKET SHARMA S/O VINOD SHARMA WARD NO.
5, KUMBHRAJ, POST KUMBHRAJ JILA GUNA
MAHODAY JILA GUNA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
7.
ADD. ABNISH RAJORIYA S/O KAILASHNARAYAN
R AJ OR IYA WARD NO. 5 KUMBHRAJ, POST
KUMBHRAJ, JILA GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SUDARSHAN JOSHI- GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE)
T h is petition coming on for orders this day, t h e cou rt passed the
following:
ORDER
The petitioners have filed the present petition seeking police protection.
According to them, they are major and performed their marriage, but they are
receiving threat from their parents.
2. If the petitioners are major and entered into the marriage voluntarily,
then they should not be harassed by any one, just because they have objection
with their marriage. In future, if the petitioners receive any threat or fear to their
life from anyone order to avoid any harassment, the petitioners are certainly
entitled for police protection.
3. That, in case of Lata Singh Vs. State of U.P. Another : AIR 2006
SC 2522, the Apex Court has observed as under:
"th is is free and democratic country and once a person
becomes a major he or she likes. If the parents of the boy or
girl do not approve of such inter caste of inter religious
marriage the maximum they can do is that they can cut-off
social relation with the son or daughter, but they can give
threats or commit of instigate acts of violence and cannot
h a r a s s the person undergoes such inter caste or inter
religious relationship marriage. We therefore direct that the
administrative/ police authorities throughout the country will
see to it that if any boy or girl who is major, the couple are
harassed by any one nor subjected to threats or acts of
violence and may one who gives such threats or harass or
commit acts of violence either himself of at his instigation is
taken to task by instituting criminal proceedings, by the
Signed by: PRAVEEN
Signing time: 03-012024 19:09:01
police against such person and further stem action is taken
against such persons as provided by law"
4. The Apex Court in the matter of "Khap Panchayat" has taken up the
issue of "Honour Killing'' very seriously and issued certain preventive, remedial
punitive measures to all the State Governments. The relevant direction passed in
case No. 231/2010 (Shakti Vahini vs. State of M.P.) decided on 27.03.2018
are as under:"To meet the challenges of the agonising effect of honour
crime, we think that there has to be preventive, remedial and
punitive measures and,accordingly, we state the broad
contours and the modalities with liberty to the executive and
the police administration of the concerned States to add
further measures to evolve a robust mechanism for the stated
purposes.
I. Preventive Steps:(a) The State Governments should forthwith identify Districts,
Sub-Divisions and/or Villages where instances of honour
killing or assembly of Khap Panchayats have been reported
in the recent past,e.g., in the last five years.
(b) The Secretary, Home Department of the concerned States
shall issue directives/advisories to the Superintendent of
Police of the concerned Districts for ensuring that the Officer
Incharge of the Police Stations of the identified areas are
extra cautious if any instance of inter-caste or interreligious marriage within their jurisdiction comes to their
notice.
(c) If information about any proposed gathering of a Khap
Panchayat comes to the knowledge of any police officer or
any officer of the District Administration, he shall forthwith
inform
his
immediate
superior
officer and also
simultaneously
intimate
the
jurisdictional
Deputy
Superintendent of Police and Superintendent of Police.
( d ) On receiving such information, the Deputy
Superintendent of Police (or such senior police officer as
identified by the State Governments with respect to the
area/district) shall immediately interact with the members of
the Khap Panchayat and impress upon them that convening
o f such meeting/gathering is not permissible in law and to
eschew from going ahead with such a meeting. Additionally,
he should issue appropriate directions to the Officer
Incharge of the jurisdictional Police Station to be vigilant
Signed by: PRAVEEN
Signing time: 03-012024 19:09:01
and, if necessary, to deploy adequate police force for
prevention of assembly of the proposed gathering.
(e) Despite taking such measures, if the meeting is conducted,
the Deputy Superintendent of Police shall personally remain
present during the meeting and impress upon the assembly
that no decision can be taken to cause any harm to the couple
or the family members of the couple, failing which each one
participating in the meeting besides the organisers would be
personally liable for criminal prosecution. He shall also
ensure that video recording of the discussion and
participation of the members of the assembly is done on the
basis of which the law enforcing machinery can resort to
suitable action.
(f) If the Deputy Superintendent of Police, after interaction
with the members of the Khap Panchayat, has reason to
believe that the gathering cannot be prevented and/or is
likely to cause harm to the couple or members of their family,
he shall forthwith submit a proposal to the District
Magistrate/Sub-Divisional Magistrate of the District/
Competent Authority of the concerned area for issuing
orders to take preventive steps under the Cr.P.C., including
by invoking prohibitory orders under Section 144 Cr.P.C.
and also by causing arrest of the participants in the assembly
under Section 151 Cr.P.C.
(g) The Home Department of the Government of India must
take initiative and work in coordination with the State
Governments for sensitising the law enforcement agencies
and by involving all the stake holders to identify the
measures for prevention of such violence and to implement
the constitutional goal of social justice and the rule of law.
( h ) There should be an institutional machinery with the
necessary coordination of all the stakeholders. The different
State Governments and the Centre ought to work on
sensitization of the law enforcement agencies to mandate
social initiatives and awareness to curb such violence.
II. Remedial Measures:(a) Despite the preventive measures taken by the State Police,
if it comes to the notice of the local police that the Khap
Panchayat has taken place and it has passed any diktat to
take action against a couple/family of an inter-caste or interreligious marriage (or any other marriage which does not
meet their acceptance), the jurisdictional police official shall
cause to immediately lodge an F.I.R. under the appropriate
provisions of the Indian Penal Code including Sections 141,
143, 503 read with 506 of IPC.
( b ) Upon registration of F.I.R., intimation shall be
Signed by: PRAVEEN
Signing time: 03-012024 19:09:01
simultaneously given to the Superintendent of Police/ Deputy
Superintendent of Police who, in turn, shall ensure that
effective investigation of the crime is done and taken to its
logical end with promptitude.
(c) Additionally, immediate steps should be taken to provide
security to the couple/family and, if necessary, to remove
them to a safe house within the same district or elsewhere
keeping in mind their safety and threat perception. The State
Government may consider of establishing a safe house at
each District Headquarter for that purpose. Such safe houses
can cater to accommodate (i) young bachelor-bachelorette
co u p le s whose relationship is being opposed by their
families /local community/Khaps and (ii) young married
couples (of an inter-caste or inter-religious or any other
marriage
being
opposed
by
their families/local
community/Khaps). Such safe houses may be placed under
the supervision of the jurisdictional District Magistrate and
Superintendent of Police.
( d ) The District Magistrate/Superintendent of Police must
deal with the complaint regarding threat administered to
such couple/family with utmost sensitivity. It should be first
ascertained whether the bachelor-bachelorette are capable
adults. Thereafter, if necessary, they may be provided
logistical support for solemnising their marriage and/or for
being duly registered under police protection, if they so
desire. After the marriage, if the couple so desire, they can be
provided accommodation on payment of nominal charges in
the safe house initially for a period of one month to be
extended on monthly basis but not exceeding one year in
aggregate, depending on their threat assessment on case to
case basis.
(e) The initial inquiry regarding the complaint received from
the couple (bachelor-bachelorette or a young married
couple) or upon receiving information from an independent
source that the relationship/marriage of such couple is
opposed by their family members/local community/Khaps
shall be entrusted by the District Magistrate/ Superintendent
of
Police to an officer of the rank of Additional
Superintendent of Police. He shall conduct a preliminary
inquiry and ascertain the authenticity, nature and gravity of
threat perception. On being satisfied as to the authenticity of
such threats, he shall immediately submit a report to the
Superintendent of Police in not later than one week.
(f) The District Superintendent of Police, upon receipt of such
report, shall direct the Deputy Superintendent of Police
incharge of the concerned sub-division to cause to register
Signed by: PRAVEEN
Signing time: 03-012024 19:09:01
an F.I.R. against the persons threatening the couple(s) and, if
necessary, invoke Section 151 of Cr.P.C. Additionally, the
Deputy Superintendent of Police shall personally supervise
the progress of investigation and ensure that the same is
completed and taken to its logical end with promptitude. In
the course of investigation, the concerned persons shall be
booked without any exception including the members who
have participated in the assembly. If the involvement of the
members of Khap Panchayat comes to the fore, they shall
also be charged for the offence of conspiracy or abetment, as
the case may be.
III. Punitive Measures:(a) Any failure by either the police or district officer/officials
t o comply with the aforesaid directions shall be considered
as an act of deliberate negligence and/or misconduct for
which departmental action must be taken under the service
rules. The departmental action shall be initiated and taken to
its logical end, preferably not exceeding six months, by the
authority of the first instance.
(b) In terms of the ruling of this Court in Arumugam Servai
(supra), the States are directed to take disciplinary action
against the concerned officials if it is found that (I) such
official(s) did not prevent the incident, despite having prior
knowledge of it, or (ii) where the incident had already
occurred, such official(s) did not promptly apprehend and
institute criminal proceedings against the culprits.
(c) The State Governments shall create Special Cells in every
District comprising of the Superintendent of Police, the
District Social Welfare Officer and District Adi-Dravidar
Welfare Officer to receive petitions/complaints of harassment
of and threat to couples of inter-caste marriage.
(d ) These Special Cells shall create a 24 hour helpline to
receive and register such complaints and to provide
necessary assistance/advice and protection to the couple.
( e ) The criminal cases pertaining to honour killing or
violence to the couple(s) shall be tried before the designated
Court/Fast Track Court earmarked for that purpose. The trial
must proceed on day to day basis to be concluded preferably
within six months from the date of taking cognizance of the
offence. We may hasten to add that this direction shall apply
even to pending cases. The concerned District Judge shall
assign those cases, as far as possible, to one jurisdictional
court so as to ensure expeditious disposal thereof."
5. In view of the above, if the petitioners receive any threat or fear to their
Signed by: PRAVEEN
Signing time: 03-012024 19:09:01
life from their parents or anyone, in future, they may approach to the Police
Commissioner Indore along with their documents relating to age proof and
marriage and record their statement and also inform the name of the person who
is
threatening
them.
If
the petitioners
cannot
approach
to Police
Commissioner Indore due to some reason and in case of emergency then they
are permitted to approach the nearest police station to record their statements.
If the Superintendent of Police /SHO finds that there is threat to the life of the
petitioners then he shall immediately take action in accordance with the direction
given by the Apex Court in the case of Shakti Vahini (Supra).
With the aforesaid, present writ petition stands disposed of.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Praveen
Signed by: PRAVEEN
Signing time: 03-012024 19:09:01
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review