The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
08. 10.2021 is liable to be quashed and similarly the subsequent notices dated 16.10.2021 (Annexures P/11 and P/12) are concerned, the same also cannot be sustained in the light of the fact that wrong entry was made by the respondents in the revenue records that the disputed land belongs to Simhastha Mela Kshetra. Accordingly, the same are also liable to be quashed. 17] So far as the ground raised by the respondents that against the revocation of the building permission, a remedy of appeal is also available to the petitioner is concerned, this court finds that the revocation is based on the revenue entry dated 08.10.2021, which cannot be assailed in an appeal under the M.P. Bhoomi Vikas Nigam Adhiniyam. 18] On the other hand, it is also found that the petitioner has placed on record various photographs of the area in which the petitioner’s building has been constructed, and it is found that adjacent to and in the surrounding area of petitioner’s building, hundreds of other buildings are already in existence, and it is apparent that no such action has been taken against any of the owners of such buildings. Thus, the petitioner has also been discriminated for the reasons best known to the building officer, and in such circumstances, when the petitioners right guaranteed under Article 14 are also violated, the remedy of appeal is inconsequential. 19] So far as the decision relied upon…
16. 10.2021 (Annexure P/11 and P/12) are hereby quashed and the respondents are directed not to restrain the petitioners to complete the building and the use of the same. 21] Accordingly, writ petition stands allowed and disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR
ON THE 8
th
OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 22676 of 2021
BETWEEN:1. RAKESH KOTHARI S/O SHRI PRAKASH CHANDRA
KOTHARI OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 10, RAJ
NAGAR, HIRA MILL ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. SANJAY KOTHARI S/O LATE SHRI PRAKASH
CHANDRA KOTHARI OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 10,
RAJ NAGAR, HEERA MILL ROAD, UJJAIN (MADHYA
PRADESH)
3. MANISH KOTHARI S/O LATE SHRI PRAKASH
CHANDRA KOTHARI OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 6,
RAJ NAGAR, HEERA MILL ROAD, (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(SHRI V. K. JAIN, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH SHRI VAIBHAV JAIN,
ADVOCATE)
AND
UJJAIN
MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION
COMMISSIONER/BUILDING OFFICER ZONE NO.2,
MUNICIPAL CORPORATION (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(SHRI PIYUSH JAIN- ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENT NO.1 AND MS.
HARSHLATA SONI, PANEL LAWYER FOR THE RESPONDENT NO.2 /STATE)
___________________________________________________________________________________________
Reserved on
: 30.11.2023
Pronounced on
: 08.01.2024
_____________________________________________________
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
1]
The writ petition has been filed by the petitioners under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, against the orders dated 08.10.2021
(Annexure P/9), 16.10.2021 (Annexure P/11)-revenue entry and
16.10.2021
(Annexure
P/12)
passed
by
the
respondent
No.1/Commissioner/Building Officer, Zone No.2, Ujjain Municipal
Corporation, Ujjain.
2]
Notice dated 13.10.2021has been issued by the respondent No.1
asking the petitioners to show cause as to why the building permission
shall not be revoked.
3]
The order dated 08.10.2021 (Annexure P/9) is the revenue entry
of Khasara No.1535/2/1 made by the Tehsildar in col.No.12, recording
that from 08.10.2021 the said area is reserved for Simhastha Mela
Kshetra.
4]
By the notices dated 16.10.2021 (Annexure P/11) and
16.10.2021(Annexure P/12), the petitioners’ building permission has
been revoked by invoking Rule 25 of Madhya Pradesh Bhoomi Vikas
Rules, 2012, and the notice Annexure P/11 has been passed by the
respondent No.1/Building Officer; whereas the notice Annexure P/12
has been issued by the respondent No.3/Mela Adhikari, Simhastha
Mela Office, Ujjain informing the petitioners that their construction
falls within the area reserved for Simhastha Mela Kshetra and hence,
why it should not be demolished.
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
5]
In brief, the facts of the case are that the petitioners are the
resident of Ujjain and have purchased the disputed land situated at
Survey No.1535/2/1 from its erstwhile owner Savita Devi through a
registered sale deed dated 15.12.2017.Thereafter the building
permission was also obtained from the Municipal Corporation Ujjain
on 16.4.2018, and after taking all other permissions, the petitioners
started the construction and completed the building in the month of
July, 2021, and since there was some additional construction also made,
the same was also compounded vide order Annexure P/5 after making
due payment to the Municipal Corporation, Ujjain.
However, on
13.10.2021, the petitioners have been issued the notice dated
13.10.2021 as aforesaid by the respondent/Municipal Corporation
mainly on the ground that the construction made by the petitioners falls
within the Simhastha Mela Kshetra and they have suppressed material
facts while taking the building permission.
6]
A detailed reply to the aforesaid notice has also been sent by the
petitioners on 14.10.2021, through e-mail which is also placed on
record. However, no order has been passed on the said reply and
subsequently the petitioners have also filed the present petition on
15.10.2021, and while the petition was pending before this Court, the
order on the petitioners’ reply has been passed on 16.10.2021 which is
also under challenge.
7]
Learned senior counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the
order has been passed by the respondent, and notice has also been
issued by the Mela Adhikari on the same line that the construction is
made on the Simhastha Mela Kshetra.
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
It is also submitted that a
perusal of the so-called order dated 16.10.2021 reveals that it is actually
a show cause notice only informing the petitioners that their building
permission has been revoked as per the provisions of Rule 25 of the
M.P. Bhoomi Vikas Rules, 2012 without reflecting upon the reply filed
by the petitioners on 14.10.2021, although the receipt of the same is
mentioned in the aforesaid order only. It is further submitted that the
objection of the respondents was that the petitioners have made
construction by filing a different registry of the property, however, in its
clarification, which has already been given in the reply stating that the
registry of the predecessor of the petitioners which was uploaded earlier
was for a larger area, and from whom, only a small portion of land was
purchased by the petitioners, and subsequently, the registry of the
petitioners’ land has also been uploaded in the Website of the Municipal
Corporation which is a matter of record.
8]
Learned senior counsel for the petitioners has also submitted that
the main contention of the respondents is that the disputed land falls
within the Simhastha Mela Kshetra is absolutely misconceived and
arbitrary, as admittedly, the petitioners were granted all building
permission prior to the year 2021, on the basis of which the
construction was also made. However, because of a subsequent entry
in the revenue record on 08.10.2021, made by the Tehsildar, it is
mentioned that the survey No.1535/2/1 falls within the Simhastha Mela
Kshetra. It is submitted that such subsequent entry made in the revenue
record cannot be made a basis to issue show cause notice to the
petitioners that their land is within Simhastha Mela Kshetra. It is
further submitted that such retrospective effect of the revenue entry
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
cannot applied by the respondents which is clearly against the
provisions of law. It is also submitted that the petitioners’ building
situated on a land on which, hundreds of other buildings have already
been erected prior to the year 2021 with the permission of Municipal
Corporation but, no action has been taken against them and only the
petitioners are being targeted.
9]
Learned senior counsel for the petitioners has also submitted that
even according to the documents filed by the respondents along with
their reply that the land on which the building is constructed the land
does not fall within the Simhastha Mela Kshetra as per the document
Annexure R/5 which reflects that the Simhastha Mela Kshetra was for
the year 2016 only and subsequently the petitioners have also obtained
the information under the Right to Information Act in which the Naib
Tehsildar has also informed that the land situated at survey No.1535/2/1
has never been used during the Simhastha Mela of 1992 to 2004 and
2016. Thus, it is submitted that these facts also substantiate the case of
the petitioners that the land does not fall within Simhastha Mela
Kshetra. Thus, it is submitted that the impugned order be set aside and
the petitioners may be allowed to occupy and use the building.
10]
Reply to the petition has been filed by the respondent No.1 only
and denying the averments made in the petition. It is submitted that
after the notice dated 16.10.2021 (Annexure P/11) passed by the
respondent under the provisions of Section 25(A) of M.P. Bhoomi
Vikas Nigam Adhiniyam, 1976 the petition does not survive as the
aforesaid order is an appealable order, hence the petition is
misconceived and is liable to be dismissed on this ground only.
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
11]
Learned counsel for the respondent has submitted that the
petitioners have also been given various notices by the Municipal
Corporation Ujjain and it is not that the order has been passed without
any intimation or without any notice to the petitioners.
12]
Counsel for the respondents has also relied upon a decision
rendered by this Court in the case of Suyash Exim Private Limited &
one another Vs. State of M.P. & Ors. passed in W.P. No.4778 of 2021
dated 01.07.2021 to submit that in case if an alternative remedy is
available, the petition is not maintainable.
13]
In rebuttal, learned senior counsel for the petitioners has
submitted that the earlier notices issued to the petitioners were prior to
the compounding and, thus, this ground is not available to the
respondents, and even otherwise, the main contention of the
respondents is that the land falls within the Simhastha Mela Kshetra
only as there is no other objection raised by the respondents in the order
itself. And, it is also submitted that otherwise also the first point raised
by the respondents in the impugned order dated 16.10.2021 regarding
the suppression of the registry, the petitioners had already uploaded the
correct registry and the other three points are in respect of the building
being constructed on the area reserved for Simhastha Mela Kshtra only
would also not survive for the reason that the revenue record has been
subsequently changed.
14]
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
15]
From the record, it is found that from the Khasra entries filed
along the petition from the year 1984 till 2021, the land was never
reserved for Simhastha Mela, whereas the impugned Khasra entry
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
Annexure P/9 reveals that it has been mutated in the name of
Simhastha Mela Kshetra, which was incorporated by Tehsildar on
08.10.2021. The letter dated 27.05.2013 issued by the Collector, Ujjain
clearly reveals that the disputed land bearing Survey No.1535/2
measuring 0.037 hectare is not reserved for Simhastha Kshetra. Thus, it
is rather surprising that the aforesaid subsequent entries, that the land
belongs to Simhastha Mela Kshetra and falls under the reserved area
vide Annexure P/9 . The respondents are silent as to how this entry
came to be entered into in the revenue record. It is also found that all
the requisite permissions for building constructions were already
obtained and fees were also paid by the petitioner by 18.07.2021 and
the earlier notice dated 13.10.2021 issued to the petitioner on the
premise that the land is reserved for Simhastha Mela Kshetra since last
16 years. Apparently, the aforesaid ground raised in the notice runs
contrary to the facts on record.
16]
It is also found that the petitioner has already satisfied/complied
with the objections/queries raised by the respondents that a wrong
registry has been uploaded as according to the petitioner the registry
which was uploaded was the registry of the erstwhile owner and
subsequently the registry of the petitioner has already been uploaded in
the respondents’ portal. This Court is of the considered opinion that the
respondents cannot apply the entry in revenue record retrospectively
i.e., after entering the name of Simhastha Mela Kshetra in the revenue
record on 08.10.2021, it cannot be enforced prior to the said date and
even otherwise how the aforesaid entry has come to be made is also a
question, which has not been answered by the respondents in their
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
reply. In such circumstances, the revenue entry (Annexure P/9) dated
08.10.2021 is liable to be quashed and similarly the subsequent notices
dated 16.10.2021 (Annexures P/11 and P/12) are concerned, the same
also cannot be sustained in the light of the fact that wrong entry was
made by the respondents in the revenue records that the disputed land
belongs to Simhastha Mela Kshetra. Accordingly, the same are also
liable to be quashed.
17]
So far as the ground raised by the respondents that against the
revocation of the building permission, a remedy of appeal is also
available to the petitioner is concerned, this court finds that the
revocation is based on the revenue entry dated 08.10.2021, which
cannot be assailed in an appeal under the M.P. Bhoomi Vikas Nigam
Adhiniyam.
18]
On the other hand, it is also found that the petitioner has placed
on record various photographs of the area in which the petitioner’s
building has been constructed, and it is found that adjacent to and in the
surrounding area of petitioner’s building, hundreds of other buildings
are already in existence, and it is apparent that no such action has been
taken against any of the owners of such buildings. Thus, the petitioner
has also been discriminated for the reasons best known to the building
officer, and in such circumstances, when the petitioners right
guaranteed under Article 14 are also violated, the remedy of appeal is
inconsequential.
19]
So far as the decision relied upon by the counsel for the
respondents in the case of Suyash Exim Private Limited & Anr.
(supra), is concerned, this Court is of the considered opinion that it is
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
distinguishable on facts and cannot be applied in the facts and
circumstances of the case on hand.
20]
Thus, the impugned orders dated 08.10.2021 (Annexure P/9),
16.10.2021 (Annexure P/11 and P/12) are hereby quashed and the
respondents are directed not to restrain the petitioners to complete the
building and the use of the same.
21]
Accordingly, writ petition stands allowed and disposed of.
(SUBODH ABHYANKAR)
JUDGE
moni
Signed by: MONI RAJU
Signing time: 1/10/2024
10:03:38 AM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review