Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL VERMA
WRIT PETITION No. 8168 of 2023
BETWEEN:RAJENDRA SINGH S/O LATE SHRI RANJEET SINGH ATAL R/O 615
STADIUM GROUND NANDA NAGAR INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
( BY SHRI CHANCHAL GUPTA-ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
JILADHEESH MAHODAY INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
POLICE AYUKT, INDORE POLICE AYUKT KARYALAY, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
AYUKT NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
BHARAT SARKAR THROUGH KENDRIYA ANVESHAN BYURO
(C.B.I.) 6TH MANZIL, LODHI ROAD, PLOT NO. 5 B, C.J.O.
COMPLEX, NEW DELHI (DELHI)
.....RESPONDENTS
( BY MS. ARCHANA KHER ALONGWITH SHRI GAURAV SINGH CHOUHANGOVRNMENT ADVOCATE)
(BY SHRI ANIKET NAIK-ADVOCATE RESPONDENT [R-4].)
WRIT PETITION No. 7934 of 2023
-2-
BETWEEN:MAHESH GARG S/O LATE SHRI R.K. GARG, AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: PURVA PARSHAD AND SOCIL WORKER R/O 16
SAMVAD NAGAR NAVLAKHA INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI MANISH YADAV-ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH COLLECTOR DISTT.
INODRE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
POLICE AAYUKT POLICE AAYUKT KARYALAYA INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
BHARAT SHASAN DWARA KENDRIYA ANVESHAN BUERO
(C.B.I) 6TH FLOOR, LODHI ROAD, PLOT NO. 5B JAWAHARLAL
NEHRU STADIUM MARG, C.G.O. COMPLEX NEW DELHI
(DELHI)
4.
AAYUKT NAGAR
PRADESH)
5.
THROUGH PRESIDENT/SECRETARY BALESHWAR MAHADEV
JHULELAL MANDIR TRUST SARVODAY NAGAR, PATEL
NAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
PALIKA
NIGAM
INDORE
(MADHYA
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI ANIKET NAIK-ADVOCATE [R-1 ).
( BY MS. ARCHANA KHER ALONGWITH SHRI GAURAV SINGH CHOUHANGOVRNMENT ADVOCATE)
WRIT PETITION No. 7935 of 2023
BETWEEN:-
-3PRAMOD DWIVEDI S/O SHRI RAMADHAR DWIVEDI, AGED ABOUT
51 YEARS, OCCUPATION: VAKALAT AVM SAMAJSEVA AMBIKA
NAGAR EXTENSION DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI MANISH YADAV-ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH COLLECTOR
DISTRICT INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
POLICE AAYUKT POLICE AAYUKT KARYALAYA, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
BHARAT SHASAN DWARA KENDRIYA ANVESHAN BUERO
(C.B.I) 6TH FLOR, LODHI ROAD, PLOT NO. 5B JAWAHARLAL
NEHRU STADIUM MARG, C.G.O. COMPLEXN NEW DELHI
(DELHI)
4.
AAYUKT NAGAR
PRADESH)
5.
THROUGH PRESIDENT/SECRETARY BALESHWAR MAHADEV
JHULELAL MANDIR TRUST SARVODAY NAGAR, PATEL
NAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
PALIKA
NIGAM
INDORE
(MADHYA
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI ANIKET NAIK-ADVOCATE [R-4].
( BY MS. ARCHANA KHER ALONGWITH SHRI GAURAV SINGH CHOUHANGOVRNMENT ADVOCATE)
This petition coming on for orders this day, Justice Vivek Rusia
passed the following:
Heard and reserved on : 10.01.2024
Order pronounced on : 19.01.2024
ORDER
-4-
Petitioners have filed these Writ Petitions in the nature of Public
Litigation Interest seeking enquiry/investigation by CBI, registration of
the criminal case against office bearers of Shri Veleshwar Mahadev
Jhulelal Mandir, Sneh Nagar and officers and employees of Municipal
Corporation, Indore or enquiry by the High-Level Committee appointed
by the High Court. The petitioners are also seeking payment of
compensation of Rs.25 lacs- 25 lacs to the family members of the
deceased family and Government Jobs to one of the dependents.
2.
The petitioners are permanent residents of Indore and claim to be
Public Spirited Persons.
3.
These Public Interest Litigations are in respect to the accident that
took place on 30.03.2023 in the
Shri Veleshwar Mahadev Jhulelal
Mandir situated at Sneh Nagar/ Patel Nagar, Indore. The temple and its
properties were managed by a registered trust. Inside the campus of the
temple, there used to be an ancient Baavadee/stepwell, which was
covered by the RCC slab constructed 30 years ago and a room was built
there. On 30.03.2023, the day of Ramnavmi, oblation (Havan) was going
on inside the room built over the stepwell. Suddenly, the said slab
collapsed on the date of Ramnavmi. Near about 11:40 am, as many as 67
persons were sitting inside the room on that floor/ slab and performing
the Havan. Suddenly, the slab collapsed, and all of them fell into the
Baavadee/stepwell. Immediately rescue operation was started and life of
18 persons was saved but 36 persons lost their lives. The size of the slab
was 20 x 50 and the depth of the Baavadee/ stepwell was 60 to 70 feet.
The slab was constructed 30 to 35 years back by the persons who were
managing the affairs of the temple without permission from the Indore
Municipal Corporation.
4.
Initial investigation revealed that the slab was constructed by using
iron girders, farsi, and cement mortar and thereafter flooring was done by
-5-
kota stone. The slab was 10 to 20 inches thick and because of the heat
generated by Havan, the girder and iron were expanded and could not
sustain, the weight and collapsed. A team of Civil Engineers and
Professors from SGSITS visited the place of the incident and found that
no support of the pillar was there below the slab. The slab was fixed on
all four corners by faulty and improper engineering. By the passing of
time, the girders rusted and because of heat generated during the Havan,
were expanded and possibly was the main cause of collapsed.
Immediately, an FIR was registered under Section 304/34 of IPC on
31.03.2023 against the accused persons namely Sewaram Galani and
Murli Kumar Sabnani but till today except for recording the statement,
there has been no progress in the investigation.
5.
According to the return filed by the respondents, the State
Government immediately paid compensation of Rs. 50,000/- to the 18
injured and Rs. 5,00,000/- to the members of all deceased families. The
State Government also handed over the enquiry to the Executive
Magistrate. Dr. Abhay Bedekar (IAS), Additional Collector conducted
the ministerial enquiry and submitted its report on 11.07.2023. On the
basis of the evidence collected during the enquiry, the learned Magistrate
opined that there was negligence in the survey of well by the Employees
and Officers of the Indore Municipal Corporation. The Magistrate
recorded the statements of the family members of the deceased who
deposed that they had no knowledge about the existence of Baavadee/
Stepwell in the campus of the temple which was covered by way of the
slab. No notice was displayed in the temple for information to the visitors
about the history of Stepwell for which President Shri Sewaram Galani
and Secretary Shri Murli Kumar Sabnani are negligent and responsible
for the incident. In order to avoid such types of incidents, the Magistrate
-6-
has given certain suggestions. The relevant part of the report and
suggestions are reproduced below:3-
mDr
?kfVr
l a
iw
. kZ ?kVukØ e
es
a D; k i fj fLFkfr ; ka Fkh] bl d s fy ,
d kS
u
ft Ee s
n kj gS
\
mDr ?kfVr l a
iw
. kZ ?kVu kØe esa ft u i fj fLFkfr ; ka
s d s d kj . k u q
d l ku gq
v k og bl
i zd kj gS
%
&
1-
i zkp hu f’ koea
fn j esackoM+
h gSbl
ckr d s d gha d ks
bZ uks
fVl
cks
MZ v Fkok l kbZ
us
t
ughay x k, x , FksA
2-
y x Hkx gj i zkp hu ea
fn j d k bfr gkl
, oa ea
fn j esa d kS
u &d kS
u l s n so r k LFkkfi r gS
r Fkk ea
fn j esad q
a
v k@i M
s @c koM+
h v kfn gSr ks ml d k bfr gkl
Hkh ckgj cks
MZ i j fy [ kd j
fn[ kk; k t kr k gS
] r kfd v ket u r k d ks bl d h t ku d kj h j gsA ; gka , sl h d ksb Z O; oLFkk u gha
FkhA
3-
i zkp hu f’ koea
fn j esafLFkr i q
j ku h ckoM+
h d ks fcu k r d u hfd l q
> ko , oaen n d s fcuk
mfp r j hba
Q ks
Z
l es
a
V d s Ly s
c Mky d j ca
n d j fn ; k x ; kA
4-
VªLV d si n kf/kd kfj ; ka
s d sl a
K ku esaj gr sgq
, Hkh u hp s ckoM+
h gS
] ogka/ kkfeZ
d d k; Z
Ø eka
s
d sfy , ea
fn j esa; K gsr qd kQ h e k= k e sa y ks
x ksa d ks v ke a
f= r fd ; k x ; kA
5-
ft l
LFkku i j Ly cs Mky d j ckoM+
h d ks ca
n fd ; k x ; k Fkk] ml h LFkku i j VªLV
d s } kj k gou d q
. M cukd j gou , oa; K d k v k; kst u fd ; k x ; kA mDr gou esa v kgw
fr
n su sgsr qv u sd O; fDr ; ka
sd ksLy cs i j fcBk; k x ; kA
6-
iq
j ku k , oa d et kjs Ly cs v R; kf/ kd ot u , oa gou l s i S
n k gq
bZ x e hZ d s d kj . k
/kl d x ; k r Fkk Ly sc i j cS
Bsl Hkh y ksx ckoM+
h d sv a
n j fx j i M+
A
s
7-
fu x e d s > ku
s y v f/kd kj h } kj k > ku
s &18 esa fLFkr ckofM+
; ksa d h t ks l w
p h i zn ku d h
x bZgS
] ml
l w
p h esabl
c koM+
h d k d ghad kb
s ZmYy s[ k u ghagS
A;g l a
Hko u ghagSfd fu x e d s
l osZesa mDr ckoM+
h d k mYy [s k u v k, ] D; ka
fsd ; g , d i q
j ku h ckoM+
h gS, oabl d k mYy s[ k
fu x e d s l osZ, oal w
p h esav ku k p kfg, FkkA ; g Li "V gSfd c kofM+
; ksad s l os
Ze s
a y ki j okgh
d h x bZ, oa ; g fu x e d s , oafu x e d s v f/kd kfj ; ka
s d sl a
K ku esaHkh u gha Fkk fd ml
LFkku
i j d ksb ZckoM+
h gS
A ; fn fu x e d s t y ; a
= ky ; , oa Mªu
s ts foHkkx } kj k ea
fn j d s ckgj mDr
ckoM+
h d s ckj s esa l w
p u k i Vy i j fy [ kk x ; k gkrs k r ks l Hkh d s l a
K ku esa j gr k fd ogka
ckoM+
h fLFkr gS
A
8-
t ka
p d s n kS
j ku ft r us Hkh y ksx er̀
gq
, gS
a mu d s i fj okj t u ksa l s , oa ft r u s y ksx
?kk; y gSmu l s esjs } kj k mu d s ?kj Lo; a t kd j eq
y kd kr d h x bZ gS
A bu O; fDr ; ksa esa l s
-7y x Hkx 90 i zfr ’ kr ; q
o kv ka
s } kj k ; g cr k; k x ; k fd ea
n j i fj l j esa, sl h d ksb Zc koM+
h gS; g
mu d s l aK ku e sa gh ugha gS
A l kFk gh 10 i fzr ’ kr i kzS
< + v Fkok o`)
y ksx ksa } kj k ; g cr k; k
x ; k fd ; g mu d sl a
K ku esagSfd ogkac koM+
h gSi j a
r qckoM+
h d ksLy sc l s<a
d fn , t ku sd s
d kj . k c koM+
h ea
fn j d s v a
n j fu f’ p r : Ik l s fd l
LFkku i j fLFkr gS; g cr k i ku k mu d s
fy , Hkh l a
Hko u gha gS
A ckoM+
h d sl a
ca
/ k esa v K ku r k Hkh cgq
r gn r d bl
nq
?kZ
Vu k d s fy ,
ft Eesn kj gS
A
9-
mDr
l eLr
i fj fLFkfr ; ka
s d s fy ,
csy ’soj egkn o
s >w
y ys ky
ea
fn j VªLV d s v /; {k
l so kj ke x y ku h , oa l fp o eq
j y h l cu ku h] t ks ea
fn j d s l a
p ky u , oa ml esa v k; ksft r gksu s
oky s l eLr d k; Z
Ø eka
s d k d k; Zn [s kr s Fks] os ea
fn j esa ckoM+
h d s fy , l w
p u k i Vy u y x ku s]
ea
fn j d s bfr gkl
d k ckM
s Zu y x ku s r Fkk ea
fn j esa v ku s oky s HkDr t u ksa d ks ea
fn j esa fLFkr
ckoM+
h d h t ku d kj h u n u
s sd si w
. kZ
r %nks
"kh gS
A VªLV d s v /; {k o l fp o d ks bl
Hky hHkkW
r h K ku Fkk fd ml
c kr d k
LFkku i j ckoM+
h gS
] D; ka
fsd mu d s od hy } kj k i zLr q
r t cko d s
fcUn q Øeka
d 05 esa ; g fy [ kk gSfd mud s } kj k fookfnr
ckoM+
h d h t kud kj h ux j
fux e d ks nh x bZFkh , oa ; g Hkh fy [ kk gSfd ux j fux e } kj k Ly s
c d h e t cw
rhds
l a
ca
/k es
a fd l h i zd kj d h d ksbZt ku d kj h ge s
a ugha nh x bZ
A
bl l s ; g LFkkfi r gkrs k gSfd VªLV d s v /; {k , oa l fp o d ks u d so y bl
t ku d kj h Fkh fd ea
fn j esa c koM+
h fLFkr gScfYd bl
ckoM+
h fd l
ckr d h
ckr d h Hkh l Vhd t ku d kj h Fkh fd
LFkku i j fLFkr gS
A v r %l Hkh HkDr t u ka
s d ks mDr Ly sc i j v k; ksft r gou esa
cS
Bku sd sfy , v / ; {k , oal fp o i w
. kZ: Ik l s nks
"kh gS
a
A
fu x e d s v f/kd kfj ; ka
s } kj k fn , x , d Fku ka
s esa, oai zLr q
r d h x bZfj i ksVZesa; gk d gk
gSfd mu d s } kj k fd , x , l osa
Zesa J h csy ’soj egkn o
s >w
y ys ky ea
fn j esa fLFkr ckoM+
hdh
d ksb Zfj i ksVZu gha gS
A bl l s Li "V gSfd fu x e d s v f/kd kfj ; ka
s u s l osZ
a d j u s esa y ki j okgh d h
, oackoM+
h d ksy ksd ksi ; kxs gsr ql q
j f{kr d j u sd sfy , fd l h i d
z kj d k d ksb Zi z; kl
; fn mu d s } kj k ckoM+
h fp fUgr
u ghafd ; kA
d j ogka l kbZ
V i j ckM
s Z v kfn y x k, t kr s , oa y ksx ksa d ks
ckoM+
h d s ckj s esacr k; k t kr k r ksl a
Hkor %n q
?kZ
Vu k u ghagkrs hA v r %fux e d s r Rd ky hu , oa
or Z
e ku t ks
u y v f/ kd kj h , oa t y ; a
= ky ; foHkkx d s r Rd ky hu , oa or Z
e ku v f/ kd kj h
Hkh nks
"kh gS
A
fu x e d s v f/kd kfj ; ka
su scr k; k gSfd mu d s} kj k t ks u ; k fu ekZ
. k x kMZ
u esafd ; k t k
j gk Fkk ml s u ksfVl
fu ekZ
. k fd l
fn ; k x ; k Fkk] i j a
r qi kzp hu f’ ko ea
fn j , oackoM+
h d s mi j x kMZ
u {ks= esa
i zd kj fd ; k x ; k , oaml
l e; fu x e d s v f/kd kfj ; ksau s fd l h i zd kj d h d ksb Z
d k; Z
o kgh D; ksau ghad h\ bl d k mu d si kl
d kb
s ZLi "Vhd j . k u ghagS
A v r %; g Hkh Li "V gSfd
-8d kW
y ksu h d s i kd Z d s v a
n j t gka fd l h Hkh i d
z kj d k fu ekZ
. k i fzr ca
f/kr gS
] ogka i zkp hu f’ ko
fi . Mh d s mi j
fu ekZ
. k Hkh u gha j ksd k x ; kA v r % fu x e d s Hkou v f/ kd kj h , oa Hkou
fuj h{kd Hkh nks
"kh gS
A
4-
Hkfo"; e s
a bl
bl
fd ,
i zd kj d h ?kVuk d h i q
u j kof̀Rr u gks
] bl
gs
r ql q
> koA
l a
ca
/ k esa J h t h-, l -v kbZ
-Vh-, l - d s fu n ’skd MkW
- j kd ’sk l Dl su k l s l q
> ko i zkIr
x , A mu d s } kj k d k; kZ
y;
esa cS
Bd
v kgw
r d j fop kj foe’ kZ fd ; k x ; k , oa fop kj
mi j ka
r fu Eu ku q
l kj l q
> ko i fsz"kr fd , x , %
&
1-
l a
iw
. kZ ' kgj esa ekS
t w
nk d q
,a
s , oa ckofM+
; ka
s d h i gp ku d j mDr
LkHkh d h t ku d kj h
, d f= r d h t kosr kfd mu d sl ja{k. k d h ; Fkk l a
Hko ; kst u k fu feZ
r d h t k l d sA
2-
l Hkh ckofM+
; ka
s, oad q
, sad k HkkS
fr d l R; ki u , oar d u hfd t ka
p d j okbZt kosA
3-
t gka Hkh d q
,a
s , oa c koM+
h [ kq
y s gS
a v kS
j ml d s mi j fd l h Hkh i zd kj d k LVªDp j d k
fu ekZ
. k u gha gksA mDr gsr q Hkkj r l j d kj d s fu n Z
’sk] , u -t h-Vh- bR; kfn d h x kbZ
M y kbZ
u dk
; Fkkl a
Hko i ky u d j sa
A
4-
l kekU; r %ckofM+
; ka
s esal hf<+
; kWgkrs h gSv kS
j dq
, aesal hf<+
; k u ghagksr h gS
A v r %c koM+
h
d h l hf<+
; ksav kS
+
j dq
, sad h y kbZ
fu a
x d k l e; l e; i j fu j h{k. k d j ej Eer , oal a
/ kkj . k fd ; k
t ku k p kfg, A
5-
fd l h d kj . k l sckoM+
h d ks<a
d u sd h v ko’ ; d r k gksr ks ofj "B LVªDp j y ba
t hfu ; j l s
i j ke’ kZv u q
l kj ckoM+
h v kS
j dq
,a
s d h Hkw
fe d k mfp r l a
LFkk l s eǹ k v Uos"k. k d j gh fMt kbZ
u
rS
; kj fd ; k t kd j r Fkk mfp r l a
LFkk l s v fHker mi j ka
r gh fØ; kfUor fd ; k t kosA mDr d q
, sa
ckofM+
; ksa d ks <+
d u s d s fy , ekV
s h t ky h l s Qze
s LVªDp j d k i ;z ksx d j fu feZ
r fd ; k t kos
ft l l st gj hy h x S
l safu d y t k, , oax kn bR; kfn d h l QkbZl j y r k l sgksl d sA
6-
ckoM+
h , oa d q
,a
s d h t ehu d s u hp s mi j , oa fu d Vor hZ l a
j p u k ¼mr j u s d s j kLr s]
n hokj bR; kfn ½d k okf"kZ
d fu j h{k. k d j mDr d sO; ki d okf"kZ
d j [ kj [ kko fd ; k t kosA+
7-
dq
, sackoM+
h ft l esaeq
Mjs u ghagSml d h eq
a
Mjs d k ma
a
pk d j l a
j f{kr fd ; k t kos] ft l l s
t u gkfu , oaI’ kq
g kfu l scp k t k l d A
s
8-
dq
,a
s , oa ckoM+
ht S
l hl a
j p u kv ka
s d ks ey ck Hkj u s d s LFkku i j l a
j f{kr fd ; k t kosA
ckoM+
h d ks d p j k Qsa
d u s d k LFkku u cu u s n s o ckoM+
h esa x kn bR; kfn d k Hkj . k u gks , oa
iw
o Zesat ek x kn d h fu d kl h d j mDr d ksHkwt y l a
o /kZ
u d sfy , mi ; ksx fd ; k t kosA
6.
It is very unfortunate that the above report was submitted by the
learned Executive Magistrate on 11.07.2023 to the Collector Indore and
the same was not brought to the knowledge of this Court as well as the
-9-
general public well within time. This report was disclosed only when this
Court passed the order on 28.11.2023 by giving directions to submit the
status of the enquiry report and the current status of the FIR. Now vide
application dated 30.12.2023, this Magistrate report has been filed, but
the status report has not been filed in respect of the FIR. After the
aforesaid incident, immediately, on 31.03.2023 Shri P.R. Aroliya,
Assistant Engineer and Shri Prabhat Tiwari were placed under
suspension. On 10.05.2023 charge sheet was issued, Enquiry Officers
have been appointed but till then the departmental enquiry has not been
completed in this matter.
7.
Now more than one year is going to pass from the date of an
unfortunate incident. Neither the accused have been put on Trial nor the
departmental enquiry has been completed.
8.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties we are of the
considered opinion that now no need for CBI Enquiry or the High-Level
Enquiry appointed by the High Court is required. The Respondents are
directed to take action on the ministerial enquiry report and implement its
suggestions. The Station House Officer, Police Station Juni, District
Indore is directed to complete the investigation in the FIR. The Deputy
Commissioner of Police, Indore of the concerned zone is directed to
monitor the investigation and see that it should be completed at least
before completion of one year from the date of the incident.
9.
So far as the claim of payment of the compensation of Rs.
25,00,000/- to the dependent of the deceased is concerned, the State
Government from its discretion immediately released the compensation.
If the injured and family members of the deceased are not satisfied with
the compensation. They shall be at liberty to claim the compensation
10.
Shri Manish Yadav, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
after the said incident, the Municipal Corporation, Indore closed all the
-10-
Baavadee and wells in Indore which cannot said to be the solution for
avoiding such type of incident. The Baavadee and wells used to be the
main source of water for the public, they were constructed by earlier
rulers and kings to preserve the water and raise the groundwater level,
therefore, instead of maintaining and providing safety measures,
Baavadee and wells should not have been closed permanently, therefore,
direction to issue to be opened Baavadee and wells for use of the public.
11.
During the princely era, more than a hundred stepwells were built
in Indore. Somewhere one storey and somewhere tow storeyed. Their
beauty is worth seeing. People used to drinke water from these stepwells.
Farming was done by extracting water from Chadas. Its marks are still
present on many stepwells. Champa stepwell is built in front of Rampur
Kothi. It was built in 1836 before the construction of Lalbagh. The
special thing about this two-storey stepwell is that there is water in its two
parts. There is a square stepwell smaller than champa stepwell. There is a
big fort built on the banks of Khan river near Moti Tabela. Here the
Chhatri of king Harirao Holker of Holkar state and his relatives is built.
There is a very ancient stepwell in the fort. It has access from three sides,
while a road used to run on one side. Farming was done in the area
through Chadas from the stepwell of Idgah in Sadar Bazar. There is also a
princely period stepwell in Kamathipura. The stepwell located in the Lal
Hospital complex is called Tatya’s stepwell. Apart from Panchkuiya area,
there was also a stepwell in Gorakund. There are many ancient stepwells
in Juni Indore, Rambagh, Narsingh Bazar Chowk, Kashinath Holkar Ka
Bada, Khajrana, Malharashram, Narayan Bagh. There is also an ancient
stepwell in Juni Indore Bada Rawala, which is still the main source of
water.
12.
Baavadee are an integral part of our culture life. Evidence of
-11-
stepwell dates back to the Indus Valley Civilization between 2500-1700
B.C. Initially constructed as crude trenches, they slowly evolved into
engineering marvels between 11th -15 Centaury, the Mughal Emperors did
not disrupt the culture that was practices in these stepwell and encouraged
the building of stepwell. But the authorities during the British Raj found
the hygiene of the stepwell less that desirable and installed pipe and pump
system to replace their purpose. The excellent water harvesting and
drainage system in the cities of ancient India are master pieces of their
time and were prominent that even today’s modern day water harvesting
structures can be based upon their design.
13. Baavadee is another type of stepwells built around the reservoirs to
narrow and deeper them, which helps in minimizing the loss of water
through evaporation. Baavadee water harvesting is an ancient Indian
practice that involves collecting rainwater from roof tops and storing it
for later use. This method has been used for centuries like Indian as a way
of providing access to clean drinking water during times of drought or
other water shortages. One of the old rain water management approaches
in Baavadees, these Baavadee allow storing water for prolonged time as
amount of water evaporation from the deep well is very limited.
Restoration requires surveying surrounding structures to present any
damage. A Baavadee needs a proper catchment area through which water
can reach underground aquifers. Unfortunately, there is no universal way
of restoring a Baavadee restoration needs to be done using traditional
material with skilled craftsmen, architects and structural engineer.
Restoration of Baavadees can certainly provide solution at the local level
to battle water scarcity.
14.
The Baavadee and wells that have been integral sources of water
for our community for many generations have been significant.
-12-
Historically, these Baavadee wells were ingeniously constructed by
earlier rulers and kings with the foresight to preserve water and elevate
the groundwater levels. The continued use of these water sources has
been a lifeline for our community, providing not only a vital resource for
daily needs but also contributing to the sustainability of our environment.
However, there has been a recent decision to permanently close these
Baavadee and wells, after the incident dated 30.03.2023 which, in our
opinion, goes against the spirit of their original purpose. Instead of opting
for closure, we direct respondents to maintain and implement safety
measures to ensure the well-being of the public while still allowing them
access to these essential water sources.
15.
Accordingly we direct to Indore Municipal Corporation for the
immediate reopening of the Baavadee and wells. By doing so, it will not
only honour the historical significance of these structures but also
continue to provide a reliable and sustainable water source for our
community with proper regulations and oversight to ensure the wellbeing of the public while preserving these invaluable resources.
16.
These Baavadee and wells in the city and nearby villages are
required to be maintained and cleaned from time to time by the Indore
Municipal Corporation or local bodies. Even if it is on private land, the
owner of the land is required to maintain the Baavadee and wells properly
with all safety measures. The State Government and Corporation both are
directed to revive these Baavadee and wells and take necessary steps for
providing protection, and safety measures in order to avoid any incident.
The services of experts and technical be taken for the revival of these
Baavadee and wells. This court hopes and trusts that NGOs and societies,
Clubs, Social organizations, Communities, Private companies or Public
sectors may come forward to adopt these historical Baavadee and wells
-13-
for their revivals and developments.
17.
With the above observation and direction, all the Writ
Petitions are disposed of. No order as to cost.
18.
Office is directed to place the photocopy of this order in all
connected cases.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Praveen
PRAVEEN
Date: 2024.01.19 18:16:46
+05'30'
(ANIL VERMA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review