Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
\
132521
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 17377 OF 2026
Between:
Rachamalla Pushpalatha, Wo. Rachamalla Narender Reddy, aged 49 years,
R/o. Plot No. 60, Shirdipuram Colony, Turkayamjal Village, Abdullapurmet
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
...PETITIONER
AND
'1. The State of Telangana, rep. by its Prl. Secretary, Finance and Planning
Department, Saifabad, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, rep. by its Commissioner,
Hyderabad.
3. The District Collector, Ranga Reddy District, Kongara Kalan, Adibhatla,
Ranga Reddy Diskict.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a Writ, Order or direction more especially in the nature of mandamus
declaring the action of the Respondents authorities in not clearing the bills of the
petitioner for the works executed vide agreemenlNo. 43312024-25 dated 17.10.2024
and vide agreement No. EEC-4I63/2023-24 daled 22.09.2023 sanctioned under
CDP funds and consequently direct the respondents to clear the bills for the subject
works with an interest @ 12 o/o per annum from the date of taking over possession of
the subject works, till realization.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed rn support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct the
respondents authorities to clear the bills for the subject works covered by
Agreements vide Nr 433/2024-25 dared 1z.10.2024 and vide agreement No. EEC4/6312023- A. dated 22.09.2023 executed by petitioner and make the payments forth
with pendrnE disposal of Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI p U BHASKARA RAO
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.l and 3: Gp FOR FINANCE AND PLANNING
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI p. SRINIVASA RAO, SC
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION
o.L7377 ol 2026
DATE: 16 .06.2026
Between:
Rachamalla Pushpalatha
...Petationer
And
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Fina nce and Planning Department,
Saifabad, Secretariat, Hyderabad
and two others
...Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri P.U.Bhaskara Rao, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner, learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Finance & Planning appearing
on behalf of the respondent Nos.1 and 3 and
Sri P.Srinivasa Rao, learned Standing Counsel for
GHMC, appearing on behalf of respondent No.2.
2. The oetitioner aporoached t heC ourt seekinq
praver a s under:
SN,J
W,P.No.L7377 of 2026
"...to issue a Writ, Order or direction more
especially in the nature of mandamus declaring the
action of the Respondents authorities in not clearirig the
bjlls of the petitioner for the works executed vide
agreement No.433/2024-25 dated 77.tO.2024 and vide
agreement No.EEC-4/63/2023-24 dated 22.O9.2023
sanctioned under CDP funds and consequently direct the
respondents to clear the bills for the subject works with
an interest @ 12% per annum from the date of taking
over possession of the subject works, till realization and
to pass any such other order, and further orders as this
Hon'b,e Court may deem fit and proper in the
circu msta nces of the case...... "
3.
The c a se of the Detitio ner in brief as Der the
avermen s made in the affidavit filed bv the
etitio ner
in suooort of the oresent Writ Petiti on is as under:-
(i)
The petitioner is a Class-III Civil Contractor executing
civil works for Government departments and local bodies in
the State of Telangana. The petitioner was awarded two works
by the respondent authorities, namely (i) Providing Open Gym
at Gandhrnagar, Division No.29, Badangapet Municipal
Corporation under CDP Funds, covered by Agreement
No.43312024-25 dated 17.70.2024, and (ii) providing Open
Gym at Sai Tirumala Nagar Colony, Hastinapuram Division
under CDP Funds, covered by Agreement No.EEC-4/63/202324 dated 22.09.2023.
ri)
The petitioner completed both works in all respects and
the same were duly measured, check measured, and recorded
l
sN,l
W,P.No,L7377 ol 2026
by the competent authorities. pass order was issued and pD
cheques were also generated for payment of the bills.
However, the amounts due to the petitioner have not been
released on the ground that funds have not been allotted by
the Finance Department.
iii)
Despite repeated requests and representations, the
respondents have failed to clear the petitioner,s admitted
dues. Aggrieved by the arbitrary non-payment of the bills for
the completed works, the petitioner has filed the present writ
petition seeking appropriate directions from this Court.
4.
PER USED T E RECO RD:-
(A)
The
relev ant
dat d oa.o .2019
Vs
State
assed
Do rtion
f
in M/s.
urva C onstruc rons
the
IU do
of Utta rP rad e s h a d othe rsr el'ort
Cou rt in Ci il Aooe
eTw
d
I No.2 61O of
nch
ent
n
EA
O19 (Ar isino o tof
SL P (C) N o .29505 of 2O1 4). is extracte d hereun der:
"...It is clear, therefore, from the aforesaid
order dated 22.O3.2014 that there is no dispute
as to the amount that has to be paid to the
appellant. Despite this, when the appellant
knocked at the doors of the High Court in a writ
,1
SN,J
W.P,No.L7377 ot 2026
petition being Writ Civil No.25126 of 2014, the
impugned judgment dated 02.05.2014 dismissed
the writ petition stating that disputed questions of
fact arise and that the amount due arises out of
contract. We ar e afraid th Hioh Cou was
who llv incorr ect I nas uch as there wa sno
d iso uted ou estion of fact. On the con
tv,
the amount oavable to the aooellant is
wholly undisputed. Equally, it is well settled
that where the State behaves arbitrarilv,
e en in the rea lm of cont r a
the H oh Cou rt
t rl
r
th
Cons itution of India I'A BL Intern tiona I
Ltd. and Another v. Export Credit Guarantee
Coroor tion of India td. and Othe
(2()04
(3) SC 553)1.
This being the case and the work having
been completed long back in 2009, we direct the
Uttar Pradesh Jal Nigam to make the necessary
payment within a period of four weeks from
today. Given the long period of delay, interest at
the rate of 6 per cent per annum may also be
awarded.
The appeal stands disposed of accordingly.,,
(B) The Apex Court in th
8SC
iudqme
reDo
tn
OinM
sAl
rum
an
Limi ed vs. T amil Nad u Electrici tv Board and An other
vide udqment d ated 06.07. 2023, at
raq ra Dh
os.39
and 4O obse rved as u der:
"39, A Bench of two learned Judges of this
Court in Shritekha Vidyarthi (Kumari) v. State of
U. P. ' observed that there exists .,an
obvious
difference" between contracts concerning private
SN,J
W.P.No.17377 of 2026
parties to those which have State as a party. The
primary difference being that the State while
exercising its powers and discharging its functions
"acts indubitably, as is expected of it, for public
good and in public interest". The said factor
singularly is sufficient to bring into any
transaction the minimal requirements of public
Iaw, to which the State is a party. The fact that a
dispute falls into the contractual realm does not
relieve the State of its obligation to comply with
the requirements of Article 14.
40. Further the Court in Shrilekha Vidyarthi
case4 had observed that: (SCC p.237, para 24)
"24. fhe State cannot be attributed the
split personality of Dr.Jekyll and Mr. Hyde in the
contractual field so as to impress on it all the
characteristics of the State at the threshold while
making a contract requiring it to fulfil the
obligation of Article 14 of the Constitution and
thereafter permitting it to cast off its garb of State
to adorn the new robe of a private body during
the subsistence of the contract enabling it to act
arbitrarily subject only to
the contractual
obllgations and remedies flowing from it. It is
really the nature of its personality as State which
is significant and must characterize all its actions,
in whatever field, and not the nature of function,
contractual or otherwise, which is decisive of the
nature of scrutiny permitted for examining the
validity of its act. The requirement of Article 14
being the duty to act fairly, justly and reasonably,
there is nothing which militates against the
concept of requiring the State always to so act,
even in contractual matters. There is a basic
difference between the acts of the State which
must invariably be in public interest and those of
a private individual, engaged in similar activities,
being primarily for personal gain, which may or
may not promote public interest. Viewed in thls
matter, in which we find no conceptual difficulty
SN,J
W.P.No.L7377 of 2026
or anachronism, we find no reason why the
requirement of Article 14 should not extend even
in the sphere of contractual matters for regulating
the conduct of the State activity."
(c)
her
30. 4.2
nt
he
n
th
Pra desh in Katta Chi nna Ko
c
en
An
iah vs. The Sta
of
An dhra Pr adesh reoo rted in MA NU/AP/ 72L/20 22, as
extra cted hereu nder:
"The Aoex Co urt and this Cou rt in
cate na of decisi ns held th at when th ere ts
n on-Da m en to t the u n d sDUte.l biil s. the
vl rt
rti ac l, rri d1 .rf +h6
Const itution of India. The counsel for the
petrtioner rightly placed reliance on the decision
of the Apex Court in Surya Constructons Vs.
State of Utter Pradesh and others, following the
judgment in ABL International Ltd. Vs, Export
Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. Cited
supra. In view of the Apex Court judgment, the
contention of the learned Government pleader
that the writ petition is not maintainable before
this Court couid not be countenanced. The bills of
the petitioner dated 13.3.2019 are admitted by
the respondents and forwarded for payment after
due measurements and obtaining quality control
and the Vigilance report. Hence, the authorities
are estopped from stating that the bills are
submitted without executing the works. On the
rrere ground of pendency of Vigilance report,
payment cannot be stopped. Accordinoly, there
sha I bead rection o the re sDonden ts to
oav the bill amount of Rs.g,Og,g2g/- to the
DE tione r within aDe iod of stx w eeks fr
om
th eda eof rece iDt o f coo vof this orde
sNrJ
W.P.No.L7377 ol 2026
(D)
The
releva n t
oortio noft
e iudq ent
dated 16.03.2021 pErssed bv the High Court of Andhra
Pradesh
The
in Mutvala Veeravenka
Satvanarava na vs,
State of Andhra Pra desh re orted in 2 o2L
SCCOnI ine AP 1410, in oarticular
raoraDh No .8 and
9, is extracted hereunder:
"8. The provisions of the Act make it clear
that it is a welfare legislation meant to create
employment/eradicate unemployment in rural
areas and in the process to create durable assets
for rural India. Thus, it is clear that a public
element is involved in these works with State
participation and funding, The "States" presence
is therefore all pervasive in this scheme. The law
on the interpretation of welfare legislation is also
very clear. As held in number of cases including
K.H.Nazar v. lvlathew K Jacob case by the
Supreme Court of India "Judges ought to be
concerned with the colour, content and the
context of such statutes". Therefore, in view of
the settled law and keeping in mind the purpose
for which the legislation is enacted, this Court has
to hold that there is a public element involved in
thls and that it is not a pure case of the State
entering into a commercial contract.
9. Apart from this when State or State
instru m entalities act i an arbitrarv ma n ner
or fail to act within time the Writ Court does
have iuri iction to entertain t he matter.
Even the case law cited by the learned counsel for
the petitioner supports this to an extent. Besides
this Court notices that there is no method/mode
for settlement of disputes provided for. Section 23
of the Act and Rule 14 of Schedule-I for example
SN,J
W.P.No.L7377 ot 2026
provide for constant monitoring of the
works/books to be maintained etc. Despite this,
there is no strict denial of the exact quantum of
work executed. "
(E)
at
.202
22.
Pra desh
Dortio nof
relev ant
Th
as
Da ra qraDh Nos.2
iudqm ent
eHi
b
W.P.No.2 511
tn
the
of
2022.
tn
t
dh
a
rticu lar
3and2 4, is ext racted here u nder:
'23 )Th e Hiqh Court o f And hra Prad esh
in J. Devendra Reddy v Kakativa University
n
h r
tn
A
held that withholdino of the amount pavable
ton
t I
r
rk
constitutes patent arbitrariness on the part
t
t
d
h
res ondent stoDa v 2015 the am Unt du eto
n f
w
tn
e
r
annum.
241 fhe Hi h Court of And hra Pra esh
in S. Srinivas vs. State of Andhra pradesh
and others reDort ed in o2t ( 5) AL T 267.
hel that the Det itioner is entit led for the
r
r
tr
bill to till the date of oavment.,,
at
(F)
Th
21.
.2025
of 2025in
hereunder:
rele va nt
ed
arti cular
oortio nof
thi c
araq
Dh
the
tn
IU do
N
ent
L7
No.5. lSe xtra cted
o
SN,J
W.P.No.L7377 ot 2026
*5.
h
the s ubmissi ons of
e
c
r
appropriate to dispose of the writ Petition bv
avt no reoard
mount of
rele ase th e adm itted b iil
Rs.1.16,51.734.OO/ due to the petitioner' as
expeditiouslv as Dossible, Dreferablv within a
oen od of ix (6) weeks f rom t he dat of
Dtofa coov of h e order. No co ts
(G) The relevant Dortion of the order of this Court
date
03.10. O23 Das
d under similar circumsta nces
tn
.P.No,12 655 of
2023 in
Da rticul
ar Dara raDh
Nos. 2 and 13 is extrac ted hereu der:
"12. In the light of the pleadings and
arguments referred to above, it is clear that there
is no dispute with regard to amounts payable
under Bill Nos.34, 35 and 36. It as been held
by the Hon'ble supreme court from time to
time that writ iurisdiction per se cannot be
denied merelv because the dispute arose out
of a commercial contract as held in Surya
Constructions' case (SuDra 1),
I nter
ational Li ited's cas
ABL
(Suora 2 ) and
Manufa unnq
Soinn ino and
ComD anv Limited 's case (S ora 3). In Su rva
,hte
c on truct o n ' case ( trnrA 1 ) the Ho
s UDT eme C rrrt ora n ted re ti ef trl thc
petitioner therein takino note of the fact that
etitioner were
bills oava ble to the
Centu rv
n
ln
tn
getitioner stands on a better footino as the
itioner are not n lv adm itted
bi! ls of the
but also certified. As observed above, in the
present case there is no dispute as such between
the parties. The only issue is with regard to
release of payment under Bill Nos.34, 35 and 36
l0
SN,J
W,P,No.L7377 of 2026
by the respondents - State. No explanation is
forthcoming from the respondents as to why the
amounts covered by Bill Nos.34, 35 and 36
cannot be released. According to the respondents,
Bill Nos.34, 35 and 36 are pending for want of
budgetary clearance. On the face of it, action of
the respondents is arbitrary, unreasonable and
unjust and the same cannot be countenanced.
13. Th
contention of th e learned
Add itional Advoc ate G enera I that the
petitioners have to approach civil Court even
for pavment of admitted bills runs contrarv
to the settled leoal proposition, This Court
would also look into the public interest involved.
The project, as informed by the learned counsel
on either side, is an ongoing project ancl the bi s
worth of hundreds of crores are kept pending for
no reason and there is every possibility of non_
release of payment impacting the ongoing project
and the same would not be in public interest.
Even for this reason, this Court holds that the
petitioner has made out a case warranting
interference in writ jurisdiction. Further, as there
is inordlnate delay in release of payments covered
by the subject bills by the respondents to the
petitioner without any justification, in the opinion
of this Court, the respondents are liable to pay
penal interest. However, as against the claim of
187o per annum sought by the petitioler, this
Court hoids that the respondents are liable to pay
penal interest at go/o per annum.,,
H
Th
m n
Kris hna Ma ndir
ar
lar
r
H
Trust V State of Maha ashtra
o ther s reDorte in AIR 2 o
tn
h
o
oo
Suo reme
d1
el
and
ou rt 396 9 and
f il w
il
SN,J
W.P.No,L7377 oC 2026
"100. The High Courts exercising their jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, not only have
the power to issue a writ of mandamus or in the nature
of mandamus, but are d utv-bound to exe ise such
DOWer, Wh re the Government or a oublic
authoritv has failed to exercise or has wronqlv
exercised discretion conferred uoon it by a
oolicv decision of the
statute, or a rule, or
Government or has exerc ised such discretion mala
r
tr
v n
nsideration
101. In all such cases, the High Court must issue a writ
of mandamus and give directions to compel
performance in an appropriate and lawful manner of the
discretion conferred upon the Government or a public
authority. "
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION:-
5. The learned counsel appearinq on behalf of the
petitioner submits that the subiect issue in the present
writ petition is souarely covered bv the order of this
Court dated 02.03.2026 Dassed in W.P.No.3346 ot 2026
and hence, the Detitioner is entitled for the qrant of
relief as
extended to
the
Detitioner in
W.P.No.3346 of 2026, dated 02.03.2026
6.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner
mainly puts-forth the following submissions:-
a) Petitioner was awarded two works by the respondent
authorities, namely (i) Providing Open Gym at Gandhinagar,
Division No.29, Badangapet Municipal Corporation under CDP
t2
SN,J
W.P.No.17377 of 2026
Funds, covered by Agreement No.433/2024-25 dated
17.10.2024, and (ii) Providing Open Gym at Sai Tirumala
Nagar Colony, Hastinapuram Division under CDp Funds,
covered by Agreement No.EEC- /63/2023-24 dated
22.09.2023.
b)
The petitioner had executed subject work entrusted by
the said agreements and concluded the same on time.
c)
The said executed works were duly recorded and check
measured and pass orders were issued in favour of the 3.d
respondent
d) The PD cheque Nos.2700319302, dated 06.05.2026 and
2514726326, dated 20.06.2024 were also issued in favour of
the 3'd Respondent for an amount of Rs.9,70,415/- and
Rs.4,B2,B1O /- respectively.
e) However, treasury authorities did not clear the said pD
cheques as no funds were released by the Finance
Department
Base d on the afores aid submissi ns, learned
ADD earl no
ounsel
n beh alf of th e Detiti oner con tends that
l3
SN,J
W-P.No.17377 ol 2026
petitioner is entitled for the relief as oraved for bv the
petitioner herein
7, The learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Finance & Planning appearing on behalf of the
respondent Nos.1 and 3 does not dispute the
submissions made by the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner, in so far as the application of
the principle laid down in the said judgments (referred
to and extracted above) to the facts of the present
case on the point that when there is non-payment of
the undisputed bills, the same is violative of Articles 14
& 16 of the Constitution of fndia and the state is bound
to act fairly.
8.
A bare perusal of the record indicates that the
facts pleaded by the petitioner had been undisputed by
the respondents and work completion report filed by
the petitioner as material document in support of
petitioner's case, further indicates that the subject
work sanctioned vide order, dated O9.0S.2023 of the
Collector had been completed at a cost of Rs.4,82,810/-
and had been handed over to the user Agency under
t4
SN,J
W.P.No.17377 of 2026
intimation to the District Authority for use on
06.11.2023. Record also indicates PD cheque
No,25L4726326, dated 20,06.2024 for an amount of
Rs.4,82,810/- as having been issued in favour of the 3'd
respondent, which however had not been cleared by the
Finance Department. Hence, this Court opines that
petitioner is entitled for grant of relief in the present
writ petition.
9.
TAKING INTO CONSIDERATIO N:
a)
The aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case,
b) The submissions made by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner and learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Finance & Planning
appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos.1 and 3,
c) The observations in the judgments referred to and
extracted above and again enlisted belowl
(i) (2019) L6 SCC 794,
(ii) (2023) 8 SCC 240,
(iii) MANU/AP / 07 2L / 2O22t
(iv) 2O21 SCCOnline AP 1410,
(v) The judgment dated 22.O3.2022 passed by the
High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P.No.2511 of
2022,
l5
SN,J
W.P.No.L7377 of 2026
(vi) The judgment dated 21.04.2025 passed by
this Court in W.P.No.1L744 ol 2025,
(vii) The order dated 03.10.2023 passed by this
Court in W.P.No.12555 ot 2O23,
(viii) AIR 2O2O Supreme Court 3969
(d)
The discussion and conclusion as arrived at
paragraph Nos.s to 8 of this order,
The oresent writ Detitao
terms of the order of thi
is also disoosed of in
Court, dated O2.O3.2026
eliraatiarr tha
of 2026
resoondents herein to co nsider the reouest of the
oetitioner for release of the admitted, undisouted,
bills of the Petitioner a ountino to Rs.g.7O.4LSlass ad
in
n
.4 a2 8 o
R
WDNa??
4A
h
Nos.2700319302. dated O6.05.2026 and 2514726326.
dated 20.06.2024 oertainin q to the works executed in
resDect of (a) Providinq O oen Gvm at Gandhinaoar,
B
d n
un der CDP Funds. covered
et Muni
o
v Aoree m e n t No.433 2 o24-
25 dated 17.10.2024, and (ii) Providinq Ooen Gvm at
Sai Tirumala Naqar Colonv, HastinaDuram Divislon
under CDP Funds, covered by Aqreement No.EEC:
416312023-24 dated 22.09.2023 alonq with interest,
t6
SN,J
W.P.No.17377 of 2026
within a D er! d of four (O4) week s fro
receiDt
the date of
of a coDv of this order dulv takinq into
consideration the observati ons of the ADex Court and
other Courts in the various Judqments referred to and
extracted abo ve and oass aDoroDriate ord ers oertaininq
o release of the said am
Providin
n
Ooen Gvm at Gandhinaqar, Division No.2 , BadanqaDet
Municioal Cor ooration under CDP Fund
024-25 dat d L7,L
covered bv
2 2
Providino Oo en Gvm at Sai Tirumala Naqar Colonv,
a
a ura
Division under CDP F n
b
Aoreement No.EEC-4l63 I 2O23-24 dated 22.09.2023 to
the oetitioner herein, as oer oetitioner's leoal
entitlement. No order as to costs.
N4iscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this Writ
Petition, shall stand closed.
//TRUE COPYII
SD/-P. PONNA KRISHNA
AS STANT REGISTRAR
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Prl. secretary, Finance,and pranning
Department, saifabad, secretariat,
The State or Telangana. Hyderabad.
2. The Commissioner,
Hyderabad.
The Greater Hyderabad Municipal
Corporation,
3. The District Collector Ranga Reddy
District, Kongara Kalan,
Ranga Reddy District
One CC to Sri p. U. Bhaskara
Rao, Advocate tOpUCl
Adibhafla,
5. Two CCs to the GP for Revenue, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
HyderabadIOUT]
6. One CC to Sri P. Srinivasa Rao, SC [OPUC]
7. Two CD CoPies
TJ
BS
/{0../
I
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1610612026
1\rE STAIF
(
o
o
ORDER
.r9 .l'- r :^ii \: -:=---_:-=:
WP.No.17377 of 2026
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
rtN
\$
),
"c
7-
25JUN2 020
C)
*
I
fJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review