Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
- : 1 :W.P. Nos. 5465/2011 & 4161/2011
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
WRIT PETITION No. 5465 of 2011
BETWEEN:PROPRIETOR M.U.STEEL WORKS THRU. PROP. MOHD. USMAN, 8/4,
DAULATGANJ, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI VEER KUMAR JAIN, LEARNED SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS.
VAISHALI JAIN, ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER.)
AND
CHAIRMAN INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AND 2 ORS.
1. THRU.CHAIRMAN/CEO,7,RACE COURSE ROAD,INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
ESTATE OFFICER INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY 7, RACE
2.
COURSE ROAD, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
INDORE LOHA VYAPARI ASSOCIATION THR: PRESIDENT LOHA
3.
BHAWAN, NEW LOHA MANDI, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI YOGESH KUMAR MITTAL,
RESPONDENTS NO.1 AND 2.)
LEARNED
COUNSEL
FOR
WRIT PETITION No. 4161 of 2011
BETWEEN:M/S MALWA STEEL TRADERS THRU. PARTNER, PARSHURAM
1. MISHRA, 35, JOY BUILDERS COLONY, INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
M/S. MALWA STEEL TRADERS THRU: PRABHAT S/O PARSHURAM
2. MISHRA, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 35,
JOY BUILDERS COLONY (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI NITIN PHADKE, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS.)
AND
1. CHAIRMAN INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY AND 4 ORS.
- : 2 :W.P. Nos. 5465/2011 & 4161/2011
7,RACE COURSE ROAD,INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
C.E.O. INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY 7, RACE COURSE
2.
ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
ESTATE OFFICER INDORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY 7, RACE
3.
COURSE ROAD (MADHYA PRADESH)
4. DISTRICT COLLECTOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
PRESIDENT THE INDORE LOHA VYAPARI ASSOCIATION LOHA
5.
BHAWAN,NEW LOHA MANDI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI YOGESH KUMAR MITTAL,
RESPONDENTS NO.1 AND 2.)
LEARNED
Reserved on
:
18.12.2023
Pronounced on
:
03.01.2024
COUNSEL
FOR
These petitions having been heard and reserved for order,
coming up for pronouncement this day, this Court pronounced the
following:
ORDER
As the controversy involved in the present writ petitions is
identical, therefore, they are being disposed of by this common order.
For the sake of convenience, the facts narrated in W.P. No.5465/2011
are being taken into consideration.
1.
The petitioners have filed the present petitions seeking
quashment of letter No. 3697 dated 25.4.2011 whereby a decision was
taken to allot the plots situated in Scheme No. 78 (New Loha Mandi,
Indore) to 8 members of the Indore Loha Vyapari Association
(hereinafter referred to as “the Association” for short) including the
present petitioners by way of a draw @ Rs.17,757/- per Sq.mtr. The
petitioners and 6 others were directed to given consent by depositing
amount of Rs.1,50,000/- each as registration fee within a period of 15
days. Out of 8, only two petitioners have filed the present petitions
- : 3 :W.P. Nos. 5465/2011 & 4161/2011
challenging the rate i.e. Rs.17,757/- per Sq.mtr.
2.
The facts of the case, in short, are as under :
2.1
The petitioners are the proprietor and partnership firms engaged
in the business of trading of steel/iron. Respondent No.1 is Indore
Development Authority (IDA) established u/s. 38 of the M.P. Nagar
Tatha Gram Nivesh Adhiniyam, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “the
Act of 1973” for short). Respondent No.1 is the Estate Officer of IDA
and respondent No.3 is the Association of the traders engaged in the
business of steel trading.
2.2
IDA proposed the scheme No. 78 Part-I for establishment of a
market for the iron & steel traders i.e. “New Loha Mandi” so that they
can be shifted to newly established Loha Mandi. The iron & steel
traders formed an association i.e. respondent No.3 and got registered
under the provisions of the M.P. Society Registrikaran Adhiniyam. The
petitioners are the members of the said Association. The IDA invited
the applications from the members of the Association for allotment of
plots in New Loha Mandi on premium and annual lease-rent. On the
aforesaid proposal, the Association sent the consent by letter dated
9.9.2005 for allotment of plots to its members. A meeting was
conducted between the office bearers of the Association and the Chief
Executive Officer of the IDA and the minutes were recorded on
5.10.2005. According to the petitioner, in the aforesaid meeting a
proposal was made for allotment of 'A' type plots (78 plots) @
Rs.4,006/- per Sq.mtr. and 'B' type (296 plots) @ Rs.4,011/- per Sq.mtr.
The petitioner gave their consent for allotment of plot and after holding
various negotiations, Resolution No. 255 dated 7.12.2005 was passed
for allotment of the plots to the members of the Association @
Rs.3,500/- per Sq.mtr. by holding a draw.
- : 4 :W.P. Nos. 5465/2011 & 4161/2011
2.3
According to the petitioners, in pursuant to the aforesaid
resolution, the Association collected Rs.25,000/- each (25,000/- x 367)
from its members and deposited with the IDA by way of Pay Order of
Rs. 91,75,000/- along with the list of members who were desirous for
allotment of the plots in Scheme No. 78. The name of the petitioner
appeared in the list at Sr. No.270. According to the petitioner, in the
first list, the name was wrongly typed as “M.A. Steel Works”, but in
the second list it was corrected. The IDA also published the list of 45
ineligible members, in which the name of the petitioner was not there.
A draw was held in which the petitioner's name was not considered for
allotment. The petitioner submitted a complainton which a survey was
conducted and note-sheet dated 17.7.2006 was drawn. The petitioner
served the demand notice dated 5.1.2009. The IDA vide letter
26.3.2010 informed the petitioner that survey of the firm has been done
and some more documents were demanded from the petitioner. Vide
letter No. 3697 dated 25.4.2011 the IDA informed the Association that
a resolution has been passed for allotment of plots to 8 members of the
Association @ Rs.17,757/- per Sq.mtr. and the consent from each
member was sought by way of deposit of Rs.1,50,000/- each within a
period of 15 days. Respondent No.3 vide letter dated 30.4.2011 sought
consent from the petitioner. The petitioner served legal notice dated
9.5.2011 to respondents No.1 and 2 objecting the rate of allotment i.e.
Rs.17,757/- per Sq.mtr. against the earlier sanctioned rate @ Rs.3,500/per Sq.mtr. and thereafter filed the present petition before this Court.
3.
Respondents No.1 and 2 filed their reply by submitting that a
draw was conducted amongst the members of the Association
mentioned in the list communicated by respondent No.3. It is further
submitted that out of 8 members mentioned in the impugned letter, six
- : 5 :W.P. Nos. 5465/2011 & 4161/2011
gave the consent and also deposited the amount of Rs.1,50,000/- each
with the Association. No direct communication was made between the
IDA and the petitioner and all the communications were made with
respondent No.3, therefore, the petitioner has no right to claim
allotment at the rate of their choice. The IDA cannot be put to revenue
loss by reducing the rate from Rs. 17,757/- to Rs.3,500/- per Sq.mtr.,
hence the petition is liable to be dismissed.
Respondent No.3 has not filed any reply.
4.
The petitioner filed an application (I.A. No.6333/2022)
complaining that due to the pendency of this petition, the respondents
No.1 and 2 are neither allotting the plot nor completing other
formalities. The petitioner should be permitted to deposit the entire
amount with the IDA under protest and the same shall be subject to the
final outcome of this petition as has already
been ordered in the
identical writ petition (W.P. No.4161/2011) in the case of Malwa Steel
Traders vide order dated 9.2.2015. The said application was opposed
by the respondents No.1 and 2 on the ground that Malwa Steel Traders
filed an application and shown the intention to pay the amount of the
plot in the year 2015 and the same was not objected and the order was
passed. But in the present petition, no order can be passed for allotment
at the same rate at par with Malwa Steel Traders. In this petition as well
as in the connected writ petition, by way of interim relief the IDA was
directed to maintain status quo till the next date of hearing.
After having heard the learned counsel for the parties, I have
perused the material available on record.
5.
In both the writ petitions, the petitioners have grievance about
the rate of allotment. According to them, they are also entitled for
allotment of the plots in New Loha Mandi (Scheme No.78) @
- : 6 :W.P. Nos. 5465/2011 & 4161/2011
Rs.3,500/- per Sq.mtr. as they are also the members of the Association
and their names were duly sent by the Association but they were denied
allotment along with other allottees. They were not at fault, therefore,
they cannot be put to loss by allotment of plots on higher rate.
6.
In both the petitions, the petitioners are challenging only the
communication made by the IDA to the Association i.e. respondent
No.3. By way of the impugned letter, the resolution passed by the IDA
was communicated to the Association about the allotment of the plot @
Rs.17,757/- per Sq.mtr. and the consent was sought by way of deposit
of Rs.1,50,000/- each. Out of 8 only these two petitioners filed the writ
petitions before this Court challenging the rate of allotment and the
remaining 6 members have already deposited the said amount and at
the same rate and they have been allotted the plots. The petitioners
have not challenged the validity of resolution No. 44 dated 21.3.2011
passed by the IDA. There was no direct communication between the
petitioners and the IDA. The IDA was allotting the plots through the
Association. The entire communications were made between the IDA
and the office bears of the Association. The IDA took a decision on
21.3.2011 for allotment of plots to 8 members of the Association
including the present petitioners @ Rs.17,757/-. If the petitioners are
not willing, there is no compulsion on the part of the IDA for allotment
of the plots as the petitioners cannot claim allotment as a matter of
legal and statutory right for allotment of plots if they are not agreed
with the rate decided by the IDA vide resolution No. 44 dated
21.3.2011. If any mistake has occurred in the list sent by the
Association, the IDA cannot be held responsible. For this, the
petitioners are free to claim damages from respondent No.3,
Association. Therefore, no case for interference is made out in respect
- : 7 :W.P. Nos. 5465/2011 & 4161/2011
of ascertaining the rate of allotment.
7.
Accordingly, these petitions are dismissed. If the petitioners have
deposited the amount, allotment fees, premium and they have been
given possession over the plots by completing the formalities, same be
made absolute. If the petitioners have not deposited the said amount
and the fee, etc., then their allotment be treated as cancelled. Let a
photocopy of this order be retained in the file of connected writ
petition.
( VIVEK RUSIA )
JUDGE
Alok/-
Date: 2024.01.04 11:37:32 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review