Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 1st OF FEBRUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 211 of 2024
BETWEEN:PRO SHEEL CHANDRA KAILASHI S/O LATE BABULAL JAIN, AGED
ABOUT 83 YEARS, VISHNUPURA FREEGANJ (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI MURTUZA BOHRA, ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPTT.
1. GOVT. OF MADHYA PRADESH VALLABH BHAVAN BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
COMMISSIONER HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT 5TH FLOOR
2. DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION SATPURA BHAWAN BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
VIKRAM UNIVERSITY THROUGH REGISTRAR UNIVERSITY ROAD
MADHAV BHAWAN UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(STATE BY SHRI SUDHANSHU VYAS, PANEL LAWYER)
(RESPONDENT NO.3 BY SHRI NITIN SINGH BHATI, ADVOCATE)
This petition coming on for hearing this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
The petitioner has filed the present petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India seeking following reliefs:(a) To allow the present petition with costs.
(b) To issue appropriate writ / order / direction to the
respondents to grant revised pension with entire arrears in
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-2-
accordance of the notification dated 11.06.2018 and to revise
the pension of the petitioner from time to time at par with the
state government employee in furture also.
(c) To issue appropriate writ / order / direction to the
respondent to pay the interest @ 12% on arrears of delayed
payment of pension and pensionary benefits as per Finance
Department
Circular
F.B.6/19/83/Rule-2/Four
dated
25.04.1984 upheld decision passed by Division Bench in State
of M.P. v/s Ramji Das Agrawal reported in 2013 (1) M.P.L.J.
53.
(d) Any other relief that this Hon'ble Court deems fit.
02.
The grievance of the petitioner is that he is not being given the
revised pension as per the 7th Central Pay Commission Revision and
arrears of pension and pensionary benefits including Gratuity and Leave
Encashment, as per notification dated 11.06.2018 at par with the State
Government employees.
03.
Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the case of the
petitioner is squarely covered by the decision dated 03.02.2015 rendered
by the Single Bench of this Court in the case of Dr. Surendra Kumar
Gupta S/o Late Shri Dhirendra Narayan Gupta v/s The State of
Madhya Pradesh and another (Writ Petition No.12169/2013) wherein
the Court has allowed the petition, directing the State of Madhya
Pradesh to extend all the pensionary benefits to the petitioner in view of
notification dated 03.08.2009.
04.
Counsel for the respondent / State, on the other hand, has not
opposed the prayer. . However, it is not denied that the decision
rendered by this Court in Writ Petition No.12169/2013 was challenged
by the State before a Division Bench of this Court in Writ Appeal
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-3-
No.372/2015, which was dismissed on 29.01.2016, affirming the’ order
passed by the Writ Court; and thereafter, Petition for Special Leave to
Appeal (C) No (s).10143/2016 (Arising out of impugned final judgment
and order dated 29.01.2016 in WA No.372/2015 passed by the High
Court of MP at Indore) preferred by the ‘State of Madhya Pradesh was
also dismissed on 22.04.2016.
05.
In view of the same, considering the relief sought by the
petitioner and the order passed by this Court in the case of Dr. Surendra
Kumar Gupta S/o Late Shri Dhirendra Narayan Gupta (supra), which
reads as under:“The petitioner before this court a retired Professor, who
has attained the age of superannuation after serving the Vikram
University, Ujjain, aged about seventy three years has
approached this court on account of non-grant of pensionary
benefits, which have been extended to the State Government
employees, vide notification dated 03-08-2009.
03. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner is
that the petitioner has attained the age of superannuation on 3107-2002. It has been further stated that earlier the employees of
the University were entitled for contributory provident fund.
However, as a need wasfelt by the State Government to grant
pension to the ~ employees, the Vikram University, Ujjain, in
exercise of powers.conferred under the Madhya Pradesh
Vishwavidhyalaya Adhiniyam, 1973, enacted statute No.37, for
grant of pension and gratuity to the employees. of the Vikram
University, Ujjain.
04. Learned counsel for the petitioner has also argued that by
virtue of statute No. 37, a consolidated pension fund has been
created which is under the control of the State Government and
the State Government is regularly paying pension ‘to the
petitioner and other retiral benefits to other mployees of the
Vikram Univeristy, Ujjain. He has further stated that by virtue of
Statute No.37, the provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 and the Madhya Pradesh Civil
Pension (Commutation) Rules, 1976 as amended from time to
time as applicable to the State Government employees are
applicable to the petitioner, who is a retired employee of the
University. He has also drawn the attention of this court towards
the judgment delivered by the High Court of Chhattisgarh,
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-4-
Bilaspur in Writ Petition (s) No. 196/2011 (Santosh Kumar
Upadhyay and others Vs. State of Chhattisgarh and others) and
his contention is that in similar circumstances the Chhattisgarh
High Court has extended the benefit of revised pension on
account of 6" Pay Commission to the employees of Ravishankar
University. Learned counsel for the petitioner has prayed for
issuance of an appropriate writ, order or direction directing the
State of Madhya Pradesh to grant pension, arrears of pension
and other benefits, in terms of the notification dated 03-082009.
05. On the other hand, learned counscl appearing for the
Vikram University has not disputed the StatuteNo.37. However,
has argued before this court that so far the payment of pension is
concerned, it is the State Government, which is required to pay
pension1to the retired employees of the University and it is not
the University, which is required to pay pension to the
employees, keeping - in view the Statute No. 37, framed under
the provisicns of the Madhya Pradesh Vishwavidhyalaya
Adhiniyam, 1973.
06. Reply has been filed by the State Government and the stand
of the State Government is that pension of the employees of the
Vikram University iIs being paid from the self finance fund with
the aid of the State Government and in case of Government
servants, pension is being paid by the State Government, alone.
It has been stated that the petitioner cannot claim parity. with the
employees of the State Government. It is also been stated that
State Government has taken a decision to grant the benefit of
revised pension passed upon the recommendation of the 6 th Pay
Commission to the petitioner by the order dated 31-10-2014 and
he will be paid revised pension with effect from 01-04-2014 and
no arrears will be paid to him, keeping in view the order dated
31-10-2014.
07. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record. The matter is being heard finally, with the consent of all
the parties at motion hearing stage itself.
08. In the present case, it is an admitted fact that the petitioner
is a retired Professor and has attained the age of superannuation
after serving the Vikram University, Ujjain on 31-07-2002. The
Statute No.37 has been enacted in exercise of powers conferred
under the provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Vishwavidhyalaya
Adhiniyam, 1973 and the relevant paragraph of Statute No.37
reads as under:"9.
Creation and Constitution of University Employees
Pension and Gratuity Fund:- In order to meet the expenditure
on pension and gratuity disbursement to the employees of
the University as prescribed in the MP. Civil Service
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-5-
(Pension) Rules, 1976 and in order to meet other incidental
expenses on the operation of the Scheme, a
University..Employees Pension and Gratuity Fund
(UNIPENGRAF) shall be created and. it shall be centrally
controlled and administered by the Madhya Pradesh Uchcha
Shiksha Anudan Ayog, Bhopal. It shall comprise and be
constituted out of the following amounts :a) Monthly contributory provident fund:subscription
made by the University to the account of each employee
as University share as per Statute No.26 of the
University in respect of persons who elect to join the
pension and Gratuity Schemeunderthis Statute. b) The
accumulated balance of the subscription to the
contributory provident fund of each employee made by
the University as University share together with interest
thereon (upto the date of transfer of the amount by
University) will be credited to the University Employees
Pension and Gratuity Fund (UNIPENGRAF) maintained
at the level of the MP. Ucchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog.
The University share of the employee who have opted to
retain the Contributory Provident Fund Scheme, will not
be transferred tu the University Employees Pension and
Gratuity Fund (UNIPENGRAF) but shall be continued
to be maintained separately as per provisions of the
existing Contributory Provident Fund Scheme under
Statute No.26.
In order to implement the pension Scheme, the
Registrar of the University will ensure that at least 90%
of the accumulated balance of University share is
credited to University Employees Pension and Gratuity
Fund (UNIPENGRAF) within one month from the date
of promulgation of the statute. Only such employees in
respect of whom 90% of the University share is credited
to the pension fund within prescribed time shall be
covered under the scheme. Where a University has
granted horse building advance to any employee to the
extent of 75% of the total amount of CPF as provided in
the relevant Statute, the condition regarding deposit of
90% of University share due.to an employee could be
relaxed by the M.P. Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog on
merits of each case. Fort his purpose the M.P.U.S.AA.
would be competent to issue necessary directions and
such directions will be binding on the University, Where
M.P.U.S.A.A. has granted relaxation in respect of an
employee, such employee would be covered by this
scheme. The remaining amount of 10% of the university
share with interest shall be deposited by the Registrar in
the University Employees pension and gratuity Fund
(UNIPENGRAF)within a maximum period of six
months from the date of promulgation of the Statute in
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-6respect of the employees who opt to join this scheme.
c) Grant-in-aid sanctioned by the Government from
time to time to cover the deficient, of funds. in running
the Pension and Gratuity Scheme. Procedure for pension
and gratuity payment to the University Employees :a)
When calculating the pension, family
pension, gratuity and " commutation amount payable
to the employee on retirement, the procedure, the
proformas and the Rules as laid down in the MP. Cvil Service (Pension) Rules, 1976 and the MP. Civil
Pension (Commutation) Rules, 1976 as amended
from time to time by ~ : the Government shall be
applicable muutatis-mutandis.”
09. The aforesaid provision of law makes it very clear that
while calculating pension, family pension, gratuity and
commutation in respect of retired employees of Vikram
‘University, Ujjain, the provisions ‘of the Madhya Pradesh Civil
Services (Pension)Rules, 1976 and the Madhya Pradesh Civil
Pension (Commutation) Rules, 1976 as amended from time to
time by the Government shall be applicable mutatis mutandis.
Not only this, the Chhattisgarh High Court while dealing with
the similar controversy in paragraphs 8 to 17 held as under in
Writ Petition (s) No. 196/2011 (Santosh Kumar Upadhyay and
others v. State of Chhattisgarh and others):"8.
Clause 9 of Statute No.32 provides for contribution
for creation of employees pension and gratuity fund. It is .
further provided that each employee will make a
contribution to the fund and the University will also
contribute the same amount to the said fund: The said fund
Shall be centrally controlled and administered by the '
Madhya Pradesh Uchha Shiksha Anudan Ayog / Department
of Higher Education. It is further provided that the grant-inaid sanctioned by the Government from time to time ‘will be
made to cover the deficiency of funds in running” the
Pension and Gratuity Scheme.
9. Clause-13 of Statute No.32 Provides for procedure
regulating the Payment of Pension and Gratuity to the
Employees and clause 14 provides for procedure for Pension
and Gratuity Payment to the University Employees.
10.
It is well settled principle of law that pension is not
a bounty payable on the sweet will and pleasure of the
Government. and that, on the other hand, the right of pension
is a valuable right vesting in a Government servant (see
Deokinandan v. State and others SCC pg. 344 para-31).
11.
The Supreme Court recently in Repsu Transport
Corporation Patiala v. Mangilal Singh & Others observed as
under:"34. Pension is a retirement benefit partaking of the
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-7character of regular payment to a person in consideration
of the past Services rendered by him. We hasten to add ~
that although pension is not a bounty but is claimable as
a matter of right, yet the fight is not absolute or
unconditional. The person’ claiming pension must ~
establish his entitlement to such pension in law. The
entitlement might be dependent. upen various
considerations or conditions. In a given case, the retired
employee is entitled to pension or not depend on the
provisions and interpretation of Rules and
Regulations..."
It is further held that :"29. It is well settled law that the Regulations made .
“under the statute laying down the terms and
conditions of service of employees, including. the
grant of retirement - benefits, has the force of law..
The Regulations validly made under statutory powers
are binding and effective as - the enactment of the
competent legislature. The statutory - bodies as well as
general public are bound to comply with the terms and
conditions laid down in the Regulations as a legal
compulsion. Any action or order in breach of the terms
and. Conditions of the Regulations shall amount to
violation of Regulations which are in the nature of
statutory provisions and shall render such action or
order illegal and invalid. "
12.
The fund so created will be controlled and
administered by the Madhya Pradesh Uccha Shiksha Anudan
Ayog/Department of Higher Education. Now,it will be done
by the Higher Education Department of the Government, as
the Shiksha Anudan Ayog was abolished, . In 1994.
13. Subsequently, under the provisions of the Madhya
Pradesh Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog (Nirsan) Adhiniyam,
1994 (for short "the Adhiniyam, 1994"), the - Madhya
Pradesh Uchcha Shiksha Anudan Ayog Adhiniyam, 1973
was repealed and as a result, under subsection (1) section 3
of the Adhiniyam, 1994, the Ayog stood dissolved.
14.
Sub-section (2) Section 3 provides that all assets
and liabilities of the Ayog on the appointed day shall stand
vested in the State Government and the State Government
shall have all powers necessary to take possession, recover
and deal with such assets and to discharge such liabilities.
15.
Sub-section (3) Section 3 of the Adhiniyam, 1994
provides that any proceeding pending immediately before
the appointed day to which the Ayog was party shall be
continued as if the State Government was party thereof in
lieu of the Ayog.
16.
In view of the above, all the responsibilities and
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-8-
functions of the Ayog continued to be performed by the State
Government. The petitioners being the cmployccs of the
University arc entitled to all the benefits, as afore-stated, at
par’ with the Government employees.: oA Accordingly, the
respondents are: directed to grant retiral benefits to the
petitioners, as-rcvised from time to time for the State
Government employees*in. accordance with the ‘provisions
of Statue ‘No.32 and’ as per the Circular dated 6th
December, 1989 issued by the then, State of Madhya
Pradesh and the memo dated 22nd March, 2001 of the State
of Chhattisgarh.
17.
As an upshot, the writ petition is allowed to the
extent indicated above, leaving the parties to bear their own
costs.”
10. This court keeping in view the aforesaid ‘statutory
provision of law ‘and the judgment delivered in an identical
case is of the considered Opinion that the petitioner, who is a
retired employee of Vikram University cannot be discriminated
in the matter of grant of pension as _the provisions of Madhya
Pradesh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 are applicable
mutatismutandis in case of the petitioner also, by virtue of
Statute No.37.
11. It has also been brought to the notice of this court that the
Professors working under the State of Madhya Pradesh and in
Vikram University, Ujjain are receiving the same pay scale and,
therefore, the action of the respondents is amounting to
disparity, within the same rank. In light of the aforesaid, it can
be safely gathered that the action of the respondents which
brings disparity between the same rank specially when same
rules are applicable to all persons in the matter of grant of
pension, the petitioner is being discriminated vis-a-vis his
counter parts who have attained the age of superannuation from
the services of the State of Madhya Pradesh.
12. The apex court while deciding the land mark case in the
matter of grant of pension in case of D.S. Nakara and others v.
Union of India reported in (1983) 1 SCC 305 in paragraphs 20,
27,29, 31 and 36 held as under:"20.
The antequated notion of pension being a bounty a
gratuitous payment depending upon the sweet will or grace
of the employer not claimable as a right and, therefore, no
right to pension can be enforced through Court has been
swept under the:Carpet by the decision ofthe Constitution
Bench in Deoki Nandan Prasad v. State of Bihar & Others
(1) wherein this Court authoritatively ruled that pension is a
right and the payment of it does not depend upon the
discretion of the Government but!is governed by the rules
and a Government servant coming within those rules is
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-9-
entitled to claim pension. It was further held that the grant of
pension does not depend upon any one's discretion. It is only
for the purpose of 182 quantifying the ‘amount having
regard to service and other allied matters that it may be
necessary for the authority to pass an order to that effect but
the right to receive pension flows to the officer not because
of any such order but by virtue of the rules. This view was
reaffirmed in Punjab another v. Iqbal Singh (1).
27.
Viewed in the light of the present day notions
pension is a term applied to periodic money payments to a
person who retires at a certain age considered age of
disability, payments usually continue for the rest of the
natural life of the recipient. The reasons underlying the grant
of pension vary from country to country and from scheme to
scheme. Butbroadly stated they are
(i) as compensation to former members of the armed
forces or their dependents for old age, disability, or
death (usually from service causes),
(ii) as old age retirement or disability benefits for
civilian employees, and
(iii) as social security payments for the aged,
disabled, or deceased citizens made in accordance
with the mules governing social service programmes
of the country. Pensions under the first head are of
great antiquity. Under the second head they have been
in force in one form or another in- some countries for
over a century but those coming under the third head
are relatively of recent origin, though they are of the
greatest 185 magnitude. There are other views about
pensions such as charity, paternalism, deferred pay,
rewards for service rendered, or as a means or
promoting gencral welfare (see Encyclopaedia
Britannica, Vol. 17 p.575.) But these views have
become otiose.
29.
Summing-up it can be said with confidence that
pension is not only compensation for loyal service rendered
in the past, but pension also has a broader significance, in
that it is a measure of socio-economic justice which inheres
economic security in the fall of lite when physical and
mental prowess is ebbing corresponding to aging process
and therefore, one is required to fall back on savings: One
such saving in kind is when you gave your best in the. heyday oflifeto your: employer, in days of invalidity, economic
Security by way: of periodical payment is assured. The term
has been judicially defined as a stated allowance or stipend
made in consideration of past service or a surrender of rights
or emoluments to one retired from service. Thus ihe pension
payable: to a Government employee is earned by rendering
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-10-
long and efficient service and therefore can be said to be a
deferred portion of the compensation nor for service
rendered.: In one sentence one can say that the most
practical reason d'etre for pension is the inability to provide
for oneself due to old age. One may live and avoid
unemployment but not senility and penury if there is nothing
to fall back upon.
31.
From the discussion three things emerge:
(i) that pension is neither a bounty nor a matter of
grace depending upon the sweet will of the employer
and that it creates a vested right subject to 1972 mules
which are statutory in character because they are
enacted in exercise of-powers conferred by the proviso
to Art. 309 and clause (5) of Art. 148 of the
Constitution;
(ii) that the pension is not an ex-gratia payment but it
is a payment for the past service rendered; and :
(iii) it is a social welfare measure rendering socioeconomic justice to those who in the heyday of their
lite ceaselessly toiled for the employer on an assurance
that in their old age they would not be left in lurch. It
must also be noticed that the quantum of pension is a
certain percentage correlated to the average
emoluments drawn during last three years of service
reduced to ten months under liberalised pension
scheme. Its payment is dependent upon an additional .
condition of impeccable behaviour even subsequent to
requirement, that is, since the cessation of the contract
of service and that it can be reduced or withdrawn as a
disciplinary measure.
36.
Having set out clearly the society which we propose
to set up, the direction in which the State action must move,
the welfare State which we propose to build up, the
constitutional goal of setting up a socialist State and the.
assurance in the Directive Principles of State Policy
especially of security in old age at least to those who have
rendered useful service during their active years, it is
indisputable, nor was it questioned, that pension as a
retirement benefit is in consonance with and furtherance of
the goals of the Constitution. The goals for which pension is
paid themselves give fillip and push to the policy of setting
up a welfare State because by pension the socialist goal of
security of cradle to grave is assured at least when it is
mostly needed and least available, namely, in the fall of life."
In light of the aforesaid, it is evident that the payment of
pension. is payment for the past services rendered. “Its'a social
welfare measure ‘rendering socio-economic justice to those who
in ‘the hey-day of their life ceaselessly toiled for the ‘employer
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
-11-
on an assurance that in their old age they would not be left in
lurch and, therefore, in the opinion of this court the petitioner is
certainly ‘entitled for the. Same benefit which has been
-extended to the retired persons of the State of Madhya Pradesh,
specially when the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 1976 are applicable mutatis-mutandis in case of the
petitioner also.
11. Resultantly, the writ petition is allowed. - The State of
Madhya Pradesh is directed to extend all pensionary benefits to
the petitioner, in view of the notification dated 03-08-2009. The
exercise of granting pension, arrears of pension and other
benefits by issuing a revised pension payment order be
completed, within a period of ninety days, from the date of
receipt of certified copy of this order.
No order as to costs.”
06.
In view of the above, the respondents are directed to act, in
accordance with the direction contained in Dr. Surendra Kumar Gupta
(supra). The State of Madhya Pradesh is directed to extend all
pensionary benefits to the petitioner in view of the notification dated
11.06.2018. The exercise of grant of pension, arrears of pension and
other benefits by issuing a revised Pension Payment Order (PPO) be
completed within a period of ninety days from the date of receipt of
certified copy of this order.
07.
With the aforesaid, Writ Petition stands allowed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Ravi
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 2/1/2024
6:28:07 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review