The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. Having considered the submissions made by the counsel for the parties, the present petition stands disposed of on the same terms by holding that the direction issued in the case of Yogendra Singh Bhadauria & Ors. (supra), except the cost, will apply mutatis mutandis in the present case also. C.c. as per rules.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 24th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 1758 of 2024
BETWEEN:PRASHANT DUBEY S/O SHRI G.S. DUBEY, AGED
ABOUT 68 YEARS, OCCUPATION: RETIRED DY.
DIRECTOR AGRICULTURE SHRI J.P. MISHRA'S
HOUSE 548, KALANI NAGAR, AIRPORT ROAD
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI SHISHIR- ADVOCATE )
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY
VALLABH
BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT
GOVT.
OF
PRADESH
VALLABH
MANTRALAYA,
BHOPAL
PRADESH)
3.
COMMISSIONER FARMER WELFARE AND
AGRICULTURE DEPARTMENT 2ND FLOOR
C WING, VINDHYACHAL BHAVAN, ARERA
HILLS BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
MANAGING
DIRECTOR
M.P.
STATE
ORGANIC
CERTIFICATION
AGENCY
VASUNDHARA, B-II OFFICE COMPLEX,
GAUTAM NAGAR BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
5.
DIVISIONAL PENSION OFFICER BHOPAL
DIVISION, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
FINANCE
MADHYA
BHAWAN,
(MADHYA
.....RESPONDENTS
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
3:26:24 PM
(BY MS. ASHI VAIDYA- PANEL LAWYER)
This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed
the following:
ORDER
This petition has been filed by the petitioner under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India seeking the following reliefs:"A) It is therefore prayed that petition may kindly be
allowed and petitioner may kindly be granted the
annual increment which fell due on 01.07.2017 for the
services rendered by him w.e.f.01.07.2016 to
30.06.2017.
B) Petition may kindly be allowed by issuing
appropriate writ, order or direction by commanding
the respondents to revise the pension by adding
increment and pay the arrears due him with the
interest @ 10% per annum.
C) Any other relief which this Hon’ble Court deems fit
may kindly be granted.”
2. Counsel for the petitioner submits that the case of the petitioner is
squarely covered by the order passed by the Division Bench of this Court
at Gwalior in the case of Yogendra Singh Bhadauria and Ors. Vs. State
of Madhya Pradesh and Ors. W.A. No.645 of 2020 dated 22.09.2020,
which reads as under:"The instant writ appeal has been filed under Section 2(A) of M.P. Uchcha
Nyayalay (Khand Peeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 assailing the final
order dated 06.03.2020 passed in WP 25702/2019 by learned Single Judge
while exercising writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution,
disposing of the petition in question whereby the following reliefs have
been made :
“(i) Provide benefit of annual increment to
petitioners;
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
3:26:24 PM
(ii) Re-fix the pension and pay the differential
amount of pension and other arrears such as
Gratuity and Leave Encashment with interest.
(iii) Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court
deems fit in the facts and circumstances of the
case may also kindly be granted.”
Learned writ court directed the official respondents to consider the claim of
petitioners/appellants for grant of one increment which shall due on 1st of
July which was a day after the date of superannuation of each of the
petitioners, after taking into account the order passed by the Madras High
Court in the case of P. Ayyamperumal Vs. The Registrar, Central
Administrative Tribunal & ors. (writ petition No.15732 of 2017) which
was affirmed by the Supreme Court in SLP (Civil) Diary No.22283/2018
and as per the entitlement under the service Rules. A further direction was
given that in case petitioners are entitled for payment of one annual
increment, then the same be released or else reasons for denial be
communicate by a speaking order. While so disposing of the petition in
question, the writ court though recognized the cause raised by the
petitioner to be recurring in nature but declined grant of consequential
benefits of arrears of pension and interest on the ground of the petitioners
having approached to the court with delay and latches.
The instant appeal is filed for seeking arrears of pension and
interest.
After hearing learned counsel for the rival parties, this Court is of
the considered view that petitioners/appellants are entitled to the arrears of
pension and so also to interest for the reasons infra.
(i) It is not disputed at the bar that the cause of non grant of
increment due on 1st of July in different years in case of the petitioners had
direct effect of proportionately reducing the pension which was being paid
to the petitioner on the monthly basis since their retirement. Thus the cause
raised was of a recurring nature.
(ii) The issue of entitlement of an employee retiring on 30th June to
an increment which was due w.e.f. 1st July, came to be adjudicated by the
Division Bench of Madras High Court for the first time on 15.09.2017 in
the case of P. Ayyamperumal Vs The Registrar & Ors (WP 15732 of 2017)
vide P/4 interpreting the Central Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008
held that the entitlement of one annual increment to an employee is
dependent upon the employee completing one year of service. It was thus
held that an employee superannuating w.e.f. 30th June had completed one
year of service on 30th June and therefore, became entitle to the increment.
The Division Bench held that whether the increment become due from 1st
of July or from any subsequent date is irrelevant once the employee has
completed one year of service. Thus it was held by the Division Bench that
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
3:26:24 PM
just because Rule stipulate that increment would be due from 1st of July, it
does not mean that an employee who had superannuated on 30th June
would not be entitled to the said increment merely because he was not in
service on 1st July. The Division Bench of Madras High Court therefore,
quashed the order of Central Administrative Tribunal Madras Bench and
granted relief to the employee therein to the following effect:
“7. The petitioner herein had completed one full year service as on
30.06.2013, but the increment fell due on 01.07.2013, on which date he
was not in service. In view of the above judgment of this Court, naturally
he has to be treated as having completed one full year of service, though
the date of increment falls on the next day of his retirement. Applying the
said judgment to the present case, the writ petition is allowed and the
impugned order passed by the first respondent-Tribunal dated 21.03.2017
is quashed. The petitioner shall be given one notional increment for the
period from 01.07.2012 to 30.06.2013, as he has completed one full year of
service, though his increment fell on 01.07.2013, for the purpose of
pensionary benefits and not for any other purpose. No costs”
Learned counsel for the State has raised objection as to grant of
arrears of pension and interest by submitting that six petitioners/ appellants
herein had superannuated on 30th June but in different years ranging from
2010, 2012, 2013, 2014 and 2015. It is submitted that the cause of non
grant of increment due from 1st of July i.e. a day after their retirement
became known to them on the receipt of depressed pension immediately
after their retirement.Thus the objection is that the petitioners who have
approached this court late by filing the petition in the year 2019 without
explaining delayed approach are not entitled to the arrears of pension and
interest.
The question of delay causing an adverse effect to the claim of
consequential benefit of arrears would arise only if the cause raised is a one
time cause of action. Undoubtedly the cause of receipt of depressed
pension on account of non grant of increment is a recurring cause of action
which arose to the petitioner every month they received proportionately
depressed pension. Thus in the considered opinion of this court all the
petitioners/appellants are entitled to arrears of pension.
A further argument/objection which was raised by the State was
that the quantum of arrears at best cannot be more than 3 years prior to the
date of filing of petition, which is the period under the Limitation Act
prescribed for raising money claim, in a civil court.
This argument of the State is heard to be rejected since denial of
even a fraction of arrears of pension would amount to denial of right to
livelihood which is a part and parcel of the right to life a fundamental right
in the Constitution. Undeniably there is no limitation fixed for invoking
power of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution but the
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
3:26:24 PM
petitioner concerned has to satisfy the Court if the approach to the court is
delayed. Once it is held (supra) that the cause of action raised by the
petitioner is a recurring cause of action then the question of restricting the
arrears of pension does not arise.
Another objection raised by the learned counsel for the State and
it's functionaries is that assuming without admitting that petitioners are
entitled to arrears of pension but the same cannot be granted for a period
prior to the Supreme Court dismissed the SLP filed against the order of
Division Bench of Madras High Court passed in P. Ayyamperumal
(supra).The argument/objection raised appears to be ostensibly plausible
and attractive but in actuality is not. Since this Court has already held that
the Madras High Court for the first time and later different High Courts
including this Court merely explained correct meaning and purpose of the
Rule and did not interpret Rule in the manner for the first time which was
never understood earlier. The Rule as stood since it's inception was clearly
understood to meant that increment becomes due on completion of one
year of service. since there was no further requirement of the entitlement to
reach the beneficiaries only when the beneficiary is in service on the due
date of increment, it was incumbent upon the employer to understand the
plain meaning of the Rule. Instead the employer interpreted the Rule on it's
own interest which led to financial benefit to the employer and
corresponding pecuniary loss to the employee. In this manner, the benefits
of arrears of pension which fell due even prior to the dismissal of SLP filed
against the order of Division Bench of Madras High Court cannot be
denied to the petitioners.
Thereafter comes to the question of entitlement of interest over the
arrears of pension. The interest over a particular monetary claim is
ordinary granted where it was found that the claim due under the law was
wrongfully denied. Thus just to compensate the petitioner for the financial
loss owing to the devaluation of the currency and the delayed grant of
justice from the period of arising of the cause till the grant of relief, courts
do grant interest.
In the instant case, the Central Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules,
2008 provides that an increment would become due to an employee on
completion of one year of service. However, for administrative and
accountancy purposes the employer fixes a particular date for grant of
increment, which in the instant case was 1st of July. The Rules nowhere
stipulate that on the due date of increment i.e. 1st of July, the employee
concerned must be in service. Thus in the case of petitioner, the employer
without any supportive statutory provision was interpreting the Rule in a
manner which financially benefited the employer by denying one
increment due on the 1st of July to all those employees/officers who retired
on 30th June. This act on the part of employer was not only against the
spirit of Rules but also in defiance of it's claim of being a welfare State.
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
3:26:24 PM
Consequently, the picture that emerges from the act of employer in
the present case is that the increment due to the petitioner on 1st July was
withheld not only against the Rules but by twisting and misinterpreting the
Rule to suit the employer to the detriment of petitioner.
Moreso the Division Bench of Madras High Court on15.09.2017
and thereafter the Apex Court on 23.07.2018 while declining to admit the
SLP of Union of India, merely explained the rule position without causing
any normal interpretation or carving out a new meaning of rule which
could not be deciphered earlier by truthful and honest interpretation of the
Rule. Thus the decision of the Madras High Court and all the subsequent
decisions of this Court following the Madras High Court verdict gave
correct meaning of the rule position which was being misinterpreted by the
employer and therefore, the Rule regarding grant of increment on
completion of one year of service and not on deem in service on the due
date of increment could very easily be understood by any man of ordinary
purdance by truthful and honest reading of the Rule.
Accordingly, the judgment of Madras High Court and all
subsequent judgments in the same lines are retrospective in nature as they
did not work out any new interpretation of the rule which was not
understood earlier. The judgments merely explain the Rule as stood since
the beginning. From the above discussion, it is clear that non-grant of
increment to the petitioners was due to the misinterpretation of the rule
position by the employer and therefore, the employees i.e.
petitioners/appellants ought not to be suffered because of the same. Thus
the entitlement of the interest over the arrears of pension cannot be taken
away from the petitioners.
Accordingly, this Court allows this WA in the following terms:
(i) The official respondents are directed to release the increment
due to the appellants w.e.f. 01.07.2014, 01.07.2010, 01.07.2013,
01.07.2012, 01.07.2015 and 01.07.2015 respectively.
(ii)The pension be refixed after adding the grant of aforesaid
increment and the arrears of pension be paid to the petitioners.
(iii) The petitioners are entitled to interest over the aforesaid arrears
of pension @ 10% p.a. from the date the arrears became due till their
payment.
(iv) Despite the rule position having been explained by the Division
Bench of Madras High Court on 15.09.2017 against which Supreme Court
declined to entertain the SLP of the employer on 23.07.2018, the official
respondents ought to have offered the benefit of one increment to the
petitioners without compelling the petitioners to approach the court in the
evening of their life. Not having done so, the official respondents have
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
3:26:24 PM
failed to adhere to the policy of the Government of being a welfare State
and therefore, respondents are liable to pay cost of this litigation to the
petitioners which are quantified at Rs. 5000/- to each of the petitioners.
(v) The aforesaid direction be complied with within a period of 60
days from the date of receipt copy of this order."
3. Counsel for the State has not disputed the same.
4.
Having considered the submissions made by the counsel for the
parties, the present petition stands disposed of on the same terms by
holding that the direction issued in the case of Yogendra Singh
Bhadauria & Ors. (supra), except the cost, will apply mutatis mutandis
in the present case also.
C.c. as per rules.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
jyoti
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 25-Jan-24
3:26:24 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review