The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. 8.2016 cannot supersede the policy framed by the State Government. In Policy dated 29.9.2014, there is no such provision of payment of Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation in case the dependent does not have necessary qualification for Samvida Shala Shikshak, Grade-III post. Clause 9.8 of the said policy also provides that compensation of Rs.2,00,000/is liable to be given if the candidate does not fulfill the qualification for Class-IV post. Therefore, the action of the respondents is totally contrary to the policy framed by the State Government. Respondent No.2 is so adamant to deny appointment to the petitioner for the reason best known to him. This is nothing but harassment of a widow of a Govt. employee, who with her minor children is fighting with the Government since 2017. The husband of the petitioner was regular Teacher in School Education Department. The petitioner fulfills the qualification for appointment to the Class IV post and she is ready to work as Class-IV employee. Hence, this Court has no option to issue writ of mandamus to respondents to issue appointment order instead of directing to reconsider the matter again, as this would further delay the matter. In view of the foregoing discussion, this petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to appoint the petitioner on a Class-IV post in School Education Department within a period of two months from today. This p…
08. 08.2023 has been passed by the same Assistant Commissioner, Tribal Welfare Department, Nilesh Singh Raghuwanshi, who had passed the impugned order in W.P. No.12281/2021, which was also decided in his very presence by this Court and a cost of Rs.25,000/- 11:20:14 AM was also imposed on the respondents taking note of the fact that the petitioner is made to run from pillar to post since 2017, it is apparent that the said Assistant Commissioner Tribal Welfare Department, Shri Nilesh Singh Raghuwanshi has not learnt any lessons from his past mistakes by continuing to act according to his preconceived notions, and has again passed the same order in the same fashion, which only shows the defiant attitude of the concerned Officer and needs to be dealt with properly. In such circumstances, a cost of Rs.25,000/- is again imposed on the respondent No.2, to be paid in the account of -President and Secretary H.C. Employees Union H.C. (Account No.63006406008, Branch Code No. 30528, No. SBIN0030528, CIF No. 73003108919) within a period of 30 days. 9] Accordingly, the petition is allowed, and the impugned order dated 08.08.2023 is hereby quashed and the respondents are directed to appoint the petitioner on compassionate basis on any Class IV post within a period of one month from the date of receipt of this order. 10] With the aforesaid, the petition stands allowed and disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
A T IND OR E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR
ON THE 22nd OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 23462 of 2023
BETWEEN:PIYUSH BADOLE S/O LATE SHRI BABULAL BADOLE, AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
NOTHING WARD NO. 2, TRIVENI MANDIR KE
PICHE, BADWANI ROAD, RAJPUR, DISTRICT
BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI JITENDRA VERMA, ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF TRIBAL WELFARE
VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER TRIBAL
WELFARE DEPARTMENT OFFICE OF ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER BARWANI, DIST.
BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
THE DISTRICT EDUCATION OFFICER BARWANI, DIST. BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
THE BLOCK EDUCATION OFFICER RAJPUR,
TEH. RAJPUR, DIST. BARWANI (MADHYA
PRADESH)
5.
THE PRINCIPAL, GOVT. HIGHER SECONDARY SCHOOL LIMABI, BLOCK PATI, DIST.
BARWANI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 2/3/2024
11:20:14 AM
(BY MS. BHARTI LAKKAD, P.L./G.A.)
………………………………………………………………………………………
This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed
the following:
ORDER
Heard finally, as the respondents have failed to file any reply
despite last opportunity having given on 13.12.2013.
2]
This petition has been filed by the petitioner under Article 226
of the Constitution of India seeking the following reliefs:“The petitioner therefore, prays that this Hon’ble Court may be
pleased to:(a) Allow the present writ petition and quash the impugned order
dated 08-08-2023 bearing letter No. No.6498/आदिम/सामा.
स्थाd./
2023 (ANNEXURE P/1) issued by respondent no. 2 and issue
appropriate writ, direction or order, directing the respondent No. 2
& 3 to issue compassionate appointment in favour of petitioner on
the post of “PEON” (Class-IV employee) under any Government
Department or direct the respondent no. 2 and 3 to consider the case
of present petitioner for compassionate appointment on the post of
“PEON”(Class-IV employee).
(b) issue appropriate writ, direction or order, directing the
respondents to pay the other consequential benefits for which he is
entitled with effect from 2021 along with interest.
(c) issue any other appropriate writ, direction or order, which this
Hon’ble Court deems just and fair in the circumstances of the case.
(d) The petitioner may be awarded cost of this petition.”
3]
The petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated 08.08.2023,
passed by the respondent No.2 Assistant Commissioner, Tribal
Welfare Department, Barwani, whereby, the petitioner’s application
for compassionate appointment has been rejected while relying upon a
circular dated 11.08.2016 wherein, it is provided that if a deceased
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 2/3/2024
11:20:14 AM
teacher’s dependent is not eligible to be appointed as a Class-III
teacher, in that case, instead of compassionate appointment, matter
may be finalized by giving him a lumpsum amount of Rs.1 lakh.
4]
Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that in the reply filed
by the respondents also, they have relied upon the same circular
whereas, this Court in W.P. No.12281/2021 (Indu Jadhav Vs. The
State of M.P. and Others) dated 07.02.2023, has already dealt with the
aforesaid circular to hold that it is not applicable and even if the
dependent of the deceased government teacher is not found to be fit
for the post of Grade-III teacher, he can be accommodated in Class-IV
category employment. It is further submitted that the aforesaid order
has also been affirmed by the Division Bench in Writ Appeal
No.688/2023 vide order dated 16.08.2023. Thus, it is submitted that
the impugned order be set aside, and similar directions be passed in
the present case to appoint the petitioner on any Class-IV position.
5]
On the other hand, counsel for the respondent/State has
submitted that no case for interference is made out and State has relied
upon the earlier circular dated 11.08.2018 only while rejecting the
petitioner’s claim. No reply has been filed by the State.
6]
Heard. On due consideration of submissions and on perusal of
the record, it is apparent that the petitioner’s claim for compassionate
appointment has been rejected vide impugned order dated 08.08.2023
only on the ground that he does not qualify the eligibility criteria fixed
for the compassionate appointment on the post of Grade-III teacher,
this is despite the fact that this court has already dealt with the said
issue and in W.P. No.12281/2021 decided on 07.02.2023, wherein it is
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 2/3/2024
11:20:14 AM
held as under:“Despite several opportunities, return was not filed by the
respondents and finally, vide order dated 15.12.2022, last
opportunity was granted to file the return. Now, the
respondents have filed the return by submitting that in view
of circular dated 11.8.2016 if any member of 'Teacher' dies
and the dependent does not fulfills the qualification for
Samvida Shala Shikshak, Grade-III, then the case be closed
by paying Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation. Hence, the
respondents have reiterated that the claim of the petitioner is
not liable to be considered.
In order to justify the action of respondents,
specifically the respondent No.2, learned Govt. Advocate has
argued beyond the return that the petitioner's husband was
working on contract basis, therefore, she is not entitled for
compassionate appointment. However, in both the rejection
orders, no such reason has been assigned and nothing has
been pleaded in the return also. Learned Govt. Advocate
further submits that the petitioner is not entitled to be
considered for compassionate appointment under the policy
dated 29.9.2014. This Court is shocked and surprised that
State Government is relying on letter dated 11.8.2016 to deny
compassionate appointment on a Class-IV post to a widow of
the deceased Govt. employee who was merged in the cadre of
'Teacher'. The petitioner is fighting for her claim since 2017
and every time the Department, especially respondent No.2
has rejected her case for grant of compassionate appointment
on the post of Samvida Shala Shikshak, Grade-III, whereas
she has specifically submitted the representation that she is
ready to work on a Class-IV post for survival of her minor
children. In the similar facts and circumstances, this Court in
the case of Smt. Neelam Baghel (supra) has allowed the
petition. In the present case also, the writ petition was
disposed of with a direction to the respondents to re-consider
her claim. That does not mean that the respondents shall pass
same order as was passed earlier. After rejection of the earlier
representation and disposal of the earlier writ petition, the
petitioner has submitted her fresh representation for
compassionate appointment on a Class-IV post and for which
she is having the qualification. Clause 5.4 of Policy dated
29.9.2014 clearly provides that if there is non-eligibility for
Class-III post, then appointment can be given against the
vacant Class-IV post of direct recruitment. When the State
Government through General Administration Department has
made a policy for all the Government Departments, then the
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 2/3/2024
11:20:14 AM
same cannot be diluted by issuing internal circular/s by
School Education Department. The internal circular dated
11.8.2016 cannot supersede the policy framed by the State
Government. In Policy dated 29.9.2014, there is no such
provision of payment of Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation in
case the dependent does not have necessary qualification for
Samvida Shala Shikshak, Grade-III post. Clause 9.8 of the
said policy also provides that compensation of Rs.2,00,000/is liable to be given if the candidate does not fulfill the
qualification for Class-IV post. Therefore, the action of the
respondents is totally contrary to the policy framed by the
State Government. Respondent No.2 is so adamant to deny
appointment to the petitioner for the reason best known to
him. This is nothing but harassment of a widow of a Govt.
employee, who with her minor children is fighting with the
Government since 2017. The husband of the petitioner was
regular Teacher in School Education Department. The
petitioner fulfills the qualification for appointment to the
Class IV post and she is ready to work as Class-IV
employee. Hence, this Court has no option to issue writ of
mandamus to respondents to issue appointment order instead
of directing to reconsider the matter again, as this would
further delay the matter.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this petition is
allowed. The respondents are directed to appoint the
petitioner on a Class-IV post in School Education
Department within a period of two months from today. This
petition is allowed with costs of Rs.25,000/- (Twenty Five
Thousand) payable to the petitioner.”
7]
(Emphasis Supplied)
Thus, by applying the aforesaid decision in the present case also,
the impugned order is liable to be set aside as in the present case also
the sole basis for rejection of the petitioner’s claim is the circular
dated 11.8.2016.
8]
Further considering the fact that the impugned order dated
08.08.2023 has been passed by the same Assistant Commissioner,
Tribal Welfare Department, Nilesh Singh Raghuwanshi, who had
passed the impugned order in W.P. No.12281/2021, which was also
decided in his very presence by this Court and a cost of Rs.25,000/-
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 2/3/2024
11:20:14 AM
was also imposed on the respondents taking note of the fact that the
petitioner is made to run from pillar to post since 2017, it is apparent
that the said Assistant Commissioner Tribal Welfare Department, Shri
Nilesh Singh Raghuwanshi has not learnt any lessons from his past
mistakes by continuing to act according to his preconceived notions,
and has again passed the same order in the same fashion, which only
shows the defiant attitude of the concerned Officer and needs to be
dealt with properly. In such circumstances, a cost of Rs.25,000/- is
again imposed on the respondent No.2, to be paid in the account of
-President and Secretary H.C. Employees Union H.C. (Account
No.63006406008,
Branch
Code
No.
30528,
IFSC
No.
SBIN0030528, CIF No. 73003108919) within a period of 30 days.
9]
Accordingly, the petition is allowed, and the impugned order
dated 08.08.2023 is hereby quashed and the respondents are directed
to appoint the petitioner on compassionate basis on any Class IV post
within a period of one month from the date of receipt of this order.
10]
With the aforesaid, the petition stands allowed and disposed of.
(SUBODH ABHYANKAR)
JUDGE
Bahar
Signed by: BAHAR CHAWLA
Signing time: 2/3/2024
11:20:14 AM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review