Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 348e ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION No s.29654 0F 2 013 AND 41356 0F 2014
WRIT PETITION NO i 29654 OF 2013
Between:
?: Ve!\atg Kumar, S/o. late P. Satyanarayana, Aged about 47 years, R/o. H. No. .12_
1 1-1580, Boudhnagar, Warasiguda, Hydeiabad - 5OO OOt.
...PETITIONER
AND
The_State of A.P. Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Backward Classes Welfare
(U) Department. Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The Collector, Karimnagar District, Collectorate, Karimnagar, Karimnagar
Dist.,
lttlurtujg. Ali Ahmed, S/o [Mohd. Jameet Ahmed Occ working as AIr4Vt
!9n!.
Rl/o Kothapalli Village,
Jammikunta Mandal, Karimnagar District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of rhe constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or Direction(s) more particularly, one in the nature
of writ of Mandamus and call for the records relating to and connected with Go
Ms. No. 18 Backward classes welfare (c) Department, dated 04-09-2013 issued
by the fa Respondent and set aside the same and consequen y declare that the
third Respondenl is not a Doodikula caste candidate and further direct
appropriate steps to be taken against the third Respondent and the offiiials who
have furnished the illegal caste certificate to the third Respondent by holding the
same as erroneous, bad, illegal, arbitrary, without application of mind, unfair,
baseless and unconstitutional.
lA NO: 1 oF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the ( ircumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cr urt may be pleased
Expedite the hearing of W.P.No. 29654 of 2013 by fixing an r errly date.
lA NO: 1 OF 2020
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the c rcumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Coi r may be pleased to
Expedite the hearing of W.P.No.29654 of 20'|,3 by fixing an ,: rrly date.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI M. SURENDER RAO, SENIC'I I COUNSEL
REPRESENTING SRI M. SRINIVAIJ q RAO
Counsel for the Respondents No.1 & 2: GP FOR SOCIAL lA'l I-FARE
Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI G. VIDYA SAGAR, Sl NIOR COUNSEL
REPRESENTING SMT. K. UT AYA SRI
WRIT PETITION NO:41356 OF 2014
Between:
Mohd. Murtuja Ali Ahmed, s/o Mohd. Jameel Ahmed, Aged 38 ears, Occ: Assistant
lvlotor Vehicle lnspector, Rl/o Kothapalli village, Jamrnikunta v4andal, Karimnagar
District.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Transport, Roads and Br ldings Department,
Secretarlat Buildings, Hyderabad, Rep. by its Principal Se ;retary.
2. The Transport Commissioner, State of Telangana, Khair i b,ad, Hyderabad.
3. The Telangana State Public Service Commission, Iv1. J Road, Hyderabad,
Rep. by its Secretary
4- The Collector, Karimnagar District, Karimnagar.
5. P.Venkata Kumar, s/o late P.Satyanaruyana, Advoczl., Rl/o H.No.12-111580, Boudhnagar, Warasiguda, Hyderabad-61
6. The Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal, Purani Ha z rli, Hyderabad, Rep.
by its Registrar.
(Formal Party)
(Cause Title amended as per Court Order dated 31.12.20 ,1.)
...RESPONDENTS
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus:
to declare the order passed by the Hon'ble Andhra Pradesh
Administrative Tribunal, Hyderabad, daled 6.12.2014 in OA No.2147 of
2012 as illegal, arbitrary, unjust apart from violative of principles of
natural justice and against the settled law and
to consequently set aside the same by directing the respondents 1 to 3
ii.
to continue the petitioner In service as Assistant Motor Vehicle lnspector
in Zone-V pursuant to his selection as Assistant Motor Vehicle lnspector.
l.A. NO: 2OF 2014(WPMP. NO: 51785 OF 2014)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the order passed by the Hon'ble Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal,
Hyderabad, dated 6.12.2014 in OA No.2147 of 2012.
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2015( WPMP. NO:.25272 OF 2015)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
extend the interim direction granted on 31 .12.2O14 and which has been extended
from time to time, In the above writ petition.
tA NO: 1 OF 2022
Between:
1. The State of Telangana, Transport, Roads and Buildings Department,
Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad, Rep. by its Principal Secretary.
2. The Transport Commissioner, State of Telangana, Khairtabad, Hyderabad.
...PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS
AND
1.
tvlohd. Murtuja Ali Ahmed, s/o [/ohd. Jameel Ahmed, Aged 38 years, Occ:
Assistant Motor Vehicle lnspector, Rl/o Kothapalli village, Jamrnikunta lVlandal,
Karimnagar District.
...RESPOI DENT/PETITIONER
2. The Telangana State Public Service Commission, I\4." Road, Hyderabad,
Rep. by its Secretary
3. The Collector, Karimnagar District, Karimnagar
4. P.Venkata Kumar, s/o late P.Satyana rayana, Advocit:, R/o H.No.12-1'11580, Boudhnagar, Warasiguda, Hyderabad-6'1
5. The Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal, Purani Hav -. i, Hyderabad, Rep.
by its Registrar. (Proposed Party)
(Cause Title amended as per Court Order dated 31 .12.2) I +.)
(Respondents No.2 to 5 are not necessary parties to this retition)
...RESPONDEI{ TS/RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the cir; rrstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Courl lay be pleased to
vacate the lnterim Orders (Suspension) dated 31 .12.2O14 pas,r ed in WP.No.41356
of 2014.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI G. VIDYA SAGAR, SENIOR (: IUNSEL
REPRESENTING SMT. K. UDAYA -T RI
Counsel for the Respondents No.1, 2 & 4: GP FOR SERVICI: ; - lll
Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI GUTHA MALLIKARJL NA RAO,
STANDING COUNSEICounsel forthe Respondent No.5: SRI M. SURENDER RAO. ;ENIOR COUNSEL
REPRESENTING SRI M. SRIl IVASA RAO
The Court made the following: COMMON OROER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WP.Nos.29654 o f 2Ol3 an d 41356 ol2OL4
Dt.O4o 2.2026
WP.No. 29 654 of 2Ol3
Between:
P.Venkata Kumar
.... Petitioner
and
The State of AP (presently State of Telangana)
and two others.
..Respondents
WP.No .4135 6 of 2OL4
Betuteen'.
Mohd. Murtuja Ali Ahmed
Petitioner
and
The State of Telalgana and five others
...
Respondents
COMM ON ORDER: (Per the Hon'ble Sri Justice Suddalo' Chalapathi
Rao)
Since both the writ petitions arise out of the same cause
of action between the same parties, and as the issues involved
in both the writ petitions are interconnected and related to
each other, both the matters aJe taken up together and are
being disposed of by this common order.
convenience and to avoid repetition, the
F
tr the sake of
partl(.r are referred to
as arrayed in W.p. No.29654 of 2012, which
rs treated as the
lead writ petition.
WP.No.29654 of 2073
2. This Writ petit.ion is filed to issue a \ I rt_ or
order or
direction more particularly one in the
nat _ -3 of w rit of
maldamus by calling for records relating
to z rLd connected
with G.O.Ms.No.1g, Backward Classes \Melfare
Department, dt.O4.O9.2OI3 issued by the
(C)
l"r r,:;pondent and
set aside the same and consequently to
decl:u.r that the 3.a
respondent does not belong to Dudekula
comnt I rity and also
r,r,ith a further direction to the respondents
to tal<: appropriate
steps against the 3.d respondent and the
offici1 s,, u.ho have
issued the caste certificate to the 3.a respondent.
WP.No.41356 o f 2074
3.
This Writ petition is filed by the 3.d
Wp.No.29654 of 2OI3 challenging the
ln
order pzr sed bv the
Andhra pradesh Administrative Tribunal,
.the ApATJ in OA.No.214Z
r_i r pondenr
Hyderair rd(for short
of 2012 dt.O6.t2.2}t, as illegal,
-rv
)
arbitrary, unjust and violative of principles of natura-l justice
arld consequently set aside the same by directing respondents
No. 1 and 2 to continue the petitioner in service as Assistant
Motor Vehicle Inspector (AMVI) in Zone V pursuant to his
selection as such.
The brief facts of the case :
4.
The Andhra Pradesh Public Service Commission(APPsc)
by Notification No.45/2008, dt.30. 12.2OO8 invited applications
for appointment to the post of Assistant Motor Vehicle
Inspector. Both the petitioner and the 3.d respondent,
belonging to Zone-Y, both competed for selection under the
BC-B(Dudekula) category. The 3.d respondent was selected
and appointed to the said post of AMVI under the category of
BC-B (Dudekula) community certificate and has been
discharging his duties as such.
5.
The petitioner thereafter submitted a complaint to the
District Collector-2"d respondent alleging that the 3'd
respondent did not belong to Dudekula Community and had
obtained the BC-B certil-rcate by suppressing material facts
r?!
and on false declarations before the Tahsildar, . zrmmikunta
It
was alleged that the 3.d respondent actuall , belonged
to
Muslim community, which falls under the ( rlten Category
(OC), and that by misrepresentation, he r r:cured
BC_B
Certilicate and was appointed under BC-B c uota, ttrereby
depriving the petitioner, who was next in mer. [, of selection
belonging to the very same communitv BC_B.
6.
The District Collector, basing on the com: i nt, referred
the matter to the District Level Scrutiny Commit ee headed
the Joint Collector, Karimnagar, and during thr enquir1,,
Tahsildar, Jammikunta, was directed to verifl. t .re
the
ciaim and
submit a report, a,d arso the reports were also c.i llecl
from the
Revenue Divisional Officer and thereby approt riate
notices
were issued to the 3'd respondent, afforc i ,tg him
opportunity to produce documentary evidence ir
by
an
support of
his claim to prove that he belongs to Dudekul:i ,rommunity.
Further, as the 3.a respondent failed to appeeu and
produce any documents to the satisfaction of t}r r
did not
2uth61i1isg
and solely basing on the material collected durins lhe
enquiry
forwarded the report to the District Collector, (arimnagar,
stating that the claim of the 3'd respondent was not
substantiated by any evidence. Further, the District Collector,
relying upon the reports of the DLSC and other material on
record, cancelled the BC-B community certificate issued to the
3.d respondent uide Notification in R.DisNo-C4/ 1222/2012,
dt:.5.09.2012.
7.
Assailing the said cancellation, the 3rd respondent
preferred an appeal before the l"t resPondent-Government
contending that the prescribed procedure had not been
followed by the 2"d and 3'd respondents and that he had not
been afforded adequate opportunity. It was further urged that
no proper enquiry was conducted by the authorities and that
the cancellation was based mainly on the caste status of his
maternal uncle and certain school records, and contended
that the said enquiry has not conclusively established that the
3'd respondent belonged to the Muslim community and not
BC-B Category. It was also asserted that the District Collector
had cancelled the certificate without undertaking a
comprehensive enquiry in the native village, from which the
3.d respondent hails from.
1rya.
a\
8.
The petitioner, who was arrayed as a par.. respondent in
the said appeal, has vehemently opposed the s;r id contentions
by asserting that the procedure pre,;:ribed under
G.O.Ms.No.18, dt.04.09.2013 and the applicatir: rules as on
the said d ate have been strictly followt:<l and further
contended that the reports of the Mandal Reve: ;e Officer
and
the Revenue Divisional Officer, clearly establislL .rl that the 3.a
respondent did not belong to the Dudekula Cc mmunity
and
belonged to Muslim Community. It was also ,: rntended
that
the father of the 3r(l respondent, who was also cc n.tended to be
working as Pump Mechanic in the office of t re EE, RWS,
Karimnagar, at the relevant point, his sr: r,ice records
established tl-rat he was Muslim by religion an c1 r .as appointed
in the Open Category and that the maternal u- :le of the 3,a
respondent was also appointed as AMVI unrl :r the BC-E
(Muslim) category under the creamy layer, thereby
petitioner contended that the action taken b., thc
District
Collector in cancelling the certilicate issuecL to the
respondent, was rralid.
the
3.d
-/
9.
The 1.t respondent-Government, after
affording
opportunity to both parties and upon consideratiorr of the
material available on record, has passed the impugned orders
holding out that the 2.4 respondent-District Collector had
erred in cancelling the community certificate of the 3.a
respondent without following the due procedure contemplated
under law and accordingly set aside the cancellation order by
issuing G.O.Ms.No.18, Backward Classes Welfare (C)
Department, dt.04.09.2013. The said Government Order is
challenged by the petitioner in the instant writ petition.
lO. Further, during the pendency of the above writ petition,
the petitioner approached the APAT by filing O.A. No.2l47 of
2O 12 seeking
a direction to the respondents-authorities to
conduct an enquiry into the social status of the 3'd respondent
and to cancel his appointment, and to appoint the petitioner
as AMVI in Zone-V with all consequential beneftts alleging that
the failure of the authorities to verify the social status of the
3.d respondent prior to appointment was illegal, arbitrary, and
unconstitutional and deprived the petitioner/applicant of his
legitimate right to be appointed under the post of AMVI.
. The learned APAT, after hearing both the I ,arties, allowed
the said Original Application and directed the .r:spondents to
cancel the appointment of the 3.d respondent ,r.rd appoint the
petitioner as AMVI in Zone-v under the local cr
-egory, subject
to the outcome of W.p. No.29654 of 2OI2. TLr said order of
the Tribunal is under challenge in W.p. No.4l3:5 of 2Ol4
hled
by the 3.d respondent and this Court initially r uspended
proceedings and is pending adjudication before t ris
the
Court.
12. Heard Sri M. Surender Rao learned Sir nior Counsel
representing Sri M.Srinivas Rao, counsel f<rr. petitioner
1n
WP.No.29654 of 2013 and 5th respondent in W. ) No.41356
of
2014, and Sri G. Vidya Sagar, learned S: rior Counsel
representing Smt K. Udaya Sri, learned co _ rrsel for
respondent
1n
3.a
WP.No.29654 of 2013 and retitioner in
WP.No.4l 356 of 2014.
CONTENTI ONS:
13.
The learned Senior Counsel appearing for rhe petitioner
in the lead writ petition mainly contended hat the 3.a
respondent, rn.ho admittedly belonged to
tre Muslim
community and not beloned to the Dudekula corr raunity,
had
w'
deliberately suppressed this materia-l fact and furnished false
information before the Tahsildar, Jammikunta, thereby
fraudulently secured a BC-B community certificate and
obtained appointment under BC-B category. In support of this
,contention, the learned Senior Counsel places reliance on the
service record of the father of the 3'd respondent, who was
employed in the lrrigation Depa-rtment and that his service
records unequivocally reflected his community status as
Muslim. It was further urged that the maternal uncle of the 3'a
respondent, who also belonged to the sarne Muslim
Community, was appointed as Assistant Motor Vehicle
Inspector under the very same notification, but under the BCE (Muslim) category. Placing reliance on these facts, it was
asserted that the 3'd respondent belongs to Muslim
Community and did not belong to the Dudekula community
and had obtained the BC-B certificate by misrepresentation
and false declarations.
14. It was further contended by the learned Senior Counsel
that the 2"d respondent, after conducting a proper enquiry and
affording sufficient opportunity to the 3.d respondent, had
\
\
rightly cancelled the BC B community certifica , issued to him
by follou,ing the procedure under the reler I -nt rules, and
despite being granted adequate opportur ity, the 3.d
respondent failed to appear either before the 2r),i r.espondent or
the District Level Scrutiny Committee and fir I :,i to produce
any reliable material to substantiate his craim rr show that he
belongs to Dudekula Community. It was furll t:r contended
that the "t respondent, u,ithout due apprc < i.ation of the
factual matrix, in the absence of any sustainabl:
lyounds, had
erroneously interfered with the well-reasoned o- ler passed by
the 2"a respondent ald the same is contrzu r to law and
procedure and suflers from serious legal infirm I ies, and thus
liable to be set aside.
15. Per contra., the learned Senior Counsel apP :aring for the
3.d respondent contended that the 2.d respor( ent has not
followed the procedure mandated undc. law
uid.e
G.O.Ms.No.18, Backward Classes Welfare (C) Department,
dt.04.09.2013. It
was submitted that thr Tahsildar,
Jammikunta, submitted a report dt.l2.O3.2Ol2, r1,, cailing for
the school records of the 3.a respondent, and iss,r rr:d a notice,
dt.30.04.2012 which was served on the mother of the 3'd
respondent sought time as the 3'd respondent was not
available and though the time rvas extended, as the 3'd
respondent was not informed by his mother, as such he could
not appear on the date of enquiry, and thus, it is contended
that the enquiry was concluded and a fair opportunity was
given and in a case of this nature, the 2"d respondent ought to
have seen that the notices are served upon the proper person'
16. It was further submitted that the Revenue Divisional
Officer, Karimnagar, merely stated that the father of the 3'a
respondent was employed in the lrrigation Department and
that his service records reflected his caste as "Fakheer
Muslim". On sole basis of this information, the District Level
Committee recommended for cancellation of the certihcate and
the District Collector proceeded to issue the order
dt. 15.09.2012, without proper appreciation of the facts and
reports, and grossly erred in holding that the 3'd respondent
had fraudulently obta-rned a BC-B communit5r certihcate and
thereby secured selection to the post of AMVI, without
I2
undertaking an independent and comprehens.r c assessment
of the factual matrix of the case
. The learned Senior Counsel also conte - c ed that the
community certificate of the 3.a respondent ha r been issued
prior to the enforcement of the A.p. (SC, ST & B( s) Regulation
of Issue of Community Certificates Act, 1993 arr, L the Rules of
1997, atd therefore, by virtue of Section 21 o' the said Act,
the certificate ought to have been treated as valic. The leanred
Senior Counsel placed reliance on the reports o. Lhe Tahsildar
and the Revenue Divisional Authority, which i r,Cicated that
the surname of the 3.d respondent correspol-i .t :d rvith that
commonly associated with the Dudekuia comrnl nitv, namely
'Mohammad". It was also submitted that the far rer of the 3.d
respondent had entered government service rrior to the
inclusion of the Dudekula community .in the lis of Backr,r,ard
Classes and that, at the relevant point of time, ttere was no
mandatory requirement to disclose caste particu l, -:.s in service
records, but hornever, the 2na respondent 5qls r got carried
away by the same and without proper verificaticr has passed
the orders by cancelling the certificate.
{
18. It was further contended that the caste of the maternal
uncle could not be determinative of the socia-l status of the 3'd
respondent and more pa-rticularly, Dedekula Caste people
believe and practice Islam for many reasons. It was asserted
that while the mother of the 3'a respondent belonged to the
Fakheer Muslim community, the father belonged to the
Dudekula community, ard this crucia,l distinction was neither
properly examined by the 2"d respondent nor by the District
Level Scrutiny Committee. It vr''as also contended that prior to
the father of the 3'd respondent entering government service,
there was no statutory obligation to produce caste certihcate
in the service registers for recording the same and further it
was contended that no proper field-level or village-level
enquiry was conducted to verify the social status of the 3'd
respondent, for reaching proper conclusion.
19. It was a-lso contended that the State Government had
amended the relevant provisions by including a BC-E category
for persons prolessing Islarn who are able to establish that
they belong to the Dudekula communit5r, and thus, this aspect
T4
would clinchingry prove that the 3.d respond.rr
a,d his father
belong to Dudekula Community
20. On all these grounds, it was submitted 11. the
Senior Counsel that the l"r respondent
had ri
its appellate jurisdiction in setting aside
respondent and that the petitioner
grounds warranting interference by
considered order passed by the lst
11_r
learned
tly exercised
the . aer of the 2.d
failed to r:stablish any
this Cou r L ,,r,ith the well
respondent. .l.hus, prayed
to dismiss W.p. No.29654 of 20t2 and
to a.[ou, \ / p. No.41356
of 2Ol4
21 .
We have given earnest consideration
made by the learned Senior Counsel
Government pleaders appearing for
perused the entire material on
to r, submissions
as well zr: the learned
the respectiu: parties and
record.
Although both writ petitions were heard
the 1is in the subsequent writ petition
1c1 e.ther, sr nce,
is who I .. dependent
upon the outcome of the lead u,rit petition
impugned therein is merely a consequential
orrk:
of the proceedings in the lead writ petition,
substance of the contentions raised
: I the order
arlsrng out
tf e sum ald
in the leacl ,'nt petition
would adequately cover and sub-serve the issues involved in
the subsequent writ petition as rvell as both pertain to the
appointment of the 3'a respondent under BC-B quota.
23. From the factual matrix of the case and the riva-l
submissions advanced, the following aspects emerge for
consideration:
(i) Whether the enquiry conducted by the 2nd
respondent leading to cancellation of the BC-B
communit5r certificate of the 3'a respondent was in
accordance with the procedure prescribed under
Act 16 of 1993 and the Rules framed thereunder;
(ii) Whether the 1't respondent was justified in setting
aside the cancellation order without directing a
fresh enquiry; and
(iii) Whether the order passed by the A.P.
Administrative Tribunal could be sustained when
the very foundation is under challenge in the lead
writ petition.
24. Before delving into the matter, it is necessar5r to briefly
refer to the provisions under the Act and Rules of Andhra
Pradesh (Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward
Classes) Regulation of Issue of Community Certificate Act,
1993 (Act 16/19931.
)
i
25. Section 3 of the Act 16/1993 envisages l rat any person
may appiy for a community certificate, which ;halt
be issued
by the competent authority after being sarr,;lied with the
genuineness of claim. The provisions specifica
L, envisage that
a prescribed procedure must be followed befor<:
irssuing such a
certificate, and the said provision is reproduc,: I
for reference
as under:
"3. Application of a community certificate
r,":g,l belon€ing t,,
of the S<l ttturcd Casrcs,
!r]"lLY,
ucneduied 't'rtbes or Backward ".,y
Classes may I order to claim
the benefit of any reservation provided to
i Castes, Tribes
or Classes either for any public appointment
"1, c r lor admission
into any educational institution 1., tfr. Stat,r or outside
the
State for the students of the State o. r.ry oth, I
benefit under
any special provisions made under clause (4r cr
Articte
the Constitution of India or for the pr.po". r :contesting15 of
for
elective post in any local authority oi f.i .1..i
vc prrsts in the
Co-operative Institutions, make an applicatir,r in
and in such manner as may te p..siiiteJ i; the such form
competent
authoritv for the issue of a community c.. t.r,".
(2) Arry
person belonging to a Scheduled Tribe may
I rr tlie p*.po"L
of claiming any benerrt or protection mea,r lcr
Scheduled
Tribes undcr aly notification, direction o. ,
- 1rtario., made
under thc Fifth Schedule to the ConstitutiL r: of
India or
Act, Rule,. Regulation or Order for tt, I tin.," being
in
X::^..,".I
Iorce ln the Scheduled Areas, make an
,
zLtior.r in such
form and in such manner as may beapplrr
pr.r: r-_ribt:d
to the
r:crtrricate.
i
Explanation:- For the purposes of thi , section
and
section 13,
competent_ authority for the issue of communit
Scheduled Areas, means the areas
paragraph 6 to the Schedule to the Constitutio- ,as dehned in
ulrGr
o.,r:Y
t7
-/{
26. Under Section 5, the District Collector may either on suo
motu or on a written complaint, cancel the Caste Certificate
after caliing for the records and enquiring into its correctness'
Under Section 6, the caldidate may apply for a fresh
community certificate and that the burden of proving
belonging to a particular caste or tribe rests upon the
claimalt. It is thus for the individual claiming a particular
caste to establish the same, and not lor the complainant or
enquiry officer to prove otherwise. Under Section 7(2) an
appeal to the Government against the order of the District
Collector passed under Section 5, empowering the
Government to conhrm or set aside such orders' Sections 1O,
13, and 20 d.eal with penalties and confer pow6rs on the
Government to make rules, which were framed under
G.O.Ms.No.58, dated 12.O5.1997. Even Rule 6, similarly
reinforces that the burden of proof rests on the claimant'
.
Now coming to the facts of the case, the petitioner filed a
complaint alleging that the 3'd respondent had obtained a BC-
B community certificate from the MRO, Jammikunta, by
misrepresentation, claiming to be belong to the Dudekula
community, though he actually belonged 1r the Muslim
community falling under the Open Categor.. . The District
Collector entertained the compiaint and referr: I the matter to
the District Level Scrutiny Committee (DLSC) I tr enquiry into
the validity of the caste certificate.
28. Pursuant thereto, the MRO, JammikrL. rr:a, by letter,
dt.02.03.2012, requested the concerned auth: -ity to furnish
details. Notices were issued to the 3.d responder rt_ cailing upon
him to produce relevant documents. The notic. vuas served on
the mother of the 3.a respondent, as he was nrt avajlable. On
05.O3.2O12, the mother of the 3.a respondent rr rpeared
before
the MRO ald sought time to produce documer ts, rvhich was
granted till 08.03.2012. However, on the said d, i:, neither
the
3.d respondent nor his mother produced any dc cuments,
and
the MRO basing on the above facts and : r.cumstances,
submitted a report drawing an adverse inferenr e that the
3.d
respondent had faiied to produce aly proof/rl rcuments
to
establish that he belonged to BC_B Dudekula cor rmunity.
29. The DLSC, under the Chairmanship ri. the Joint
Collector, addressed a letter to the Headmastt:r, ZpHS
Boys
School, Jammikunta to send the school records and the said
records indicated that the religion of the 3'd respondent was
Muslim arld that he belonged to a Forward Catcgory(FC), and
his father's narne was shown as Jameel Ahmed. On the basis
of the said records, the MRO concluded that the 3'd
respondent did not belong to BC-B Dudekula community and
communicated the same to the District Collector uide letter
dated 72.03.2012.
30. ThereaJter, the 2'd respondent referred the matter to the
DLSC in Aprll, 2012, which in turn was referred it to the
Revenue Divisional Officer(RDO), Karimnagar. The RDO
conducted an enquiry and obtained details from the Irrigation
Department as the father of the 3'a respondent was employed
in Irrigation Department. Further, the service records revealed
that the father of the 3'a respondent belongcd to Muslim
community, which is under OC category' It u'as also noted
that the surnatne of the 3'd respondent i.e', Mohammad also
tallied with the Dudekula community, but however, the school
records of the 3.d respondent and along with service records of
the father did not reflect BC-B status. It was further noticed
that the matcrnal uncle of the 3.d respori lent was also
appointed as AMVI under BC_E (Muslinr
crearny layer
category under the very sarne notification. On
-hese grounds,
the District Level Service Committee rec ( mmended for
cancellation and the 2"d respondent cancelled he
community
certificate issued to the 3.d responde nt, uid.e \otification
R.DisNo.C4l t222 / 2012, dt. 15.09.2012, which
in
was assailed
before the 1"r respondent.
31.
The 1"t respondent, after considering the ),)ntentions
of
both sides, observed that none of the a _ L.horities had
conducted a detailed enquiry in the native vilt
rge of ttre 3rd
respondent, as required under Secti on L4 of
the relevant
Rules. It was further observed that the frlt ily
examined only up to the paternar gra,dfathe-
properly appreciating the scope of pedigree
rand without
en( Llirv, the 2.d
respondent passcd orders. The 1"t respondent
hr ld that caste
determination czrnnot be made solely on the bir;ts
records of the father or the caste of the
of service
materrt rl uncle and
further, the sen ice book of the father did
social status and that mere entry of
tree was
no . disclose his
mother torlfi re as ..Urdu,,
t
/
2t
cannot be treated as al indication of forward caste status. In
the absence of a proper village-level enquiry, the 1"t
respondent concluded that the cardinal principles of fair
enquiry as envisaged under the Andhra pradesh (SC, ST and
BC) Regulation of Issue of Community Certificates Act, 1993
and Rules, 1997 were not followed by the 2.d respondent.
32. Further, the l"t respondent observed that there was no
conclusive material to establish that the 3..r respondent
belonged to Muslim community a-lone and noted that
Dudekula community, though classified under BC-B, follows
Muslim religious practices. On these grounds, the 1"t
respondent set aside the orders passed by the 2nd respondent.
33. The main ground on which the proceedings of the 2",r
respondent is assailed is that the 3.a respondent has not
produced proper material to prove that he belonged to BC_B
Category despite being afforded opportuni[z and also failed to
produce satisfactory material to conclusively establish that he
belonged to the BC-B Dudekula community.
r', r{.-1!1'-:
34. Evidently, the notice was served on the mot ter of the 3.a
respondent though she requested time, in a rr a tter of this
nature, the 2"a respondent ought to have takerr a1l steps for
service of notice on the 3.d respondent by all r( €rns and the
service affected is not proper. However, mere n() r-production
of documents cannot, by itself, justify canci llation of a
community certihcate rvithout conducting a c: rrprehensive
enquiry, particularly one involving village-level r., rifi6a1ior, ."
mandated by law. When a community certificatr i:s cancelled,
the same must be supported by cogent evidence ; t:qually, the
basis on which the certificate was initiatty rs r r.red by the
competent authority must also be examined uis-a ri-s service of
proper notice on the affected party.
35. In the present case, the cancellation rvas : lsed mainly
on inferences drawn from the service records of he father of
the 3,a respondent and the social status of the me tcrnal uncle
of the 3.d respondent. Mere inferences, without pr rper village-
Ievel enquiry and without exarnining the overa_ll r ocial status
of the family, cannot form the basis for canci I ation of a
communit5r certificate, especially when such ce r Lr:ellation is
sought at the instance of a rival claimant that too, when no
proper service is a-ffected on the 3.d respondent. At the same
time, the 1"t respondent, having found that the enquiry
conducted rvas defective ought to have remanded the matter
for fresh enquiry by giving proper opportunity to the aifected
party and also the writ petitioner and taking into account a-11
the material placed on either side instead of conclusively
deciding the issue, by setting aside the orders of the 2'a
respondent as being vitiated by procedure and law
36. In these circumstances, in our considered view, it is a fit
case to set aside the orders passed by the 1st and 2nd
respondents ald remand the matter for fresh and proper
enquiry by the 2.d respondent by following due process of iaw
37. In view of the above findings, the orders passed by the
l"t respondent ald the 2'd respondent are both set aside,
and the matter is remanded to the 2'd respondent to conduct
a detailed enquiry into the complaint of the petitioner for
cancellation of the caste/community certificate issued to the
3.d respondent under BC-B Category, in accordance with law,
after giving due opportunity to the petitioner as well as the 3'd
i
{
e
respondent, and to pass appropriate orders I :rsed on the
materia-l placed on record.
38. Consequently, in view ol the remand of thr r;sue relating
to the caste certificate of the 3.a responderr to the 2.d
respondent for fresh consideration, the orde: passed in
O.A.No.2147 of 2072 dated 06.07.2014 on the .i r: of the A.p.
Administrative Tribunal shall stand set aside.
39. Accordingly, the writ petition Wp.No.296ti l. of 2013 is
partly allowed and the r.r,-rit petition 41356 of 2O14. is a1lowed.
No order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitior s; pending if
any, shall stand closed.
SD/- II.PONNA KRISHNA
ASSI! TANT REGISTRAR
\
l
//TRUE COPY//
JECTION OFFICER
To
\
'1. The Principal Secretary, Backward Classes Welfa
c) )epartment, State of
Telangana, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Principal Secretary, State of Telangana, Transport, {,)ads and Buildings
Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
.)
. The Transport Commissioner, State of Telangana, Khair i bad, Hyderabad.
4 . The Secretary, Telangana State Public Service Con r rission, [\rl.J. Road,
Hyderabad.
5 . The Collector, Karimnagar District, Karimnagar.
6 . One CC to SRI M. SRINIVASA RAO, Advocate [OPUC]
7 . One CC to SMT. K. UDAYA SRl, Advocate [OPUC]
B . Two CCs to GP for Social Welfare, High Court foi the li ate of Telangana at
Hyderabad.
. Two CCs to[OUT]
GP for Services-lll, High Court for the St rle of Telangana at
Hyderabad. [OUT]
1 0.One CC to SRI GUTHA IVALLTKARJUNA RAO, Standinls lounsel
[OPUC]
1 1.One CC toSRl P.S. RAJASEKHAR, S.C. forTSPSC
[OFil r(ll
1 2.Two CD Copies
I
MP
,\c"
IIIGH COURT
DATE ):0610212026
( )'l
\--\
lii)
'irr
sliit\.
*'i',
I Ii2126 ?lj
frr?
,:!-12:Pil
COMI]/ION ORDER
W.P. Nos.29654 OF 2013 AND 41 356 OF 2014
PARTLY ALLOWING THE W.P.No.296l i4 OF 2013 &
ALLOWING THE W.P.No.41356 OF 2014
r4
, \aL
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review