Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010212702024
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : I.A.(Civil)/2351/2025
ORIENTAL INSUANCE COMPANY LTD.
A CENTRAL GOVT. UNDERTAKING HAVING ITS REGIONAL OFFICE AT
GUWAHATI, G.S. ROAD, ULUBARI, GUWAHATI-781007 REP. BY THE
MANAGER, GAUHATI REGIONAL OFFICE, UUBARI, GUWAHATI-781007.
VERSUS
SUPARNA DAS AND 4 ORS
W/O. LT. DULU DAS
2:BIKI DAS
S/O. LT. DULU DAS
3:SNEHA DAS
D/O. LT. DULU DAS
ALL ARE R/O. VILL.- GUNAMOYEE ROAD
SUSTIPALLY
TARAPUR
P/O. AND P/S. SILCHAR
DIST. SILCHAR
ASSAM
PIN-788003
OPPOSITE PARTY NO. 3 IS REP. BY OPPOSITE NO. 1
4:SUNIL BAISNAB
S/O. GOPAL BAISNAB
R/O. VILL.- KHELMA PT.-IV
P/O. GUMRAH
P/S. KATIGORAG
DIST. CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN-788815.
Page No.# 2/9
5:CHIRANJIT BISWAS
S/O. CHITTARANJAN BISWAS
R/O. SRI RAMPALLY
BIDYASAGAR SARANI
P/O. P/S.- SILCHAR
DIST. CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN-788001
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS. C MOZUMDAR, MR. S P SHARMA,MS. R D MOZUMDAR
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. A BISWAS (R1-R3), MR P K BASU (R1-R3)
Linked Case :
ORIENTAL INSUANCE COMPANY LTD
VERSUS
SUPARNA DAS AND 4 ORS
-----------Advocate for : MS. C MOZUMDAR
Advocate for : appearing for SUPARNA DAS AND 4 ORS
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
::ORDER ::
09.09.2026
1.
Heard Ms. R. D. Mozumdar, learned counsel for the
Page No.# 3/9
applicant. Also heard Mr. A. Biswas, learned counsel for the
respondent/claimants.
2.
This application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act,
1963, has been filed by the applicant, namely, Oriental Insurance
Company Limited, praying for condonation of delay of 237 days in
preferring the connected appeal, wherein the judgment and award
dated 06.11.2023 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Cachar, Silchar, in MAC Case No. 339/2016 has been impugned.
3.
Ms. R. D. Mozumdar, the learned counsel for the applicant
submits that the delay of 237 days in preferring the connected
appeal has been occasioned due to reasons which were beyond the
control of the applicant and also due to time consumed in
administrative processes within the Insurance Company for filing an
appeal against a judgment in a claim case. She submits that though
the impugned judgment was passed by the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Cachar, Silchar on 06.11.2023, however, the legal opinion
for preferring an appeal by the concerned counsel was received by
the Insurance Company on 01.08.2024, i.e., 268 days after passing
of the said judgment. She submits that this was beyond the control
of the Insurance Company.
4.
The learned counsel for the applicant further submits that
after receipt of the legal opinion, the relevant file was prepared on
13.08.2024 and was sent to the Regional Manager of the Insurance
Company on 23.08.2024 and thereafter approval for filing the appeal
Page No.# 4/9
was granted by the competent authority on 29.08.2024. She further
submits that thereafter the file was prepared and handed over to the
present counsel on 03.09.2024 and some days were taken for
preparation of the memo of appeal and ultimately the appeal was
preferred on 01.10.2024. She submits that in the process, 237 days
of delay has occasioned. She submits that the said delay was not
due to the lapses on the part of the Insurance Company, but due to
normal time taken in following the administrative procedures which
are required to be followed before preferring an appeal by the
Insurance Company.
5.
She further submits that there was no deliberate lapse on
the part of the Insurance Company in preferring the appeal. She has
also submitted that since the applicant/Insurance Company has to
handle a lot of appeals, hence, the time consumed in completing the
administrative processes before preferring an appeal may not be
regarded as intentional lapse by the applicant/Insurance Company.
She also submits that the delay occasioned in this case should be
looked at with a liberal approach and by taking a justice-oriented
approach, the delay of 237 days may be condoned. In support of her
submission, the learned counsel for the applicant has cited the
following rulings:
1.
“State of Nagaland Vs. Lipokao and Others ” reported in
“(2005)” 3 SCC 752”.
2.
“Executive Officer, Antiyur Town Panchayat Vs. G.
Page No.# 5/9
Arumugam (Dead) by LRs.”, reported in “(2015) 3 SCC 569”.
6.
On the other hand, Mr. A. Biswas, the learned counsel for
the opposite party/claimant has vehemently opposed the prayer for
condonation of delay of 237 days in preferring the connected appeal.
He submits that the Insurance Company has merely stated the facts
which have occasioned the delay and has not sufficiently explained
the reason for such delay. He submits that by merely stating that the
legal opinion by the dealing counsel was given to the Insurance
Company after 268 days, the same may not be regarded as
explaining the said delay. He further submits that the delay
occasioned in processing the matter before preferring an appeal has
also not been explained by the Insurance Company. He submits that
the Insurance Company has only stated the facts which occasioned
the delay without justifying the reasons for the said delay.
7.
He further submits that on perusal of the certified copy of
the impugned judgment which has been annexed along with this
interlocutory application, it appears that though the impugned
judgment was passed on 06.11.2023, however, the certified copy of
the same was applied for after a period of 6 months, i.e., on
09.05.2024 and no reason for the belated filing of the application for
certified copy has been stated by the Insurance Company.
8.
He further submits that the averments made in the instant
interlocutory application itself indicate that the applicant was not
diligent in preferring the delay condonation in preferring the
Page No.# 6/9
connected appeal within the prescribed period of limitation. He
submits that it is not open for the Insurance Company to ignore the
prescribed period of appeal preferred by the law of limitation and
approach the Court by filing an appeal as and when it pleases. He
submits that the delay occasioned due to the negligence of its
officers and its engaged counsel has to be explained by the
Insurance Company, which has not been explained by the Insurance
Company.
9.
He further submits that the Motor Vehicles Act being a
beneficial legislation, the claimant to whom compensation has been
awarded on occasion of the death of somebody on whom they were
dependent may not be deprived of the fruits of the award for more
than three years, since the award in this case has been passed on
06.11.2023. He, therefore, submits that the prayer for condonation
of delay may be rejected in this case. In support of his submission,
he has cited the following rulings:
1.
“State of Bihar and Others Vs. Deo Kumar Singh and
Others, reported in “(2022) 16 SCC 483”.
2.
“ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Limited
Vs. Shri Rupnath Brahma Choudhury and another ”, reported in
“2017 2 GLJ 494”.
10.
I have considered the submissions made by the learned
counsel for both sides and have gone through the materials on
Page No.# 7/9
record. I have also gone through the rulings cited by the learned
counsel for both sides in support of their respective submissions.
11.
The period of limitation for filing an appeal under Section
173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is 90 days from the date of the
impugned judgment. It appears that in the instant case, the
impugned judgment and award was passed on 06.11.2023 and,
therefore, the appeal ought to have been filed within a period of 90
days from the said date. However, in the instant case, it appears that
even the legal opinion suggesting that an appeal may be preferred
against the impugned judgment was rendered much beyond the
period of limitation for filing the appeal itself, i.e., after 268 days of
the delivery of the judgment and award by the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal.
12.
In the instant case, though the applicant has explained the
reasons for delay after the file for preferring the appeal was
prepared on 13.08.2024, however, nothing has been stated
regarding the period from 01.08.2024 to 13.08.2024. Even if we
ignore this period regarding it to be a small period of time, however,
the applicant has only stated the fact of delay in receipt of legal
opinion from its engaged counsel after 268 days of the passing of
the impugned judgment. There is no indication as to what it did to
pursue the matter after the judgment was delivered.
13.
There is also no indication in the instant interlocutory
application regarding the date on which the Insurance Company
Page No.# 8/9
came to know about the impugned judgment. In paragraph No. 3 of
the instant interlocutory application, the applicant has only stated
regarding the fact of obtaining legal opinion for preferring and filing
an appeal after 268 days of the date of the impugned judgment.
14.
It cannot be disputed that in dealing with the question of
condonation of delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 the
party applying for such condonation has to satisfy the Court that
sufficient cause for not preferring the appeal or making the
application beyond the prescribed period of limitation. It has to cover
the whole period of delay. However, in the instant case, the applicant
has not explained the reasons for delay which has occasioned in
belated rendering of legal opinion by its engaged counsel and it has
only merely stated the fact of such delay.
15.
Though, there is no dispute over the settled proposition of
law that while dealing with an application under Section 5 of the
Limitation Act, a liberal and justice-oriented approach is required to
be adopted, however, Courts cannot become oblivious of the fact
that the successful litigant has acquired certain rights on the basis of
the judgment under challenge and a lot of time is consumed at
various stages of litigation, apart from the costs involved in pursuing
such litigation before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal.
16.
It is also to be taken note of that there is a point beyond
which even Courts cannot help a litigant, even when such litigant is
an Insurance Company which has been directed to pay the
Page No.# 9/9
compensation to the claimant who had to suffer due to a motor
vehicular accident because of no fault of theirs.
17.
This Court is also of the considered opinion that though a
short period of delay which may be occasioned in completing the
administrative
processes
within
the
Insurance
Company
for
preferring an appeal against an award granted in Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal may be condoned, however, this latitude may not be
given in a case where the delay involved is an inordinate delay of
237 days, as in this case.
18.
For the discussions made and reasons stated in the
foregoing paragraphs, this Court is of considered opinion that the
applicant/Insurance Company has not been able to sufficiently
explain the delay of 237 days which has been occasioned in this case
in preferring the connected appeal.
19.
20.
As such, this interlocutory application is hereby dismissed.
Statutory
deposit
of
Rs.25,000/-
deposited
by
the
applicant/appellant at the time of filing of the connected appeal may
be returned back to the appellant after proper verification.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review