Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: CR No. 28/2025
CM No. 4983/2025
Reserved on: 14.07.2026
Pronounced on:07.08.2026
Uploaded on:07.08.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced :Full
1. Nitin Malhotra, aged 62
years,
S/O
Sh.Satish
Malhotra, R/O 150 A/D
Gandhi Nagar,Jammu.
2. Harish Choudhary, aged 56
years, S/O Sh. Sat Pal
Choudhary,R/O 227, Shastri
Nagar, Jammu.
……Petitioner(s)…..
Through: Mr. Vikas Mangotra, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Rajat Jamwal, Advocate
v/s
Arya Pratinidhi Sabha J&K Arya
Samaj Balidhan Bhawan, Bakshi
Nagar, Jammu through its Vice
President Mr. Arun Kumar Gupta,
S/O late Shri Dwarka Nath, R/O
Quarter No.170, Rehari Colony,
Jammu.
Through:
Mr. Rakesh Chargotra, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Sabhya Gandhi, Advocate
……Respondent(s)…
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioners, through the medium of this revision petition, have
challenged the order dated 10.03.2025 passed by the Court of the
CR No. 28/2025
learned Additional District Judge, Jammu (for short, "the trial court"),
in the civil suit titled “Arya Pratinidhi Sabha v. Hariish Choudhary
and another”, whereby the application filed by the petitioners under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC for rejection of the plaint has been dismissed.
2. The petitioners have assailed the impugned order primarily on the
ground that Arya Pratinidhi Sabha, Jammu & Kashmir was registered
as society with the Registrar of Societies, J&K, and as per the letter
dated 29.12.2023 issued by the Registrar of Societies, the respondent
did not apply for re-registration within the prescribed period, i.e., on
or
before
18.12.2021,
consequently,
the
society
stood
de-
registered/deleted from the records of the Registrar of Societies and,
therefore, ceased to be a legal entity, and as such has no locus standi
to institute the suit. It is further contended that Shri Arun Kumar
Gupta was neither an office-bearer nor a member of the society, and
as such not competent to maintain the suit. Reliance has also been
placed on the communication dated 06.01.2004 issued by the
Assistant Director, Directorate of Industries and Commerce, Jammu
wherein it is stated that Arya Samaj, Purana Hospital Road, Jammu,
stands de-registered/deleted from its records.
3. The respondent has filed its response/synopsis and, besides narrating
the factual background of the case, has contended that, while
exercising powers under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the Court is required
to consider only the averments made in the plaint and the documents
annexed thereto. The facts pleaded in the written statement, as well as
the pleas raised in an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC by
way of defence, are wholly irrelevant for deciding such an application.
CR No. 28/2025
It is further stated that the petitioners have failed to demonstrate how
the plaint does not disclose a cause of action, or how the suit is barred
by any law, or suffers from any of the infirmities contemplated under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC. It is further submitted that the respondent
society is a registered society under the J&K Societies Registration
Act, VI of 1998. By virtue of the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganization (Removal of Difficulties) Order, 2019, dated 30.10.2019,
issued by the Hon'ble President of India, every certificate issued under
the J&K Societies Registration Act is deemed to have been issued
under the corresponding provisions of the Central Act made
applicable to the Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir with effect
from 31.10.2019. Therefore, the contention that the respondent society
was required to obtain re-registration is misconceived and cannot
constitute a ground for rejection of the plaint. It is also submitted that
the documents relied upon by the petitioners, form part of their
defence, as pleaded in the written statement, and such material cannot
be looked into while deciding an application under Order VII Rule 11
CPC. Consequently, the plaint could not have been rejected on the
grounds urged by the petitioners.
4. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners argued that the
trial court has failed to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it, as the
respondent had created an illusory cause of action by withholding,
concealing, and misrepresenting, material facts relating to its legal
status, locus standi, and right to sue, thereby failing to disclose a valid
cause of action for maintaining the suit. It was, therefore, contended
that the plaint was liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
CR No. 28/2025
Learned Senior Counsel has relied upon the information obtained
under the Right to Information Act to dispute the legal status of the
respondent and to contend that the suit, having been instituted by a
non-entity, was not maintainable and the plaint deserved to be
rejected. It was also submitted that Shri Arun Kumar Gupta, through
whom the suit has been instituted, was neither an office-bearer nor a
member of Arya Pratinidhi Sabha, J&K. In support of his
submissions, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners placed
reliance upon the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in T.
Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal, (1977) 4 SCC 467; Church of Christ
Charitable Trust and Educational Charitable Society v. M/s
Poonniamman Educational Trust, AIR 2012 SC 3912; and P. Nazeer
etc. v. Salafi Trust and Another, AIR 2022 SC 1580. Reliance was
also placed upon the judgment of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in
F2Fun and Fitness Pvt. Ltd. v. Golden Globe Fitness Pvt. Ltd. and
Another, CR No. 36/2018, decided on 26.10.2018.
5. Learned Senior counsel, Mr. Rakesh Chargotra, argued that the suit
was instituted by the respondent in February, 2023, whereas the
petitioners sought to persuade the learned trial Court to rely upon their
defence, based on the information/documents obtained under the
Right to Information Act after the institution of suit, for rejection of
the respondent's plaint, but in the light of settled position of law that,
while considering an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the
Court is required to examine only the averments contained in the
plaint and the documents annexed thereto, and cannot take into
consideration the defence raised by the defendants, the learned trial
CR No. 28/2025
court has rightly decided the application. In support of his
submissions, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent has placed
reliance upon the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sopan
Sukhdeo Sable v. Assistant Charity Commissioner, AIR 2004 SC
1801, and R.K. Roja v. U.S. Rayudu and Another, AIR 2016 SCW
328.
6. Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the
record.
7. The record depicts that the suit came to be instituted by the respondent
through its Vice President seeking a decree of permanent prohibitory
injunction restraining the petitioners and their agents, attorney,
associates or any other person/s claiming through them from
interfering into the smooth functioning/working of Arya Samaj
Mandir, Gandhi Nagar, Jammu in any manner whatsoever. A further
prayer was made for injunction restraining the defendants from
exercising any functions as office bearers of Arya Samaj Mandir,
Gandhi Nagar, Jammu or claiming themselves as the office bearers of
Arya Samaj Mandir, Gandhi Nagar, Jammu; and also restraining the
defendants from interfering into the peaceful possession of Arya
Samaj Mandir, Gandhi Nagar, Jammu in any manner either
themselves or through their agents, associates, aides etc.
8. Thereafter, the defendants-petitioners filed written statement stating
therein that Shri Arun Kumar Gupta has not annexed any
authorization to file the present suit for and on behalf of Arya
Pratinidhi Sabha, Jammu. In the preliminary objections, it is stated
that the respondent has no cause of action and legal right to interfere
CR No. 28/2025
in the management, functioning and working of Arya Samaj Mandir,
Gandhi Nagar, Jammu, which has its own office bearers, elected
through democratic process of election duly acknowledged by Arya
Prathindhi Sabha, J&K. As per the averments made in paragraph
No.1 of the written statement, the petitioners have admitted
registration and goal of Arya Pratinidhi Sabha, Jammu and Kashmir.
However, it is specifically pleaded that the respondent has no direct
control over Arya Pratinidhi Sabha, Gandhi Nagar, Jammu, which is
governed and run by its elected office-bearers through a democratic
process of election.
9. Thereafter, the petitioners filed an application under Order VII Rule
11 CPC seeking rejection of the plaint on the grounds recorded above.
In support of the application, the petitioners relied upon a
communication dated 08.09.2023 issued by the Registrar of Societies
to one Ms. Archana Kumari, wherein it was stated that Arya
Pratinidhi Sabha, J&K was originally registered under the J&K
Registration Act, 1998 (Samvat) vide Registration No. 99 of 1968.
However, as the society had failed to apply for re-registration under
the Societies Registration Act, 1860, it was de-registered/deleted from
the records of the Registrar's office with effect from 20.12.2021. The
petitioners have also placed reliance upon another communication
dated 29.12.2023, wherein it was stated that, as per the case file of the
society, Shri Arun Kumar Gupta and Shri Narender Trehan were not
office-bearers or members of the said society. Further reliance was
placed on information furnished under the Right to Information Act
vide communication dated 06.04.2004, wherein it was stated that Arya
CR No. 28/2025
Pratinidhi Sabha, J&K was not registered under the Societies
Registration Act, 1860 and that the society was shown as nonoperational in the official records.
10.In response to the aforesaid application, the respondents contended
that the issues raised by the petitioners do not fall within the ambit of
Order VII Rule 11 CPC. It was submitted that, while considering an
application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the Court is required to
examine only the averments contained in the plaint, and that neither
the pleas raised in the written statement nor the defences set up in the
application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC can be taken into
consideration for the purpose of rejecting the plaint.
11.In terms of the order dated 21.04.2026, the Assistant Director
(Development), Department of Industries and Commerce, Jammu,
was directed to appear in person along with the original record
pertaining to Registration Certificate No. 99 of 1968 dated
16.10.1968. In compliance with the said order, Shri Jatinder Pal
Singh, Assistant Director, Industries and Commerce, Jammu,
appeared before the Court and produced the relevant record, which
was retained by the Court.
12.The principles governing the exercise of jurisdiction under Order VII
Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) are well-settled through
a long line of authoritative judicial pronouncements. It is a trite law
that an application seeking rejection of a plaint must be decided
exclusively on the basis of the averments made in the plaint, read in
conjunction with the documents annexed thereto. Neither the defence
set up in the written statement nor any extraneous material/documents
CR No. 28/2025
produced by the defendant can be adverted to at this stage. The Court
is duty-bound to undertake a meaningful and not merely a formal
reading of the plaint to ascertain whether it discloses a clear cause of
action or whether the suit, on a plain reading, is barred by any law. It
is only upon the strict satisfaction of these statutory conditions that the
plaint can be rejected in the exercise of powers under Order VII Rule
11 of the CPC.
13.In Church of Christ Charitable Trust and Educational Charitable
Society Vs. M/s Ponniamman Education Trust, AIR 2012 SC 3912
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has observed that the averments
made in the written statement are immaterial and it is duty of the court
to scrutinize the averments/pleas in the plaint to consider the
application for rejection of the plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
17.It would also be apposite to refer to the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India in R.K. Roja v. U.S. Rayudu and another,
AIR 2016 SCW 3282. Paragraph 5 of the said judgment, being
relevant for the present controversy, is extracted hereunder:
“5.
We are afraid that the stand taken by the High Court in
the impugned order cannot be appreciated. An application
under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC can be filed at any stage,
as held by this Court in Sopan Sukhdeo Sable and others v.
Assistant Charity Commissioner and others.. “The trial court
can exercise the power at any stage of the suit – before
registering the plaint or after issuing summons to the
defendant at any time before the conclusion of the trial. …”.
The only restriction is that the consideration of the
application for rejection should not be on the basis of the
allegations made by the defendant in his written statement
CR No. 28/2025
or on the basis of the allegations in the application for
rejection of the plaint. The court has to consider only the
plaint as a whole, and in case, the entire plaint comes under
the situations covered by Order VII Rule 11 (a) to (f) of the
CPC, the same has to be rejected.”
(emhasis added)
14.A perusal of the record produced by the Registrar of Societies reveals
that the issue regarding the re-registration of Arya Pratinidhi Sabha,
J&K is presently pending consideration before the Joint Director
(M&P), Directorate of Industries and Commerce, Jammu. The record
further reveals that the inquiry directed by the Administrative
Department has not been proceeded with, in view of the pendency of
the matter before the Court.
15.The petitioners' plea regarding the respondent's lack of legal status to
maintain the suit, is a pure defence that falls outside the limited scope
of Order VII Rule 11 CPC. In deciding an application under Order VII
Rule 11 CPC, the Court must look entirely at the plaint. Though the
Court may examine parties under Order X CPC to nip sham litigation
in the bud where no real cause of action exists and mirage of cause of
action has been created. It cannot exercise powers under Order VII
Rule 11 where there are serious, disputed questions of material fact.
Such factual controversies can only be adjudicated by framing issues
and taking evidence on record.
16.This Court has carefully examined the order passed by the learned
trial Court. The view taken and the conclusion arrived at by the
learned trial Court while rejecting the application preferred by the
petitioners under Order VII Rule 11 CPC are found to be wellCR No. 28/2025
reasoned and in consonance with the settled principles of law. The
opinion formed by the learned trial Court is unexceptionable and does
not warrant any interference by this Court in the exercise of its
supervisory jurisdiction. Accordingly, the present petition, being
devoid of merit, is dismissed.
17.The record produced by Mr. Dewakar Sharma, learned Deputy
Advocate General, shall be returned to him by the Registry against
proper receipt.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
07.08.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Yes.
Whether order is reportable? No.
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.08.07 17:12
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR No. 28/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review