The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. So much so, in the grounds of detention formulated by the respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu, there is no whisper of mention as to whether the petitioner ever suffered any arrest or evasion of arrest in FIR No. 60/2023 of Police Station Samba. The respondent No. 4 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba had put up the dossier against the petitioner in the month of December, 2025 and the detention order No. PITNDPS 74 of 2025 came to be passed on 17.12.2025 and even as on that date neither the respondent No. 4 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba nor the respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu are found to be having any clue about the status of the petitioner in a criminal case by reference to FIR No. 60/2023 of Police Station Samba as to whether he is a declared absconder in said criminal case or he actually came to be arrested and then granted bail by the criminal court. This is such an alarming factual fallacy in the entire preventive detention case of the petitioner that it leaves the entire exercise a serious suspect. If the petitioner came to be granted bail in FIR No. 173/2025 of Police Station Bari Brahmana, then how by reference to FIR No. 60/2023 of Police Station Samba the petitioner was being hold as absent is a very intriguing fact.
24. In the light of the aforesaid glaring omission on the part of the respondent No. 4 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba and the respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu in the matter of exercise of jurisdiction under the PIT NDPS Act, 1988, this Court holds the preventive detention of the petitioner as illegal and consequently sets aside/quashes the preventive detention order No. PITNDPS 74 of 2025 dated 17.12.2025 read with confirmation order No. Home/PB-V/94 of dated 23.01.2026 and consequently directs release of the petitioner from preventive detention custody of District Jail, Udhampur with immediate effect for which Superintendent to carry out the compliance of the writ hereby being issued.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
(through virtual mode from Srinagar)
Reserved on : 31.08.2026
Pronounced on : 06.11.2026
Uploaded on : 06.11.2026
Case:-
HCP No. 37/2026
Masoom Ali @ Kala, Age 26 years
S/o Dullah
R/o Rakh Barotian Tehsil Vijaypur, District Samba
through his wife namely
Bibi Begum, Age 23 years
W/o Masoom Ali
R/o Rakh Barotian, Tehsil Vijaypur, District Samba.
…..Petitioner
Through: Mr. Qadri Towkeer Nazir, Advocate &
Mr. Amjed Khan, Advocate
Vs
1. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir through Principal Secretary to Govt.,
Home Department, Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2. Chairman Advisory Board,
Constituted under the Prevention of Illicit in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1999 Mini Secretariat, Jammu.
3. Divisional Commissioner, Jammu.
4. Senior Superintendent of Police Samba.
5. Superintendent, District Jail Udhampur.
.…. Respondents
Through: Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG with
Ms. Nazia Fazal, Assisting Counsel.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAHUL BHARTI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
The petitioner is a preventive detention detenue undergoing
preventive detention custody under the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 (“PIT NDPS
HCP No. 37/2026
Act, 1988” in short) being detained in the District Jail, Udhampur
with effect from 10.01.2026.
02.
From his said preventive detention confinement, the
petitioner acting through his wife – Bibi Begum, came forward with
the present writ petition filed on 15.05.2026 after having spent four
months out of one year prescribed period of custody being lodged in
the District Jail, Udhampur.
03.
In this writ petition, the petitioner has come forward
seeking a writ of habeas corpus for quashment of his preventive
detention custody as ordered by the respondent No. 3 - Divisional
Commissioner, Jammu, in terms of an order No. PITNDPS 74 of
2025 dated 17.12.2025, whereby the petitioner’s reported alleged
state of activities were reckoned by the respondent No. 3 - Divisional
Commissioner, Jammu to warrant the preventive detention of the
petitioner in order to prevent him from indulging in state of
activities falling within the scope of mischief of PIT NDPS Act, 1988.
04.
The case for preventive detention of the petitioner was, in
fact, processed and put forth by the respondent No. 4 – Sr.
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba who, vide his letter No.
Legal/PIT-NDPS/25/3875-78 dated 11.12.2025, submitted a
dossier stating therein that the petitioner – Masoom Ali @ Kala R/o
Rakh Barotian, Tehsil Vijaypur, District Samba was found in
continuous illegal activities of drug peddling.
HCP No. 37/2026
05.
In said dossier, the petitioner’s criminal antecedents came
to be highlighted to persuade the respondent No. 3 – Divisional
Commissioner, Jammu to order the preventive detention of the
petitioner.
06.
The respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu
on his part came to formulate the grounds of detention by referring
himself to the alleged stage of activities of the petitioner as adversely
reported in the dossier submitted by the respondent No. 4 – Sr.
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba.
07.
In the grounds of detention the respondent No. 3 –
Divisional Commissioner, Jammu came to refer to the list of
criminal cases in which the petitioner has come to be booked for his
trial.
08.
In this regard, first reference made is to criminal case
under FIR No. 46/2023 registered by the Police Station Samba for
alleged commission of offences under section 8/21 of Narcotic
Drugs & Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (“NDPS Act, 1985” in
short), in which case, the petitioner is said to have been put up for
trial going on before the criminal court of law wherein the petitioner
came to be admitted to bail.
09.
Next reference in terms of the petitioner’s criminal
antecedents is with respect to his involvement in criminal case
under FIR No. 60/2023 again registered by the Police Station
Samba for alleged commission of offences under section 8/21/29 of
HCP No. 37/2026
NDPS Act, 1985. In this case also, the petitioner is said to have been
challaned in absentia.
10.
The petitioner’s 3rd involvement in the criminal case is in
FIR No.173/2025 registered by the Police Station Bari Brahmana
for alleged commission of offences under section 8/21/25/29 of
NDPS Act, 1985 highlighted in which case also the petitioner is
reported to have been challaned to undergo trial but earning bail
from the court which upon challenged for the sake of cancellation
resulted in failure by virtue of a court order dated 04.12.2025,
whereafter the District Police switched over to book the petitioner
under preventive detention custody.
11.
The preventive detention warrant came to be executed
upon the petitioner by SI Romesh Chander of Police Station Bari
Brahmana who is said to have delivered a 47 leaves compilation of
detention warrant, notice of detention, grounds of detention, copies
of FIRs, statements and other related documents to the petitioner on
10.01.2026 and reading over the documents with their contents in
English but explaining to the petitioner in Dogri/Gojri/Urdu as
understood by the petitioner.
12.
The petitioner is said to have been informed of his right to
make a representation against the preventive detention to the
Government.
13.
The petitioner’s preventive detention case was referred to
the Advisory Board for its opinion which came to be tendered on
HCP No. 37/2026
20.01.2026 holding the petitioner’s preventive detention to be
based on justifiable grounds thereby facilitating issuance of Govt.
Order No. Home/PB-V/94 of 2026 dated 23.01.2026 confirming
the preventive detention of the petitioner and ordering his detention
for a period of one year with effect from 10.01.2026 till 09.01.2027
to be kept lodged in the District Jail, Udhampur.
14.
The petitioner is said to have made representation/s,
through his wife, to the Principal Secretary to Govt., Home
Department, UT of J&K, to the Advisory Board and also to the
respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu all sent
through registered post.
15.
In his writ petition, the petitioner has assailed his
preventive detention on the grounds as set out in para 5 by terming
his detention as illegal, arbitrary and unconstitutional, ordered in
utter disregard to the settled principles governing preventive
detention.
16.
The petitioner has alleged that the respondent No. 3 –
Divisional Commissioner, Jammu and the respondent No. 1 – UT of
Jammu & Kashmir have acted mechanically without any application
of mind and literally following the dictates of the sponsoring agency
without any independent or subjective satisfaction exercised at their
respective end, but only to circumvent the bail orders granted in
favour of the petitioner by the criminal court seized of the criminal
trial against the petitioner.
HCP No. 37/2026
17.
The petitioner has alleged that his right to representation
has been seriously jeopardized by an omission on the part of the
respondent No. 3 to apprise the petitioner as to before whom the
representation was to be made from the end of the petitioner and
the timeline for making the same. The petitioner submits that his
wife had sent postal mode representation on 13.05.2026 which
received no response whatsoever from the respondents No. 1, 2 &
3s’ end.
18.
In
the
counter
affidavit
filed
on
25.07.2026,
the
respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu has borrowed
textual and contextual support from the grounds of detention
formulated by him in support of detention order No. PITNDPS 74 of
2025 dated 17.12.2025 passed by him.
19.
The thrust of the learned counsel for the petitioner in
assailing the preventive detention custody slapped upon the
petitioner is that it is meant to overreach the earning of bail by the
petitioner on the merits of the case thereby leaving the District
Police upset and, thus, in order to serve a beforehand punishment
unto the petitioner, case was processed for seeking the preventive
detention of the petitioner and got the favour from the respondent
No. 3’s end.
20.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that there is a
total non-application of mind on the part of the respondent No. 3 –
Divisional Commissioner, Jammu who is alleged to have acted with
HCP No. 37/2026
a closed mind and more like a post-office to the respondent No. 4 –
Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba.
21.
This Court, while examining the facts as cited in the
dossier and reproduced and referred in the grounds of detention,
comes across with an informed impression that the placement of the
petitioner under preventive detention custody is a counter action to
the indulgence of ordinary criminal court of land in granting bail in
favour of the petitioner and, thus, the respondent No. 4 – Sr.
Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba intended to overreach the
bail granting criminal court/s in favour of the petitioner without
bothering labour at his end to set up a case before the same very
criminal court for seeking cancellation of bail granted in favour of
the petitioner.
22.
If the District Police of Samba did not have a conviction to
consider and claim cancellation of bail granted in favour of the
petitioner from the ordinary criminal court of law seized of trial of
the petitioner by reference to FIR No. 46/2023 of the Police Station
Samba & FIR No. 173/2025 of the Police Station Bari Brahmana,
then on what factual basis the petitioner came to be reckoned as a
person deserving of suffering preventive detention custody is
something which leave this Court puzzled.
23.
So much so, in the grounds of detention formulated by the
respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu, there is no
whisper of mention as to whether the petitioner ever suffered any
HCP No. 37/2026
arrest or evasion of arrest in FIR No. 60/2023 of Police Station
Samba. The respondent No. 4 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP),
Samba had put up the dossier against the petitioner in the month of
December, 2025 and the detention order No. PITNDPS 74 of 2025
came to be passed on 17.12.2025 and even as on that date neither
the respondent No. 4 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba
nor the respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu are
found to be having any clue about the status of the petitioner in a
criminal case by reference to FIR No. 60/2023 of Police Station
Samba as to whether he is a declared absconder in said criminal
case or he actually came to be arrested and then granted bail by the
criminal court. This is such an alarming factual fallacy in the entire
preventive detention case of the petitioner that it leaves the entire
exercise a serious suspect. If the petitioner came to be granted bail
in FIR No. 173/2025 of Police Station Bari Brahmana, then how by
reference to FIR No. 60/2023 of Police Station Samba the petitioner
was being hold as absent is a very intriguing fact.
24.
In the light of the aforesaid glaring omission on the part of
the respondent No. 4 – Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Samba
and the respondent No. 3 – Divisional Commissioner, Jammu in the
matter of exercise of jurisdiction under the PIT NDPS Act, 1988, this
Court holds the preventive detention of the petitioner as illegal and
consequently sets aside/quashes the preventive detention order No.
PITNDPS 74 of 2025 dated 17.12.2025 read with confirmation
order
No.
HCP No. 37/2026
Home/PB-V/94
of
dated 23.01.2026
and
consequently directs release of the petitioner from preventive
detention custody of District Jail, Udhampur with immediate effect
for which Superintendent to carry out the compliance of the writ
hereby being issued.
25.
Disposed of.
26.
Detention record in original, if any produced to be returned
back to the counsel representing the respondents.
(RAHUL BHARTI)
JUDGE
JAMMU
06.11.2026
Muneesh
HCP No. 37/2026
Whether the judgment is speaking
:
Yes / No
Whether the judgment is reportable
:
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review