The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. This Court has examined the judgment of acquitted passed by the learned trial Court and after perusing the same, this Court is of the considered opinion that the opinion formed by the learned trial Court while acquitting the respondents cannot be termed as perverse in any manner, rather the opinion formed by the learned trial Court is possible and plausible. It is settled law that while dealing with the acquittal appeal, the appellate Court cannot substitute the view of the learned trial Court with its own view, particularly, when the opinion formed by the learned trial Court is plausible or possible.
18. In view of the above, this Court does not find any reason to show indulgence and, as such, this appeal is found to be devoid of any merit and the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 24
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRAA No. 45/2008
Date of pronouncement: 12.11.2026
Date of uploading: 16.11.2026
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
State
Through: Mr. P.D. Singh. Dy. AG
vs
1. Romesh Kumar S/o Ram Lal
2. Raj Kumar S/o Jagan Nath both residents of
Chanderbagha Haridwar Kshanchan Dehradun,
Uttaranchal
3. Balbir Chand alias Beeru S/o Paras Ram R/o
Pargwal Akhnoor
4. Dev Raj alias Devi S/o Basant Ram R/o Karyal
Pallanwala, Tehsil Akhnoor.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. L.K. Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Mohit Kumar, Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This acquittal appeal is directed against the judgment dated
14.03.2008 recorded by the Court of 1 st Additional Sessions Judge,
Jammu [“the trial Court”] in case titled “State vs. Romesh Kumar and
Others”, whereby the respondents have been acquitted of of the
charges for the commission of offences under Section 8/21 of the
NDPS Act.
2.
The State has come up in appeal against the aforesaid judgment
thereby assailing the same on the ground that the learned trial Court
has acquitted the respondents erroneously despite the fact that the
CRAA No. 45/2008
prosecution had led cogent evidence regarding commission of offence
by the respondents.
3.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the
record.
4.
The story as projected by the prosecution is that a Naka was laid at
Rajpura Chungi on 04.06.2005 and a vehicle had approached from
Akhnoor side at about 08:50 AM. Two persons came down from the
vehicle and fled towards Ganesh Marble Shop and were apprehended
by Naka party from the bushes and they disclosed their identities as
Romesh Kumar and Raj Kumar. Romesh Kumar was having a
briefcase whereas the other accused Raj Kumar was having a bag with
him. During the search of briefcase and bag, 1 kg and 40 grams each
of heroin was recovered from bag and briefcase. Docket was sent
through PW-Nishant Sharma for registration of case to Police Station
Nowabad. During enquiry they disclosed that they had procured the
drugs from Balbir Chand and Dev Raj residents of village Pargwal and
from them also 1 kg 40 grams each of heroin was recovered. They too
were arrested and after completing the formalities, the charge sheet for
commission of offence under Section 8/21 of the NDPS Act was filed
on 02.08.2005 against the respondents. The respondents came to be
charged for commission of offence under Section 8/21 of the NDPS
Act in terms of order dated 27.10.2005. The prosecution led its
evidence, whereas the respondents did not lead any. After hearing the
parties, learned trial Court acquitted the respondents. In order to
appreciate as to whether the learned trial Court has rightly appreciated
CRAA No. 45/2008
the evidence or not, it is deemed proper to have a brief resume of the
evidence led by the prosecution.
5.
PW Nishant Sharma (PSO to SHO) has stated that a Naka was laid at
Rajpura Mangotrian road on 04.06.2005. Two persons alighted from a
vehicle and started running towards bushes. Romesh Kumar had a
briefcase with him. The accused were chased and caught. On opening
of briefcase, a white coloured bag and clothes were found. A drug
officer was called, who identified the matter. It was disclosed by these
two persons that they had a meeting with two persons at Pargwal. He
along with SHO and other police officials went to Pargwal and found
two persons sitting under a tree outside the village. SP Basant Kumar
was called on spot by the SHO. Head constable searched those two
persons and identity cards and money were recovered. Romesh Kumar
Bhat identified the other material seized from both the accused which
was weighed and found to be 01 kg 400 grams, whereas from the other
seized material weighing 01 kg 40 gram, five grams each was
extracted for the purpose of sample. SHO gave an option to the
accused for their search from Magistrate or Gazetted Officer and
prepared the papers which bear his signatures. Seizure memos were
also prepared regarding Balbir Chand and Dev Raj. During crossexamination, he stated that he does not know the registration number
of the vehicle from which two persons alighted and there were many
passengers in the bus. Ajay Kohli and Sunil Dutt caught hold of
persons who had fled from spot. The papers were prepared on spot
near Gypsy No. 9689-JK02T. Police proceeded from that place
CRAA No. 45/2008
towards Pargwal. None from the Police team went to police station.
The accused who were earlier caught, also accompanied the police and
showed them the way. No police personnel from Akhnoor or police
post were called on spot. The proceedings were conducted in presence
of SP. Two persons were present under a tree and did not try to flee on
seeing the police and other two accused. Sunil Dutt HC searched those
two persons on the directions of SP. Neither any civilian was present
on spot nor any shopkeeper was summoned.
6.
PWs Ashok Kumar and Ganesh Kumar turned hostile and despite
cross-examination no incriminating material could be extracted from
them.
7.
PW Romesh Chander Bhat has stated that on instructions of Inspector,
Gian Chand, he went to Paloura Chungi and brought drug detection
kit, as two persons had been apprehended and powder like substance
was recovered from them. He along with one NCB personnel reached
the spot along with weighing scale and drug detection kit. SHO Gian
Chand showed him two packets and asked him to identify the
substance. The packet weighed 1.40 kgs and having identity mark 222.
On checking the substance, it was found to be heroin. 05 grams each
of heroin as sample was extracted from the packets and seal of NCB
was fixed over the same. The accused disclosed that the drug was
obtained from two persons from Akhnoor and was to be delivered to
one Sham Pandit at Delhi. Accused were arrested and brought to
Nowabad Police Station, thereafter the police team headed by SSP
Basant Kumar proceeded towards Pargwal at 01:30 PM. Two accused
CRAA No. 45/2008
were arrested from Pargwal village and two packets were seized from
them, having 999 and 555 marks on them. The packets contained
drugs weighing 01 kg 40 grams each. Again 05 grams of heroin as
sample was extracted from each packet and samples were sealed. The
seizures from Dev Raj and Balbir Chand were prepared in police
station. During cross-examination it is stated that when the police was
questioning Raj Kumar and Romesh Kumar, he reached on spot. The
articles were not seized in his presence though sealed in his presence.
SP Basant Kumar was present on spot when the articles were seized.
The seizure memos are not correct to the extent that the articles were
seized in his presence. He obtained seal from Satish Sharma and
returned the same to him. Thereafter, the seal remained under the
control of Satish Sharma. The kit was once used in Domana Police
Station in another case. The police team had reached prior to him and
accused along with the articles were brought on spot by the police.
The documents were prepared in Nowabad Police Station. Munshi had
prepared the documents at 5/6 PM on the day of occurrence.
8.
PW Haji Mohd Hussain states that he re-sealed ten packets on
06.06.2005 and issued certificate for the same. During crossexamination it is stated that he neither weighed nor opened the sealed
packets.
9.
PW Basant Kumar stated that he was posted as ASP, Jammu (Rural)
on 04.06.2005. At 10 AM SHO Nowabad sent a message from
Pargwal that two persons had been detained and are required to be
searched. He reached on spot at 01:45 PM where two accused had
CRAA No. 45/2008
been detained at open place near sawmill. SHO asked the accused if
they wanted to be searched by Magistrate or Gazetted Officer. Option
notice shown to witness did not bear his signature. He conducted
search of HC Sunil Dutt who in turn carried search of two accused. A
packet was recovered from one person and another packet was
recovered from dub of Mehra. NCB Personnel checked the material
and the same was found to be heroin. NCB Personnel also weighed the
article and lifted sample of five gram each. No civilian came on spot
despite request. Seizure memo was signed by him. During crossexamination it is stated that it is wrong to state that he was in office
from 10:00 AM to 02 PM. He did not take any independent witness
along with him or summoned BSF or Army personnel. He does not
remember if Chowki Officer was called on spot. He does not
remember as to who prepared the seizure memos and also whether the
samples were taken on paper. He did not sign the samples.
10.
PW Sunil Dutt stated that he along with others had laid naka at
Rajpura Chungi on 04.06.2025 at 09:00 AM and were checking the
vehicles. Two persons alighted from bus, coming from Akhnoor, and
fled towards other side of the road. They were chased and caught by
police from bushes behind Ganesh Marble shop. One of them had
attaché and other had bag with him. They disclosed their names as
Ramesh Kumar and Raj Kumar. Ramesh Kumar was having an attaché
and Raj Kumar was having a bag. SHO searched Romesh Kumar and
found clothes and plastic packets from attaché and on finding some
suspicious material, he called NCB people on spot. NCB people
CRAA No. 45/2008
checked the articles with kit and found the same as heroin and weight
of the article was found to be 01 kg and 40 grams. From the bag of Raj
Kumar, same quantity of article was found. Five grams of heroin as
sample was extracted by NCB people from each packet. The articles
were seized and were sealed with ring. He admitted contents and that
he signed the seizure memos. The accused in turn disclosed that they
had procured the contraband from Dev Raj and Balbir resident of
Pargwal. Both of them were caught on spot. SHO gave an option to
them for their search before the Magistrate or Gazetted Officer and the
accused opted for Gazetted Officer. SHO sent wireless message to
ASP (Rural) Basant Kumar who reached the spot, as the accused opted
to be searched by Gazetted Officer. In his presence search was
conducted and 1.40 grams of heroin was found in plastic bag and cloth
from dub. The seizure memos were prepared, which bear his signature.
The packets were sealed and brought to police station. During crossexamination, it is stated that naka was laid on right side of road
leading towards Akhnoor and the naka party was on the left side of the
road. The bushes from where the accused were apprehended, were 50
yards away from the naka. He had not seen attaché and bag in the
court. NCB team was called on spot by the SHO after the accused
were searched. The IO conducted the proceedings. The party
proceeded directly to Pargwal and it is wrong to state that police party
came back to police station. It is wrong to state that seizure memos
were prepared in police station. ASP Basant Kumar was summoned on
spot from Pargwal. He does not remember as to who prepared the
CRAA No. 45/2008
seizure memos. He does not know to whom the seal belonged to. He
does not know if anyone from Naka, shops or panch or sarpanch was
called on spot. SHO gave an option to the accused. Option notice was
neither written by him nor by SHO.
11.
PW Rohit Koul had proved the FSL report.
12.
PW Gian Chand Sharma (IO) has stated that on 04.06.2005 he along
with other police personnel had laid naka at Rajpura. Two persons
came down from the bus, which was coming from Akhnoor and they
had bag and attaché with them. They disclosed their names as Ramesh
Chander and Raj Kumar. Some powder like substance was found
wrapped in cloth, which was discovered from bag and attaché case. He
suspected that powder was heroin. NCB officials were called on spot,
who detected the material as heroin with the drug detection kit. He
sent docket for lodging of FIR through constable Nishant Kumar. The
docket bears his signature. The material was weighed by NCB
officials and five gram each was extracted as samples from packets
and samples were sealed and the seal was given to Ashok Kumar on
supurdnama. Both the accused disclosed that they had procured the
articles from Balbir Chand and Dev Raj from Pargwal and co-accused
had more heroin with them. He then went to Pargwal and found the
accused sitting under Safeda tree. The accused were given an option to
be searched by Gazetted or police officer. Gazetted Officer of police
was summoned on spot. The heroin was found in plastic bags from
dub of accused and was weighing 01 kg and 40 grams. From the total
05 grams of heroin was extracted as sample and was seized. He stated
CRAA No. 45/2008
that the documents were prepared on spot by him. The witness
identified the seized material in the court. During cross-examination,
he stated that both the persons fled towards down side after crossing
the road. Krishan Chand and Vijay Koul who chased accused are not
cited as witnesses in the charge-sheet. The reference to bag and attaché
has not been made in the docket. The signatures of accused were not
obtained on the seizure memos. The accused disclosed, in presence of
Ashok Kumar, Romesh Chander Bhat and Ganesh about presence of
co-accused at Pargwal. After obtaining option from accused at 01:05
PM, Bsant Kumar, SP Rural was sent a message through PCO situated
at Pargwal Market. SP reached on spot at 01:45 PM. The people from
vicinity were called, but they refused, as recorded in the case diary,
but their names are not mentioned in the file. The police returned to
police station at 02:45 PM. The packets were not produced before the
Naib Tehsildar when remand of accused was obtained. Bashir Ahmed,
Malkhana in-charge has not been cited as witness. He has not
mentioned about removing of packets and sample packets from
malkhana in the record. He is witness to occurrence and investigated
the case as well. He did not inform his superior officers of the
proceedings. The letter dated 06.06.2005 from SSP West to Director
FSL does not carry impression of seal.
13.
The record depicts that in the seizure memo qua the accused Raj
Kumar and Romesh Kumar, besides other official witnesses, PW
Ganesh Kumar and Ashok Kumar have been cited as witnesses who
were independent witnesses. Both these witnesses have not supported
CRAA No. 45/2008
the prosecution story and turned hostile. PWs Sunil Dutt, Nishant
Kumar and Gian Chand Sharma have deposed about the recovery of
the contraband from the bag and the attaché which were in possession
of the accused Raj Kumar and Romesh Kumar, but surprisingly in the
docket in EXPW-GC there is no reference of bag and attaché rather it
is mentioned that from the possession of both the accused one packet
each was recovered. If the contraband was recovered from the bag and
attaché in possession of the accused Raj Kumar and Romesh Kumar,
then the reference must have been made in the docket EXPW-GC
which is the first document pursuant to which FIR was registered by
the police station. It casts a dent upon the story projected by the
prosecution regarding the recovery of contraband from the accused Raj
Kumar and Romesh Kumar.
14.
Record depicts that FIR No. 88 of 2005 was registered on 04.06.2005
at 10:00 AM and as per the statement made by PW Gian Chand
Sharma, docket was prepared and sent through Constable Nishant
Kumar for registration of FIR whereas PW Nishant Kumar in his
deposition has categorically stated that the seizure proceedings were
conducted by the Investigating Officer near Gypsy No. 9689-JK02T
which took 30 minutes and, thereafter, the police proceeded towards
Pargwal at 10:30 AM and none from the team went to the police
station, as such doubt is created with regard to the registration of FIR
at 10:00 AM. This is also a material fact which cannot be ignored.
15.
The prosecution witnesses have also given the divergent versions with
regard to the apprehending of the accused, namely Balbir Chand and
CRAA No. 45/2008
Dev Raj from Pargwal. PW Gian Chand Sharma (IO) has stated that
when he went to Pargwal, he found the co-accused sitting under the
Safeda tree, who tried to flee, but police overpowered them whereas
PW Nishant Sharma has stated that the accused did not try to flee from
the spot. More so, PW-Romesh Chander has stated that the accused
were arrested from Pargwal village, but had not specified the place
whereas PW-Basant Kumar had deposed that the accused were at an
open place near a Sawmill and he further states that at 10:00 AM,
SHO sent message from Pargwal that two persons were detained and
required to be searched. Further, PW Romesh Chander Bhat has stated
that seizure memos were prepared by the Police Station Nowabad
which also creates doubt about the authenticity of alleged seizures
affected from the accused. PW Sunil Dutt has too not specified the
exact location of the arrest of the accused. These different versions of
the prosecution witnesses have also caused dent in the prosecution
case.
16.
Last but not the least there is no evidence that after the contraband was
allegedly recovered from the accused persons, the same was kept in
safe custody. The record depicts that the seizure were effected on
04.06.2005 and packets were taken before the Tehsildar on 06.06.2005
for re-sealing. There is nothing on record to show as to where the
samples were kept on 04.06.2005, 05.06.2005 and 06.06.2005. Neither
the register of Malkhana has been placed on record nor in-charge
Malkhana has been has been examined to prove the safe custody of the
seized contraband as well as samples.
17.
CRAA No. 45/2008
This Court has examined the judgment of acquitted passed by the
learned trial Court and after perusing the same, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the opinion formed by the learned trial Court
while acquitting the respondents cannot be termed as perverse in any
manner, rather the opinion formed by the learned trial Court is
possible and plausible. It is settled law that while dealing with the
acquittal appeal, the appellate Court cannot substitute the view of the
learned trial Court with its own view, particularly, when the opinion
formed by the learned trial Court is plausible or possible.
18.
In view of the above, this Court does not find any reason to show
indulgence and, as such, this appeal is found to be devoid of any merit
and the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
19.
Record of the trial Court be sent back.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
Jammu
12.11.2026
Manik
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review