Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/nandyala-narendar-reddy-vs-malkjagiri-municipal-corporation-20260724/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Constitutional

Nandyala Narendar Reddy vs Malkjagiri Municipal Corporation

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Telangana High Court
Date
24 July 2026
Case No.
WP 24243/2026
Result
Disposed
Bench
B.vijaysen Reddy
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

17. Pending consideration of the regularization application of the petitioner dated 06.06.2026, status quo, obtaining as on today shall be maintained in respect of the structures standing on the subject property. As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in the writ petition stand closed. No order as to costs.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

[ 3183 J IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) FRIDAY, THE TWENry FOURTH DAY OF JULY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B.VIJAYSEN REDDY WRIT PETITION NO: 24243 OF 2O26 Between: Nandyala Narendar Reddy, S/o. Nandyala Mohan Reddy, aged about 46 years, Occupation. Business, R/o. H.No.3-4- 639142, Anitha Nagar Colony, Mansoorabad, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District. .....PETITIONER AND 1. Malkjagiri Municipal Corporation, rep. by its Commissioner, near Ayyappa Swamy Temple, Geetha Nagar, Hyderabad 2. The Deputy Commissioner, Malkajgiri Municipal Corporation, Circle No.9, Uppal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District. 3. The Zonal Commissioner, Malkajgiri Municipal Corporation, Uppal Zone, Uppal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District. 4. The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Municipal Administration and Urban Development Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. .....RESPONDENTS Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate writ directing the respondent corporation to regularize the unauthorized construction of the building comprising of cellar, stilt plus five upper floors in 1000 sq. yards of plot in Plot No.62 of Uppal Bhagayath HMDA Layout (unauthorized/deviations admeasuring 911.72 sq. meters) on payment of such penalty/fine/compensation as the Honourable Court may specify and on payment thereof direct the respondents to regularize the entire building and issue Occupation Certificate (OC) to the petitioner as a permanent measure and further direct the respondenrrs not to interfere in any manner with the possession and enjoyment of the petitioner n respect of the said building (in which rhe Hyderabad Law College is running). l.A.NO:1 OF 2026 Petition under section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in suppo( cf the petrtion, the High court may be pleased to direct the respondent corporation to regularize the unauthorized portion of the constructions (namely setback deviations to the extent of g11 ]2 sq. meters) in construction of the building situated in Plot No.62 of Uppal Bhagayath village, Uppal Mandal, Medchal - Malkajgiri District consisting of cellar, stilt plus five upper floors in land admeasuring 1000 sc. yards plot on such terms and conditions as the Honourable Court may direct pendrng disposal of the wnt petition. Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI VEDULA VENKATARAMANA, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR M/s BHARAOWAJ ASSOCTATES Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 3 : SRI SRINIVAS RAO PACHWA, SC FOR MALKAJGTRT MUNtCtpAL CORpORATTON (MMC) Counsel for the Respondent No.4 : Gp FOR MCPL ADMN AND URBAN DEV The Court made the fottowing ORDER HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B. VI.IAYST]N REDDY WRIT PE TITON No.24243 o F 2026 DAT E:24-07-2026 Between: Mr. NandYala Narender ReddY ... Petitioner AND Malkaj giri Municipal Corporatron, Rep. by its Commissioner. Near Ayyappa Swamy Temple. Geetha Nagar' Hyderabad .., Respondents ORDER:(ORAL) Heard Mr. Vedula Vetlkataramana, iearned senior appearing for M/s. Bhaladrvaj Associates' learned counsel' counsel ftrr the petitioner and Mr. Srinivas Rao Pachwa' learned standing cot-itlsel forMatkajgiriMunicipalCorporation(MMC),appearinglbr responder-rt Nos. I to 3 2. Leamed standing counsel for MMC submitted circumstances this Court disposed of W'P that in similar No 13424 of 2026 b1' order dated 17.06'2026 directing MMC to consider thc l rr.lilarizarion r,il-ir1ic:rLion subiect to the condition of the petitioner th:tein dt-positrru c()sts. ln the instant case trlere are serlous r-1cr iations rnacic i I-earneri .irn,(l counsel submitted thal reascnable costs may 1-'e it,.t1,.oserl !)Ir l. br thc pctitioner to the satrctioned 1llan. irJ i)(:iir.iollel flggqrrdirrg i r,: sr-rt-.rniss ions of both the leamed counse[, tIt . ri rit peli' 1,11 clisposecl o1-. directing respondeut No.l to !(,:r'iidcr. thc rt-'rrrla izrrtion application dated 18.05.1026130.05.2026 oi ,hc 1-rctitioncr :uirnrittccl uncler Sections -155-A and 455-AA of the (ir',.)atr-r Ilrclerlhrcl \lurricipal Corporation Act i9j5 in respect of t ),:' i)roperl) l-r,: rrir !. Plot No.6ll adnrelisulirrg 101)0 square irards sitLLatcrl ai Lipn.rl )hagevath llMI)A lavout. and pass orders, ln lu!Lor'(lilnc. rr i lr ler, . rr issuing notice to the petitioner, and all other c(in,t-.t'ned intr-r'.iteii l)et s()ns. hr uflbrdinu ol)ltoltunit)/ of hcarine to rlrrr:r. sub.ject ,r th,' e ,rnrlition ol petitionct. pay ing fbllowing costs l;tirin rr perioii ,rl'i.ro (l)uecks ll ortt the clate ol.r,:ceipt o1'a cop1, otilris ordcr' J (i) A sum of Rs.4,00,000/- (Rupees foLrr lakhs only) to the Matkaj gili Municipal Corporation. (ii) A sum of Rs.2.00,000/- (Rupees nvo lakhs only) to the Telangana High Court Adr ocates Association (THCAA)' (iii) A sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- (Rupees one lakh fifty thousand only) to the Court Masters & Personal Secretaries to Hon'blc J udges Association. 5. Pending consideration of the regularization application ofthe petitioner dated 28.05'2016/30.05.2026, stattts 4zro, obtaining as on today shall be maintained in respect ofthe structures standing on the subject propeftY. Asa sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in the writ petition stand closed' MEMO RANDU M OF COSTS Rs. i) Ps. Costs Quantified bY Hon'ble Court (That the Petitioner herein and Counsel for the Petitioner are directed to PaY costs of Rs.4,00,000/- (RuPees Four Lakhs OnlY) in favour of the Malkajgiri Municipal Corporation with in a Period of two weeks from the date of receiPt 4,00,000 L-d) ii) Costs Quantified by Hon'ble Court (That the Petitirner herein and Counsel for th: petitioner are directed to oay costs of Rs 2,00,0001 (Rupees Two Lakhs Only) in favour of Telangana High Court Advocates Association (TH(IAA) High Court for the State of Telangana, High Court Buildingls, Hyderabad within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt. 2,00,000 iii) Costs Quantified by Hon'ble Court (That the Petitioner herein and Counsel for the petitioner are pay costs of Rs.1 50 000t (R.rpees One Lakh fifty thousand O rly) in favour of Court Masters and personal Secretaries to t-lon'ble Judges Association within a period of two weeks frorr the date of receipt. directed to 1,50,000 TOTAL 7,50,000 SD/. B. REKHA RANI //TRUE COPY// ASSISTANT REGISTRAR SECTION OFFICER To The Commissioner, t\talkjagiri Municipal Corporation, near Ayyappa Swamy Temple, Geetha Nagar. Hyderabad. The Deputy commisr;ioner, Malkajgiri Municipar corporation, circre No.g, Uppal Medchal-Malkajgirr District. The Zonal Commissioner,. Malkajgiri Municipal Corporation, Uppal Zone, Uppal. Medchal-Malka grri District. 4 The Principal Secretary Administration and Urban Development ^Municipal Department. Secretarrzri State of Telangana at Hyderabad. 5. The secretary, Telangana High court Advocates Association (THCAA) High Court for the State of Telangana, High Court Buildings, Hyderabad 6. The secretary, cou( Masters and personar secretariei to Hon'bre Judges Association, High Court for the State of Telangana, Hyderabad _ T Two CCs to GP FOR MCPL ADMN AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT, High \ ', Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT] 8. One CC to M/s BHARADWAJ ASSOCTATES, Advocate tOpUCl 9. One CC to SRt SR|N|VAS RAO PACHWA, SC FOR MALKAJGTRT MUNICIPAL CORPORATTON (MMC), Advocate (OPUC) 10.Two CD Copies 11-(Along with a copy of the order dated 1r-6-2026 in wp.No.18424 of 2026 to this order) SA GJP C.C. TODAY HIGH COURT DATED: 2410712026 ORDER WP.No.24243 of 2026 ( ) () !) 1Hl : SrA r € o^ z l) 3 1 JUL 2026 ..\ r-.r i-s DISPOSING OF THE W.P WITHOUT COSTS, b ZI o I * HONOURABLE SR] JUSTICE B. VIJAYSEN REDDY + WRIT PETITION No.18424 OF 2026 %" Date: 17.06.2026 # Aruna Agarwal ... Petitioner $ The State ofTelangana, Rep. By its Principal Secretary, Municipal Administration and Urban Development Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, and others ... Respondents ! Counsel for the Petitioner : Mr. Thoom Srinivas ^ Counsel for the respondents : Mr. Laxmaiah Kanchani, learned standing counsel for respondent Nos.2 to 4. < GIST: > HEADNOTE ? CASESREFERRED: 1. Vellore Citizens' Welfare Forum v. Union of India [(1996) 5 SCC 647] J HIGTI COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE B. VIJAYSEN REDDY WRI'I PETITON No.18424 OF 2026 DATE: 17-06-2026 Betrveen: NIrs. Aruna Agan" a ... Petitioner AND 'Ihe State of Te langana Rep. By its Principal Secretary, Municipal Administration and Urban Development Department, Secretariat, Hyderabrid. and others ... Respondents ORDER This ririt petition is filed b1, the petitioner seeking to declare the action of respordcnts in not considering her lepresentation dated 06.06.2026 submittcd under Sections ,155-A and 455-AA of the Greater Hvderabad Municipal Corporation Act 1!)55 (for short 'GHl\{C Act') IN respect of the property bearing Plot No.30, Block-8, Sector-lll, admcasuring 598 square yards ln Survey No. 108 siruared ar R,rad No.23, Alkapur Township, Neknampur Village, Gandipet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, as being illegal and arbitrary 2. Heard Mr. Thoom Srinivas, learned counsel for the petitioner, and Mr. Laxmaiah Kanchani, leamed standing counsel for respondent Nos.2 to 4, and perused the material on record 3. It is stated petitioner is the owner of the property bearing Plot No.30, Block-B, Sector-lll, Survey No. 108 admeasuring 598 square yards siruated at Road No.23, Alkapur Township, Neknampur Village, Gandipet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, i.e., subject property. Petitioner constructed Ground + two (2) upper floors on the subject property about twenty fle (25) years ago and it has been utilized for residential purpose 4. It is submitted that owing to joint family requirements, petitioner constructed additional two (2) floors and a pent house on the subject property over the existing Ground + two (2) upper floors. Respondent No.3 passed impugned speaking ordet vide No.G I /UC/TPSNRSG/S LPZ I CMC I 2026I OW3 7 dated 29.0 5 .2026 pursuant to a complaint alleging that petitioner has encroached two public roads (each admeasuring 320 feet X 25 feet at Road No.23, Alkapur Torvnship. bv constructing compound walls. That the office of respondent No.3 inspected the site and observed that petitioner rvas proceeciing with construction of 3'd, 4'h and 5'h floors and a pent house c,n existing Ground + one (I) upper floor on subject propert) contrary to the provisions of GHMC' Act and Bye- law: made there under, and directed the petitioner to forthwith stop unauthorized constnrction and remove the same within hfteen (15) days. It is lurther stated petitioner submitted representation dated 06.06.2026 to respordent No.2 under Sections 455-A and 455-AA of GHMC r\ct to rcgularize the unauthorized construction made on the subject propert). As there is inaction on the part of respondent authorities rn proce:;sing the petitioner's representation, she is constrained to approa:h this Court. MENANCE OF' UN,\UTHORIZED CONSTRUCTIONS: 6. IJnauthorized cf,nsrructions in the city of Hyderabad appear to har..e becorne a norrn rather than breach. Thousands of writ petitions are filed every year challenging the orders passed by the GHMC/Municipal authorities, whereby, building owners are directed to remove unauthorized constructions. It has become a habit in filing writ petitions even after speaking (demolition) orders have been passed for removal of unauthorized construction. In many such cases, parties are filing applications under Sections 455-4 and 455-AA of the GHMC Act for regularization of unauthorized construction and pending consideration of such regularization applications, interim orders have been passed. Courts had been taking lenient view to protect the interests of the parties, pending consideration of such regularization applications. In the counter affidavit filed by GHMC in W.P. (PIL) No.63 of 2016, in paragraph No.28 therein, it was stated that Corporation received 1,38,630 (One lakh thirty eight thousand six hundred and thirty only) applications seeking regularization of unauthorized constructions, from which it can be assumed that now there might be more than two (2) lakhs applications seeking regularization. . It is pertinent to note that this Court has not come across a single order passed regularizing unauthorized structures under Sections 455-r\ ancl 455-AA of the GHMC Act. Notwithstanding the entitlement o1-prrrties seeking regularization and their eligibility under the above t,r'o (2) provisions, in several cases building owners har ing land of about 100-200 square yards are approaching this Court seeking rcgularization of structures, as of three (3)/four (4)rfive (5) floors ,rven when building regulations (under G.O. Ms.No.l68 MA& UD dated 07.04.2012) permit maximum of Stilt (Ibr parking) - tivo (2) upper floors. The regularization under Sections 455-,,\ anl -155-AA can be done onlv if building permission can other$.ise be appror.ed as per the existing building bye-laws and zonal resulations. It is not as if for an area of 100 square vards rvherc building permission to maximum can be granted lbr Stitt - on: (l)or two (2) upper floors, the building can be regularized if four (4) or five (5) floors are constructed. which is incomprehensible 8. The permissibl,- building envelope (built-up area) as per G.O. Ms.No.l68. MA,tt,D. dated0l .04.2012 is extracted below: GREATER HYDERABA.D MUMCIPAL CORTORATION READY.RECKONE& P PtrtES PI,.ANNTNG SECTTON - TOWN [I. +.III, Rd. 5. co, M! N.. rol MA&UD, Dr' 07 Ollolarsm.Ldl PERMESIELE BIJILDNG EI{VELOPE _ !{ON.ruO}I.R!sE PLOTS uP TO 750 Sa5 iffiidr! 'iL.ldi1 @-E +{sqE !d ftY.r)Fj ffiffi iDi!5ZJal Efr_r# l r5 Md!* .ridlln aEF r ld 51r s I t D I2 ! FrEirld t! r ?3 + Yc. crc't oc@.1< r@ s...*. r. I l l 1,5 I15iE5:trllv. FstrTAr.4 B pski E& &rl il-,,ffiffi No rl lrl r aJ 6 dE Edn d {ts [dtjr rd) Fqrlliilrl gc+d da. s(.ft Ydr l{rt t4i) rl[' L'r lIiq &t iq & Fei, >5 . ccEEdr,'aU' q l. dlft Iilc)h,t6JAiFE-rft s.9 t EtE-n*r{rm=loaitr.rE'.6d'.F68'bhn6'u(6tn'hd'lnnrEldt'ar,'E.dmond a2l s.6..tr n @+d a iEitla x. dr6 -i: ihr. Hn!, F6}r! ull co{D hrs - FAi I l,l0a o.o rLyL!D5.ds -Rroe 1 .pi6; rsjiiss Is li{+^n or xilt- d o{ rr.(61 6:!eE& E\cfir! "1dl ?.s 6 d.:r &Ld.i rd lEllhl (rrai&: Noc O, r 'td' ^rlrl L;"6.r'dd *-u*,lnrr. -,o*oynzrr r0 a a-rl tuEll!* -s r.r (BJ 'm sdt. PI]IANEE AISISTANT CIIY sdl PI-A,\'IIER CHIEF CITY sd' COi/G'ISSIONER It is clear from the above that for the plots having area between 100-200 square meters (120-239 square yards), maximum height permissible is ten ( 10) meters and building permission can be sanctioned maximum for Ground + two (2) upper floors. 9. It is astonishing to notice from several cases filed in this Court that property owners having 400-600 square yards despite having permission for two (2)/three (3) floors are going for construction of extra floor without any permission. Even five floors permission is granted, still sixth (6'h) unauthorized floor construction is made and in many cases pent house is constructed. The pent house so constructed in most of the cases is with an oblique motir e tc, make it appear that terrace (unauthorized portion) is pafily c,tnstructed and for the so called vaastu or other reasons invented orlv lor seeking relief from the Court. In fact, pent houses corlstr.tcted in most of the buildings in the city are unauthorized. It is called pent house onlv to make it appear that structures over the .errace is not constructed for the entire roof but only in the parr of roof. The hidden reason however appears to be o\\'ner ol thc pIopeft) does not want such unauthorized construction to be visible fiom outside. 10. Several unaurhorized constructions in the manner discussed above are macle u ithout paying single rupee to the GHMC'Municipal authorities and only fraction of cases land up in Courts, that too because ol the r igilant neighbours ilnd sometimes by busy bodies. N'lan1' thousands of building owners have constructed unauthcnzcd floors/structures and the loss caused to local authorities i.e.. GHMCrMunicipal authorities, as the case may be is huge. It is not as if structures are made over night. When unauthorized structrlres'deviations are made, it is expected of GH\,lC/Municipality to srop the construction at the initial stages which is often not done. If unauthorized constructions go unabated then it will send a wrong message to the society. A law abiding citizen who takes permission, constructs building in accordance with sanctioned plan, gets the property assessed, pays property tax, will naturally get an impression that persons making unauthorized construction does not have any fear of law and are going scot free. Both cannot be treated equally, otherwise the wrong doer making unauthorized construction would get habituated and in future may go for another unauthorized building /construction. In the opinion of this Court, the GHMC and the Govemment also seem to be not having strict policy in tackling unauthorized constructions t 1. This Court in fact heard hundreds of cases where property owners having less than 150-100 square yards also have gone for construction of three (3) - five (5) floors and major portion of structures are unauthorized. Unfortunately Municipal authorities who are aware and supposed to be aware when building construction is commenced violating bye laws and building permission and they are bound to stop such construction, they do not take prompt action. This happens because of political or other II support people enjo'/. If unauthorized constructions go unchecked and not resulated end people are allowed to take advantage of orders in similar cas,:s in the guise of regularization under Sections 455-A and .+55- \A of GHMC Act, then it may also lead to another danger that people u'ho do not have title to property may also make unar-rthorized construction either by grabbing or encroaching private or public propefty. Eventually a person who does not have title to the propertv may construct building without any building permit from the comltctent authority. This will not only lead to a dangerous situation but rlould further lead to colossal loss to the local authorities 12. -fhc Hon'ble Srrpreme Court in Vellore Citizens, Welfare Forum v. Union of Indiar has recognized the principle "polluter pays'' in a matter relating to environmental pollution by tannery industries. On the :;ame analogy wrong doer/property owner making unauthorized construction should be penalized. The wrong doer or violator has tc, pay. Unless penalty is imposed it u,ould become habitual tbr th: u'rong doers and it r.vill lead to unhealthy ' (I 99n) -s sc(. 6-1, t2 trend and also cause huge loss to State exchequer' Unless persons making unauthorized constructions are penalized this Court feels that there will be no change in their mind set' If about five (5) years back, there were one lakh (1,00,000) unauthorized constmctions within GHMC limits (GHMC, MMC, CMC), be assumed the figures can be much more in the present it can times' l3.Theunauthorizedconstructionmadebyviolatingbuilding bye laws creates burden on the civic administration' infrastructure and environment; huge men and machinery is required to and regulate unauthorized construction and as stated remove above' there is loss to GHMC/ Municipai authorities and they are deprived of building permission fees. Thus, to curb the unauthorized construction this Court finds it necessary to impose costs There is a need to send clear message that unauthorized constructions cannot be tolerated and have to be penalized' 14. On query of this Court as to why costs should not be imposed for making unauthorized construction, leamed counsel the petitioner submitted that reasonable costs may be imposed' for 15. In the instant case, propertv ofpetitioner is admeasuring 598 square yards and tr,, o (2) floors along with pent house are unauthorizedly cons[ructed i.e., approximately about 8,000- 1 0,000 square feet is unauthorizedly constructed and the value of n.hich ll ill not be less than Rs.3-21 crores 16. In the abore circumstances, the writ petition is disposed of, directing responclent No.2 to consider the representation dated 06.06.2026 submittcrl by the petitioner under Sections 455-A and 455-AA of the GHMC Act for regularizine the unauthorized constnrct ion 'fl oors over the property bearing Plot No.30, Block -B, Sector-lII, admeasuring 598 square yards 1n Survey No.l08 situated at Road No 3. Alkapur Township, Neknampur Village, Gandipet \4andal. Ranga Reddy District, and pass orders, ln accordance with [aw, by rssuing notice to the petitioner, and all other concemed,interr:sted persons, by affording opportunity of hearing to them. subject to the condition of petitioner paying following costs (i) A sum of R:,.2,00,000/- (Rupees tu'o lakhs only) to the Cyberabad Municipal Corporation (CMC). I4 The Commissioner, Cyberabad Municipal Corporation shall utilize this amount for providing health benefits to the Class-lV employees like scavengers, sanitary workers, sweepers etc. who are appointed on contractual or outsourcing basis. (ii) A sum of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh only) to the Telangana High Court Advocates Association (THCAA). The High Court Advocates Association shall maintain separate account under the Head "Young Advocates Welfare Fund" and shall utilise the amount by framing guidelines for the benefit of young advocates having standing of less than seven (07) years. 17. Pending consideration of the regularization application of the petitioner dated 06.06.2026, status quo, obtaining as on today shall be maintained in respect of the structures standing on the subject property. As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in the writ petition stand closed. No order as to costs. B. VIJAYSEN REDDY, J June17,2026 Note: (i) LR copy to be marked (ii) Issue CC today (BO) MS

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Telangana HC judgments →