Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010177962015
2026:GAU-AS:13858
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL
PRADESH)
Case No. : MACApp./180/2015
MUSST. RABIA KHATUN and ANR
W/O MD. JAMIR ALI
2: MD. JAMIR ALI
S/O LATE FAIZUDDIN
BOTH ARE R/O VILL. KOIADAL DHANKALI
P.O. and P.S. JAGIROAD
DIST. MORIGAON
ASSAM
VERSUS
MD INTAJUL ALI and ANR
S/O MD. IRFAN ALI, R/O VILL. TELAHI BALPUKHURI, P.S. DHARAMTUL,
DIST. MORIGAON, ASSAM.
2:REGIONAL MANAGER
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
GUWAHATI REGIONAL OFFICE
ULUBARI
GUWAHATIAdvocate for the Petitioner :
Advocate for the Respondent :
MR.M TALUKDAR, MS.D KALITA
MR.N HOQUER-1, MS R D MAZUMDAR,
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
17.09.2026
ORDER
Heard Mr. M Talukdar, learned counsel for the claimants. Also
heard Ms. R D Mazumdar, learned counsel for the respondent No.
2/insurance company.
2.
Office Note dated 06.01.2020 indicates that service in respect
of the respondent No. 1 complete, however, there is no representation
on behalf of the said respondent on call.
3.
By way of this appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 as amended, the claimants are claiming enhancement of the
compensation awarded by the judgment and order dated 30.07.2014
passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Morigaon, Assam in MAC Case No. 44/2012.
4.
The brief facts of the case are that on 06.02.2012, the son of
the claimant was crossing the National Highway No. 37 at Bamfar
Dikshak near PFL Company when suddenly the vehicle owned by the
opposite party No. 1 coming from Jagiroad towards Guwahati in a rash
and negligent manner knocked down their son from the back side. As a
result, he sustained multiple grievous injuries. Immediately thereafter
he was taken to Jagiroad S.H.C. for treatment wherefrom he was
referred to GMCH, Guwahati where he died on the same day. The
deceased was 20 years of age at the time of the accident and was
earning Rs. 6,000/- per month, leaving behind his parents being the
dependent of the deceased.
5.
Accordingly, a claim petition was filed before the learned
Member, MACT, Morigaon, wherein the learned Tribunal after hearing
the parties, by judgment and order dated 30.07.2014 awarded Rs.
4,51,000/- (Rupees Four Lakh Fifty One Thousand) only with interest
@ 6% per annum from the date of filing the claim petition. The
claimants being not satisfied with the adequacy of the awarded
compensation, have preferred the instant appeal.
6.
Mr. M Talukdar, learned counsel for the claimants, referring to
the evidence on record, submits that the deceased was earning a
monthly income of Rs. 6,000/-. It is, therefore, contended that the
learned Tribunal, having assessed the monthly income of the deceased
at Rs. 4,000/-, has erred in assessing the compensation and the same
warrants interference and enhancement by this Court. Learned counsel
further submits that the learned Tribunal has also erred in not taking
into consideration the future prospects of the deceased while
computing the compensation. The deceased was aged about 20 years
at the time of the accident and, having regard to his age, at least 50%
ought to have been added to his income towards future prospects in
terms of the law laid down by the Apex Court in National
Insurance Company Limited -Vs- Pranay Sethi & Ors.,
reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680.
Learned counsel further submits that the learned Tribunal has
failed to award appropriate compensation towards loss of estate and
funeral expenses in terms of the principles laid down by the Apex
Court in Pranay Sethi (supra). It is also submitted that no amount
towards loss of consortium has been awarded to the parents of the
deceased and, therefore, the compensation under the aforesaid
conventional heads is also liable to be suitably enhanced in accordance
with law.
Learned counsel lastly submits that the interest awarded by the
learned Tribunal at the rate of 6% per annum is on the lower side and
ought to have been awarded at the rate of 9% per annum from the
date of filing of the claim petition till realization of the awarded
amount. On the aforesaid grounds, learned counsel submits that the
impugned award passed by the learned Tribunal is liable to be
modified and the compensation suitably enhanced.
In support of his submissions, learned counsel has placed
reliance upon the following decisions:
Narendra Singh -Vs- Nishant Sharma and Anr.
(i)
reported in (2015) 14 SCC 353
The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd -Vs- Niru @
(ii)
Niharika & Ors. in Special Leave Petition (C) No.
11340 of 2020.
(iii)
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd -Vs- Omenchiba,
reported in 2023 Legal Eagle (GAU) 545
(iv)
Josphine Jemes -Vs- United India Insurance Co.
Ltd and Anr. reported in 2013 (4) T.A.C. 22 (S.C.)
Waghji Laxman Aayar -Vs- Arjan Vala Ahir and
(v)
Ors. reported in 2013 (4) T.A.C. 28 (Guj)
(vi)
Golap Lata Goswami and Anr -Vs- Ajit Deka and
Ors. reported in 2016 (2) T.A.C. 896 (Gau)
(vii)
National Insurance Company Ltd. -Vs- Mithu
Singh and Ors.,
reported in 2016 (2) T.A.C. 905
(P&H)
(viii)
Mrs. Karima Begum -Vs- Badsha Bhuyan and Ors.
reported in 2018 (2) T.A.C. 198 (Gau)
7.
Per contra,
Ms. R D Mazumdar, learned counsel for the
respondent No. 2/insurance company submits that the claimants,
having failed to prove the income of the deceased by adducing cogent
and reliable evidence, the learned Tribunal was justified in assessing
the monthly income of the deceased at Rs. 4,000/-. It is contended
that the burden was upon the claimants to establish the income and
earning capacity of the deceased by leading cogent and convincing
evidence before the learned Tribunal. Since the claimants failed to
discharge the said burden and could not establish that the deceased
was earning Rs. 6,000/- per month, no interference with the finding of
the learned Tribunal on the question of income is warranted.
Learned counsel for the respondent No. 2 further submits that,
in the absence of any reliable evidence establishing the alleged income
of Rs. 6,000/- per month, the claimants are not entitled to seek
enhancement of the compensation on that basis. It is, accordingly,
submitted that the award passed by the learned Tribunal does not call
for any interference by this Court.
In support of her submissions, learned counsel for the
respondent No. 2 places reliance upon the decisions of the Apex Court
in Syed Sadiq etc. -Vs- Divisional Manager, United India
Insurance Company, reported in 2014 (1) T.A.C. 369 (S.C.),
and Rani & Ors. -Vs- National Insurance Company Ltd. &
Ors., reported in 2018 STPL 9049 SC.
8.
I have given my prudent considerations to the arguments
advanced by the learned counsels for the parties and have perused the
materials available on record. I have also duly considered the case
laws cited at the bar.
9.
The instant appeal is confined to the question as to whether
the compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal is just and
adequate, the challenge being at the instance of the claimants seeking
enhancement thereof. This Court, while exercising its appellate
jurisdiction, is, therefore, entitled to re-appreciate the evidence on
record and examine the various components on the basis of which the
compensation has been determined, so as to ascertain whether the
claimants have been awarded just compensation in accordance with
law. If, upon such examination, this Court finds that the compensation
awarded by the learned Tribunal falls short of the just compensation to
which the claimants are entitled, this Court can suitably modify and
enhance the same. It is, therefore, necessary to examine the claim for
enhancement under the respective heads in the light of the evidence
on record and the principles governing determination of compensation.
10.
Keeping the aforesaid principles in mind, let me now turn to the
materials available on record.
11.
It appears that, in order to establish the income of the
deceased, the claimants examined claimant No. 1, who is the mother
of the deceased, as PW-1. In her deposition, PW-1 stated that the
deceased was earning a sum of Rs. 6,000/- per month by carrying on
the business of selling plastic utensils. In support of the said
contention, the claimants exhibited
a
document
as
Exhibit-5,
purportedly issued by one Akbar Ali, stated to be a wholesaler of
plastic products. In the said document, Akbar Ali certified that the
deceased had been purchasing plastic utensils from his shop for about
four years and used to sell the same from village to village by cycle. He
further certified that, from the said business, the deceased used to
earn approximately Rs. 6,000/- to Rs. 7,000/- per month.
The learned Tribunal, however, assessed the monthly income
of the deceased at Rs. 4,000/- and accordingly determined his annual
income at Rs. 48,000/-. While doing so, the learned Tribunal observed
that Exhibit-5 was issued on plain paper, that there was no material on
record to establish that its author, namely, Akbar Ali, was a wholesaler
of plastic products, and that the said author was also not examined as
a witness.
12.
It is well settled that the onus lies upon the claimant to
establish the income of the deceased by adducing cogent and reliable
evidence. At the same time, in a claim for compensation arising out of
a motor accident, the Court is required to adopt a realistic approach
while determining just compensation. The Apex Court in Sunita and
Ors. -Vs- Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation and
Ors., reported in (2020) 13 SCC 486, has held that the approach of
the Tribunal should be to undertake a holistic analysis of the pleadings
and evidence by applying the principle of preponderance of
probabilities. Once the fundamental fact of occurrence of the accident
is established, the Tribunal is required to determine the quantum of
just compensation arising out of the accident and, while doing so, is
not to be strictly bound by the pleadings of the parties.
13.
In Anita Sharma and Ors. -Vs- New India Assurance
Company Limited and Anr., reported in (2021) 1 SCC 171, the
Apex Court has reiterated that, in motor accident claim proceedings,
the standard of proof is that of preponderance of probabilities and not
proof beyond reasonable doubt. It has further been observed that the
approach of the Court, while examining the evidence in such
proceedings, ought not to be akin to that adopted in a criminal trial by
insisting upon the examination of every possible or best witness.
Rather, the Court is required to analyse the material placed on record
and ascertain whether the version of the claimant is more likely than
not to be true.
The relevant paragraph of the aforesaid judgment reads as
under:
“21. Equally, we are concerned over the failure of the High
Court to be cognizant of the fact that strict principles of
evidence and standards of proof like in a criminal trial are
inapplicable in MACT claim cases. The standard of proof in
such like matters is one of preponderance of probabilities,
rather than beyond reasonable doubt One needs to be mindful
that the approach and role of courts while examining evidence
in accident claim cases ought not to be to find fault with nonexamination of some best eyewitnesses, as may happen in a
criminal trial, but, instead should be only to analyse the
material placed on record by the parties to ascertain whether
the claimant's version is more likely than not true.”
14.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present
case, it is evident that the claimants have failed to establish by cogent
and reliable evidence that the deceased was earning Rs. 6,000/- per
month. Claimant No. 1, who was examined as PW-1, stated that the
deceased was earning Rs. 6,000/- per month from the business of
plastic utensils. However, she did not state anything in her deposition
regarding the author of Exhibit-5, namely, Akbar Ali, his business, or
the basis on which the income of the deceased was certified in the said
document. Except exhibiting Exhibit-5, no evidence was adduced to
establish the credentials of its author or the correctness of the income
mentioned therein. The author of the said document was also not
examined as a witness. Thus, the claim of the claimants that the
deceased was earning Rs. 6,000/- per month cannot be accepted.
At the same time, the evidence of PW-1 regarding the
occupation of the deceased cannot be altogether disregarded. It has
come on record that the deceased was engaged in the business of
selling plastic utensils from village to village by cycle. Having regard to
the nature of his occupation and the circumstances in which such
business was being carried on, it may not be realistic to expect formal
documentary evidence reflecting his actual earnings. The income,
therefore, has to be assessed on the basis of the evidence available on
record and the probabilities arising therefrom, keeping in view the
requirement of awarding just compensation.
Considering the evidence on record in its entirety, this Court is
of the view that a monthly income of Rs. 5,000/- would be a
reasonable assessment of the income of the deceased. Accordingly,
the monthly income of the deceased is modified and enhanced from
Rs. 4,000/- to Rs. 5,000/-. The question of addition towards future
prospects and the consequential computation of loss of dependency
are considered hereinafter.
15.
Since the deceased was self-employed and was below the age
of 40 years at the time of the accident, an addition of 40% of his
income towards future prospects is required to be made in terms of
the principles laid down by the Apex Court in Pranay Sethi (supra).
The learned Tribunal, having failed to make such addition, the same is
required to be suitably modified. Accordingly, 40% of the monthly
income of Rs. 5,000/-, i.e. Rs. 2,000/-, is added towards future
prospects, thereby taking the monthly income for the purpose of
computation of loss of dependency to Rs. 7,000/-. Consequently, the
annual income, inclusive of future prospects, comes to Rs. 84,000/(Rs. 7,000/- × 12). Applying the multiplier of 18 and deducting 50%
towards the personal and living expenses of the deceased, the loss of
dependency would come to Rs. 7,56,000/- (Rs. 84,000/- × 18 × 50%).
16.
It further appears that, in terms of the principles laid down by
the Apex Court in Pranay Sethi (supra), the claimants are also
entitled to compensation under the conventional heads of loss of
estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses. The learned Tribunal
had awarded only Rs. 4,000/-, Rs. 5,000/- and Rs. 5,000/- respectively
under
the
aforesaid
heads.
The
amounts
so
awarded
being
inadequate, the same are liable to be suitably modified in accordance
with the principles laid down in Pranay Sethi (supra). Accordingly,
the amount under the head of loss of estate is enhanced to Rs.
15,000/-, loss of consortium to Rs. 40,000/- each for claimant Nos. 1
and 2, and funeral expenses to Rs. 15,000/-.
The aforesaid amount shall be enhanced at the rate of 10% in
every three year period, in terms of Pranay Sethi (supra).
Accordingly, in the facts of the present case, as the relevant period
extends to six years, the aforesaid amount shall be enhanced by 10%
on two occasions.
17.
In view of the above, the claimants are entitled to
compensation under the following heads:
Loss of dependency
Rs. 3,500/- X 12 X 18
= Rs. 7,56,000/-
Loss of consortium
Rs. 40,000/- × 2 = Rs. 80,000/Rs. 80,000/- +10%= Rs.88,000/Rs. 88,000/- + 10% = Rs. 96,800/-
Funeral Expenses
Rs. 15,000/Rs. 15,000/- + 10% = Rs. 16,500/Rs. 16,500/- + 10% = Rs. 18,150/-
Loss of Estate
Rs. 15,000/Rs. 15,000/- + 10% = Rs. 16,500/Rs. 16,500/- + 10% = Rs. 18,150/-
Total
Rs. 8,89,100/-
Thus, the total compensation payable to the claimants is assessed at
Rs. 8,89,100/-.
18.
Now, turning to the submission of learned counsel for the
claimants that the rate of interest awarded by the learned Tribunal at
6% per annum is inadequate and ought to have been fixed at 9% per
annum, it is to be noted that the award of interest on the amount of
compensation is a matter within the judicial discretion of the Court, to
be exercised having regard to the facts and circumstances of each
case. Having regard to the fact that the rate of 6% per annum is
somewhat modest, this Court is of the view that interest at the rate of
7.5% per annum would meet the ends of justice. At the same time,
there is nothing on record to indicate any delay attributable to
respondent No. 2/insurance company in complying with the award. On
the contrary, respondent No. 2 has not preferred any appeal against
the award and has already deposited the awarded compensation in
terms thereof. In the facts and circumstances of the present case,
therefore, the rate of interest is modified from 6% to 7.5% per annum
from the date of filing of the claim petition till realization. The prayer
for enhancement of interest to 9% per annum is, accordingly, rejected.
19.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the claimants are held
entitled to enhanced compensation of Rs. 4,38,100/- (Rupees Four
Lakh Thirty Eight Thousand One Hundred) only, over and above the
compensation of Rs. 4,51,000/- (Rupees Four Lakh Fifty One
Thousand) awarded by the learned Tribunal. The respondent No.
2/insurance company is directed to pay the enhanced compensation of
Rs. 4,38,100/- along with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from
the date of filing of the claim petition till realization, through the
learned Tribunal, within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt
of a certified copy of this judgment.
20.
The judgment and order dated judgment and order dated
30.07.2014 passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Morigaon, Assam in MAC Case No. 44/2012 is accordingly
stands modified to the aforesaid extent.
21.
The appeal stands disposed of in the above terms.
22.
Send back the TCR.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review