Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.10.30 16:50:50 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010
M/S AL-Baari & Sons through its proprietor Md. Abdul Barik,
aged about 66 years, S/O Md. Mohiddeen, a resident of
Muslim Nagar, Ward No. 5, P.O and P.S. Moreh, Chandel
District, Manipur.
… PETITIONER
-VERSUS1.
The Union of India through its Secretary, Finance,
Government of India.
2.
Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, Kolkata through its
Additional Director General.
3.
The
Deputy
Director,
Directorate
of
Revenue
Directorate
of
Revenue
Intelligence, Silchar.
4.
The
Deputy
Director,
Intelligence, Guwahati.
5.
Intelligence Officer, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence,
Imphal.
6.
The Commissioner of Custom (Preventive), N.E. Region,
Shillong, Meghalaya.
7.
The Superintendent of Customs Preventive Force,
Moreh, Manipur.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Page |2
8.
The
State
of
Manipur
through
its
Principal
Secretary/Secretary, Forest & Environment, Government
of Manipur.
9.
The Conservator of Forest/Admn. & Plg., Government of
Manipur.
10. The State of Maharashtra through its Commissioner
(Forests), Government of Maharashtra.
11. The
Chief
Conservator
of
Forests
(T),
Thane,
Government of Maharashtra.
… RESPONDENTS
WP(C) No. 351 of 2010
M/S AL-Baari & Sons through its proprietor Md. Abdul Barik,
aged about 66 years, S/O Md. Mohiddeen, a resident of
Muslim Nagar, Ward No. 5, P.O and P.S. Moreh, Chandel
District, Manipur.
… PETITIONER
-VERSUS1. The Union of India through its Secretary, Finance,
Government of India.
2. Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, Kolkata through its
Additional Director General.
3. The Deputy Director, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence,
Silchar.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Page |3
4. The Deputy Director, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence,
Guwahati.
5. Intelligence Officer, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence,
Imphal.
6. The Commissioner of Custom (Preventive), N.E. Region,
Shillong, Meghalaya.
7. The Superintendent of Customs Preventive Force, Moreh,
Manipur.
8. The
State
of
Manipur
through
its
Principal
Secretary/Secretary, Forest & Environment, Government
of Manipur.
9. The Conservator of Forest/Admn. & Plg., Government of
Manipur.
10. The State of Maharashtra through its Commissioner
(Forests), Government of Maharashtra.
11. The Chief Conservator of Forests (T), Thane, Government
of Maharashtra.
… RESPONDENTS
WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
M/S AL-Baari & Sons through its proprietor Md. Abdul Barik,
aged about 66 years, S/O Md. Mohiddeen, a resident of
Muslim Nagar, Ward No. 5, P.O and P.S. Moreh, Chandel
District, Manipur.
… PETITIONER
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Page |4
-VERSUS1. The Union of India through its Secretary, Finance,
Government of India.
2. The Commissioner of Custom (Preventive), N.E. Region,
Shillong, Meghalaya.
3. The Superintendent of Customs Preventive Force, Moreh,
Manipur.
… RESPONDENTS
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
::
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Th. Sanachouba, Adv.
Mr. BR Sharma, CGSC
.
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
12.10.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
30.10.2023
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
Heard Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner; Mr. BR Sharma, learned CGSC for the respondent Union
of India; Mr. Th. Sanachouba, learned counsel for respondent
Directorate of Revenue Intelligence and learned counsel for the
Customs.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Page |5
2.
In these writ petitions, the petitioner has challenged
the show cause notice dated 8.1.2010; the investigation report
dated 8.1.2010 and the order of Commissioner of Customs dated
7.4.2011.
3.
Since the issue involved in the writ petitions is
interlinked with each other, all three writ petitions were heard
together and disposed of by this common order.
4.
Mr. HS Paonam, the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the petitioner is a proprietorship firm and
they have procured red sanders from M/s. Shree Durga
Enterprises, Mumbai under three invoices in the format against C
Form vide letter dated 13.6.2009 and, under the said three invoices,
the total quantity of the red sander has been indicated as 49467.4
kgs. The petitioner is yet to make full payment of the red sander so
procured from M/s. Shree Durga Enterprises. The goods under
three invoices were released and transported through M/s. Anand
Roadlines from Mumbai to Manipur and M/s. Anand Roadlines was
also issued with consignor and consignee’s copies dated
13.6.2009. The transportation of the said goods was done on three
transit passes dated 13.6.2009 issued by the competent authority
of originating State of Maharastra through the State of MP, UP,
Bihar, West Bengal, Assam, Meghalaya, Nagaland up to the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Page |6
destination of Moreh and the other transit passes issued by different
States after paying all taxes and fees.
5.
The learned senior counsel submitted that the Chief
Conservator of Forest had confirmed the genuineness of the transit
pass issued by the Range Forest Officer, Khalapur dated 9.7.2009
and had permitted change of transportation of red sanders from
three trucks of M/s. Anand Roadlines to five Manipur trucks bearing
Nos.MN-01 7108, MN-01 7126; MN-01 7252, MN-01 8125 and MN01 5736 vide letter dated 15.7.2009 when change of transportation
was felt necessary at Mao due to road condition in playing by three
big trucks. No occasion has ever occured to question the legality
of the procurement of transportation of red sanders of the
petitioner’s firm. The Divisional Forest Officer, Senapati Forest
Division had also informed the Beat Officer, Mao Beat Office vide
letter dated 21.7.2009 for affixing the Government seal on the
original transit passes issued by Mirzapur Forest Division, UP for
further transportation through Mao Beat Office up to the destination
of Moreh.
Accordingly, the goods were transporting from the
original three trucks to five Manipur trucks at Mao smoothly by
paying requisite taxes and fees to the respective check posts up to
the office of the Range Officer, Kakching.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Page |7
6.
The learned senior counsel would submit that while
things stood thus, to the shock and surprise of the petitioner, the
five trucks of goods were detained by the personnel of Assam Rifle
at Khudengthabi in Chandel District in purported instruction
received from the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), Zonal
Office, Kolkata and despite showing relevant documents including
the transport pass, the goods have been seized on 8.8.2009.
Challenging the legality of the seizure of red sanders transported
under the transit pass, the petitioner had filed W.P.(C) No.504 of
2009 for release of the goods.
By the interim order dated
18.9.2009, this Court directed the respondents therein to
immediately release the red sanders seized under inventory dated
8.8.2009 to the petitioner on execution of an indemnity bond against
the invoice value which is not different from the recent pricing of red
sanders by the Forest Department. Aggrieved by the order dated
18.9.2009, writ appeal, being W.A.No.310 of 2009, was preferred
and, by the order dated 19.10.2009, a Division Bench of this Court
directed to conclude the investigation within a period of eight weeks
and not to give effect of the order dated 18.9.2009 passed in
W.P.(C) No.504 of 2009.
7.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that the
respondent DRI could not complete their investigation within the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Page |8
time granted by the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court in
W.A.No.310 of 2009 and they have filed Miscellaneous Case
No.3439 of 2009 seeking to grant further eight weeks time to
complete the investigation. The Division Bench, vide order dated
21.12.2009, granted four weeks time from the expiry of the earlier
granted time for completing the investigation. After coming to know
the Miscellaneous Case filed by the respondent authorities, the
petitioner has filed an affidavit controverting the statement made in
the Miscellaneous Case and prayed for discontinuation or nonextension of the time for completing the investigation.
When
Miscellaneous Case No.3439 of 2009 was listed on 19.1.2010, the
DRI authority by making a statement to the effect that the
investigation has already been completed has not pressed the said
Miscellaneous Case. Thus, in terms of the earlier order, it is to be
seen as to whether the second confiscation proceedings of the
seized goods may be initiated again.
8.
According to the learned senior counsel, the impugned
show cause notice dated 8.1.2010 was issued, thereby ordering
confiscation of the seized goods of the petitioner and directed the
petitioner to submit an explanation within 30 days from the date of
the receipt of the notice. Since the impugned show cause notice
was issued based on the investigation report, on 10.2.2010, the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Page |9
petitioner has submitted a letter to the DRI authority requesting to
furnish the copy of the investigation report. However, no response
has been received by the petitioner. Since the red sander being
perishable goods, the petitioner has submitted an application to the
Commissioner (Custom) NE Region, Shiling for releasing the
seized goods under Section 110A of the Customs Act, 1962. The
said application was made for the reason that exercise of power
under Section 110A is an independent power notwithstanding the
other proceeding which may be taken up by the other authority.
9.
The learned senior counsel urged that while the DRI
authority is claiming to have completed the investigation on one
hand, they are pressurising personal attendance of the petitioner at
DRI, Guwahati for the purpose of giving statement in connection
with the investigation on the other hand. The learned CJM, Chandel
has enlarged the proprietor of the petitioner on bail vide order dated
5.3.2010 after satisfying the cooperation extended as well as the
health condition of the proprietor. The alleged completion of the
investigation by the DRI is wholly incorrect as the procedure
adopted is in connection with those persons who are believed to
have not extended cooperation in the investigation under Section
108 of the Customs Act. The issuance of the impugned show cause
notice, which is based on the investigation report, is an arbitrary
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 10
exercise of power by the respondent DRI disregarding the settled
principle of law qua the impermissibility of taking up a second
confiscation proceedings of the goods which had already been
subjected to another confiscation proceeding under the Customs
Act. Therefore, the impugned show cause notice is liable to be
quashed.
10.
Adding further, the learned senior counsel submitted
that the respondent DRI has filed an additional affidavit in W.P.(C)
No.180 of 2010 along with the investigation report, wherefrom the
petitioner found that the said investigation report is not supported
by any forwarding letter nor any kind of letter indicating as
investigation report except endorsing with the signature of the then
Deputy Director, DRI, Guwahati dated 8.1.2010. Nothing can be
ascertained as to the nature of the document as investigation
report. The said investigation report cannot be acted upon in view
of the fact that it is merely summary in nature without any supporting
documents, inasmuch as the report has failed to take note of the
fact that the transportation of the red sander was done on the basis
of the transit pass issued by the competent authority of the State of
Maharashtra, which was subsequently authorised by the Forest
Department, Government of Manipur. That apart, the finding of the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 11
investigating authority stated at para (i) of the investigating report
lacks legal support and, therefore, the same is liable to be quashed.
11.
The learned senior counsel next submitted that while
issuing notice returnable in W.P.(C) No.180 of 2010, the Court
passed an interim order for not giving effect to the show cause
notice dated 8.1.2010 and further directed the concerned
respondent to consider and dispose of the application filed by the
petitioner for provisional release of the seized red sander. Despite
the request made by the petitioner and its counsel, the concerned
authority, namely the Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) has
not considered the provisional release of the seized goods.
12.
It is submitted that on 7.3.2010, the petitioner has
received a communication from the Commissioner of Customs
preventing provisional release of the seized goods stating that no
evidence was produced in support of the ownership as well as the
payment, if any made. On 4.10.2010, the petitioner submitted an
application to the Commissioner of Customs enclosing supporting
documents seeking provisional release of the seized goods. Since
the same has not been considered, the petitioner had filed W.P.(C)
No.655 of 2010 to reconsider the application dated 4.10.2010 and
the said writ petition was disposed of directing the respondents
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 12
therein to consider the application/representation dated 4.10.2010
afresh in terms of the observation made in the order. The petitioner
was called for enquiry and he had also appeared through its
representative and submitted all the documents. However, without
considering the documents produced by the petitioner, the
Commissioner has issued the impugned order dated 7.4.2011
thereby declining to release the seized goods on the ground that
instead of submitting reply to the show cause notice dated 8.1.2010,
the petitioner has filed the writ petition. According to the learned
senior counsel, the said ground taken by the Commissioner of
Customs is erroneous and without looking into the factual aspects
of the matter, the Commissioner of Customs has issued the
impugned order dated 7.4.2011 and, therefore, the same is liable to
be set aside.
13.
Per contra, Mr. Th. Sanachouba, the learned counsel
for the respondent DRI submitted that the seizure was effected on
the basis of an intelligence collected and developed by the
Directorate. At the time of interception and seizure, only one invoice
of M/s.Shree Durga Enterprises of Mumbai was produced,
however, the same does not cover all the seized goods in question
and that the said invoice is forged one. The subject goods were
meant for illegal export to Myanmar through the route not specified
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 13
under Section 7(1)(C) of the Customs Act, 1962 read with the
provisions of Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act,
1992, thereby rendering the same liable for confiscation.
14.
The learned counsel further submitted that M/s. Shree
Durga Enterprises is a proprietorship concern of Umesh Dhan
Singh and the said Umesh Dhan Singh clarified that his firm did not
carry out any transaction with the petitioner and had not procured
any red sander logs and, as such, the issue of storage and
transportation did not arise. M/s. Shree Durga Enterprises and the
petitioner are not the seller and buyer respectively and, in fact,
M/s.Shree Durga Enterprises did not have title to the goods and so
cannot pass on the same to the petitioner.
The invoice dated
13.6.2009 issued by M/s.Shree Durga Enterprises in the name of
the petitioner is a forged one.
15.
The learned counsel would submit that though the
learned Single Judge in W.P.(C) No.504 of 2009 ordered release of
seized goods, in the appeal, being W.A.No.310 of 2009, preferred,
it has been ordered that the seized goods will abide by the final
decision to be taken by the revenue authorities on conclusion of the
investigation. Pursuant to the order of the Division Bench several
opportunities were given to the petitioner, however, the petitioner
has not extended co-operation in the investigation.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
Since the
P a g e | 14
petitioner has failed to appear before the investigating agency, the
DRI has filed a Criminal (Complaint) Case No.18 of 2009 before the
CJM, Chandel, wherein warrant of arrest was issued and,
thereafter, the petitioner and another accused namely S.K.Jain
appeared and were enlarged on bail.
16.
The
learned
counsel
next
submitted
that
on
completion of the investigation as directed by the Division Bench,
the investigation report has been submitted before the Court and
consequently, the show cause notice was also issued. According
to the learned counsel, the show cause notice issued is nothing but
after completion of the investigation. The issuance of show cause
notice to the petitioner has not caused any prejudice to the
petitioner and the petitioner is bound to reply the same.
17.
The learned counsel urged that after completion of the
investigation following the seizure of the red sanders, sow dust etc.
submitted the investigation report dated 8.1.2010 stating that it
appears that the seized red sanders valued at Rs.1,95,62,750/were meant for illegal export to Myanmar through a route not
specified under the provisions of the Customs Act and, therefore,
all the named persons are liable for imposition of penalty under
Section 114 of the Customs Act and also liable for prosecution
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 15
under Section 135(1)(c)(C) of the Customs Act. The investigation
report is completely based on the show cause and not vice versa
as has been alleged by the petitioner. In the course of investigation,
the voluntary statement of Umesh Dhan Singh was recorded
wherein he himself stated to be the sole proprietor of M/s.Shree
Durga Enterprises and he does not know any person by name
Suresh Kumar Jain claiming to be the partner of the said firm. The
petitioner has no right to challenge the investigation report dated
8.1.2010 of the DRI and, therefore, there is no illegality in the report
as well as the show cause notice.
18.
The learned counsel for the respondent Customs
submitted that from the investigation report submitted by the Deputy
Director, Director of Enforcement it appears that M/s.Shree Durga
Enterprises is a proprietorship concern of Umesh Dhan Singh and
that the letters addressed to the petitioner under the signature of
Suresh Kumar Jain are forged. The same was clarified by Umesh
Dhan Singh that his firm did not carry out any transaction with the
petitioner and had not procured red sander logs and, therefore, the
storage and transportation did not arise. At the time of seizure, only
one invoice has been produced and the same does not cover all the
seized goods in question. He would submit that from the intelligence
report developed by the DRI, about 50 MT of red sander wood in
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 16
the form of logs, chip etc. were being attempted to be illegally
exported out of India to Myanmar through Moreh, Manipur. The red
sander woods recovered from the trucks did not tally with the
documents found accompanying with the goods and there was no
market of such huge quantity of red sander woods in the area and
it was reasonable belief that DRI officers that the consignment of
red sander wood, buttend etc. so recovered were brought near
international border is an attempt to illegally export the same to
Myanmar. 48.2 MT of red sander logs, 1.015 MT of red sander butt
ends, 41 kg. of red sander chips and 150 kg. of red sander saw dust
were seized.
19.
The learned counsel further submitted that on
26.2.2010, the petitioner submitted an application to the
Commissioner of Customs (P) Shillong requesting for releasing the
seized red sander woods to the prevailing rate in the State of
Manipur. Another representation dated 4.10.2010 was received
from the petitioner in which a further request has been made for
releasing the seized goods provisionally subject to the condition as
may be imposed by the authorities in compliance of the order
passed in W.P.(C) No.180 of 2010. Accordingly, the representation
of the petitioner has been considered and disposed of on 3.6.2010.
Further, as per the direction given in W.P.(C) No.655 of 2010 dated
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 17
1.2.2011, the representation of the petitioner dated 4.10.2010 was
considered and disposed of vide the impugned order dated
7.4.2011 on the ground that about 50 MT red sander wood in the
form of logs, chips etc. were being attempted to be exported out of
India to Myanmar. Though there is a provision for release of seized
goods provisionally, the ownership of the same has not been
proved beyond doubt.
20.
The learned counsel for the respondent Customs
added that red sander is highly endangered plant species as per
CITES and, as such, its export is prohibited. Such goods cannot be
redeemed in favour of individuals who are smuggling it. Since the
allegations against Md. Abdul Bark, proprietor of M/s.A1-Baari and
Sons, Moreh, Manipur and Suresh Kumar Jain brought on record
by the investigation remains to be disproved, the request for
provisional release of the seized goods by Md. Abdul Bark cannot
be acceded to.
21.
The learned counsel for the respondent Forest
Department submitted that three transit passes dated 13.6.2009 for
the quantity of red sanders worth 16100.60 kg., 16289.20 kg. and
17077.60 kg. respectively were originally issued by the then Range
Forest Officer, Khalapur, Maharastra for transportation from Raigad
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 18
to Moreh, Manipur. The registration numbers of the trucks were
also mentioned on the transit passes. As per the documents made
available to the Forest Department by the petitioner, Mirzapur
Forest Division, UP issued transit passes in lieu of the original
transit passes for Moreh during transport. On the back side of the
lieu transit passes issued by the Mirzapur Forest Division, the seals
of various forest check posts in various States through which the
said consignment had passed are available. On reaching Mao Gate
at the border of Manipur, the petitioner applied to the Forest
Department on 29.6.2009 to issue him lieu transit passes for 51.5
MT (51,500 kg.) for further transportation to Moreh and vide letter
dated 30.6.2009 the petitioner requested the Forest Department for
allowing them to carry the same consignment on five trucks as the
owner of the previous three trucks who was from Gauhati was not
willing to enter in Manipur due to law and order problem.
22.
The learned counsel further submitted that on
7.7.2009, the Forest Department sought confirmation on the
genuineness of the three transit passes from the concerned Chief
Conservator of Forests, who in turn, vide letter dated 9.7.2009,
confirmed to the Forest Department, Manipur that the said transit
passes were genuine.
After obtaining confirmation from the
Maharastra Forest Department, vide letter dated 15.7.2009 directed
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 19
the Divisional Forest Officer, Senapati Forest Division to allow
passage of the three consignments of red sanders on the basis of
the three transit passes. No lieu transit pass was issued by the
Forest Department.
However, it was permitted to change the
consignment on five trucks. On enquiry, it has come to the notice
that the consignee did not comply with the orders of the Forest
Department and committed an offence. The consignee had not
arranged the five trucks for shifting at Mao Beat Office, instead, the
consignee had shifted the consignment from 3 trucks to five trucks
at some other place enroute from Mao to Moreh.
The petitioner
has not intimated about such shifting to any other Divisional Forest
Office falling NH-39 from Mao to Moreh. Thus, the actions of the
consignee were not as per the directions issued by the Department.
23.
This Court considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
24.
Admittedly, there were three challenges made in these
writ petitions. Firstly, the petitioner has challenged the show cause
notice dated 8.1.2010. Secondly, the investigation report dated
8.1.2010. Thirdly, the order dated 7.4.2011 of the Commissioner of
Customs thereby rejecting the representation of the petitioner dated
4.10.2010.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 20
25.
As far as the impugned show cause notice dated
8.1.2010 is concerned, according to the respondent DRI, the same
was issued based on the investigation report and it cannot be
contended that the show cause notice was issued behind the back
of the petitioner and that too without giving copy of the investigation
report to the petitioner.
26.
It is an admitted fact that earlier the petitioner had filed
W.P.(C) No.504 of 2009 for release of the seized goods and upon
hearing the respective counsel, the Imphal Bench of Gauhati High
Court passed the following interim order on 18.9.2009:
“In the circumstances, I am satisfied that a
case for an interim order is made out and
accordingly it is directed that respondent
Nos.2, 3 and 4 shall immediately release the
Red Sanders (Sandle Wood) seized under
inventory dated 8.8.2009 (Annexure-A/11 to
the petition) to the petitioners on execution of
an indemnity bond against the invoice value
which is not different from the recent pricing
of Red Sanders (Sandle Wood) by the Forest
Department of Manipur as is evidence in the
communication dated 3.1.2009 (Annexure13) to the additional affidavit.”
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 21
27.
Aggrieved by the said interim order, the DRI has
preferred an appeal, being W.A.No.310 of 2009.
The Division
Bench of the Principal Seat at Guwahati High Court, by the
judgment and order dated 19.10.2009, ordered as under:
“Having regard to the above contentions and
after considering the submissions made by
Mr.Sarma, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-writ petitioner, we are of the
opinion that the present matter can be
disposed of by permitting the appellant to
conclude their investigation into the matter
within a period of next eight weeks. During
this period, the release order passed on
18.9.2009 shall not be given effect to. The
seized goods will abide by the final decision
to be taken by the Revenue authorities in the
matter, on conclusion of the investigation.
Appeal stands disposed of.”
28.
Thus, from the above order, it is clear that the plea of
the respondent DRI that the show cause notice was issued based
on the investigation report submitted is highly doubtful. Since the
respondent DRI could not complete the investigation as ordered by
the Division Bench, it has filed Miscellaneous Case No.3439 of
2009 seeking extension of time. By the order dated 27.1.2010, the
Division Bench granted another four weeks time. Thus, from the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 22
above also, it is clear that as on the date of issuance of the show
cause notice, the investigation has not been completed.
29.
According to the petitioner, the show cause notice
dated 8.1.2010 was served on the petitioner on 27.1.2010.
The
contention of the respondent DRI as recorded in the judgment and
order dated 19.10.2009 states that the revenue authorities were
investigating into the matter. If really, the investigation was
completed before the date of issuance of the impugned show cause
notice i.e. 8.1.2010, there is no necessity on the part of the
respondent DRI in filing Miscellaneous Case No.3439 of 2009
seeking extension of time. Further, if really, the respondent DRI
prepared the investigation report on 8.1.2010 impugned in W.P.(C)
No.351 of 2010, why the respondent DRI filed Miscellaneous Case
praying for further eight weeks’ time to complete the investigation
has not been explained/clarified.
30.
As could be seen from the records, upon receipt of the
show cause notice, on 10.2.2010, the petitioner submitted an
application before the Additional Director General of DRI for supply
of the investigation report so as to enable the petitioner to submit
the statement of defence in writing in reply.
According to the
petitioner, till date the investigation report has not been supplied to
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 23
the petitioner.
However, the petitioner was able to see the
investigation report when the respondent DRI filed the copy of the
same along with the additional affidavit filed in W.P.(C) No.180 of
2010 .
31.
The petitioner has also assailed the investigation
report contending that nothing can be ascertained as to the nature
of the said document. According to the petitioner, it is merely
summary in nature without any supporting documents and the said
report failed to take note of the fact that transportation of the red
sander was done on the basis of the transit pass issued by the
competent authority of the State of Maharashtra.
32.
On a perusal of the alleged investigation report dated
8.1.2010, this Court finds that the same is not a investigation report.
As rightly submitted by the petitioner, it is a summary report.
Assuming that the same is investigation report, it should contain the
enclosures, namely the supporting documents.
Admittedly, the
report dated 8.1.2010 does not contain any list of persons examined
and the documents gone through by the investigating agency. If
really, the respondent DRI treated the report dated 8.1.2010 as an
investigation report, they could have immediately forwarded the
same to the concerned authorities for action with a copy to the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 24
affected persons, namely the petitioner. Failing to do so, clearly
indicates that the report dated 8.1.2010 is not an investigation
report. Therefore, this Court is of the view that it is quite strange
and may not be possible on the part of the respondent DRI to issue
the show cause notice dated 8.1.2010 when the investigation report
dated 8.1.2010 was submitted by the Deputy Director thereby
exposing the mala fide and the artificial cause invented by the
respondent DRI in their attempt to have a second confiscation
proceeding of the seized goods under the Customs Act.
33.
At this juncture, the learned counsel for the
respondent DRI submitted that goods once subjected to
confiscation proceedings can again be subjected to confiscation
proceedings if there arises allegation of another violation of the law.
The goods once released cannot get any immunity from further
proceedings only on the ground that the same has been released.
34.
On a perusal of the order dated 11.8.2008 of the
Customs Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, West
Regional Bench at Mumbai in Appeal No.C/552/08, it is seen that
the red sanders which were procured from M/s.Shree Durga
Enterprises through its partner Suresh Kumar Jain have already
been subjected to a confiscation proceeding under Section 110 of
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 25
the Customs Act and the same has been released by the order of
the CESTAT on condition of making revenue payment of Rs.1 lakh
and the enforcement of the order has also been endorsed by the
Mumbai High Court in W.P.(C) No.396 of 2009 dated 21.4.2009.
35.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner submitted
that the red sander procured by the petitioner’s firm which is out of
the red sander amounting to 41.52 MT of Suresh Kumar Jain having
been subject matter of confiscation proceedings, the same
procedure cannot be done as it amounts to double jeopardy, hence,
making the illegal seizure unsustainable in the eye of law. This
Court finds some force in the said submission made by the learned
senior counsel for the petitioner.
Though the respondent DRI
contended that the seized goods are for the purpose of export,
nothing has been produced to establish the same. On the other
hand, it is the plea of the petitioner that red sanders were allowed
to be purchased and transmitted.
36.
According to the petitioner, the red sanders in question
was legally procured by the petitioner from M/s.Shree Durga
Enterprises, Mumbai under three invoices in the prescribed format
against C Form vide letter dated 13.6.2009.
Under the three
invoices, total quantity of red sander has been indicated as 49467.4
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 26
kgs. Upon receipt of the invoices, the petitioner made a request to
M/s.Shree Durga Enterprises for allowing payment of the bill
amount whole instalments within a period of two months with effect
from the date of receiving f the consignment. According to the
petitioner, they are yet to make full payment of the red sander so
procured from M/s.Shree Durga Enterprises.
The goods were
transported through M/s.Anand Roadlines from Mumbai to Manipur
and in this regard, the letters for releasing and transportation of the
goods were exchanged by the petitioner and the M/s.Anand
Roadlines. The Chief Conservator of Forest had also confirmed the
genuineness of the transit pass issued by the Range Forest Officer,
Khalapur. It has also permitted change of transportation of red
sanders from three trucks of M/s.Anand Roadlines to five Manipur
trucks on 15.7.2009 when change of transportation was felt
necessary at Mao due to road condition. No occasion ever occurr
questioning the legality of the procurement of transportation of red
sanders of the petitioner.
37.
There is no dispute that the goods were transported
by transferree from the original three trucks to five Manipur trucks
at Mao smoothly by paying taxes and the required fees to the
respective check posts up to the officer of Range Officer,
Tengnoupal, Government of Manipur. While so, on 8.8.2009, the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 27
five trucks carrying the goods were detained by the Assam Rifles at
Khudengthabi in Chandel District on the basis of the purported
instruction of the DRI Zonal Office, Kolkatta and, according to the
petitioner, despite showing the relevant documents including the
transit pass, the goods have been seized. In this regard, the Forest
Department filed affidavit-in-opposition stating as under:
“….. On reaching Mao Gate (Senapati Forest
Division) at the border of Manipur States, the
petitioner applied to the forest Department,
Manipur vide letter dated 29.6.2009 to issue
him lieu TPs for 51.5 Metric Tonnes (51,500
kg) for further transportation to Moreh,
District Chandel, Manipur. Subsequently the
petitioner organisation vide letter dated
30.6.2009
also
requested
this
Forest
Department for allowing him to carry the
same consignment as per the said three TPs
on 5 (five) trucks as the owner of the previous
three trucks who was from Gauhati, was not
willing to enter in Manipur due to law and
order problem.
The Forest Department, Government of
Manipur vide letter dated 07.07.2009 sought
confirmation on the genuineness of the said
3 (three) TPs from the concerned Chief
Conservator of Forests, Thane (Maharastra),
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 28
who
in
turn
vide
letter
No.
Desk-
8/Vigi/284/2009-10
dated:
09.07.2009
confirmed
Forest
Department
to
the
(Government of Manipur) that the said TPs
were genuine and issued under directions of
this office.”
38.
The affidavit of the Forest Department further states
that after obtaining confirmation from the Maharashtra Forest
Department, the Forest Department of Government of Manipur
directed the Divisional Forest Officer, Senapti Forest Division to
allow passage of the three consignments of red sanders on the
basis of the three transit passes after affixing the seals on the
original transit passes. The Forest Department of Manipur stated
that no lieu transit pass was issued.
However, the Forest
Department, Government of Manipur, stated that it was permitted
to change the consignment on five trucks of Manipur. When the
Forest Department, Government of Manipur, after verifying the
genuineness of the transit passes issued by the Forest Department
of Government of Maharashtra permitted passage and also
permitted to change the consignments on five trucks, it cannot
contend that the consignee did not comply with the directions of the
Forest Department and had not arranged the five trucks for shifting
at Mao Beat Office, instead the consignee had shifted the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 29
consignment from three trucks to five trucks at some other place
enroute from Mao to Moreh. The Forest Department cannot take a
different stand at its whims and fancies.
39.
The red sanders in question were detained by the
Assam Rifles on 2.8.2009 at Khudengtabi i.e. about 11 km. before
reaching Moreh and the same was seized on 8.8.2009 by the
Customs authority by preparing an inventory under Section 110 of
the Customs Act, 1962. In the present case, the petitioner had
raised various legal issues qua jurisdiction to invoke the power of
seizure as provided under Section 110 of the Act, as the Act does
not contemplate second confiscation of an article which has already
been confiscated and released by the orders of the Court and that
there is no material to establish and suggest that the goods in
question were meant for export outside India. In fact, prima facie,
the petitioner has established that the goods in question were
purchased under valid transaction and transported up to Moreh
under the transit passes issued by the Forest Department of
Government of Maharashtra which has been confirmed as genuine
by the Forest Department, Government of Manipur.
40.
It is pertinent to note that the respondent authorities in
order to resort to the proposed proceedings have construed that
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 30
Suresh Kumar Jain is disowned by the proprietor of M/s.Shree
Durga Enterprises as one of the partners in his business thereby
projecting it as illegal procurement. In fact, while coming to such
conclusion, the respondent authorities, more particularly, the
respondent DRI has overlooked the fact that Suresh Kumar Jain is
not refrained by any legal impediment in selling the red sander to
any other third party having regard to the fact that the competent
Court in the State of Maharastra has not accepted about Suresh
Kumar Jain as person who violated relevant law of export of red
sander. In other words, the contention of Suresh Kumar Jain that
red sander procured by him was not for the purpose of export had
already been accepted by the competent Court. Therefore, the
procurement of red sander by the petitioner firm from Suresh Kumar
Jain has not infringed any prohibitive law under the Customs Act in
any manner. Therefore, the show cause notice being an act to do
indirectly which is no longer permitted to do directly is unsustainable
in the eye of law.
41.
From the available materials produced before this
Court and the pleadings of the parties, it appears that the petitioner
has been able to establish that the reds sanders in question were
procured under valid transaction and in this regard transit passes
were issued for transportation from Mumbai to Moreh which was
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 31
also verified and found genuine by the Forest Department,
Government of Manipur. Thus, the issuance of show cause notice
was in fact an arbitrary exercise of power disregarding the settled
principle of law qua the impermissibility of taking up a second
confiscation proceeding, inasmuch the documents relied by the
respondent authorities, particularly, the investigation report on basis
whereof the show cause notice was issued, has not been furnished
to the petitioner despite the request made by the petitioner.
Nothing has been produced by the respondent DRI to show that
they have furnished the copy of the investigation report to the
petitioner. As stated supra, it is the duty of the respondent DRI to
furnish the copy of the investigation report when they intend to serve
show cause notice.
Thus, this Court is of the view that the
impugned show cause notice and the investigation report are not
sustainable in the eye of law.
42.
Coming to the impugned order dated 7.4.2011 passed
by the Commissioner of Customs, the learned senior counsel for
the petitioner argued that the same is against the spirit of the
provision of Section 110(A) of the Customs Act whereby an
independent power is vested with the officer concerned for
releasing the seized goods provisionally during the pendency of the
adjudication proceeding.
The learned senior counsel further
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 32
submitted that the prayer of the petitioner has been declined by the
Commissioner on the ground that the petitioner instead of
submitting reply to the impugned show cause notice has filed the
writ petition.
43.
This Court in the previous paragraphs held that the
impugned show cause notice issued to the petitioner and the
investigation report impugned in W.P.(C) Nos.180 of 2010 and 351
of 2010 are not sustainable in the eye of law.
44.
In
the
impugned
order
dated
7.4.2011,
the
Commissioner of Customs took a stand that instead of submitting
reply to the show cause notice dated 8.1.2010 with supporting
documents to challenge the charges, the proprietor of the petitioner
has submitted an application for provisional release of the seized
goods. In the impugned order dated 7.4.2011, the Commissioner
has also observed that the invoice issued to the petitioner by
M/s.Shree Durga Enterprises was a forged one and no transaction
was carried out between the firms. As such, there is nothing on
record to substantiate that the petitioner procured any red sander
wood from Maharashtra as claimed by them. Admittedly, the said
observation made by the Commissioner of Customs is without any
concrete
evidence.
When
the
Forest
Department
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
of
the
P a g e | 33
Maharashtra as well as the Manipur endorsed that the goods in
question were transported from Mumbai to Moreh via Manipur and
in that regard during enquiry the petitioner has produced materials,
without appreciating such materials, the Commissioner has arrived
at such a finding. The finding of the Commissioner that in the
absence of any corroborative evidence on record it was not possible
to consider the petitioner as the legal owner of the red sander logs,
buttend, chips and saw dust under seizure is unsustainable in view
of the finding arrived at by this Court in this order that the show
cause notice dated 8.1.2010 and the investigation report dated
8.1.2010 are not sustainable in the eye of law, as on the date of
issuance of the show cause notice by the respondent DRI, no such
investigation report was available. That apart, the alleged
investigation report dated 8.1.2010 relied on by the respondent DRI
is not the investigation report and is summary in nature.
45.
On 13.4.2010, the petitioner through its counsel sent
a representation to the DRI and the Commissioner of Customs by
enclosing the interim order dated 9.4.2010 passed in W.P.(C)
No.180 of 2010 requesting release of the goods in exercise of
power under Section 110A o the Customs Act. On 3.6.2020, the
Commissioner of Customs passed an order stating that the seized
goods cannot be released to the petitioner. On 4.10.2010, the
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 34
petitioner again submitted a representation to the Commissioner of
Customs for releasing the seized goods provisionally subject to the
condition as may be imposed by the said authority. Since the said
representation dated 4.10.2010 has not been considered, the
petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.655 of 2010 before the Gauhati High
Court.
By the order dated 1.2.2011, the Gauhati High Court
disposed of the said writ petition. The operative portion of the order
reads thus:
“Accordingly, this writ petition is disposed of with
a direction to the respondent No.2 to consider
afresh of the representation dated 04.10.2010
(Annexure-A/12) and take appropriate decision
within a period of 2 (two) months from the date
of receipt of a certified copy of this order. It is
also made clear that respondent No.2 shall be
guided by the observation made by this Court in
the order dated 08.04.2010 passed in W.P.(C)
No.180 of 2010, while determining the market
price of Red Sanders wood.”
46.
Thereafter, on 2.3.2011, the petitioner submitted
another representation thereby enclosing all the orders passed in
the writ petitions instituted by the petitioner to the Commissioner of
Customs for releasing the seized goods provisionally.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 35
47.
In paragraph 1.9 of the impugned order dated
7.4.2011, the Commissioner stated that as under :“1.9 Md. Abdul Barik, Proprietor of M/s.AIBaari & Sons submitted an application
dated 02.03.2011 to the Commissioner of
Customs (Preventive) NER, Shillong along
with enclosures in support of his claim. He
inter alia mentioned that the transit pass on
the basis of which transportation of the Red
Sanders in question was made from the
State of Maharastra to Manipur is clarified
as genuine by the competent authority. He
added that having regard to the attended
circumstances and in view of the Hon’ble
High Court’s Order passed on 01.02.2011 in
W.P. (C) No.655 of 2010, necessary orders
may be passed for releasing the seized
goods in accordance with Section 110-A of
the Customs Act, 1962.”
48.
After stating so, in paragraph 2.1, the Commissioner
observed as under:
“2.1 I have gone through the case records
and submissions made by Md. Abdul Barik,
Proprietor of M/s.AI-Baari & Sons regarding
his claim for ownership of the seized Red
Sander logs, butt ends, chips and saw dust.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 36
I
find
that
in
the
subject
case,
the
investigation has been completed and show
cause notice under Section 124 of the
Customs Act 1962 has already been issued
on 08.01.2010. Adjudication proceedings by
the Department has been pending not due to
any delay by the Department but due to the
dilatory tactics adopted by the party, i.e.
M/s.AI-Baari & Sons. A show cause notice
issued under Section 124 of the Customs Act
1962 contains the grounds for taking action
against the notice by the Department and
provides opportunity to the notice to make
representations against the grounds/charges
mentioned in the show cause notice besides
according the notice with an opportunity of
being heard in person.
However, in the
instant case Md. Abdul Barik, Proprietor of
M/s.AI-Baari & Sons instead of submitting
any
reply
to
the
show
cause
notice
challenging the grounds for seizure of the
Red Sanders wood and exhausting the
Departmental adjudication and appellate
procedures available to him under the
provisions of the Customs Act 1962 has
preferred to file writ petitions before the
Hon’ble High Court.”
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 37
49.
The
main
ground
for
rejection
of
the
representation/application dated 04.10.2010 of the petitioner by the
Commissioner of Customs is issuance of the show cause notice
dated 8.1.2010 to Md. Abdul Barik that the documents
accompanying the subject goods are not valid documents, as
Umesh Dhan Singh, Proprietor of M/s.Shree Durga Enterprises,
Mumbai has denied to have ever dealt with red sander woods and
no transaction of the subject goods has taken place between
M/s.Shree Durga Enterprises, Mumbai and M/s.AI-Baari & Sons,
Moreh.
When in paragraph 1.9 of the impugned order dated
7.4.2011, the Commissioner stated that the petitioner has filed
documents in support of his claim, the Commissioner subsequently
cannot say that the documents accompanying the subject goods
are not valid documents. There is no elaborate discussion about
the documents that were produced by the petitioner during enquiry
before the Commissioner of Customs. In the order impugned, the
Commissioner simply stated that opportunity was afforded to the
petitioner and the petitioner had produced documents in support of
his claim. But the documents which were produced by the petitioner
during enquiry have not been duly considered by the Commissioner
of Customs and the impugned order was issued merely citing that
a show cause notice has been issued to the petitioner by the DRI.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 38
Such a finding arrived at by the Commissioner of Customs is not
sustainable.
50.
At this juncture, it is pertinent to point out that there is
a statutory provision under Section 110(A) of the Customs Act,
1972 enabling the Commissioner of Customs to release the seized
goods pending adjudication. Section 110A of the Customs Act
mentions that “any goods, documents or things seized under
Section 110 may, pending the order of the adjudicating officer, be
released to the owner on taking a bond from him in the proper form
with such security and conditions as the Commissioner of Customs
may require”. The plain reading of Section 110A of the Act clearly
indicates that seized goods can be granted provisional release
pending adjudication to the owner of the said goods and not to any
other person. Thus, the claim for provisional release of the seized
goods by the petitioner is to be proved beyond reasonable doubt.
While
issuing
the
impugned
order
dated
7.4.2011,
the
Commissioner of Customs has not considered the claim of the
petitioner that it had made part payment for the consignment of
wood under seizure. Further, all the documents produced by the
petitioner to substantiate its claim have not been discussed in the
impugned order by the Commissioner of Customs.
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
P a g e | 39
51.
On
overall
consideration
of
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case, this Court is of the view that the order
passed by the Commissioner of Customs is unsustainable in the
eye of law.
52.
For all the reasons stated above, this Court is inclined
to pass the following orders:
(i)
W.P.(C) Nos.180 and 351 of 2010
and 159 of 2011 are allowed.
(ii)
The impugned show cause notice
and the investigation report dated
8.1.2010 of the respondent DRI
impugned in the writ petitions are set
aside.
(iii)
The impugned order dated 7.4.2011
passed by the Commissioner of
Customs is also set aside.
(iv)
The Respondents No. 2 to 7 are
hereby
directed
to
immediately
release the Red Sanders (Sandal
Wood)
seized
under
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
inventory
P a g e | 40
dated 08.08.2009 within two weeks
from the date of receipt of this order.
(v)
No costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 180 of 2010, WP(C) No. 351 of 2010 and WP(C) No. 159 of 2011
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review