Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MNHC:149-DB
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Item No. 11 - 12
W.P.(C) No. 249 of 2026
1.
Namoijam Jeetu, aged about 56 years, S/o (Late)
Shyamkishore Singh of Khagempalli Panthak, PO &
PS Imphal West District, Manipur-795001
2.
Arambam Satyabrata aged about 38 years, S/o
Arambam Ranjit Singh of Sagolband Bijoygovinda
Mantri Leikai, Imphal West District, Manipur795001
3.
Chongtham Bimol aged about 43 years, S/o Ch.
Meghachandra of Singjamei Wangma Bheigyabati
Leikai, Imphal -795008
4.
Sonia Ahongshangbam, aged about 29 years D/o
A. Bharjit Singh of Athokpam Khunou, Thoubal
District, Manipur-795138
5.
Kundongbam Sundarita Chanu, aged about 35
years, S/o Kh. Rajen Meitei of Heirok Part-II Bazar,
Thoubal District, Manipur-795148
6.
Oinam Shaya Devi aged about 36 years D/o Oinam
Binoy Singh of Palace Compound, near Advance
Hospital, Imphal East District, Manipur-795005
7.
Gaininglung Malangmei aged about 36 years, S/o
Landingam Malangmei of Satudai, Tamenglong
District, Manipur-795147
8.
Gitchandra Oinam, aged about 42 years, S/o Oinam
Biren Singh of Singjamei Oinam Thingel, Imphal
West District, Manipur-795008
P a g e 1 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
9.
L. Taruba aged about 38 years, S/o Luikham of
New Magamei Village, P.O. Maram Bazar, Senapati
District, Manipur-795015
10. Khumanthem Surendra Singh, aged about 49
years, S/o Kh. Iboyai Singh of Lamding
Khumanthem Leikai, PO & PS Wangjing, Thoubal
District, Manipur-795148
11. Salam Babudhol Singh aged about 45 years, S/o S.
Biren Singh of Heirok Part-III, Salam Leikai,
Thoubal District, Manipur-795148
12. Prabesh Singh K. aged about 39 years, S/o
Konjengbam Ibotomba Singh of Khagempalli
Pankha, Ningom Leirak, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001
13. Wairokpam Lokeshwor Singh, aged about 48 years,
S/o (L) W. Nilakanta Singh of Lilong Chajing
Kongjeng Leikai, Imphal West District, Manipur795130.
…. Petitioners
- versus 1.
The State of Manipur represented by the
Commissioner (RD & PR), Government of Manipur,
Civil Secretariat Complex, Mantripukhri, Imphal795002
2.
The Secretary, Manipur Public Service Commission
(MPSC), North AOC, D.M. Road, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001
3.
The Deputy Secretary, (DP) Government of Manipur,
Civil Secretariat Complex, Mantripukhri, Imphal795002
P a g e 2 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
4.
The Chief Engineer, Rural Engineering Department,
MSRRDA, Government of Manipur, 4th Floor, Secured
Office Building, AT-Line, 2nd MR Gate, Imphal,
Manipur-795001
… Official respondents
5.
Laishram Bidyabati Devi, Computer Operator/GIS
Mapping, Rural Engineering Department, posted at
Head Office, 4th Floor, Secured Office Building, ATLine, 2nd MR Gate, Imphal, Manipur-795001
6.
Jenson
Laishram,
Computer
Operator/GIS
Mapping, Rural Engineering Department, posted at
Head Office, 4th Floor, Secured Office Building, ATLine, 2nd MR Gate, Imphal, Manipur-795001
….. Private respondents
With
MC[W.P.(C)] No. 269 of 2026
Namoijam Jeetu, aged about 56 years, S/o (Late)
Shyamkishore Singh of Khagempalli Panthak, PO & PS
Imphal West District, Manipur-795001
…. Applicant
- versus 1.
The State of Manipur represented by the
Commissioner (RD & PR), Government of Manipur,
Civil Secretariat Complex, Mantripukhri, Imphal795002
2.
The Secretary, Manipur Public Service Commission
(MPSC), North AOC, D.M. Road, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001
P a g e 3 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
3.
The Deputy Secretary, (DP) Government of Manipur,
Civil Secretariat Complex, Mantripukhri, Imphal795002
4.
The Chief Engineer, Rural Engineering Department,
MSRRDA, Government of Manipur, 4th Floor, Secured
Office Building, AT-Line, 2nd MR Gate, Imphal,
Manipur-795001
… Official respondents
5.
Laishram Bidyabati Devi, Computer Operator/GIS
Mapping, Rural Engineering Department, posted at
Head Office, 4th Floor, Secured Office Building, ATLine, 2nd MR Gate, Imphal, Manipur-795001
6.
Jenson Laishram, Computer Operator/GIS Mapping,
Rural Engineering Department, posted at Head
Office, 4th Floor, Secured Office Building, AT-Line,
2nd MR Gate, Imphal, Manipur-795001
….. Private respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For petitioners
:
Mr. David Boon, Advocate
Date of order
:
31.07.2026
P a g e 4 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
O R D E R
(Oral)
[Order of the Court was made by Mr. M. Sundar, CJ]
[1]
Following abbreviations/short forms have been used in this
order (for the sake of brevity, convenience and clarity):
Sl. Abbreviation/short
Full form / Expansion
No. form/other
short
references
1. Impugned Rules
Rural Engineering Department (RED)
under
RD
&
PR
Department,
Government of Manipur Section Officer
(IT) Grade – I Recruitment Rules, 2022
2. Impugned
Proceedings of Expert Committee dated
proceedings
09.03.2026
3. Impugned order
Order dated 10.03.2026 bearing
reference No. 4/18/2023-RD&PR(HC)
made by respondent No. 1
4. R-1
Respondent No. 1, to be noted similar
abbreviations shall be used for
respondent Nos. 2 to 6 also
5. WP
Writ petition
6. MC
Miscellaneous Case
7. RD & PR
Rural Development and Panchayat Raj
8. DP
Department of Personnel
9. RED/MSRRDA
Rural Engineering Department/Manipur
State Rural Roads Development Agency
10. S.O.
Section Officer
[2]
Factual matrix in a nutshell i.e. short facts shorn of
elaboration and particulars which are not imperative for appreciating
instant order are that 19 (nineteen) individuals were appointed as
Computer Operators/GIS Mapping under Rural Engineering Department,
Government of Manipur on contractual basis on various dates between
P a g e 5 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
04.02.2006 and 16.09.2016; that 9 (nine) out of 19 (nineteen)
individuals were regularized on 16.09.2016 and remaining 10 (ten) were
regularised on 02.11.2016; that in the interregnum, Government of
Manipur by executive order dated 19.10.2016, created 3 (three)
temporary posts and one of them is S.O.(IT) Grade – I and this Court is
informed that S.O. denotes Section Officer; that while creating this S.O.
(IT) Grade–I post, State had proposed decree/diploma in Electronics and
Communication Engineering, Electronics and Electrical Engineering,
Information Technology as educational qualifications required for the
post and had suggested promotion as a method of recruitment; that
thereafter, said rules were made by State in exercise of powers under
proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India; that in and vide said
rules, educational qualifications substantially remained the same as
proposed but degree or diploma in Computer Science and Engineering
was added and as regards method of recruitment, it was set out in the
said rules that it can be by promotion, failing which by direct
recruitment; that as regards promotion, Computer Operator / GIS
Mapping is the feeder post but those possessing degree or diploma in
Electronics and Communication Engineering, Electronics and Electrical
Engineering,
Information
Technology/Computer
Science
and
Engineering with 5 (five) years regular service in the grade for Degree
holders 8 years service for diploma holders were made the eligibility
P a g e 6 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
criteria; that out of the 19 (nineteen) individuals who were appointed on
contractual basis on various dates between 04.02.2006 and 16.09.2016
thereafter regularized on 16.09.2016 and 02.11.2016, only two
individuals possess requisite qualifications as they have degrees in
engineering one B.E.(ECE) and another B.E.(CSE); that it is to be noted,
that these two individuals have been arrayed as R-5 and R-6 in captioned
writ petition; that the set of rules which is being referred to as impugned
rules was assailed earlier by serving Computer Operators/GIS Mapping
and predecessor Hon’ble Bench in and by order dated 29.01.2025 made
in W.P.(C) No. 361 of 2023 directed State to consider a representation
dated 23.09.2019; that it is to be noted, there were 15 (fifteen) writ
petitioners in W.P.(C) No. 361 of 2023; that pursuant to this judicial
order dated 29.01.2025, an Expert Committee sat on 09.03.2026,
reconsidered impugned rules and came to the conclusion that the same
does not warrant any change inter alia considering the responsibilities
and job profile of S.O. (IT) which was accepted by State vide impugned
order; that assailing impugned rules, impugned proceedings and
impugned order with some other prayers such as a direction to declare
that the post of Computer Operator cannot be treated as feeder post
qua S.O. (IT) and a direction to respondents to frame a rational
promotional hierarchy for the cadre of Computer Operators have been
filed.
P a g e 7 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
[3]
Mr. David Boon, learned counsel on record for writ
petitioners is before this Court in the Admission Board.
[4]
At the outset, it is deemed appropriate to write that out of
19 (nineteen) individuals who were originally appointed as Computer
Operators/GIS Mapping, two of them possess requisite qualifications and
as already alluded to supra in factual matrix, they have been arrayed as
R-5 and R-6 (private respondents) and out of remaining 17 (seventeen),
15 (fifteen) chose to file earlier writ {W.P.(C) No. 361 of 2023} and now
13 (thirteen) have chosen to file captioned writ petition.
[5]
Mr. David Boon, learned counsel on record for writ
petitioner, notwithstanding myriad grounds raised in the writ petition
predicated his campaign against impugned rules, impugned proceedings
and impugned order on following points:
(i)
at the time of creation of post, the proposal did not
include degree/diploma in Computer Science and
Engineering but the same has now been included in
impugned rules;
(ii)
the conditions of service have been altered post
employment the goal post has been re-set and the
same is not permissible;
(iii)
there is discrimination qua Computer Operators/GIS
Mapping as amongst those now serving as Computer
P a g e 8 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
Operators/GIS Mapping, all of them do not possess
degree or diploma in Engineering which has now
been made requisite qualification for promotion;
(iv)
the impugned rules have been tailor cut for
facilitating R-5 and R-6.
[6]
This Court carefully considered the aforesaid four points
raised by learned counsel for writ petitioners. As regards first point, the
order dated 19.10.2016 bearing reference No. 7/15/2012-RD(MC)Pt.
1/2140 vide which S.O. (IT) Grade – I post was created is an executive
order traceable to Article 162 of Constitution of India. It is an executive
order by which three temporary posts were created and S.O. (IT) Grade
– I is one of the three posts. As regards the impugned rules, the same
are a set of rules made in exercise of powers under proviso to Article
309 of Constitution of India. A proposal/suggestion in an executive order
traceable to Article 162 of Constitution of India as regards the
qualification for post created cannot control rules made in exercise of
powers under proviso to Article 309 of Constitution of India as rules
made under proviso to Article 309 of Constitution of India have statutory
flavour. To put it differently, suggestions/proposals in executive
instructions issued under Article 162 of the Constitution of India, cannot
control Rule making powers or rules which have statutory flavour made
in exercise of powers under proviso to Article 309 of Constitution of
P a g e 9 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
India. This is end of the road as regards the first point urged by learned
counsel for writ petitioner. To be noted, in any event, none of the
thirteen writ petitioners have either degree or diploma in engineering
therefore, adding degree or diploma in Computer Science and
Engineering does not in any manner affect or even touch the writ
petitioners.
[7]
This takes this Court to the second point urged by learned
counsel for writ petitioner. The second point, as already alluded to supra
is that the goal post has been changed after recruitment/employment.
To put it differently, conditions of service have been altered after
employment is the second point. In the considered view of this Court,
this argument is clearly a non-starter and it is no argument. The reason
is, on the date of engagement of writ petitioners as Computer
Operator/GIS Mapping, the promotional post i.e. S.O. (IT) Grade – I did
not exist. To add clarity, as would be evident from allusion in factual
matrix supra, the thirteen writ petitioners were engaged on various dates
between 04.02.2006 and 16.09.2016 on contractual basis whereas the
promotional post i.e. S.O.(IT) Grade – I was created only on 19.10.2016.
On the date of engagement, there was no promotional post at all and
therefore this Court has no hesitation in saying that the argument that
the goal post has been changed after employment i.e., conditions of
service have been altered post employment is a non-starter.
P a g e 10 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
[8]
This takes this Court to the third point and this point
pertains to discrimination. Admittedly, as would be evident from the
paper book (Annexure-A/2) placed before this Court by writ petitioners,
out of nineteen individuals who were engaged as Computer
Operators/GIS Mapping on contractual basis, only two of them were
engineering
graduates,
the
remaining
seventeen
were
neither
engineering graduates nor diploma holders in engineering. This means
that R-5, R-6 and thirteen writ petitioners are not equals. In this view
of the matter, the argument predicated on discrimination pales into
insignificance.
To be noted, the impugned rules also provides for
promotional avenue to those who acquire the qualification of degree or
diploma in engineering while in service. Therefore, there was no
impediment for writ petitioners to seek promotion if they have acquired
degree or diploma in engineering even after being engaged in/while in
service.
[9]
This takes this Court to the last and fourth point on which
writ petitioners’ counsel predicated his campaign against the impugned
rules, impugned proceedings and impugned order. This argument is that
the rules have been designed/tailor cut by to facilitate R-5 and R-6
(private respondents) who were two individuals who were engineering
graduates even on the date of engagement as Computer Operators/GIS
Mapping. A careful perusal of the impugned proceedings brings to light
P a g e 11 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
that an Expert Committee consisting of Joint Secretary (RD & PR), Joint
Secretary (DP), Joint Secretary (Finance Department) and Chief
Engineer (RED)/MSRRDA, Government of Manipur has gone into /
examined the duties and responsibilities of S.O. (IT) Grade – I and it has
been clearly articulated that the duties and functions of S.O. (IT) is
technical in nature and that the duties are primarily anchored on
assisting the Assistant Engineer (IT) and IT Nodal Officer in resolving IT
related matters of the Department and S.O.(IT) Grade – I is responsible
for updating master data on OMMAS (Online Management Monetary and
Accounting System). S.O. (IT) has also to help the staff concerned in
preserving details of data and information regarding identification of
Core Network of Rural Road Plan, Proposal, from Core Network (as a
part of Tendering Procedure), Quality, Monitoring Reports, recording of
Receipt and Payments of works, expenditure, viewing report of real time
statics etc. Therefore, the qualification prescribed is clearly relatable to
and relevant to the duties and responsibilities which S.O. (IT) has to
perform. It is clearly technical in nature. In this view of the matter, the
argument that the said rules were made solely to facilitate R-5 and R-6
does not cut ice with us much less in the Admission Board.
[10]
All the four points, qua which learned counsel for writ
petitioners predicated his campaign against the impugned rules,
impugned proceedings and impugned order fail to cut ice with us.
P a g e 12 | 13
2026:MNHC:149-DB
[11]
Before writing the concluding paragraph of this order, this
Court deems it appropriate to respectfully remind itself that in service
jurisprudence, promotion is not a right and at the highest an individual
has a right to be considered for promotion.
[12]
Ergo, the sequitur is, captioned WP fails to pass muster in
the Admission Board and the same is dismissed. Consequently,
captioned MC thereat also perishes with the captioned main WP and the
same is also dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Bipin
signed by
KHOIROM Digitally
KHOIROM
BIPINCHANDRA
BIPINCHAN Date: 2026.08.01SINGH
DRA SINGH 19:42:07 +05'30'
P a g e 13 | 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review