Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MNHC:166
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 905 of 2025
With
WP(C) No. 384 of 2026
With
MC(WP(C)) No. 407 of 2026
With
MC(WP(C)) No. 834 of 2025
1.
Smt. Shanta Keithellakpam, aged about 46 years, W/o. Urikhimbam
Manadeva Singh of Wangkhei Konsam Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur-795005.
… Petitioner/Applicant
- Versus 1.
The State of Manipur represented by the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner/
Secretary
(Higher
&
Technical
Education),
Government of Manipur, office at Old Secretariat Building, Babupara,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West, Manipur-795001;
2.
The Joint Secretary (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur,
Office at New Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West, Manipur-795001;
3.
The Director of University & Higher Education, Government of
Manipur, Office at Nityaipat Chuthek Near Raj Bhavan, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur- 795001 and
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
4.
The Controller of Technical Education, Manipur and its Office at
Government Polytechnic, Imphal Takyelpat, P.O. & P.S. Patsoi,
Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
5.
Dr. Kharibam Jilenkumari Devi, aged about 41 years, W/o Dr. Okram
Jotinkumar Singh, resident of Wangjing Heitupokpi Mamang Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Wangjing, District Thoubal, Manipur-795148.
… Respondents
With
WP(C) No. 880 of 2025
With
WP(C) No. 523 of 2025
With
MC(WP(C)) No. 502 of 2025
With
MC(WP(C)) No. 760 of 2025
With
MC(WP(C)) No. 810 of 2025
With
MC(WP(C)) No. 870 of 2025
1.
Shri L. Meghachandra Singh, aged about 52 years, S/o L. Iboyaima
Singh of Kongba Road, Singjamei Bheigyabati Leikai P.O. & P.S.
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur, Pin- 795008;
2.
Smt. Sandhyarani Loitongbam, aged about 45 years, D/o Loitongbam
Mangi Singh of Thoubal Awang Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Thoubal, Manipur,
Pin- 795138 and
3.
Smt. Ajita Khundrakpam, aged about 44 years, C/o Thiyam Gambhir
Singh of Khongman Zone-II West, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei, Imphal East
District, Manipur, Pin- 795008.
… Petitioners/Applicants
- Versus WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
1.
The State of Manipur represented by the Chief Secretary/ the Principal
Secretary/ Commissioner/ Secretary (Higher & Technical Education),
Government of Manipur, Old Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. &
P.S. Imphal, Imphal West, Manipur-795001;
2.
The Joint Secretary (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur, New
Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West,
Manipur-795001;
3.
The Director of University & Higher Education, Government of
Manipur, Nityaipat Chuthek Near Raj Bhavan, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur- 795001 and
4.
The Controller of Technical Education, Manipur and its Office at
Government Polytechnic, Imphal Takyelpat, P.O. & P.S. Patsoi,
Imphal West District, Manipur.
… Respondents
With
MC(WP(C)) No. 388 of 2026
[in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025]
1.
Dr. Kharibam Jilenkumari Devi, aged about 41 years, W/o Dr. Okram
Jotinkumar Singh, resident of Wangjing Heitupokpi Mamang Leikai,
P.O. & P.S. Wangjing, District Thoubal, Manipur-795148.
… Applicant
- Versus –
1.
Smt. Shanta Keithellakpam, aged about 46 years, W/o. Urikhimbam
Manadeva Singh of Wangkhei Konsam Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur-795005.
… Principal Respondent
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
2.
The State of Manipur represented by the Principal Secretary/
Commissioner/
Secretary
(Higher
&
Technical
Education),
Government of Manipur, office at Old Secretariat Building, Babupara,
P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West, Manipur-795001;
3.
The Joint Secretary (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur,
Office at New Secretariat Building, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West, Manipur-795001;
4.
The Director of University & Higher Education, Government of
Manipur, Office at Nityaipat Chuthek Near Raj Bhavan, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur- 795001 and
5.
The Controller of Technical Education, Manipur and its Office at
Government Polytechnic, Imphal Takyelpat, P.O. & P.S. Patsoi,
Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
… Official Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners
:
Mr. M. Rendy, Adv. & Ms. Gunapriya, Adv.
[in WP(C) Nos. 905 of 2025 & 384 of
2026], Mr. Ng. Jotindra Luwang, Adv. &
Ms. W. Geetarani, Adv. [in WP(C) Nos.
523 of 2025 & 880 of 2025].
For the respondents
:
Mr. M. Devananda, Addl. AG &
Ms. N. Jyotsana, Adv. [for State],
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, Sr. Adv., Mr. Jamon,
Adv. & Mr. Rustam, Adv. [respondent
no. 5 in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025]
Date of reserved
:
18.07.2026
Date of Judgement
:
12.08.2026
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Present Mr. M. Rendy, learned counsel along with Ms.
Gunapriya, learned counsel and Mr. Ng. Jotindra Luwang, learned counsel
along with Ms. W. Geetarani, learned counsel on behalf of the writ
petitioners; Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. Advocate General assisted
by Ms. N. Jyotsana, learned counsel on behalf of the State respondents;
and Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned sr. counsel assisted by Mr. Jamon,
learned counsel and Mr. Rustam, learned counsel for the respondent no.
5 in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025.
[2]
WP(C) No. 523 of 2025 is also filed by the same 3 writ
petitioners in WP(C) No. 880 of 2025 with the following prayers:
(i)
to issue a writ in the nature of certiorari or any other
appropriate writ, orders or quashing the impugned letter
dated 15.05.2025 (Annexure-A/25) of the Joint
Secretary (Hr. &Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur as
arbitrary, malafide and unconstitutional;
(ii) to issue a writ in the nature of mandamus or any other
appropriate writ, orders or directions directing the
respondents to regularize of the service of the petitioners
as
Lecturer in Government Polytechnic, Imphal forthwith as
was done in case of similarly situated persons;
(iii) to
direct
the
respondents
for
payment
of
due
remuneration for working as Guest Lecturer in their
respective faculty(s) at the Government Polytechnic,
Imphal for the period from 02.03.2022 till date.
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
(iv) to pass an interim order directing the respondents not to
oust the petitioners from their service during the
pendency of the writ petition;
(v) to pass an interim order directing the respondents to
release the remuneration due to the petitioners for the
period from 02.03.2022 till date;
(vi) to suspend the operation of the impugned letter dated
15.05.2025(Annexure-A/25)
issued
by
the
Joint
Secretary (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur
during the pendency of the writ petition;
(vii) to direct the respondents for heavy costs and;
(viii) to pass any further order or orders as the Hon'ble High
Court may seem fit and proper for the ends of justice and
equity.
[3]
WP(C) No. 880 of 2025 is filed by the 3 writ petitioners, who
are Guest Lecturers [2 Guest Lecturers in Pharmacy and 1 in Mathematics]
for quashing the impugned letter dated 21.09.2025 issued by the Joint
Secretary (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Govt. of Manipur and the impugned
notification dated 31.10.2025 issued by the Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur and the prayer is reproduced below:
(i)
to issue a writ in the nature of certiorari or any other
appropriate writ, orders or quashing the impugned letter
dated 21.09.2025(Annexure-A/28) issued by the Joint
Secretary (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur
and
the
impugned
notification
dated
31.10.2025
(Annexure-A/30) issued by the Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur to the extent of the petitioners as
arbitrary, malafide and unconstitutional;
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
(ii) to pass an interim order directing the respondents not to
fill up one post of Lecturer (Mathematics) and two posts
of Lecturers (Pharmacy) against the vacancies notified in
impugned notification dated 31.10.2025 (AnnexureA/30) during the pendency of the writ petition;
(iii) to suspend the operation of the impugned letter dated
21.09.2025(Annexure-A/28)
issued
by
the
Joint
Secretary (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur
and
the
impugned
notification
dated
31.10.2025
(Annexure-A/30) issued by the Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur to the extent of the petitioners during
the pendency of the writ petition;
(iv) to direct the respondents for heavy costs and;
(v) to pass any further order or orders as the Hon'ble High
Court may seem fit and proper for the ends of justice and
equity.
[4]
The petitioner, who is a Guest Lecturer in Electronics &
Communication Engineering filed the WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 under Article
226 of the Constitution of India inter-alia praying for setting aside the
impugned letter dated 21.09.2025 issued by the Joint Secretary (Hr. &
Tech. Education), Govt. of Manipur; any consequential action, notification,
letter pursuant to impugned letter dated 21.09.2025; and to set-aside the
impugned notification dated 31.10.2025 issued by the Controller of
Technical Education, Manipur in respect of sl. no. 4 Lecturer (Electronics
& Communication Engineering). The prayer of the petitioner is reproduced
below:
(i)
To admit the present writ petition.
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
(ii) To issue rule nisi calling upon the respondent to show
cause as to why prayer made by the petitioners shall not
be granted in the facts and circumstances of the present
petition.
(iii) To issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari/ Mandamus or
any other appropriate writ / orders / directions to quash
and set aside the impugned letter dated 21.09.2025
(ANNEXURE-A/27) issued by the Joint Secretary (Hr.
& Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur and any
consequential action, notification, letter pursuant to
impugned letter dated 21.09.2025, in view of the facts
and circumstances of the present petition.
(iv) To issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari/ Mandamus or
any other appropriate writ / orders / directions to quash
and
set
31.10.2025
aside
the
impugned
notification
dated
issued
the
(ANNEXURE-A/28)
by
Controller of Technical Education, Manipur in respect of
Sl. No. 4 (Lecturer, Electronics & Communication
Engineering) and any consequential action, notification,
letter
pursuant
to
impugned
Notification
dated
31.10.2025, in view of the facts and circumstances of the
present petition.
(v) If no cause is shown or insufficient cause is shown, make
the rule absolute.
(vi) To call for the entire relevant records.
(vii) To pass any order/ writ/ directions which the Hon'ble
Court deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances
of the present case.
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
[5]
WP(C) No. 384 of 2026 is also filed by the same petitioner
in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
inter-alia praying for setting aside the impugned letter dated 15.05.2025
issued by the Joint Secretary (Hr. & Tech. Education), Govt. of Manipur;
any consequential action, notification, letter pursuant to impugned letter
dated 15.05.2025; and the prayer of the petitioner is reproduced below:
(i)
To admit the present writ petition.
(ii) To issue rule nisi calling upon the respondent to show
cause as to why prayer made by the petitioners shall not
be granted in the facts and circumstances of the present
petition.
(iii) To issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari/ Mandamus or
any other appropriate writ / orders / directions to quash
and set aside the impugned letter dated 15.05.2025
(ANNEXURE-A/27) issued by the Joint Secretary (Hr.
& Tech. Edn.), Government of Manipur and any
consequential action, notification, letter pursuant to
impugned letter dated 15.05.2025, in view of the facts
and circumstances of the present petition.
(iv) If no cause is shown or insufficient cause is shown, make
the rule absolute.
(v) To call for the entire relevant records.
(vi) To pass any order/ writ/ directions which the Hon'ble
Court deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances
of the present case.
[6]
MC(WP(C)) No. 407 of 2026 is filed in WP(C) No. 384 of 2026
for stayed of the letter dated 15.05.2025; MC(WP(C)) No. 834 of 2025 is
filed in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 for passing interim order/stay of the
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
appointment of 1 Guest Lecturer in Electronics & Communication
Engineering or not to fill up; MC(WP(C)) No. 502 of 2025 is filed in WP(C)
No. 523 of 2025 for passing interim order for releasing remuneration to
the petitioner for the period from 02.03.2022 till date and stay of letter
dated 15.05.2025; MC(WP(C)) No. 760 of 2025 is filed in WP(C) No. 523
of 2025 for not to fill up 1 post of Guest Lecturer in Mathematics and 2
posts of Guest Lecturer in Pharmacy; MC(WP(C)) No. 810 of 2025 is filed
in WP(C) No.880 of 2025 for passing interim order for not to fill up 1 post
of Guest Lecturer in Mathematics and 2 posts of Guest Lecturer in
Pharmacy; MC(WP(C)) No. 870 of 2025 is filed in WP(C) No. 523 of 2025
for passing interim order and MC(WP(C) No. 301 of 2026 is filed in WP(C)
No. 905 of 2025 for impleadment of respondent no. 5; and MC(WP(C)) No.
301 of 2026 is allowed and disposed of by this Court on 18.05.2026 by
impleading the applicant (Dr. Kharibam Jilenkumari Devi) as respondent
no. 5 in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025.
Brief facts common in all writ petitions are as follow:
[7]
An advertisement dated 13.02.2008 was issued by the
Controller of Technical Education, Manipur inviting applications from
interested candidates for engagement of Guest Lecturers in Civil
Engineering, Electronics Engineering, Pharmacy and Mathematics in the
Government Polytechnics, Imphal and the petitioners in this batch of writ
petitions applied for the said posts of Guest Lecturers. Vide order dated
15.07.2008, the petitioners were appointed as Guest Lecturers in Govt.
Polytechnics, Imphal for a period of 6(six) months with effect from the
date of joining. Thereafter, the service of the petitioners was extended
from time to time till 28.02.2022 by various Government convey letters
dated 30.08.2012, 11.02.2014, 19.01.2015, 19.07.2016, 05.10.2016,
05.10.2017, 25.10.2018, 08.03.2019, 05.01.2021 & 24.05.2022. Letter
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
dated 03.06.2022 was sent by the Controller of Technical Education,
Manipur to the Commissioner (Hr. & Technical Education), Govt. of
Manipur for extension of 4(four) Guest Lecturers [4 writ petitioners herein
i.e. 3 petitioners in WP(C) Nos. 523 of 2025, 880 of 2025 & 1 petitioner in
WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 & 384 of 2026] of the Govt. Polytechnic, Imphal.
It is stated that in case of similarly situated persons, who are working as
Guest Lecturers in several Government Colleges, their services were
extended from time to time in a similar manner to that of the present writ
petitioners and subsequently their service were regularized. For instance,
vide letter dated 26.09.2016 was issued by the Deputy Secretary (Hr. &
Tech. Edn.), Manipur to the Director of University & Higher Education,
Manipur conveying the Govt. approval for extension/re-engagement of
service of 49 (forty-nine) Guest Lecturers in Govt. College for 1(one) year
and their service were regularized by order dated 07.01.2022 of the
Commissioner (Hr. & Tech. Edn.), Manipur. As such, it is submitted that
the petitioners are also entitled to receive the similar benefits as granted
to the similarly situated persons in order dated 07.01.2022. It may be
mentioned that the petitioners have approached the authorities concerned
several times by submitting various representations dated 20.12.2020,
11.08.2023 and 10.09.2025 for regularization of their service as done in
the similarly situated persons and the authorities did not consider their
case.
[8]
It may be relevant to refer to a letter dated 24.02.2025
written by the Controller of Technical Education, Manipur to the
Commissioner (Higher & Technical Education), Manipur requesting to
extend the service of 4 Guest Lecturers (4 writ petitioners in this batch of
writ petitions) for another 3 years for the period from 02.03.2022 to
28.02.2025 with retrospective effect. It may be noted that the last
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
extension of the 4 writ petitioners was vide letter dated 24.05.2022 for a
period from 02.03.2021 to 28.02.2022. It may be noted that the 1 year
extension since the initial appointment in the year 2008, was done by
making one day gap in between each successive order. The proposal in
the letter dated 24.02.2025 of the Controller of Technical Education,
Manipur was returned by the Joint Secretary (Higher & Technical
Education), Manipur by a letter dated 27.03.2025 instructing to make the
proposal for extension of 1 year each by keeping one day gap each and
also to mention about the requirement for the next 4 years i.e. 02.03.2022
to 28.02.2026. Thereafter, Controller of Technical Education, Manipur
submitted another letter dated 28.04.2025 to the Commissioner (Higher &
Technical Education), Manipur for extension of the tenure of the 4 Guest
Lecturers (writ petitioners herein) for a period of 4 years by keeping one
day gap in between two orders. The request made by the Controller of
Technical Education, Manipur by each letter dated 24.02.2025 was
received by the Administrative Department, Govt. of Manipur and the
earlier proposal for engagement of Guest Lecturers awaiting direct
recruitment will be reviewed. A letter dated 15.05.2025 issued by Joint
Secretary, Higher & Technical Education, Manipur rejecting the proposal
for 3 years extension of the 4 Guest Lecturers (writ petitioners herein) for
the period from 02.03.2022 to 28.02.2025, has been challenged before
this Court in WP(C) No. 384 of 2026 & WP(C) No. 523 of 2025 by the 4
Guest Lecturers. Thereafter, Joint Secretary, Higher & Technical
Education, Manipur issued another letter dated 21.09.2025 to the
Controller of Technical Education, Manipur for engagement of 25 Guest
Lecturers in Govt. Polytechnic, Takyel with remuneration of Rs. 580/- per
lecture, subject to a maximum of Rs. 21,000/- in a month for Guest
Lecturer with Bachelor’s Degree and Rs.600/- per lecture, subject to a
maximum of Rs.21,600/- in a month for Guest Lecturer with Master’s
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
Degree. The list of 25 Guest Lecturers also includes Electronics &
Communication Engineering subject seen at sl. No. 4, Pharmacy at sl. no.
5 & Mathematics at sl. no. 7 in the Annexure-I of letter dated 21.09.2025.
The scanned copy of letter dated 21.09.2025 is reproduced herein below:
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
[9]
In pursuance to the direction in the letter dated 21.09.2025
of the Administrative Department, the Controller of Technical Education,
Manipur issued a notification dated 31.10.2025 calling for application from
intending candidates for engagement as Guest Lecturers, purely on
temporary basis in Govt. Polytechnic College for 25 posts in 10 subjects,
including the 4 subjects mentioned above and the minimum eligibility
criteria as per AICTE Regulations, adopted by the Department of Higher &
Technical Education, Govt. of Manipur and the mode of selection will be
100 marks test, consisting of 70 marks MCQs followed by a viva-voce of
30 marks. The letter dated 21.09.2025 issued by Administrative
Department to the Controller of Technical Education, Manipur for
engagement of 25 Guest Lecturers in 10 subjects and the notification dated
31.10.2025 issued by Controller of Technical Education, Manipur for
engagement of 25 posts as Guest Lecturers, have challenged before this
Court in WP(C) Nos. 880 of 2025 & 905 of 2025.
[10]
The learned counsel for the petitioners submit that the
petitioners have been duly appointed after a proper advertisement in the
year 2008 as Guest Lecturers and their service has been extended from
time to time till 28.02.2022, as the college is satisfied with their
performances. Even though there is no formal extension of their service
post 28.02.2022, they have been discharging their duties as Guest
Lecturers till today anticipating the ex post facto approval as done in past.
It is pointed out that in earlier occasion by letter dated 30.08.2012, the
service of the Guest Lecturers were extended from the period of 2009 to
2013 in bulk as post facto and in the present case also by letters dated
24.02.2025 & 28.04.2025, the Controller of Technical Education, Manipur
submitted a proposal to the Commissioner, Higher & Technical Education,
Manipur for ex post facto extension of the Guest Lecturers of the 4 writ
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
petitioners for the period from 02.03.2022 to 28.02.2026. The learned
counsel for the petitioners also refers to the Additional Affidavit filed in this
batch of writ petitions where; they have been engaged by order dated
12.01.2026 issued by the Principal of Govt. Polytechnic College. It is the
common case of the writ petitioners that the Guest Lecturers/contract
employees cannot be substituted by another set of Guest Lecturers/
contract employees, when such Guest Lecturers are discharging duty
without any complaint for the period more than 17 years. It is also pointed
out that the petitioners have been appointed after following due process
by open advertisement against the sanctioned posts and as such, they
cannot be substituted by another set of Guest Lecturers/contract
employees.
[11]
Mr. M. Rendy, learned counsel for the petitioner refers to the
wording used in the appointment letter especially order dated 15.07.2008
appointing Smt. Shanta Keithellakpam [petitioner in WP(C) Nos. 905 of
2025 & 384 of 2026] that her appointment is by way of contract
agreement; as such the so-called engagement of Guest Lecturers is
nothing but appointment of the petitioner as Lecturer on contract basis in
Govt. Polytechnic, College. He refers to the decisions of Hon’ble Supreme
Court reported in AIR 1989 SCC 1431 para nos. 5, 6 & 7 and Judgement
dated 30.08.2023 passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.
5876 of 2022. It is his submissions that there is no termination order of
the writ petitioners and no reason is given in the impugned letter dated
15.05.2025 regarding the request for extension of Guest Lectureship of
the 4 writ petitioners submitted by the Controller of Technical Education,
Manipur vide letter dated 28.04.2025. In order to buttress his submission
that a temporary employee cannot be replaced by another temporary
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
employee, the learned counsel for the petitioner refers the following case
laws:
1. Order dated 21.04.2022 passed in Civil Appeal No.
3084-3088 of 2022.
2. (2007) 13 SCC 293 para 2 & 3
3. (1992) 4 SCC 118 para 45 to 47
4. AIR 1996 SCC 1565 para 5
5. 2023 SCC Online Kerala 913
[12]
It is also submitted that the petitioner having worked
satisfactorily for a period of 17 years, she has legitimate expectation to
hold the post until regular appointment is made and for her regularization.
[13]
Mr. Ng. Jotindra Luwang, learned counsel for the petitioners
in WP(C) Nos. 523 of 2025 and 880 of 2025 adopts the submission of Mr.
M. Rendy, learned counsel for the petitioners in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 &
384 of 2026. It is submitted that the petitioners have been appointed in
the year 2008 by an open advertisement and having worked for continuous
17 years without any intervention from court, they are entitled for
regularization in terms of the Hon’ble Supreme Court decisions in the case
of “Secretary, State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi” reported in (2006)
4 SCC 1 (para 53). The learned counsel for the petitioners further refers
to the decisions of (i) “Hargurpratap Singh vs. State of Panjab &
Ors.” reported in (2007) 13 SCC 292 Para 3 and (ii) “Amrinder Kaur
vs. State of Punjab and Ors.” reported in (2016) SCC Online P&H
7383. It is submitted that in spite of interim order protecting status quo
as on date in order dated 17.07.2025 passed by this Court in WP(C) No.
523 of 2025, the respondents have proceeded and conducted the
examination. Hence, the subsequent letter dated 21.09.2025 issued by
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
Administrative Department and notification dated 31.10.2025 issued by
Controller of Technical Education, Manipur for engagement of 25 Guest
Lecturers in 10 subjects including the posts hold by the writ petitioners,
are liable to be set aside; as the same are issued in violation of the interim
order of the status quo. By an order dated 18.11.2025 in WP(C) No. 905
of 2025, this Court directed the respondents not to fill up 1 post of Lecturer
in Electronics & Communication Engineering without leave of this Court
and by a similar order dated 07.11.2025 in WP(C) No.880 of 2025, this
Court also passed an interim order directing the respondents not to fill up
1 post of Lecturer in Mathematics and 2 posts of Lecturer in Pharmacy till
next date. All the interim orders have been extended from time to time
and are operating till date.
[14]
Mr. M. Devananda, learned Addl. AG appearing on behalf of
the State respondents submitted that the 4 writ petitioners involved the
same issues regarding extension of their service of Guest Lecturers and
engagement of their service. The appointment of the petitioners as Guest
Lecturer in the year, 2008 and subsequent extension was purely on
temporary basis and time bound, and without any assurance of continuity
or regularization. The extension was given as per requirement for
engagement of Guest Lecturers in Govt. Polytechnic College from time to
time due to shortage of teaching faculty. He further pointed out that no
enforceable right arises merely from continuous engagement or in absence
of adverse remark. Hence, reliance on the provisions of Article 14, 16, 21,
23 & 43 is misplaced in absence of any legal entitlement to regularization
and the decisions cited by the petitioners are not applicable in the facts of
the present cases. It is submitted that the original notice dated 13.02.2008
issued by Controller of Technical Education, Manipur for engagement of
Guest Lecturers in Govt. Polytechnic College, was not against any
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
sanctioned post and the procedure for recruitment of Lecturers on regular
basis was not followed. The extension was necessitated keeping in mind
the acute shortage of teaching faculty in the Govt. Polytechnic College.
The learned Addl. AG has further highlighted that the decision in the case
of Uma Devi (supra) will not be applicable in the present case, as the
petitioners were not appointed against sanctioned posts and without
following due process of examination. They were appointed on the basis
of mere screening of the applications and documents. The learned Addl.
AG further pointed out that the letter dated 21.09.2025 issued by Higher
& Technical Education, Manipur to the Controller of Technical Education,
Manipur for engagement of 25 Guest Lecturers in 10 subjects on daily
remuneration is as per AICTE Regulations adopted by the Department of
Higher & Technical Education, Govt. of Manipur and the mode of selection
shall be 100 marks consisting of written examination (70 marks MCQs
followed by a viva-voce of 30 marks). It is highlighted that this new criteria
as per AICTE norm was absent in the earlier notification dated 13.02.2008
by which the petitioners were appointed. In the notification dated
31.10.2025, there is no age limitation; and the petitioner could have
applied. Regarding the interim order passed by this Court on 17.07.2025
in WP(C) No. 523 of 2025, it is clarified that the same was just an order of
status quo as on that day and the relevant para no. 8 of the order dated
17.07.2025 reads as follow:
“[8]
In the meantime and till the next date status quo as
on today shall be maintained in respect of the present
application.”
[15]
The learned Addl. AG has explained that status quo on the
day of passing of the order on 17.07.2025, it is admitted fact that service
of the petitioners was no longer extended and the last extension expired
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
on 28.02.2022. Hence, the status quo order reinforced the stand of the
respondents that the petitioners are no longer in the service of the Govt.
Polytechnic College as Guest Lecturers. Learned Addl. AG has pointed out
that taking classes post 28.02.2022 is simply on anticipation of post facto
extension; and the same was denied by letter dated 15.05.2025 issued by
Joint Secretary, Higher & Technical Education, Manipur. Any further
process of engagement of the 25 Guest Lecturers, in terms of the letter
dated 21.09.2025 issued by Joint Secretary, Higher & Technical Education,
Manipur and notification dated 31.10.2025 issued by Controller of
Technical Education, Manipur, does not violate the interim order dated
17.07.2025.
[16]
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned sr. counsel appearing on behalf
of newly impleaded respondent no. 5 [Dr. Kharibam Jilenkumari Devi in
WP(C) No. 905 of 2025, vide order dated 18.05.2026 passed by this Court
in MC(WP(C)) No. 301 of 2026] has also submitted that respondent no. 5
was not originally impleaded in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025. She is appointed
on the basis of notification dated 31.10.2025 and her name is included at
sl. no. 2 of the selected merit list of the candidates for appointment of
Guest Lecturers in Electronics & Communication Engineering subject. The
respondent no. 5 filed an application being MC(WP(C)) No. 388 of 2026 in
WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 for vacation/modification of the interim order dated
18.11.2025 passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025. It is submitted
that the name of the respondent No.5 was included in order dated
02.01.2026 issued by Controller of Technical Education, Manipur where,
list of candidates in 11 subjects were shortlisted for engagement for the
period of 1 year as Guest Lecturers and the name of the respondent no. 5
is at sl. no. 2 in Electronics & Communication Engineering subject. In the
notification dated 31.10.2025 issued by Controller of Technical Education,
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
Manipur, 2 posts were advertised for the subject of Electronics &
Communication Engineering, 4 posts for Pharmacy and 2 posts for
Mathematics for engagement as Guest Lecturer. By the interim order dated
17.07.2025 in WP(C) No. 523 of 2025, status quo was directed and by an
order dated 18.11.2025 in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025, this Court directed the
respondent not to fill up 1 post of Lecturer in Electronics & Communication
Engineering subject without leave of this Court. In the circumstances, the
respondent No.5, who is at sl. no. 2 in the merit list of Electronics &
Communication Engineering subject in terms of the notification dated
31.08.2025, could not be appointed even though, she was included at sl.
no. 2. It is pointed out that the interim order was passed without
impleading respondent no. 5 as party in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025.
Respondent no. 5 filed an application being MC(WP(C)) No. 301 of 2026
in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 for impleading her as respondent no. 5. It is
pointed out that the petitioner in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 and other
petitioners in WP(C) No. 523 of 2025 are not in the service of the Govt.
Polytechnic as their last extension expired on 28.02.2022 and the same
has not been extended. The proposal of the Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur vide its letter dated 24.02.2025 for 3 years post facto
extension from 02.03.2025 to 28.02.2025 was rejected by the
Administrative Department vide letter dated 15.05.2025. It is pointed out
that without challenging the letter dated 15.05.2025 rejecting the proposal
for extension of the tenure of the Guest Lecturers of the petitioners for 3
years, WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 was filed. The petitioners could not have
asked the prayer for stay of the appointment, as they are no longer in
service of the respondents. It is also pointed out that after taking the plea
of non-maintainability as the petitioner failed to challenge the letter dated
15.05.2025 rejecting her extension, the petitioner subsequently filed
another writ petition being WP(C) No. 384 of 2026 challenging the letter
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
dated 15.05.2025 of the Administrative Department rejecting the proposal
of the Controller of Technical Education, Manipur for extension of the
tenure of the 4 Guest Lecturers (Petitioners herein) with post facto effect
for 3 years. It is also submitted that subsequent WP(C) No. 384 of 2026 is
also not maintainable. It is urged that the interim order be vacated and
respondent no. 5 be permitted to join in terms of the result/order dated
02.01.2026 issued by Controller of Technical Education, Manipur. The
petitioner in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 also filed an objection to the
MC(WP(C)) No. 388 of 2026 filed by respondent no. 5 reiterating the stand
taken in the writ petition; stated that respondent no. 5 should have filed
an independent writ petition for a direction for her appointment; and the
application is not maintainable. The learned sr. counsel for the respondent
no. 5 refers to the decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “Shiv
Kumar Sharma vs. Santosh Kumari” reported in (2007) 8 SCC 600
to the proposition that what cannot be done directly should not be done
indirectly (para 21 & 22). It is pointed out that the petitioner failed to
challenge the letter dated 15.05.2025 issued by Joint Secretary, Higher &
Technical Education, Manipur rejecting the request for extension of the
tenure of the 4 Guest Lecturers (petitioners herein) and having failed to
challenge the letter dated 15.05.2025, she cannot challenge the
subsequent notification
dated
31.10.2025
inviting application
for
engagement of 25 Guest Lecturers in 10 different subjects. Regarding the
plea of the absence of termination order for the petitioners, it is pointed
out that in a tenure-post there is no requirement of termination letter, as
the engagement of the petitioners will automatically expire on the maturity
of the initial period and also the extended period. The proposition that
service of adhoc/contract employee cannot be replaced by another
contract/adhoc employee will not be applicable in the present case, as the
Guest Lecturers cannot be termed as temporary employees; and they are
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
getting honorarium per lecture and not on monthly basis. It is further
pointed out that the decisions cited for regularization will not be applicable
in the present case, as the service of the petitioner has not been extended
beyond 28.02.2022. The learned sr. counsel refers to the decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “U.P. State Electricity Board vs.
Pooran Chandra Pandey and others” reported in (2007) 11 SCC 92
to the point that the decision is an authority for what is actually decides,
and a little difference in facts or additional facts may make a lot of
difference in the precedential value of a decision. Since respondent no. 5
was duly selected after recruitment test in terms of the advertisement, she
is entitled to be appointed as Guest Lecturer.
POINTS FOR DETERMINATION:
[17]
The points for determination involved in the present cases
are:
(i) Whether the Guest Lecturer engaged in terms of the
initial notification dated 13.02.2008 is an engagement
against the sanctioned post? or,
(ii) Whether the petitioners were engaged in terms of notice
dated 13.02.2008 issued by Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur as stop gap arrangement?; &
(iii)
Whether the principle of contract/adhoc appointment
cannot be replaced by another set of contract/adhoc
employee will be applicable in the present case or not?
[18]
Before proceeding further, it will be relevant to enumerate
the admitted and undisputed facts in the present cases:
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
(i)
Notice dated 13.02.2008 was issued by Controller of
Technical Education, Manipur inviting Guest Lecturers of
Electronics & Communication Engineering, Pharmacy &
Mathematics in Govt. Polytechnic College and in terms of
the notification the 4 writ petitioners and others were
appointed for a period of 6 months.
(ii) Vide letter dated 30.08.2012 issued by Under Secretary,
Technical Education, Manipur that service of 7 Guest
Lecturers was extended with retrospective effect from
the period 18.01.2009 to 28.02.2013.
(iii) By another letter dated 11.02.2014 of the Administrative
Department, the service of the 7 Guest Lecturers were
extended for another period of 1 years from 02.03.2013
to 28.02.2014 and ultimately, the last extension for 4
Guest Lecturer was vide letter dated 24.05.2022 for
period from 02.03.2021 to 28.02.2022. In the last
extension of 4 Guest Lecturers are 4 writ petitioners
herein. It may be noted that in every extension, there is
a gap of 1 day and petitioners are re-engaged from the
second of March of the corresponding years by giving a
gap of one day i.e. 1st March of the year, out of the
extension.
(iv) It is the case of the writ petitioners that in spite of formal
non-extension
after
28.02.2022,
they
have
been
discharging their duties as Guest Lecturers in Govt.
Polytechnic College till date. In this respect, photocopy
of the attendance register has been filed by the petitioner
by way of an additional affidavit.
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
(v) By a letter dated 24.02.2025 written by the Controller of
Technical Education, Manipur to the Commissioner,
Higher & Technical Education, Manipur a request was
made for extension of the service of the 4 Guest
Lecturers (petitioners herein) for a period of 3 years
w.e.f. 02.03.2022 to 28.02.2025.
(vi) The request for 3 years post facto extension for
engagement of 4 Guest Lecturers was rejected by the
Joint Secretary, Higher & Technical Education, Manipur
by a letter dated 15.05.2025 to the Controller of
Technical Education, Manipur. It is alleged that in spite
of rejection of the extension of the engagement of 4
Guest Lecturers, by various orders issued by the Principal
and other Authorities, the petitioners are still working in
Govt. Polytechnic College. It may be noted that there is
no approval of engagement of the 4 Guest Lecturers,
post 28.02.2025 from the Administrative Department.
[19]
In these 4 writ petitions, (i) letter dated 15.05.2025 rejecting
the extension of the engagement of 4 Guest Lecturers; (ii) letter dated
21.09.2025 issued by Joint Secretary, Higher & Technical Education,
Manipur to the Controller of Technical Education, Manipur informing to
engage 25 Guest Lecturers in 10 subjects of Govt. Polytechnic College; and
(iii) notification dated 31.10.2025 issued by the Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur issuing notification for engagement of 25 Guest
Lecturers in Govt. Polytechnic College including 2 posts in Electronics &
Communication Engineering, 4 in Pharmacy & 2 in Mathematics, are
challenged. Interim order dated 17.07.2025 was passed by this Court in
WP(C) No. 523 of 2025 for maintaining status quo as on that day; interim
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
order dated 07.11.2025 was passed in WP(C) No. 880 of 2025 restraining
the respondents not to fill up 1 post of Mathematics and 2 posts of
Pharmacy without leave of this Court and interim order dated 18.11.2025
was passed in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 for not to fill up 1 post of Guest
Lecturer in Electronics & Communication Engineering without leave of this
Court. The interim order dated 18.11.2025 restraining from filling up 1 post
of Guest Lecturer in Electronics & Communication Engineering was passed
without impleading the respondent no. 5, who was selected at sl. no. 2 for
the post graduate in the same subject.
[20]
Interim order in WP(C) No. 880 of 2025 restraining from
filling up 1 post of Mathematics & 2 posts in Pharmacy was passed without
impleading the selected/recommended candidates. In order to have better
understanding of the issues at hand, it would be appropriate to reproduce
the original notice dated 13.02.2008 issued by Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur for engagement of Guest Lecturers in Civil
Engineering, Electronics Engineering, Mathematics & Pharmacy in Govt.
Polytechnic College and the scanned copy of the same is reproduced
below:
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
[21]
The scanned copy of notification dated 31.10.2025 issued by
the Controller of Technical Education, Manipur for engagement of 25 Guest
Lecturers is reproduced below:
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
[22]
From the above scanned reproduction, it is seen from the
notice dated 13.02.2008 that the same did not mention about the
appointment will be against sanctioned post and does not prescribe any
mode of selection. Perhaps, the appointment was on the basis of
verification of the applications and original documents of the candidates
by a screening committee, without following any procedure in terms of
the applicable recruitment rules. However, in the notification dated
31.10.2025 for recruitment of 25 Guest Lecturers, the minimum eligibility
criteria will be in terms of the AICTE Regulations, adopted by the
Department of Higher & Technical Education, Govt. of Manipur and the
mode of selection shall be on the basis of written examination of 70 marks
MCQs followed by viva-voce of 30 marks; and the candidates like the
respondent no. 5 in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025, were appointed on the basis
of the procedure prescribed and after fulfilling the minimum AICTE
criteria as adopted by the Govt. of Manipur. It may be noted that while
extending the engagement of the petitioners as Guest Lecturers from
time to time, no formal test was conducted; the same was on temporary
basis; and in order to augment the shortage of teaching faculty in the
Govt. Polytechnic College. There is also 1 day gap in between extension
from 1 year to another year. The notification dated 31.10.2025 does not
prescribe any age limit, as the nature of Guest Lectureship is only to
augment the temporary shortage in the teaching faculty. This shows that
the engagement of Guest Lecturers does not have any permanency.
While issuing necessary appointment order dated 15.07.2008 to the
petitioner in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025 (Smt. Shanta Keithellakpam), it was
specifically mentioned in second para that the appointment shall have no
right to claim for extension of the term of her contract appointment and
the validity of the order shall lapse on expiry of 6 months and similar
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
orders are issued for other appointment of Guest Lecturers. The scanned
reproduction initial engagement order of the same is shown below:
[23]
On perusal of the initial
engagement order
dated
15.07.2008, this clearly shows that the appointment will lapse after expiry
of 6 months and with no right to claim for extension. However, due to
exigency in the service, the appointment has been extended from time
to time without any assurance for regularization. Nothing is mentioned to
the effect that the engagement against any sanctioned post.
[24]
This Court does not find any substances in the submissions
of the learned counsel for the petitioners to the point that termination
order has not been issued till date. Admittedly, the last extension expired
on 28.02.2022; there is no further extension; and proposal for further
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
extension has already been rejected by the administrative department by
letter dated 15.05.2025. This Court is of the considered view that in view
of contents in the second para of initial engagement order dated
15.07.2008 (similar order for other engagement), the engagement will
automatically expire on the maturity of the initial period of engagement
and the extended period, if any. Admittedly in the present cases, there is
no extension order, post 28.02.2022 and the proposal for extension of 3
years post facto by letter dated 24.02.2025 of the Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur was rejected by the Administrative Department vide
letter dated 15.05.2025.
[25]
In view of the above discussions, findings and observations,
this Court answers the 3 issues framed as (i) the engagement of the
petitioners in terms of the initial notice dated 13.02.2008 is not against
the sanctioned posts and is purely on engagement basis without any
assurance of extension and regularization; (ii) their engagement is purely
as stop gap arrangement due to shortage of teaching faculty in Govt.
Polytechnic College, Takyel; and (iii) the principles of one contract/adhoc
employee cannot be replaced by another set of adhoc/contract employee
will not be applicable to the facts of the present cases; (iv) their
engagement is not against sanctioned posts and on the basis of per
lecture honorarium and they are not paid on the basis of monthly
honorarium.
CONCLUSION:
[26]
In conclusion, this Court passes the following directions &
observations:
(i)
The petitioners and others were engaged on the basis
of notice dated 13.02.2008 issued by the Controller of
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
Technical Education, Manipur purely on temporary
basis, time bound and as stop gap arrangement;
(ii) Their
appointment
was
never
intended
against
sanctioned posts; the appointment order itself says that
they have no right for extension and on the expiry of
the last extension on 28.02.2022, there is no further
extension; and the proposal for 3 years extension vide
letter dated 24.02.2025 of the Controller of Technical
Education, Manipur has already been rejected by the
Administrative Department, Govt. of Manipur vide letter
dated 15.05.2025.
(iii) WP(C) Nos. 905 of 2025, 880 of 2025, 523 of 2025 and
384 of 2026 are dismissed. Interim orders stand
vacated.
(iv) The respondents are directed to issue appointment
order forthwith to the candidates whose appointment
has been stayed by this Court [including respondent
No.5 in WP(C) No. 905 of 2025] and the period of 1 year
will be counted from the day, the new appointees have
taken charge.
(v) MC(WP(C)) Nos. 407 of 2026, 834 of 2025, 502 of 2025,
760 of 2025, 810 of 2025, 870 of 2025 and 388 of 2026
are also disposed of in terms of the above directions &
observations.
(vi) Parties are directed to bear their own costs.
(vii) If the petitioners are actually working without any
formal extension post 28.02.2022 (as alleged by the
petitioners), such period shall be verified by the
Controller of Technical Education, Manipur; and the
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
2026:MNHC:166
petitioners may claim their entitlement for remuneration
for the lectures they have already undertaken.
However, the same does not amount to extension of
their service by this Court.
(viii) Regarding the plea of regularization, this Court does not
express any opinion and the issue is left open to the
wisdom of the competent authority to proceed as per
rules, if the petitioners are so eligible.
(ix) Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to
the Controller of Technical Education, Manipur for
information and necessary compliance.
Oinam
Thoiba
Meitei
JUDGE
Oinam Thoiba Meitei
Date: 2026.08.12
16:23:31 +05'30'
FR/NFR
Thoiba
WP(C) Nos. 905, 880, 523 of 2025 with WP(C) Nos. 384 of 2026 with MC(WP(C)) Nos. 388, 407 of 2026 with
MC(WP(C)) Nos. 502, 760, 810, 834, 870 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review