Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3485 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENry THIRD DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NO: 1558 OF 2009
Between:
1. Mohd. Abdul Jabbar, S/o. Late Md. Moulana Saheb Muslim, Aged about 33
years, Business, Rl/o. H.No. 2-1-1701213, Amarawadi Nagar, Suryapet Village
and Mandal, Nalgonda District.
2. Mohd. Abdul Gaffar, S/o. Late Md. Moulana Saheb Muslim, aged about 30
years, Employee,
Rl/o. H.No. 2-1-1701213, Amarawadi Nagar,
Suryapet Village and Mandal, Nalgonda District.
...PETITIONERS
AND
The Municipal Counsel, Suryapet Municipality, Suryapet, Nalgonda District,
Rep by its Chairman
The Municipality, Suryapet, Rep by its Commissioner, Suryapet, Nalgonda
District.
Shaik Tajuddin, S/o. Late Nabi Saheb, Muslim, Advocate, H.No. 1-1-469,
Nehru Nagar, Suryapet, Nalgonda District.
4. Shaik Gulam Dastagiri, S/o. Late Nabi Saheb, Muslim, Business, R/o
Tungathurthy Village and Mandal, Nalgonda District.
5. Shaik Abdul Raheem, S/o. Late Nabi Saheb, Muslim, Business, Rl/o.
Tungathurthy Village and Mandal, Nalgonda District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 ol the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly a Writ of Mandamus
declaring the proceedings of the 1st respondent dated 22-1-2009 issued in
proceedings No. M.C.R. No. 749 along with proceedings of the 2nd respondent
dated 1B-10-2008 issued in Proc. No. A11241412008 as arbitrary, illegal, contrary
to rules, without application of mind and also with a prejudiced mind to help the
respondents 3 to 5 and consequently direct the respondents I and 2 not to
entertain any mutalion proceedings or any other proposals as long as the
respondents 3 to 5 do not establish their rights over any part of the property
situated in H.No. 2-1-1701213 including open land comprising 546 square yards
situated at Aaravadi Veedi, Suryapet, Nalgonda through a competent Civil Court
and further direct the respondents No. 2 to take further steps to mutate the names
of the petitioners in place of their late fater in the assessment registers of the 2nd
respondent.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2009(WPMP- NO: 1974 OF 2009)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the impugned proceedings of the 1st respondent dated 22-1-2009 issued
in Proceedings of the 2nd respondent dated 1 B- 1 0-2008 issued in Proc. No. A1 2414|2OOB in respect of part of the property situated in H.No. 2-1-1701213 including
open land comprising 546 square yards situated at Aaravadi Veedi, Suryapet,
Nalgonda District pending disposal of the writ petition.
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased be
pleased to permit the petitioners to file the additional documents i.e., (1) Plaint in
O.S. No.140 of 2006 (2) Copy of Written Statement of D1 in O.S. No.140 of 2006
(3) Copy of Written Statement of D2 and D3 in O.S. No.'140 of 2006 (4) Copy of
order in l.A.No.43B of 2009 in O S.No 140 of 2006 dated: 12.03.2010, (5) Copy of
order in lA No. 526 of 2006 in O.S.No.140 of 2006 dated: 14.08.2008 and (6) Copy
of Report submitted by Advocate Commissioner in lA No.664 of 2006 in OS
No.'140 of 2006.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI T. P. ACHARYA
Counsel forthe Respondent Nos.1 and 2: SRI PUTTA KRISHNA REDDY,
SC FOR MUNICIPALITIES
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.3 to 5: SRI P S P SURESH KUMAR
The Court made the following: ORDER
)
I
IN THE HIGH COURT ITOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SITI JUSTICE SUT]DALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIl'PETI'TION NO.1558 OF 2OO9
DATE:23.01.2026
Bctween:
Mohd. Abdul Jabbar s/o. late Mci.Moulana Saheb,
r/o.H.No.2-1-270 / 2 / 3, Amaran,adi Nagar,
Suryapet Village and lvlandal. Nalgoncla District
and another.
-
... Petitioners
Antl
'Ihe Municipal Counsel, Suryapet Municipatity,
Suryapet, Nalgonda District, rep. by its Chairman
and 4 others.
.... Respondents
ORDER:
-Ihe prcsent writ
Lretifiel-r has been filed, cleclaring the
proceeclings of tl-re I't respondent dated 22.01 .2009, irt
proceedings No.MCR No.749, along with the proceedings
of the 2nd respondent ciated 18.10.2008 issued in
proceedings No.41l2414 /2OOB,
AS
arbitrary, illegal,
SCR,J
WP.N1.1558 of 2009
contrarlr to rules, n,ithout application of min6 and also with
a preiucliced mind to help the respondent Nos.3 to 5, and
consequently sought a direction to the respondent Nos.1
and 2 not to entertain any rnutation proceedings in respect
<rf the disputed house bearing H.No.2-1 -170/2/3 along
with open land comprising 546 square yards, situated at
Aaravadi Veedi, Sur1,apg1, Nalgonda in favour of
respondent Nos.3 to 5, and also to restore the entries of the
petitioners, in place of their late father in the assessment
registers of the 2"d respondent.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, the petitioners'
father Mohd. Moulana Saheb s/o. late Nabi Saheb, allegecl
to have purchased the land to an extcnt of Ac.O.4|/z guntas
equivalent to 546 square yards in Sy.No.773, situated in
Suryapet Town and Municipality, Nalgonda District, under
a
registered sale deecl dated 23.17.7987, which was
registered as document No.3661/1987 and it is also
SCR,-J
W.P-No.1558 of 2009
contended by the writ petitioners that the said property
was purchasecl by their father, and that during the lifetime
of their father, thev have applieci for municipal sanction
permission for construction of house and the 1st respondent
had grantecl permission vide proceedings No.D/25/97-92
dated 17.05.1997, for cor-rstruction of a house and
compound wal[, and due to paucity of funds, only four
roorrrs were constructec{ alorrg with compouncl wall, and
the total compounc-l wall was not corlstructecl around the
total land, and they have been living in the said land. It is
also contendecl that u.,lrile so, their father expired on
76.04.7996, leaving behincl thc petitioners, their rnother and
also two sisters, ancl the saicl trvo sisters were married and
have been living with their husbands, and that the
petitioners have beerr in constant possession and enjoyment
of the saicl house arrd along rt'ith the appurtenant land as
on the date.
I
SCR, J
W. P. No. 1 558 of 2009
3.
It is also contenclecl that subsequent to the cleath of
their father, both sisters and mother, lr,ho are also lraving
equal share out of the saicl land, har,'e executecl registered
Release Deed dated 76.10.2006, in their favor, which was
rergisterecl as document No.4500/2006 and thus, the
petitioners are the absolute owners and possessors oi the
said propertv admeasuring 546 square yards along with the
house thereupon, and it is further stated that the
responclent Nos.3 to 5 herein, who are the brothers of their
late father, having cleveloped an evil eye to grab their
house, and having managed the 2nd respondent, got the
mutation proceedings bearing No.A1/2414/2006, dated
24.04.2006 in their favor bifurcating the house numbers as
2-7-770/2/3/ A to C, though there are no structures other
tl-ran four rooms constructed try their father, more so, the
petitioners are residing in the same house. It is contended
that, the mutation proceedings were obtained by the
I
SCR)
W-P,No.1558 of 2@9
respondent Nos.3 to 5 herein with the active collusion of
the respondent No.2 an<l questionilg the said mutation
proceeclings in favor of respondent Nos.3 to 5 herein dated
24.04.2006, the petitioner's mother alleged to have filed
W.P.No.24370 of 2006 before this Court, which was allowed
b1' this Court on 29.71 .2006 n,ith the following obscrvations:
"Taking into consideration thc fact that ncither the
petitioner nor other legal hc'irs of Mohd. Moulana
Saheb has been put on noticc beforc effecting the
mutation proceedings, the impugned mutation
proceeclings arc hereby sct aside, and the mattcr is
remitted to the first respontlent to put all the parties
said to bc interested in thc property in qucstion and
make appropriate orders in relation thercto at an
early date,"
4.
It is contended that while so, basing on the
rnutation proceecl ings issued in favour of respondent
Nos.1 to 3, the 5th respondent had applied for perrnission
and the sarne was grantcd on 08.11.2006 by the 2"d
respondent ar-rd the application of the petitioners for
SCR,]
W.P.N1.1558 of 2009
grant ()f permission was kept pending. Further, they
have fileci a r,r,rit petition in W.P.No.17767 of 2O0B
challenging the grant of permission to the respondent
Nos.3 to 5 herein, which is pending adjudication beforc
tl-ris Court. [t is contende'd that after the orders passed by
tl-ris Hon'ble Court, dated 29.11.2006 in W.P.No.24370 of
2006. 'l'tre 2,'d responclent had issued notices to the
petitioners along with the respondent Nos.3 to 5 hereirr
.r n cl
conse'quently, issued proceedings N o. A1 / 2414 / 2005
dated 01 .03.2007 setting aside the mutation proceedings
issr-red in favour of the respondent Nos.3 to 5 and the
ccrrsequerrtial prl66sgclings bearing No. A1. / 247 4 / 2005,
clirtccl 09.08 .2007 was also issued deleting the narnes of
rcsponclent Nos.3 to 5 herein by restoring the narne of
tl-rt:ir latt: father in the revenue records. It is contended
that the s;-ricl proceedings have become final as they were
not questioned subsequently.
scR)
W.P.N1.155B of 2009
(
5. Further, it is also corrtendecl that while so, the
person working as Commissioner of the 2'd respondent
Municipality was transferred and the present incumbent
hacl took the charge and the respondent Nos.3 to 5 herein
have started their efforts once again, and under the
influence of the respondcnt Nos.3 to 5, the 2nd
respondent allegecl to have reope necl thci r case for
hearing, and issued notices, ancl thereupon, the 2nd
rcspondent after conducting an inquiry, has passed
orders once again by conducting enquiry vide
proceedings No.A7/241412008 datecl 18.10.2008. It is
contended that assailing the sarne, the petitioners filed
the W.P.No.233B1 of 2008 before this Court and this
Court after considering the facts on record, as there is
alternative appeal provicled for the writ petitioners to
challenge the order dated 18.10.2008 under Rule 7 of the
A.l'. Municipalities (Alternation of Ownership of
SCR,]
W.P.No.1558 of 2009
B
Prope r ty I l-l Assessmerrt Books) Rules, 1966, this Court
releg.-rtecl the petitioners to file ar-r appeal before the
Council i.c., I'r respondent against the orders dated
18.10.2008 passed by
the 2"d respondent and
subsequently, it is contended that writ petitioners have
filccl Appcarl bciore the 1't respondent and the 1.t
respondent reiterating the same has rejected the said
Appeal rvithout valid reasons and as such, the present
writ petition is iiled before this Court questioning the
orders of the 1.t respondent
6.
'[-he l'asic contcntion of the writ petitioners is that,
when tl.rc. mutation proceedings dated 24.O4.2006 in
favour oi resprorrdent Nos.3 to 5 were granted,
W.P.No.2437O of 2O06 was filed before this Court and
this Court by setting aside the orders of mutation
procecdinlls datcd 24.04.2006, directed the
2"d
responderrt to concluct a fresh enquiry and in pursuance
SCR,)
W.P.N1.1558 of 2009
of the same, the 2nd respondent has already heard the
matter and consequently, orders were also passed and
while so, the new Cornmissioner, who took the charge of
the Office of the 2",1 respondent, cannot revierru its own
orders by reopening the case and as such, though the
Appeal has been filed, it has not been properly
adjuclicated by the 1't respondcrrt. It is contencled that the
2"d rcspon,Jent has no jurisdiction to alter to their own
orciers.
7.
Per contm, the respondent Nos.3 to 5 herein have
iiled counter-affidavit contending that there were suits
and counter suits filed by the writ petitioncrs ancl also
the respondent Nos.3 to 5 herein and that in fact, after
passirlg of the orders by this Court, remitting the matter
back to the 2"d respondent for conducting a fresh enquiry
in W.P.No.2437O of 2006. The 2"d respondent has only
intimated the order passed by this Court in
scR,l
W.P.N1.1558 of 2009
W.['].No.2,1370 of 2006 datecl 29.11.2006 ancl that
consequential orrlc.rs are only passed setting aside the
mutation proceedirrgs in favour of the respondent Nos.3
to 5 ttide orcler c{artccl 09.08.2007, but, however, no fresh
enquiry was conductecl as per the orders of this Court in
W.1'].No.24370 oi
2006 dated 29.71..2006 and
subsequently, the iresh enquiry was conducted by the
Comrnissioner ancl after proper enquiry, mutation
proceeclinl;s werc rr)storer.:l ir-r favour of respondent Nos.3
to 5 and as such, the 1.t respondent also, on appeal by the
writ petitioner, h.rs dismissed the Appeal of the writ
petitioner, ars no valicl grouncls are produced.
8.
Flearci Mr. I'. 1'. Acharya, Iearned counsel for the
petitioners, Mr. S.R. Vishnu Murthy, learned counsel
representini3 Mr. I)utta Krishna Reddy, Iearned Standing
Counsel for Mur-rit:i1-ralities for respondent Nos.1 & 2, and
Mr. Abhinav Krishna Uppaluri, learned counsel
sc&)
W. P.No. 1558 of 2@9
representing Mr. P.S.P.Suresh Kumar for respondent
Nos.1 to 3.
9.
'I'he basic contention ol the petitioners IS that, by
virtue of order passed by the 2nd respondent dated
.03.2007 in
proceedings No.A7/2414/2005 and
consequential order dated 09.08.2007 in Proceedings
No.A2/2414/2005, the case of the respondent Nos.3 to 5
w,crc already considered pursuant to the order passed by
tlris Court in W.P.No.24370 t>f 2006 dated 29.77.2006 and
onr:e again, the very same Commissioner cannot conduct a
reviert, oi the earlier order. Evidently as seen from the
orclers of this Court in W.P.No.24370 of 2006, dated
29.11 .2006, this Court while setting aside the mutation
procec.clings issued in favour of the respondent Nos.3 to 5,
c{irt-ctecl the 2"d respondent to conduct a enquiry afresh and
pass appropriate orders by giving due notice to the
re-spective parties. The orders in proceedings No.A7/2774/
I
W. P. No. I 558 of 'CR,J
2005, datecl 01.03.2007, tire orclers of this Court in
W.P.No.24370 of 2006, datecl 29.17.2006 have been
intimated to the parties, but no iresh enquiry is conducted
as pcr ther clirectior-rs of this Court in the aforesaid writ
petiLion. For better u nclerstarrding of the case, the
proceedings of thc 2"d rc.sponclent dated 0'1,.03.2007 are
hereby extracted.
"'fhe Hon'ble High Court of A.P., in their Writ
Petition No.24370 / 2OO6 datcd 24.04.2006 have set aside
the mutation of property of H.No.2-1-170/2/3 rnade by
the Commissioner, Suryapet Municipality and issued
orders accordingly to takc action within four weeks
from the datc o[ reccil-rt of thc said Hon'ble High Court
orders.
Consequcnt on the basis of . thc Hon'ble High
Court crrders, mutation proccedings No.A7/2414/
2006, dated 24.04.2006 of p211 66 H.No.2-1-170/ 2/ 3 i.e.,
H.No.2-1-17ul2/3/A, H.No.2-L-17O/2/3/8, and
H.l'Jo.2-1-17O / 2/ 3/ C are hereby set aside."
10. That the very wording of the said order dated
07.03.2007 onlv would reveal that consequent upon the
-)
SCR,]
W.P.No.155a of 2009
I
orders of this Court, the mutation proceedings were set
asicle, but, however, the order do not indicate as to
conducting of an1, enquiry b), th. 2"d respondent and
perusal of the cor.rsequential order dated 09.08.2007,
consequent upon setting aside the assessment order of this
Court, the assessment orcler granted in favour of
responcicnt Nos.3 to 5 was cancelled, but, however, no fresh
enquiry was cont-lucterf by the 2nd responclent after
cancellatiorr of the saicl assessment order by virtue of the
orders passed irr W.P.No.24370 of 2006 dated 29.17.2006.
Pursuant thereto, thc. 2nd respondent in pursuance of the
orders in \V.P.no.2437O of 2006, dated 29.77.2006 has taken
up the enquirl, antl issued notice dated 16.07.2008 to the
writ petitioner and respondent Nos.3 to 5 and the orders
\,\,e re
passed by the 2ncl respondent
ltl
proceedings
No.A1 /2414l2008 clatecl 18.10.2008. It is evident that the 2nd
responclent has not reviewed the orders, but has conducted
scR,l
W. P. No. I 558 of 2009
l4
frcsh enquiry in pursuance oi the directions of this Court irr
W.P.No.24370 of 2006, dated 29.11.2006. 'thus, it cannot be
said that the 2nd respondent has either exceeded his
jurisdiction in passing the irnpugned proceedings dated
18.10.2008, nor c1o the said proceedings amoLrnt to a
review of the orrlc.r datect 01.03.2007.
. Further, as the A p;real
\^ras
f
ilccl before the 1.t
responder-rt, who after due enquiry has found that no valid
reasons are made out by the writ petitioners to interdict the
order dated 18.10.2008. 1.he petitioners have not made out
any valid grour-rds for intcrference and have not
substantiallv proved that the impugned proceedings are
bad in law arrcl untc-,nable. r\s the u,rit peLitioners
contendeci that the respondent Nos.3 to 5 have no right
over the subject property, they ought to have filed
declaration suit for reclressal of their grievance and it is
settled lau, that this Court cannot decide title issue in writ
I
,
(
sc&l
W 2 flo. 1 558 of 2009
petition and if the writ petitioners desire so, they may file
appropriate suits for reclressal of thcir grievance.
72. In such view of thc matter, the Writ Petition is devoid
of merits and the s.rme is liable to be dismissed.
13. Accordingly, the Writ l)etition is hereby dismissed.
'fhcre shall be o or,.lcr as to costs.
Miscellaneous applic311o.s if any pending shall stand
closecl.
SD/. C. DEEPIKA
SISTANT REGIST
//TRUE COPY//
\'
ECTION OFFICER
To,
\
TJ
1. One CC to Sri T. P. Acharya, Advocate IOPUC]
2. One CC to Sri Putta Krishna Reddy, SC for Municipalities[OPuc]
3. One CC to Sri P. S. P. Suresh Kumar, Advocate IOPUC]
4. Two CD Copies
HIGH COURT
DATED:2310112026
.fHE
o
021,r 2026
I
ORDER
.t
WP.No.1558 of 2009
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
@
I
S
O..
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review