Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR
ON THE 19th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 4814 of 2012
BETWEEN:LALJI S/O GOKUL KULMI (DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS. GAYATRIBAI W/O LATE
SHRI LALJI PATIDAR, AGED ABOUT 55
1.
YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE R/O
KUKSHI
TEHSIL
KUKSHI
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
LALJI S/O GOKUL KULMI (DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS. S/O VIJAY WD/O LATE SHRI
LALJI PATIDAR, AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS,
2.
OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST
R/O
KUKSHI
TEHSIL
KUKSHI
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
LALJI S/O GOKUL KULMI (DECEASED)
THROUGH LRS. S/O AJAY S/O LATE SHRI
LALJI PATIDAR, AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
3.
OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST
R/O
KUKSHI
TEHSIL
KUKSHI
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
RAJENDRA S/O GOKUL KULMI, AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
4.
AGRICULTURIST R/O KUKSHI TEHSIL
KUKSHI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
SHRI MUKESH KUMAWAT, ADVOCATE
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
COLLECTOR DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
SUB DIVISIONAL OFFICER REVENUE
2. DEPARTMENT S.D.O.OFFICE KUKSHI,DHAR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3. TEHSILDAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
4. REVENUE INSPECTOR PATWARI HALKA
1.
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
NO.32,REVENUE
CIRCLE,
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
PATWARI,
PATWARI
HALKA
NO.32
5.
TEH.KUKSHI (MADHYA PRADESH)
SUPERINTENDENT LAND RECODS &
6.
SATTLEMENT,M.P. (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
SHRI VAIBHAV BHAGWAT, GOVT.ADVOCATE
SHRI VIVEK PATWA, RESPONDENT/INTERVENER
WRIT PETITION No. 4812 of 2012
BETWEEN:RAMESHWAR
S/O
KESHAV
PATIDAR
(DECEASED) THROUGH LRS ANANDILAL S/O
LATE SHRI RAMESHWAR, AGED ABOUT 57
1.
YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE R/O
PATIDAR MOHALLA TEHSIL KUKSHI DISTT
DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
RAMESHWAR
S/O
KESHAV
PATIDAR
(DECEASED) THROUGH LRS S/O ANTIM S/O
2. LATE SHRI RAMESHWAR OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURIST
PATIDAR
MOHALLA,
TEHSIL KUKSHI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
SHRI MUKESH KUMAWAT, ADVOCATE
AND
THE
STATE
OF
MADHYA
PRADESH
COLLECTOR DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
2. TEHSILDAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
REVENUE INSPECTOR PATWARI HALKA
3. NO.32,REVENUE
CIRCLE,
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
PATWARI, PATWARI HALKA NO.32 (MADHYA
4.
PRADESH)
SUPERINTENDENT LAND & RECORDS DEPTT.
5.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
1.
.....RESPONDENTS
SHRI VAIBHAV BHAGWAT, GOVT.ADVOCATE
SHRI VIVEK PATWA, RESPONDENT/INTERVENER
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
WRIT PETITION No. 5567 of 2012
BETWEEN:MOHANLAL S/O BHANAJI, AGED ABOUT 40
YEARS,
OCCUPATION:
AGRICULTURE
HOUSE NO. 13 PRITHVIRAJ MARG CHHOTI
HATAI TEH. KUIKSHI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
SHRI MUKESH KUMAWAT, ADVOCATE
AND
STATE OF M.P. AND 5 ORS. GOVT. THRU.
COLLECTOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
SUB DIVISIONAL OFFICER S.D.O. OFFICE
2.
KUKSHI, (MADHYA PRADESH)
TEHSILDAR TESHSIL DHAR (MADHYA
3.
PRADESH)
REVENUE INSPECTOR PATWARI HALKA
4. NO. 32 REVENUE CIRCLE, TEHSIL KUKSHI
(MADHYA PRADESH)
PATWARI PATWARI HALKA NO. 32 TEHSIL
5.
KUKSHI DHAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
SUPERINTENDENT OF LAND RECORDS
6. LAND RECORDS & SETTLEMENT (MADHYA
PRADESH)
1.
.....RESPONDENTS
SHRI VAIBHAV BHAGWAT, GOVT.ADVOCATE
SHRI VIVEK PATWA, RESPONDENT/INTERVENER
RESERVED ON :
18/12/2023
HEARD ON :
19/1/2024
This petition coming on for order this day, the court passed the following:
ORDER
1.
This order shall govern the disposal of W.P.No.4814/2012, W.P.
No. 5567/2012 and W.P No. 4812/2012 as in all these three petitions
same issue are involved.
2. For the sake of convenience, the facts as
W.P.No.4814/2012 are being taken into consideration.
3.
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
These petitions
narrated
in
have been filed by the petitioners under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India against the order dated
22.3.2012 (Annexure P-8) and 18.4.2012 (Annexure P-9) passed by
the Collector Dhar, and Sub Divisional Officer (Revenue), Kukshi
Dhar, respectively.
4.
The Collector, vide order dated 22.3.2012, has allowed the
recommendation of the SDO (Revenue), Kukshi to review the order
dated 10.2.2011, passed under Section 51 of the M.P. Land
Revenue, Code 1959 (hereinafter to be referred to as “Code of
1959”), whereas vide the final order 18.4.2012, the SDO has
recalled the earlier order dated 10.2.2011, and has fixed the land
revenue under Section 59 sub section (2) of Code of 1959.
5.
In brief facts of the case are that the petitioners are resident of
Kuskshi, District Dhar, and are having land bearing Survey 365/3
admeasuring 0.059 hectares situated at Patwari Halka No.32 Tehsil
Kukshi District Dhar. The case of the petitioners is that the
petitioners had started construction on a small part of the aforesaid
land, which according to the respondents, was without any
permission, and prior to that on 20.1.2011, the petitioners also filed
an application for change of use of land i.e., for its diversion before
the respondent no.6. Hence, respondent no.6/Superintendent of
Land Records sought report from respondent no.4/Revenue
Inspector and respondent no.5/Patwari. Respondents no.4 and 5
inspected the spot, and found that the construction activities have
commenced on the land, and a panchnama was also prepared in this
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
regard on 10.1.2011, in which it was stated that as the land is not
used for agricultural purposes, and is being used for residential
purposes, and diversion is not against the public interest.
6.
After considering the report and documents submitted by
respondent no.6/Superintendent of Land Records, the respondent
no.2/SDO (Revenue) vide its order dated 10.2.2011, imposed the
penalty, charged premium and granted permission for change of use
of land under the provisions of Section 59 of the Code of 1959. A
copy of which is filed as (Annexure P-2).
7.
According to the petitioners, the order dated 10/2/2011 has
already been implemented, and the land records were accordingly,
amended and treated as diverted land. Copies of Khasra and Kista
Khataouni have been also been filed on record as Annexures P/3
and P/4.
8.
It is further the case of the petitioners that on 2.9.2011, a
notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act,1984
(hereinafter to be referred to as “Act of 1984”) was issued by the
State Government from the office of respondent no.1/Collector
Dhar for acquiring the lands situated at village Kukshi for public
purpose, and on 20.10.2011, a notification under Section 6 of the
Act of 1894 was issued regarding declaration of intended
acquisition, and the lands in question was included for acquisition.
It is further the case of the petitioners that on 25.2.2012, the
respondent no.2/Sub Divisional Officer (Revenue) issued a letter
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
under Section 51 of the Code of 1959 seeking permission for suo
motu review of the order dated 10.2.2011 on the ground, that on the
land in question, it has been found that agricultural activities are
being carried out, and cotton crops have been sown. The respondent
no.1/Collector, Dhar vide its order dated 22.3.2012 (Annexure P/8)
has granted permission to respondent no.2/SDO (Revenue) for suo
moto review.
9.
The petitioners’ contention was that they were not heard
before granting permission to respondent no.2 for suo moto review.
On 28.3.2012, the petitioners submitted the reply and denied all the
allegations and grounds for review. However, the respondent no.2/
SDO(Revenue) has passed the order on 18.4.2012(Annexure P/9)
and the earlier order of diversion dated 10/2/2011 has been
cancelled, hence, these petitions.
10.
Counsel for the petitioners has submitted that the order of
review has been made after undue delay and not within a reasonable
time, and has relied upon a decision rendered by the Division
Bench of this Court in the case of Manjeet Bhalla & Another Vs.
State of M.P and others 2011 Revenue Nirnay 186 wherein in
para 21 it is held as under:“21. That apart, question of delay is also germane is
also material in the case in hand, as the power of suo
motu review is exercised after lapse of four years,
when as per the dictum of the apex Court, referred to
above in the case of Jai Jai Ram Manohar Lal and
S.B. Gurbaksh Singh (supra) wherein the apex Court
has held that for exercising suo motu powers of
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
review, six months time is a reasonable time. There is
no explanation on record about the delay on the part
of the State Government in exercising the powers suo
motu review.”
(emphasis supplied)
11.
Thus, it is submitted that since the impugned orders have
been passed after a lapse of more than one year, the they are liable
to be quashed. It is submitted that the provisions of Section 51 of
the Code of 1959 for review of the order has also not been complied
with, and has also relied upon the decision rendered by the Division
Bench of this Court in the case of Saheed Anwar Vs. Board of
Revenue and another 2000 Revenue Nirnay 76(DB) wherein it
has been held that sanction for review by Board or any other
revenue officer cannot be granted without notice and hearing the
either side whereas, in the present cases no such notice or
opportunity of hearing was granted to the petitioners prior to
permission to review was granted
vide order dated 22.3.2012.
Thus, it is submitted that on this ground only the petitions are liable
to be allowed. It is also submitted that otherwise also no ground as
provided under Section 51 (2) of Code of 1959 would be available
to the petitioners to review the order which has to be in accordance
with Order 47 of the Civil Procedure Code 1908 as there is no
illegality or error apparent on the face of record.
12.
Counsel for the petitioners has also submitted that the report
dated 24.12.2012 has been prepared by the same person, who has
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
inspected the disputed land on earlier occasion at the time of grant
of diversion order which clearly shows malafide on the part of
respondents.
13.
Counsel for the petitioners has also submitted that admittedly,
the aforesaid lands have already come under the acquisition
proceedings under the Act of 1984, and it is a settled law that no
person can change the use of land whose land is proposed to be
acquired in the land acquisition proceedings. It is also submitted
that respondent no.2 has not considered the reply filed by the
petitioners while passing the order. It is further submitted that the
petitioners have constructed up to foundation level, however, on
account of notifications dated 2.9.2011 and 20.10.2011, they
stopped the construction work as the land was to be acquired by the
State Government and the continuation of same could have caused
great financial hardship to the petitioners. It is also submitted that
no crops were standing on the lands at the time of subsequent
inspection and a false report has been prepared.
14.
A reply to the petitions has also been filed, traversing the
averments made in the petitions counsel for the respondents has
submitted that no construction activities were going on, on the
petitioners’ land, and earlier report was certainly erroneous. It is
also submitted that lands have already been acquired for the
purposes of road constructions and award has already been passed.
The respondents have also denied that only to save themselves from
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
paying enhanced compensation that they have set aside the
diversion order.
15.
Counsel for the respondents has submitted that the petitioners
have acted malafidely by diverting their lands prior to acquisition as
admittedly, the MPRDC issued the letter on final feasibility report
dated 21.8.2009 (Annexure I-1) after detailed survey for the
construction of Jhabua-Jobat- Bagh-Kukshi (SH-39), and NIT was
issued by MPRDC on 14.10.2010 (Annexure I-2) which are also
placed on record, and only after that, when the petitioners came to
know that their lands were also being acquired, they applied for
diversion of the lands with an ulterior motive of obtaining enhanced
compensation. Thus, it is submitted that, no illegality has been
committed by respondents in passing the order.
16.
Counsel for the petitioners, in rebuttal have submitted that no
such averments has been made in the reply filed by the respondents,
and thus, such objection cannot be taken on record.
17.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
18.
From the record, it is found that the order of diversion was
passed on 10.2.2011 for the review of the same, the application was
filed by the SDO(Revenue) before the Collector Dhar on 25.2.2012,
which has been allowed by the Collector, Dhar vide its order dated
22.3.2012.
19.
A perusal of the aforesaid proceedings of the SDO (Revenue)
as well as the order dated 22.3.2012 passed by the Collector Dhar, it
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
is apparent, that no notices were ever issued to the petitioners and
no opportunity of hearing was given to them. This Court in the case
of Saheed Anwar (supra) has held as under:“1. Appellant was owner of 3.428 hectares of land
situated in village Golpurapada, Tehsil Gandhwani
(dhar). He applied for exchange of this land which was
granted by respondent no.2 vide order dated 14.2.96
and pursuant thereto, he took over possession of 3.174
hectares of Government land comprising in survey
No.33. Eversince he took possession of the land which
he had also developed. It is alleged that later successor
in office of respondent no.2 made a report to
Commissioner (Revenue), Indore and requested him to
undertake a suo motu revision of the exchange deal or
to grant him permission to review it. The
Commissioner referred the matter to Revenue Board
which granted permission to review the order of
exchange vide order dated 24.6.98.
2. Appellant challenged this order in W.P.926/98 on
the ground that exchange of land was granted under
RBC IV (3) an executive circular and not an enactment
and thus the provisions of section 5 of Land Revenue
Code providing for review were not attracted to the
case. But his petition was dismissed after it was noticed
that he was put on notice by the Collector in the review
proceedings.
3. Appellant’s grievance is that he had raised
jurisdictional plea assailing the sanction for the review
accorded by the Revenue Board at his back and that the
writ Court had failed to deal with this aspect of the
matter and had dismissed his writ petition otherwise.
4. There is no dispute that the order of exchange was
passed under the revenue circular, but it remains to be
seen whether such circular could be treated as
subordinate legislation fall within the purview of
expression “enactment” used in section 56 of the Land
Revenue Code. But all that was unnecessary to be
examined because appellant’s primary grievance was
that Revenue Board had accorded sanction to review
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
the order of exchange dated 14.2.96 at his back and
without hearing him and in violation of principles of
natural justice.
5. We find some substance in the plea. Even if it was
assumed that the power of review was available in the
given case still appellant deserved to be put on notice
and was afforded an opportunity of being heard.
Because no order affecting his interests and re-opening
of the exchange deal concluded years back could be
passed at his back and without affording him
opportunity of being heard. Moreover, it would be
innocuous to provide him such opportunity in the given
facts and circumstances of the case which would cause
prejudice to none, least of all to the interest of the State.
6. This appeal is accordingly allowed and writ Court
order dated 7.10.98 passed in W.P.No.920/98 is
quashed and W.P.No.926/98 shall revive.
7. At this stage it was prayed by both sides that the writ
petition be disposed off on the analogy of the order
passed by writ Court in the allied W.P.No.924/98 which
was disposed off on 6.11.98 by reference to the
observance of principles of natural justice.
Consequently, W.P.No.926/98 is also disposed off by
providing that impugned order passed by the Revenue
Board dated 24.6.98 granting sanction for review shall
stand quashed. Board shall re-consider the matter after
putting appellant on notice and affording him a
reasonable opportunity of hearing in the matter.”
20.
(emphasis supplied)
A perusal of the aforesaid decision passed by the Division
Bench of this Court clearly reveals that it was incumbent upon the
respondent no.1/Collector, Dhar to issue notices to the petitioners
before giving consent to review the order, and notice to concerned
parties after the consent is given by the Collector for review of the
earlier order, would not suffice and would not serve the purpose of
Section 51 of the Code of 1959.
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
21.
In such circumstances, this Court is inclined to allow these
petitions only on the ground that the petitioners were not given any
notice before passing the order dated 10.2.2011 and the order dated
22.3.2012 passed by the Collector, Dhar.
22.
So far as the period of limitation to review is concerned, this
Court is of the considered opinion that it may vary from case to
case depending upon the facts of the case, as to from which date the
period of six months shall commence to run.
23.
In view of the same, the aforesaid petitions are allowed,
and the impugned orders dated 22.3.2012 and 18.4.2012 are
hereby quashed. The matter is remanded back to the Collector,
Dhar to pass an appropriate order in accordance with law after
giving due opportunity of hearing to the petitioners.
24.
Parties are directed to appear before the Collector, Dhar on
26.2.2024.
(SUBODH ABHYANKAR)
JUDGE
das
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 21-01-2024
11:14:56
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review