Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
l32s2l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 30153 OF 2022
Between:
Mohammed Ahmed, S/o Dada Saheb, a s ed about 52 years, Workrng as
Temporary post of contingent Sweeper, P S . Utupally, Shamshabad Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District.
..PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Panchayathraj
Department, Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Finance and Planning
Department, Govt. of Telangana, Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad.
The District Collector (Panchayat), and Chairman of Minimum, Wages
Committee and District Selection Committee, Ranga Reddy District.
The, Zilla Praja Parishad, Ranga Reddy Oistrict, Rep. by its Chief Executive
Officer.
5 The Mandal Development Officer, Mandal Praja Parishad, Shamshabad
l\ilandal, Ranga Reddy Distr;ct.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus to direct the respondents to treat the services of the petitioner as
regular one in the last grade post for continuously working till date in temporary
post of last grade in contingent establishment on compassionate grounds from
05/07/1988 nor regularizing his services even on completion of 34 long years
servlce by not extending the last grade pay benefits with periodical increments
from time to time with effect from 05/07/1988 to till date from time to time with
arrears as per GO Ms. No. 687 dated 03/10/1977 to till date is highly unjust and
unfair as per Article 14, 16, 21 ,39 (d), 43 and 300 (A) of Constitution of lndia by
sublecting petitioner for expioitative enslavement due to his helpless conditions of
poverty, poor social, economical and political background by taking it as
advantage by the respondents in continuing her on pittance wages of Rs. 4,0001
p.m. and prays to direct the respondent herein to treat tl-: temDorary services of
petitioner in the last grade post of sweeper as regulafu e for all purposes by
granting last grade pay with perrodical increment revised 'om time to time from
the date of appointment of the petitioner for working 34 I ng years without any
service progress with 100 Percent compensation on arr: lrs of pay as per the
principle laid by the Honourable Supreme Court in C.A. N r 3416 - 3445 of 2010
dated 19-02-2019 in the case of Union of India Vs. Avtar I rand (2019 3 ALD SC
32) and in the case of Prem Singh Vs. State of UP and Ea ch cases (reported in
2019 '10 SCC 516 In paras 36 and 37), in the case of N( i rm Sahu Vs. State of
Chattisgarh and Anr. in Civil Appeal No 254 of 2018, dal. 2310312018, followed
by DB Orders issued in the case of Kadar Basha in WP Nc 26788 of 2017 daled
10lOBl2017 (DB) with cost by applying aforesaid princlple I iC by the Honourable
Apex Court under Artrcle 141 of our Constitution.
'1
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 15.1 CPC praying that in the ; cumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Co,r t may be pleased to
direct the respondents herein to treat the services of the etitioner provided on
compassionate grounds vide Proc No. S3/219/87 dar: I 05/07/1988 by 5th
respondent in temporary post of sweeper as per GC, l\ils. No.687 dated
r. from 05/07/1988 in
0311O11977 as regular one from the date of appointment
the last grade post iorthwith by paying last grade tune ;cale benefits to the
petitioner with periodical increments revrsed from time to trrr
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI CH. GANESH
Counsel forthe Respondent No.1 to 3: GP FOR PANCHA/ \T RAJ &
RURAL DEVELOPI\ ENT
Counsel for the Respondent No.4 & 5: SRI PRADEEP REI) ,Y KATTA
The Court made the following: ORDER
.+
5\. l
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETI T ION N 0.30153 0F 2022
ORDER:
Heard Sri CH.Ganesh, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner, learned Assistant Government
Pleader for Services-II appearing on behalf of the
respondent Nos. 1 to 3 and Sri Pradeep Reddy Katta,
learned standing counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent Nos.4 & 5.
2.
Th
ra
e
h
n
r er
as under:
to issue an order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of Writ of Mandamus to direct the
respondents to treat the services of the petitioner as
regular one in the last grade post for continuously
working till date in temporary post of last grade in
contingent establrshment on compassionate grounds
from 05/07/l9BB nor regularizing his services even on
completion of 34 Iong years service by not extending the
last grade pay beneFits with periodical increments from
time to time with effect from 05/07/1988 to till date
from time to time with arrears as per GO Ms. No.687
dated 03/10/ 1977 to till date is highly unjust and unfair
as per Article 14, 76,21,39(d),43 and 300-4 of
Constitution of India by subjecting petltioner for
exploitative enslavement due to his helpless conditions
of poverty poor social economical and political
background by taking it as advantage by the
respondents in continuing her on pittance wages of
Rs.4,000/-pm and prays to direct the respondent herein
to treat the temporary services of petitioner in the last
!
I
Sr-. J
grade post oF sweeper as regular one for a purposes by
granting last grade pay with periodical lncr I nent rev sed
from time to time from the date oF appoi r ment of the
petitioner for workrng 34 long years witho r any service
progress with 100o/o compensation on arr(, r-s of pay as
per the principle laid by the Honourable S - treme Crturt
in C.A.No.3416-3445 of 2010, dated 19.02 2019 in the
case of Union of India Vs Avtar Chand (2(r q 3 ALD SC
32) and in the case of Prem Singh Vs Stir: of UP and
Batch cases (reported in 2019 10 SCC 51: rn paras 36
and 37) in the case of Netram Sahu /s State of
Chattisgarh and Anr in Civil Appeal No,l.54 of 2018
dated 23/0312018 followed by DB Orders i;sued in the
case oF Kadar Basha in WP. No. 26788 or 2017, dated
70/08/20L7 DB with cost by applying afore : aid principle
laid by the Honourable Apex Court under 51icle 141. of
our Constitution and pass "
3.
Learned counsel apoearin qonl
thalf of the
oetitioner Dlacino rel ance on the avermen !; made in the
affidavit filed in
su
oort of the oresent _ writ oetition
oertainino in oarticul ar, to the services rendered bv
petitioner with the resoondents herein fo -_ more than a
decade contends that the petitioner is err :itled for the
relief as ora ved for in the Dre sent writ petiti ( n.
PERUSED THE RECORD:-
DISC uss IO N AND CONCLUSION:-
4.
Learned counsel appearinq on t,r h f
etitioner submits that
h
s
I
the
the Dresent
case is souarelv covered bv the order of thir Court, dated
SN, J
O8.09.2010 pass ed in W.P.No.24377 ot 2OO7 reoorted in
20 11 r1) A LD
Pa o e 234 as confirmed in W.A.No.782 of
2010. dated 10. O6.2O13 a nd also order, dated 19.09.2O17
passed in W.P.No.272L7 of 2017 reported in 2O18 (2) ALD
Paqe 282 and also the order, dated 21.04.202O passed in
w.P No.23057 of 201 9re D o r ed in 2O2O(4) ALD Paqe 379.
5.
Learned standinq counsel appearinq on behalf of the
resoondent No.4 submits that the orievance of t h e
petitioner as put-forth in the present Writ Petition had not
been addressed to the respondents herein as on date and
therefore, the petitioner cannot comDlain inaction on the
part of respondents herein in considerinq the orievance of
thb petitioner and hence, the relief as prayed for bv the
pettionerin the present Wit petitaon cannot be qranted
and no Mandamus can be issued aqainst the respondents
here under as sou q ht for and the Detitioner mav be
directed to Dut-forth the oetitioner's qrievance as Dut-
forth in the present Writ Petition bv way of a detailed
representation to the respondents herein and upon
receiDt of the said representation, the respondents would
S\. .I
consider the same in accordance to Irw, within a
reasonable period.
6. Learned counsel apDearinq on behalf of the petitioner
does not dispute the said submission made_ )v the learned
sta ndinq counsel aDoe arino on behalf of t re respondent
No.4
7. The Apex Court in the iudqment reporl:r d in (2O2O) 1
SCC (L&S) in Prem Sinqh v State of Utt E] Pradesh and
others, at para 36 held as under!
"36. There are some of the employees who hl ,e not been
regularized in spite of having rendered the se' ir--es for 3040 or more years whereas they have been sul rrannuated.
As they have worked in the work-charged e; a blis h me nt,
not against any particular project, therr serv ( )s ought to
have been regularized under the Governmen- instructions
and even as per the decision of this Court n State of
Karnataka versus Umadevi (3)11. This Cour. in the said
decision has laid down that in case service i have been
rendered for more than ten years without the over of the
Court's order, as one-time measure, the e rvices be
regularized of such employees. In the facts t f the case,
those employees who have worked for ten yr: rs or morc
should have been regularized. It would not ; ' proper to
regulate them for consideration of regularizat ( r as others
have been regularized, we direct that their ;r: Tv rces L>e
treated as a regular one. However, it is marl clea r that
they shall not be entitled to claiming any dues r f d iffe re n ce
in wages had they been continued in serv r : regularll,
before attaining the age of superannuation. ll :y shall be
entitled to receive the pension as if they h; .re retired
re ula
d ttr, servtces
lr
he dav th ( v entered
re nder
v theE
SN. J
the work-charoed establishment shall be counted as
qualifvinq service for Duroose of pension."
8. The Aoex Court in the case of Dharwad District PWD
Literate Daily lllaqe Em-plovees Assaciation vs. state of
Karnataka reoorted in 1990(2) SCC Paoe 395 laid orinciole
that the State should not keeD a person in temporarv or
adhoc service for lonq period and have to treat such
Dersons as reoular one.
9.
Para No.53 of the of the iudqment of the Apex Court
in the State of Karnataka and others Vs. Umadevi dated
1O.04.2006 reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1 is extracted
h ereu nder: -
"53. One asoect needs to be clarified. There mav be
cases where irreqular appointments (not illeqal
appointments) as explained in S.V, NarayanaDpa
L
R
L972
N n
a
B.
a
c
a a
qualified
and referred to in Dara 15 above, of dulv
persons in dulv sanctioned vacant posts miqht have
been made and the emDloyees have continued t-o
work for ten
ears or more but with OU t
the
intervention of orders of the courts or of tri bu na ls.
The ouestion of reqularizatio noft h e services of such
emolovees mav have to be consider ed on merits in
the li o ht of the o rl nci oles settle d hvt hi s Cou rt tn the
cases abovereferred to a nd tn t he lioht of this
iudqment. In that conte xt. th e Union of India, the
State Governments an their i n stru m enta lities
chnr r .l
t^ ke ste fl store
ularize a c
a
s\. J
measure, the servi ces of such irrequl ; rlv appointed,
who have worked for ten vears or mor tn
sanctioned o osts but not under cover ; i orders of the
courts or of tribunals and should furtll :r ensure that
reoular recr uitments are undertaken to fill those
vacant sanctioned Dosts that reouire I r be filled u o,
in cases where tem DOrarv emolovees : - dailv waqers
are beino now emploved. The process- nust be set in
motion within six months from this da Ft
10. The iudqment of th e Apex Court dat,:1 2O.L2.2O24
reoorted in 2024 LawSui t(SC) 12O9 in la< o Anita and
others v. Union of India and others, a n,l the relevant
oaraqraoh Nos.12, 1
24, 26,27 and 28 are extracted
he reu n der:
"12. Despite being labelled as "pe I t-time
workers," the appellants performed these
essential tasks on a daily and conl nuous
basis over extensive periods, ranginr from
over a decade to nearly two decades; Their
engagement was not sporadic or tenr )orary
in nature, instead, it was recurrent, rr gular,
and akin to the responsibilities t'r lically
associated with sanctioned posts. Mor lover,
the respondents did not engage Ern1, e16..
personnel for these tasks durinl the
appellants tenure, underscoring the
indispensable nature of their work.
The claim
h
r
n t r that
these were not re Il r
m :'it, as
the nature of the work Derformed lv the
aDoellants was oe nnial and fundame rr tal to
the functionino of the offices. The r I urfl ng
13.
nature of these duties
necessitates their
posts,
classification as regular
irrespectiv: ,f how
IO
SN, I
their initial engagements were labelled. It is also
noteworthy that subsequent outsourcing of these
same tasks to private agencies after the
appellants' termination demonstrates the inherent
need for these services. This act of outsourcing,
which effectively replaced one set of workers with
another further underscores that the work in
question was neither temporary nor occasional.
24.
The landmark judgment of the United State
in the case of Vizcaino v [v]icrosoft Corporation [97
F.3d 1187 (9th Cir. 1996)l serves as a pertinent
example from the private sector, illustrating the
consequences of misclassiFying employees to
circumvent providing beneFits. In this case,
Microsoft classified certain workers as independent
contractors, thereby denying them employee
benefits. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit determined that these workers were, in
fact, common-law employees and were entitled to
the same benefits as regular employees. The Court
noted that large Corporations have increasingly
adopted the practice of hiring temporary
employees or independent contractors as a means
of avoiding payment of employee beneFits, thereby
increasing their profits. This judgment underscores
the principle that the nature of the work
performed, rather than the label assigned to the
worker, should determine employment status and
the corresponding rights and benefits. It
hiqhliqhts the iudiciarv's role in reetifvitq
srrrh misclacs ifi aetin n c: n dc
workers receive faar treatment.
26.
n <ll rtn dt
h et
While the judgment in Uma Devi (supra)
sought to curtail the practice of backdoor entries
and ensure appointments adhered to constitutional
principles, it is regrettable that its principles are
often misinterpreted or misapplied to deny
legitimate claims of long serving employees. This
judgment aimed to distinguish between "illegal"
and
"irregular"
a ppointments.
i1
SN. ,I
It cateqori callv held tha t emplo t ses in
irreq ular a pDointments, who were en, l roed in
dulv san ctioned oosts an d had served
contin u o uslv for more t han ten vea r: t should
be cons idered for reoular ization as a onetime measure. Howev er, the laudable ittent of
the judgment is being subverted when in: itutions
rely on its dicta to ind iscrim inately ro 3ct the
claims of employees, even in cases wh. -e their
appointments are not illegal, but mei', ly lack
adherence t.o procedural formalities. 69r, ,rnment
departments otten cite the judgment in L, ra Devi
(supra) to argue that no vested " ght to
regularization exists for temporary enr rloyees,
overlooking the
judgment's ex plicit
acknowledgment of cases where regular z:tion is
appropriate. This selective aoplication 1 ts orts
the iudo ent's soirit and ou roose, eff 3 ctivelv
weaoonr inq it aoainst emo lovees wl 1: have
render ed indisoensable
servrces _ over
decades.
2-l
,
In llght of these considerations, n our
opinion, it is imperative for gov( rnment
departments to lead by example in provi: ng fair
and stable employment. Engaging work€,r s on a
temporary basis for extended periods, es )ecially
when their roles are integral to the orgar i :ation's
functioning, not only contravenes inter-r ational
labour standards but also exposes the org;r ization
to legal challenges and undermines enr tloyee
morale. By ensuring fair emplc yment
practices, government institution s can
reduce the burden of unnecessary lit'r ation,
promote job security, and upholr I the
principles of justice and fairness th;r : they
are meant to embody. This approach aligns
with international standards and s ets a
positive precedent for the private ser tor to
follow, thereby contributing to the r verall
betterment of labour practices in the c I rntry.
t2
S
^'-
28.
In vtew of the above discussion and
findings, the appeals are allowed. The impugned
orders passed by the High Court and the Tribunal
are set aside and the original application is allowed
to the following extent:
i. The termination orders dated
27 . lO.2018 are quashed;
lt.
back
The aDDellants shall be a ken
on du forthwi th and their
se rvtce s
r e o ula rtse dfo
rt hwith.
How ever, the aooellant s shall n tbe
enti tled
to
anv
Dec un la rv
be nefits /bac k waoe s for the o eriod
th e have not worked for bu t would
be entitled t o continui tv of ser vt ces
fo r the sa id oerio d and the same
ould be cou nted for thei r Dostr tiral b
ts."
11. The Judom ent of th e ADex Co urt date d 31.01.2025
re Dor ted in 2O 25 rNSC
NAGAR NIGAM
ar Nos.1
44 in "S
R IPAL AN D ANOTHER v.
GHAZIA BA D", in particular
19 ar
tracte
here u n
the rele va nt
r
15. It is manife st that the Aooe llant Workmen
continu ouslv ren dered th eir service s over severa I
"
sometimes soannin q more than a decade.
Even if cert ain muster roll were not oroduc ed in ful
the Emolover's fa ilu re to fur nish such r eco rdsdes n ate d !r ecti ns to do so
-all o san ad er se
i nfer nce
under
well-establi shed
la bou r
years
iurisor udence . Indian lab ur law st ronqlv d isfavors
l
J
1-l
s\. i
ents in
r tualld ilv -wa e or co ntractu al en aqe m
anent tn
circu msta n ces where the work ls [r,:r m
worker who fu lfil
na ture. M o ra llv and leqall
at ter vea r
on qo lnq munlcl D al reouire ment s vea
ls en sa ble
s
ca n not be dism i ssed sum marilv
rti cula rlv in th e ab sen ceofa qen ui J e contractor
E
I
Da
At this juncture, it would be :PProPriate to
"temporary"
recall the broader critique of indefinit(
judgement of
employment Dractices as done by a recent
follcrving
this court in Jaggo v. Union of India ir the
a
reemen
pa rag ra Ph s:
"22. The pervasive misuse of temporil y employment
a
contracls, as exemplified in this ce se' reflects
affects
broader systemic issue that ad v lrsely
private
workers' rights and job security' lr the to an
sector, the rlse of the gig econom) has led
increase in precarious employment arrangements'
job security'
often characterized by lack of benefit;'
been
s have
and fair treatment Such practic(
1 undermining
art
criticized for exploiting workers
entrusted
labour standards Goveinment institLl ons' justice'
and
ss
witn upnolding the principles of fairrt
such
bear an even greater responsibilit) to avoidpublic
exploitative employment practices ' When
in misuse cf temporary
sector entities engage
-mi"ots
det'imenial trends
the
contracts, it not oniy
sets a
observed in the gig economy bil . also
trust in
concerning precedentlhat can erode l ublic
governmental ope ratio ns '
reality 'hat temporary
iS. rt is a disconcerting governr
( nt institutions'
employees, particularly in
While
oft"n iu." multifaceted forms of er 1 Ioitation
contracts may
ine foundational purpose of temporal;easonal
needs'
f,uu" C""n to address short-term or
lc 2024
they have increasingly become a me( lanism
ict onrin" SC 3d2'6 evade long-t )rm obligations
l,+
sN.l
owed to employees. These practices maniFest in
several ways:
. Misuse of "TemDorarv" Labels: Emolovees
n a ed for work tha ts
n
recu rri n
and inteqral to the fun ctioninq of an institution
are
often labelled as "tem orarv" or
"c ontractual," even when their roles mirror
those of reqular
emolovees. Such
as
ation
denr
miscl sific
ves workers of th e
dionitv, securitv, and benefits that reoular
emolovees are entitled to, despite oerforminq
identical tasks.
. Arbitrary Termination: Temporary employees are
frequently dismissed without cause oT notice, as seen
in the present case. This practice undermines the
principles of natural justice and subjects workers to a
state of constant insecurity, regardless oF the quality
or duration oF their service. . Lack of Career
Progression: Temporary employees often find
themselves excluded from opportunities for skill
development, promotions, or incremental pay raises.
They remain stagnant in their roles, creating a
systemic disparity between them and their regular
counterparts, despite their contributions being
equally signiFicant.
. Using Outsourcing as a Shield: Institutions
increasingly resort to outsourcing roles performed by
temporary employees, effectively replacing one set
of exploited workers with another. This practice not
only perpetuates exploitation but also demonstrates
a deliberate effort to bypass the obligation to offer
regular employment.
. Denial of Basic Rights and BeneFits: Temporary
employees are often denied fundamental benefits
such as pension, provident fund, health insurance,
and paid leave, even when their tenure spans
decades. This lack of social securiiy subjects them
and their families to undue hardship, especially in
SN. J
cases of
illn ess,
C CU M StA N CES.
retirement, ('
unForeseen
,,
16. The High Court did acknowledge re Employer's
t
inability to justify these abrupt termination; Conseq u e ntlY,
it ordered re-engagement on daily wr l :s w th some
measure of parity in minimum pay. Regrct .ably, this only
perpetuated precariousness: the Appellant ,A/orkme n were
left in a marginally improved yet still L r certain sta tu s.
While the High Court recognized the impc riance of the ir
work and hinted at eventual regularizat n, it fa iled to
{
afford them continuity of service or meanin( ful back wages
commensurate with the degree oF stat .ltory violatio n
evident on record.
L7, In light of these considerations, he Employer's
discontinuaticn of the Appellant Work'ren stands in
violation of the most basic labour law prin: ples. Once it is
established that their services were ter-r inated without
adhering to Sections 6E and 6N of the U.P. Industrial
ln
Disputes Act, 1947, and that thev wer en a
esse n tial. oerenni al duties . these wor I ers ca nnot be
re le qated t o perp etual uncerta ntv. \'\ ile con rn
ofm unicioal bud oet and corrr rliance with
;uch co ern s
rati
rl con
ruitm nt rules
do not a bsolve th e Emolo ver of sta tut( r obli tion s
I deed
n itlem I s.
or ne a ee u ble
bu rea u cratic limitation s cannot t rumr the leq itimate
riqhts of workmen who have serve d r ntin uou s ln
I
de fac to re oular r les for an exten ded I ,eriod.
l6
SN. J
18. The imouoned order of the Hiqh Court, to the
ex te n tt h EV co n fine the A rt D ellant W o rkm e nt o fu tu re
dailv-waoe enoaoement
without continuitv or
meaninqful back waqes, is h erebv set aside with the
followinq directions:
I. The discontinuation of the Appellant Workmen's
services, effected without compliance with Section 6E
and Section 6N of the U.P. industrial Disputes Act,
1947 ,
is declared illegal. All orders or
communications terminating their services are
quashed. In consequence, the Appellant Workmen
shall be treated as continuing in service from the
date ot their termination, for all purposes, including
seniority and continuity in service.
Ii. The Respondent Employer shall reinstate the
Appellant Workmen in their respective posts (or
posts akin to the duties they previously performed)
within four weeks from the date oF this judgment.
Their entir e DE r od of absence (from the date of
termination unt la ct ua I reinstatement) shall be
counted fo r continuitv of service and all
conseo ue n tial benefits such as senioritv and
elioibilitv for or motions, if anv.
III. Considering the length of service, the Appellant
Workmen shall be entitled to 50o/o of the back wages
from the date of their discontinuation until their
actual reinstatement. The Respondent Employer shall
clear the aforesaid dues within three months from
the date of their reinstatement.
IV. The Resoonde nt E molover is directed to
initiate a fair and transDarent Drocess for
reqularizinq the Appellant Workmen within six
months from the date of reinstatement, d uly
co n sid erin o th e fa c tth t thev have oerformed
r nial munici al dutie
nto erman n
l7
p
osts. In
s\. .t
assess r n qre
ou
lil.izati on.
the
ional or
Emp lover shall not impose
pro c edural
criteria retroactiV :lv if such
req u irement s were n ever arr rlied to the
App e lla nt Wo rkmen or to sirr la rl situated
reqular em I ovees in the D a st. l-o the extent
that sa nctione d vaca ncies for st, I h d uties exist
or are reourre d. the ResDond ent MD lover shall
exDed it e all ne cessar v admini st l2 :ive Droces ses
to ensure these lonqtim e emD I rV ees are not
ind efi n ite I v retaine do n dailv wa es contrarv to
() luca
statu torv and e ouita ble norm s.
19. In viev,r of the above, the appeal' "r fi ed by the
workmen are allowed, whereas the apptl I (s) filed by the
Nagar Niganr Ghaziabad are dismissed."
L2,
The A Dex Cour t in a iudom ent re Dorl ( cl in (20L7 )1
Su Dr eme Co
urt Ca ses 148 in St ate of P ur J ab and oth
vsJaoiit S inoh an d other satP ras 54 an c its s ub-o ras
(1) 2)(3), oft he said iud qm ent observed a i under:
"54 "The Full Bench of the High Court, /,\ile adjudicating
upon the above controversy had concluded that temporarY
employees were not entitled to the minimurn : ' the regular PaYscale, merely for the reason, that the acti'/'t es carried on by
daity-wagers and regular employees were sirni t,. The full bench
however, made two exceptions. Temporary e^' ploy,ees, who fell
in either of the two exceptions, were held t:it it leC to wages at
the minimum of the pay-scale drawn by regu't ' entployees. The
exceptions recorded by the full bench of the ligh Court in the
impugned iudgment are extracted hereunder:
"(1) A daily wager, ad hoc or con:,actual appointee
aigainst the regular sanctioned posts. ' appointed after
u'nderqoing a selection process basec! t con fairness and
equality of opportunity to all other e I Tible candidates,
!
i8
SN, J
shall be entitled to minimum of the regular pay scale from
the date of engagement.
(2) But if dailv waqers ad hoc or co tractual
a DDoi ntees are not aD D otn ted aoainst reoular
sanctioned Dosts and t eir services are availed
continuo uslv. with notio al breaks. bv t e State
foras ,ct
instru men
rnment or
it wa ers.
70 ears,
riod i.e.
be enti led to
shall
a
DDointees
hoc er contractual
witho t
I r
mof
e
t work
m t
rked for
e
and
havino
I
nature
is
availa
I
oerennia
ble
ri ht
an
eriod
created in such cate aorv of o ersons, Their claim for
reoularizati on. if anv. ma v have to be co nsidered
ble scheme.
seoaratelv in terms o f leoallv perm
nces on
(3 ) In the event, a claim is made for minimum pay scale
after more than three years and two months of
comptetion of 10 years of continuous working, a daily
wager, ad hoc or contractual employee shall be entitled to
arrears for a period of three years and two months,"
13.
The iudoment of the ADex Cour t reoorted in 2 o10(9)
SCC 247 between: State of Karnataka and others v
M.L.Kesari and ot hers. in Darticular . Daras 4 to 10 reads as
u
nder:
4. The decisi on in State of Karna taka v. Umadevi wa s rendered
on 10.4.2006 re oorted in 2006 4 SCC 1). In that case a
Constitution Bench of this Court held that a ppointments made
without fottowing the due process or the rules relating to
appointment did not confer any right on the appointees and
courts cannot direct their absorption, regularization or reengagement nor make their service permanent, and the High
Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution should not ordinarily issue directions for absorption,
regularization, or permanent continuance unless the recruitment
had been done in a regular manner, in terms of the
constitutional scheme; and that the courts must be careful in
ensuring that they do not interfere unduly with the economic
SN. ]
arrangement of its affairs by the State or its rstrumentalities,
nor lend themselves to be instruments to faciltt,t the bypassing
of the constitutional and statutory mandates. I =
i:; Court further
held that a temporary, contractual, casual -. a daity-wage
employee does not have a tegal right to be r ade permanent
unless he had been appointed in terms of the r t I vant rules or in
adherence of Articles 14 and 16 of the Const,t, ion. This Court
however made one exception to the above t tsition and the
same is extracted below :
,,
"53.
e asDect needs to b e clarified. There ma be
cases where irreqular aoooi ntmen :.
t ill al
ADDOI ntm ents) as exDlai ned in S.V Na rava n A DDA
r7967 (7) SCR 7 281. R.N Na ni unda E a 797
scc 40 9l and B.N. Naoaraia n [ 7979 4 CC 5O7
and ferred
tn
5 abov.
t lul quali ted
y sanction ed vacant Do s ls miaht have
DersQns tn
been made and t e emplovee s hav,
tin ued
work for ten ve ars or mo re bur wi ut the
T n tervention of orders of the co urts t
'of tribun als.
The auestio n of re qu la rization oft 12 Servrces of
such emolovees
av have tobe >nsidered on
merits in the lio ht of the o rinciples i *tled bv this
Court in th eca ses above referred to a , din el I ht
of th is iudament. In that co ntext, 'h nion of
India,
the State Governmen ts and their
instrume ntaliti es should take steps tt I requlariz eas
a one-time measure, the services of s,. ;h irreoularlv
aooointed. who have worked for ten 1 ea rs or more
,_
in dulv sanctioned posts but not ul der cover of
orde
of the courts or of tribuna i: and sh ou ld
further ensu re that reqular recr L itmen ts are
unde 'aken to f ill those va nt sar l tioned oosts
that
ouire to be filled uD. ,n :ases wh ere
temDora rv emolovees or dail Waqt?'s are b tnq
now em Dloved. The orocess m ust be et in otion
within six months from this d. ate....,
"5. It is evident from the above that there ; an exception
to the general principles against 'regularizaticlt enunciated in
Umadevi, if the following conditions are futfilled ;
(i) The employee concerned should have worke,t tr j0 years ar
more in duly sanctioned post without the beneftt ( r protection of
the interim order of any court or tribunat. In ot ter v",orc|s. the
State Government or its instrumentality shoulct lave employed
)o
SN. J
the employee and continued him ln Servtce volu ntarily and
continuously for more than ten years,
(ii) The appointment of such employee should not be iltegat,
even if irregular. Where the appojntments are not made or
continued against sanctioned posts or where the persons
appointed do not possess the prescribed minimum qualifications,
the appointments will be considered to be ittegat. But where the
person employed possessed the prescribed quatifications and
was working against sanctioned posts, but had been selected
without undergoing the process of open competitive selection,
such appointments are considered to be irregular.
Uma
casts
dut u on
concern
Government or instrumenta I itv, to take ste Ds to
reoulatize the servi ces of those irreoularlv ao Dointed
lo ees w
had serv
for more h
ten ea
without the benefit or o rotection of a n interi orders o f
or tri als asa
-time mea
Umadevi
dire cted that s uch one-tim e measure must be set in
motion
thin six month s from the da te of
decision
(rend red on 7O.4. 2006).
6. The term ' one-time measu re' has to be understood in its
proper perspective. This would normally mean that after the
decision in Umadevi, each department or each instrumentality
should undertake a one-time exercise and prepare a tist of all
casual, daily-wage or ad hoc employees who have been working
for more than ten years without the intervention of courts and
tribunals and subject them to a process verification as to
whether they are working against vacant posts and possess the
requisite qualification for the post and if so, regularize their
services,
7. At the end of six months from the date of decision in
Umadevi, cases of several da rly -wage/ad -hoc/casua t emptoyees
were still pending before Courts. Consequentty, several
departments and instru menta tities did not commence the onetime regularization process, On the other hand, some
Government departments or instru menta lities undeftook the
one-time exercise excluding several employees from
consideration either on the ground that their cases were pending
in courts or due to sheer oversight. In such circumstances, the
employees who were entitled to be considered in terms of para
53 of the decision in lJmadevi, will not tose their right to be
considered for regularization, merely because the one-time
7t
sNl
exercise vlas completed v"ithout cortsiderirttt heii'cast:-s, or
Untaoevt
because the six month period mentioned in pi:;i 53 0t
has expired. The one-time exercise should ' ' :;ide: all d ailyput
t 1C ycars of
w age/a d hoc/those employees who had
continuotts servtce as on 10'4 2006 witL't t L availtnq the
interim orders of courts o' i tbu aals. If anY
protecton
'employer of anY
had held the one-time exercise in tctr 1.; 6f p6p 53 of
lJmadevi, but did not consider the cases of sor:'' ' employees who
,1, tne em PloYer
were entitled to the benefit of para 53 of Uma t'
concerned should consider their cases also, 'z ' ' :oFtinuatton of
ill
the one-time exercise. The one time exerctse ' 's be concluded
only when alt the employees who are entitled t be considered
in terms of Para 53 of lJmadevi, are so consiclt' t ).
)
53 of
8. fhe obiect be hin d the said d irection n Dara
ho
those
tat
to
ensure
Um adevi i. two- fold. First ,s
ervlc
n
ous
ha eDU ,n more t han te n vea rs of con t
withou t the Dro ction of anv,n terim ord 's of cou rts or
tribunals, before th e date ofd ecision irr Umadevi was
ularizal ! ,n n view of
ren dered, are const ered for
at
servrce. s cond is to ens lre
the r lon
the
etuate
1?rD
o
itie
e
ins
de a me
ad-waoe
/
a
ilv
MD lovina Ders ons on(
ctice of
periodicallv
ho / cas al for lono D eriods and th' ? L
re ula rize them on t,he oro und at th ev f ave served for
more tha n ten vears, th ere bv defeatin o tht constitutional
men t and
or statutorv Dro vrstons relatino to r<: ruit
intme nt. The true effect of the dire ton is tha all
AD
aso
ea
DC rsons who ha ve wo rked for more th anl
ithout the
Uma c'i)
de ion
.4.2 o6 t date
ofa v interim order of anv cou Iortr un ,n
tect
a L lifica ,on a
ss,l, o the ourst
ts,
vac'ant
entitled to be co nsid ered r req ulariz atic '1 . The fact that
g\ exercise of
the emolo er has not undert,akenofsulle
de is,on
re ular t ion withi n srx mo nths
nl in
ken
no(
Umadevi or th at such ex rcise wa s
such
title
reo ard toa limited few, wilI not a tsen
emolove s, th e rtq ht to be considered fc tl re ul rizati
in te rms of the above dire ctions in Umader t as a one-time
measure.
four years
9. These appeals have been pending for more (Zila
.thart
Panchayat'
after the decision in l'lmadevi. The Appellan
of
C"i"il has not considered the cases ; -espondents
llmadevi or
rijutarization within six months of the deci'; r n in
th e rea fte r.
SN. J
10. The Division Bench of the High Court has directed that the
cases of respondents should be considered in accordance with
law. The only further direction that needs be grven, in view of
Umadevi, is that the Zila Panchayat, Gadag should now
undertake an exercise within six months, a general one- time
regularization exercise, to find out whether there are any daily
wage/casua l/ ad - hoc employees serving the Zila Panchayat and rf
so whether such employees (including the respondents) fulfill
the requirements mentioned in para 53 of Umadevi. If they fulfill
them, their services have to be regularized. If such an exercise
has already been undertaken by ignoring or omitting the cases
of respondents 1 to 3 because of the pendency of these cases,
then their cases shall have to be considered in continuation of
the said one time exercise within three months. It is needless to
say that if the respondents do not fulfill the requirements of
Para 53 of Umadevi, their services need not be regularised. If
the employees who have completed ten years service do not
possess the educational qualifications prescribed for the post, at
the time of their appointment, they may be considered for
regularization in suitable lower posts. This appeal s disposed of
accordingly.
L4. In the iudqment of the A D ex Court in N ihal Sinoh
n
v
P
n a
re orted in
65, the Supreme Court considered the case of absorption
of Specaal Police Officers appointed by the State, whose
wages were paid by Banks at whose disposal their
services were made available. It held that the mere fact
that wages were paid by the Bank did not render the
appellants 'employees' of those Banks since the
appointment was made by the State and disciplinary
control vested with the State. It held that the creation of a
SN. J
cadre or sanctioning of posts for a cac re is a matter
exclusively within the authority of the St rte, but if the
State did not choose to create a cadre bUt :hose to make
appointments of
persons creatingl contractual
relationship, its action is arbitrary.
It:rso
r f sed to
acceD t the defenc e that there w ere no sit I tio n ed
os
and so there was i u stif ica tio n for the :i :ate o utilise
services of lar qe number of oeo ple like thr: a
nts for
deca d es. It held that "sanction ed oosts dr
not fall from
heaven" and that the State has to creit
them b
con scious choice on the basis of some ratio r
assessm n
of need. Referrino to Umadevi, it held that- lhe appell
before th em were not arb itrarilv chos er
ts
their i
apDointmen t was not an 'irreq ular'apo oin: nent as it had
been made in accordance with the statut rr
prescribed under the Police Act, 1861. e nd
cannot be heard to
cedure
h
State
av that thev are not en itled to b
absorbed into the services of the State )n Derm a nent
basis as,
qordinq to it, their a DDointmen I s were p u relv
ot aqain -a! y sanctionec Dosts created
bv the State. It was ield that the iudq mr: rt in Umadeva
temDorar Y and
S\- J
cann of become a licence for exolo itation bv the S tate and
its
in stru menta li
ties and neit her the Gov ernment of
Puniab nor those oub lic s ector Banks can c ontinue such a
Dractic e inconsistent with their obli q atio n to function in
accorda ce with the Con titution.
15. The iudqment of the A pex Court reoorted in 2015
SCC Online SC 1797 between B.Sri nivasulu and others v
Nellore Municioal CorDoration ReD .bv its Com mrssroner,
Nellore District, And hra Pradesh an d others, in o articular
parasTandSr eads as under:
(7)
We find it difficul t
ACCC n t the rea qon tn o ado ted b
h
Hiqh Coutt. Th e riqht of the a ppellants to seek re qularization
flows from the G.O. No.212 dated 22.4.1994 The aooellant
have been in s ervice of the first resD ondent no t onl vt) rior to the
issuance of th e said G.O but even subseouent to th e issue of
O. till to
The respondent Municipality being a statutory
body is obliged by the G.O. 212(supra). Inspite of the above
mentioned G.O. the respondents kept quite for almost 20 years
without regularising the service of the appellants and continued
to extract work from the appellants.
8.
In the circumstances, refusing the benefit of the above
mentioned G.O. on the ground that the appettants approached
the Tribunal belatedly, in our opinion, is not justified. In the
circumstances, the appeal is allowed modifying the order under
appeal by directing that the appellants' services be regularised
with effect from the date of their completing their five year
continuous service as was laid down by this Court in District
Collector/Cha irperson & Others vs. M.L. Singh & Ors. 2009 (B)
SCC 48O.
s\. l
In Amarkant Rai v State of Bihar reoo r :ed ( 201s) 8
scc 265, the Suprem e Court held that '1he objective
16.
behind the exception carved out in this case uas to permit
regularization of such appointment, which are irregular
but not illegal, and to ensure appointmenl s, which are
of
cun
irregular but not illegal, and to ensur(
em lovmen tofth ose oer sons w ho had set ed the State
Gover nment a nd their instr ume ntalities for r lore han t n
ve rs
This
In that case, e mDlo vee was workin fo r 29 vears.
decision a DDroves earl er vle w
M.L.Kesarl
xtrac
( xD re
ssed in
abo
17. In Stat eofl arkhan dvK amal Pra se( re oorted in
( 201 4)75 cc 22 3. sim ilar v iew wa s t rke n bv the
I ws
sh
rem Cour nd it
"47.... In vtew o f the ca oorical findinc of fact on the
releva n t conten tious ssue that the resDOr 1'ent emolovees
have con tinued in their serv ice fo r mor( 1,r than 70 Years
la id down b
rinc
t,
the
uou
co
this Cour tinu madevi case (St,ate of arni l'aka v Umadevi
at ra 53 souarelv
4SC 7:2O scc
The Divlst 21 Bench of the
a pplies to th e Drese nt cases.
') e respondent
Hiqh Court has riqh tlv he ld tha tl
an not
emD lovees are e ntitled for e relief, the am
interfered with bv t his Court."
SN. J
18. The Judgment of this court dated 06.t2.2o22
passed in W.p.No.27602 of 2O19 which pertains to
regularization of 35 NMRS of Sri Lakshmi Narasimha
Swamy Temple, yadadri, Nalgonda District, which
had been upheld by the Division Bench of this Court
in W.A.No.937 ot 2023 dated 10.1O.2023 and atso
confirmed by the order of Apex Court dated
09.08.2024 in SLp No.32847 ot 2OZ4-
19. The iudqm ent of the Aoex Court in Hari Krishna
Mandir Trust V. s tate of M aharas htra and Others reo orted
nAI
o2
m
an
ar
ular
Nos.lOO and 101 he da s follows:
" 10C. The High Courts exercising their jurisdiction
under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, not only have the
power to issue a writ of mandamus or in the nature of
mandamus, but are du tv-bo und to e xerctse su ch
wer
ere
ov r en
a
lic a th
has failed
exercr eor h s wron lv exer ised
dis cretion conferred u oon it b v a sta tu t .oraru le, or
olic
rston
e
ern
torh
xerct s
h
eti n
al
de
r on irrelevan
con sid e rat ron.
101. In all such cases, the High Court must issue a writ of
mandamus and give directions to compel performance in
an appropriate and lawful manner of the discretion
conferred upon the Government or a public authority.,,
2'l
20.
\\i
of this Cou rt tn il; Jud qment
The Division B en ch
da ted 10. o6.20 13 Da ssed in W.A.N os.7 82ofi I
D a ssed
he
ho ln
of 2O1 2 while
tn W.P.N o. 24377
d me
a
d8 4
dat g o8.o 9 .2010
of 2007 and c.
.N ( .48 of 2O 08
ob serv ed as un der:"Furthcr, rt is manifest from the material o" ecord that the
the law
,.iu,."1'"f the similarly placed persons who ap I oached
ion also ssued
Lor.ti *"r. regularized. The appella nt-Corpo1tt
1:
1109 1992'
9'
varlous ofiice 6rders/circulars dated 20'12
oO.io.ZOOzandlatestbeing4'72009forr:.gularizatronof
hat Section 25-
iasuat/contract employees, ltls also to be seer,
ly any employer
i or tnc lD Act prohibits unfair labourthepractice
factu'l scenario of the
ol.-*o.*n]un. As can be seen from
uch a long and
aur", on hand, engaging the respondents for
(
but unfair
thing
r
is
.oni.tiout pe.ioa of tim" on casual basis
of the
25-T
attracting the provisions of .Se r 'lon
Loow pru.ti."
'rf-'r" learned Singte :udge while relyinl ln the decisions
rO 4.,
Court, right[y hetd lhat the resporc 3nts are entitled
.i if.l"-4p",
-r"gr1!iirution
as directed in the impugnr t orders' as the
io
matter in
learnJd singl€ Judge considered all the aspects of the
view
considered
in
olr
detail, in the proper perspective, which,
does not warrant interference in these appeals'
2L. The Division
B ench
19.O 9.20t7
pa ss
da ted
of this Coutt in its lud omen t
di
re orte din2O 18(2) ALD p aoe
ob
rv da
UN
w. P.NO .2', ,-L7
ofz oL7
a2 tDa ra 1 6an dp ara 18
r
Court is
"16. It is trite that the law declared by theA- iupreme
of the
cle
binding throughout the country under
the time the
Lonstiiution oi india. It is noteworthy tha: byrendered, the
i,lao.unt tn lJma Devi's case (supra), trr1 rs
;. No.212, dated
pioiirio.t of Acr 2 of . 1994 and G'o'
-ne
Court, while
22.4.1994, were in existence' The Supte
of f
i r d absorPtion
Jenouncing the practice oF regularization
q
p"r.nnt, riho entered service through back loors by iving a
SN, J
go-bye to the due procedure prescribed for appointments to
public posts, consciously ordered for
one-time
rization of those, who were working for a
period of not less than 10 years. It has given directions rn this
regard to all the State Governments and also Union of India.
The Supreme Court is presumed to be conscious of various State
enactments such as Act 2 of 1994 and executive orders such as
G.O. Ms. No.212, dated 22.4.L994, while giving directions in
Para No.53 of the judgment in Uma Devi's case (supra). But
still, it has not made any exception in favour of the States where
State enactments banning reg u la rization/a bsorption exist.
Therefore , Act 2 of 1994 an d G,O. Ms, No .212, dated
22.4.L994, do not whittle down the width and the
m t in Man
hini's
u ra
o e r rh e tra IE cto r voft
he dir ections is sued hw the
Supreme C ourt in Para 53 o f its iudqment in U ma Devi's
case (su ra ) Iti s. there fore n ot oerm is sible f o r t h e
resDonde ts to take shelt er under Act 2 o f 1994 and c.O.
Ms. No.212 dated 22.4.1994 to denv reoulariz ation to
th e oetit ton ers wh o hav
admi ttedlv- s atisfied t h e
criteria la id down in Para N .53 of the iudome t in Uma
Devi's case (s
a).
a b sorptio n/reg u la
18. For the aforementioned reasons, order, dated 27.6.2017,
in OA No.1442 of 2074, on the file of the Tribunal is set aside
and f h
it ef t n ic r I larer ed wi t h iha zlir ection f o t h
resDo nden ts to consider reo ularisation of the s ervices of
the Detit oners aoainst the existino vacanc ies of Work
fnsoector s and aDDoint the subiect to th eir satisfvino
the criter ia laid down in Pa ra No.53 of the iu dqment in
Uma D evi's 6ase (suD ra ). This Droc s must be co Dleted
within two month s from the date of receiDt of a copv of
this or der."
22, The Division Bench of t his Cou rt in its I udoment
dated 21 .04.2020 oassed in I.A.Nos .1 o t 2O2O in 1 of 2019
and W.P.No.23O57 of 2 019 reoorted in 2O2O(41 ALD paqe
379 at paras 45, 48 and par a 50 observed as under:"45. There is no dispute that petitioners have been working on
daily wage since 1990 and have put in almost (30) years of
service by now. They have been given minimum time-scale from
2.9
SN, J
the year 2000. They have been continuously vorking without
any Coud orders in their favour from 1990 till c i :r:'
It is no t known whv t e lst res D( rd ent has not
as
f o llowed the decision tn U ma Devi's c: e( suora),
(suora
a
undertaken
)
ar
l
expl ained in M.L. Kes ari's case
one-ti me exercrse of oreoa rino the list - rf dailv waoe
48.
)-
emplo vees who had worked f or more tha r L ten (10) vears
on
without the in tervention of th e Courts and ri unal
10.4.2006 and sub iect them toaD rocess ! J rifi ation as t o
whether thev are wo rkinq aqainst va( nt DOSTS and
( sts, a nd if so,
n fo
lific
ssess r uisit
requl artze their services.
50. Accordinqly, the writ petition is allowe i the impugned
orders dated 20.8.2019 passed by the 1st rr:sg cndent rejecting
the cases of petitioners for regularization of ervices on onetime basis are declared as illegal, arbitrar)' rnd violative of
Artrcles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constituti(r of India; the
respo ndents a re directed to r eoulari eor L one-time basis
eac
the
t t he Detitioners
rvtces
ner
comD lete 10 vears of servic eo n dailv I aoes from the
initia I dates of their a DDointmen t B t,t :v shall not be
entitl ed to anv mo netarv reli ef. The said lercise shall be
don with in two [2 weeks f rom the d: !l 30f recerD tof
o
of h o rde
r
23. The Ju domen of the
Dex cou
dalrt d 19.08.202s
passed in Civil ApDeal No.8558 of 2018 reE orted in 2025
SCC ONLIN E sC 1735 in "Dharam S inqh _ rnd Others v.
State of U.P. and Ano ther", in oa rticu la r, th ! rel e vant Dara
Nos.13 ,17 .18. 19 and 20 are extracted h et I under:
"13. As we have observed in both la99o I upra) and
Shripal (Supra), outsourcing cannot Iecome a
convenient shield to perpetuate precariousr 3ss and to
sidestep fair engagement practices where l-le work is
inherently perennial. The Commissio'r s further
contention that the appellants are not "full-time"
employees but continue only by virtue of interim
SN. J
orders also does not advance their case. That interim
protection was granted precisely because of the long
history of engagement and the pendency of the
challenge to the State's refusals. It neither creates
rights that did not exist nor erases entitlements that
may arise upon a proper adjudication of the legality of
those refusa ls.
17. Before concluding, we think it necessary to recall
that the State (here referring to both the Union and
the State governments) is not a mere market
participant but a constitutional employer. It cannot
balance budgets on the backs of those who perform
the most basic and recurring public functions. Where
work recurs day after day and year after year, the
establlshment must reflect that reality in its sanctioned
strength and engagement practices. The long term
extraction oF regular labour under temporary labels
corrodes confidence in public administration and
offends the promise of equal protection. Financial
stringency certainly has a place in public policy, but it
is not a talisman that overrides fairness, reason and
the duty to organise work on lawful lines.
18. Moreover, it must necessarily be noted that '.adhocism" thrives where administration is opaque. The
State Departments must keep and produce accurate
establishment registers, muster rolls and outsourcing
arrangements, and they must explain, with evidence,
why they prefer precarious engagement over
sanctioned posts where the work is perennial. If
"constraint" is invoked, the record should show what
alternatives were considered, why similarly placed
workers were treated differenily, and how the chosen
course aligns with Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the
Constitution of India. Sensitivity to the human
consequences of prolonged insecurity is not
sentimentality. It is a constitutional discipline that
should inform every decision affecting those who keep
public offices runn ing.
t1
sN, l
of
"19, Havrng regard to the long, undisputed :t rvice
of their
the appellants, the admitted perennial natur:
indicating vacar( es and
d uties, and the material
ollowtng
comparator regularisations, we issue the
directions:
i. Regularization and creation of Superrtt tmerary
efFect
oostsiAll appellants shall stand regularized th
the I I n Court
irii zq.oq.z002, the date on which
n m issio n
directed a fresh recommendation by the C'l
ng posts
and a fresh decision by the State on sancticthe
for the appellants. For this purpose, the Sta' and
successor establishment (U P Educatior Services
supe r lJmerary
Selec tion Conlmission) shall create
Driver or
p osts in the corresPond in g cadres, Cla ss-il1
or
;uard
equivalent) a rrd Class- IV (Peon/Attendant/j
rlons. On
equivalent) without anY caveats or Precon
:d at not
regu la rization, each aPP ellant shall be Pla:
le for the
sll
less than the lninimum o f the regular PaYd
post, with Protection of Ia st-drawn wages if ligher an
the a p pella nts shall be entitled to the ; rllsequent
For
increments in the PaY sc ale as per the PaY lrade.
the
seniority and Promotion, service shall courr from
date of regu a rization as given above.
arrt: rrs: Each
ii. Financ ial consequences and
ifferen ce
appellant sh all be Paid as arrears the fu d
r ces at the
betwee n (a) the P ay and admissible allowe
post from
minlmum of the r egular PaY-level for the' paid, for
time to time, and (b) the amounts a ctua
I th. date of
the P eriod from 24.04.2002 untithe
cas: may be.
regu la r ization/retirement/death, as
interim
Amoun ts alreadY Paid under Previot; -s
shall be
directions shall be so adjusted' T
the
efault,
r
released within three months a
est at 6 o/o
unp aid amount shall carrY comP
tment.
per annum From the date of defau
who has
m
ll
d
lr
t
t
4.
r l rlarization
t e date of
\
I
i2
SN, ]
su De ra n n uation
clause (
for oav fixataon. a rrea rs under
ii), and recalculati on of oension, oratuitv
h r erminal dues. The revised ens
terminal dues shall be pai d wit h in three months
of this Judqment.
v.D ceased a
In
ella nts
Aooellant No. 5 and anv o ther aooellant who has
died
durinq
pend ncv,
his/ her
leoal
reoresentatives on record shall be Daid the
arrears under clause (ii) uD to the date of death,
with all term i n a l/ reti ra I dues
toqether
recalculated consistentl with clause ( i). within
three months of this Judoment.
v. Compliance affidavit: The Principal Secretary,
Higher Education Department, Government of Uttar
Pradesh, or the Secretary of the U.P. Education
Services Selection Commission or the prevalent
competent authority, shall file an affidavit of
compliance beFore this Court within four months of this
Judgment.
20. We have framed these directions
comprehensively because, case after case, orders of this
Court in such matters have been met with fresh
technicalities, rolling " reconsidera tio ns, " and administrative
drift which further prolongs the insecurity for those who
have already laboured for years on daily wages. Therefore,
we have learned that lustice in such cases cannot rest on
simpliciter directions, but it demands imposition of clear
duties, fixed timelines, and verifiable compliance. As a
constitutional employer, the State is held to a higher
standard and therefore it must organise its perennial
workers on a sanctioned footing, create a budget for lawful
engagement, and implement judicial directions in letter and
spirit. Delay to follow these obligations is not mere
negligence but rather it is a conscious method of denial that
erodes livelihoods and dignity for these workers. The
operative scheme we have set here comprising of creation
of supernumerary posts, full regularization, subsequent
financial benefits, and a sworn aFfidavlt of compliance, is
thereFore a pathway designed to convert rights into
outcomes and to reaffirm that fairness in engagement and
transparency in administration are not matters of grace, but
SN, J
obligations under Articles 74, 16 and 21 of t I : Constitution
of Ind ia
24. This Court oDines that in the prese I t case, the
respondents failed to discharqe their du tv i r examinino
the reoue t of the oetition er for req u l, riz ation of
petitioner's services, wh o is workino as oart
=
a nd further to consider his re o uest to treat t l
me sweeDer
em orar
service of the Detitioner in the last qrade oost of oart time
sweeDer as re qular one for all o urposes bv ! rantinq last
orade pav with oeriodical increment revised J 'om time to
time from the date of aooointm ent of the l -'titioner. in
accordan ce to law,
25.
This
Court ooines that o etitioner is :ntitled for
consideration of oetitioner' s case for qrant ol :he relief as
ra e
for in
h
resent Writ P
nt
ew of the
observations of the Apex Cou rt in va rio u ; iudoments
(referred to and extracted above) and the riew of the
Division Bench of this Court in the Judqments referred to
and extracted above.
2 6.
Takin o into consideration:-
j.+
SN, J
a) The aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case'
b) The submissions made by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner and learned standing
counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos.4 & 5
c) The observations of the Apex Court in the various
judgments (referred to and extracted above) and again
enlisted below:
i)(2020) l scc (L&s)
(ii) 1990(2) SCC Page 396
(iii) 2o2s rNsc 144
(iv) 2024 LawSuit(SC) 1209
(v) (2017) l Scc 148
(vi) 2o1o(9) scc 247
(vii) (2013) 14scc 6s
(viii) 2O15 SCC Online SC t797
(ix) (2o1s) I scc 26s
(x) (2014) 7 scc223
(xi) SLP No.32847 of 2024
(xii) AIR 2O2O Supreme Court 3969
(xiii) (2OO6) 4 Scc 1
(xiv) 2O11 (1) ALD, Page 234
(xv) 2O18(2)ALD page 282
(xvi) 2O2O(a)ALD pase 379
(xvii)2O25 SCC ONLINE SC 173s
d) The Division Bench order of this Court dated
10.06.2013 passed in W.A.Nos.782 ot 2O1O and 854 of
2012 while uploading the Judgment dated 08'09.2010
(
-15
SN, J
passed in W.P.No.2437t ol 2OO7 and C.C.ti ).48 of 2OO8
(referred to and extracted above),
e) The Division Bench order of this Court dated
L9.O9.2OL7 passed in W.p.No.2721-7 of 2O1i (referred to
and extracted above),
f
)
The Division Bench order of this Court dated
2L.O4.2O2O passed in I.A.Nos.1 of 2O2O in t of 2O19 and
W.P.No.23O57 of 2O19 (referred to and extrzr, ted above).
g) In the light of discussion and conclusior as arrived at
as above from para Nos.4 to 26 of the presen, order,
The Writ Petition
directed
ts allowed,
the reti tioner is
to put-fo rth the claim of the
ltit i oner for
req la rizat onofoetition er's services, and I so the clai m
,
of the De tition rtot reat t he te
DOra
S(
vtc es of the
petitioner i n the la et qrad e post of SweeDer I ; reqular
;
on e
for all ouro oses bv qrant i no last orade o avv t thD efl od ica I
in crem ents
revised from time to time frort th edate of
aoD ointme nt
be n efits
of the De titioner
and all
( ) nseo
ent ial
dul y enclos inq all the releva n t ,i rcu ments ln
5N, J
suDDor t of oetitioner' s case as ou -forth in the D resent
writ oe tition, within
Deriod of o ne (01) week from the
date of receipt of co v of the order and the reso n d ents
shall ex amine and c onsider the same in accord nce to
law, in conformitv with orin cioles of natural iustice bv
to th
rt rovt rl tn at
an
Detition e r
in terms of or ders oassed bv the Suoreme
Court in
ma Devi's case reD orted in 2006(4) S C Paqe 1,
h
ment
o nn ortunit
in W.P.No.24
9.2010 re
trme
ersonal h
fn
201 1
of 2OO7
e 234
A
82of2 1
tn
r|
n
10.o6.201
also as D er Division Bench Judqment of this Court dated
L9.O9.20L7 oassed in W.P.N 0.27217 of 2OO7
Dorted in
2018(2)A LD Daoe 282 a nd also the Divisi on Bench
Judome nt of this Co urt dated 2L.O4.2O2 o
I. A.Nos.l of 2O2O i n 1 of 2O19 in
orted in 2O20 4 ALD
fi nali t
assed in
.P.No.23O5 7 of 2OL9
which h d
within ane riod of four (o 4 )rru eeks from th e date
recer
id ration
the Aoex Cou
of
co
s
hi
er dul
rvations and h law
tn the various i ud o ments
a kin
wnb
referred to and
l7
SN. J
f the
e xtracted
above), and in oart icular, Dara tl r.53
iud ment
of the Apex Court in the c a5e ,f State of
Ka rnataka
v. Uma Devi
and
dulv comnt r nicate the
deci s io n
to the p etitioner. However, th ere ;hall be no
order
toc
s
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending l1 this Writ
Petition, shall stand closed
SI .M,OSMAN ALI BAIG
AS I ISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble MRS JUSTICE SUREE \LLl NANDA
(For His Lordships kind perusal)
To,
1 11 LR Copies
2. The Under Secretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Lav, Justice and Company
Affairs. New Delhi.
3 The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Associatior Library. High Coui
. Buildings,Hyderabad.
4. The Principal Secretary, Panchayathraj Department, II 3 State of felangana,
Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad.
5. The Pnncipal Secretary, Finance and Planning Deparr ent, The State of
Telangana, Govt. of Telangana, Telangana Secretari.t Hyderabad
6 The District Collector (Panchayat), and Chairman of lr,li rirrurn, Wages
Committee and District Selection Committee, Ranga l cdy District.
7. The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Praja Parishad, Ran! r Reddy Drstrict.
8 The l\,4andal Development Officer, Mandal Praja Paris" rd, Shamshabad
[\,4andal, Ranga Reddy District.
9 One CC to SRI CH GANESH, Advocate [OPUCI
f
10 One CC to SRI PRADEEP REDDY KATTA, Advocate )PUCI
11 Twp CCs to GP FOR PANCHAYAT RAJ & RURAL D : 1=LOPMENT, High
Court for the State of Telangana. [OUT]
i 2. Two CD Copies
BN/PMK
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED:2210112026
\
t.)
\j,
c-)
O
ORDER
Jtr
WP.No.30153 ot 2022
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
--1 i-. '
I r. -)
c) tf zfaa
r-y,iffixr
-^/:N
'+\
':
' rtB 2U6:':!
i
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review