Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 321e ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND ANDTWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI
WRIT PETITION No. 1071 ol 2012
WRIT PETITION No.22554 of 2019
WRIT PETITION No.26616 of 2022
WRIT PETITION No.6671 of 2025
&
WRIT PETITION No.20127 ol 2025
W.P.No.1071 OF 2012
Between:
The Fishermen Co-operative Society, Abhangapatnam Village, Rep. by its Secretary
Battu Erra Sailoo, S/o. Sayanna, R/o. Abhangapatnam Village, Navipet Mandal,
Nizamabad District
...PETITIONER
AND
The Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, Camp Court at Hyderabad Represented
by Secretary, at Hyderabad, Chandravihar, Nampally,
The Asst. Director of Frshermen/Ex-officio, Deputy Registrar of Fishermen
Coop. Societies, Nizamabad, Nizamabad District.
Battu Sailoo, S/o. Odenna, R/o. Abbapoor, Navipet Mandal, Nizamabad
District. President for the Fishermen Coop. Society of the Abbapur, Navipet
Mandal, Nizamabad District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, Order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of WRIT OF CERTIORARI calling for the records in C.T.A No.79 of
2009 dated 29-01-2011 of the 1't respondent arising oul of Proc. No, 515/8/2006
dated 02-02-2009 of the 2nd respondent and QUASH the same as illegal,
.t'
)"'
arbltrary, malafide and non-application of mind against :l e principles of natural
justice and consequently allow the C.T.A.No.79/2009 pe r Cing on the file of 1st
respondent.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2012(WPMP. NO: 1323 OF 2012
Petition unler Section 151 CPC praying that in the r rcumstances stated in
the affrdavit filed in support of the petition, the High. Co rt may be pleased to
suspend the pror;eedings No. 515/8/2006 dated 02-02-:,- 09 of the respondent
No. 2, pending di:;posal of the above writ petition.
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2012(WVMP. NO: 57'l OF 20'12
Between:
The Asst. Director of Frshermen/Ex-off icio, Deputy Registrar r 'Fishermen Coop
Societies, Nizamabad, Nizamabad District.
...PETITI(,NER/RESPONDENTS
AND
The Fishernen Co-operative Society, Rep. by its Sec r ,tary Battu Erra Sailoo
S/o. Sayanna, Abhangapatnam Village, R/o. A bhangal rtnam Village,
... REStr )NDENT/PETITIONER
'1
. The Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, Rep. by Secretar , at Hyderabad,
Nampally,
.Chandravihar,
2. Battu Sailoc, S/o. Odenna. President for the Fisherm€r Coop. Society of the
Abbapur, R/o Abbapoor, Navipet Mandal, Nizamabad )rstrict.
(Respondents 2 & 3 are not necessary parties to this gr, tition)
... RESP() ,IDENTS/PETITIONER
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the r; cumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Co- t may be pleased to
vacate the interim orders dt. 19.01 .2012 passed in WPMF No '1323 of 2012 in
WP No 1O71 of 2012
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI CH.JANARDHAN REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : GP FOR COOPERATI()
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 : GP FOR FISHERIES
Counsel for the Respondent No.3 :
--
',1
W.P.No.22554 OF 2019
Between:
1. Mekala Ramulu, S/o.Sayanna, Aged about 43 years, Oq'' Fishing.
R/o.H.No.1-47, Abbapoor Village Navipet (tvl), Nizamabad Dist, T.S.
2. Battu Yerranna, S/o.sayanna Aged about 58 years, Occ. Fishing R/o'H.No'151 , Abbapoor Village Nivipet (M), Nizamabad Dist, T.S.
about 65 years, Occ Fishing
3. Mekala Naganna, S/o.Linganna Aged(ltl),
Nizamabad Dist T S
Navipet
Viiiage
R/o H.No.'1-.i'8, Abbapoor
4 Battu Nadipi Vaddenna, S/o.Battu Vaddenna, Aged
.about {8 .y99rp-O^cc
Fishing. R/o H No.'1-30 Abbapoor Village Navipet (M). Nizamabad IJrst, I s
Fishing,
5. Battu Vaddenna, S/o Chandranna, Aged about 54 ygqp -Ogc
R/o.H.No.1-98, Abbapoor Village Navipet (M), Nizamabad Dist' I s
6. Thadiyem Ramulu, S/o.Laxmanna, Aged alout -46 years, Occ Fishing, R/o'
Abbafoor Village, Navipet (M), Nizamabad Dist, T.S.
Oc^c Fishing'
7 Mekala Thirupathi, S/o Narayana, Aged(M),about 48 y91rs,
Dist, T S
Nizamabad
Rlo H tto 1+8 Abbapoor Villale Navipet
B. Gouri Gangadhar, S/o.Bhoumanna, ASeq- about 50 y.eP!'s., 99c Fishing'
R/o H.No.1--63, Abbapoor Village Navipet (ltl), Nizamabad Drst, I 5
55. y99i9'. 99c Fishing,
9 Kunepally Sailu, S/oGangaram, Aged.about
(M),
Dast' I S'
Nizamabad
Navipet
Village
Abbapoor
Fi.No.1-31,
R/o
10. Battu Chinna sailu, s/o.Nadipi Voddenna. Aged about 56 years, o^cc Fishing.
R/o.H.No 1-22, Abbapoor Viliage Navipet (M). Nizamabad Dist' I S'
...PETITIONERS
AND
The State of Telangana, Reo bv its Princioal Secretary, Department of
Animal Husbandry and Fisheries Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
Telangana
2, The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, lrrigation and CAD
Department Secreta-riat Buildings, Hyderabad, Telangana
3. Commissioner of Fisheries, Matsya Bhavan, Masab Tank Hyderabad'
Telangana
4. The Asst. Director of Fishermen/Ex-Officio, Deputy Registrar of Fishermen
Coop. Societies Nizamabad, Nizamabad District
5. The District Fisheries Officer, Nizamabad District' Nizamabad, Telangana
6. The District Collector, Nizamabad District, Nizamabad
Rep by its
7. The Fishermen Cooperative Society, Abhangapatnam Village*
Dlstnct
Secretary Abhangapdtnam Village. Navipet Mandal Nizamabacl
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Atlicle 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stateo in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to issue Writ, order or direction more in the nature Writ of Mandamus'
declaring the inaction of the Respondent No.4 in gri nting licenses to the
Petitioners herein for fishing rights in Yerragunta Reservoir :s per G..O. MS No 74
lrrigation and CAD (LA.R and R/A2) Dept dated 't4-08-20i i. as illegal, unjust and
violative of fundamental rights of the Petitioners guarante( I under Article 14 and
21 ol our Constitution and consequently direct the Respo r. lents to issue licences
to the Petitioners for fishing rights in Yerragunta Reservoir
lA NO:1 OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the r rcumstances stated in
the affrdavit filed in support of the petition, the High C(,r rt may be pleased tcr
DIRECT the Respondent No. 4 to consider and pass app .opriate orders on the
representation submitted by the Petitioners herein dater 24-07-201g within a
stipulated period of time, pending disposal of the Writ petitr: r.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI N.SAILESH NA|K
Counsel for the Respondent No.1,3to7: GP FOR FISHERIt S
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 : GP FOR IRRIGATION i CAD
W.P.No.26616 OF 2022
Between:
The Fishermen C-ooperative Society. Abangapatnam, Rep. by its president, B. Sailu.
S/o Sayanna. Aged about 71 years. Rlo nOangapatn,i r. Naveepet Mandal.
Nizamabad District
...PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its principal Secretary, Fisheries
Department Secretariat Buildings, Hyd'erabad
-elangana.
The Commissioner, Fisheries Department, Hyderabad
J
The District Fisheries Officer, Arsapally, Nizamabad, N i amabad Distrrct
The Assistant Director of Fishermen, /Ex-Officio Deor,t Registrar, Fishermen
Cooperative Societies, Asrapally, Ni2amabad, Nizama : rd District.
The Fishermen Development Officer, Asrapally, N i amabad, Nizamabad
District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under p.rlicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue any order or orders or direction or writ or writs, more particularly
one in the nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS declaring the Proceedings
No.316D/2022, Dt.01 .6.2022, of Respondent No.3 to 5 is as illegal, arbitrary,
malafide and violation of the principles of the natural justice, and contrary to law
and set aside the same in the interest of justice and equity and consequently
direct the respondent No. 3 to 5, to recerve the lease amount and grant permission
to catch the fish in Kadicheruvu and Errakunta Tanks, in the interest of justice and
equity.
lA NO: 'l OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petrtron, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondents No. 3 to 5, to recerve the lease amount and grant permission to
catch the fish in Kadicheruvu and Errakunta Tanks, situated in Abangapatnam
Village, Naveepet Mandal, Nizamabad District in pursuance of the representation
DL2611112021, pending disposal of the above writ petition in the interest of justice
and equity.
lA NO: 2 OF 2022
Between:
'1
. Mekala Ramulu, S/o Sayanna Aged about 45 years Occ Fishing R/o H No
147 Abbapoor Village, Navipet M, Nrzamabad Dist T S
2. Battu Yerranna, S/o Sayanna Aged about 68 years Occ Fishing R/o H No 151
Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist T S.
3. Mekala Naganna, s/o Linganna Aged about 68 years Occ Fishing R/o H No
148 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist TS.
4. Battu Nadipi Vaddenna, S/o Battu Vaddenna Aged about 62 years Occ
Fishing R/o H No I30 Abbapoor Vrllage Navipet M Nizamabad Dist T S.
5. Battu Vaddenna, S/o Chandranna Aged about 60 years Occ Fishing R/o H No
'198 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist T S.
6. Thadiyem Ramulu, S/o Laxmanna Aged about 50 years Occ Fishing R/o
Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist TS.
7. Mekala Thirupathi, S/o Narayana Aged about 58 years Occ Fishing R/o H No
148 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist T S.
I
A pou_1^Ggpgadhar,
S/o Bhoomanna Aged about 52
'163
No
1 :ars Occ Flshing R/o H
Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist' .)
9. Kunepally Sailu, S/o Ganqaram Aqed about 62 veat
Occ Fishing R/o H No
131 Abbapoor Village Navi-pet M Nizamabad DistlS
10. Battu Chinna Sailu, S/o Nadipi Voddenna Aoed abc rt 63years Occ Fishinq
R/o H No i22 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Niz"amabz r Dist T S.
..,IMPLEAD PETITIONERS/PROPOSED R]: ;PONDENTS No.6to15
AND
1.
The Fishermen Cooperative Society, Abangapatnam lep by its president, B
).arlu: P/9: Sayanna, Aged about 71 yeais, R/o. At rngapatnam, Naveepet
Mandal, Ni.zamabad District
...PETITIO \ ERM/RIT PETITIONER
The State,
Telangana, .. Rep._ by its princio
Secretary, Fisherie;
Uepartment. Secretariat Buildings.
Hyderabad
of
I
3. The Commrssioner, Fisheries Department, Hyderaba,i Telangana.
4. The District Frsheries Officer, Arsapally, Nizamabad r zamabad District
5. The Assistant Director of Fishermen, /Ex-officio Dep - y Registrar, Fishermen
Cooperative Societies, Asrapally, Nizamabad, Nizanrrr'ad District.
6. The Fishermen Development Officer, Asrapally, N zamabad, Nizamabaci
District.
...RESPONt) :NTS/RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section '151 cpc praying that in the . rcumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petrtion, the High court r: ry be pleased pleased
to permit the lmplead Petitioners herein to implead the prc,l osed Respondents as
Party Respondent Nos. 6 to 15 in the main writ petition as well as in the l.A's, in
the interest of justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI CH.JANARDHAN REDDY
Counsel for the Respondents: Gp FOR FISHERIES
W.P.No.6671 OF 2o25
Between:
The Fishermen C-ooperative Society, Abangapatnam, Rep y its President Battu
trra Sailu, S/o. Sayanna, Aged a6out TS lears, Rlo. Ab,r gapatnam, Naveepet
,
Mandal, Nizamabad'Distriit
,
...PETITIONER
2AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary Fisheries Department,
Secretariat Buildings, Hyderab ad.
2. The Commissioner, Fisheries Department Hyderabad, Telangana
3 The District Fisheries Officer, Arsapally, Nizamabad. Nizamabad District,
4. The Assistant Drrector of Fisheries /Ex.-Officio, Deputy Registrar, Fishermen
Cooperative Socreties, Arsapally, Nizamabad Nizamabad District.
5. The Fishermen Development Officer, Arsapally, Nizamabad. Nizamabad
District.
6 (q!a Ramulu, S/o Sayanna Aged about 45 years Occ Fishing R/o H No 147
Abbapoor Village. Navipet M. Nizamabad Dist T S.
7 Qq!t, Yerranna, S/o Sayanna Aged about 68 years Occ Fishing R/o H No 15
Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist T S.
8 Mekala Naganna, s/o Linganna Aged about 68 years Occ Fishing R/o H No
148 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist TS
I
Qgtty Nadipi Vaddenna, S/o Battu Vaddenna Aged about 62 years Occ
Fishing R/o H No 130 Abbapoor Village Navipet M tiizamabad Dist i S.
10 Bgttu Vaddenna, S/o Chandranna Aged about 60 years Occ Frshing R/o H No
198 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist T S
1 1.
Thadiyem . Ramulu, S/o Laxmanna Aged about 58 years Occ Fishing R/o
Abbapoor Village Navrpet M Nizamabad Dist TS
12 Mekala Thirupathi, S/o Narayana Aged about 58 years Occ Fishing R/o H No
148 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist T S.
13. 9ouri 9angadhar, S/o Bhoomanna Aged about 62 years Occ Fishing R/o H
.No 163 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist T S.
14 Kunepally Sailu, S/o Gangaram Aged about 55 years Occ Fishing R/o H No
131 Abbapoor Village Navrpet M Nizamabad Dist TS.
15 Battu Chinna Sailu, S/o Nadipi Voddenna Aged about 63years Occ Fishing
R/o H No 122 Abbapoor Village Navipet tul Nizhmabad Dist T S.
RR6 to 15 are impleaded as per C.O.dt.05.08.2025 in lA No.2/2025.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue any order or direction, Writ or Writs, more particularly one in the
nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS declaring the proceedings No.744lDl2O24 dated
21.02.2025 of the 4th respondent is as illegal, arbitrary, malafide and contrary to
law and also violation of principles of natural justice and set aside the same in the
interest of justice and equity.
lA NO: 1 OF 202s
Petition under Section 15.1 CpC praying that in the ,ircumstances stated rn
the affidavit fileo in support of the petition, the High c r rrt may be pleased to
suspend the proceedings No.744lDt2o24 dated 21 .02.202! of the 4th Respondent
pending disposal of the above Writ petition in the interest ,)
Justice and equity.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI CH.JANARDHAN REDD./
Counsel for the Respondents No.1to5 : Gp FOR FISHERI iS
Counsel for the Respondents No.6tolS : SRI N.SAILESH lAtK
W.P.No.20127 OF 2025
Between:
The Fishermen Cooperative Society, Abangapatnanr Rep by its President,
Battu Erra.Sailu, S/o Sayanna. ng'eO aOou-i75 vear. , nio A bangapatnam
Naveepet lr,4andal, Nizamdbad Distr-ict_
...PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its principal Sr.r -etan/, Department of
Frshenes, Secretarial Buildings, Hyderabad
The Commissioner, Fisheries Department, Hyderabao
The District Fisheries Officer, Arsapally, Nizamabad, t l :amabad District.
'The
Assistant Director of Fishermen/Ex-Officio. Deor t Registrar, Fishermen
Cooperative Societies. Asrapally, Nizamabad, iriizail ji rd District.
The Fishermen Development Officer, Asrapally. t
District.
b
B
rr
amabad, Nizamabad
The Mandal Revenue officer, Naveepet Mandal, Nizanr bad District
Mel<ala Ranrulu, S/o Sayanna Aqed about 45 vears , tcc Fishing R/o H
No
14l Abbapocr Village, Navipet M,-Nizamabad Di6t T S
Battu Yerranna. S/o Sayanna Aqed about 68 vears Ocr Fishing R/o H No '151
Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist f S.
I Y.ulgt.". Naganng, s/o Linganna Aged about 68 years- )cc Fishing R/o H No
148 Abbapoor Vitlage Navipet M Nizamabad Diit iS.
1O.Battu Nadipi vaddenna, s/o Battu vaddenna Agec about 62 years occ
Fishing R/o H No .r 30 Abbapoor Viilage Navipet rr,r iiiir,' rabad Dist t s. - - - 11 Battu. Vaddenna, S/o Chandranna Aged about 60 year,; Jcc Fishino FIo
H No
198 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizimabad Oiit f S
12 Thadiyem Ramulu, S/o Laxmanna Aged about 50 r rrs Occ
Fishing R/o
Abbapoor Viilage Navipet M NizamabaE DisiTS.- - 1
13 ltilef<ala Thirupathi, S/o Narayana Aged about 5g years Ooc Fishing R/o H No
148 Abbapoor Village Navipet M Nizamabad Dist i S
14.9ou.ri
S/o Bhoomanna Aged about 52 years Occ Fishing R/o H
No 163^Gangadhar,.
Abbapoor Village Navipet M Ni-zamabad Dist T S.
15. Kune.pally Sailu, S/o Gangaram_ Aged about 62 years Occ Fishing R/o H
'13'1 Abbapoor
Vittage Navipet Ir/ Nizamabad DistTS
No
'16 Battu chinna
Sailu, S/o.Nadipi
Aged about 63years occ Fishing
R/o H No 122 Abbapoor Viilage .Voddenna
Navipet M Niz"amabad Dist i S
RR7 to 16 are impleaded as per C.O.dt.Os.O8.2O2S in lA No.2/2025.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to issue any order or orders or direction or writ or writs, more particularly
one in the nature of wRrr oF MANDAMUS declarrng the proceedings
No.3161D12022, DL.27.4.2022, of Respondent No.4 is as iilegal, arbitrary, matafide
and violation of the principles of the natural lustice, and contrary to the Apcs Act
and Rules 1964 and without any Notrce and also violation of Article 19 (i
) g of
constitution of India, and set-aside the same in the interest of justice and equity in
the interest of justice and equity.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
'Petitron
under section 15i cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
Suspend the Proceedings No 316/D/2022, Dt. 21 .4.2022, of Respondent No. 4
pendrng disposal of the above writ petition in the interest of justice and equity.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI CH.JANARDHAN REDDY
Counsel for the Respondents No.1tos: Gp FOR FISHERIES
Counsel forthe Respondents No.6: Gp FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondents No.7tol6 : SRI N.SAILESH NAIK
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
IN TTIE HIGI{ COURT FOR THE STATE OF T[, ,ANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
.THE
HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE T. MAI,I IA\/I DEVI
WRIT PETITION No. 1071 of 201i:
WRIT PETITION No.22554 of 20 I')
WRIT PETITION No.26616 of 202.1
WRIT PETITION No.6671 of 2025
AND
WRIT PETITION No.20127 of 202:;
Dated : 23.01.2026
WRIT PETII'ION No. l07l of 2012
Behveen:
The Fishermer. ('o-operative Society
Abhangapatnan Village, Rep. by its Secretary
Battu Erra Sailoo
Petitioner
AND
The Co-operat,ve Appellate Tribunal and 2 others
Respondents
WRI'[ PETITION No.22554 of 2019
Between:
Mekala RamulLr and 9 others
..Petitioners
AIID
The State of Telangana and 6 others.
...Respondents
TMD.J
W.P.Nos. I 07 I of 2012, 22554 of 2019,
26616 of2022.6671 &20t2'7 ol2o25
WRIT PETITION No.26616 of 2022
Befween:
The Fishermen Co-operative Society
Abhangapatnam, Rep. by its President
B. Sailu
Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana and 4 others.
Respondents
WRIT PETITION No.667l of 2025
Betlveen:
Thc Fishennen Co-operative Society
Abhangapatnam, Rep. by its President
Battu Ena Sailu
Petrtioner
AND
The State of Telangana and l4 others.
Respondents
IVRIT PETITION No.20127 of 2025
Befween:
The Fishermen Co-operative Sociery
Abhangapatnam, Rep. by its President
Battu Erra Sailu
...Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana and l5 others.
Respondents
TMD.J
W.P.Noi. ( I of2trl2,2255,1 of20t9,
26616nf2 12.66;l & 2ol2-l of2025
COMMON ORDER
W.P.NI,.l07l of 2012 was filed seeking a Writ o Certiorari to call
for the rccor,ls in C.T.A.No.19 of 2009 dated 29.C1 2011 passed by
respondcnt No.I-the Cooperative Appellate Tribunrr arising out of
proceedings i'lo,sl5/8/2006 dated 02.02.2009 of re:1 ondent No.2-the
Assistant Drrcctor of Fishermen/Ex-Ofhcio-Depr t , Registrar of
Fishcrrnen Coopcrative Societies, Nizamabad, and to c rash the same as
illegal, arbitlrry, ntttla Jide and violative of the prir :iples of natural
-justice and consequently to allow C.T.A.No.79 of 2() 9 on the llle ol
respondent Nr,.l and to pass such other order or orders
2.
Brief lacts leading to the filing of W.P.No.107l of 2012 are that
the petitioner- [:isherrnen Cooperative Society of Abharr apatnam Village
was lormcd irr the year 2003 and had two tanks, narrr y Kadi Cheruvu
and Yerrakunta, under its operation for fishing. The Fist )ries Department
leased out Kadi Cheruru to the petitioner-society for ishing purposes
Another sociery. namely the Fishermen Cooperative Sl :iety of Abbapur
Village, Navipet Mandal, Nizamabad District, wanted I be formed and
some members belonging to Fishermen community of rbbapur Village,
TMD,J
W P.Nos l07l ot2012,21554 of2019,
26616 of2022,6671 &2012? of2o25
requested to give share in the hshery wealth of Kadi Cheruvu tank and
they filed a petition before respondent No.2 seeking formation of a
separate society. Respondent No.2 rejected the proposal of the fishermen
of Abbapur Vittage lor a separate socrety on the ground that it rvas not
feasible to lorm a separate society due to scant water resources ar.'ailable
to them, but directed the petitioner-society to admit the fishermen of
Abbapur lrde proceedings No.5l5iBl2006 dated 02.04.2007 . Aggrieved
by the samc, the petitioner-society filed C.T.A.No.34 of 2007 belore the
Cooperative Tribunal, Hyderabad, and vide order dated 03.10.2008, the
Tribunal had set aside the order dated 02.04.2007 passed by respondcnt
No.2 and remanded the matter to respondent No.2 to pass fresh orders
alter giving opportunity to both sides
2.1 Pursuant to the orders of the Tribunal, respondent No.2 passed
order in proceedings No.515/8/2006 dated 02.02.2009 amending Byelaw No. 1 of the petitioner-society, which prescribes the area of operation
of the society by extending it to both the villages, narnely
Abhangapatnam and Abbapur, thereby facilitating the fishermen of
Abbapur Village also to join as members of the petitioner-society
TMD.J
W.P.N.s 'l of2l)12,22554 of 2019,
26616 ol
, 22.66-71 &.20127 of2025
Challenging lhe same, the petitioner-society filed C." \.No.79 of 2009
before respondcnt No.l
2.2 Mrile Jrsgrosing ol' C.'I.A.No.79 of 2009, thc . ribunal observed
that Abhangrrpatnam Village has Kadi Cheruru urr:r its operation.
which consisLed of water spread area of Acs.84..i , oLrt of which
Acs.44.28 berongcd to Abbapur Village. [t was furl :r observed that
Abbapur Villirge has seven tanks with a total water s r ead area of only
Acs.35.76, and that the rvater in these bodies is seasr,: al not perennial
The Tribunal also noted that Abhangapatnam Village as another tank,
Yerrakunta, rr ith a watcr spread area of Acs.22.14. () rserving that the
fishermen of Abhapur Village were making efforts t: form a separate
socrety and c,)nsidering the contention of the petitio r :r-society before
respondent No.2 that the fishermen of Abbapur Villapt cannot be made
as members ol the petitioner-society and that the peti .r rner-society was
reluctant to adrnit them as members, the Tribunal ft.l that a separate
society has to bc organized for the fishermen of Abbr 1 rr Village. The
Tribunal thus observed that when the water resources cl Abhangapatnam
and Abbapur Villages were deleted from the parent so(rt :ty, namely FCS
TMD,J
W P.Nos.l07L of 2012, 22554 ol 2019,
26616 of2022 66'71 8L2Ol27 of2O2S
Gundaram, it was the bounden duty of the Department of Fisheries to
provide livelihood to the fishermen by allotting any of the available
nearby water bodies and that the fishermen cannot be left in the lurch
without livelihood and without membership in any existing society
2.3 Accordingly, the Tribunal dismissed C.T.A.No.79 of 2009 with an
observation that issuance of membership to fishermen is different from
that of the area of the operation of the society as prescribed in Bye-law
No.
I and that it was open to respondent No.l therein/respondent No.2
herein to decide the number of fishermen to be admitted from Abbapur
Viltage into FCS Abhangapatnam, depending on the etigibility of the
existing members of FCS Abhangapatnam and the eligibility of the
proposed members/fishermen from Abbapur, in accordance with the
viability norms fixed by the Commissioner of Fisheries and the water
spread area available in the tanks of Abhangapatnam and Abbapur
Villages, as per the amended Bye-law No.1 issued in proceedings
No.515/8/2006 dated 02.02.2009. Challenging the said order,
W.P.No. 1 07 1 of 2012 is filed by the FCS Abhangapatnam.
TMD,J
W.P.No;.lI I of 2012,22554 of20l9,
26616 ol
I r2.,66i I &20127 of2025
3.
Vide order dated 19.01.2012 in W.P.M.P.No l23 of 2012 in
W.P.No.107l of 2012, this Couft granted interim i spension of the
impugned proceedings No 5 I 5/8/2006 dated 02.02.20C\
4.
Respondent No.2-the Assistant Director ol F sheries, hled a
countff affidavit along with a stay vacate petition. I. s stated that the
direction of respondent No.l to grant admission to re fishermen of
Abbapur Village into the petitioner-society was i ven only after
examining the water spread area available witlL the Fishermen
Cooperative Society of Abhangapatnam and Abbapur \/ llages, as per the
amended Bye-law No.l issued in proceedings No. j 5/Bi2006 dated
02.02.2009. It is further stated that there are eight t nks in Abbapur
Village and therefore, a separate society of its or.vr can be formed
without seeking inclusion in the petitioner-society. It i also stated that
Acs.44.28 of land of Abbapur Village has submerged rto Kadicherul.u
and therefore, the revenue rights ol the Fishermen o1 \bbapur Village
cannot be denied or written off by any authorify, as t is a matter of
natural justice to enjoy the resources fallir ;
within the
revenue/geographical jurisdiction ofan individual, socie y or village as a
TMD.J
W.P.Nos.l07l of 2012, 22i54 ol20l9,
26616 of2022.6671 &20117 o12025
whole. It is stated that since Acs.44.28 out of Acs.84.36 ol Kadi
Cheruvu belong to Abbapur Village, the Tribunal has also directed the
rcspondents to grant membership to the fishermen of Abbapur Village
and therelore, the interirn order is liable to be vacated
5.
While the matter stood thus, the Govemment of Telangana has
undertaken the construction of Yerrakunta Reservoir over more than
2000 acres of land, subsuming Kadi Cheruvu and other surrounding
tanks. The Governrnent has also issued G.O.Ms.No.74, Irrigation &
CAD (LA.R&R/A2) Dept. dated 14.08.2018, providing that when
smaller water bodies are subsumed and are no longer in existence, the
Fishermen Cooperative Socreties, earlier holding lease on such bodies,
shall cease to exist and the fishing rights of such water bodies may be
extended to the project-affected families who express interest in
undertaking fishing as their livelihood activity, along with members of
Fishermen Cooperative Societies of the subsumed smaller water bodies,
through the Iicensing system
TMD.J
I rl of2012,225)4 of20t9,
26616 t\ ' 22.6611&201)7 012025
W.P.Nrrr
6,
In these circumstances, some of the hshermen. lvho are project-
aff,ected pers()ns belonging to Abbapur Village, filed
V.P.No.22554 of
20 l9 seeking a Writ of Mandamus declaring the inacl rn on the part of
respondent No.4 in granting licences to the petitioners r rerein for Iishing
rights in Yerriigunta Reservoir, as per G.O.Ms.No.74,
I
rigation & CAD
(LA.R&R/A2'I l)ept. dated t4 08.2018, as ittegal rnd unjust and
conscquently ro direct the respondents to issue licence; o the petitioners
lbr fishing rig)rts in Yerragunta Rcscrvoir and to pass sL :h other order or
orders.
7.
fhe petLtioners in W.P.No.22554 ol20l9 stare:- that the society
in operation prior to the issuance of G.O.Ms. \ r.74, was the
Ablanghapatnarr Fishermen Cooperative Society anc that as per the
said G.O., the society must be disbanded and licensi:r
system should
be introduced, providing fishing rights to the project-;r lected families.
Accordingly, the petitioners have submitted represe,r rtions and had
sought a direction to the respondents to consider the rc1 -esentations.
-IMD'J
W.P.Nos. I 07l ot 2012, 2255 4 of 201 9.
26616 of 2022,66'l | &20127 of2025
8. This Court, vide orders dated 23.10.2019, disposed of
W.P.No.22554 of 2019, directing the respondent authorities to
consider the representation of the petitioners dated 24.07.2019 and to
pass necessary orders thereon, subject to payment of requisite charges
as may be determined
9.
Aggrieved by the order dated 23.10.2019, respondent No.7-
Fishennen Cooperativc Society, Abhangapatnam in W.P.No.22554 of
2019, filed W.A.No.925 of 2019. Vide order dated 28.10.2021, the
Division Bench of this Coun has set aside the order dated 23.10.2019
and directed the leamed Single Judge to pass appropriate orders on
merits afresh after hearing all the parties and further directed that
W.P.No.22554 of 2019 be listed along with W.P.No. 107 I of 2012.
10. In the meantime, the Fishermen Cooperative Society,
Abhanghapatnam, submitted that in spite of stay granted by this Court
in W.P.No.l07 I ol2012, the oflficial respondents therein were neither
receiving the lease amount nor granting permission to catch fish from
Kadi Cheruvu and Yerrakunta tanks. Therefore, they approached this
\\'.P.Nlr l
26616 o
TMD,J
I o42012,22554 of2019.
22 6611 & 20:2'7 of2015
Court by filing W.P.No.2l78l of 2022, seeking ir direction to the
respondents No.2 & 3 to receive the lease amount fo- he year 2021-22
and to grant l)ermission to catch fish in Yerrakunta I d Kadi Cheruvu
tanks situatcd in Abhangapatnam Village, l)u iuant to their
representatioil dated 26.1 1.2021 .
11. Vide ordcr29.04.2022, W.P.No.2178l of 20?.- \'as disposed of,
directing respondent No.2 therein to consider the rt'1 r :sentation of the
petitioner-society dated 26.11.2021 and to pass r tcessary orders
thereon within a period of tbur (04) weeks from thc ( i c olreceipt of a
copy ofthe order
12. In response to the representation of the r itio ner-society,
I
respondents No.2 to 5 informed that, vtde i rpugned order
No. 3 I 6,D/2022 dated 01.06.2022, the registration
the petitioner-
society had heen cancelled vide proceedings No j , ilD,r202l dated
2'7 .04.2022
on the grounds that the petitioner- r' ciety was not
conducting elections and was not acting in accc r lance with the
provisions of the Telangana Cooperative Societies \ct, 1964, and
TMD,J
w.P.Nos.l07l of 2012, 22554 otz0I9,
2(,616 of 2021. 66T I 8r- 201)1 oi )025
1,2
further that Kadi Cheruvu and Yerrakunta tanks situated in
Abhanghapatnam Village, as well as the tanks situated in Abbapur
Viltage, have merged into the Yerrakunta Balancing Reservoir and
also that the membership was not being granted to the Fishermen of
Abbapur Village. It is stated that the cancellation of the registration of
the society was not communicated to the petitioner-society by any
mode. Though the petitioner-society requested a copy of the
cancellation order, the same lvas not furnished. Thereafter, challenging
the cancellation order, W.P.No.266l6 of 2022 has been filed.
13. ,-W.P.No.26616 of 2022 was also directed to be listed along with
W.P.No.1071 of 2012
14. Respondent No.3 in W.P.No.266l6 of 2022 has hled a counter
affidavit stating that petitioner-society was de-registered vide
proceedings dated 2'/.04.2022 and the same was intimated to the
society videletter in Lr.No.3 l6lD12022 dated01.06.2022. It is stated
that, since FCS Abhanghapatnam ls no longer in existence, the
question of leasing of tanks to the society does not arise. It is further
TMD.J
W.P.Noi. I I of2012,22554 ot2019,
26616 at ) 22,6671 &20t2'1 of2025
stated that necessary notices were issued to the scc ety prior to deregistration and therefore the society has been de-rer stered only after
lollou,ing clue process. It is also stated that, n vierv of the
construction of Yerrakunta Reservoir, the lease .carr tt be granted to
the society lor lishing rights in the reservoir.
I5. Whilc the matter stood thus, the Fishermen Coc rerative Society,
Abhangapatnam, filed W.P.No.667l of 2025 r;, rking \Vrit of
Mandamus declaring proceedings No.7441D12024 c Lted 2l .02.2025
issued by respondent No.4 as illegat, arbitrary, un,l nstitutional and
also in violation of the principles of natural justice ar r consequently to
set aside the same and to pass such other order or ord: s
16. The pet.itioner-society is challenging the actic r of respondent
No.4 in proposing the forming of a new Fisherr en Cooperative
Society in the name of Yerrakunta Reservoir at i tbapur Viltage,
based on the representation made by the fishermen ot' lbbapur Village
with 122 members and in inviting objections regarc i rg correction of
TMD,J
\\'P Nos l07l ol'2012.22554 of20l9,
26616 ot2o22.667
t & 20t21 of2025
the area of operation of the Fisherrnen Cooperative Society of
Abhangapatnam Village.
17. 'l'he grievancc of the petitioner-soc iel)
IS
that, without
considering the fact that the petitio ner-society was already establislied
vlde Registration No.365/D/2003 dated 29.02.2003 by respondent
No.4 and has been functioning in accordance r.vith the Rules and
Regulations and that Yerrakunta Tank and Kadi Cheruvu tank fall
within the area of operation of thc pet itioner-soc iety. Respondent No.4
has initiated steps for tbrming of a new fishemren society at Abbapur
villagc, which is unwarranted. It is submitte,J that vide proceedings
dated 21 .02.2025, the Assistant Director ol [risheries called for
objections, if any, from the villages of Abbapur and Abhangapatnarn
for lormation of a society comprising of fishennen tiom both the
villages i.e., Abbapur and Abhangapatnam, rvith headquarter at
Abbapur village, on the ground that a major portion of the water
spread area, i.e., Ac.325.39 gts., falls within the Yerrakunta Reservoir
.T'MD.J
\lr.P Nos
26616 t\'
I
. 22.661l,&201)l of2}25
rL ol20l2. 12554 of20l9.
and that Abbapur Village has a larger fishermen.) pulation, as per
request made by the fishermen of Abbapur Village
18. It is noriced tlnt yirle order dated 24.042025 ir \\i.p.No.(r(r7l ol'
202-r. 1f115 Crturt had directed that W.P.No.667 I o 2025 ber listed
along with W.P.Nos.l07 I of 2012,22554 of 2019 atl266t2ot-2022
and lurther directed the respondents not to take any rl cision about the
lorrnation of the new society pursuant to the notices r :;red 2l .02.2025
and 07.01.2025
19.
'l'hc afL:cted parties rvere
subsequently implt.i led in thc writ
petitions and have flled their respective counter afficiar ts
20. Responcient No.3 in W.P.No.6671 of 2025 I rs also tilcd a
counter attlda.rit staling that the water bodies and lar ls perlaining to
Abbapur and Abhangapatnam Villages have been ; bsumed in the
Yerrakunta Reservoir and that a total extent of Acs 325.39 gts., of
Abbapur Village and Acs.98.t4 gts. of Abhangapatr m Village has
been subsumed in the said Yerrakunta Reservoir. Since a major
T]\,fD'J
W.P.Nos. 1071 of 201 2. 22554 of 201 9,
26616 of 2022. 6611 &20127 ot2025
pofiion of the water spread area was in Abbapur Village , a direction
was given to form a single Fishermen Cooperative Society with its
headquarter at Abbapur Village. It is further submitted that after
expiry of the terrn of the Managing Committee of the I'ishemren
Cooperative Society, Abhangapatnam, the Commissioner of Fisheries,
Telangana State, Hyderabad, appointed the Assistant Director of
Fisheries, Nizamabad,
AS
Person-in-Charge, vide proceedings
No.259818212019 dated 12.01 .2021, to manage the atfairs of the
society. It is stated that the Director of Fisheries, Nizamabad, has
addressed letters to the former President ol the Abhangapatrlam
Fishermen Cooperative Society calling upon him to hand over the
records of the society but they were reluctant to do so. It is further
stated that in spite of issuance of notices dated 14.07 .2021 , 05 .10 -2021
and 08.12.2021 by way of registered post for convening the General
Body Meeting, the notices were rejected and retumed
20.1 It is stated that after election proposals were sent to the State
Cooperative Election Authority, the said Authority has appointed an
TMD.J
W.P.Nos r ) of2012,22554 of2019.
26616
of) 22.6671 &20127 of2025
t7
Election Officer for conducting elections ytte proceedings
No.l167[NZR/SCEN20I9, dated 04.04.2022. Horv ,ver, the society
did not respond and did not parlicipatc in the electi n process, even
after issuance of a letter to Fishermen Cooperativ: Society, r.vith a
copy marked to the Panchayat Secretary, Abha I lapatnam Gram
Panchayat, vi,le letter No.287 lDl2022 dated 11.04.1'.t 22. It is stated
that there is no provision for electing the Managing I tmmittee by the
members thernselves without involving the Electic,r Officer as per
Section i I -tt read with Rule 22 (8-e)(iii)(vf ) of Telangana
Cooperative Societies Act, 1964. It is further state j thar the society
was de-registered during the year 2022 tnder Ser:t on 9(B) of the
Telangana Cooperative Societies Act, 1964. It is st lmitted that the
reserwoir carL accommodate 423 fishermen fa I ilies and that
Abhangapatnam Village has only 20 families as agr,i Lst 404 fan.rilies
olAbbapur Village. Thereflore, it was prayed for va: ting the interim
order and to dismiss the writ petitions filed b., rhe Fishermen
Cooperative Society, Abhangapatnam.
TMD J
W P Nos.lOTl of20t2,2255a of20l9,
26616 of 2022.6611 &20121 0f1075
21. The Fishermen Cooperative Society, Abhangapatnam, hled
W.P.No.20l27 of 2025 seeking a Writ of Mandamus declaring
proceedings No.3l6lD/2022 dated 27.04.2022 issued by respondent
No.4 as illegal, arbitrary, mala Jide and in violation of principlcs of
naturaljustice
22. The proccedings dated 27.04.2022 were passed de-registenng
tl're Fishermen Cooperative Society, Abhangapatnam, on the ground
that thc area of operation of Fishermen Cooperative Socrety,
Abhangapatnarn Village, had been subsumed into the Yerrakunta
Balancing Reservoir and that the tanks are no more in physical
exrstence.
23. The members of Fishermen Cooperative Society, Abbapur, were
also arrayed as respondents in the said Writ Petition.
24. Respondents No.7 to 16 have filed their counter affidavits.
25. Learned counsel for the petitioner-Fishermen Cooperative
Society, Abhangapatnam, vehemently argued that the de-registration
TMD.J
!\' P.ho> I 7l of20l2,22ii4 of20l9,
26616 ot
. 12.6611 &2At21 of2o25
of the Fishermen Cooperative Society at Abhangapi nam was illegal
and therefore was liable to be set aside and that the retitioner-society
should be granted tishing rights ovcr the waters i) the Yerr.akunta
Reseruoir
26. Leamed counscl fbr the unoltlcial responderr; submitted that
the order of de-registration ts appealable under S; ction 76 ol the
Telangana Ciroperarir.e Societies Act, 1964 and ftr her that (lue to
merqer and srrbsumine of both the u,ater bodies unc|r the operation of
FCS Abhangapatnarn into Yerakunta Reservoir as t.r the provisions
of G.O.Ms.N,t.74, a single Fishermen Cooperative S tciety has to be
formed for both the villages
27. Learnecl Colentrnent Plcader. lor Fisheries al ; contended that
the lands of both thc villages have been acquired an J that most of the
water tanks have been subsumed under the Yerrakun r Reservoir. [t is
further submitted that there is sulficient water s[ I rad area in the
reservoir to accommodate the fishermen of both . re villages and
therefore, a new and single Fishermen Cooperative Sr ;iety is required
TMD,J
W P.Nos.107l of2012,32554 of 2019,
26616 of 2022. 66'7 I & 2OlZ7 of 2025
to be formed and licences are required to be issued to the Fishermen
Cooperative Society as well as the project-affectedidisplaced persons
in accordance rvith G.O.Ms.No.74. Therefore. learned Government
Pleader supported the irnpugned proceedings dated 27.04.2022 and
2t.02.2025.
28. Having regard to the rival contentions and the material on
record. this Court hnds that the issues involved in W.P.No.107l ol
2012 and 22554 of 2019 have become inf'rucruous. The issues in
W.P.No.266l6 of 2022 and W.P.No.20127 of 2025 pertain to the de-
registration of the society and the said issue is appealable under
Section 76 of the Telansana Cooperative Societies Act, 1964. Insolar
as.W.P.No.667 | of 2025 is concerned, this Court is of the opinion that
since rnost of the water bodies of both the villages have already been
subsumed in Yerrakunta Reservoir, the area of operation ofeach of the
Fishermen Cooperative Society cannot be earmarked separately
Therefore, in the interest of all the parties, a new and single Fishermen
Cooperative Society comprising of members from the hshermen
TMD,J
W.P.Nos t, 'l of2012,22554 of20l9,
26616
ofi 22.66;L &20127 of2025
21,
communities of both Abhangapatnam and Abbapu- Village shall be
formed. Tht: existing members of Fishermen Co,r rerative Society,
Abhangapatnam, shall be granted membership in he new society
without conducting any skill test. Since the Irisher ren Cooperative
Society of Abbapur Viltage r,",as not lormed by concr :ting a skill test,
the respondents are directed to call for applications zr J conduct a skill
test and thereafter, grant mernbership to eligibie fishermen from
Abbapur Village- Membership shall be granted stri,: y in accordance
with the viability ol the a','ailable r.vater resouro s. The projectdisplaced pcrsons who are eligible for mcr rbership under
G.O.Ms.No.7,1 shall also be considered by the Fish, ries Department
after granting membership to the fishermen of botlr Abhangapatnam
and Abbapur Villages. If the new society is formec. the chalienge to
the de-registrzrtion oIFCS Abhangapatnam would ber: me infructuous,
29. Since it is already observed that water rl ources are not
{
available separately for the Fishermen Coopenr ve Society of
{.
Abhangapatnam, this Courl fails to understand he efficacy of
I
I
<-.r....'i, r-..ij-r..ri-
7jry!a]!,+;i'i!r
, -:.:ie+,i+ir - ."-
-
TMD,J
W.P.Nos. I 071 ot 20t2, 22554 ot 20t9,
2661 6 ot 2022, 6b7 | & 2Ot 27 of )O2S
challenging the de-registration before the Cooperative Tribunal.
However, it is left to the wisdom of the petitioners therein for taking
appropdate action thereon
30. In the lesult,
(i)
W.P.Nos.107l of 2012 and 22554 of 2019 are dismissed
as inf-rucfuous.
(ii) W.P.Ncs.266 I 6 of 2022 and 20127 of 2025 are disposed
ol rvith liberty to the petitioner-society to approach the
l
Tribunal under Section 76 of the Telangana Cooperative
Societies Act, 1964.
(iii) W.P.No.667l of 2025 is disposed of with above directions
I
I
There shall be no order as to costs
Pending n.riscellaneous petitions, if any, shall also stand
dismissed
SD/-A. SRINIVASA REDDY
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
,,.
//TRUE COPY/ I
(9
sEcTtoN oFFtcER
To,
'l The Principal Secretary. Fisheries Department, Secretariat, Telangana State,
Hyderabad
2. The Commissioner, Fisheries Department, Hyderabad, Telangana.
3. The District Fisheries Officer, Arsapally, Nizamabad, Nizamabad District
4, The Assistant Director of Fishermen, /Ex-Officio Deputy Registrar, Fishermen
Cooperative Societies, Asrapally, Nizamabad, Nizamabad'Olstri[t
C^;TA_
5' The Frshermen Deveropment officer, AsrapaIy, Nizamabir , Nizamabad District.
Q. The Mandal Revenue officer, Naveepet lVlandal, Nizamab I I District
7. One CC to SRt CH.JANARDHAN REDDY, Advocate.
]l
[Opt
B. One CC to SRI N.SAILESH NAIK, Advocate [OpUC]
9 Two CCS to GP FOR FISHERIES, High Court for the Stak: rf Telangana
[OUT]
10 Two ccs to cP FoR rRRrcATroN AND cAD, High r
ourt for the state of
Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT]
1.1 . Two CD Copies
12 Two CCs to Gp FoR coopERATrON, High court for
lourl
13.Two CD Copies.
BSK
BS
tkz
ti r State of rerangana
\
HlGH COURT
DATED:2310112026
n' coMMoN oRDER
W.P.No.1071 of 20ta
W.P.No.22554 of 2019
v or I
.s
\s
a7
+
\
It
,
:(
(t
(,/
t'
Ig+
W.P.No.26616 of 2022
W.P.No.6671 of 2025
\f
&
W.P.No.20127 of 2025
DISMISSING THE W.P.Nos.1071 OF 21112 & 2ZSS4 OF
2019 AS INFRUCTUOUS, DISPOSING OF THE
W.P.Nos.26616 OF 2022,20127 OF 2t2S & 6621 OF
2O2SWITHOUT COSTS
KS
PlzP-e '
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review