The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. Furthermore, this Court is in agreement with the contention of respondent Corporation that the claim of petitioner being the one for refund of the security deposit, expenditure and damages arising out of an alleged breach of contract, the same is triable by a competent civil Court, but petitioner has not availed the said remedy. Yet another thing to be remembered is, it is trite law that jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution is supervisory in nature and is not to be exercised for adjudicating disputed questions of fact arising out of contract or for compelling a public body to contract with a person upon terms of that person’s own preference. In the light of the above, the Writ Petition, in the considered opinion of this Court, is devoid of merit and the same is liable to be dismissed.
6. The Writ Petition is accordingly, dismissed. No costs.
7. Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if any shall stand closed. -------- ----------------------------NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA, J 08th September 2026 ksld
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 21738 OF 2026
(CNR No. HBHC010448962026
Between:
Md. Rizwana Begum
….. Petitioner
And
Telangana State Road Transport Corporation,
Rep. by its Managing Director & another
….. Respondents
Reserved on
: 15.07.2026
Pronounced on
: 08.09.2026
Uploaded on
: 08.09.2026
O R D E R:
Petitioner claims to have been allotted stall No. J-20
at Rathifile Bus Station for running Mirchi, Snacks and fast-food
centre for five years on a monthly licensee fee of Rs.81,200/enhanceable every year.
The complaint of petitioner is that
though the 2nd respondent issued allotment letter dated
13.02.2025, he did not make the stall ready for occupation till
April 2026, hence, she did not commence her business. But,
however, the 2nd respondent
issued termination order dated
19.05.2026
and
issued
fresh
tender
notification
dated
22.06.2026 calling for tenders in respect of the subject stall.
1.1.
According to petitioner, though she paid security
deposit of Rs.7,60,676/- as directed by the 2nd respondent, even
before completion of civil works, the 2nd respondent insisted her
to enter into an Agreement with effect from 27.10.2025 and pay
licence fee from that date, for which she did not agree and
requested the 2nd respondent to commence her contract from the
date of execution of the Agreement, but unfortunately, the 2nd
respondent did not consider the said request. It is alleged, the
2nd respondent not only terminated the contract of petitioner but
also forfeited the security deposit without there being any
justification and without issuing any show cause notice, but
strangely, the Personal Officer, who is not the competent
authority, had issued the show cause notice dated 26.02.2026
calling for explanation stating that the competent authority has
ordered him to cancel the allotment of stall.
1.2.
Petitioner states that she made representation dated
23.02.2026 to the 2nd respondent stating that she is ready to
execute
the
Agreement
on
23.02.2026,
followed
by
the
representations dated 06.04.2026, 17.04.2026 and 07.05.2026,
but the 2nd respondent did not agree. In fact, previously, there
was a generator room which was allotted to petitioner which
required a lot of civil works for modification and make the room
a suitable stall ready for doing business; it took lot of time for
doing civil works; after taking possession of the stall on
27.10.2025, she had undertaken all the necessary civil works at
her cost and made the stall ready for occupation in April 2026;
therefore, the 2nd respondent is not at all justified in demanding
her to execute the Agreement from 27.10.2025 even before the
stall
is
made
ready.
Petitioner
states
that
she
made
representation on 07.05.2026 to the 2nd respondent requesting
to execute the Agreement in her favour from 20.04.2026 and in
case, he is not prepared to do so, to refund the EMD and
security deposit amount and the expenditure incurred by her,
but the 2nd respondent did not respond to the same. Hence, the
Writ Petition.
2.
The Corporation filed counter stating that the
impugned termination proceeding is an act of contractual
determination effected under Clauses 3(d) and 11 of the Tender
Notification and the forfeiture of security deposit is a express
contractual consequence stipulated under Clause 11 to which
petitioner had agreed while bidding.
It is trite law that
extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution
is not intended for adjudication of purely contractual disputes
between a State instrumentality and a private party in the
commercial field and that a party complaining of breach of
contract, wrongful termination or wrongful forfeiture is liable to
be relegated to the remedies available to it in private law; on this
ground alone, the Writ Petition is liable to be dismissed
2.1.
According to the Corporation, the Writ Petition
raises serious disputed questions of fact which are not amenable
to writ jurisdiction and petitioner has an efficacious alternative
remedy which she has not availed. It is stated, the substantive
grievance of petitioner is monetary in nature i.e. refund of
security deposit of Rs.7,60,676/-, refund of amounts she claims
to have expended upon the civil works and interest thereon;
such a claim being one founded upon an alleged breach of
contract, is triable by a competent civil court in a suit wherein
the disputed facts can be gone into and tested on evidence.
2.2.
It is further stated, petitioner cannot be permitted to
approbate
and
reprobate;
vide
her
representation
dated
07.05.2026, she declined to enter into an Agreement, demanded
refund of her security deposit together with expenditure and
interest and stated that she wish to withdraw from the tender. It
was only upon such withdrawal, her allotment came to be
terminated. Having repudiated the contract at her own instance,
petitioner cannot now approach this Court and compel the
Corporation to perform the very same contract.
2.3.
According to the Corporation, the Tender Committee
approved the bid of petitioner and issued Allotment Letter dated
13.03.2025 in respect of the subject stall for five years at an
initial monthly licence fee of Rs.81,200/- subject to annual
enhancement; she has to pay the balance security deposit of
Rs.7,35,676/- after adjustment of EMD of Rs.25,000/-, pay
stamp duty of Rs.22,450/- and execute the licence Agreement
within the period stipulated under Clause 3(d) of the Tender
Notification. The Depot Manager, Ranigunj informed petitioned
by letters dated 20.06.2025, 21.07.2025, 04.09.2025 and
09.10.2025 that
civil works at the stall stood completed;
premises was in a ready-to-occupy condition and she should
remit the security deposit and take possession of the stall. It is
stated, petitioner remitted the balance security deposit only
on 25.09.2025 i.e. more than six months after the allotment
letter, whereas as per Clause 1 of the allotment letter, she
ought to have deposited the same either within seven days
from the receipt of allotment letter or 15 days from the date
of allotment letter.
2.4.
It is further stated, additional works desired by
petitioner were permitted by letter dated 12.08.2025 at her own
cost and under the supervision of the civil engineering
authorities; petitioner took over the stall and its keys on
27.10.2025, thereafter, she neither executed the Agreement nor
paid a single rupee; as such, show cause notice for cancellation
of allotment was issued on 26.02.2026 which was received by
petitioner on 02.03.2026 and she also submitted explanation on
11.03.2026.
explanation
The Competent Authority considered the said
and
communicated
their
decision
thereon
to
petitioner on 26.03.2026 calling upon her to pay the outstanding
licence fee and to enter into the Agreement; further opportunities
were
afforded
16.04.2026
to petitioner
and
by
letter
by
telephonic
dated
message
02.05.2026
dated
whereunder
commencement of licence was fixed at 27.10.2025 being the very
date on which she had taken possession. Subsequently, vide
representation dated 07.05.2026, petitioner refused to enter into
the Agreement and demanded refund of her security deposit and
expenditure. It is only thereafter, Respondent No.2 who is the
competent authority terminated the allotment of contract on
19.05.2026 in exercise of the rights reserved under Clauses 3(d)
and 11 of the Tender Notification. The subject stall thus fallen
vacant came to be included along with the other vacant stalls of
Secunderabad Region in Tender Notification dated 02.06.2026.
3.
Heard Sri C. Ramachandra Raju, learned counsel for
petitioner as well as Sri R. Anurag, learned Standing Counsel for
the Corporation.
4.
Having perused the material on record and having
heard learned counsel on either side, as could be seen from the
counter-affidavit, admittedly, petitioner took over possession of
the stall and its keys on 27.10.2025. Even as per the
explanation of petitioner to the show cause notice dated
11.03.2026, all the civil, plumbing, electrical and structural
works were completed and the premises were completely ready
by 14.11.2025; her representations dated 23.02.2026 and
01.06.2026 also sate the very same fact, however, petitioner has
not executed the Agreement nor paid the stamp duty nor paid
any licensee fee nor commenced the business for over six
months thereinafter until the date of termination. This default,
by itself, squarely attracts Clause 11 of the Tender notification.
Further, the representation of petitioner dated 07.05.2026
makes it clear that she was unwilling to enter into the
Agreement with effect from 27.10.2025 and called upon
respondent Corporation to refund her security deposit together
with the entire expenditure incurred by her towards repairs and
civil modifications and that she wish to withdraw from the
tender. The said representation falsifies the version of petitioner
that she is always ready and willing to execute the agreement of
contract.
5.
Furthermore, this Court is in agreement with the
contention of respondent Corporation that the claim of petitioner
being the one for refund of the security deposit, expenditure and
damages arising out of an alleged breach of contract, the same is
triable by a competent civil Court, but petitioner has not availed
the said remedy. Yet another thing to be remembered is, it is
trite law that jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution is
supervisory in nature and is not to be exercised for adjudicating
disputed questions of fact arising out of contract or for
compelling a public body to contract with a person upon terms
of that person’s own preference. In the light of the above, the
Writ Petition, in the considered opinion of this Court, is devoid of
merit and the same is liable to be dismissed.
6.
The Writ Petition is accordingly, dismissed. No costs.
7.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
-------- ----------------------------NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA, J
08th September 2026
ksld
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review