Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 15572 OF 2026
(CNR No. HBHC010315902026)
Between:
M/s Vinayaka Enterprises
Rep. by its sole Proprietor Sri Ganteti Krishna
….. Petitioner
And
The Chairman & Managing Director,
TS GENCO & others
….. Respondents
Reserved on
: 06.08.2026
Pronounced on
: 08.09.2026
Uploaded on
: 08.09.2026
O R D E R:
Respondent authorities rejected the offer/bid of
Petitioner and awarded tender to Respondent No.5 pursuant to
the impugned Tender Notification issued by Respondent No.3
pertaining to the works of Mill Rejects. The same is questioned
in this Writ Petition.
2.
The case of petitioner is that, Respondent No.3, on
behalf of Respondent No.1, called for an open tender for loading
and unloading and cleaning of Mill Rejects Coal, debris and
coal on Feeder’s Floor Area and transporting the same in KPTS
VII Stage as and when required during FY-2026-27 and
dumping the same in the dumping yard, with an estimated
value at Rs.29,22,121/-. Clause No.6 of the Tender Form
required the participant Bidder/Firm to submit documentary
evidence of Similar Work Experience in execution of works, i.e.,
transportation of Mill Rejects.
2.1.
It is also stated, petitioner addressed letter dated
13-03-2026 to respondent authorities requesting review of the
Similar Work Experience eligibility condition, since in earlier
Tender Notifications also, the authorities had recalled the
condition relating to Similar Nature of Work. In an earlier
instance, a Corrigendum was issued stating that the experience
condition, which is kept under mandatory is considered as
optional. Tender was extended. According to Petitioner, despite
this earlier position, the same unreasonable condition requiring
Similar Work Experience in execution of Transportation of Mill
Rejects was again incorporated in the present tender.
2.2.
Pursuant to the Tender Notification, Petitioner is
stated to have offered bid on 08-03-2026 within the stipulated
time, along with all testimonials, required documents and
necessary fee and uploaded documents evidencing Similar
Work Experience and similar nature of works in accordance
with
the
Tender
Conditions,
with
a
Contract
Value
of
Rs.6,24,816/-, whereas the other bidders quoted amounts
higher than the Tender Value. Petitioner therefore contends
that its bid was the lowest and most reasonable.
2.3.
After
evaluation
of
bids,
on
09-03-2026,
Petitioner’s bid was rejected on the ground that it did not meet
the eligibility criterion of Similar Work Experience and awarded
tender to Respondent No.5, who quoted Rs.15,75,000/-.
Petitioner alleges that Respondents 3 and 4 rejected its bid with
a pre-determined intention to allot the tender to persons of
their choice. It is further alleged that respondent authorities
intentionally and calculatedly enhanced the Tender amount
from Rs.8,24,800/- to Rs.27,72,000/- with a mischievous
intention to accommodate persons/participants of their choice
and eliminate other competitive bidders. Respondent No.5 is
alleged to have quoted an unreasonable amount and to be not
eligible or qualified for award of the tender, but was
nevertheless declared successful by the authorities.
2.4.
Immediately, it is stated, Petitioner got issued Legal
Notice dated 06-04-2026
to respondent authorities calling
upon them to cancel the subject tender and call for a fresh
tender by following due procedure, but in vain. It is also stated,
Respondents
and
intentionally
and
maliciously
incorporated unreasonable clause in brackets under Clause
No.6 relating to Transportation of Mill Rejects, referring to
“Similar to Same”, with the intention of eliminating competitive
bidders and awarding the tender to a bidder of their choice.
2.5.
According to Petitioner, Respondents 1 and 2 were
aware of the Tender Rules and Regulations; Respondent No.2
had recently been appointed as Chief Engineer to VII Stage of
KTPS and Respondents 3 and 4 took undue advantage of the
said fact and maliciously awarded tender to a contractor of
their choice in collusion, contrary to the Tender Rules and
principles of natural justice. Petitioner’s letter dated 13-032026 addressed to Respondent No.2 requesting to review the
matter and do justice, was not considered. The subsequent
Legal Notice dated 06-04-2026 calling for cancellation of tender
and a fresh tender through a transparent and impartial
procedure, also did not result in any positive response or
action.
2.6.
Petitioner
states
that,
to
its
knowledge,
immediately after evaluation of the tender, a provisional LOI
was issued in favour of Respondent No.5, but final LOI had not
been issued as on the date of the affidavit. It further asserts
that a person dealing with the Government in contractual
matters has a legitimate interest or expectation and alleges that
respondents acted in a biased manner to obtain wrongful gain
with the other bidder, resulting in rejection of Petitioner’s bid
without sufficient reason.
3.
Respondents 1 to 4, in their counter, raise a
preliminary objection that they are not juristic persons in law
and refer to Article 300A of the Constitution. It is stated that
the impugned Tender Notification was issued by TG GENCO,
which is a State enterprise falling within the definition of
“State”
under
Article
12.
The
employees
of
the
State,
irrespective of their rank, cannot sue or be sued on behalf of
the State in their individual capacity. Respondents further
contend that the doctrine of Dominus Litis is not applicable to
writ proceedings and that a writ cannot be maintained against
incompetent persons. Since the Tender Notification was issued
by TG GENCO, they alone can answer the queries raised by
petitioner through any of its authorised employees and not vice
versa. In support of the same, respondents rely upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Chief Conservator
of Forest, Government of A.P. v. The Collector1. It is
contended, in proceedings concerning the property or acts of
the State, the State is a necessary party and has to be
2003 AIR SCW 1251
impleaded in accordance with Article 300 of the Constitution
and Section 79 of the CPC. It is stated that every post in the
Government hierarchy, from the lowest to the highest, is not
recognised as a juristic person and the State cannot be treated
as represented merely because a proceeding is instituted in the
name of an office/post or officer holding such post. In the
absence of the State in the array of parties, the proceeding is
liable to fail for non-joinder of a necessary party. Respondents
also note the exception recognised in the said judgment where
an
official
acts
as
a
statutory
authority
and
pursues
contend
that
having
proceedings in its own name.
3.1.
Respondents
further
participated in the tender process without raising any objection
to
the
tender
conditions,
petitioner
is
not
entitled
to
subsequently challenge the said conditions after failing in the
tender process. On the objection relating to participation in the
tender, it is stated, petitioner had full knowledge of the
conditions contained in the impugned Tender Notification,
nevertheless participated in the tender without raising any
objection and, only after being unsuccessful, approached this
Court alleging bias.
3.2.
Respondents specifically contend that petitioner
did not comply with the Similar Work Experience certificate
condition. The work certificate submitted by petitioner relates
to “LIFTING ASH FROM ASH POND”, whereas the impugned
tender
concerns
“LOADING
AND
UNLOADING
OF
MILL
REJECTS COAL ON 24 HOURS BASIS”, and the two works are
totally different. Respondents rely upon the judgment of the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Corporation
Court
National
Limited
v.
High
Speed
Montecarlo
Rail
Limited
(MANU/SC/0112/2022), wherein it was held that where
bidders participate in a tender process with full knowledge of
the applicable terms and conditions, they cannot subsequently
challenge those conditions after participating in the process.
Respondents rely upon the principle that if petitioner was
aggrieved by the tender conditions, it ought either not to have
participated in the tender or should have challenged the
conditions before participating.
3.3.
It is also the contention of respondents that
petitioner admittedly had no required experience, therefore,
considering the extreme technicalities involved in the work,
tender was awarded to Respondent No.5, who possessed
sufficient experience in the said work. Petitioner has not made
out any case of extreme bias, irregularity or unjust action on
the part of TG GENCO warranting interference by this Court. It
is also stated, considering the nature of work and accidents
that had occurred in the past, it was decided to impose the
condition requiring a “SIMILAR NATURE OF WORK” certificate.
Since petitioner did not furnish a certificate relating to similar
nature of work, its bid was rejected. According to respondents,
value of bid alone cannot determine award of the contract,
hence, Petitioner’s bid was rightly rejected for failure to satisfy
the eligibility criteria.
4.
Respondent No.5 puts-forward his case that he
possesses rich experience in execution of similar works and
holds valid experience certificates issued by Respondent No.3,
which were duly submitted along with his bid. He submitted
bid on 09-03-2026 along with the necessary experience
certificates as required under the tender conditions, quoting a
highly competitive amount of Rs.15,75,000/-. In contrast,
Petitioner did not possess the required experience in similar
works and failed to produce relevant certificates establishing
such experience. Consequently, Petitioner was technicallydisqualified and he was declared the successful bidder and the
tender was validly awarded to him vide LOI dated 31-03-2026
and
thereafer,
respondent
authorities
issued
PO
dated
21-05-2026, directing commencement of work and accordingly,
he had commenced the work on 03-04-2026 and work has
since been progressing continuously, with weighment bills
being raised regularly.
4.1.
It is also stated that Respondents 1 and 2 adopted
a uniform policy decision to make specific work experience
strictly mandatory across all their thermal units in the interest
of operational safety. In support of the same, Respondent No.5
refers to Yadadri Thermal Power Station (YTPS), where prior
experience was made an absolute pre-requisite under
NIT/Tender Notice No. e-17/SE/E&M/Stage-II/YTPS/2026-27
for Loading, transportation TGGENCO-YTPS(5X800 MW)- BE-IV
unloading and cleaning of mill rejects coal, debris and coal
from feeder's flow area, mill pits, mill surrounding area at zero
meter and dumpi ng at designated area, under whi ch
Respondent No.5 was awarded the work. It is therefore,
contended that a similar uniform standard was applied to the
KTPS units. Hence, Petitioner’s allegation that experience
condition was arbitrarily or selectively imposed only for the
subject work is denied as baseless and untenable.
4.2.
It is further stated, Petitioner did not challenge the
conditions contained in the tender notification either before or
during submission of bid. Having participated fully in the
tender process and accepted the terms and conditions, they
cannot
subsequently
challenge
the
same
conditions
as
arbitrary merely because they did not emerge as the successful
bidder. Respondent No.5 therefore, contends that Petitioner is
legally-estopped from challenging the tender conditions and
Writ Petition is frivolous, vexatious and devoid of merits.
5.
Petitioner filed reply stating that being a prudent
contractor and participant in the tender, they had raised
objections regarding the procedure and modus operandi
adopted by Respondent Authorities, as Respondent Authorities
failed to address their grievances, the contention that Petitioner
participated without objection and approached the Court only
after failing in the tender is denied as false, untrue, incorrect
and a distortion of facts. It is contended, non-joinder of a party
is a curable defect and is not fatal. As Dominus Litis, they claim
the right to choose the persons against whom they seek relief in
the writ petition and contends that they cannot be compelled to
implead a party against whom they have no grievance. The
objection of Respondents on this ground is therefore, denied as
legally-unsustainable.
5.1.
Petitioner states that the scope of work concerning
Coal Handling Plant knowledge is limited to lifting, cleaning,
transporting and dumping mill rejects in the designated yard
and does not require the extensive Coal Handling Plant
knowledge alleged by Respondents. Similarly, environmental
compliance and disposal requirements, according to them, are
limited to lifting, cleaning, transporting and dumping the
material in the designated yard.
6.
Heard Sri Srihari Parasharan, learned counsel
representing Sri P.V.V. Gopala Krishna Murthy, learned
counsel for petitioner and Sri Mohammad Adnan, learned
Standing Counsel for TS GENCO and Sri Srinivas Velagapudi,
learned counsel for Respondent No.5.
7.
The preliminary objection raised by Respondents 1
to 4 is that relief was sought against non-juristic persons. As
rightly contended by learned Standing Counsel, Respondents 1
to 4 are not juristic persons but are only officials of TG GENCO
and in the absence of the said company being arrayed as a
party respondent to Writ Petition, no relief can be granted. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Chief Conservator of Forest,
Government of A.P. v. The Collector held as under:
“
The question that needs to be addressed is whether the Chief
Conservator of Forest as the petitioner/appellant in the writ petition/appeal 'is a
mere misdescription for the State of Andhra Pradesh or whether it is a case of
non-joinder of the State of Andhra a necessary party. In a lis dealing with the
property of a State, there can be no dispute that the State is the necessary party
and should be impleaded as provided in Article 300 of the Constitution and
Section 79 of C.P.C., viz., in the name of the State/Union of India, as the case
may be, lest the suit will be bad for non-joinder of the necessary party. Every
post in the hierarchy of the posts in the Government set-up, from the lowest to
the highest, is not recognised as represented when a a juristic person nor can
the State be treated as suit/proceeding is in the name of such offices/posts or
the officers holding such posts, therefore, in the absence of the State in the
array of parties, the cause will be defeated for non-joinder of a necessary party
to the lis, in any court or Tribunal. We make it clear that this a principle does
not apply to a case where an official of the Government acts as a statutory
authority and sues or pursues further proceeding in its name because in that
event, it will not be a suit or proceeding for or on behalf of a State/Union of
India but by the statutory authority as such"
8.
In view of the law laid down on this aspect, it is to
be held that Respondents 1 to 4 are non-juristic persons and
writ Court cannot exercise powers against incompetent
persons more particularly when tender notification is issued
by the TG GENCO, then TG GENCO alone can answer all the
queries raised by petitioner and Section 79 CPC makes it
abundantly clear.
9.
The next objection raised by Respondents is that
having participated in the tender process without any
objection to any conditions, petitioner is not entitled to
challenge the conditions later. Here, it is to be noted the said
issued fell for consideration before the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in National High Speed Rail Corporation Limited v.
Montecarlo Limited (supra), wherein it has been held as
under:
"
14. Now so far as the view taken by the High Court in the
impugned judgment and order that Clause 28 under Clause (e) of Option A
Section 1 and Clause 42.5 of ITB are patently illegal, inasmuch as they seek to
curtail the right of the bidders to challenge the rejection of their bid in a multistage bidding process at the earliest, and before the award of the contract is
concerned, at the outset, it is required to be noted that as such the aforesaid
clauses of the ITB were not under challenge before the High Court. Even
otherwise, it is required to be noted that Clauses 28.1 and 42.5 of ITB were well
within the knowledge of the original writ petitioner at the time of participating in
the tender process. The aforesaid clauses of the ITB were put to the knowledge
of all the participants/bidders and the same applied to all. Despite the above
clauses in the ITB, original writ petitioner participated in the tender process.
Therefore, once having accepted the terms and conditions of the tender process
with the full knowledge of Clauses 28.1 and 42.5, and participated with full
knowledge, thereafter, it was not open for the original writ petitioner to make a
grievance with respect to such clauses.
14.5.
Under the circumstances, the High Court has committed a grave
error in holding that Clauses 28.1 and 42.5 are patently illegal, more
particularly, in absence of any challenge to the same and also on having
knowledge of the aforesaid clauses in the ITB, thereafter it was not open for the
original writ petitioner to challenge the same. The original writ petitioner was
knowing right from the very beginning with respect to the confidentiality clause
contained in Clause 28 and that grounds on which the Bids of unsuccessful
Bidders are not selected shall be communicated only after a final decision to
award the contract is communicated under Clause 42. If the original writ
petitioner was aggrieved either it would not have participated and/or ought to
have challenged such clauses before participating in the tender process. Under
the circumstances, the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court
holding Clauses 28.1 and 42.5 as patently illegal cannot sustain and the same
also deserves to be quashed and set aside".
10.
The principle stated in the aforesaid judgment is
relevant to the extent that a bidder who participates in a
tender process cannot ordinarily seek to invalidate the tender
conditions merely because the result is adverse to him.
In the light of the above, this Court, without going into
the merits of the matter, decides that petitioner is not entitled
to the relief sought.
11.
Further, it is also to be noted, the scope of judicial
review in contractual and tender matters is limited. The Court
is concerned with the legality and fairness of the decisionmaking process and does not ordinarily undertake a fresh
technical evaluation of the bids. In the present case,
respondents
have
identified
the
specific
deficiency
in
Petitioner’s bid and explained why the experience documents
produced by them were not treated as satisfying the Similar
Work Experience requirement. Unless the decision is shown to
be arbitrary, discriminatory, mala fide, irrational or contrary
to the tender conditions, the Court would not substitute its
own assessment merely because a different view may also be
possible. Petitioner has not demonstrated that respondents
departed from Clause No.6, applied a different condition to
him, granted Respondent No.5 an exemption from the
prescribed requirement, or altered the eligibility condition
after receipt of the bids. The allegation of bias or mala fides
therefore, remains unsupported by sufficient material.
12.
Accordingly, challenge to rejection of Petitioner’s
bid and consequential award of tender to Respondent No.5
cannot be accepted. No case is made out for issuance of a Writ
of Mandamus directing cancellation of tender or for directing
respondents to conduct a fresh tender.
13.
The Writ Petition is, therefore, dismissed. No
costs.
14.
Consequently, the miscellaneous
Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
-------- ----------------------------NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA, J
08th September 2026
ksld
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review