Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3301 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NOs: 11'145 OF 2021.14057.25088 & 250 90 of 2024
W.P.No.1't145 OF 2021
Between:
M/s. Suncore Power Projects Private Limited, Represented by Datla Srinivasa
Raju Having its registered office at Room No. 203. H. No. 8-3-224141N11 and
12. Madhura Nagar. Yusufguda. Hyderabad.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Revenue Department. Represented by its Principal
Secretary. Secretariat Building. Hyderabad. Telangana.
2. The District Collector, Hyderabad District. Hyderabad. Telangana.
3. Mandal Revenue Officer, Khairtabad Mandal. 6-3-6281911. Anand Nagar
Colony. Khairtabad-500004.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 ot the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to issue a writ order or direction. more particularly a writ in the nature of mandamus
to declare the action of the Respondent authorities in interfering with the possession
of the schedule Property belonging to petitioner company as illegal, arbitrary,
unconstitutional and consequenfly restrain the Respondent authorities from
interfering with the possession of the rand admeasuring 14gs.72
square yards
forming part of sy No 116/4, prot No 11, bearing door no g-2-24BrN1, g-2-24grN1rp,
Khairtabad village and Mandar, Hyderabad Diskict beronging to the petitioner
Company except in accordance with law.
I.A. NO: 1OF 2021
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petltion, the High Court may be pleased to restrain the
Respondent authorities from interfering with the possession Schedule Property
including construction on the land admeasuring 1495.72 square yards forming part of
Sy No 1'16/4. Plot No 11, bearing door no 8-2-2481N1,8-2-2481N11P, Khairtabad
village and Mandal, Hyderabad District belonging to Petitioner Company.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2021
Between:
1. The State of Telangana, Revenue Department. Represented by its Principal
Secretary. Secretariat Building. Hyderabad. Telangana.
2. The District Collector, Hyderabad District. Hyderabad. Telangana.
3. Mandal Revenue Officer, Khairtabad Mandal. 6-3-6281911. Anand Nagar
Colony. Khairtabad-500004.
... PETITIONER/RESPONDENTS
AND
M/s. Suncore Power Projects Private Limited, Represented by Datla Srinivasa Raju
Having its registered office at Room No. 203. H. No. 8-3-224141N11 and 12.
Madhura Nagar. Yusufguda. Hyderabad.
... RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
afficlavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to vacate the
interim order daled.27.o4.2O21 in lA.No.1/2021 in WP.No.1114512021 and dismiss
the writ petition.
counser for the Petition"'
' :.Xl,irli+3ior=o.#,,Tr,.,
counser
counserf ortheResponr""Er:TIg'H0;|"r^TJa:t-tdSL
WP NO:1
7 0F 2024
Between:
M/s Suncore Power Projects Private Limited, Represented by Chilukuri Kirthi S/o
Rajender, aged about 40 years Room No 203, H. No 8 - 3 - 22414tN1,t and 12,
Madhura Nagar, Yusoufguda, Hyderabad
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Revenue Department, Represented by its Principal
Secretary, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad, Telangana
2. The District Collector, Hyderabad District, Hyderabad, Telangana
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad
4. The Tahsildar, Khairtabad Tahsil, Hyderabad
5. The Sub - Registrar, Erragadda, Hyderabad
6. The Sub - Regiskar, Punjagutta, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arlicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus, (a) Declaring the action of the Respondent No. 4 in issuing the Letter
bearing LR. No. C135212006 dated 20. 04.2024 issued by the Respondent No. 4 to
the Respondent 5, wherein, the Respondent No.4 had directed the Respondent No.
5 not to register the property belonging to the Petitioner hereln, admeasuring 1495
Sq. Yards in Plot No. 11 of Sy. No. 116/ A situated at Khairatabad Village, Journalist
Colony, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, for being without jurisdiction, illegal, arbitrary,
unconstitutional and consequently, set aside the Letter bearing LR. No. C135212006
dated 20. 04.2024 issued by the Respondent No. 4 to the Respondent No. 5 and (b)
set aside all the consequent actions taken by the Respondents pursuant to issuance
of the Letter bearing LR. No. cl3s2tz006 dated 20. 04.2024 by the Respondent No.
4 to the Respondent 5 incruding the act of incruding the property belonging to the
Petitioner herein, admeasuring 1495 Sq. yards in plot No. .t 1 of Sy. No. 116/ A
situated at Khairatabad Village, Journalist colony, Baryara Hills, Hyderabad, in the
list of prohibited lands under Section 22 - A ot the Regishation Act, 19og and (c)
Pass such other order(s) that this Honble Court may deem fit and proper in the
interest of justice.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under section 15'1 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to suspend
the operation of the Letter bearing LR. No. c/3s2l2006 dated 20. 04.2024 issued by
the Respondent No.4 to the Respondent 5 and all consequential actions taken by
Respondents pursuant to issuance of the Letter bearing LR. No. c/352/2006 dated
.20.04.2024 by the Respondent No. 4 to the Respondent 5 including the act of
including the property belonging to the petitioner herein, admeasuring 14g5 sq.
Yards in Plot No. 1'1 of Sy. No. 'l 16/ A situated at Khairatabad Village, Journalist
oolony, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, in the list of prohibited lands under section 22 - A
of the Registration Act, 1 908 pending disposal of the Writ petition.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2024
Between:
1. The State of Telangana, Revenue Department, Represented by its principal
Secretary, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad, Telangana
2. The District Collector, Hyderabad District, Hyderabad, Telangana
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad
4. The Tahsildar, Khairtabad Tahsil, Hyderabad
5. The Sub - Registrar, Erragadda, Hyderabad
6. The Sub - Registrar, Punjagutta, Hyderabad
... PETITIONERYRESPONDENTS
AND
M/s Suncore Power Projects Private Limited, Represented by Chilukuri Kirthi S/o
Rajender, aged about 40 years Room No 203, H. No 8 - 3 - 224141N11 and 12,
Madhura Nagar, Yusoufguda, Hyderabad
... RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER
F'etition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim orders dt.06.06.2024 in W.P.No.'14057 ol 2024 and dismiss the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI AVINASH DESAI, Senior Counsel
rep., SRI T.P.S.HARSHA
GounserrortheRespont""E;lThtH0s'^TJa:r-:-T.
P NO: 5088
F 2024
Between:
M/s suncore Power Projects private Limited, Room No 203, H. No B -
3 - 22414tN11
yusoufguda, Hyderabad Represented Uy
12,
Nagar,
nritoiii"O
lladhura
Signatory Chilukuri Kirthi S/ o. K. Rajender, aged about 40 years,
...PET|T|oNER
AND
. The state of relangana,. Revenue Department, Represented by its principar
Secretary, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad, Telangana
2. The District Collector, Hyderabad, Telangana.
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad
4. The Tahsildar, Khairtabad Tahsil, Hyderabad
5. The District Registrar, S.R Nagar, Hyderabad
,..RESPONDENTS
Petition under Anide 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to issue a writ, order or direction more pa'ticurarry one in the nature of writ of
Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondent No. 2 in lssuing the Letter
bearing
Lr. No. E1l15591 2024 dated 24.07.2024, to the Respondent 5 to be in violation
of
the orders of this Hon'bre High court, without jurisdiction, iilegar, arbitrary,
unconstitutional and consequenfly, set aside the Letter bearing LR. No.
Elllssgl
2024 dated 24.07 .2024, issued by the Respondent No. 2 to the Respondent
5 and all
the actions taken by the Respondents pursuant to issuance of
the Letter bearing LR.
No E'rl1559/2024 dated 24.07.2024, incruding but not rimited to pracing
Petitioner's property into the prohibited list.
the
I.A. N o :'l o F 2024
Petition under section 1 51 cpc praying that
affidavit fired in support of the petition, the High
in the circumstances stated in the
court may be preased to suspend
the operation of the Letter bearing Lr. No. E1l1559/2024 dated 24.02.2024, issued
by the Respondent No. 2 to the Respondent 5.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2024
Petition under section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to restrain the
Respondents from taking any coercive action/steps against the petitioner company.
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2024
Between:
l The State of relangana, Revenue Department, Represented by its principar
Secretary, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad, Telangana
2. The District Collector, Hyderabad, Telangana.
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad
4. The Tahsildar, Khairtabad Tahsil, Hyderabad
5. The District Registrar, S.R Nagar, Hyderabad
AND
... PETTTIONER/RESPONDENTS
M/s suncore Power Projects private Limited, Room No 203, H. No g - 3 - 224141N11
and 12, Madhura Nagar, Yusoufguda, Hyderabad Represented by Authorized
Signatory Chilukuri Kirthi S/ o. K. Rajender, aged about 40 years,
... RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER
Petition under section 151 cPc praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim orders dt 11.09.2024 passed in lA.No. '1 ol 2024 in WP.No.25088 ot 2024
and dismiss the writ petition.
counser ror the Petition"'
' :"Ti,i'#+;i?=ot#'rT''"
counser
counserf ortheRespont"":;:Tl='xJ0#'^TJe:t":ff
.
WP NO: 25 90 0F 2024
Between:
M/s Suncore Power Projects private Limited, Room No 203,
H. No g yusoufguda, Hyderabad Represented 3 - 22414rN11
l.Z,
Nagar,
UV nrinoii""a
1yA
!|3!hura
Signatory Chilukuri Kirthi S/o. K. Rajender, aged about 40 years,
,..PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Revenue Department, Represented by its principal
Secretary, Sbcretariat Building, Hyderabad, Telangana
2. The District Collector, Hyderabad, Telangana.
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad
4. The Tahsitdar, Khairtabad Tahsil, Hyderabad.
5. The Commissioner, GHMC, Tank Bund, Hyderabad
,..RESPONDENTS
Petition under Articre 226 of rhe constitution of rndia praying that
circumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High
in the
court may be preased
to issue a writ, order or direction more particurarry one in the nature of writ of
Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondent No. 2 in issuing
the Letter bearing
Lr. No. E1l1559r 2024 dated 24.07.2024, issued by the Respondent No.2
Respondent 5, wherein, the Respondent No. 2 had directed the Respondent
to the
No. 5 to
direct the concerned to cancer the Buirding permission aflotted vide
1lcl17l1140gr 2020 daled 04.11.2020, to ailegedry protect the interest
government, to be in violation of the orders of this Honorable
jurisdiction, illegar, arbitrary, unconstitutionar
No.
of the
High court, without
and consequenfly, set aside the Letter
bearing LR. No. E1r1ss9t2o24 dared 24.07.2024, issued
by the Respondent No. 2 to
the Respondent 5, and aU consequent actions taken by
the Respondents pursuant to
issuance of the Letter bearing LR. No. E'u1ssgt2o24
dated 24.02.2024, issued by
the Respondent No. 2 to the Respondent 5.
LA. NO: 1 O F 2024
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the
circumstances stated in the
affidavit fired in support of the petition, the High court
may be preased to suspend
the operation of the Letter bearing Lr. No. E1ll559/2024 dated 24.07.2024, issued
by the Respondent No 2 to the Respondenl5, 04.11.2020.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to restrain the
Respondents from taking any coercive action/steps against the Petitioner Company.
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2024
Between:
. The State of Telangana, Revenue Department, Represented by its Principal
Secretary, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad, Telangana
2 The District Collector, Hyderabad, Telangana.
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad
4. The Tahsildar, Khairtabad Tahsil, Hyderabad.
5. The Commissioner, GHMC, Tank Bund, Hyderabad
... PETITIONER/RESPONDENTS
AND
lt4/s Suncore Power Projects Private Limited, Room No 203, H. No I - 3 - 224141N11
and 12, Madhura Nagar, Yusoufguda, Hyderabad Represented by Authorised
Signatory Chilukuri Kirthi S/o. K. Rajender, aged about 40 years,
... RESPONDENTS/PETITIONER
Petition under Section 1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim orders dt. 11.09.2024 passed in WP.No.25090 ol 2024 and dismiss the writ
petition.
Gounsel for the Petition"' ,
:"Tiir#ffiior=oft,rT"'".
co u nser for th e Res po n dents N o. 1 tos
:,
counsel
?[[. ?'JJ33^1=I3 ;i,?hf
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PET IT ION Nos. 11145 of2O21 14057
25O88 and 25 O9O of 2024
Dated lOtt July,2026.
Between:
M/s. Suncorc Pou,cr projccts l)rivate Limited
Pctitioner
AND
The State of Telangana,
Revenur: Department,
Rcprescntcd bl its Irrincipal Scr rt,ta11..
Secrerariat I3uilding, Hyderabad,
'lelangana ald others.
Respondcnts
COMMO N ORDER:
Sincc thc 1ls raiscd in all rhosc. q,riL pctit jons ls utter
u,ith each oLhcr, rhcy zrrc Li,{kcn up Logethcr, hcard
se relatcd
ancl being drsposcd
of by this common order.
2)
Writ Pctjtion No.I 1 14,5 ot 2O2j is tilcd qucstioning rhc
Ihc respondcnL au thorities in in Lcrforing \4,irh
action ol
thc posscssion of the
petitioncr Company rn respect of thr:
land admeasuring l4gi.72
square yards forming part of survcl,
l)oor No.8 2 248/A/ t, I 2_2+8/Al t
No. I I6/4,
Plot No. l1 beanng
/t) at Khalra ra bad Village and
-
PK. .I
I,|:1'. vo ] 1 1 .1
r af )A) I &. bat(h
Mandal. Ilr-clr:rabad l)istrict (in shori subjcct property ) and
consequentl\. io dLrect thc respondents n()t to interfere with the
lrossr:ssion rrt thc pcli ionr:r' ir-r rcspcct. ol thc sultject propcrtv
3)
\'rit Pctirion No. 1.1057 ol 2024 rs Iilcrl sceking to declare thc
lettcr bearing l-r.No.C i 352/2006 datcd 20.O1 .2024 addressed by rhe
Tahsildar. Kh:rirathabad. to thc Sub-Registrar, Erragadda, not to
regls[er lhe sut)-rc.t l)ropcrt\,. as illetgal and arl-,itrary
4)
WnL l)ctirion No.25088 ol 2a24 is fiicd seeking to declare the
lcttcr bearilrg. 1-r,No.ll I 1,559 12024 daLed 24.O7.2024 addressed by
thc [)rstrrr:l (]olLcctor to thc [)islnct llcgistrar. S,]1. Nagar, not to
enterLain anr salcs-/tr:rns:lctiolts in rcspccL ol thr: sutrjcct propcrt\', t1s
illega) and arbitrar,,, .
5)
Wrrt Pctition No.25090 of 2024 is filed questioning the letter
bearing No.F,l/ l:tl'9 12024 dated 24.o7.2o2.1 addresscd b1' the
Disrrict Collectr.ir. to rhe Cornmissioncr, (iflNlC, to cancel thc building
permisslon qr:rntcrl in respecI ofthe subject pro]rerty.
6)F-acLsleacltngLOf.i]rncolthcpr(SCnIrttitpctltirlnsasr'r,cllatslht.
case of lhe l)etitir)nt'r. in a llrrtshell, ;lrc Lh.rt ongLnalll' the land to an
cxtent of Acs.,: 3r guntas ln surve,v No.1 16/ 1 of Khairatabad Village
was purchasecl in public.Iuction bv one late Sri Ping'lli Venkat Ram
/
I'K, J
& batch
W.t).No.1I14r of )0)]
in I353 Fasli
RecldY ior a sum of Rs 30'000/-
turn, said Venkat Ram Reddy had sold
i.e' in the Year 1943 In
the said land to one K Gopal
Sale Deed bearing document
Rao and others through registered
of 1356 Fasli ie in the year 1946
No.216
and others have obtained permission
of Hyderabad vide File No 139/
Thereafter, K.GoPal Rao
from the Municipal Corporation
1'4Ol2F dated 15 07 1963 and
divided
and sold thc same to sevcral
the property into number ol plots
survey No l16/1 was re
in
land
said
above
lhe
and
persons
said land'
numbered as 116/4 Out o[ the
one Pan Rai Pannalal Pitti
MemorialCharitable.I.IuSthadpurchasedtheland,inwhichthc
subject property fa1ls, from K Gopal
sa-1e deed No.2O41/ 1963
Rao and others vide registered
dated 09 03'1963 Thereafter'
executed a sale deed vide document No
the said Trust
1694/ 1994 dated 20'06'1994
in favour of Gayathri Devi Badruka and three
olhers in respcct of the
8-2property bearing municipal Nos 8-2-248lA ll' 8-2'248lAll lP'
248lAlllPlt and 8-2-248lAlIlPl2 in plot No 11 in survev
No.I 16/4 situated at Khairatabad Villagc, Journalist Colony'
Banjara
Hills, Flyderabad, consisting ol building and land appurtenant thereto
admeasuring 747.a6 Sq. Yards and also document No'1695/ 1994 in
respect of property bearing municipal Nos.8-2-248 /A/ I , 8-2-
248lAl1lP,8-2-248lAl1lPlt andS'2'248lAl llPl2 in plot No,1 1 in
\--
W.
survcr. No. 1 I 6/4
BanJara LIirs,
sit uated at Khairatabad
appurtenant thereto
admeasuring 14gs.72
Badruka and others
Sq. yards. rhereafte'
Deeds dated 72.O8.2O10
mortgaged the
rights in respect
Compan,y India
Limttcd had turther
Cal,athri Devi Badruka
others have failed to repay
No.351/IV/ 17, In view
and others have to clear
Devi Badruka and
the loan amounts, they
were declared as
in accordancc with the provisions
Sccuntization and Rr:construction
Enforcement of Securitv Intcrcst
or
of Financial Assets and
AcL, 2OO2 (in short ,SARFAESI
Further, on an applicarion being
Cr1.M.P. No.5567
through an Assignment
to ARCIL. As Gayathri
lvon-Profitable Asset (NI']A)
assignc.d its
to Asset Reconstruction
11.2O17 vidc document
the loan by paying amounts
and
documenL No.317g/2010.
Ltd (in short ,ARC]I_)
of such assignment,
Deposit of Title
Auto Finance Limited
of Ihc subject property
Agrccment dared 30,
Sq yards totalry
a Memorardum of
in favour of Bajaj
Ari Lo I..inancc
land
r, said Gayathri Devi
subiect property vide
I,'urthcr, rhc IlaJai
oro*",
building and
admeasuring 747.g6
havs g)<ssu1s6
oj 20, I & ;[;./,
.ruu.r"rist colony,
!.i11
Iivderabad, consistrng
p Na. I I t 4 5
Act,).
made b,y the ARCIL in
of 20\7. rhe Chief Metropolitan Magistrate,
Nampalll-, Hyderabad, vide order dated
09.O3.201g had appointed an
Advocate Commissioner, who took possession of the subject propcrty
PK, J
W.P.No.1 1145 of 2O21 & batch
and handed over the same to ARCIL in execution of warrant and a
Sale Certificate dated 2O.O9.2O18 was also issued in favour ol the
ARCIL. Thereafter, after following due procedure, the ARCIL has
auctioned the subject property wherein the petitioner has participat.ed
and being the highest bidder, thc petitionnr has purchascd the
subject property in the auction conducted under the provisions of
SARFAESI Act from ARCIL vide document No.797O/2018 dated
16.11.2018. Since the date of purchase, the petitioner Company has
been in continuous possession of the schedule property and also
obtained building permission bearing No.1./CI7/1I4O9 l2O2O dated
04.ll.2O2O for construction of building and also started conslruction.
6 l) Whilc so, on I7. I 1.2020, rhc rcspondcnI zru[hurirics cermc to
the subjcct properLy and tried to inLcrfcrc with the possession of the
petitioner slating that the same belongs to Government. Immediately,
on 18.11.2O2O, petitioner made a representation to respondent No.3
clearly explaining thc flow of titlc and requesting the authorities to
refrain from taking any illegal action. However, on 31.O3.2021, again
the authorities have tried to interfere with the possession of the
petitioner. During the interrcgnum period i.c. on 21.I 1.2020, the
pctitroner Company rcccivcd a noticc lrom thc Inspcctor of l)olice,
Panjagutta, Ilyderabad, informing about registration of crime
PK, J
W.P.\o 11 145 of 2021 & batch
No.634 l2O2O date(l 17.11.2020 against the petitioner Company and
re(luesting the lfircctor ol thc pctitioner Coml;any to appear before the
Policc SLatron. Onll';,rfter rcgrstration of the said crime , the petltioner
Company' camc to knou' about pendency of W.P. Nos. 13497 and
1319 I oi 2012 filt:c] br (lara[hri l)cvi I]adruka and others s'herein
intcrim ortlcrs of stllLus cluo \\'crc passed by this llonblc Court'
Hencc, thc pctltroner has approached this Court and filed
W.P.No. 1L145 of
2021 sceking a direction to the respondent
authorities not to interfcre u'ith the possession of the petitioner in
rcspcct of thc schcclult: property wherein lhis Court has passed
interim ordcr clatcd 27 .O1.2O21 restraining the respondent authorities
from interfcring r,,,ith the posscssion ol the pctitioni:r in rcspect of the
5u llj r'c I I)r()pcrl\.
6.2\ lt is the lurther case of the pe titioner that during the pendency
of sard r,"'rit pelition i.e . W.P. No.11145 of 2027 and the interim orders
passed bl
this Court in the said writ pctition, the 'l'ahsildar,
Khairatabad Tahsil, had
addressed a
Lr.No.C/352/2006 dated 20.O4.2021 to the
letter
bearing
Sub-l?egtstrar,
Erragadda. rcqucsting not lo rcgister the subject propcrty
Challcngrnr. rht' :;iLid lcttcr. pe ti[roncr hacl filcd W [) No 14057 ol 2024
PK, J
W.P.No I 1145 of 202j & batch
wherein this Hon'ble Court vide ordcr dated 06.06.2024 has grantcd
lnterim suspension of t-he lerter daLcd 20.O4.2024
6.3) While so, based on the reporr submitted by the Revenue
Divisional Officer & Tahsildar, Khairatabad, the District Collcctor,
Hyderabad, had addressed a letter bearing Lr.No.El/ lSSg/2024
daLed 24.07.2024 to the District Registrar, S.R. Nagar, Hyderabad,
requesting not to entertain any sales/ transaction in the subject
property. Questroning rhc samc, rhc. pctitioncr lilcd W.lr. No.2S0gti of
2024 wherern this Court vidc order datecl I l.Og.2024 has granted
interim suspension of the letter daled 24.O7 .2024.
6.4) Similarly, the Districr Collcclor, Hyderabad, had addrcsscd the
letrer vide Lr.No.tr1l1559/2024 dared 24.OT.2024 to
the
Commissioner, GHMC, Hyderabad, to cancel the building permission
granted to the petitioner in respect of the subject property.
Challenging the same, thc peri[ioncr had l-r]ed W.p. No.25O9 O ot 2024
wherein this Hon'ble Court vidc order dated ll.Og.2024 has granted
interim suspension of the letter daLed 24 .O7 .2024.
7l
IIeard Sri Avinash [)csaj. ]carncd senior counscl, representing
Sri T.P.S. Harsha, learned counsel for the petitioner, and Smt. Divya
PK, J
V'l).iro 1 I l4:t ol 20)1 & bcLtch
Adcpu, learncd Spccial (lovernmcnt Plcader, representing the learned
Advocate General. for the respondents.
8)
Learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner, while
drarving the attention of this Courl to severaL sale deeds, to explain
the title flow to the pclitioncr in rcspect o[ the subject property, has
conLended thal thc I)clitioncr hard purchased the schedule propcrtf in
the public :ru( tion coniluctcd b] AItCIL under thc provisions of
SAIRITAESL\ct and at the time ol purchase, tl-re subject property was
not included in thc list of prohibited proporties. Learned scnior
counscl has contendecl rhat the status quo orders wcre passcd by this
Court aftcr tht: iand was mortgaged by Ga1'athri Devi Badruka &
others to Bajaj Auto Finance. Therefore, the status quo orders are
not appJicablc Lo thc pre cxisting rights accruecl by' tlaj aj Auto
Iiinanr:c lrv ua-r ol rrorLgrlgc. uhich sr-Lbscqucntly resultcd tn public
auctlon shelcin thc pctitioncr has purchased thc subject propcrty. It
is settled princrple of lau, that under Order XXXVIll Rule 10 o[ the
Code of Civil Proccdure, anv attachment shall not affect the rights
existing pricir lo the a Ltachment. Therefore, the status quo orders
passed b1. this Court cannot affect the pre-existing rights accrued
throu gh mortgal<e to the Baj aj Auto Finance and later to the ARCIL,
u,hich arc tl)c prr)dccrcssor in-tit1c to thc peti[ioner, Further, thc
PK, J
W l,.Na. 1 11.1J oJ 2A)t & batctt
status orders do not come in the way of petitioner,s right to enjoy thc
subject property and the respondent authorities without any basis or
ma[erial to support thcir rit]c to thc subject property have issued the
impugned notices, which is illegal and arbitrary. Further, it is settled
law that the State cannot declare themselves to be the owners of the
property in a summ:iry m:tnncr and cannol rcsorl to summary
proccr:dings undcr Lhc Ltrnd l.lnr:roachment Act without proving their
title over the subject properly bcforc appropriatc l..orum. Whcn thc
petitioner Company has clcarly established the title flow to it from the
year 1356 Fasli i.c. 1946. the respondent authoritics cannot
unilatcrally dcclare thc property to be the property of the State and
try to dispossess the petitioner from the subject property. Further,
while placing rcliance on rhe order datod t1.10.2006 passed by this
Cour[ in W.l). No.2lOl3 ol 2016. rhc lcarned Senior counsel has
con[cnded that thc r(]spondent authorities cernnot claim fhc subjcct
property to be Government land merely relying on the'I.SLR entries.
I,-urthcr, thc pctiLioncr rs irr continous possession ol the subject
propcrty and obtatncd al) ncc:r:ssary pr:rmissions lrom the competent
authorities for development of the subject property. That apart, thc
ARCIL i.e. the vendor of the pel.itioner was put in possession of the
subjccr propcrty on 20.OC).2O 18 by thc n dvocal.e Commissioner by
PK,.I
\4t P No.1 1 11t. of )02 1
& btltch
virtuc ol ('xc('u1ion o1 \\ arranl issLted br tltc (lhici NletrcipoLttan
Magistratc. \amnir1lr. Ilrdcrarbad. in Crl.M.P.No.5567 of 2017 dated
09.0,1..2018. lfrr ri'fcrc. lhr: rcspondcnt artLhr,ril.ics cannot in[erfcre
\\,llh tho poss('sslon ol thc pctrtioner clarming thc plopcrtv to bc thc
GovernmenI propcrt-\ \\ irhout proVing iLs titlc bt:lore the Civil Court.
13.1) l,carnccl scnior colrnscl has lurthcr srLbrnitted that ignoring and
rlisobel ing rhc intcrim ordi'r datcd ),7.O4.2021 passcd by lhis Corrrt
in W.P. No. 1 1 1,1.r ot 20-l 1. thc 'l'ahsildar. Khair :ilaba(1, has adctrcsscd
the Icrtcr d.ttc(l 20.()1 .2O2+ lo thc S rrb - llegistrar. Drragadda,
ir-rforrnit:s ,rot to ralisl{:. ilrr: subjccl propcrl\. \\'itho,it anv auLhorlt-\
of lar.r . As pcr S('.Lron .12 ,\ lll (b) ol thc l(r'gistration Act, 1908, onlr
the Distrir:t Clollecto: is thc compctcnt au tl-rorit.\- to issue such
direclrons. F urther, u'hcn thc strong prima facie casc and balilnce of
convenicncc llcs rn favour ol thc petitioner, issuance of thc lctter
dated 20.0.+.2021 is in cicar violation o{ Iau and contrary to thc
.ludgmcnt ol r he [ul] l]cnch ol Lhis Court irt Vinjamuri Rajagopala
Chary u, Principal Secretary, Relenze Department, Hgderabadl.
8.2) I.-urther'. tlrc lcarnerl st'nior coLtt-tscl has cot.ttctrrlcd tirat thc
t)istricl (lo1lc'cLor-, I lr cler':rbad, had addressed thc lctter vidr:
2015 SC(l OLrl-rLrr I1!(i 40','
PK, J
W.P.No.1 1 l4 5 of 202 ) & batch
Lr. No. E i / 1559 I 2024 dated 24 .O7 .2024 Lo
the District Registrar,
t{yderabad, stating that the land in survey No.116/1 is classihed as
'Government land' and that thc pctil.ioner hcrcin had obtaincd
building permission from the GFIMC authorities without obtaining
any consent from the revenue authorities as the land in question is a
government land. Lcarncd scnior counscl has vehemently contcndcd
that on one hand the District Collector is stating that the land in
survey No. 116/ 1 is a Government Land and on the other the District
Collector has requested the District Registrar not to entertain any
sale s/ transac tion
s in respect of thc property belonging to the
petitioner herein, which is in lact situated in survcy No.116/4 or
166/4, which is admittedly not a government land, and not in survev
No. l16/1.
Learned scnior counsel has lurther contendcd that thc
l.'ull Llench of this Court in Vlnjamuri RaJagopalo Chary, s case
(reJen'ed. sltptd) has framed the guidelines to be followed for
classifying any land / immovable property as government land
.
However, without lollowing the said guidelincs, the District Collcctor
has unilaterally issued the letter dated 24.O7.2024, which is nothing
but abuse of process of law. Further, the District Cotlector has no
power whatsoevcr to drrect rhc I)istrict Rcgistr::r not ro cntcrLain any
salcs/transactions in tcspcct o[ thc subjcct property morc so whcn
t2
PK, J
W.P. \o 11145 of 2021 & batch
thc subject property rs existing in survey No.116/4 or 116/A and not
in su rver,' No.1 I61 l
8.3) Learncd senior counsel has lurther contcnded that the l)istrict
Collector rs noL vr:sLcd rvith ernt pou.cr to address thc lcILcr
No.i'-1/l-5()'202'l d;rtcrl 2,1.07.202,1 to thc Commissioncr, (itlMC, to
cani:r:l thc building permission granted to the petitioner and the
petil-ioner is noi issued s'ith an,v prior notice. I.lence, the action of the
District Collector is in clear violation of principlcs of natural justicc.
Thereforc, t.he learned scnior counsel pral'ed thrs Court to allow the
writ petitions, as praycd for. Reliance has been placed on:
a)
lnterinr ordcr ditLcd 06.1 1.2025 passed in \.\.1). No.l I145 oi 12021;
bl
State of A.P. v. Prameela Modiz.
c)
Gouernment of Andhra Prad.esh u. Thummala Xrishna Raoa;
d)
The Special Dg. Collector u, Kond.a La.kshman Bapujia,
e)
Hgderabo.d. Potteries Priuate Limited u. Collector, Hgderabads;
\
g)
The State of Telangana u. Blue Wings Deuelopers6;
Durga Enterprises (P) Ltd.. u. Principal Secretary, Govt. oJ U.P.7;
h)
Dr Bal Krishna Agarwal u. State o.f U.P.8(service matter-verifyl
rl2(10(,r i.l SCC '1,
r(1982r : SCC I .la
rM A N r-
/ .1P/ al l4.t / I
()8..,
12001 t.l l-AI) a)(r0
r,MANL. /'l'Ll00 I'/' /:2023
(2004 l3 SCC tr5:l
----==
PK, J
W.P.No.1l145 o[ 2O2I & betch
9)
Per contra, the lcarncd Spccial Government plcader has
contended that the subjecr property claimed by the petitioner falls in
'1.S. No.75, Block-J, Ward-89. correlating ro Survey No.116/
I of
Khairatabad Village and the same is classified as Government land.
As per Town Survey records, the land in survey No. 1 l6/ I to an extent
of Acs.29-19 guntas is recorded as 'poramboke Sarkari,. Further, the
sale deed of the petitioner mentions the survey number as 116/4,
which does not even exist, and in fact thc subject land actually lalls in
survcy No. i l6/ I, which is a (iovcrnnrcnt lancl. The TSLII rccords.
revenuc records and location skel.ch prcpared from the said records
clearly identify and Iocalise the subjecr land to be falling in survey
No.1 16/ 1 but not in survey No.I 16/4 as claimed by the petitioner.
As per the pahanies, survey No.l16/1 of Khairatabad Village to an
extent of Acs.29- 19 guntas recorded as ,poramboke Sarkari,. As per
Town Survey Record, T.S. No.75, Block-J, Ward-g9 correlated. to
survcy No.1 16/ I Part is rccordcd as Sarkari in column No. l0 and ,G_
Govcrnment' in column No.20 and therc is no survey No. I 16/A in
Khairatabad Village. As such, the allegcd document No.797O l2Olg
relied upon by the petitioner cannot crcatc any right or titlc to the
petitioner to claim the subject land.
3(1995) l SCC 614
1.4
PK, J
WP.i;o 1l 14 5 o12021 & batch
9. 1l l,earned Spccial Govcrnment Pleader further submitted that the
clarm o[ thc peLrtroncr that thu.Advoc.rte Contmissioner has delivered
posscssion ol lhc sLrblcct propcrt) and salc certifit<atc was issued by
ARCIL arc al1 invcnled to grab the valuable Government property and
therefore the same is not binding on the respondents as they are not
pariics to thc saicl proccedings. Irurther, thc allegcd building
permission darcd 04. I L)O2O u as obtaincd by thc pctrtioncr by
supprcssing thc material lacts bclorc thc GI{MC :rnd the aLrthorities
of (lllN4C uithout secking lan.i sta[us report {rom the revenue
au Ihorirics havc sanctioned construction pet-mrssion without
examining the governmcnt interest over the said property. F\rther,
mere sanction of construction permission does not create an)' right or
titlc to the pctitioner. Thc learned Special Government Pleader has
specilicallY contCnclcd that the claim of the petitroner [hat survcy
No.I 16/ t has br:cn renumbcrcd as survcy No.1 16/4 is incorrect and
furthcr contcnclcd that thi: land Ialling tn survev No.116/4 is
classil-iccl .rs pn\ar(' land but thc l:rnd claimed by the petirioner is
differcnt and distinct and the same falls in survey No. 116/ 1, which is
ciassified as Government land. Thus, under the guise oi the
documents relaring to survcy No. 116/4, the petitioner is claiming
righLs in rcspect of the land in survey No. I 16/ 1.
It is further
PK, J
W.P.No.I I 145 of 2A21 & batch
contended that as the subject propcrtlr falls in survey No. 116/t
corresponding to T.S. No.75, Block-J, Ward No.g9 of Khairatabad
Village, which is Government Land, the revenue authorities have
initiated proceedings under thc provisions of Andhra pradcsh Land
Encroachment Act against Gayatri Devi f3adruka, who is the
predecessor-in title of the petitioner. In W.p. Nos.13497 and 13491 of
2012, this Hon'ble Court has issucd in[erim direction on 05.06.20ig
rcstraining thc aul.horitics frotn lnlcrl'cring \,,,i th thc posscssion.
'lherelore, the subsequent devclopments averred by the petitioner are
not binding on the authorities and the petitioner is bound to honor
the said directions and maintain status quo in respect of the subject
property till the dispute is resolved. It is further submitted that as
W.P.No.21O13 ol 2006 was liled against GHMC questioning non_
issuance of construction pcrmission to the petil.ioner thercin, thc
orders in thc said writ pc[it)on cannoL bt madc applicable to thc case
on hand. Learned Spccial Govcrnmcnt l)lcadcr has further submitted
that the subject land is vacant on ground wilh the custody of the
Government and kept in the land bank vide L.B.No. 1129. As the
petitioner, under the guise of sale deed d,ated 2O.Og.2O1g stated to
have been executed by ARCIL and the construction permission issued
by the GHMC, is trying to takc up rhe construction work in the
PK, J
W P.llo.l I 14 5 of 2021 & batch
subtcct land Changing thc nature of the lands contrary to the order
datccl 2 7.0.1.202 I passed br this Court in W.l). No. I 1 145 of 202 l, the
autlroritics h.rVC rcslstc(l thc action of thc pctitroncr in order to
prolcCt the GOvcrnrnerrt land.
9 2l
It is further contended that Town Survey was conducted in
Hyderabad District ciuring the period 196.1- 197 1 by the Deputy
DirccLor, Survev & I-and Records, Hyderabad Dlstrict, under the
provisions ol A P Survcv & Boundary Act, 1923. 'lhereafter, after
issurng notices lo all the o\\ners ol the subjec.L propertics and calling
their objeclions. rCcorcls',rcrc implcmcntcd in 1981.82. 'lhc Location
SkeLch Map rndicating survct No.116/l and 116/4 prepared by the
I)cputy Inspccror (S&l,R). and thc Rccord ot- Measurcments (ROM)
and Tou n Survel Letnd Rccords (1'SI-R) re',,ea1 that survey No, 1 I6/ 1
co-rclatcs to 'l'.S. No.75. Block-J, Ward No.89 and the subject land is
continuouslv included in Lald Book Parcel as well as in POB
(Prohibitorv of Book) Furthcr, the issue has zrriscn in the year 2020
u,hcn thc pclitioncr sl:l:tcd constru(.tion in survc,r, No.1 t6/ 1, u.hich is
a go\ ernm('llL pr()pcrt\ . on rhc prcmisc ol c.)nstruction permission
grantcd in survev No.116/A, and thcrefore, the respondents started
taking actton. Horvever, the petitioner has approached this Llonble
Court in W.P. No. I 1 145 ol 2021 alicging inrerferencc from the official
L7
PK, J
W.P.No.11145 oJ 202I & batch
respondents. But, in such a situation, the petitioner ought to have
approached the competent Civil Court by filing appropriate civil suit
for injunction. Further, the pcti[roner himsell is not clcar as to
whether the subject propcrty lies rn survcy No. 116/4 or l I6/4 since
in W.P.No.I I145 ol 2021, the petitioner is claiming that the subject
property is in survey No. I 16/4 whereas in W.p. No.14057 of 2024.
the petitioner is claiming that the subject property is in survey
No. 1 i
6/A.
Thereflore, the identihcation of the larld of the writ
petitioner is in dispute as the claim o[ the respondent authorities is
that it falls in survey No,1 16/ 1. which is a government land. The
petitioner has approachcd this Court [or adjuclication of disputcd
questions of fact withou t approaching the Civil Court. I.-urther, there
is no such survey No.1 I6/A in Khairatabad Village.
9 3) Learned Special Governmcnl l)lcader has furlher contonded
that it is settled law that pure disputed questions of fact cannot be
decided on the basis of documents filed in the writ petition and in
such cases evidence has to be led by the parties and the appropriate
remedy would be to [ilc a civil suir for ad.judication of the samc. It is
furthcr contcnded that thc subjcct land is recorded as governmenI
land vide No.8300008 with vacant on the ground to an extent of 1495
Sq. Mtrs. as verificd in the Land tlook Rcgistr:r. F.urther, thc Joint
PK, J
W.P.Iio.1l145 of 202I & batch
CollccLor. Hydcrzrbacl District. has rejected lhe request of the
petitioner Ibr NOC vide File No.N213123 12006 dated O7.10.2007 on
the ground that the subject land is government land and further
directed thc' N,lunicrpal Corporation. Ilvdcrabad, not to accord any
buikling pcrmissron. Supprcssing thc satnc, thc pctitioner has
obtained thc burlding permission dated 04. l1.2O2O from GIIMC.
llenct--. thc sairl building permission does not create anv right or title
to thc pctitioncr. Furthcr, it is rvcll settlcd principle of lar,"' that any
building permrssion accorded over the Government land is not valid
under la\. and Ls null and void.
91) Lcarned Spi:cral (lor,,ernmcnt l)lcadcr as further contcnded that
tr., Vinjamuri Ra.jagopala Chary's ca-se (referred supral, it has
been categoricalll hcld Lhat anv gricvance ol the parlics with relerence
to thc propcrtics corcr<'d br clauses (a) to (d) will have to be
questroncd b1 rhc aggricved partics only by appropriate proceedings
before a competent Civil Court and the adju<lication of such courts
would be final. If the petitioner is aggrieved by rhe action of the
authorities in piac:ing thc subject property in prohibitory list, it ought
[o havc appro:rchccl the compctcnt Civi] Court lbr proper adj udication.
'l'he petitioner had approached thrs Hon'ble Court wir hou t therc being
:rny',iolaLion of fundamcntal right that too whcn thcrc exjsts a proper
PK, J
W. P No.11 14 5 of 2A2t & batch
remedy available lor redressal of lts grievance. Further, in
W.P.No.28300 of 2OO7 vlde order dated 19.I0.2023, this Hon'ble
Court has hcid that thc subjcct propcrtv kcpt undcr Scction 22 A of
the Registration Act does not violate the right to hold the property.
Learned Special Government while referring to the judgment in
Prq.meela Modi's case (reJerred. supra). has contended that the
[Ionble Apex Court has upheld that survey No. 116/1 is a
Government land. Relying on thc same, the petitioner contended that
survey No.1l6 is divided into sub-parts. The authoritics arc not
disputing sub-division of survcl, No. l1(r. but it is the spccific claim of
the authoril.les that thc property clatmed by the petitioner falls in
survey No. 1 16/ 1, which is admittedly a government land.
9 5) Learned Special Government Pleader has further contended
that the petitioner has prematurely approached this Court in W.P.
No.2509O of 2024 challenging the letter dated 24.07.2024, which is
merely an inter departmental communication between thc District
Collcclor and Commrssioncr, (lllNIC, and thcrclorc thc said writ
petition is liablc to bc dismissccl sincc there is no cause of action.
The Flon'ble Supreme Court, in State of Ortssa v. Mesco Steels
2a
PK, J
W P.''ta 1 1 14 5 oJ 2021 & l)at(h
Limitede. has held that thc rvrit pctition lilcd seeking interl'erence at
prt clecisional stagr: u'ith provisional dccisior-r which constituted only
a sr"ep in proccss of taking final decision by lhe authority must be
treated as premature. Therefore, it is prayed to dismiss all the writ
petitions as devoid of merits, Reliance has also been placed on:
a)
Judgment dated 07.07.2023 passed by tl-re Divrsion Bench in Writ
Appeal No.4 84 ol 2017:
bl
M.Yadagiri Reddg u. V.C. Bro.hmanna'
c)
Nli s. Inv( (La 'l ccnnologics [)riratc Limitcd r,. Government ol Andhra
Pradesh. Wrir I)c[rtron Nos.28300 of 2007 & batch dated 19.1O.2023.
d)
Comrnon order ciated 21.02.2025 passcd by thr: Division Bench of
this Court in LA. Nos. i a:rrd 2 of 2023 in Writ Appea.l No.484 of 2017.
10) ln reply, thc lcarned senior counscl appcaring for the petitioner
has submitted that thc survcv No.1 16/ 1 uas divided into survcy
Nos. 116/1 to
116/-- anrl thc sutrjcct land ialls within survev
No. I16r4. rrhich is a priva[e land and is amrdst ol series of private
lanr1s. FLrrthcr. as per salc dced document No.1694/94 dated
20.06.1994. it rvas rightiy described that the subject land forms part
'1u o r 3t
.r scc :+o
'o:00 t ScC oni,Lie \t, 9,I9
PK, J
W.P. No. 1 I I45 o1 2021 & batcLl
of survey No.l 16/4, which is not a government land and that i.i
transcribing error occurrcd , hcn thc schcclule in thc sale deed
No.1694 l9a dated 20.06. 1994, due ro which, survey No. I t6l4 was
mentioned as 1i6/A. As such, the revenue records and the Town
Survey Record relied by the authoritics do not pcrtain to the sublect
land as thc saicl rccorcls pcrterin to survcy No. I I6/ I bul. not survey
No.I16/4, u,hich is noL a govcrnnlent [and. FurLhcr, as held by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Prameela Modi's case (rcferred supra), tht:
factum of division of survcv No.116/t to tl6/l
ro I1615 was not
carricd out in the TSI,R records erroneously. F-urther, the pctitioner
had clearly established thc title flow to the petitioncr from 1356 fasli
i.e. year 1946 and the tile of the predecessor-in - title of the petitioner
is also clcarlv establishcd in Khasra l)ahani for the year 1954.
Ifurtht:r, cv<:n :tc)cordtng lo the rccord of thc authoritics i.e. Area
Reconciliation Statemcnt. it rccords that Lhc lands in survel,
No. I 16/ [ is governmcnt Iand and it does not include '1.S, No.7S,
Illock-J, Ward No.89, as l.rncl bclongrng to Lhc Clovcrnmcnt. Rcliance
has been placed on:
l1) This Court has taken note of the submissions made by
rcspective counsel and perusccl Lhe material on rccord
PK, J
w.P.Na.11145 of ?021 & batch
1)) 'l'hc rn:t;l-r ,.olrr,,;tllr..:-, ol rhct pcti[ioncr ]s Lhart it is tlrc orlner of
thc sutlr:ct I)1 op('rl\ , ,,r ltrclt lalls in srLrvcv N t. 1 16, A or 1 16/4 having
pu rchascd (hC sarnc in an auction from /\RCIL and has been in
posscssiort oi rhc samr:. l.'urthcr, thc petitioner has also frlcd
documenIs substantiating thc litlc flor,", Il-om r.hc vc;ir 1943 onu,ards.
13) I-'rom the pleadings oi both the parties, it is an admitted fact by
both the parties that thc land in survcl. No.116/ 1 was sub-divided
int. sur'c' Nos. I 16, 1 to 1 la),r5, ollt ,l r itir.lt. tne la.c.l iit survr:r
No. L ltri I is th(, go\.('rnrn.'ltt l;rncl and thc letrcl in survcr. No. I 16/4 is
a privzr te lalt(i.
l4)
ln thc alror.r' ba<.kgrouncl. the lrrlle ,,i ing issrrcs :rrisc lrtr
adjudication before rhrs (lour[:
l) \\'hctbr:r lh(,Governmenr can claim the ownership rights
unilatcrall-r'?
))
\\ hcLlicr Lht, sutr.jcc.r propcrL\ falls in survcr. No.I 16/ 1 or
116t4 or llii'.-\/
.3) \!'hcLhrtr sr rrt cr No. 1 1 614 was wronglv mentioncd as survcy
15) lnsolar .rs issuc No. I is r.oriccrrrcd, this Court is ol thc r",rcu. that
lhc petrtioncr has cslablishecl the title flou, in respect of the schedule
PK, J
W.I'. No.1 l l4 5 of 2O2l & betctl
property through registcred sale deeds from the year 1943 onwards
and ir is rts specrlic casc that thc subjecr property falls in survel'
No.116/A \l16l4). IIowevcr, the rcspondcnt authorities contcnd rhat
the subject propert-v" falls in survcy No. I l6/ I , which is the
(]overnment land. From lhe above, it rs clcar that both the parties are
unablc to rdentify ihc location of the land wherc the su bjecr
construction is being undertaken. llowcvcr, thc rcspondcnts havc
unilaterally declared themsclves as owners of the subject land.
15.
l) In this context, thrs Court deems it apt to refcr that the Hon'blc
Supreme Court in Thumtnalq Krishna Rco's ccse (reJerred suprd),
which reads as under:
''f hc Oor.cr nrncrt caDltot dccidc sucl'r qucstions LLnilalerally
in its ourr favour and evict any pcrson summaril\ on tl'to basrs
oi such decisron. Ilut duration ol occr,Lpation is relevant in Lhe
sense that a person who is in occLlpation of a property openl)
Ior an apprecrable length of tLme can bc takcn, prima tacie. ro
havc a bonafide claim to thc propertv rcquiring an impartial
ad1Lrchcation accordrng to the established procedure of law."
15.2) ln view ol lhc abovc settied proposition of' lar.r., this Court is ol
the view that the action of thc I)istrict Collector in addrcssing Ietters
to the Regislcring authoritics noL Lo cnterIatn rcgistrations in respect
ol thc subjcct property and ro the Commissioner, GtlMC, Lo cancel
thc burlding permissions granted in lavour ol the petitioner,
PK,,I
l{.. /)
\ir I / I 1i al ).!)2 1 & but h
unilateralh decl:rring that the subject property lrrlls in government
Iand. is unsustainabl(r undcr thc law
15.31 If the S:ar( . bt ir-rq thc i:ustodian ol Lhi: govcrnmcnt land, is of
the opinion Lhat ih,' Pctilioncr is making ConsLruction in Govcrnmcnt
Land, Llrc ,rutitor itlcs ougirt Io havc :rpproa,'hcd rrpplopriarLc lrorrrrrr
for redrr:ssal ol' lhcir grcivance. instcad of :rcting urlilalcrallv, and
u'ilhout doing so. thi. authonties cannot intet-ferc \,\'ith the possession
of the pe titioncr.
I6)
[ssuer Nos.2 and.] raise disputecl qlcstio;'rs of fact, which
cannot be gonr: inLrr Dy thrs Court rvhilc cxcrcislng inherent powers
unrlcr Arlick' 22o ot thc Ccins[i[urron of lndia. It is settled iau under
Artir:1e .226 of Lltc (lonslitu lion ol India. thc Coults should imposc
self reslriction lrr inlr'r{i,rrnq into disputccl rl.rcstions rclatjltg lo title
ancl possessior
16.-) In lhis corltcxt, ir is apropos to rclcr Lo thr judgment in Municipal
Corporation, Aurangabad through its Commissi oner us. State of
Maharashtrq.r r. rvhcrein thc IIon'ble Apcx Court held that rhe High
Cour-1 crrccl in cxerc'ising its lurisdiction under Article 226 of thc
(.20 5 1,, s(.i a8,
I'K, J
1,t'l'i\0 1 I 1 1.) al 202 t &, bcu.lt
Constitutron of lnctia in dcciding thc disputcd qucstions of lact
regarding titlc ovcr disputcd Iand rarscd bY thc partics rhurcin.
16.2) Similarlv. in S urati Ferro Allogs Priuate Limited. us. Orissa
Industrial Infra.structure Developrnent Corporation (IDCO)L2, |nc
IIon'blc Apex Court hc-ld rhat matrcr involving drspurcd clr.tcstion ot'
lat:t about [hc ou,ncrship r;]'thc lr-rncl in clucslion could nol bt: dccidccl
in a nrit pcLition unclcr ,\r Lir'le 22(> ol' thc: ConsLiLution of India and
that thc lligh Court s as justilicd in dircr_-rrng rhc partics to approach
the civil Court for resolving such disputc.
l7) lfor the aforc-mcnrioncd rcasons. all thc WriL pctitions are
alloucrl ars ptrary'cd for. Ilour',,,cr, it is mudc clear th:rt thjs order does
not precludc the rcspondt:nI authorjtics in rrvailtng approprialr: 1cgaL
rcrncdics, sLricrly in accordancc r,r'ith lrrl
Miscr-'llirnct.rr,rs i.rpplic.aLiotrs. iI
.
anr,, peltding in these writ
petilions, shall stand closcd. No costs.
SD/. MOHD. ISMAIL
//TRUE COPYII
D PUTY REGISTRAR
SECTION OFFTCER
To,
The Principal Secretarv. St"g of Telangana, Revenue
Department,
.
.
Secretariat Building. Hyderabad. tetangana.- "-"-'
The District Collector, Hyderabad District. Hyderabad.
Telangana.
The Mandar Revenue officer, Khairtabad Mandar.
6-3-62grgt1 . Anand Nagar
Colony. Khairtabad-500004.
4. The District Collector, Hyderabad District, Hyderabad, Telangana
5. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Secunderabad Division, Hyderabad
6. The Tahsildar, Khairtabad Tahsil, Hyderabad
7. The Sub - Registrar, Erragadda, Hyderabad
8. The Sub - Registrar, punjagutta, Hyderabad
?ro
9. The Commissioner, GHIMC, Tank Bund, Hyderabad
'10.One CC to SRI T P.S.HARSHA, Advocate
'l '1 .Two CCs
to THE ADVOCATE GENERAL, High Cou( for the State of
Telangana at Hyderabad. [OUT]
12.Two CD Copies.
BSK
GJP
PAA
[OPUC]
--A
:'!
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1010712026
CC TODAY
COMMON ORDER
ilir- sr1t€
c
WP.Nos.1 1145 OF 2021, 14057,
lio
25088 & 25090 ot 2024
11,..,
\r :;
r9 P^q.
c\d \>t
-\
$
k
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITIONS
WITHOUT COSTS
P
2 0 JUL 2026
l<
tt::.'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review