Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34881
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITIO N NO:21328 OF 2026
Between:
M/s. Sri Vasista Homes and lnfra LLP, (previously known as M/s. Sri Vasista
Constructions) rep. by its Manager, Mr. R. Surendranath Reddy, Son of Sri R.
Nageswara Reddy, aged about 38 years, 501, 8-2-3501312, Sri Vasista
Apurva, Road No.3, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad-500 034.
..
Petitioner
AND
1. Additional Commissioner (Appeals-l), 7th Floor, Kendriya Shulk Bhavan, Opp.
L.B. Stadium Basheerbagh, Hyderabad-500 004.
2. Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax, Ameerpet Division, Srinagar Colony,
Hyderabad-500 073.
3 _Unlon of lndia, rep. by its secretary, Ministry of Finance, Jeevan Deep
Building, 3rd Floor, Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110 001.
4 central Board of rndirect raxes and customs, GST poricy wing, Government
of lndia, Ministry of Finance, New Delhi, rep. by its Commission6i
lGSt;.
5. State of Tetangana, rep. by irs Chief Secretary, and Special Chief
Secretary to
Government (FAC), State Tax Departmeni, S6.[irn"t,
Hyderabad.
... Respondents
Petition under Articre 226 0f the constitution
circumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith,
of rndia praying that in the
the High court may be preased
to issue a writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate
(a)declaring that the finar adjudication
writ or order or direction
order in Form GST DRC-07 dated 1 1.3.2024
passed under section 73 0f the .GST and
sGST Act by the 2nd Respondent for the
tax period 2018-19 as being a nullity, non-est in law on account of not having any
signatures and consequently, set-aside the adjudication order dated 30.10.2023 and
Form GST DRC-07 dated 11.3.2024 for the year 2017-18 under section 73 of the
cGST Act as being illegal, without jurisdiction, and (b)declare that the levy of GST
on construction servrces arising from Development Agreement-cum-General Power
without
of Attorney bearing Document No.826 of 2014 dated 13.2.2014 is illegal and
jurisdiction and outside the purview of the GST regime which was introduced only
appeal
ftom 1.7.2017, or (c)alte rnatively, declare that the limitation to file a statutory
until a signed copy of
under Section '107 of the GST Act. 2017 would not commence
the order in Form DRC-07 dated 1 1 03 2024 is served on the Petitioner
in
limitation to f ile a statutory
accordance with law, or (d )alternatively, declare that the
not commence until a copy of
appeal under Secton 107 of the GST Acl,2017 would
'1
on the portal in accordance
the order in Form DRC-07 dated 1 '3 2024 is uploaded
withlawandsetasdetheappellateoiderdated65'2026passedbythelst
and
statutory appeal on the ground of delay
Respondent dismissing the Petitioner's
appeal filed by the Petitioner and adjudicate
direct the 1st Respondent to restore the
the same on the merits of the assessment
and record
l.A. NO: 1 oF 2026
the
the circumstances stated in
petition under section 15,1 cpc praying that in
to grant stav
High Court may be pleased
the
petition'
the
of
affidavit filed in support
Respondent and
impugned order of the 2nd
the
to
pursuant
of all further proceedings
dated 30 10 2023 and 6 5'2026
Respondent
1"
of
impugned order-in-appeal
will be
as otherwise the Petitioner
Petition
Writ
the
of
respectively pending disposal
put to severe loss and hardshiP
STi KARTHIK
Counsel for the Petitioner:
counsel for the Respondent
RAMANA PUTTAMREDDY
Nos'2 to 4: sri'
'[he Court made the following: ORDER
3;Xi?!1fil9ri3 33i"'"' for
cBtc
ilErr-
IN THf, HIGH COU RT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT IIYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JT]STICI S RI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
ANI)
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G. M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PE'TITION No.21328 of2026
Dated: 04.08.2026
Befween:
M/s. Sri Vasista I Iorncs and Infia [.1.]'.
Rep.. bf its Managcr. Mr. R. Surenclranath Rcddy.
[]an jara IJills. I l1'dcrabad.
... Petitioner
And
Additional Commissioner (Appeals-l ).
Kendril'a Shulk Bhavan. Basheerbagh.
Hyderabad and 4 othcrs.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Mr. '['arun Chadha. learrnctl reprcscnts Mr. Karthik Rarrana
Puttamreddy. lcarned counsel tbr the petitioner.
Mr. D. Raghavendra Rao. learncd Senior Standing Counsel fbr
Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) appears fbr
respondent Nos.2 and 4.
2.
'fhe appeal prel-erred by the petitioner on 30'03'2024 against the
order- in-origina l. dated 30.10.2023 covering tax period 2018- l9 and the
Forrr GS't' DRC-07. datcd t 1,03.2021 nas disntissed on the ground ol'
delay' as being beyoncl the condt;nable period o1'one month over the
-|III
l
tlrrce rnonths period prescribed under Secrion 107( l) and (,1) of the
( entral (rorrd: anrl Sclr iccs Iax Act. 20 I 7 (tirr shorr. ..thc r\cr..)
l-carned counscl lhr thc pctitioner subrrits that on account o1 a
bono fidc' bel el' rhat thc appeal lould lie on)r upon uploading of.the
l:ornt (i\l
pre I'elred
I)RC-t)l thal look Placc
on
0l.10:.1
the petitioner
an appeiLl on 30 0-1.202,1. rvhich rras u ithin the period
prescribed under Sccrion 107( 1) and (4) ol the Aot. Ilorvever. the
appcllate arrthcrir) coLrrrin-e rhc pcriod of'liuritation tionr the date ol'the
orcler-irr-oriqirrul has re'jcctcd the appeal. I-carncd c.unscl lbr the
pctitioner rclic,s upon a decision of rhis Court irr \\,.lr.No.2g22l of 1025.
datcd 23.09.20-15 *hir:h re r'crs ro Rurc r08 oI the crerrtrar Coods and
Scrr iecs Ia', llrrlc:. l0 l: iftrr short. .-lhc Rules") and a def.ective Form
GS I I)RC-07 rr hich did ,ot contain rhe intcrest a.tl penalty. I-here rvas
also some dela1. in uploadine the sunlmar), o1'the order in Form GST
DI{( -()7. l'his ( oLrrt in such c irc u rr.rstances renrandecl thc rlatter to the
appcll.tc au(h.ri:r ()n accoLlrt ol the inhercnt cle l'ect rn the proccedings
rvhich should enure to the benetlt ol' the assessee/tax payer. It is
suhmitted thar trr the presc.nt case lrecause of the delar Itl uploading the
sL rnrirr\ o1'Lhc irrdcr iIr l:.rrlr (is
I I)R( -07. thc pctitioncr bona.fidel1.,
llled thc appcal uirhrn rhe pcriod prescribed under Scction 107(
(.{) ot rhe ,\cr ()n i0 {)l.l0ll \\hich.
I'hcrclirrc. hc pr,rs trrat thc
ho,,rerer. stands re.jectecl.
irrrrLrr:.cd appcar or(rer r)ra\
that tltc appeal can )e (j.ci(1.(i
on rrrcrits.
l) and
Lrc set aside so
ha'e liled thc appcar on r0.03.202,1 i..,,hich bcca,c tirnc barred
reckoning the period fiorn the date o{' the order_in_original dated
30 .10.2023
. ln such circumstances, we are of the vierv that the matter
should be remitted to the appellate authority to take a fiesh dccision
the appeal in accordance with law within a reasonable period.
impugned order-in-appeal is accordingll, set asido. -l.he
on
The
appellate
authority would entertain the appcal on rnerits takin_e into account
the
observations made herc inabove.
Accordingly, the writ petition. is disposed ol. No order as to
costs.
Miscellaneous applications. il'any, pending. shall stand closed
//TRUE COPY//
SD/. B.REKHA RANI
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
l9
SECTION OFFICER
To,
l
The Additionar commissioner (Appears-r), 7th Froor, Kendriya
shurk Bhavan,
Opp. L.B. Stadium Basheerbagh, Hydera6ad-500 004.
2. The Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax, Ameerpet Division,
Colony, Hyderabad-500 073.
Srinagar
3. The se^cretary, _Ministry of Finance, Union of lndia, Jeevan Deep Building,
Floor, Sansad Marg, New Delhi- j 10 001 .
3rd
4 Centrar Board of Indirect Taxes and customs,-UVGST poricy wing, Government
- .
of lndia, Ministry of Finance, New Delhi, r."p
it, CommtsionE, (GSi).
5 The chief secretarv and speciar chief secretary to Government (FAC),
Tax Department, secretarli,-ivo# o"ol""'
"-'' "
state
6. One CC to Sri. KARTHTK RAMANA PUTTAMREDDy,
Advocate [OPUC]
7. One CC to Sri. D. RAGHAVENDRA RAO, Senior Standing
Advocate [OpUC]
B. Two CD Copies
PSR
TKS
(v
Counset for CBIC,
1.
I.earnccl Scnitrr Standing (_otrnscl lbr CIIIC' has opposed the
prarer o1- thc lcurned eounsel lbr thc petitioner. Ile has also ret-crred to
I{ulc l()8 trl- the RLrle: u hich pror ides tbr filing ol an appeal against the
ordc'r-in-ori5ltnul crcrr il nor uploaclecl b1 suhrritting a sell'-certilled copv
ot'thc sai(l tlee i:rort r ithin a pcriocl ol socn dars liom thc date ol'ljlin_q
of' I ornr (;S l' ,\l)l--() I .
A llnal acknowle(lgment indicating appeal
nurnher is issu.d thcrcitItcr hr thc appellate authorit) in Forrr GST
API -()2 unti tlrc tlatc trl' issrrc ol' provisional acknorv ledgerncn t is
considererl as the datc ol liling ol appcal. Ilc subrnits that the petitioner
should har c lilcrl the uppeal auainst thc order-irr-original rvithin the rime
prcscri[.red er cr] llrotruh tlte sutnntar\ ol'the order rvas uploaded laler on.
The approach ol tltc appcllatc authofit\ thcrelbrc should not be l'ound
l-ault l irh.
5.
We har c considerecl the subrnissions ol the leamed counsel lor
the petitioner'. takcn notc ol'the relc\ant dates as are bornc out lioln the
pleadinus on recortl ancl also pcrused the irnpuened order. Rule 108
lhiclr deals sitl. appeal to the appellate authority provides lor the
procedure to lre l.,llrructl lirr Illing an appcal against ordcr-in-orrginal
Ordinarrh . th,.' 'Lrnunrrrr ol' tlrc ordcl i: uploadcd ON the samc day or the
lbllou ing dar ol pas:in-s ol the order- in -original. The period of
li.ritati.n is crrLrr.rrcd li(rnr thc datc of'comrrunication ol the order-inoriejnal. IIorrc.re-. itr rhc instarrt casc. duc to delal ln
\urrrnar\ ol'lltc ortler. llrc p!-riti()Dcr \tn ,<t
ruploading rhe
bonLt /ictc bclict_ appears to
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0410812026
ORDER
WP.No.21328 of 2026
1 \\E STAT€
i:
(-P
1sAUG2026
t,,
D 45, ,prr6,C
DISPOSING OF
THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS.
\C
(ct\-
-
\cr,
-iq\*ta'
t
.f
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review