Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 348e 1
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSANDAND TWENW SIX
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATH! RAO
WRIT
N NO:5{72 oF 20lo
M/s. Sri Um rya & Co. 42-2311 , Opp K.G. Bus Depot, Patel Nagar, Moula-Ali,
by its Pahher Dayalal Patel S/o.Parbat Patel.
Hyderabad,
D
1. The lncome Tax Officer, Ward-11 (4), lncome Tax Towers, A.C. Guards'
Hyderabad.
2. The lncome Tax fficer, Range-10 (3), lncome Tax Towers, A.C. Guards'
Hyderabad.
3. Commissioner of lncome Tax, Hyderabad-V, lncome Tax Towers, A.C.
Guards, Hyderabad.
Petition under Article 226 ol the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, order or direction one in the nature of Mandamus
in not refunding the amount of
declaring the action of the
the certificates by the Forest
of
in
terms
Rs.44,1121- collected at source
Department under Form 27 D issued to the Respondents during the assessment
year 2005-06 as arbitrary, illegal and consequently direct the Respondents to
refund the said amount of Rs.44,1121- in the interests of justice.
Counse! forthe Petitioner: SRI A.V.A SHIVA KARTHIKEYA
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms.BOKARO SAPNA REDDY' SENIOR SC FOR
INCOME TAX
The Court made the following: ORDER
')
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
IIYDERABAD
HONOURABLE SRIIUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
HON'IiLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALACHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION
.s172oE20t0
DATE:\2-az.nze
Between:
M/s. Sri Umiya & Co.,
Rep.by its Partner Dayalal Patel,
r/o. Patel Nagar, Moula-ali, Hyderabad.
. . ..
Petitioner
And
The Income Tax Officer,
Ward-11(4), Itrcome Tax Towers,
AC Guards, Llyderabad and two others.
ORDER: (per Hon'hle Sri lustice Suddala Chalapathi Rao)
The insl:ant writ petition has been filed declaring the action of
the responderrts in not refunding the amount of 7 M'L12/ - collected
at source in terms of the certificates issued by the Forest Department
under Form-27D issued to the respondents during the assessment
year 2005-06, as arbitrary, illegal and consequently, to direct the
respondents to refund the said amount forthwith in the interest of
justice and equity.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, the petitioner-M/s.Sri
Umiya & Company, Hyderabad, is a dealer in timber and an assessee
on the rolls of L't respondent for the assessment year 2005-06, the
petitioner has filed return of income on 27.07.2005 admitting an
income of t 9,935 / - td claimed a refund of { 3,300 / -. The Assessing
Officer issued an intimation under Section 1a3(1) of the Income Tax
Act, 1961 (for short, 'Act, 1961') on 29.1'1,.2005, determining the tax
payable by the petitioner at { 335/-. The petitioner subsequently
realized that during the assessment year in questiory a sum of
< 44,112/- was collected at source as income tax from the petitioner
by the Forest Department in terms of provisions of Section 206-C (L)
of the Act, 196'1, and to inadvertence the claim was not made at the
time of filing of ttte return.
3.
Further, the petitioner alleged to have filed the representation
dated 01.02.2002 enclosir,g the TCS certificates along with Form-27D
issued by the Forest Departrnent rqquesting him to grant the refund
after rectifying the earlier order under Section 154 of the Act, 1961.
Further, as no action was initiated on requests made by the
petitioner, the petitioner was advised by the 1't respondent that an
application has to A{iude for cirndoning the delay in Form z7-D
before the 3'd respondent-assessing authority and the petitioner filed
a
.)
the said application on 01.02.2008 narrating all these facts to direct
the L"t to pey the refund by accepting Form-27D by condoning the
delay. The 3,d respondent passed orders on 15.04.2008 rejecting the
said represerrtation stating that the claim for refund of. 7 44,112/ - is
supplementary in nature and the claim of refund of 1 M,112/ - is after
completion of processing under Section 143(1) of the Act.
4. In the meanwhile, the file of the petitioner was from
transferred to the Income Tax Officer, Range'10(3), Hyderabad i.e.
2"d respondent herein and in the said circumstances the petitioner
alleged to have addressed one more representation to the 2"d
respondent herrein requesting him to do the needful and grant the
refund. Since there was no response from the 2d respondent also, the
petitioner add;:essed further representation on 1.0.@.2009 to the 3,4
respondent herein and sought a direction from him to the Assessing
Officer to pass appropriate orders in the petition filed under Section
154 for rectification which has been kept pendrng by seeking an
opportunity of hearing, but however, the 3rd resPondent oide hts
order dated 26.L1,.2009 reiected the said application of the petitioner
by stating that, to pass an order under Section L54, the intimation
under Section la3(1), dated 29.11.2005, is not corning under the
purview of orclers, as such, no instruction can be issued to an
Assessing officer except under Section 264 of the Act. The said
rejection along with non-granting refund claim is assailed in this writ
petition.
5.
The learned counsel appearing'for the petitioner contends that,
under the provisions of sectio nlls4,the Assessing Authority has got
power for correction of the Assessment Orders even after issuance of
the notice of intimation under section 143 (1) of the Act,l96'1. and the
3'd respondent being a superior authority has every authority to
direct the 2"d respondent to act upon the. application of the petitioner
for refund vide his applications dated 01,.02.2007 and,10.09.200g by
considering the delay application filed along with Form-27D.
Further, the learned counsel for the petitioner has also placed
reliance in a circular issued aide No.1.4 (XL-35) dated 11.04.1955,
wherein the specific instructions were issued in the form of
guidelines for the Income Tax Officers on matters pertaining to
refund claims by the CBDT. Whereiru the Board has categorically
instructed that though specific instructions have been issued from
time to time in regard to the attitude of the officers of the Department
should adopt in dealing with the assessees in matters affecting their
interests. [t was stated that the said instructions were not followed
uniformly and thereupon, pursuant to which certain complaints were
i
/
-'4
also issued against the income tax officers complaining that though
they are prc,mpt in making assessments likely to result into dernands
in effecting recovery, but however they are lethargic and indifferent
in granting refunds for giving relief due to the assesses under the
Act. Vide the said circular, the Board has categorically directed the
assessing aulhorities to act upon the refund claims promptly
6-
The leerrned counsel also referred to a judgment of thg High
Court for the State of Kerala in the case of Parekh Brothers vs. CfIa,
the Hon'ble l{igh Court directed the assessing authorities to bear in
mind the spirit of the said circular in affording relief to the assessee,
as indicated therein, and at least when the matter is brought to their
notice, withorrt raising technical objections, the matter should be
resolved. That the said circular was also reiterated by the Honjble
High Court ol Bombay in the case of Dattatraya Gopal Shette vs.
CIfi wherein the High Court of Bombay directed the authorities
must carry out their duties in the light of the said circular. The
learned counsel contends that though there was a delay in filing the
refund claim, however, an application to condone the delay along
with Form-27D was also filed before the Assessing Authority and the
(1%4) 150 ITR 105 (K,rr)
' lrsae; rso rrn t6o (Bom)
I
3.d respondent though vested with authority has failed to direct the
authorities to consider the application and refund the claim. It is
urged that the respondent Nos.L to 3 cannot defeat the legitimate
claim of the petitioner on flimsy grounds, more so, when the circular
and the judgments of the Hon'ble High Courts are binding on the
Assessing Authorities.
7.
Per contra, Ms. B.Sapna Reddy, learned Senior Standing
Counse[ for lncome Tax Department appearing for the respondents
would contend that the application is filed at belated stage and that
without enclosing the Form-z7D, which is mandatory and that #ter
issuance of Section 143(1), the said application for refund claim was
made and the 3.d respondent has rightly rejected in refusing to direct
the assessing authorities to act upon the said representation of the
petitioner fcir refund claim.
8.
We have heard Mr. A.V.A. Shiva Karthikeya, learned counsel
for the petitioner and Ms. B.Sapna Reddy, learned Senior Standing
Counsel for respondents and having given earnest consideration to
their submissions, perused the material on record.
9.
-Evidently, the circular
dated 11.04.1955 along with the
judgments in Parekh Brbthers (supra) and Dattatreya Gopal Shetty
I
(supra), the High Courts of Kerala and Bombay respectively,
categorically directed the assessing authorities to take appropriate
steps on ther respective refund applications by considering them
promptly without raising any technicalities. In that view of the
matter, the petitioner has already filed an application for refund of
the said clainr as early as 01'.02.2007 by enclosing the TCS certificates
for grant of refund amount of - M,172/'along with the application
for condonation of delay under Form-27D and although the said
intimation under Section 143 (1) dated 29.1L.2005 categorically show
that the intirrration notice under Section 1a3(1) is an order, the 3d
respondent trcing superior authority and appellate authority vested
with power urrder Section264 of the Act, ought to have directed the
assessing authorities to act upon the representations of the petitioner
for refund of the claim dated 01.02.2007 and 10.09.2008.
10.
In that view of the matter, in our considered view, the
petitioner has :nade out a case for interference by this Court and the
proceedings ol'the 3.d respondent dated 26.11.2009 are hereby set
aside and tlre 2"d respondent, who is the present Assessing Authority
of the petitioner, is directed to consider the claim of the petitioner for
refund of the arnount of I 44,1.12/- in pursuance of the application of
the petitioner dated 01.02.2007 and 10.09.2008 filed along with
I
t
application to condone the detay and Form- 2ZD byverifying the TCS :
certificates issued by the Forest Department.
11. However, as much time elapsed since the non-consideration of
the refund of the amount, in view of the pendency of the writ
petition before this Court since 20'1,0, keeping into the circumstances
on hand, w€ make it clear that the petitioner is only entitled to the
principal sum of t 44,112/- without there being any further interest
on the said amount.
12. with the above directions, the Writ Petition is disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications if any shall stand closed.
ANT
,/TRUE COPY'/
SECTION OFFICER
\
To,
1.
The lncome Tax Officer, Ward-11 (4), lncome
Hyderabad.
A.C. Guards,
Tax
2.ThelncomeTaxofficer'Range.1o(3),lncomeTax
Towers, A.C. Guards,
Hyderabad.
3. The commissioner of lncome Tax, Hyderabad-V, lncome
Tax Towers' A'C'
Guards, HYderabad.
4.oneCCtoSRlA.V.ASH|VAKARTHIKEYA,AdvocatetoPucl
SC FOR INCOME TAX
CC tO SRI BOKARO SAPNA REDDY' SENIOR
5. ONC
loPucl
6. Two CD CoPies
BS
t
/
HIGH COURT
DATED.l'2to2l,2026
X{*'
,icG $
,)
.-)
TJ
ORDER
WP.No.51',fZ of 2O1 I
*
g*lk+.r
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
2 3 tlfiB Iil:;
*
/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review