Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 8th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 28766 of 2023
BETWEEN:M/S SIMRAN FISHERIES PVT. LTD. THROUGH ITS AUTHORIZED
SIGNATORY/ DIRECTOR HARPAL SINGH BHATIA S/O GURDEEP SINGH
BHATIA ANJANI PLAZA, 3-4 ASHOK NAGAR, BHANWARKUA, MAIN
ROAD, TOWER CHAURAHA, OPPOSITE SUNDARAM COMPLEX, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI RAVINDRA SINGH CHHABRA, LEARNED SENIOR ADVOCATE
ALONGWITH SHRI GAURAV CHHABRA, ADVOCATE.)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
1. DEPARTMENT OF FISHERIES ANIMAL HUSBANDRY AND DAIRYING
VALLABH BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
M.P. FISHERIES FEDERATION (CO OPERATIVE) LTD. THROUGH ITS
2. MANAGING DIRECTOR H.O. BHADBHADA FISHSEED FARM,
BHADBADA ROAD, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
M.P. FISHERIES FEDERATION (CO OPERATIVE) LTD. THROUGH
3. ITSREGIONAL MANAGER H.O. BHADBHADA FISHSEED FARM,
BHADBADA ROAD, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
M.P. FISHERIES FEDERATION (CO OPERATIVE) LTD. THROUGH ITS
4. CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER H.O. BHADBHADA FISHSEED FARM,
BHADBADA ROAD, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK KATORA TALAAB BRANCH, RAIPUR
(CHHATTISGARH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(STATE BY SHRI SUDARSHAN JOSHI, GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE.
NO.4 BY MS. MINI RAVINDRAN, ADVOCATE.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This petition coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 11-01-2024
14:37:24
-2-
ORDER
The petitioner has filed the present petition challenging the
order dated 03.11.2023 whereby the respondents No.2, 3 & 4 have
directed respondent No.5 to encash the bank guarantee given by the
petitioner. The petitioner is also seeking direction to the respondent to
completely waive of the amount equivalent to 20% of annual license fee
payable for the year 2019-20 in pursuant to the contract in light of the
recommendation dated 09.09.2020 made by 101st Working Committee
of the Federation. The petitioner is also seeking exemption from the
payment of penal interest levied from 15.04.2020 to 15.10.2020 on fifth
installment etc.
02.
The petitioner was given the fishing license by respondent
No.2, 3 & 4 (for brevity “Fishing Federation”) on 13.07.2018 for the
period of 5 years on the terms and conditions incorporated therein. As
per the terms and condition of the allotment the petitioner was required
to pay the license fee of Rs.57,84,56,170/- in 5 years by way of 5 equal
installments. The petitioner executed a bank guarantee in the name of
Fishing Federation amounting to Rs.9,54,46,815/- issued by the
respondent No.5 bank.
03.
According to the petitioner, in the month of March 2022, on
account of Covid Pandemic and the complete Lockdown imposed by the
Government, all the fishing activities in the Indra Sagar Dam were
suspended by the respondent No.3 on 23.03.2020. The petitioner could
not operate his business during the said ban period i.e. for the period of
2 months. The association of contractors requested the respondents for
waiver of the installments of the license fee and for not imposing any
penal interest on account of loss of the working days in the year 2019-20
and 2020-21. The petitioner also sought extension of the period of
license by 2 years.
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 11-01-2024
14:37:24
-3-
04.
According to the petitioner, the genuine request was
considered by the Working Committee in its 101st meeting held on
09.09.2020 and recommendations were made for grant of relaxation of
20% of the license fee and waiver of penal interest. Accordingly, the
petitioner claimed the waiver of 20% of annual license fee in fifth
installment Rs.2,19,87,316/- as per the aforesaid recommendation, the
petitioner has also claimed waiver of penal interest. Thereafter, the
aforesaid recommendations were considered in 102nd meeting of
Working Committee held on 20.07.2021 and two auctions were
proposed, firstly, that extension of one year with nominal increase of 5%
license fee, secondly, exemption of 20% of annual fee for the year 201920, the petitioner opted for exemption of license fee. According to the
petitioner, the said benefit was not extended to the petitioner
discriminately and vide order dated 06.11.2013, the respondent No.4 has
rejected the recommendation of the Working Committee and requested
bank to invoke the bank guarantee hence, the present petition before this
Court. Vide order dated 08.11.2023, this Court has restrained the
respondent No.5 to invoke the bank guarantee.
05.
After notice, the respondents Fisheries Federation filed the
reply as well as an application for vacating the stay by submitting that
the agreement has been cancelled vide order dated 23.02.2023 on
account of their being a serious lapses in making the payment of yearly
license fee within the time schedule as prescribed in the contract. The
petitioner cannot seek waiver of such recoverable amount outstanding
which is tune of Rs.16,61,69,018/-. The petitioner has not challenged the
termination of the contract and the quantum of the amount under
recovery. The only grievance of the petitioner is that the benefit of
recommendation of the Working Committee has not been given to the
petitioner, therefore, the respondents be restrained to encash the bank
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 11-01-2024
14:37:24
-4-
guarantee.
06.
The amount of security Rs.3,18,15,605/- has already been
adjusted and now the outstanding dues against the petitioner is
Rs.13,43,51,413/- out of which only Rs.9,54,46,815/- is liable to be
recovered by way of encashment of bank guarantee. The petitioner has
submitted a calculation of 20% waiver in the annual fee and 20% of
waiver on interest and that comes to only Rs.3,86,45,120/-, therefore,
for this amount only the respondents cannot be restrained to encash the
bank guarantee. Even after encashment of bank guarantee to the tune of
Rs.9,54,46,815/- an adjustment of Rs.3,86,45,120/- still the federation if
liable to recover the balance amount from the petitioner.
07.
Shri Ravindra Singh Chhabra, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner submits that the petitioner has two sister concerned, namely,
Sona Fisheries and B.T. Fisheries and the petitioner is entitled for
waiver of amount in total Rs.9,95,81,949/- in respect of aforesaid 3
companies, therefore, the bank guarantee cannot be permitted to be
encashed.
08.
The aforesaid contention in unacceptable because the
petitioner submitted a bank guarantee only in respect of contract given
to the Simran Fisheries and against which the recovery is
Rs.13,43,51,413/- therefore, the bank guarantee is liable to be encashed.
So far as other issues regarding quantum of the recovery, quantum of the
waiver of the amount, entitlement of waiver of the amount due to Covid
Pandimic, validity of termination of contract all these issues are liable to
be decided by way of Arbitration and Conciliation Act as provided under
Clause 46 of the registered contract dated 13.07.2018. Clause 46 of the
said contract is reproduced below:
46- vuqca/k@fufonk ds fu;e ,oa 'krksZ ds laca/k esa vuqca/k ds igys]
vuqca/k vof/k esa ,oa ckn esa fdlh izdkj dk fookn mRiUu gksrk gS rks
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 11-01-2024
14:37:24
-5-
ml fLFkfr esa ,d i{k nwljs i{k dks uksfVl nsdj fookn ds
fu.kZ;@vokMZ gsrq ,deso e/;LFk ¼vkfcZVªsVj½ dks lkSisxkA ;g e/;LFk
nksuksa i{kksa dh vkilh lgefr ls fu;qDr gksxk tks fd ;k rks e/;LFke
,oa lqyg vf/kfu;e 1996 dh /kkjk 11 ¼v?kru rd la’kksf/kr½ vFkok
e/;izn’s k lgdkjh lkslk;Vh vf/kfu;e 1960 dh /kkjk 64 ¼v?kru rd
la’kksf/kr½ ds rgr fu;qDr gksxkA e/;LFkrk ¼vkfcZVªs’ku½ dk
fu.kZ;@vokMZ nksuks i{kks dks ekU; ,oa ca/kudkjh gksxkA fookn dh
fLFkfr esa e/;LFkrk gsrq vkosnu nsus dh vof/k 6 ekg rd gksxhA
vkfcZVªs’ku ds fu.kZ; ds ckn gh vuqca/kxzghrk U;k;ky; esa tk ldsxkA
bl lac/a k esa lacaf/kr okn dk {ks=kf/kdkj flfoy U;k;ky; Hkksiky
jgsxkA
bl vuqca/k i= dks mHk; i{kdkjksa us i<dj le>dj vkt
fnukad 11@07@2018 dks eRL; egkla?k eq[;ky; Hkksiky esa gLrk{kj
fd;k x;k rkfd izek.k Lo:Ik miyC/k jgs vkSj le; ij dke vkosA
LFkku [kaMokA
09.
Shri Chhabra, learned senior counsel has placed reliance on
a judgment passed by the Apex Court in cases of (i) Shrilekha Vidyarthi
(Kumari) V/s State of U.P. [(1991) 1 SCC 212] regarding applicability
of Article 14 to all the executive extent of the State Government, (ii)
Union of India & Ors. V/s Tantia Constructions Pvt. Ltd. [(2011) 5
SCC 697] about the maintainability of the writ petition on account of
arbitration clause included in the agreement.
10.
To counter the aforesaid rulings, Ms. Mini Ravindran,
learned counsel for the respondent No.4 has cited judgment passed by
Apex Court in case of (i) Union of India V/s M/s Mohit Minerals Pvt.
Ltd. [(2022) 10 SCC 700] that the recommendations cannot create
binding and enforceable rights, in contradistinction to a „direction‟ or
„mandate‟, (ii) Bannari Amman Sugars Ltd. V/s Commercial Tax
Officer and other [(2005) 1 SCC 625] on the point of legitimate
expectation the doctrine does not give scope to claim relief straightway
from the administrative authority as no crystalized right as such is
involved.
11.
It is a settled law that the Court should be slow in staying
the encashment of the bank guarantee. As held above, the recovery of
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 11-01-2024
14:37:24
-6-
the petitioner is Rs.16,61,69,018/- out of which adjustment of security
Rs.3,18,15,605/- has already been granted. The total claim of the
petitioner in respect of waiver is not more than Rs.3,86,45,120/-.
Therefore, for remaining amount which is more than Rs.10,00,00,000/recoverable from the petitioner, the respondent cannot be restrained to
encash the bank guarantee of Rs.9,54,46,815/-. In all fairness the
petitioner ought to have filed copy of contract in writ petition fairly
disclosing the arbitration clause therein. The respondent filed the copy
of contract which contained the arbitration clause.
12.
In view of the above, Writ Petition is dismissed. However,
the petitioner shall be at liberty to invoke the arbitration clause.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Divyansh
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 11-01-2024
14:37:24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review