Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND
DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 22nd OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 8123 of 2023
BETWEEN:M/S PATANJALI AYURVED LIMITED THROUGH ITS
AUTHORIZED SIGNATORY AND CFO SHRI YAJ DEVI
ARYA S/O SHRI M.R. ARYA GODOWN NO. 02, 2-A,
KHASRA NO. 1/5/1/2, 1/6/1/2/1 JAIMAN VILLA NEAR
INDORE R/O 20, DATARAM SOCIETY ROHINI
SECTOR-18 NORTH EAST DELHI NEW DELHI (DELHI)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI GAGAN TIWARI, ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS
SECRETARY COMMERCIAL TAX, VALLABH
1.
BHAWAN-III BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
COMMISSIONER
OF
COMMERCIAL
TAX
COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICE MG ROAD INDORE
2.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX
3. DIVISION 5TH FLOOR, CHETAK CHAMBER, 13-14
RNT MARG INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI ANIKET NAIK, DY. ADVOCATE GENERAL)
WRIT PETITION No. 8125 of 2023
BETWEEN:M/S PATANJALI AYURVED LIMITED INDORE
THROUGH ITS AUTORIZED SIGNATORY AND CFO
SHRI YAJ DEVI ARYA S/O SHRI MR.R. ARYA 20
DATARAM SOCIEETY, ROHINI SECTOR 18 NORTH
EAST DELHI NEW DELHI (DELHI)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI GAGAN TIWARI, ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH ITS
SECRETARY COMMERCIAL TAX
VALLABH
1. BHAWAN, III DISTRICT BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
COMMISSIONER
OF
COMMERCIAL
TAX
COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICE MG ROAD INDORE
2.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF STATE TAX 5TH
3. FLOOR, CHETAK CHAMBER, 13-14 RNT MARG
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI ANIKET NAIK, DY. ADVOCATE GENERAL)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This petition coming on for hearing this day, JUSTICE SUSHRUT
ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI passed the following:
ORDER
Heard finally with the consent of both the parties.
This order shall govern disposal of both the writ petitions viz., W.P.
No. 8123/2023 and W.P. No. 8125/2023. Regard being had to the
similitude of the controversy involved in the aforesaid petitions, they have
been heard analogously and disposed of by this singular order
2. For the sake of convenience, facts of W.P. No. 8123/2023 are
taken.
3. The brief facts of the case are that:(I) The instant Writ Petition is being filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 challenging the adjudication order in form GST
DRC-07 having reference no. ZD230722004961P dated 15.07.2022 passed
by the Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, Division - I, Indore by which a
demand for excess Input Tax Credit (hereinafter referred to as 'ITC) has
been raised amounting to Rs. 78,49,607/- (1.29,600/- CGST, 1,29,600/MPGST, 75,90,407/-under IGST head) along with imposition of interest
and equivalent penalty under Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services
Tax Act, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as 'CGST Act') and Madhya Pradesh
Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as 'MPGST Act')
as made applicable to the Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
(hereinafter referred to as “IGST Act”) vide Section 20 of the said IGST
Act, 2017 on the ground that the said order has been passed without
considering the submissions of petitioner and also without providing an
opportunity of hearing to the petitioner thereby leading to utter disregard to
the settled principles of natural justice.
IMPUGNED ORDER PASSED UNDER SECTION 74 of the CGST
ACT/MPGST ACT IS IN VIOLATION TO THE PRINCIPLES OF NATURAL
JUSTICE
(II) That Section 74(9) of the CGST Act/MPGST Act provides that
the proper officer shall pass an order under Section 74 of the CGST
Act/MPGST Act determining the amount of tax, interest and penalty only
after considering the representation made by the Assessee.
(III) The relevant provision is as under:"Section 74: Determination of tax not paid or short paid or
erroneously refunded or input tax credit wrongly availed or utilized
by reason of fraud or any willful misstatement or suppression of facts
(9) The proper officer shall, after considering the representation, if
any, made by the person chargeable with tax, determine the amount of
tax, interest and penalty due from such person and issue an order."
(IV) An examination of the above shows that at the foremost, as per
the sub- section (9) of Section 74 of the CGST Act/MPGST Act, the
representation made by your Petitioner vide its reply dated 13.05.2022 was
not at all considered by the Adjudicating authority before passing the
impugned order under dispute.
(V) Further, Section 75(4) of the CGST Act/MPGST Act provides
that an opportunity of hearing shall be provided to the Assessee where an
adverse order is to be passed against the Assessee. The relevant provision
is as under:
"75. General provisions relating to determination of tax..
(4) An opportunity of hearing shall be granted where a request is
received in writing from the person chargeable with tax or penalty, or
where any adverse decision is contemplated against such person."
(VI) That as per the provisions of sub-section (4) of Section 75 of
the CGST Act/WBGST Act no adverse order shall be passed against your
Petitioner without providing the opportunity of hearing. However, it is
clearly evident that in the present case of your Petitioner the impugned
order was passed without providing an opportunity of being heard and that
same is against the settled principles of the legal maxim "Audi Alteram
Partem" which means a fair hearing shall be provided before adjudication a
proceeding.
(VII) Being aggrieved by the impugned actions of the Respondents
and left with no other alternate and efficacious remedy, Petitioner is
compelled to knock the doors of this Court on following facts and grounds,
in the interests of justice and fair treatment. The petitioner is constrained to
seek shelter of this Court as the impugned order passed by the adjudicating
authority is in violation to the principles of natural justice. Hence, the
present writ petition is being filed before this Court.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that a plain reading of
Sub Section 4 of Section 75 of the Act makes it clear that providing
opportunity of hearing is a mandatory requirement. The said requirement
needs to be fulfilled in twin situations :(I) When a specific request is received in writing from a person
chargeable with tax or where any adverse decision is contemplated against
such person. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the use of
word ‘or’ is very important in this statutory provision. Admittedly, in the
present cases, the adverse decision was contemplated on said
contemplation is translated into reality, when tax was levied on the
petitioners. In that event whether or not the petitioners specifically
opted/demanded for a personal hearing, a personal hearing ought to have
been provided. In absence thereof, the principles of natural justice and
statutory mandate mentioned in Sub Section 4 of Section 75 of the Act are
grossly violated.
(II) In support of his submission, learned counsel for the petitioners
placed reliance on the judgment of this Court reported in (2023) 4 Centax
198 (M.P.) (19.01.2023) (Ultratech Cement Ltd. Vs. Union of India),
the judgment of Gujarat High Court reported in 2022 (66) G.S.T.L. 38
(Guj.) (23.06.2022) (Graziano Trasmissioni India Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of
Gujarat) and lastly on a Division Bench judgment of Allahabad High
Court reported in 2023 (8) TMI 1091, Allahabad High Court, (M/s. BL
Pahariya Medical Store Vs. State of U.P. And another).
5. Per contra, learned counsel for the State submits that petitioners
have not projected requirement of Sub Section 4 of Section 75 of the Act in
a proper manner. This provision nowhere talks about opportunity of
‘personal hearing’. On the contrary, it talk about only ‘opportunity of
hearing’. Pursuant to the show cause notice issued as prescribed in form
DRC-01, the petitioner was required to opt for ‘personal hearing’ which
was admittedly not opted and in that event, no fault can be found in the
action of the respondents. He placed further reliance in the case of Union
of India and Another vs. Jesus Sales Corporation reported in (1996) 4 SCC
69, wherein it is observed that:“It shall not be out of place to mention that sub-section (2) of Section 4-M
provides specifically that appellant shall be given reasonable opportunity of
being heard if he so desires before final order is passed on his appeal. That
requirement according to us cannot be read impliedly as an implicit
condition in the third proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 4-M. But it need
not be impressed that when the Appellate authority has been vested with the
discretion to dispense with such deposit unconditionally or on conditions,
then it has to apply its mind on that question like a quasi- judicial authority
taking into consideration all the facts and circumstances of the case
including the undue hardship which has been pointed out on behalf of the
appellant. In that proviso the two expressions ’opinion’ and ’descretion’
both have been used. In view of the settled position that whenever a
statutory authority has to form an opinion on a question, it does not mean
that it has to be formed in a subjective or casual manner. That opinion must
be formed objectively on relevant considerations. Same is the position in
respect of the exercise of discretion. The framers of the Act require such
Appellate authority to exercise its discretion in a reasonable and rational
manner taking into consideration the relevant facts and circumstances of a
particular appeal while considering the question as to whether the deposit
of the amount of the penalty be dispensed with unconditionally or subject to
the conditions”.
6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and
perused the relevant documents.
7. Before dealing with rival contentions, it is apposite to quote
Section 75 (4) of GST Act which reads as under:"(4) An opportunity of hearing shall be granted where a
request is received in writing from the person chargeable with
tax or penalty, or where any adverse decision is contemplated
against such person."
(Emphasis supplied)
8. A plain reading of sub-section 4 of Section 75 of the Act makes it
crystal clear that “opportunity of hearing” must be granted in two
situations viz (a) where a request in specific is received in writing from the
person chargeable; (b) where any adverse decision is contemplated against
such person.
9. This is trite that when language of statute is plain and
unambiguous, it should be given effect to irrespective of its consequences.
(See Nelson Motis Vs. Union of India (1992) 4 SCC 711).
10. The language employed in sub-section 4 of Section 75 of the Act
leaves no room for any doubt that the word ‘or’ is used by the law makers
for a specific purpose. Although, in the first portion of the statute, i.e. sub-
section 4 of Section 75 of the Act, the statute talks about a specific request,
the portion after the word ‘or’ makes it clear like cloudless sky that
opportunity of hearing is required to be given, even in those cases where
no such request is made but adverse decision is contemplated against such
person. We find support in our view by the Division Bench judgment of
Allahabad High Court in M/s. BL Pahariya Medical Store (supra).
11. The ancillary question springs up from the argument of learned
Government Advocate for the State whether the expression ‘opportunity of
hearing’ is fulfilled if reply to show cause notice is received. We find
substance in the arguments of learned counsel for the petitioners that even
law makers while prescribing the statutory form has visualized different
stages for the purpose of ‘personal hearing’. The one stage is when the
reply is submitted and the other stage is date, venue and time of the
personal hearing. Thus, we are unable to persuade ourselves with the line
of argument of learned Government Advocate that ‘opportunity of hearing’
does not include the opportunity of ‘personal hearing’.
12. In the instant case whether or not the petitioners have
specifically asked for personal hearing, fact remains that the adverse
decision was contemplated against the petitioners. In that event, it was
obligatory and mandatory on the part of respondents to provide the
petitioners opportunity of personal hearing. Admittedly, no opportunity of
personal hearing has been provided in both the matters. Resultantly, the
decision making process adopted by the respondents is vitiated and runs
contrary to the principles of natural justice and statutory requirement of
sub-section 4 of Section 75 of GST Act. (See Graziano Trasmissioni
India Pvt. Ltd. (supra).
13. As a result, the impugned proceedings after the stage of reply of
show cause notices, in both the cases are set-aside. The respondents shall
provide opportunity of hearing to the petitioners in both the cases by some
other officer than the officer who has issued the show cause notice as per
Ultratech Cement Ltd. (supra).
14. Both the writ petitions are disposed of.
15. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on
merits of the case.
16. A copy of this order be placed in the record of W.P. No.
8125/2023.
(S.A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
Vatan
VATAN
VATAN SHRIVASTAVA
2024.01.24
SHRIVASTAVA Date:
18:42:22 +05'30'
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review