Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.F.A. No.05 of 2019
1.
M/s North East Group of Engineers (P) Ltd.,
Gangtok Lodge,
M.G. Marg, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Taktuk Bhutia,
Managing Director,
M/s North East Group of Engineers (P) Ltd.,
M.G. Marg, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
….. Appellants/Plaintiffs
Versus
General Manager,
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL),
Telephone Exchange,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…..Respondent/Defendant
Appeal under Order XLI Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Advocate along with Mr.
Sayshay Hang Subba, Advocate for the
Appellants/Plaintiffs.
Mr. K. T. Tamang, Advocate for the
Respondent/Defendant.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------Date of hearing : 20.07.2021 & 29.07.2021
Date of judgment : 06.08.2021
JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
This is a first appeal from the judgment and
decree of the Learned District Judge, Special Division-1
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
(learned Trial Court) dated 28.02.2019. First appeal is a
valuable right for the aggrieved. It is beyond doubt that all
question of facts and law decided by the learned Trial
Court are open for reconsideration. It is, however,
necessary for this Court to carefully examine and deeply
consider both the fact as well as the law arising herein and
give cogent reasons while disposing the appeal. It is our
duty to properly deal with all the issues and the evidence
led by the parties. Learned Counsel Mr. Zangpo Sherpa for
the appellant and Mr. K. T. Tamang for the respondent
have been heard in detail on facts as well as in law. This
judgement reflects their erudite submissions.
2.
A money suit was filed by the plaintiffs (the
appellants herein) against the defendant (the respondent
herein) for recovery of money towards payment for work
done under a contract. The suit went for trial after the
defendant filed the written statement and eight issues
were framed.
3.
The learned Trial Court while dismissing the suit
held that time was the essence of the agreement dated
22.02.2008 (exhibit-2) (the agreement); that although the
defendant had extended the time for completion, time did
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
not cease to be of the essence merely because a party
agreed to short extensions; that the contract awarded to
the plaintiff no.1 by the defendant was not completed
within
the
stipulated/extended
time
limit;
that
the
plaintiffs were in breach of the terms of the agreement and
therefore, the defendant was not liable to pay any amount
to the plaintiffs. The learned Trial Court held that the suit
was not barred by limitation, but it was not maintainable
as plaintiffs had not been able to substantiate their case
and had not approached the court with clean hands. The
learned Trial Court further held that the defendant cannot
be held liable to pay the interest amount paid by the
plaintiffs to Punjab National Bank towards the loan taken
by them, as it was the plaintiff who had committed the
breach of the terms of the agreement. Accordingly, the
learned Trial Court dismissed the suit filed by the
plaintiffs. The plaintiffs have therefore, filed the present
appeal against the judgment and decree both dated
28.02.2019 passed by the learned Trial Court.
4.
Out of the eight issues framed by the learned Trial
Court issue no.2 on the point of limitation and issue no.4
as to whether valid extensions were given to plaintiff no.1
from time to time to complete the concerned work was
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
held against the defendant and in favour of the plaintiffs.
There is no appeal by the defendant on both these issues.
The rest of the issue which are agitated are taken up.
5.
The
first
issue
was
whether
the
suit
was
maintainable. If the plaintiffs had failed to substantiate
their
case,
the
suit
would
fail.
The
question
of
maintainability of a suit is a question of law. Section 9 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) provides that the
court shall have jurisdiction to try all suits of civil nature,
accepting suits of which their cognizance is either
expressly or impliedly barred. The point of limitation was
separately decided in favour of the plaintiffs. The record
reveals that the defendant’s contention that no notice
under Section 80 CPC was given by the plaintiffs was also
decided in favour of the plaintiffs while deciding an
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC filed by the
defendant.
6.
It is also urged by the defendant that the plaintiff
no.2 has filed a letter dated 14.05.2010 bearing No.W290/2007-08/23 to project that time had been extended
till 21.02.2010. This document was exhibited by the
plaintiff no.2 as exhibit-7. Exhibit 7 clearly mentions that
it related to another work order. During the cross-
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
examination he explained- “Exhibit-7 though filed by me
does not seem to be with regard to Namchi work. It seems it
was inadvertently filed. Since I had performed many works
for the defendant I am often confused regarding the said
documents.” Besides, exhibit-7 the plaintiff had also filed
other documents claiming that they related to the work.
However, a bare perusal of exhibit-5 and exhibit-N makes
it evident that they related to some other work as
specifically mentioned therein. During cross-examination
the plaintiff No.2 again admitted that exhibit-N and
exhibit-5 did not relate to the Namchi work. Therefore,
there was no way the defendant could be misled by those
correspondences since they themselves were the issuer of
the work orders and correspondences. With the aforesaid
explanation, which is a plausible one, the weight of the
defendant’s argument that the plaintiff no.2 had sought to
mislead the court would lose much of its weight.
Resultantly, it may not be possible to hold that the
plaintiffs had approached the court with unclean hands on
these facts to such an extent that it would disentitle them
for any relief. It is also the defendant’s case that the
plaintiffs had sought to mislead the court by stating that
they had completed the work although it was not true. The
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
defendant’s own witness, Jay Prakash Thapa (D.W.2) the
engineer who supervised the work having admitted during
cross-examination that he had issued the work certificate
(exhibit-K) which reflects that the work was completed on
28.02.2010 nullifies this argument.
7.
There was no other plea taken by the defendant
in the written statement which would touch upon the
maintainability of the suit. It must, therefore, be held that
that the suit was maintainable.
8.
In answer to question no.3 it must be held that
the plaintiff no.1 had been able to complete the works as
recorded in the measurement book.
9.
Issue
no.5
was
whether
the
plaintiff
no.1
committed breach of the terms of the agreement, in
respect of the work, and whether the defendant could
avoid its liability. The learned Trial Court found that the
plaintiffs had committed breach of the agreement, thereby
causing loss to the defendant. This finding that the
defendant had suffered loss is held to be dehors the
evidence on record. The defendant had not even pleaded
so. Whether time was of the essence or not is always a
question of the intention of the parties. If it was not the
intention of the parties that time should be of the essence
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
of the contract, the contract does not become voidable by
the failure to do such thing at or before the specified time;
but the promisee is entitled to compensation from the
promisor for any loss occasioned to him by such failure.
The defendant had allowed the plaintiffs to complete the
work by extending the time and the last of such extension
was open ended. Further, there is neither a plea for
compensation due to any loss suffered nor any evidence of
any loss suffered by the defendant. Thus, it is held that
there was no breach and breach of timelines, if at all, were
all condoned by the defendant by extending it again and
again.
10.
On issue no.6 it is held that although time was
originally agreed to be of the essence under clause 8 of the
agreement, the defendant by its own action extended the
original deadline from time to time and finally allowed the
plaintiff to complete the work as soon as possible making
time no longer the essence of the contract.
11.
The findings of the learned Trial Court on issue no
8 that the defendant cannot be held liable to pay the
interest amount paid by the plaintiff to Punjab National
Bank on account of delay, is upheld. It is held that the
defendant is not liable to do so. There was no such
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
provision in the agreement. However, the rest of the
learned Trial Court’s finding that it was the plaintiff who
had committed the breach of the terms of the contract and
work order are set aside.
12.
Thus, in answer to issue no.7 which is decided in
the affirmative, it is held that the plaintiffs are entitled to
the reliefs as granted below. The reasons are also
discussed in detail hereinbelow.
13.
The plaintiffs filed Money Suit No.25 of 2016 on
28.12.2016. It was the case of the plaintiffs that a work
order No.22 D(a)/05-06 dated 25.09.2008 (work order) was
issued in favour of the plaintiff no.2 by the defendant for
execution of work of laying of primary cables, distribution
of U/G cables, erection of DP’s, carrying of stores and
distribution to different sites (carrying of stores from
Gangtok to Namchi and distribution) under the work name
of „beautification of Namchi Town Area‟. The work order
was awarded to the plaintiff no.2 to execute and complete
within 45 days of the date of its issuance. No estimate cost
of the work was fixed by the defendant in the work order,
but it was decided between the parties that the plaintiffs
shall be paid according to the work done and charges
incurred. Although, the plaintiff no. 2 commenced the
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
work soon after the issuance of work order there were
many hindrances and work could not be completed on
time due to the defaults of the defendant. The plaintiffs,
therefore, sought extension of time on various occasions
which was considered and granted by the defendant. The
plaintiffs completed the work within the extended period
pursuant to which the defendant was informed, and bill
presented for payment. The plaintiff No.2 had also taken a
loan from the Punjab National Bank for the said work and
the plaintiff no.2 received a notice on 19.10.2012 to pay
back the loan with interest. The plaintiffs asserted that the
work was monitored by the concerned engineer of the
defendant who entered the progress of the work in the
measurement
book.
The
plaintiffs
pleaded
that
the
concerned engineer also issued work completion certificate
but despite that the defendant failed to make payments
although various request and reminders were made. Due
to this the plaintiffs were compelled to approach the Lok
Adalat for settlement of disputes. It is the case of the
plaintiffs that during the Lok Adalat proceedings the
General Manager, DGM and AGM of the defendant assured
that they shall investigate the matter and disburse the
payment as soon as possible. Due to the assurance given
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
by them the plaintiffs withdrew the case before the Lok
Adalat. However, despite various visits by the plaintiff no.2
to the office of the defendant they failed to make the
payments compelling the plaintiffs to issue a legal notice
dated 04.03.2016. Despite the receipt of the notice no
payment was made and thus, the Money Suit was filed.
14.
The defendant filed its written statement. It was
contended that the suit was barred by limitation. The
defendant
also
alleged
that
the
plaintiffs
had
not
approached the court with clean hands and suppressed
material facts misleading the court with documents which
did not relate to the work order. The defendant admitted
the issuance of the work order and stated that prior to the
issuance of work order the agreement had been entered
between the plaintiffs and the defendant for execution of
such works in the State of Sikkim. The defendant stated
that time was the essence of the contract. However, the
plaintiffs did not complete the work on time and instead
sought for extensions. The defendant agreed to such
extension and the last of the extensions was agreed upon
by the defendant vide letter dated 27.01.2009. The
defendant stated that plaintiff had to complete the work by
the end of February 2009 and no further time would be
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
granted by the defendant.
The defendant stated that the
plaintiffs failed to complete the work even till January
2011 which gets established by their letter bearing
No.SDE(P)/NMC-2010-11/CW-2
dated
28.01.2011
(exhibit-P). It is the case of the defendant that as the
plaintiffs did not complete the work within the stipulated
time, they were not liable to make any payment at all. The
defendant
denied
having
assured
the
plaintiffs
for
payment.
15.
The plaintiffs examined Taktuk Bhutia (plaintiff
no.2) as P.W.1 and two other witnesses i.e., Gambu
Tamang (P.W.2) and Pema Tamang (P.W.3). The defendant
examined Deepak Agrawal (D.W.1) the General Manager
and Jay Prakash Thapa (D.W.2).
16.
The plaintiff no.2 reiterated the pleadings in the
plaint
in
his
evidence
on
affidavit.
In
his
cross-
examination the plaintiff no.2 admitted that exhibit-N did
not relate to the work order and related to work carried
out for the defendant from Mangan to Makha via Dikchu
covered by Work Order No. W-290/07-08/12. He also
admitted that exhibits 5 & 7 also did not pertain to the
work order. He admitted that although he had filed
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
exhibit-7 he did so inadvertently as he was confused since
he was working for the defendant on several similar
projects.
17.
Gambu Tamang stated that he knew the plaintiffs
and reiterated what plaintiff no.2 deposed in his evidence
on affidavit. He exhibited the AT report for u/g cable laying
as work completion certificate dated 18.12.2012 (exhibit15) issued by A.K. Dey, Sub-Divisional Engineer of the
defendant after inspection of the work. During crossexamination Gambu Tamang stated that he was employed
by plaintiff No.2 who was his supervisor. He admitted that
the initial time for completion of the work order was 45
days which was extended from time to time. According to
him the concerned work was completed in the year 2010.
It is important to note that this fact has been stated by
Gambu Tamang during his cross-examination by the
defendant.
18.
Pema Tamang also reiterated the facts as stated
by the plaintiff no.2 in his evidence on affidavit. He also
stated during cross-examination that as far as he could
recollect the contract work was completed by the plaintiffs
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
within the extended time frame and that the measurement
books would depict the true completion work.
19.
Deepak Agrawal reiterated the averments in the
written statement in his evidence on affidavit. He stated
that the agreement was entered between the plaintiffs as
the contractor and the defendant. As per Clause 8 thereof
time was of the essence and work order required it to be
completed within 45 days. The plaintiffs failed to complete
the work on time and instead sought extensions. The
defendant vide letter dated 18.11.2008 (exhibit-4) allowed
extension for a further period of 60 days in response to the
plaintiffs’ letter dated 05.11.2008 (exhibit-C). He stated
that vide letter dated 15.01.2009 (exhibit-D) the plaintiff
no.2
was
informed
that
they
had
been
receiving
complaints and pressure from public and government
departments regarding the slow process in works and
request the plaintiffs to gear up the process of work to be
completed within the extended time frame. The plaintiffs
failed to complete the work even during extended period of
60 days therefore, by letter dated 20.01.2009 (exhibit-F)
the plaintiff request for further extension of one month.
The defendant vide letter dated 27.01.2009 allowed
extension of 30 days (exhibit-J).
According to Deepak
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
Agrawal the further period of one month granted vide letter
dated 27.01.2009 (exhibit-J) was the maximum period
that the defendant could have allowed and no further
extension was given. Thus, the plaintiff was bound to
complete the work by end of February 2009.
20.
On 06.02.2009 the defendant issued another
communication (exhibit-I) to the plaintiffs to complete the
work on time and in the event of their failure departmental
action could also be initiated.
21.
Deepak Agrawal stated that although it was
incumbent upon the plaintiff to complete the work by the
end of February 2009 the plaintiff with malafide intention
filed letter dated 14.05.2010 bearing No. W-290/200708/23 (exhibit-7) with the plaint to project that time frame
to complete the work was extended till 21.02.2010 when in
fact
this
letter
related
to
another
work
as
laying
underground cables from Mangan to Makha via Dikchu. It
was therefore, submitted that the plaintiff has not
approached the trial court with clean hands.
22.
Deepak Agrawal stated that the work completion
certificate forming part of the measurement book (exhibit13 collectively and exhibit-O) proved that the plaintiff
carried out only 60% of the assigned work and did not
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
complete 40% of the work and even out of the said 60%
only 10% underground cables were made up to date with
respect to point-to-point jointing/joining work. Deepak
Agrawal stated that the defendant was not liable for the
loan taken by the plaintiffs. He stated that the work was
not completed till the month of January 2011 which is
established by the letter dated 28.01.2011 (exhibit-P)
which was filed by the plaintiff before the Lok Adalat.
23.
Deepak Agrawal authenticated his evidence on
affidavit and exhibited various communications including
the extensions. During his cross-examination he admitted
that the defendant had not terminated the contract
awarded to the plaintiffs; that the original measurement
book (exhibit-O) were misplaced in their office; that once a
contract work is given their engineers also supervise the
work and in the present contract work their engineers
were involved in supervising it; that the progress of work
in the measurement book is recorded by their engineers;
that exhibit-K (comprised of exhibit-O) was also recorded
by the engineer from their department; exhibit-K only
mentions that 60% of the concerned contract work
awarded to the plaintiffs work had been completed and it
does not specifically say that the remaining 40% work is
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
incomplete; the plaintiffs had repeatedly submitted letters
for release of bills in respect of the concerned work; there
was nothing in writing given by them to show that the
defendant had refused the prayer of the plaintiffs to
release the payments; and that they had extended the time
frame for completion of their contract work from time to
time on the request of the plaintiffs.
24.
Jay Prakash Thapa was the Sub Divisional
Engineer of the defendant. He reiterated what was stated
in the written statement by the defendant in his evidence
on affidavit. He also admitted to the issuance of the work
order; the failure of the plaintiff to execute the work on
time; the extension granted by the defendant from time to
time and the failure of the plaintiff to complete the work
even during the extended period. During his crossexamination Jay Prakash Thapa admitted that he was the
supervisor of the concerned work as per exhibit-2; the
defendant had not terminated the contract work; exhibit13 (collectively) and exhibit-4 are the measurement
book/copy in respect of the entire work carried out by the
plaintiffs pertaining to this case; exhibit-K (its original)
was written by him in which he had mentioned that the
work had been completed on 28.02.2010; exhibit-15 was
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
written by A.K. Dey, the Sub-Divisional Engineer of the
defendant and as per exhibit-15 he had checked the
concerned work undertaken by the plaintiffs and was
satisfied with the work; that since he worked in the field
he could say that it is not possible for contract work to be
completed within the stipulated time mentioned in the
work order and that the General Manager of the defendant
who had come and deposed before the court was not
present during the execution of the said contract work.
25.
The admitted fact seems to be that the plaintiffs
had been awarded the work order by the defendant. Prior
to that the agreement had been entered between them for
execution of similar works by the plaintiffs for the
defendant throughout Sikkim. Although the plaintiffs
initially were hesitant to admit that the agreement related
to the work order as well, he did so during his crossexamination. Apparently, the work order was issued
pursuant thereto.
26.
The agreement between the plaintiff no.1 and the
defendant was executed on 22.02.2008. The following
clauses are relevant and quoted herein below:
…………………………………………………………
“3. The CONTRACTOR will, during the period of this
CONTRACT from 22.02.2008 to 21.02.2009 or
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
until this contract shall be terminated by such
notices as is hereafter mentioned, whichever is
earlier, safely carry out at his own expense and
by means of tools, implements equipments etc.,
to be arranged by him at his own expense all
repair works as described in the said Tender
document hereunder which the BSNL or the
General Manager Telecom, Gangtok, Sikkim or
Divisional Engineer concerned under the
jurisdiction of Gangtok Telecom District
authorized by the General Manager Telecom,
Gangtok, Sikkim in that behalf shall require.
The contract is extendable for further period of
one year considering performance of the
Contractor as per discretion of the General
Manager Telecom, Gangtok.”
……………………………………………………….
“6.
The CONTRACTOR shall promptly carry out the
work wherever called upon by the Competent
Authority of BSNL or any of the officers
mentioned in the term & conditions above
within the jurisdiction of the General Manager
Telecom, Gangtok, Sikkim and within the time
frame specified in the terms and conditions
hereof at the time of issuing WORK ORDER.
7.
The CONTRACTOR shall execute the work as
specified in the Work Order using his own good
tools and required instruments so that to
maintain the standard of work as specified by
the BSNL.
8.
The above work shall, throughout the stipulated
time period, be executed with all due diligence
and the time allowed for completing the work as
specified in Tender paper strictly be observed
by the CONTRACTOR. The time in this respect
shall be deemed to be essence of the Contract
on the part of the CONTRACTOR.
9.
If the CONTRACTOR fails to carry out any of his
obligations under this Agreement. Penalty or
recovery at the rate as prescribed at terms and
conditions shall be imposed by the concerned
officers mentioned in Tender Paper.”
………………………………………………….……….
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
“14. The aforesaid Security Deposit of Rs.3.00.000/(Rupees Three Lakh only) furnished by the
CONTRACTOR shall be retained by the BSNL as
security for the due and faithful performance by
the CONTRACTOR of all the covenants herein
contained and on his/her part to be satisfactory
fulfill, keep and observes all or any of the
covenants, conditions or agreements on his/her
part contained herein, then, unless the same is
already forfeited, the General Manager Telecom,
Gangtok, Sikkim will have the power to retain
the whole or any part of the same and to
appropriate the same or any part thereof to the
use of BSNL, absolutely as and when by way of
liquidated damages and or other dues and
without reference to the relative importance of
the particular breach or breaches of Contract
which might have given occasion for such
appropriate and whether the BSNL may
aforesaid or not. In the case of such
appropriation or retention of whole or part of the
amount or an amount sufficient to make up the
deficit as the case may be.”
……………………………………………………………
“16. That the BSNL will pay the CONTRACTOR for
the work, which the CONTRACTOR was called
upon by the BSNL or by the concerned officers
and which was satisfactorily done by the
CONTRACTOR at the rates approved. For this
purpose the CONTRACTOR should submit to the
General Manager Telecom, Gangtok, Sikkim
his/their bill for the terms of the work done by
him/them against a particular work order at the
rates approved within 30 (thirty) days of the
items of work covered by that work order
having been satisfactorily completed by
him/them.
17. The bill will ordinarily be payable within two (2)
months of the date of its submission.”
.....................................................................
“25. The CONTRACTOR will submit for examination
in the office of the General Manager Telecom,
Gangtok, Sikkim its books of account and all
concerned papers immediately by it in this
connection within fifteen (15) days from the date
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
of its being called upon to do so if the
CONTRACTOR fails to do so, and /or
…………………………………………….
(i)
27.
If the CONTRACTOR‟s work is
found unsatisfactory in the opinion
of the General Manager Telecom,
Gangtok, Sikkim the General
Manager Telecom, Gangtok shall be
at liberty by notice in writing to the
CONTRACTOR,
terminate
the
Contract in any of the cases stated
above. The CONTRACTOR shall
thereupon pay to the General
Manager Telecom, Gangtok, Sikkim
in addition to any sum or sums of
money which the CONTRACTOR
may be able to pay under the
provisions herein before stated,
such sum or sums as the General
Manager Telecom, Gangtok, Sikkim
may decide to be reasonable
compensation
for
loss
or
inconvenience caused. The amount
of the sum or sums for such breach
on the part of the CONTRACTOR
will be fixed by the General
Manager Telecom, Gangtok, Sikkim
and shall be final and conclusive
against the CONTRACTOR.”
Clause 3 of the agreement provides a definite time
frame for execution of the contract extendable by one more
year as per discretion of the General Manager. Clause 6
mandates that the plaintiff No.1 complete the work within
the time to be provided in the work order. The work order
provided that the work should be completed within 45
days. Clause 8 provided time was of the essence. However,
clause 9 provided for payment of penalty or recovery at the
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
rate prescribed if the plaintiff no.1 failed to carry out any
of its obligations under the agreement. Clause 8 providing
that time was of the essence was also one of the
obligations under the agreement. Clause 14 further
provided that the security deposit was liable to be
appropriated as liquidated damages by the defendant on
the failure of the plaintiff No.1 to duly and faithfully
perform all the covenants and to satisfactory fulfill, keep
and observe all or any of the covenants, conditions of
agreement. The agreement must be read in its entirety and
not individual clause alone. True intent of the parties
needs to be ascertained.
28.
In Citadel Fine Pharmaceuticals v. Ramaniyam
Real Estates (P) Ltd.1 the Supreme Court held:
"50. By referring to various judgments,
the Constitution Bench in Chand Rani (1993) 1
SCC 519] formulated the proposition that even
where parties have expressly provided time to
be of the essence of the contract, such a
stipulation will have to be read along with
other terms of the contract. Such other terms,
on a proper construction, may exclude the
inference that the completion of work by a
particular date was meant to be fundamental.
The learned Judges indicated the following
circumstances which may indicate a contrary
inference; (a) if a contract includes clauses
1(2011) 9 SCC 147
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
providing for extension of time in certain
contingencies, or (b) if there are clauses for
payment of fine or penalty for every day or
week, the work undertaken remains unfinished
after the expiry of time. The Constitution Bench
held that such clauses would be construed as
rendering ineffective the express provision
relating to time being of the essence of contract
(see para 22 at p. 528 of the Report)."
29.
Reading the agreement in its entirety it is held
that clauses for imposition penalty and forfeiture of the
security deposit for nonadherence to the covenants also
diluted clause 8 of the agreement.
30.
The
work
was
to
be
completed
under
the
supervision of Jay Prakash Thapa. The defendant admits
that the plaintiffs had done some work although not as
contemplated within the initial time frame in the work
order. The defendant admits to the extensions of time
granted by them to the plaintiff and in fact exhibited
various correspondences to that effect. The defendant also
admits that they have not yet taken any action against the
plaintiffs for the plaintiffs’ nonadherence to the time
schedule. Admission in pleadings, if true and clear are the
best proof of the facts admitted. Admission in pleadings
are judicial admissions and admissible under Section 58
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It stands on a higher
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
footing than evidentiary admissions, fully binding and
constitutes waiver of proof. Facts admitted need not be
proved unless the court requires otherwise.
31.
The defendant contention that time was the
essence of the agreement despite the extensions granted
seems to have appealed to the learned Trial Court. The
learned Trial Court relied upon the judgment in Orissa
Textile Mills Ltd. vs. Ganesh Das Ramkishun2 and Dr. Bal
Saroop Daulat Ram vs. Lt. Col.
Lakhbir Singh Kirpal
Singh3 to hold that:
“it is trite that if the time is originally of the
essence of the contract it does not seize to be of
the essence merely because a party agrees to
short extensions. Instead, such brief extension
may at the most amount only to a waiver to the
extent of substituting such extended time for
the original time and does not destroy the
essential character of time.”
32.
In Orissa Textile Mills (supra) the Patna High
Court was examining a revision application against the
judgment of the learned Small Cause Court, Judge,
decreeing the plaintiff’s suit for damages for breach of
contract. The plaintiff had placed the order with the
defendant no.1 through its selling agent for supply of five
bales. The goods were to be delivered within January
AIR 1961 Patna 107
AIR 1964 Punjab 375
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
1956. The order had been accepted by the defendant no.1.
Out of these five bales, only one bale was supplied to the
plaintiff till February 1956, but the remaining four bales
were not at all supplied by the defendant to the plaintiff.
The plaintiffs were informed that they would deliver the
remaining bales if they agreed to pay the new excise duty.
The defendant No.1 was informed that the plaintiff was
prepared to take delivery of the remaining bales but only
at the old contract rate. The remaining goods were
therefore, not supplied. The suit was, thereafter, filed for
recovery of damages for breach of contract. On facts it was
held that the plaintiff in his order had fixed the month of
January
defendants
for
while
the
fulfillment
accepting
the
of
contract.
plaintiff
order
The
had
extended the time of delivery to the end of February 1956.
Both the parties conceded before the court that the
plaintiff agreed to the extension of time and therefore end
of February 1956 was the date fixed for the fulfillment of
contract. It was in such fact situation that the Patna High
Court held: “16. This extension of time by the
defendants and its acceptance by the
plaintiff clearly shows that time was of
the essence of the contract. Where time is
of the essence of the contract and is
extended the extended date is also of the
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
essence of the contract the time of
delivery was certainly a necessary term,
and that is the reason why the parties
intended it to be a term of the contract.
The letter sent by defendant 2 in March,
1956, Exhibit A (1), offering to supply the
remaining goods in March, 1956, on the
plaintiff agreeing to pay the new Excise
Duty and the plaintiffs reply to it, Exhibit
A, agreeing to accept the goods in March,
1956, at the old rate, but reluctant to pay
the new Excise Duty, also point to time
being of the essence of the contract. In
my opinion, therefore, the learned Judge
has rightly held that time was of the
essence of the contract.”
33.
In Dr. Bal Saroop Daulat Ram (supra) the Punjab
and Haryana High Court was examining the plaintiff’s first
appeal against the judgment and decree dismissing his
suit for specific performance of the agreement to sell
relating to a bungalow in Amritsar. The Punjab & Haryana
High Court held:
“46. On
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case in hand, time
was presumably of the essence and this
view seems to find additional support
from the subsequent conduct of the
parties. The fact that the vendor granted
some extension for specified period
would not seem to detract from the
intention of making time of the essence; it
may on the contrary support the
existence of such an intention. But as I
have observed earlier, in view of the
finding that there was no term of delivery
of vacant possession, and that the
plaintiff-appellant
had
repudiated
performance of his part of the contract
without getting vacant possession it is
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
unnecessary to express any considered
view on this point”.
34.
In both the judgments cited above, the High Court
of Patna as well as the Punjab and Haryana High Court
have held that time was of the essence as it was
specifically agreed between the parties that it would be
done within the specified time.
35.
The work order provided for a definite time frame
of 45 days to complete the work. This was, however,
extended by the defendant for a further period of 60 days.
Thereafter, it was also extended for a period of 30 days
taking the time for completion of the work till end of
February 2009. This is an admitted position. However,
admittedly the plaintiffs did not complete the work by the
end of February 2009.
36.
Section 55 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 which
is important at this juncture, provides:
"55. Effect of failure to perform at fixed
time, in contract in which time is essential.—
When a party to a contract promises to do a certain
thing at or before a specified time, or certain things
at or before specified times, and fails to do any such
thing at or before the specified time, the contract, or
so much of it as has not been performed, becomes
voidable at the option of the promisee, if the intention
of the parties was that time should be of the essence
of the contract.
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
Effect of such failure when time is not
essential.—If it was not the intention of the parties
that time should be of the essence of the contract, the
contract does not become voidable by the failure to
do such thing at or before the specified time; but the
promisee is entitled to compensation from the
promisor for any loss occasioned to him by such
failure.
Effect of acceptance of performance at
time other than that agreed upon.—If, in case of
a contract voidable on account of the promisor's
failure to perform his promise at the time agreed, the
promisee accepts performance of such promise at
any time other than that agreed, the promisee cannot
claim compensation for any loss occasioned by the
non-performance of the promise at the time agreed,
unless, at the time of such acceptance, he gives
notice to the promisor of his intention to do so."
37.
In M/s. Hind Construction Contractors vs. State of
Maharashtra4 relating to building contracts, the Supreme
Court relying upon the 4th edition of Halsbury’s Laws of
England held that even where the parties had expressly
provided that time is of the essence of the contract such a
stipulation will have to be read along with other provisions
of the contract and such other provisions may, on
construction of the contract, exclude the inference that the
completion of the work by a particular date was intended
to be fundamental; for instances, if the contract were to
include clauses providing for extension of time in certain
(1979) 2 SCC 70
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
contingencies or for payment of fine or penalty for every
day or week the work undertaken remains unfinished on
the expiry of the time provided in the contract such
clauses would be construed as rendering ineffective the
express provision relating to the time being of the essence
of contract.
38.
In Arosan Enterprises Ltd. v. Union of India5 the
Supreme Court held:
“13. These presumptions of the High
Court in our view are wholly unwarranted in the
contextual facts for the reasons detailed below
but before so doing it is to be noted that in the
event the time is the essence of the contract,
question of there being any presumption or
presumed extension or presumed acceptance of
a renewed date would not arise. The extension
if there be any, should and ought to be
categorical in nature rather than being vague or
on the anvil of presumptions. In the event the
parties knowingly give a go-by to the stipulation
as regards the time — the same may have two
several effects: (a) parties name a future specific
date for delivery, any (b) parties may also agree
to the abandonment of the contract — as
regards (a) above, there must be a specific date
within which delivery has to be effected and in
the event there is no such specific date
available in the course of conduct of the parties,
then and in that event, the courts are not left
with any other conclusion but a finding that the
parties themselves by their conduct have given
a go-by to the original term of the contract as
(1999) 9 SCC 449
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
regards the time being the essence of the
contract. Be it recorded that in the event the
contract comes within the ambit of Section 55,
Contract Act, the remedy is also provided
therein. For convenience sake Section 55 reads
as below:
“55. When a party to a contract promises
to do a certain thing at or before a specified
time, or certain things at or before specified
times, and fails to do any such thing at or
before the specified time, the contract, or so
much of it as has not been performed, becomes
voidable at the option of the promisee, if the
intention of the parties was that time should be
of the essence of the contract.
If it was not the intention of the parties
that time should be of the essence of the
contract, the contract does not become voidable
by the failure to do such thing at or before the
specified time; but the promisee is entitled to
compensation from the promisor for any loss
occasioned to him by such failure.
If, in case of a contract voidable on
account of the promisor's failure to perform his
promise at the time agreed, the promisee
accepts performance of such promise at any
time other than that agreed, the promisee
cannot claim compensation for any loss
occasioned by the non-performance of the
promise at the time agreed, unless, at the time
of such acceptance, he gives notice to the
promisor of his intention to do so.”
14. Incidentally the law is well settled
on this score on which no further dilation is
required in this judgment to the effect that when
the contract itself provides for extension of time,
the same cannot be termed to be the essence of
the contract and default however, in such a
case does not make the contract voidable either.
It becomes voidable provided the matter in issue
can be brought within the ambit of the first para
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
of Section 55 and it is only in that event that the
Government would be entitled to claim damages
and not otherwise.”
39.
If time had been of the essence, on the failure of
the plaintiffs to complete the work on time, the agreement
would become voidable at the option of the defendant.
However, the defendant admittedly has not terminated the
agreement or taken any action contemplated under the
agreement. Jay Prakash Thapa as well as Deepak Agrawal
both admits that the defendant had not terminated the
contract/work order. There is not a single correspondence
after the extended completion period or material placed
which
reflect
contemplated
that
by
any
the
action
was
taken
defendant.
In
fact,
it
or
even
is
the
defendant’s case that the plaintiffs had not completed the
work even till January 2011 which gets established from
the correspondence
written by the defendant dated
28.01.2011 (exhibit-P) filed by the plaintiffs before the Lok
Adalat. The defendant has extracted the contents of
exhibit-P in the written statement and exhibited it through
Deepak Agrawal. This admitted correspondence is of
relevance. The contents are extracted below:
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
“Sir,
This is for your kind information
and necessary action to the fact that only
approximately 10% u/g cable laying by
your concern has become up to date with
respect to point to point verification under
Namchi jurisdiction vide work order no22D(a)/05-06 dt 25/9/08 as intimated
from our T.M. Station Namchi.
Henceforth you are requested to
arrange for completion of rest as early as
possible especially at the eve of visiting of
Hon‟ble Prime Minister on 12/2/2011.”
40.
This
correspondence
establishes
that
the
defendant had requested the plaintiffs vide letter dated
28.01.2011 to complete making up to date the cable laying
with respect to point-to-point verification “as early as
possible” especially on the eve of the Hon’ble Prime
Minister’s
visit
correspondence
and
kept
establishes
it
open
that
the
ended.
This
point-to-point
verification of the underground cable laying by the
plaintiffs had been completed only up to 10%. This was
not a complaint of complete non completion of work which
as per defendant’s witness Jay Prakash Thapa was done in
the year 2010. The work order did not specify point-topoint verification and the defendant have not pleaded what
work remained to be completed. Thus, it would not be
possible for this court to agree to the view taken by the
learned Trial Court that although time was of the essence
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
of the contract, it did not cease to be of the essence merely
because the defendant agrees to grant short extensions.
The learned Trial Court seems to have failed to examine
the correspondence in his correct prospective. The learned
Trial Court seems to have ignored the pleadings in the
written statement as well as affidavit on evidence of
Deepak Agrawal which clearly takes a position that the
plaintiff had not completed the work till January 2011
which was established by exhibit-P. With such clear stand
taken by the defendant there was no reason for the
learned Trial Court, with great respect, to wonder about
the reason for the issuance of the letter dated 28.01.2011
as being abruptly and hastily issued to the plaintiffs.
Thus, if, in case of a contract voidable on account of the
promisor's failure to perform his promise at the time
agreed, the promisee accepts performance of such promise
at any time other than that agreed, the promisee cannot
claim compensation for any loss occasioned by the nonperformance of the promise at the time agreed, unless, at
the time of such acceptance, he gives notice to the
promisor of his intention to do so. A voidable contract is a
contract that can be affirmed or rejected at the option of
one of the parties or in other words the contract which, in
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
its inception, is valid, but which may be avoided i.e.
rendered void at the option of one of the parties. The
defendant however, as seen from its conduct, has not
avoided the contract but continued to request the plaintiffs
to complete the work even in the year 2011.
41.
Deepak Agrawal exhibited the measurement
book of the contract (exhibit-O), the copy whereof was
exhibited by the plaintiff No.2. He has also exhibited the
work
certificate
(exhibit-K)
forming
part
of
the
measurement book. Jay Prakash Thapa admitted he
supervised the work and wrote the work certificate. He
admitted in cross-examination that he had mentioned that
the work had been completed on 28.02.2010 by the
plaintiffs in the work certificate.
In his evidence on
affidavit, he has however, stated that the plaintiff no.2
executed the work by successfully completing only 60% of
the underground cable and did not complete 40% of the
work and out of the 60% assigned work only 10% of
underground laying cables was made up to date with
respect to point-to-point jointing/joining work. It is settled
that the documents speak for itself. Section 94 of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 provides when language used in
a document is plain, and when it applies accurately to
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
existing facts, evidence may not be given to show that it
was not meant to apply to such facts. The work certificate
reads thus:
“work certificate
It is certified that the excavating,
trenching, construction of cabinet, pillar and
laying of U/G cable has been tested and 60%
U/G cable pair found ok. The work has been
completed on 28.2.2010.”
42.
Further, Jay Prakash Thapa stated that he had
himself mentioned in the work certificate that the work
has been completed on 28.02.2010 by the plaintiffs. He
had also admitted that since he worked in the field, he
could say that it was not possible for contract work to be
completed within the stipulated time mentioned in the
work order. There is also clear admission of Deepak
Agrawal that the plaintiffs had in fact done work to the
extent of 60%. Thus, in any case this was not a case in
which no work at all was done. Be that as it may there is
no dispute about the contents of the measurement book
filed by the defendant. Deepak Agrawal admits that the
progress of the work in the measurement book was
recorded by the defendant’s engineers. The total work done
quantified
in
terms
of
money
is
reflected
as
Rs.12,13,321/- therein. The measurement book records
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
the date of commencement as 21.11.2008 and date of
completion as 28.02.2010. The measurement book also
reflects that the work continued even after the end of
February 2009 which according to the defendant was the
last extension. The plaintiff No.2 has stated that on
04.07.2012 the Sub Divisional Engineer submitted the
total contractor’s bill along with the measurement book to
the
defendant
for
further
action.
The
letter
dated
04.07.2012 written by the Sub Divisional Engineer to the
General Manager submitting the contractors bill as
enclosed has been exhibited as exhibit-11 by the plaintiffs
and the bills as exhibit-12. The defendant has denied that
the
Sub
Divisional
Engineer
has
submitted
the
contractor’s bill to the defendant’s office by contending it
was the contractor’s job to do so.
The defendant has
admitted that the concerned officer had forwarded the
measurement book. The Sub Divisional Engineer’s letter
dated 04.07.2012 (exhibit-11) however, forwards both the
bill and the measurement book together. Although, the
plaintiffs had furnished a copy of the bill (exhibit-12) the
defendant has not denied the contents thereof. The
plaintiff no.2 also stated that the original bill is in the
possession of the defendant. The plaintiff no.2 was not
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
cross-examined on this aspect by the defendant and
therefore, there is no denial of the contents of the bill. The
bill is dated 15.06.2012 and contain the particulars,
quantity,
rate
and
the
amount
and
totals
to
Rs.12,97,412/- only round about the same figure of
Rs.12,13,321/- as reflected in the measurement book.
Deepak Agrawal admits that the plaintiffs had written
several letters reminding the defendants to make the
payment. These correspondences have also been exhibited
by the plaintiffs.
43.
In view of all the above facts, circumstances and
applying the ratio of the judgment as discussed above, it
must be held that although the clause 8 of the agreement
provided time was of the essence, the conduct of the
defendant allowing extensions and finally the open ended
one, time no longer remained of the essence. As held
above, the defendant by their own act had waived their
right to make the contract voidable, even if the penalty and
forfeiture clauses are ignored, and permitted the plaintiffs
to continue the work. No action of termination, forfeiture
or imposition of penalty has been taken by the defendant
against the plaintiffs. Having thus, extended the time for
completion of work even till 2011 and requiring the
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
plaintiffs to do the work as indicated in the measurement
book at their own costs, it would not be correct on the
part of the defendant not to pay the plaintiffs what was
legitimately due to them for works already completed.
There is no dispute about the measurement book which
reflects the amount of Rs.12,13,321/- as work done till
then. Therefore, this court is of the view, that the plaintiffs
are entitled to a decree of the aforesaid amount of
Rs.12,13,321/-.
44.
In the entirety of the records of the case there is
not a single correspondence from the defendant disputing
the
reasons
mentioned
by
the
plaintiffs
in
their
correspondences seeking extension save complaining that
the progress was slow.
Although the defendant did
threaten departmental action because of slow progress no
action was taken. There is no correspondence from the
defendant complaining of non-completion of work after the
last
communication
on
06.02.2009
(exhibit-I)
till
28.01.2011 (exhibit-P). There was a duty for the defendant
to speak and its failure to do so constitutes a waiver of the
delay in execution of the work. Under clause 17 of the
agreement the plaintiffs’ bill became payable within two
months of its submission.
R.F.A. No. 05 of 2019
M/s North East Group of Engineers (p) Ltd. & Anr. Vs. General Manager (BSNL)
45.
It is held that the payment became payable on
03.09.2012 i.e. before the expiry of the two months of
submission of bill on 04.07.2012. Therefore, the defendant
is also liable to pay interest thereon at the rate of 6% per
annum from 03.09.2012 till date of actual payment on the
amount of Rs.12,13,321/-.
46.
The appeal is allowed. The impugned judgement
and decree of the learned Trial Court are set aside. In the
facts of the present case, no order as to costs.
47.
The decree may be drawn accordingly.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
to
Approved for reporting: Yes/No
Internet
: Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review